Excellent discussion. Please don't dump it down. A series of discussions would be wonderful. If not the government, the people of Punjab have that innate capability to rise from the ashes and I firmly believe we will sooner or later get rid of these issues via people's initiatives and innovations.
@@1008apocalypse1008 Not just free electricity, but most freebies across various sections have made us beggars, always greedily seeking from the government. Instead of empowering us with education and skills, we have been reduced to phocomelic citizens.
I hope next time they listen more rather than interrupting and talking over each other! I wish they let Mr. Lakhanpal speak more as he has worked with a range of politicians in Punjab.
Madam, important question is that 6 lakhs acres of government land is illegally encroached. I can prove it with documents. No one put question to government to get it vacated and give all sorts of subsidies. Naresh Johar Amritsar
Absolutely correct ✅ sir, I am fighting to restore the original title of one such government land illegally occupied by mafia inconvenience with government officials since last 10 years,now because to shield the corrupt government officials they are working tooth and nail 😂😂😂
So true, Sikh religion teaches not to beg , and take pride in hardwark to earn livelihood, but these Politicians have made them hooked to freebies like sasta nashe 😢😢
Punjab’s current state shud open eyes to limitation of any religion on progress of society. As per Punjab’s people Sikhs are great coz they follow Sikhi but condition of Punjab doesn’t reflect any greatness
What about freebies BJP promised in other states during elections ? I know freebies isn't good, especially electricity. But quality free education and healthcare isn't freebies. @@1008apocalypse1008
Lions share subsidies go to rich farmers, who in fact are PROXY farmers, and also enjoy free income tax benefits. Actual tillers , whom these rich farmers RENT OUT their farms, get nothing!
Alright farmer hater, u can cry all you can. People whose ancestors gave blood for this land owns the land and can do anything they want with their land. Either rent it or till it. Whats your problem?
@@randhawaz1 Wow these present landlords are ex servicemen of British Indian Army or their supporters who got these lands and Jagirs gifted to them for the loyalty they showed for the Crown. Go check out the facts about the landlords of Punjab both in India and Pakistan and see the lands where they got it from, there are many books written on it with historical records from British museum like Ishtiaq Ahmed's Punjab: Partioned cleansed, Hardit Singh Malik book on Independent India and Punjabi jatt etc. Go read the history before making a fool out of yourselves
@@thatwasyesterday Arrey sir land ceiling itself is limited to 18 acres for Punjab, over it follows the cold storage, dairy, with many renting agri equipment all tax free under farmer/agriculturist category!! Also it doesn’t includes the subsidy of free electricity, pesticides and MSP gurantee which the govt of state and centre guarantees!! I myself come from farmers family of Punjab and I know how the arthiya/jimmidars of big agricultural lands operate especially in Punjab Haryana
Punjab Gets MSP for Rice and Wheat, however due to accumulated debt largely due to Power sector, the state Govt pays back Rs 18,000 Crore in interest payments each year to central agencies etc plus Punjab's water level has gone down leading to cancer in rural areas. Revolution was for India , it has been a slow poison for Punjab. Central govt should encourage MSP on lentils which India imports from Canada. Switch away from Rice cultivation asap in Punjab.
Punjab & Punjabis are kind hearted, dedication, hard working, bold. At present the farmers are passing through critical situation, goverment is not considering demand. Farmers should boycott by avoiding grains growing for one year. For AGNIVIR no participate.
Couldn’t help but chuckle on the irony of state’s finance modernisation and diversification efforts in parallel to those currently underway at The Tribune! Perhaps ma’am already knows the inertia stemming from strong traditionalism that impacts so many facets of life, including traditional media
As always it was a pleasure to watch your interview and your bit of Punjabi added a lot a color. Ruchika also did a good job by asking some good questions. One suggestion, if possible, you could brief your guest to answer questions in such a manner which makes it easy for the listener to understand. They were answering in detail and were going over our head. There was no link. Tell them to be informative in answering the public at large.
Soyabean can be grown in lieu of Paddy because its season is same as that of a paddy. Secondly, it can be used as an oilseed to extract oil and as an Dal (Pulses). Both of these food items are imported. Additionally , Punjabi kids are protein deficient.
I am glad Mr Lakhanpal talked about the biggest freebie that employees are being given. Punjab employees get 40% higher salary than the rest of the country. And yet we go on blaming farmers !
