Is Saying 'Ya Ali' Allowed in Islam?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лют 2021
- It is a common phrase uttered by many Muslims, but is its shirk? Is it acceptable in Islam?
Presented by Sheikh Mohammed Al-Hilli
Watch the whole lecture here:
• Sheikh Mohammad Al Hil...
I never said Ya Ali and some Shia don't like that too much, but I do fear the fury of Allah (SWT) and I don't want to do something that would upset him.
You watched this video for what? U don’t have to say ya Ali but we Shia say it for strength because Ali (A.S) was the strongest imam.
@@notSalarito akhi why are you angry at a fellow shia on Shar Ramadan who has committed no haram. I never said it was even wrong to do. I dont do it too protect myself from ever doing something by accident to convince my self that Allah SWT is not the ask mighty. Why are you angry at me for watching a video?
Ya Allah Ya Mohammed Ya Ali Ya Zahraa Ya Hasan Ya Hussein ❤️
Ya Allah, you are the all seeing, the all wise. Ya Allah, only you can answer the prayer of the distressed in his hour of need.
Mashallah. May Allah bless you Allama :)
Beautifully explained
Thank you for the kind words. Sh. Mohammed
In shaa Allah. JazakAllah for the reminder.
Ya Ali we love you for all eternity! Ya Ali we will die a thousand times for you and the pure Holy Ahlul Bayt masoomeen and for your haters Ya Ali they still have to visit your birth place every year. Ya Ali and we will never stop saying Ya Ali Madad!
It is shirk
I will say Ya Ali infinity times.
I am not doing shirk.
I am merely calling out the name of one of the Ahlulbayt.
Shirk is associating partners with Allah.
Imam Ali (as) is not the partner of Allah.
@@DaTruth1017 ok. But if you expect him to answer you or help you than that's exactly what shirk is. Do you say ya Muhammad as much as you say ya Ali? After all he was chosen by God to bring us the final message.
I left school at 16 with no qualifications yet I can speak about ya imam Ali and his progeny till my last breath.
My name is Zulfikar and will defend any human who is being oppressed.
Thank you so much 🤲
May Allah keep you safe Ya shaikh🌹💖🌹💖
Ya Ali
I love and learning a lot.
very insightful lecture. Could we please have more on this topic in regarding to shias saying Ya Ali madad and where we stand on this matter.
Ya Ali!!! 💖
Yooo chill only Allah is the true Ya Allah. Ali is not God
Great explaination
InshAllah 🤲
Ya Ali (AS)
Mashallah, subahanallah. Rightly explained.
❤❤thanks a lot, beautiful explanation,.
When Allah wanted me to be a Muslim, 40 year ago, He made my husband tell me," when you found yourself in trouble or you can't do something, say YA ALI. MADAD.
FROM THAT MOMENT I AM A MUSLIM, and be happier ever.
Y have big Cristian family, no body botters me for been a Muslim, and they love my husnand
Anyone have links to the ahlul Sunnah books mentioned which have "Mentioning of Ali is ibadah"?
I love listening to your lectures shiekh
, god bless you
Thank you for your kind words. M. Al-Hilli
I am no one to judge because I don't know the intentions and niyat of a person who says this.. only Allah knows our intention our deep down feeling.. So i ask whoever says Ya Ali madad, Do you ask Ali (A.S) to help you in need or you're calling Allah for help? because Allah knows our true hidden intention. Allah will know what you meant by it.. So beware.. And we all know the definition of shirk..Rest is upto you..
Why Allah sent prophets to us ..why Allah didnt directly tell us?
Allah never directly help us Allah sent angles and buzurg . Hazart Ali is consider to help in difficulties . Cause Allah create mediums between us . Mediums are prophets and angles . Ya ali madad is a medium not shirk ..
People need to use common sense
We never get massages from Allah
And never get signs from Allah directly
SUBHANALLAH
Stayblessed
Thank you. You too
@@NoorIslamicEducation السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته مولانا الحلي
Magnificent marshallah 💯❤️❤️❤️❤️
Ya Ali a.s.madad..very well explained..MashaAllah..with lots of Du'a and Salaam
Ya ali madad is in my opinion not good but who want who schould
Majority of Muslims talk highly about the first 3 caliphates but how many do things to honour them (non).
Ya Ali (as) helped the caliphates even though they were wrong but how many Muslims knows this general knowledge?
