Bias Refs or Honest Mistakes? Rugby's Worst Calls

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 53

  • @jamesrautha162
    @jamesrautha162 10 днів тому +7

    The Wales Italy one is really unforgiveable - 'do we have time?' 'yes' then ends the game. He might've been told time was up but he's the ref - just override it and say the lineout is the last play of the game. Madness.

  • @HayManned
    @HayManned 14 днів тому +12

    No way you put the england dissallowed try 2007 there

  • @magnusmcgee993
    @magnusmcgee993 19 днів тому +23

    0:15 Charged in, shoulder first.

    • @Srioll
      @Srioll 19 днів тому +9

      Yeah what's wrong with the ref giving a card there. It's 100% a red and the ref is right.

    • @torinsuriarachi700
      @torinsuriarachi700 15 днів тому +1

      He got an arm around

    • @magnusmcgee993
      @magnusmcgee993 15 днів тому +4

      ​@torinsuriarachi700Yes, he did get his arm around AFTER he made head contact

  • @jamiejp4007
    @jamiejp4007 18 днів тому +15

    The England final try of Cueto is 50/50, doesnt belong in a worst decision list

  • @conoromelia8435
    @conoromelia8435 18 днів тому +4

    Love the video. Very hot topic with the current rule changes and scrutiny of refereeing and TMO intervention.
    Mac Hansen is definitely watching this 🤣

  • @sl1cc1x40
    @sl1cc1x40 19 днів тому +3

    Great video man keep up the good work!

  • @torinsuriarachi700
    @torinsuriarachi700 15 днів тому +4

    7:11 Some of them not completely the refs fault. It also TMO making controversial conclusions and looking more conclusive and dominant with their conclusions than ref. Refs need to be able to argue back or ask for alternative angles and give reviewing directions.

    • @camza11
      @camza11 14 днів тому

      Steff Evans knocked it on before the grounding there anyways. Seems to always be forgotten about...

  • @offbrandsoup2579
    @offbrandsoup2579 День тому +1

    Some of these are correct 😅

  • @jlptnutrition5134
    @jlptnutrition5134 12 днів тому +3

    And basically 90% of the video were northern hemisphere refs 😂😂😂

  • @robertwardlaw9999
    @robertwardlaw9999 17 днів тому +6

    Australian penalty cost Scotland there best ever World Cup

    • @georgefrederikoosthuizen891
      @georgefrederikoosthuizen891 17 днів тому

      As from safa i agree,but beleive me if sa"n wants to help a team between scot and ausie he will rather help scots.....we all felt for scots that day.

    • @RugbyManual
      @RugbyManual  17 днів тому

      Agreed 🥲

    • @Goomlahexpress
      @Goomlahexpress 11 днів тому

      I'm trying to figure out what you wanted the Scotland player to do? Not catch the ball that was coming straight for his stomach?

    • @nifty512
      @nifty512 6 днів тому

      @@Goomlahexpressthat’s not the point. It’s still accidental offside regardless

    • @nifty512
      @nifty512 6 днів тому

      Why was it controversial? Because it looks like it came off 20s shoulder but I am probably wrong

  • @saffamatt8612
    @saffamatt8612 16 днів тому +2

    A few controversial ones. Du Plessis hit on Carter was talked about for months and months! Great hit, poor decision.

    • @MacAoidh4
      @MacAoidh4 16 днів тому

      Beautiful hit

    • @tsaki_titan
      @tsaki_titan 16 днів тому

      It's just like that hit Andre Esterhuizen did against Portugal last year july and that shit female ref who knows Jack shit about rugby gave him a red card🤦🏽‍♂️

  • @martinbielby334
    @martinbielby334 16 днів тому +1

    Prince William swore 😂😂😂

  • @BigFudgeXD
    @BigFudgeXD 14 днів тому +3

    No Owen Farrell videos?.....

  • @joedennehy386
    @joedennehy386 19 днів тому +1

    Good video thanks

  • @honahwikeepa2115
    @honahwikeepa2115 16 днів тому +2

    All Northern Hemisphere romantics.

  • @davidlewis2055
    @davidlewis2055 19 днів тому +16

    Warburton should not have been sent off by french ref

    • @RugbyManual
      @RugbyManual  19 днів тому +2

      Agreed

    • @RollinRoadblock
      @RollinRoadblock 18 днів тому +4

      Rolland shouldn't have been the official in that or any other France game.
      I do think it was a red tho, sam should ave put the winger down safely instead of dropping him 🤷‍♂️

    • @jamiejp4007
      @jamiejp4007 18 днів тому +1

      By today's standards, stone cold red but not by 2011 standards

    • @djpandsmm
      @djpandsmm 18 днів тому +5

      Red every day of the week, even back then. They had all been told about it at the start of the competitio.
      Lifted above the horizontal and dumped on the shoulder/neck area.

    • @georgepatterson3428
      @georgepatterson3428 16 днів тому

      He’s not French. He’s Irish.

  • @torinsuriarachi700
    @torinsuriarachi700 15 днів тому

    U missed Jeremy Williams try against England. That was clearly in touch

  • @samaudas2246
    @samaudas2246 13 днів тому

    Elliott Dixon one was a try

  • @Edgel-in6bs
    @Edgel-in6bs 11 днів тому +1

    Warburton one was fine - a red. McAllister was fine - a yellow.
    Cueto was in touch

  • @redsidebiker
    @redsidebiker 13 днів тому

    Let us get late hits after scoring tries out of the sport. Ball is down, player is clearly now going to be stopped, don't touch the player. If you have time to pull out and do not, red card - deliberate foul play. Lets tidy our sport up please

  • @revanomichael
    @revanomichael 16 днів тому +3

    Weak video. Some of these decisions were not controversial. Click bait

  • @Edgel-in6bs
    @Edgel-in6bs 11 днів тому

    As for the france forward pass, it *was* a forward pass, but often not mentioned is all teams (all blacks included) did thay numerpus times in a game.

  • @ByDunny
    @ByDunny 7 днів тому

    Should make one of these for any irish every game or any irish team in the URC the cheats

  • @rugbymandan5207
    @rugbymandan5207 14 днів тому +3

    Half these videos are genuinely 50/50s, not worst ever decisions by referees.