Please clarify if 10 acre farmer is not economically not comfortable then WHY lease rate per acre is highest in punjab which is varying from rs 50k to 80k
Good discussion on an important topic. Apart from budget and funds,Punjab needs to address Migration of intellectuals and Creating a better environment for industrial and service sector
Well said about paddy growth, by calling all the Agricultural Unions and discussing about the problem of water and water-table , the government should have banned the growth of paddy. Instead of paddy other crops, vegetables, fruits should be introduced in the State. This year it should have been. To survive Panjab it must be from the next year. Dr. Ghuman and the other three members to please do efforts. M. Singh🇨🇦
It was such a pleasure to have heard Y'all...and a great discussion...And Jyoti it was even more PLEASURE listening to your bit of PUNJABI on brief interjections.. Pl do a Full Punjabi episode.. Regards Lali SINGH. 🎉
Sorry, but looking at Punjab condition I don't think they're going to cop up with other states in industrialisation even Bihar which is considered to be as one of the most poor state of India they're are going for manufacturing And planning to Attracting big MNCs in the State , some so called Punjabis kisan leader just opposing every scheme which center took to them for their own money and politics and trapping common Punjab kisan
Problem of punjab is one corrupt politicians and bureacrats incorrigible. They have looted punjab. Second is the subsidies people are used to. No leadership
I just dropped a like 👍 Because I love the subject as being an Indian we all love to see Punjab as every other state to prosper Because as a regular follower of Jyotiji from her Print days especially her foreign news segments, I wish her the best and want her to improve. She is well intentioned. Just her interview skills needs to improve. She is impatient, does not allow the topic to be explained by the guests, she interrupts and jumps in. I think she can make better compilation of all her questions and pose them later.
Great discussion! It would hugely enhance the engagement if you really structure the discussion and aks the questions in an orderly fashion. Wonderful distinguished guests, would like to listen more on ' ILLITERATE POLITICAL ELITES ' and their role in pulling the Punjab into morass in which it's currently in.
Weren’t these people once responsible for changing the course of Punjab’s destiny. Now they have lived their lives, enjoyed their highest positions and now sitting in a newsroom and giving their opinions! Sad & disappointing.
Insightful ! A submission, Let the conversation language be punjabi ( punjabi version), as it is concerned with Punjab ( targeted audience). Your punjabi is very good.
Jyoti and Ruchika unfortunately not good candidates to conduct this interview. Very tactical and their lack of genuine interest in what is being said is clear. Punjab needs better interviewers too :)
PAU members of '60s are also equally responsible for the mess that has been created. Not kept in mind that what implications could be in the long run for using pesticides and draining ground water.
Pal sahab, a blueprint for change over was given under the farm act which the subversives refused for their own reasons, they had a larger design. If Punjab thought it was right it should have allowed the court to adjudicate but it refused because it wanted to blackmail the govt.
I have been listening to these issues for over 20 years now. A few things which come to mind. Hypothetically should Punjab still desist from Paddy if 100% area is converted to DSR? Then Paddy would have no effect on Ground water depletion and it becomes just another monsoon season crop. Solves both problems of farmer assured income as well as food security. Secondly despite having huge respect for the Panelist’s, I wish for some fresh blood. Maybe some younger economists can be added on and some new solutions might emerge. Thirdly, when state goes broke then the solution lies not only in reducing costs ie all the noise about subsidy but a better solution lies in increasing income of the state ie state owned Liquor, Mining and Long distance public transportation businesses. If the income of the state goes up then all the noise about subsidies goes silent.
Punjab green revolution has been over shadowed by other states agri development. 95% tractor are sold outside Punjab. Punjab has missed diversification into fruits, floriculture, dairy and poultry etc
Simple solution is there. Let Centre announce a National Subsidy kitty and allocate subsidy to each state equitably. States can allocate their share of subsidy (within the broad contours of a subsidy policy) in whichever sector be it for power, or input subsidy or MSP subsidy or whatever. Punjab will not agree because it wants more than every one else. Damad Hai Na.
An interview in which Jyoti Malhotra interrupts to prevent truth from emerging. Punjab gained a lot due to rest of India financing the Bhakra Nangal Project ( at the expense of the development needs of rest of India) and later supported Punjab in the green revolution by giving seeds, technology and exceptionally high prices in the MSP. Decades of such support has led Punjab to develop a beggar mentality that I always asks for more money. Punjab’s problems are caused by its internal issues and politics. Another bout of aid by the Centre ( this necessarily means less funds to other more deserving states) will solve nothing
True..Punjabis in living in their own dream world far tar away from reality. Opposing every government initiatives and denying the state much needed resources and other support from Centre. Punjabis are most to blame. Why this rebellion is rejoiced by Punjabis while it is hitting on own foot.😢
@@baltejsingh3041 Punjab can easily survive and continue its growth if it's able to expand canal irrigation to atleast 70% of farm land...these green activists are spreading unnecessary fear...
