BEST and WORST Line Distributions Of Kpop Girl Groups (OUTDATED)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 січ 2022
- Video Credits:
@random_k @kawaiikpopofficial @HEXA6ONKPOP @CHOGlWA
What do you think about the video?
Please don't copy my videos, thumbnails or layouts!
If you like my content, feel free to subscribe it would help allot~
If you want to comment anything make sure it is in english otherwise i won't understand it /:
I do NOT own anything! All rights are reserved
FAQ:
Q : What editing platforms do you use for editing your videos?
A : I use Adobe Photoshop, Adobe After Effects & Vegas Pro
Q : From where did you learn how to make line distribution videos:
A : I learned form @CHOGlWA & GL-KPOP they have great tutorials!
Q : Are you a boy or a girl?
A : I am a boy and my pronounces are he/him
Q : What is your favorite kpop group?
A : My favourite is BLACKPINK
Q : Who is your ultimate bias of all time?
A : My ultimate bias is rosie~
Q : From where are you?
A : I am from israel
Tags:
#Kpop #BLACKPINK #TWICE # ITZY #aespa #EVERGLOW #STAYC #IVE #CLC #(G)I-dle #Dreamcatcher
Credits For The Video:
random_k, HEXA6ON, C H O G I W A, kawaiikpop, ultimatekpop
You forgot kom26 music
And also you forgot to put *miggy smallz* for your intro
Can u tell me the intros song name?
@@heuniofied lo
random_k makes it VERY clear in their videos that you cannot use their videos EVEN with credit and/or consent. You stole their content. You should know what their rules are, they put them on every single one of their video intros. Take the clip down.
I can't believe that everglow's fairest line distribution still has +30s gap between the first and last member 🤯
and I think the line distribution is wrong- it counted some adlibs for EU that wasnt her
Ikr
and the fact that it's less fair than Aespa's most UNFAIR
Yeah, a average of 6 seconds gap per member....
And their most unfair line distribution is pretty much the worst of all in my opinion
FYI,Mia's line in No lie is longer than Jennie's line in Solo
You think that’s normal til you realise Jennie’s solo is her solo and then you realise that’s so wrong
@@aliliso_n just joke
Wait what????
@@jihyosmicrophone638 yeahh
@@aliliso_n Jennie's solo is also mostly instrumental
The fact that Everglow's "fairest" line distribution is still more unfair than most other groups "worst" line distributions, like let that sink in.. EVERGLOW really needs to do better and take notes from ITZY and aespa...
this is not the girls fault, they can't do something about that, it's all because of the company and producers
Finally someone beat mia in everglow
Ever heard of SISTAR?? 😂
ever heard of sistar and loona?
Please stop! Its not The girls fault
Haseul's line at hi high made me cry😭😭😭
"EoTtOkHaE" -Haseul
Eottokhae
The fact that some of the "worst" ones are better than EVERGLOW's "best" line distribution... 💀
Honestly Itzy's "worst" line distribution isn't really that bad considering it is a vocal focused song
Also their title songs are always very balanced. B-sides or other songs can be unbalanced sometimes, especially cause they often have a very specific style.
Yep it is pretty fair
that’s why i love itzy, they’re very fair. if a member doesn’t get as much lines in one song they get more in another. each take turns but most of the time they get about a good duration time each in a song
@@-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-. u have to be joking
@@momoisbae2515 why? Itzy is by far the most fairest one I have seen in girl group or even in kpop overall. They each get pretty equal time to shine.
The fact that the worst Itzy line distribution still fair
I just cant stand people who say that it aint fair because only Lia could pull of a song like that (not saying that the others cant but Lia's voice suits it the best).💜
ikr, lia is the best!
Yeah like ryujin got least lines in that song (be in love) bc she is sub vocal and every song have like yeji more line then yuna and ryujin and chaer and lia sometimes get less lines so jyp give her the most lines in songs she suits the best and it looks good but in one song lia got so many lines and I hate that (sorry not sorry) yeji got very little song but it's okkk we love yeji lia ryujin chaer yuna ot5
Love itzy btwsorry for my English it's not good it's not my first language hehe
@@anayaghalib6965 but lia has more lines overall than yeji so lia has more lines than yeji
@@Milan20997 yea bc yeji is the lead vocalist the main vocalist is lia
when Wa Da Da has the fairest line distribution despite bahiyyih only having one line
👁️👄👁️
I think it isn't the fairest
Like even O.O.O is more fair than "WA DA DA" (not for Hikaru, but for the reste it's the best :/)
Also yujin unnie has one line
8s is better than nothing
@@_kh.ced_9593 O.O is Nmixx though? Or are you saying out of all the songs In this video?
