@@EvanEvans9 I doubt that they would invite her, she only participated in one album (that floped) and didn't work with any of the ogs. Plus the general public doesn't really know much about 4.0 and the songs they made were nothing like the sugababes. No hate to Jade but, if they don't even want to invite Heidi who was in the group at their peak in popularity, I doubt they would ever invite her.
@@EvanEvans9 I have nothing against Jade and wouldn't mind her joining, but she was only with the group for two years and only recorded one original song with the group. The Sweet 7 album was basically done when Keisha was forced out and they just slapped Jade's vocals on it to replace Keisha so Jade feels like an anomaly in the Sugababes history.
Vocally 1.0 wins hands down. No comparaison. I am not taking away anything Heidi brought to Sugababes and she was a huge part of their commercial appeal. There is also an edge, an authenticity with 1.0 which I love.
I agree with you. Vocally 1.0 is the best by far. Commercially, 2.0 is better. But when we talk about stage presence and energy, 3.0 wins! Every lineup has its streghts and weaknesses
The current version of Sugarbabes is the best one,the original one and therefore the most authentic.They seem to have managed a great comeback in 2022.Of course the other former members are all important and relevant to the history of Sugarbabes.
@@loveandpeace_totheworld she could have been if she hadn't done what she did in 09 to Keisha.... now their chemistry crashed and burned - pun intended.
Fantastic edit, I always love your work and the time and effort you put into it. A Superbabes (as I like to call a potential lineup with all six) lineup would be fantastic, but for now these edits would do. As for personal favourite lineup, it's always been 2.0, as I grew up with them and they were the most successful. Sugababes without Heidi Range is like Atomic Kitten without Jenny Frost.
Thank you!! Heidi is not a original member, but she surely gave Sugababes something more, it is not a coincidence their most successful songs had her in the lineup. She is definitely a Sugababe in her very essence.
@@vagneredits Agreed! She lasted longer than 4/5 of the other members, and the majority of the hits the group had were with her. People who use the "original is best" argument fail to realise that; 1.0 gave no hits other than Overload. 2.0 on the other hand gave us Ugly, Caught In A Moment, Round Round, Too Lost In You, etc.
Atomic kitten got a no.1 single with an original song by kerry, they were successful with her but of course isn't like the times when they were with Jenny 🥰 they got 2 number one singles with Jenny and non of the 2 singles is an original song by atomic kitten.
@@mahdidabaddie that number one your referring to is Whole Again, which was actually rerecorded with Jenny by the time the song and music video were released.
Sugababes 2.0 all the way. Keisha. Mutya. Heidi. That’s the iconic line up. Sionhan is great but she left the group so early that besides Overload, all of the classics belong to Heidi. Give her some credit!
and Heidi gave up her right to the group when she got Keisha kicked out of the band she founded. So glad the originals are back together and showing us how the classics should've always sounded.
@@ColinnOkI doubt the classics would even exist without Heidi. I mean she wrote her part on Round round, Stronger or Hole in The Head. So without her, these songs wouldn't exist. Things happened, Heidi moved on and so did Keisha. I am waiting for new Sugababes music in 2024 and I remember all Sugababes members in a good way. I'm glad 2.0 happened, I'm happy about 3.0 and I ignore 4.0
@@Philipp19967 Absolutely, Sugababes would've probably never been as commercially successful without Heidi. But as the line-up changes went on, so did the loss of creativity. It turned into the anti-thesis of what the original line-up was about. I'm glad they're back and giving us quality.
@@danieltongaww It is their best selling single in the UK. However _Round Round_ and _Push the Button_ are more iconic and frankly successful in the current music era as they're the most streamed songs in their catalogue. They stood the test of time better and more. Sugababes 2.0 had the longest run of hits. _About You Now_ was a lucky hit before their fast short journey towards the end.