@@Dk2-vs7hh As much wheat as Madhya Pardes grows, a large part of it is used for its domestic consumption, while Punjab fills the center granary of the country, which is used in the public distribution system.
@@tejvirjhinjer7794 it’s got more to do with agitating violent Punjabi farmers, hence GOI is forced to procure more under MSP subsidy from Punjab compared to farmers of other states.. what GOI is simply saying is divert to millets and pulses we will give you MSP, however the punjabis have become so anti-BJP they don’t want to listen!!
Good discussion. Just add to the point of salaries , the salary of a post is determined by the education level of the post and nature of the work, with the increased need of higher analytical, reasoning and communicationnal skills for clerks who has become primitive cog of the administration administration graduation has become the benchmark for the post same as doctors and engineers so the argument of paying one set of graduates on the expense of the others seem absurd. Also one crucial point that this esteemed panel missed was the corruption by burecracy, It is not a big secret that Punjab has one of the highest number of corrupt burocrates who are the biggest problem of state yet this key issue almost never becomes a part of an experts analysis and consequently the part of public discourse.
Now Punjab employees are getting atleast 12% DA than that of Central employees n also there is no Rural allowance n RFA now as Manpreet withdrew both the allowances.
Jyotiji from Print to here?? Good news but you still have a problem with interviews. I did mention on the print that even youngsters are able to interview better than you. As Editor in Chief, you have not improved yet.😢 Please improve.
Both anchors are interruptimg both the guests. The guests both are talking sense. I have lived in Punjab from 1996+1999. Sad to see the state of the affairs in Punjab. Please stop playing victim and elect good leaders
Thank you doing these insightful conversations…enough of tamasha need ground work. We missed IT revolution and we will miss manufacturing too now which is already is shambles
Punjab needs to hit rock bottom before it can really recover.. only post falling below Bihar, Bengal it will wake up from balle balle! Even Karnataka doesn’t want manufacturing or IT now, so what are you talking about?? Kejriwal Freebies model is the way forward in the age of AI!!
I think it’s time media stops bashing Punjab for no rime and reason. The Bureaucrats have ruined the country for too long. The state may be bankrupt (govt) people aren’t. Punjabis are ruling around the world. Punjab was in chardikala and will always be. These drawing room discussions have no meaning.
Bro just get out of this bubble , they're talking about 95% Punjabi not 5% and some Punjabi singers are doing good that doesn't mean Punjabis are rulling the world
I ain’t in no cuckooland. I live in a small village in Doaba farming , doing alright for myself.all I am saying is the bashing has to stop. There’s nothing wrong with the people, the people are in chardikala and will always be. Talking about deficit, has anyone looked at UPs deficit ???
And what the heck is “Balle Balle” mode. Never heard of it , sounds like lack of vocabulary at the spokesman’s end. Little education might have helped , but I guess it’s too late now
Only non punjabis and Bollywood gives it balle balle mode. Real Punjabis have never been in this. They have always struggled economically. Center has always sidelined Punjab.
Why didn’t Manmohan fix Punjab ? When I was growing up in Mumbai, Sikhs had the highest respect for being protectors and provider, today their value is worth like a Bihari Panipuri seller who only run Dhabbas and protest to beg for money. No one today thinks they are protectors and most feel uncomfortable being around aggressive and insecure Punjabi. You were much better as Jokers than your current form
Punjab has made the noise already , that’s how they didn’t let farm laws passed. That’s what it was “the noise”. I am using the lighter word not to trigger the so called Bharat mata caring Punjabis.