@@lolitasfake O.O.O is Girls Planet 999 song but they released a KEP1ER version
fair doesn't mean equal... equal means they all get the approximate number of lines. fair means that all the members have lines that make them stand out in the song, Besides, no one has a lot of lines and others have too few.
For Loona, I think the worst is probably Favorite or Stylish. Chuu had 40+ seconds while Hyunjin only has 1 second (which is shared with Chuu) in Stylish.
IDK, Hi high is the iconic worst ld of them
@@amitkpoplds 0.7 for a superior vocalist in a title track
I also think Star/Voice is fairer than Butterfly, then again maybe they only wanted to include OT12 songs which is why Butterfly is here
@@amitkpoplds no it isn't
@@icecoffee981 yes it is, more people have talked about haseul's 0.7 seconds than they have favorite
When Dreamcatcher first debuted 5 of the members already had 5+ years training while the other two had only been trainees for 6 months. So, their company leaned way more on the experienced members, giving the newer members a chance to grow as performers. Five years later and I can't complain with the results! I'm truly a spoiled fan! ^^
Dami n'a pourtant pas encore eu la chance de montrer assez son potentiel malgré ses 5 ans d'expérience
@@julesfoury9240 Certes, les rôles de Dami étaient petits au début, mais elle a commencé à obtenir des crédits d'écriture avant tout le monde.
If this were true Sua would've had the most lines considering she trained the longest
@@soniacastro4246 But, she spent most that time training as a dancer. That's why she was a rapper in Minx.
Dreamcatcher used to be awful but for the last few comebacks they've been so insanely fair
For aespa black mamba it makes sense why the main and lead vocalist will get the most lines since it's a vocal song
it’d be cool to see stayc in these videos too since they’re usually known for a fair line distribution
Hi high is literally a really good song but the line distribution is so bad
Just like "no lie" but if you see any line distribution of them u can see Mia literally spamming every mv not hating Mia tho
"No lie" is Mia's solo, i think
It’s kinda sad that IZ*ONE’s most fair song is their disbandment song
0:25 Blackpink
1:02 Twice
1:39 Itzy
2:13 Red Velvet
2:50 Aespa
3:25 Loona
4:02 Everglow
4:37 (G)I-dle
5:15 Dreamcatcher
5:50 Iz*One
6:25 Kep1er
7:00 Ive
7:37 Secret Number
8:14 Brave Girls
8:49 CLC
Thanks for reading!❤️
I like the line evolution in Dreamcatcher.
Handong and Gahyeon used to be the last ones, which drastically changed the past few comebacks. But tbh even before, Handong gets the best lines despite having little of it (DejaVu was ICONIC)
Maison might be the one that I thought is the fairest (although it's actually BEcause). Maison era was everything, Gahyeon getting way more lines and Handong slaying hers. Although my bias SuA was last in this era, I'm not even complaining since she got the best shots hands down😌
But if you will look at their overall line distribution then you will notice that Handong is always in the bottom 3 whereas gahyeon and Dami got the chance to be top 3. Handong also has the least center time, most edge and least screentime.
That's true, but I think it's starting to change recently. Back then, I wouldn't even dream for Handong to get a line in the chorus but Odd Eye exists sooo
Well, I definitely hope HappyFace would give more of what you stated above, but I am already happy with what we have now :)
Sua's dance break was iconic! She slayed it! And because she was seen a lot in the MV, people thought she had more lines.
Im shocked in twices best line distribution Chaeyong and Dahyun got the most lines.
I consider Twice's Feel Special also as one of the best line distribution of them.
Also signal or more and more.
i think the best line distribution is signal
Fake AND True is better
@@jhxnymr3273 yes fake and true also.
Can you add Mamamoo next time, was looking forward to seeing them on the list! Nice vid tho!
In almost all the everglow line songs, it's unfair🙃
no almost
No almost...
Are you blind?
@@bhikhabhaichaudhari8387 yeah
True.
Yeap except ladida and first all the songs have the most unfair distribution 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
Everytime I read " unfair line distribution " I immediately think of Everglow and Loona :c such a big contrast to Itzy and Aespa, their worst distributions aren't actually bad
About Dreamcatcher I thought their worst line distribution was Sleep walking, I'm not really sure though
I think ITZY have the fairest line distribution, i know they have some that are not fair like "be in love" but i think they have a fair amount in a lot song
Hi! Some corrections...
Loona's worst distribution is stylish (Chuu: almost 40 seconds/ Hyunjin: 1.2 seconds)
And their best is UR
(Chuu 19 / Olivia 8)
As for red velvet:
Butterflies is their fairest line distribution, and that Russian Roulette distribution video is innacurrate since it doesn't have pauses when they dont sing,,, So the difference between Joy and Irene is about 5 seconds? While on Butterflies its less than 3
Idk about the rest
Anyway, thanks for the video 😁
i think the best LD of red velvet is "butterflies" and the worst one is "be natural"
random_k doesnt want their videos reposted credits or not.