@@loveandpeace_totheworld I'm happy the originals are back together. Amelle ended up ruining the group in the end. Keisha was probably a bitch but Amelle thinking she could continue the group with Heidi and someone else was deluded.
Moderate at best vocals?! Heidi was and always will be a very sub-par replacement! She was brought it due to their manager being from Liverpool at the time. The girl got lucky - she never worked from childhood to create Sugababes! They went more pop when she joined in order to be relevant. Heidi was not a writer or responsible for their success. Stop prioritising some basic blonde white woman over the original trio!
@@TM-ht6idSiobhan is just as white as Heidi lol. And Heidi did write her parts in several songs like Round Round or Hole in The Head. Or stronger, which is about her moving to London anyways. She worked just as hard as Keisha and Mutya (confirmed by Keisha and Mutya). And Mutya didn't write much anyways, she didn't write on TIMW, she didn't write half of her songs on her solo record, she wrote less than half of the songs on The Lost Tapes. Between 2002-2008, it was Keisha who wrote the most by far. Heidi, Mutya and Amelle wrote a bit but Keisha was the Sugababes songwriter. Now it's her and Siobhan since both wrote on The Lost Tapes. Idk why Mutya wasn't involved but please don't act as if Heidi was lazy and didn't work. She and Keisha kept the group alive in 2005 when Mutya was missing and she worked hard for them.
@@Philipp19967 its not the same for everyone. Singers would have a peak. For example 90s Mariah is the peak of her vocals. Even Whitney’s voice deteriorated over time.
and Heidi was a sheep in wolves clothing, backstabbing one of the founding members and getting her kicked. She was also more than happy to have the narrative spread that Mutya & Keisha were bullies throughout their career. Her smiley act doesn't wash anymore and people can see her for who she is. MKS vocals >>>
I really hope MKS bring Heidi and Amelle on stage for a few songs some day. Would love to see the five of them together.
What about Jade?
@@EvanEvans9 I doubt that they would invite her, she only participated in one album (that floped) and didn't work with any of the ogs. Plus the general public doesn't really know much about 4.0 and the songs they made were nothing like the sugababes. No hate to Jade but, if they don't even want to invite Heidi who was in the group at their peak in popularity, I doubt they would ever invite her.
@@abc_jv_xyz Jade was my fave. She had Keeshas range but without the aggressive edge.
@@EvanEvans9 I have nothing against Jade and wouldn't mind her joining, but she was only with the group for two years and only recorded one original song with the group. The Sweet 7 album was basically done when Keisha was forced out and they just slapped Jade's vocals on it to replace Keisha so Jade feels like an anomaly in the Sugababes history.
@@HoennMaster I personally loved Jade. I'd love to hear her sing Red Dress with Amelle and Heidi🤞
Nothing better than Heidi, Amelle and Keisha performing this number one hit. Love you girls, you rocks and you made my childhood ❤❤❤
This is so heartbreaking to watching but amazing at the same time. Heidi and amelle loved this song so much
I miss Amelle and Heidi so much😊
The best girls of this group. Impeccable.
Vocally 1.0 wins hands down. No comparaison. I am not taking away anything Heidi brought to Sugababes and she was a huge part of their commercial appeal. There is also an edge, an authenticity with 1.0 which I love.
I agree with you. Vocally 1.0 is the best by far. Commercially, 2.0 is better. But when we talk about stage presence and energy, 3.0 wins! Every lineup has its streghts and weaknesses
@@vagneredits3.0 ❤❤❤
The current version of Sugarbabes is the best one,the original one and therefore the most authentic.They seem to have managed a great comeback in 2022.Of course the other former members are all important and relevant to the history of Sugarbabes.
No. Its not the best because Heidi isn't there 😕 😔
@@loveandpeace_totheworld she could have been if she hadn't done what she did in 09 to Keisha.... now their chemistry crashed and burned - pun intended.
My favorite girl group!
Wow I love this, such a great edit! 1.0 and 3.0 are definitely my favourite lineups, they have such great energy and harmonies 😊
Thank you! I agree with you. All of them add something special to the group.