Haryana and western UP were also chosen for same purpose the problem was Punjab never overcame the transition from agriculture to higher industrial sectors!! Haryana diversified its economy with Gurgaon as IT and financial services hub and now see how much revenue just one district is contributing to Haryana’s economy!! Similarly UP diversified into many sectors and still doing the likes of Kanpur Noida Meerut all came as major business hubs! On contrary Punjab never came over it’s agricultural hierarchy now blame it on militancy period, or lack of govt vision to facilitate new industries with subsidies or grants instead they continued and increased subsidies to farmers even by taking loans now we are in a mess with mass migration and low industrial base and farm Unions opposition to any land reforms
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 Haryana has the benefit of being closer to the capital.With the opening of market, MNC's came to Gurgaon, because it was near national capital, not because of any initiative by the farmer.Besides every central govt.irrespective of the patry it belongs to , have always been biased in allocations as far as Punjab is concerned
@@ninderkaurdhindsa8656 You might be right but till the early 1980’s Punjab cities like Ludhiana Jalandhar were all did better in industrial growth and economic prosperity than Haryana as a whole, but ever since the economic liberalization in 1990’s the state govts of Punjab never initiated any reforms to attract investment of new industries like IT Telecom Pharmaceuticals Organic and Inorganic chemicals automobiles and industrial parts etc which became the growth engine of Indian economy for next 25 years on contrary all govts supported subsidies on diesel, electricity fertilizer and most importantly the MSP and farmers income support all by taking huge debts making our economy go from bad to worse ✌️ now blaming everything on central govt won’t make sense because all these actions come under state govt jurisdiction!! All industries of Ludhiana and Jalandhar moved out due to increased electricity costs and lower supply, bad law and order during the militancy period which were direct consequence of govt policies of free subsidies to agriculture sector!
She's correct as MP, UP, Haryana all have started contribution unlike Green Revolution time when these states were not properly linked with water canals, agricultural ecosystem etc which Punjab, Haryana and Western UP enjoyed due to canal system, agricultural land economy established by British post partition.
@@BaljeetSinghKhosa-d7fPaji Pata ni tusi kittoh data vekheya? FCI di official website ch UP top supplier aa wheat da india ch followed by MP, then Punjab and Haryana!! Baki eh gal twadi theek aa k sarkar apni stockpile low kardi payi 35 million tons toh 22 ch agyi aa GOI de storage te eh kehnde hor low karni aa capacity excess hogyi si 🙏 Punjab nu rice te wheat crop toh hatna pena cheti because Sade groundwater level neeche jayi jande te apne bande pumps free bijli ale use karna chadte ni paye!
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 center pull which Is waar v addi wheat dey lagbhag Punjab d hai ji baki state da Kota pura nahi ho sakya, duniya nu bhukmari da dar hai dost ehe bhram hai ki bohot hai bohat hai
Best way to constraint on voter looter party to maintain certain economic level of state while ruling , if they failed than e.c.i.may put bar that party for certain period, than only all the party will participate to bring some slogan to discourage free bee togather. Sir, mantrana ke liye bula liya na maan saab nu. Now punjab need a hard administrator for 10 yrs to settle state for longer peace.
Excellent initiative of Jyoti Malhotra. This is the correct role of the Press. Keep doing the good job. We need such good journalists in Punjab
Excellent discussion. Please don't dump it down. A series of discussions would be wonderful.
If not the government, the people of Punjab have that innate capability to rise from the ashes and I firmly believe we will sooner or later get rid of these issues via people's initiatives and innovations.
Free electricity destroyed Punjab.
@@1008apocalypse1008 Not just free electricity, but most freebies across various sections have made us beggars, always greedily seeking from the government. Instead of empowering us with education and skills, we have been reduced to phocomelic citizens.
I hope next time they listen more rather than interrupting and talking over each other!
I wish they let Mr. Lakhanpal speak more as he has worked with a range of politicians in Punjab.
All the subsidies should be withdrawn, and the price of farmers' produce should be based on cost of production
How about drugs being imported through Gujrat ports, still the trade between India and Pakistan is going on through those ports
Madam, important question is that 6 lakhs acres of government land is illegally encroached. I can prove it with documents. No one put question to government to get it vacated and give all sorts of subsidies. Naresh Johar Amritsar
Absolutely correct ✅ sir, I am fighting to restore the original title of one such government land illegally occupied by mafia inconvenience with government officials since last 10 years,now because to shield the corrupt government officials they are working tooth and nail 😂😂😂
These two gentlemen are probably of the most respectful debaters I have ever seen
Jyothi ji you are not listening to Mr. lakhanpal that the problem of resolving Punjab's problem lies with Punjab!
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਨੀਵਾਣ ਵੱਲ ਜਾਣ ਦਾ ਇੱਕ ਵੱਡਾ ਕਾਰਨ ਭ੍ਰਿਸ਼ਟ ਅਫ਼ਰਸਸ਼ਾਹੀ ਹੈ ਜਿਹਨੇ ਸਿਰਫ ਆਪਣਾ ਢਿੱਡ ਭਰਨ ਦਾ ਸੋਚਿਆ।
Please interrupt less Jyoti ji
I would love to listen to the guests more
So true, Sikh religion teaches not to beg , and take pride in hardwark to earn livelihood, but these Politicians have made them hooked to freebies like sasta nashe 😢😢
Punjab’s current state shud open eyes to limitation of any religion on progress of society. As per Punjab’s people Sikhs are great coz they follow Sikhi but condition of Punjab doesn’t reflect any greatness
Such discussions should be encouraged.. Punjab needs this ..