MA SHA ALLAH
Allahu bless you
YAA ALI
Yaa Ali(as)
Labbaika Yaa Ali❤
SUBHAANALLAH
Ya Ali Ya Ali Ya Ali ❤🌹🌹🌹❤
Ya Allah! ❤
يا علي حتى ينقطع النفس 💛
Remember them mention them yes..but dont call out to them seeking guidance. Thats only for Allah SWT.
We cal on behalf of them not to them always to allah
JAZAKALLAH JAZAKALLAH
2:30 may I ask what the hadith is called?
The prophet's last khitab (final message) to his Ummah
Ya Ali (as) Madad! ✋🏼❤
Alhamdulillah. Ya Ali Ya Ali Ya Ali.
I have a question. Is music halal in Islam
As much as I know It's haram
So why in islamic video's background you added music. 😒
Because they are shia lol misguided, some of them are not but yeah they have tons of innovations
Assalamualaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barkatuh
Please don't come at me I am a revert shia, still learning. Do we have any authentic traditions stating that Imam Ali a.s. was born in kaba?
Quran 3:149. O you who believe, if you listen to the non-believers, they will turn you back on your heels, and you will become losers. 150. Allah is your Protector, and He is the best of helpers. 151. We will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve, because they ASSOCIATE partners with Allah without His authorization. And their refuge will be the Fire, and wretched is the residence of the transgressors.
Quran 16:86. When those who ASSOCIATED partners with God see their supposed partners, they will cry, “Our Lord, these are our partners whom we invoked besides You.” But they will throw back at them the words, “You are liars!”
Quran 30:40. Allah is the One who created you, provides for you, causes you to die, and then revives you. Can any of your ’partners’ do any of that? Glorified is He, and exalted above what they ASSOCIATE with Him.
سبحان الله الحمد الله
Yes we can call each other but is it okay to call upon the dead?
I say Ya Mohammed (SAW)
Ya Ali, Ya Ali, is permissible. Even in Sunni Hadith books cited. Scholar sir truly explained.
i don't identify myself as who follows any sect shia sunni ahl e hadees they are all labels we all are muslims but i do acknowledge the greatness when i see it or hear about it.. Ya Ali!
Shiism is not a sect you should probably educate yourself. the Messenger of Allah (S) used to say the phrase of "Shia of ‘Ali" only. This phrase is not something we invented later! Prophet Muhammad (S) said that the TRUE followers of imam ‘Ali will go to Paradise in many sunni and Shia books. And this is a great felicity. Also Jabir Ibn Abdillah al-Ansari narrated that:
The Messenger of Allah (S) said: "The Shia of ‘Ali are the real victorious in the day of resurrection/rising"
شيعة علي هم الفائزون يوم القيامة
Sunni references:
• al-Manaqib Ahmad, as mentioned in:
• Yanabi al-Mawaddah, by al-Qundoozi al-Hanafi, p62
Also the Quran uses the term shia
If somebody calls himself a Shia , it is not due to any sectarianism, nor any innovation. It is because Quran has used the phrase for some of His best servants. The above verses that I mentioned in support of Shia has used this term singular form (i.e., one group of followers).
This means that it has special meaning, such as: The Shi’a of Noah (as), The Shi’a of Moses (as). Also in the History of Islam, Shi’a has been specially used for the "followers of ‘Ali". The first individual who used this term was the Messenger of Allah
@@thelion2087 i didn't know this so appreciate the knowledge share! But yes the classic 'but', feminism was suppose to mean movement for the rights of females but in today's world it is turned into tyranny of misandrist! Now I'm not saying the words definition is changed cause of the people but we have to acknowledge that the shia u r talking about is what everybody believes in cuz if u don't respect hazrat Ali then u r more of a munafiq than Muslim but the shia I meant in my comment is indeed a sect that people have turned it into they have their set of opinions and many things that differs to many other sects this version of shia is not what was defined in Quran that I can tell u!
Hope you answer to my questions. I am just a muslim. You mentioned that you are shia? You are denying quran that Waatasimu behablillahi jameeaoa la tafaraqu.
2nd. iyyaka naabodo wa ayyaka nastaeen.
3rd. Atheeullaaha wa atheeu rasool.
You mentioned about the other prophets Yaa idrees, ya Musa right. They are the prophets. Ali is not a prophet. You can't ask help from a prophet even, How can you ask Help from Ali?
You need to spread deen (Islam) (إِنَّ ٱلدِّينَ عِندَٱللَّهِ ٱلْإِسْلَٰمُۗ)Not shiasm or Alism. You are going on a wrong track.
