@Pinkceramics Heidi has never really gotten the credit she deserves for all that she's brought to the group over the years. Notice that she's also the only one who doesn't have to check herself during any part of the song (even the coda at the end) because she has perfect pitch.
keisha and mutya's voice compliment each other during the "trip by trip, etc." part. i love amelle and all, but this is mutya's. they have different vocal personalities.
That aside, Amelle does miss a few notes ONLY in the first verse, but even when Keisha sang Mutya's parts live, she always missed a lot of notes because Mutya's voice was so much deeper than any other member's. Amelle can also sing deep and has greater range than Mutya (can sing quite a bit higher) but she can't reach the lowest part of Mutya's register. Mutya has a very special voice and wrote her part based on it, give Amelle some credit for pulling it off in the face of all that!
amelle is doing pretty well in filling for mutya's place.. and it's not an easy job as we all know.. it's just that, the more amelle sings those line the more i am convince that mutya's line in every song that they have with her (mutya), are untouchable.
I'm only saying that - as a suggestion if you like - if Amelle wouldn't sing Mutya's parts, it would avoid her being compared. As example, I don't imagine "About you now" being sung by Mutya. It's Amelle's territory. But if she sings "Caught in a moment" it's like looking for trouble.....
OMG....This is awful, so many bum notes? I don't understand how anyone thinks this is a good version. Just play the one that they have produced in a studio and see if you still think its OK? Oh dear...This is (was) my favourite of their songs.
keisha looks really pretty here and in the beginng of the first verse amelle doesn't sound that good but her 2nd verse is good heidi sounds flawless here
haters just shut up sugababes are amazing they can sing and they're also good and talented...look at the others that sing in playback because they suck at live while these three girls are incredible!
I don't blame Amelle for getting nervous singing Mutya's parts. I prefer Amelle's drier voice in Follow Me Home and Easy, but this one she's really not getting the warmth or the soul. Plus, she really is a bit off-key. What the hell - still better than I could ever do :)
are you serious??? If that's not a good live perfomance for you in a crappy club, what is it then? Of course that doesn't sound like the CD, and even the audio is crappy but they can sing at least. That question is how OTHER people have been famous singing shit.
this is terrible. it sounds like women who are put in singing group, and are trying way to hard to be a girl band. too much obvious effort for such a simple song
amelles voice isnt the best here cuz this wasnt her song annyways...mutya sang it but on tracks like red dress,easy,follow me home,change ..amelle performs them perfectly
Everyone seems to have overlooked how beautiful Heidi's voice is here.
@Pinkceramics Heidi has never really gotten the credit she deserves for all that she's brought to the group over the years. Notice that she's also the only one who doesn't have to check herself during any part of the song (even the coda at the end) because she has perfect pitch.
I wonder if Mutya watches this and pisses herself laughing
like I just did!
Amelle should have toned down her singing for this. I love her, but Mutya was perfect on this song.
keisha and mutya's voice compliment each other during the "trip by trip, etc." part.
i love amelle and all, but this is mutya's. they have different vocal personalities.
heidi sings great here
That aside, Amelle does miss a few notes ONLY in the first verse, but even when Keisha sang Mutya's parts live, she always missed a lot of notes because Mutya's voice was so much deeper than any other member's. Amelle can also sing deep and has greater range than Mutya (can sing quite a bit higher) but she can't reach the lowest part of Mutya's register. Mutya has a very special voice and wrote her part based on it, give Amelle some credit for pulling it off in the face of all that!
heidi is the best babe
amelle is doing pretty well in filling for mutya's place.. and it's not an easy job as we all know.. it's just that, the more amelle sings those line the more i am convince that mutya's line in every song that they have with her (mutya), are untouchable.
amelle ruined the song
I'm only saying that - as a suggestion if you like - if Amelle wouldn't sing Mutya's parts, it would avoid her being compared.
As example, I don't imagine "About you now" being sung by Mutya. It's Amelle's territory. But if she sings "Caught in a moment" it's like looking for trouble.....
great voices, they truly deserve their place in pop music,so many singers today who cant actually sing a note
i think amelle is well good!
OMG....This is awful, so many bum notes? I don't understand how anyone thinks this is a good version. Just play the one that they have produced in a studio and see if you still think its OK? Oh dear...This is (was) my favourite of their songs.
i think when heidi is calm and not dancing is when her voice is perfection
what the HELL is amelle doing?!
MUTYA SAVE ME ....
AGREEEEEEE!!!
I'd say Amelle shouldn't sing Mutya's songs to avoid comparisons.
Amelle sounded terrible doing Mutya's parts
keisha looks really pretty here and in the beginng of the first verse amelle doesn't sound that good but her 2nd verse is good heidi sounds flawless here
haters just shut up sugababes are amazing they can sing and they're also good and talented...look at the others that sing in playback because they suck at live while these three girls are incredible!
I love me some Amelle, but this song is NOT for her
Amelle lacks of subtlety (is that ok?)
Keisha and Heidi sound great here.
Mutya's version is so mutch BETER!
nobody will ever be able to sing this like mutya. amelle sounds dreadful on this.
wow Heidi sounds great live, and so does Keisha
I don't blame Amelle for getting nervous singing Mutya's parts. I prefer Amelle's drier voice in Follow Me Home and Easy, but this one she's really not getting the warmth or the soul. Plus, she really is a bit off-key. What the hell - still better than I could ever do :)
Ms Thing MURDERED THE SONG, please hide this video in a basement
are you serious??? If that's not a good live perfomance for you in a crappy club, what is it then? Of course that doesn't sound like the CD, and even the audio is crappy but they can sing at least. That question is how OTHER people have been famous singing shit.
especially the end of the song where keisha sings is very good,amelle sings so hectic and wiv not much emotion i think!
this is terrible. it sounds like women who are put in singing group, and are trying way to hard to be a girl band. too much obvious effort for such a simple song
Amelle ugh
ameli iz mint as, she dun make skwarky souns an that, she reel talentd.
honestly i love the sugababes and i miss mutuya.
amazing performance !!! amelle should be better but it is not her worst
Mutya is better at singing this song, but Amelle is not awful.
I completely agree!
haha aww i love the first 30 seconds
Cette chanson est trop mimi ! Je l'adore. Elles chantent trop bien et le rythme est super ! Rien a dire a pars qu'elle est parfaite !
amelles voice isnt the best here cuz this wasnt her song annyways...mutya sang it but on tracks like red dress,easy,follow me home,change ..amelle performs them perfectly
you're thinking of TLC's Dear Lie.
sugababes are so amazing
sugababes are so amazing
@30031181sean LMAO
i love it
Wow Amelle that was wonderful-ly bad.