No Lie is literally 90% Mia 😂
And in most of the songs, Mia has 50% the lines 🤣
Everglow's company (YueHua Ent.) should really take notes from STAYC and other groups :)
It's not StayC , it's SlayC !
3:18 At least my bias sings the most
people: sIgNal iS TWiCE's bESt lINE dIstRIBUtiOn
*twice song has entered the chat*
itzy ,txt are fair almost everytime...
U know mamamoo is a group
Also stray kids
aespa*
who tf is moomooma
@@chaenival3785 u blind
I wrote mamamoo
That's funny
itzy's best should be weapon. all members had more than 30s, so yeahh
Well but with a bigger gap
KPop groups REALLY need to step up their game. Like, I understand it might be hard to let 6+ people get enough time (clc, twice, loona, dreamcatcher, etc.) but for groups with 5 or less… Either way they need to do better.
try watching a few jpop line distributions
you'll see real unfairness 🤩
@@wjshty lol now I’m scared
@@spaghettilawn-mower9620 it's mostly the ones from the early 2000s to early 2010s that would have one or two members singing over a minute and then 4 sing less than 20 seconds but they've improved now
Check one directions distributions and stop complaining
@@nihilongongo hey, no reason to get snappy
For me, most unfair Everglow song is of course 'No Lie', but the fairest is not 'Don't Speak'.. Maybe Gxxd Boy is kinda more fair..
If 'Don't speak' is the fairest it's still unfair.. I'm waiting for their good distribution..
yeah, Gxxd boy is a fair line distribution but....
ONDA. SHE GOT 7 SECONDS IN GXXD BOY WHILE EVERYONE ELSE GOT 35+
@@mtheblepalopYT Now it's edited. People said someone from Everglow said it's Onda's lines not E:U's after 'I'm in love with a good boy' line.
Onda has a lot of lines example:
all 'Must be good' after Yiren's parts
So Onda has a lot lines, poor E:U has only few lines...
Yup, in rap song MAIN RAPPER has no lines, YueHua's logic..
My poor E:U, it's so sad..
Wouldn't promise be the fairest other than E:U's 4 seconds?
Actually, E:U basically don't have lines in gxxd boy since her chorus lines is actually onda
Here are the Everglow songs with the fairest line distribution:
1. Gxxd boy
2. Untouchable (debatable)
3. Adios
4. Don't speak
5. Promise
6. Moon
7. LA DI DA
Itzy usually has songs geared towards certain members, but it varies (tho I think Chaeryoung could use a little more love) so even tho there is some disparity between members song to song it evens out by the end.
I AGREE OMG I LOVE CHAER and i cried when i saw “voltage” and the love chaer was getting
sorn: lead vocalist
seunghee: main vocalist
**sorn getting more than double of seunghee's lines**
Wouldn't Everglow's fairest be Promise? (Aside from E:U ofc)
Here are their songs with the fairest line distribution:
1. Gxxd biy
2. Untouchable (debatable)
3. Adios
4. Don't speak
5. Promise
6. Moon
7. LA DI DA
Even no lie not fair but it so good song to relaxing i love it
Thank you for including Secret Number. Such and underrated group and they are all amazing (btw who is still sad Denise left)
Mee😔
@@Honestly_Yasmin Omg Same😢😢😢🥺
Just wanted to say Lucid Dream is one of the best Aespa songs, and in my opinion it's absolutely underrated
the "worst" part in forever young is my favorite part
i was completely SPEECHLESS when i first saw the line distribution for 'No Lie'... like whoever is organizing the line distribution for Everglow, we get it, Mia is very talented, but please let the other members shine more often since they are a GROUP
Mia is my bias , but … 90% of the time of the song , she is singing 😂
Wow it's so nice 💗
For izone most fir one is ssots by each member had 8+ lines which is pretty rare for a 12 member group
Everglow's best line distribution still isn't fair to E:u😭
Your intro🥰😍😍 (and ending🤩)
Thank you for including CLC
*I SEE ROSÉ, I CLICK*
4:22 Mia: Baby no lines baby no lines
actually in dreamcatcher there's a song called "sleep walking". For how much i love their discography, it's totally easy and sad to admit that the most unfair line distribution (go to check it and you're gonna understand what I said) like yoohyeon ft friends. It's gving nayeon+ dancers in i can't stop me era tho help
Mia ft. EVERGLOW - "NO LIE" (Official Audio)
Thanks for adding Brave Girls
I'm using screens from your video in ny quora answer and I'll link you 👍🏾👍🏾
Be in love is the only song where lia got lines ...
not really she always gets the most or 2nd most line
actually the fairest line distribution of Everglow Is "Adiós"
Actually is Gxxd boy
Moon was fairest
@@klmnopqrstuvwxyz1874 but Gxxd boy E:U got alot of lines...