We ask everything from Allah, which is the right path.
The Christians and the Shia's believe is almost the same. They are asking help from Jesus and shia is asking help from Ali.
Brother, you have completely misunderstood the school of Shiasm. Please email us at sheikh@islamiced.org and we will gladly show you where to look to find correct information and be enlightened.
We do not worship Ali (A.S) astagfirullah. Kindly do more research on this issue from the Shia perspective. If you keep hearing the opinions of non Shias about us you will most definitely have a biased stance my brother.
@@Ishi1XP was Muhammad SAW shia? Where shiasm came from? It is nothing but just to weaken the Islam.
@@NoorIslamicEducation I understood it very well. There is no Sunni & Shia in Islam. Islam is deen and is based on tawheed. It is shirk to ask from Ali. What do you want from Ali? Did ever Ali helped you? Were all the prophets Shia? Was Muhammad SA shia? Why are you making pieces of Islam? Plz revert back to Islam. Shirk is the biggest sin in Islam.
@@socialmediacenter2881
Shia will never weaken Islam.
If you research further instead of writing unnecessarily thoughts I'm sure that you will delete your comments.
I pray not to Ali but our Almighty Allah to see you on the right path and not the path that others that have lead you astray🤲
I never STEAL things as i know stealing is HARAM. I only take things from shop and quickly walk away from there without paying for it, and no where this act is prohibited, but only STEALING is prohibited. So i know i never do SIN of stealing.
Similarly some ppl never do SHIRK as shirk i e. associating partners to Allah (swt) is HARAM. They only say Ya Ali madad.
Ya Ali❤️
Mashaallah molana.the voice is so low
What does YA means
Yaaa Aleeeeee
Al madad yaaa Maulaaaaaa.
🤲🤲🤲
Allahumma sali ala muhamad wa Ali muhamad wajjil farzahom shreef
Ya علی
Shaikh I would like to ask a question
As u said we can offer namaz e shab
While lying in bed too,my question is for ladies they must be in hijab just like in Wajib prayer?
Yes hijba is needed. M.Al-Hilli
Yes for recommended prayers. M. Al-Hilli
Appreciate your concern
Ya Ali!!! Ya Ali!!! Ya Ali!!!
Yea but you can say Ya allah
یا علی الحق ۔
Ya Allah
Zikkri ALIYUN EBADAH 💖
YA ALI MADAD
say ya allah its better
@@Sara-ey1fb then asking for what?
Sunnies refuse to follow the truth. Everything they do is the opposite of what Allah swt says. It’s shameful and disrespectful to the lord and the holy prophet. They will answer for their hypocrisy on the day of judgement.
the Messenger of Allah (S) used to say the phrase of "Shia of ‘Ali" only. This phrase is not something we invented later! Prophet Muhammad (S) said that the TRUE followers of imam ‘Ali will go to Paradise in many sunni and Shia books. And this is a great felicity. Also Jabir Ibn Abdillah al-Ansari narrated that:
The Messenger of Allah (S) said: "The Shia of ‘Ali are the real victorious in the day of resurrection/rising"
شيعة علي هم الفائزون يوم القيامة
Sunni references:
• al-Manaqib Ahmad, as mentioned in:
• Yanabi al-Mawaddah, by al-Qundoozi al-Hanafi, p62
Also the Quran uses the term shia
If somebody calls himself a Shia , it is not due to any sectarianism, nor any innovation. It is because Quran has used the phrase for some of His best servants. The above verses that I mentioned in support of Shia has used this term singular form (i.e., one group of followers).
This means that it has special meaning, such as: The Shi’a of Noah (as), The Shi’a of Moses (as). Also in the History of Islam, Shi’a has been specially used for the "followers of ‘Ali". The first individual who used this term was the Messenger of Allah
Could you please provide one verse of the Qur'an talking about Shia. You don't seem to include any in your comment.
You seem amongst "Shi'a" of al imam Ali (RA) which isn't a bad thing. But you are attributing him a partnering place with Allah.
Why do you ask Allah for help through someone else?
If asking Allah for help through the help of shayatheen/ie sihr or black magic is a Shirk why isn't it shirk to ask Allah for help through a person like imam Ali (RA)?
And isn't this what the Ansar are doing?