Refinements will come over time ..
I hope state government is also listening..
Thank you so much for such thoughtful interview. At the same time we need to let this panel speak.
70 ਤੋਂ 80 ਹਜ਼ਾਰ ਰੁਪਏ ਪਰ ਏਕੜ ਦਾ ਠੇਕਾ ਹੈ ਜਿਸਦਾ ਵੱਡਾ ਹਿੱਸਾ ਬਾਹਰਲੇ ਮੁਲਕਾਂ ਵਿੱਚ ਜਾ ਰਿਹੈ I ਹਰਿਤ ਕ੍ਰਾਂਤੀ ਦਾ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਨੇ ਰੱਜ ਕੇ ਫਾਇਦਾ ਮਾਣਿਆ ਹੈ ਜਿਸਦਾ ਪ੍ਰਮਾਣ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਪਿੰਡਾਂ ਦੀ ਖੁਸ਼ਹਾਲੀ, ਜੋ ਭਾਰਤ ਦੇ ਕਿਸੇ ਵੀ ਸੂਬੇ ਨਾਲੋਂ ਜਾਦਾ ਹੈ I ਖੇਤੀ ਦੀ ਆਮਦਨ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਵਿੱਚ ਪਰ ਏਕੜ ਪੂਰੀ ਦੁਨੀਆ ਨਾਲੋਂ ਵੱਧ ਹੈ, ਪਰ ਜੇ ਕਿਸੇ ਕੋਲ ਜਮੀਨ ਹੀ ਥੋੜ੍ਹੀ ਹੈ ਤਾਂ ਉਹਦੀ ਆਮਦਨ ਪਰ ਏਕੜ ਕਿਵੇਂ ਵਧਾਈ ਜਾਵੇਗੀ?
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਨੂੰ ਲੋੜ ਸੀ ਇੰਡਸਟਰੀ ਦੀ, ਜੋ ਵਧਾਉਣ ਦੀ ਥਾਂ ਸਾਲ ਦਰ ਸਾਲ ਘਟਾਈ ਗਈ ਤੇ ਇਸਦੇ ਜੁੰਮੇਵਾਰ ਮੁੱਖ ਰੂਪ ਵਿੱਚ ਕਾਂਗਰਸ ਅਤੇ ਅਕਾਲੀ ਹਨ ਅਤੇ ਬਣਦਾ ਸਰਦਾ ਯੋਗਦਾਨ ਸਾਡੇ ਆਪਣੇ ਲੋਕਾਂ ਦਾ ਵੀ ਹੈ, ਜਿਵੇਂ ਕਿ ਬਿਨਾਂ ਮਤਲਬ ਦੇ ਬੰਦ, ਰੇਲ ਰੋਕੋ, ਕੁਟਮਾਰ ਜੋ ਕਿ ਇੰਡਸਟਰੀ ਵਾਲਿਆ ਨੂੰ ਏਥੇ ਆਉਣ ਤੋਂ ਡਰਾਉਂਦੇ ਹਨ I
Never seen such poor moderators. They seem hell bent on interrupting. Hats off to the two men for not getting irritated.
A very good discussion opening many facets of Punjab's economic situation
Request to media to keep asking questions to the ruling party on behalf of all the Punjabis
Free electricity destroyed Punjab not central govt.
What about freebies BJP promised in other states during elections ? I know freebies isn't good, especially electricity. But quality free education and healthcare isn't freebies. @@1008apocalypse1008
Very good analysis of Punjab economies. Appreciate
Lions share subsidies go to rich farmers, who in fact are PROXY farmers, and also enjoy free income tax benefits. Actual tillers , whom these rich farmers RENT OUT their farms, get nothing!
Alright farmer hater, u can cry all you can. People whose ancestors gave blood for this land owns the land and can do anything they want with their land. Either rent it or till it. Whats your problem?
They are going to do another few years of andolan for more freebies from the taxes collected from hard working people of the nation
@@randhawaz1 Wow these present landlords are ex servicemen of British Indian Army or their supporters who got these lands and Jagirs gifted to them for the loyalty they showed for the Crown. Go check out the facts about the landlords of Punjab both in India and Pakistan and see the lands where they got it from, there are many books written on it with historical records from British museum like Ishtiaq Ahmed's Punjab: Partioned cleansed, Hardit Singh Malik book on Independent India and Punjabi jatt etc. Go read the history before making a fool out of yourselves
@@kamaljeetsingh1467what happened to the land ceiling act? The big landlords are few and far between.