It is harder for groups with a lot of members like twice to get fair line distribution cuz there is so many members.
why is it always the ones where my biases get the most lines that are the worst-
I hope you can do a part 2 that features WJSN and GFRIEND!! ❤
Dreamcatcher’s break the wall is the best
6:08 this sounds so beautiful ☺️
For me,Nobody like you is more fair than mafia in the morning
dreamcatcher the lines were horrible but nowadays the dreamcatcher lines are the best
Black Mamba is actually very fair relative to each member's position in terms of singing. It's already passable as a distribution that focuses on equality, but when judging it based on equity, it makes a lot of sense. There's an almost equal gap between all of the members that's around only double the size from shortest to longest, and Giselle's minimum of 15 seconds is still a lot. Giselle's lines are also the rap verses, which add contrast and stand out in vocal-heavy songs solely for being different from the rest of the song. And throughout the song, all members are always consistently singing after one another. It's a fair distribution that does not focus on the total number of seconds, but rather the sound and performance overall.
I actually hope SM does give them a fair distribution
Please do second gen
I have to mention that in the intro you are using the remix from Miggy Smallz, and i think you should credit them at the description as well.
There is a fact that Be In Love is one of my favorite song
Where is mamamoo, how can u not include that iconic gg❤️
I love do what we like song
I am so happy tht lucid dream is here on out the list of best one lol ✨✨
POV: EVERGLOW's Fairest song is Unfair and Aespa's Unfairest song is fair.
your intro song is sooooo good, what mashup is it? or did u make it yourself?
Excuse me i have commented at your last video hehe tnx
1:50 - 1:52 that was really satisfying!!
ive literally had two songs when u made this video
Blackpink: 4ever young, kick it
Twice: The twice song/Fake & true, Truth. If you count the twice song, 1.8s
Itzy: mitm, be in love
Red velvet: Butterfly, automatic
Aespa: Lucid dream, Black mamba
Loona: Colors/U r, Wow. Colors if you count gap between first and last, u r if you count who shines.
Everglow: Ladida/Don’t speak, No lie
Gidle: Lion, Put it straight
Izone: Panorama, You and I
I think itzy most fair is "what i want"
For izone, slow journey and spaceship are the fairest i think
i think the most fair song of iz*one is "slow journey"
MY ULTS IDLE EVERGLOW SN AND TRIBE
Everglow is on another level their worst line distribution is crazy like 100
be in love is actually fair, it’s a vocal based song so ofc lia and yeji got more partd
70 secs for Jennie, damn...
No lie - Mia & Sihyeon ft. E.U, Yiren, Aisha, Onda
for automatic i think it’s because it was more of a vocal song also for the video in general main vocals are usually supposed to get the most lines
Everglow ☠️
Why does everyone is pointing out negativeness of Everglow but not positiveness. Every group has negativess and of everglow, they have too. But ever since debut, only this point has been topic, but it's because of there company. And it's somewhere they also had there reasons which probably hase'nt been reveal. What if they group is still not ready, it's not like everyone is declared on camera. And yueha has other groups too, and they don't treat this way to them. I am true forever and far as I know, some of the members does not have stable voice. So it's not good to point one bad think about company and group and sleeping on their talent. They have REASONS!!!
ok so don't get me wrong but i think the fairest in loona is prolly colors (i check the standard deviation and it is much fairer than butterfly)
yall still can correct me if im wrong
Sm loves to give half of the song to Ning Ning or karina
The Kep1er worst distribution of lines is WaDaDa,from Bahiyyih, most of its “lines” were “Hey!” or “Yeah! “, her only “real line” was before one of the choirs, and she didn't deserve that :(
No lie's distribution has to be some sort of joke😭
ppl need to stop hatin on idols for unfair line distributions tho
I think the most in the kep1er line distribution is MVSK
there is more line difference in MVSK than in wa da da, literally wa da da is the best distributed in the entire FIRST IMPACT album, for you it seems that if bahiyyih is last in the distribution it is unfair but if there is another member it is fair , a lot of fanaticism and it shows.
The fact haseul didnt get a second💀
I think the line distributions mostly depend on what type of song they are going to perform. As in a rap song the rappers would get more lines than the vocalists.
nothing can beat haseul’s “eottokhae”
Mia: Baby No Lie
Other Members: Baby No Lines 💀☠️☠️☠️
Mia: Baby no lie
The others: Baby no lines