We all know from quran and hadith that Allah forgives any sin except shirk.. So if there is even slightest of chance that it can be shirk when we call Ya Ali madad then we should avoid it.. Lets say your intentions are pure but when you call it hundreds and thousands of time there will be one or two time your intention will inclined to other side where you literally asking Ali (A.S) for help other than Allah..And other reason is not everyone is literate and has knowledge of quran and hadith they only follow what they see Alims maoulvi doing..they don't know the intention of Alim who are saying Ya Ali.. He can misinterprete it and he can commit shirk without knowing it.. So its better to avoid..I hope these reasons are enough
Its big shirk just say ya Allah
Explain to me brother.
he just spent 8 minutes explaining why its not shirk. bro, dont worry about religion, God won't expect anything from you since you were born disabled mentally.
For example your brother name is Ismail in Arabic if you want to call your brother in Arabic you say ' ya Ismail ' ok if we say imam Ali a.s 'ya Ali a.s' what is shirk in this word
@@ahmedibegum5136 we dont call the dead because they cannot hear us
@@UsamamohamudQuran says the martyrs are alive with their lord, so don’t think of them as dead ya jahil.
Ya ali is normal..is that not how Arabs calls each other?...this is not a reason and saying seeking to get ^closer to God and the Quran says ALLAH is closer to us than our veins and najul balaga said He is near ....and He is Far but not by distance, finally our faiths have levels so some are nearest to God than others which can change too so I disagree with this video except I get a cleaner explanation
What i thought
I dont disagree with saying ya Ali out of love for Ali a.s but i dont get the madad bit and how he can hear and help.
@@Turaab2608 no help except from Allah but these people remind and get us close thru their remembrance but not thru them directly as sunni says..that's my understanding
@@Turaab2608 Allah helps Through Ahlulbayt a.s, if you think that "what if I ask Imam Ali a.s because Allah isn't going to help" Imam Ali a.s won't help you either because Allah helps us through them. Many times I have said "Ya Ali Madad" when I forgot where I kept my things and then I see it in an instant.
@@Turaab2608 plus, if you think that Ahlulbayt a.s are dead, they aren't because they are martyred in the way of Allah. (Some people have these misconceptions that Ahlulbayt, they've died so if you have this doubt then it's clear) hope you understand 🤗🤗🤗💫💫💫
Isn't this shirk?
Everything pertaining to the progeny is shirk according to wahhabis and salafis
It's when ghulluw it becomes shirk. Ali, Fatimah, Hassan and Hussein (radhiallah anhi) are loved by all al sunnah wal jamaah. But Shia mushrikeens have done to them what the Nasranis have done to Isa (as) and his companions.
@@wanrazul Please explain to me what we do wrong. Thank you.
@@HiHi-ek1dd To love Fatimah, Ali, Hassan and Hussein (ra) excessively (ghuluw), and to assume that Rasulallah (saw) made a mistake when picking his companions (Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Aisha, Abu Hurayrah...etc (ra)).
If the sahabahs were bad men/women, Rasulallah (saw) would have known, and would have been the first to curse them.
@@wanrazul When did the prophet Hazrat muhhamad SAW PBUH pick Omar? Abu Bakr? The prophet of Allah SWT said to leave my house on the days he was ill. Also you don't believe Imam Hussain as is the chief of Jannah? We cry we mourn for the tragic day of Karbala and Asham. Tell me what you know about Karbala? I'll try give more explanation. The prophet of Allah SWT said to Imam Ali AS he is the mola after me in Ghadeer...
This sheikh teaching to the people really shirk . We can call the people when they are alive in this world. When they are died we can not call by their names because they are died. Allah only always alive. If written in any book against the aqqeetha of Islam we not need to follow that book. May Allah save us from doing shirk.
According to Quran, a shaheed(martyr) is alive.
@@m4mano Al-Quran
Surah 39 - Az-Zumar - Ayah 2
أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم
بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
اِنَّاۤ اَنۡزَلۡنَاۤ اِلَيۡكَ الۡكِتٰبَ بِالۡحَقِّ فَاعۡبُدِ اللّٰهَ مُخۡلِصًا لَّهُ الدِّيۡنَ
Translation:
Surely We have revealed the Book to you with the truth; so worship Allah in submission to Him exclusively.
@@mobinjee4659 we don't worship anybody except Allah swt naozubillah. Hazrat Ali was a human, not God. But there's nothing wrong with calling him Ya Ali.
@@m4mano alive meaning in his grave his soul and day of resurrection, not literally alive body and soul, if he's dead is dead
I am a Sunni. I do not disagreee saying YA ALI. It is in what intentions. Ali is known as Tiger of Allah. He can be called by YA ALI but not to get the power of a Tiger.