@@thatwasyesterday Arrey sir land ceiling itself is limited to 18 acres for Punjab, over it follows the cold storage, dairy, with many renting agri equipment all tax free under farmer/agriculturist category!! Also it doesn’t includes the subsidy of free electricity, pesticides and MSP gurantee which the govt of state and centre guarantees!! I myself come from farmers family of Punjab and I know how the arthiya/jimmidars of big agricultural lands operate especially in Punjab Haryana
Punjab Gets MSP for Rice and Wheat, however due to accumulated debt largely due to Power sector, the state Govt pays back Rs 18,000 Crore in interest payments each year to central agencies etc plus Punjab's water level has gone down leading to cancer in rural areas.
Revolution was for India , it has been a slow poison for Punjab. Central govt should encourage MSP on lentils which India imports from Canada. Switch away from Rice cultivation asap in Punjab.
Punjab should have walked out in 1980s
Punjab & Punjabis are kind hearted, dedication, hard working, bold.
At present the farmers are passing through critical situation, goverment is not considering demand.
Farmers should boycott by avoiding grains growing for one year.
For AGNIVIR no participate.
Couldn’t help but chuckle on the irony of state’s finance modernisation and diversification efforts in parallel to those currently underway at The Tribune! Perhaps ma’am already knows the inertia stemming from strong traditionalism that impacts so many facets of life, including traditional media
As always it was a pleasure to watch your interview and your bit of Punjabi added a lot a color.
Ruchika also did a good job by asking some good questions. One suggestion, if possible, you could brief your guest to answer questions in such a manner which makes it easy for the listener to understand. They were answering in detail and were going over our head. There was no link. Tell them to be informative in answering the public at large.
Excellent discussion. Punjab government must involved subject matter experts to come out from present crises. Waheguru bless all of you
Madam the basic question is Punjab’s budget til 1983 was surplus , what are the reasons which brought us to this stage?
Soyabean can be grown in lieu of Paddy because its season is same as that of a paddy. Secondly, it can be used as an oilseed to extract oil and as an Dal (Pulses). Both of these food items are imported. Additionally , Punjabi kids are protein deficient.
Read and research the history and origin of soybean. It will be the final nail in coffin for punjab land.
@@munzo91daal mungfali uga lo fir instead of water guzzling rice
PAU had tried best for diversification but govt policy are responsible for current farming crisis..
I am glad Mr Lakhanpal talked about the biggest freebie that employees are being given. Punjab employees get 40% higher salary than the rest of the country. And yet we go on blaming farmers !
Please clarify if 10 acre farmer is not economically not comfortable then WHY lease rate per acre is highest in punjab which is varying from rs 50k to 80k
Es mudde te sab political parties nu unite hona chahida if you really love Punjab
Very nice suggestions good interview with experts
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਕਰਜ਼ਾਈ ਹੈ ਤੇ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦਾ ਹਰ ਕਿਸਾਨ ਮਜ਼ਦੂਰ ਕਰਜ਼ਾਈ ਹੈ , ਸਰਕਾਰੀ ਕਰਮਚਾਰੀਆਂ ਦੀਆਂ ਤਨਖਾਹਾਂ ਵਧਾਈਆਂ ਜਾ ਰਹੀਆਂ ਹਨ, ਪਰ ਰਿਸ਼ਵਤ ਹਾਲੇ ਵੀ ਪੂਰੇ ਦੇਸ਼ ਵਿਚ ਸਭ ਤੋਂ ਵੱਧ
Good discussion on an important topic.
Apart from budget and funds,Punjab needs to address
Migration of intellectuals and
Creating a better environment for industrial and service sector
Well said about paddy growth, by calling all the Agricultural Unions and discussing about the problem of water and water-table , the government should have banned the growth of paddy. Instead of paddy other crops, vegetables, fruits should be introduced in the State. This year it should have been. To survive Panjab it must be from the next year. Dr. Ghuman and the other three members to please do efforts. M. Singh🇨🇦
It was such a pleasure to have heard Y'all...and a great discussion...And Jyoti it was even more PLEASURE listening to your bit of PUNJABI on brief interjections.. Pl do a Full Punjabi episode.. Regards Lali SINGH. 🎉
Sorry, but looking at Punjab condition I don't think they're going to cop up with other states in industrialisation even Bihar which is considered to be as one of the most poor state of India they're are going for manufacturing
And planning to Attracting big MNCs in the State , some so called Punjabis kisan leader just opposing every scheme which center took to them for their own money and politics and trapping common Punjab kisan
As far as Wagah border is concerned, the trade has been stopped by Pakistan. India can’t do much.