Fantastic edit, I always love your work and the time and effort you put into it. A Superbabes (as I like to call a potential lineup with all six) lineup would be fantastic, but for now these edits would do. As for personal favourite lineup, it's always been 2.0, as I grew up with them and they were the most successful. Sugababes without Heidi Range is like Atomic Kitten without Jenny Frost.
Thank you!! Heidi is not a original member, but she surely gave Sugababes something more, it is not a coincidence their most successful songs had her in the lineup. She is definitely a Sugababe in her very essence.
@@vagneredits Agreed! She lasted longer than 4/5 of the other members, and the majority of the hits the group had were with her. People who use the "original is best" argument fail to realise that; 1.0 gave no hits other than Overload. 2.0 on the other hand gave us Ugly, Caught In A Moment, Round Round, Too Lost In You, etc.
Atomic kitten got a no.1 single with an original song by kerry, they were successful with her but of course isn't like the times when they were with Jenny 🥰 they got 2 number one singles with Jenny and non of the 2 singles is an original song by atomic kitten.
@@mahdidabaddie that number one your referring to is Whole Again, which was actually rerecorded with Jenny by the time the song and music video were released.
No.. Whole again was the last single by Atomic Kitten with Kerry Katona! ua-cam.com/video/WhQsNHrXZuU/v-deo.html
seria maravilhoso as 5 juntas!!!!
Eu super concordo!! Seria meu sonho
Great edit
Thank you!
Amelle❤❤❤❤❤
Heidi was my favourite and I like the original babes and have been a fan since.
Loved it 💖💖that was fantastic IV liked and subscribed🙂
thanks a lot!
@@vagneredits your welcome 🙂💖
AMAZING
Thank you
Sugababes 2.0 all the way.
Keisha. Mutya. Heidi.
That’s the iconic line up.
Sionhan is great but she left the group so early that besides Overload, all of the classics belong to Heidi.
Give her some credit!
So true
and Heidi gave up her right to the group when she got Keisha kicked out of the band she founded. So glad the originals are back together and showing us how the classics should've always sounded.
@@ColinnOkI doubt the classics would even exist without Heidi. I mean she wrote her part on Round round, Stronger or Hole in The Head. So without her, these songs wouldn't exist. Things happened, Heidi moved on and so did Keisha. I am waiting for new Sugababes music in 2024 and I remember all Sugababes members in a good way. I'm glad 2.0 happened, I'm happy about 3.0 and I ignore 4.0
@@Philipp19967 Absolutely, Sugababes would've probably never been as commercially successful without Heidi. But as the line-up changes went on, so did the loss of creativity. It turned into the anti-thesis of what the original line-up was about. I'm glad they're back and giving us quality.
"About you now" in the Multiverse of madness
hahahahaahaa
Amazing
Thank you!
amei!!!
Nothing beats Sugababes 3.0 for me
👏👏👏👏👏👏❤
It is not a song from the red one
It is second line up!
Please edit this song with the original backing track if you can
I've edited a version with all 6 of them, I'll release it tomorrow, but I'll put your suggestion in my notes. Thank you!
A Fucking WOW!
What about Jade Ewen?
Thanks for Asking!! I made an Edit of this with ALL 6 of them. Here's the link:
ua-cam.com/video/rREj5Xtqo4I/v-deo.html
See why I think it should be all 5? (I love jade but she was barely in it)
It's tricky to talk about most successful lineup... 2.0 and 3.0 both had huge success... 3.0 had their biggest ever hit
Whag hitbwas that ? About you know ?
Yes. About you now.
@@bemdanlif really did the win and awards I would have thought round round was there biggest
@@danieltongaww It is their best selling single in the UK. However _Round Round_ and _Push the Button_ are more iconic and frankly successful in the current music era as they're the most streamed songs in their catalogue. They stood the test of time better and more. Sugababes 2.0 had the longest run of hits. _About You Now_ was a lucky hit before their fast short journey towards the end.