Dude they’re calling upon others than allah almighty
But you're calling upon the dead which is clearly haram. This is like bowing down to idols and saying as long as you don't believe in them it's okay. Brother, the action itself is completely haram, it's shirk, whatever your intention was or wasn't it doesn't change the fact that it's completely haram to call upon the dead or anyone other than Allah (swt) when alone.
@@inkblaster_12Asking help from Allah through Ali isn’t shirk lol
@@TalibrosYou must call upon Allah alone, He is our Lord and doesn’t need His creation to help us. Exalted is He above all that they associate with Him. Why do you delude yourself and deny that it is shirk? Allah is not like His creation and throughout the Quran Allah mentions that He does not approve of those who call upon Him through His creation, Allah sent messengers for that very reason to remind the people of all generations to worship Him and call upon Him alone. Allah created all that is in the heavens and the earth, He can help you through anything but only if you invoke Him alone. If you still cannot see the truth, then it is your heart that is blind not your eyes.
@@sarahahmed16 You can ask imam Ali to ask god to help you, imam Ali’s soul is alive with Allah, he’s dead physically but he’s soul is still alive because he’s a martyr. But yes you can also ask help from Allah directly, nothing wrong with that.
La ilaha ilalha Muhamdur RasoolAllah
Ya Ali
Every day in namaz we say in fatiha, you alone we worship you alone we ask for help. Let's not do to hazrat ali what the Christians did to jesus pbuh.
We do not consider imam Ali as Allah. Christians consider Jesus as God. There is a difference.
@@thelordknows whether you ask Jesus pbuh for help or hazrat Ali for help its still shirk. Punishment for shirk is the fire. According to the quran hazrat ali will be your enemy on the day of judgement.
@uzmamahmud8305 we are not doing shirk. If that was the case then the Prophet mazallah did shirk. Because even he used to call out imam Ali to bring for them water during battles. You need to educate yourself before speaking bs.
@@thelordknows you my friend should read what you just said. Hazrat Ali is not alive today. When he was alive you could ask him for help. Muawiya was literate, the prophet would say ya muawiya come take notes. Doesn't mean you can call him for help today. It's so clear from quran that you are forbidden from asking anyone but God for help. You cross a line when your love for hazrat ali makes him superhuman. Again and again our prophet is told by God in the quran to tell the people around him that he is a man like them. He was a brilliant man blessed by God but hurt like they did, felt hunger like they did and as promised in the quran that every soul shall taste death, he died like all of them did. His duty is over. He gave us the message as God instructed him to. Now it's his time to enjoy paradise. Hazrat Ali, as beautiful as he was, was NOT a prophet. He is NOT mentioned in the bible. He is not mentioned in the quran. He will be so sad that people spilt his prophets religion in his name.
@uzmamahmud8305 Imam Ali isn't alive today but he dies as shaheed. Do you even know what Allah says in the Quran about shaheed (those who died in his path) "Verily do not think those who died in the path of Allah as dead, rather they are alive and receive sustenance).
If that is the case then stop asking people, who are full of sins, to pray for you or your loved ones who are sick. Many a times people do that without realising.
Imam Ali died as a martyr read what the Qur’an say about martyrs.
Are you a Christian? Why are you telling me he isn't mentioned in the bible? As a matter of fact, Ali and his sons are mentioned in the bible read Gensys 17:22 about 12 princes and if you see the prophet progeny were exactly 12 leaders.
If Imam Ali was mentioned in the Qur'an people like you would tear up the blessed book, The Qur'an, that's how much you hate him. But Allah swt has mentioned him in such a way that you people are blind. Sura 5 verse 55. It says only Allah is your vali (friend), and the messenger and those who give zakat while they bow. The first person to give zakat whilst bowing was Imam Ali. Go search history it is even in your books.
The Prophet is sad at looking at his ummah. The Prophet, by the order of Allah swt, chose Imam Ali to be successor. He was raised by the holy Prophet. What you guys are doing is not only sad it is an insult to the Prophet because the Prophet guided you and told you who to follow after his death,yet you follow those who were not deserving and usurped the rights of the Prophet. Since the time of Adam Allah swt chose who will be his messenger, you think Allah will leave his people after the death of the Prophet and keep it in the hands of people to choose? Think about it. These things what i said is in your own books yet you are ignoring it. May Allah guide you.
Misguided and giving wrong interpretations with out proof. May Allah guide them.
Bro did not watch the video and decided to try to look righteous
Ya Ali