Problem of punjab is one corrupt politicians and bureacrats incorrigible. They have looted punjab. Second is the subsidies people are used to. No leadership
Great discussions
I just dropped a like 👍
Because I love the subject as being an Indian we all love to see Punjab as every other state to prosper
Because as a regular follower of Jyotiji from her Print days especially her foreign news segments, I wish her the best and want her to improve. She is well intentioned. Just her interview skills needs to improve. She is impatient, does not allow the topic to be explained by the guests, she interrupts and jumps in. I think she can make better compilation of all her questions and pose them later.
Madam interruption ji, please allow the guests also to speak
Great discussion! It would hugely enhance the engagement if you really structure the discussion and aks the questions in an orderly fashion. Wonderful distinguished guests, would like to listen more on ' ILLITERATE POLITICAL ELITES ' and their role in pulling the Punjab into morass in which it's currently in.
Reminds me when badal planted the khajoor trees around his estate rather than make it a state-wide plantation.
Excellent n fruitful discussion. Hope in future too such discussions will be there on different themes.
I know many people who are crorepaties ,but are exused of paying electricity bills under AAP's 'vote buying policy
Thanks
Print should take this interview both to the state government and Government of India.
Good thing that foreign correspondent is discussing Punjab. That is how it should be done.
Hehe she is Jyotii Malhotra
Weren’t these people once responsible for changing the course of Punjab’s destiny. Now they have lived their lives, enjoyed their highest positions and now sitting in a newsroom and giving their opinions! Sad & disappointing.
Good discussions
I agree with the first but But these DRAWING room discussion are more than required.. Look at the Debt and mess PUNJAB IS IN.. Lali SINGH
Insightful ! A submission, Let the conversation language be punjabi ( punjabi version), as it is concerned with Punjab ( targeted audience). Your punjabi is very good.
Excellent
Good discussion
From the interruptions and cutting off guests, it is clear that the whole exercise was agenda driven on the part of the hosts.. Shameful..
Jyoti and Ruchika unfortunately not good candidates to conduct this interview. Very tactical and their lack of genuine interest in what is being said is clear. Punjab needs better interviewers too :)
PAU members of '60s are also equally responsible for the mess that has been created. Not kept in mind that what implications could be in the long run for using pesticides and draining ground water.
Pal sahab, a blueprint for change over was given under the farm act which the subversives refused for their own reasons, they had a larger design. If Punjab thought it was right it should have allowed the court to adjudicate but it refused because it wanted to blackmail the govt.
Only independence from India can save Punjab
Very good discussion. Well compered . Are the politicians listening ? They are deaf and dumb 😳😳😳
I have been listening to these issues for over 20 years now. A few things which come to mind. Hypothetically should Punjab still desist from Paddy if 100% area is converted to DSR? Then Paddy would have no effect on Ground water depletion and it becomes just another monsoon season crop. Solves both problems of farmer assured income as well as food security.
Secondly despite having huge respect for the Panelist’s, I wish for some fresh blood. Maybe some younger economists can be added on and some new solutions might emerge.
Thirdly, when state goes broke then the solution lies not only in reducing costs ie all the noise about subsidy but a better solution lies in increasing income of the state ie state owned Liquor, Mining and Long distance public transportation businesses. If the income of the state goes up then all the noise about subsidies goes silent.
❤ Good information and discussion ❤ Start it in Punjabi ❤
Nice👍
Thanks to tribune to bring 2 possible culprits of past which punjab is suffering today a) chief/finance secratary b) special invitee.
Arrogant selfish Punjabis
Punjab green revolution has been over shadowed by other states agri development. 95% tractor are sold outside Punjab.
Punjab has missed diversification into fruits, floriculture, dairy and poultry etc
the print chod diya kya maam?
Excellent.
Please , Badal and Captain ਦਾ ਨਾਂ ਨਾ ਲਵੋ, ਇੰਨਾਂ ਨੇ ਹੀ ਤਾਂ ਬੇੜਾ ਗ਼ਰਕ ਕੀਤਾ ਹੈ ॥
Simple solution is there.