@@xxxTIN0xxxAbout You Now has more streams than Push the button and if you add the radio edit it gets another 20 million streams on Spotify.
I miss Heidi 😰
I miss Heidi and Amelle 😥 this is Amelles song tbh.
I miss them too
It breaks my heart not to see them in the band anymore. Like I love the original 3 to. But why can't it be a 5 piece band or something
.....
Amelle isn't in the band anymore though so lol.
Its very sad how things have went 😞 💔
@@loveandpeace_totheworld I'm happy the originals are back together. Amelle ended up ruining the group in the end. Keisha was probably a bitch but Amelle thinking she could continue the group with Heidi and someone else was deluded.
Where's Jade 😔?
In the future I'll do an edit of this with all 6 of them.
Who?
@@danielebrowne Jade Ewen 🤔 you don't know anything about the sugababes
@@mahdidabaddie Actually, tomorrow I'll release this edit with Jade :)
I miss Mutya
Did you even watch the video? she's back with the original lineup lol
Hahhaha love this🤣❤️
@@Terry_Bell maybe he meant he missed her lol or he did not recronize her
Cant denied that Heidi bring something to the group, when she's no longer in there, something is missing. But I really happy with the original trio 😍
I agree, I think she's a fundamental part of the group as Keisha always were.
Bad vocals?
Moderate at best vocals?! Heidi was and always will be a very sub-par replacement! She was brought it due to their manager being from Liverpool at the time. The girl got lucky - she never worked from childhood to create Sugababes! They went more pop when she joined in order to be relevant. Heidi was not a writer or responsible for their success. Stop prioritising some basic blonde white woman over the original trio!
@@TM-ht6idSiobhan is just as white as Heidi lol.
And Heidi did write her parts in several songs like Round Round or Hole in The Head. Or stronger, which is about her moving to London anyways.
She worked just as hard as Keisha and Mutya (confirmed by Keisha and Mutya). And Mutya didn't write much anyways, she didn't write on TIMW, she didn't write half of her songs on her solo record, she wrote less than half of the songs on The Lost Tapes. Between 2002-2008, it was Keisha who wrote the most by far. Heidi, Mutya and Amelle wrote a bit but Keisha was the Sugababes songwriter. Now it's her and Siobhan since both wrote on The Lost Tapes. Idk why Mutya wasn't involved but please don't act as if Heidi was lazy and didn't work. She and Keisha kept the group alive in 2005 when Mutya was missing and she worked hard for them.
@@Philipp19967 NOSTRILS
While I love sb 2.0 most, this was an amelle song.
This is Amelles song ❤️
I'm sorry but mutya siobhan and Keisha didn't sound very well singing about you now together it was Heidi keisha and amelles song
I agree. They sounded out of breath
i guess age and health has something to do with it. We really cant compare people in their late 30s in their mid 20s.
@@WebsSite why? Keisha sounds stronger than ever.
Her voice improved with the age.
Same for Siobhan
@@Philipp19967 its not the same for everyone. Singers would have a peak. For example 90s Mariah is the peak of her vocals. Even Whitney’s voice deteriorated over time.
@@WebsSite yea i agree i feel tho some songs they sing recently were very good tho
This video only made me miss the perfect harmonies, stage presence and energy of SB 3.0 😭
2.0 > 3.0 > 1.0 > 4.0
3.0 is better than 1.0 lol?
No, just No 😂
The original line up now are out of key, oit of sync and wobbly. It disgusts me the way that Mutty Mutya pretends she wasn't a bullying POS.
and Heidi was a sheep in wolves clothing, backstabbing one of the founding members and getting her kicked. She was also more than happy to have the narrative spread that Mutya & Keisha were bullies throughout their career. Her smiley act doesn't wash anymore and people can see her for who she is.
MKS vocals >>>