Let Centre announce a National Subsidy kitty and allocate subsidy to each state equitably.
States can allocate their share of subsidy (within the broad contours of a subsidy policy) in whichever sector be it for power, or input subsidy or MSP subsidy or whatever.
Punjab will not agree because it wants more than every one else. Damad Hai Na.
Farmer's stir is causing unimaginable losses to Punjab economy,without any tangible gains.Modi Govt.would never accede to their demands again.
Hahah I love how they keep attacking punjab for not voting bjp 🤣🤣
Kar li landu jehi baat 😂
Nobody said anything about bjp. You you guys are in dillusion and filled with hate
@@shivmohan2982 Hume nhi chahiye bjp bas
Apna religion apna state baarbaad kr lenge lekin bjp nhi aayegi
@@Abhi89ps jis states mein hai voh Switzerland bnge?
@@shivmohan2982 coz ur outsider
An interview in which Jyoti Malhotra interrupts to prevent truth from emerging. Punjab gained a lot due to rest of India financing the Bhakra Nangal Project ( at the expense of the development needs of rest of India) and later supported Punjab in the green revolution by giving seeds, technology and exceptionally high prices in the MSP. Decades of such support has led Punjab to develop a beggar mentality that I always asks for more money. Punjab’s problems are caused by its internal issues and politics. Another bout of aid by the Centre ( this necessarily means less funds to other more deserving states) will solve nothing
True..Punjabis in living in their own dream world far tar away from reality. Opposing every government initiatives and denying the state much needed resources and other support from Centre. Punjabis are most to blame. Why this rebellion is rejoiced by Punjabis while it is hitting on own foot.😢
It will be more reach to common people of Punjab if they speak Punjabi.
punjab should modernize and expand its canal irrigation system...if punjab stops cultivation of food grain it will affect nations food security...
MP has replaced Punjab as the bread basket!!
Pls check wheat production for the recent year, Punjab has contributed double than the Haryana, UP, MP collectively did.
@@baltejsingh3041 Punjab can easily survive and continue its growth if it's able to expand canal irrigation to atleast 70% of farm land...these green activists are spreading unnecessary fear...
@@Dk2-vs7hh As much wheat as Madhya Pardes grows, a large part of it is used for its domestic consumption, while Punjab fills the center granary of the country, which is used in the public distribution system.
@@tejvirjhinjer7794 it’s got more to do with agitating violent Punjabi farmers, hence GOI is forced to procure more under MSP subsidy from Punjab compared to farmers of other states.. what GOI is simply saying is divert to millets and pulses we will give you MSP, however the punjabis have become so anti-BJP they don’t want to listen!!
Professor in Pagadi cares about Punjab
Good discussion. Just add to the point of salaries , the salary of a post is determined by the education level of the post and nature of the work, with the increased need of higher analytical, reasoning and communicationnal skills for clerks who has become primitive cog of the administration administration graduation has become the benchmark for the post same as doctors and engineers so the argument of paying one set of graduates on the expense of the others seem absurd. Also one crucial point that this esteemed panel missed was the corruption by burecracy, It is not a big secret that Punjab has one of the highest number of corrupt burocrates who are the biggest problem of state yet this key issue almost never becomes a part of an experts analysis and consequently the part of public discourse.
Discussions have deviated.
First step is to draw up a plan for resolving issues
The viewership is telling the whole story of the decline of our intelligence which keeps reflecting on different dimensions.
ਦੋ ਮੋਟਰਾ ਤੋਂ ਵੱਧ ਕਿਸੇ ਪਰਿਵਾਰ ਨੂੰ ਬਿਜਲੀ ਸਬਸਿਡੀ ਨਹੀਂ ਹੋਣੀ ਚਾਹੀਦਾ ਹੈ, ਨਹਿਰੀ ਪਾਣੀ ਨੂੰ ਦੁਗਣਾ ਕੀਤਾ ਜਾਵੇ ਭਾਵੇਂ ਉਹ ਬਰਸਾਤ ਵਿੱਚ ਹੀ ਮਿਲੇ, ਮਸ਼ੀਨਾਂ ਤੇ ਸਬਸੀਡੀ ਦਾ ਕੋਈ ਫਾਇਦਾ ਛੋਟੇ ਕਿਸਾਨਾਂ ਤੱਕ ਨਹੀਂ ਪਹੁੰਚ ਇਸ ਤੇ ਵਿਚਾਰ ਕਰਨ ਦੀ ਲੋੜ ਹੈ ਕਿਵੇਂ ਫਾਇਦਾ ਮਿਲੇ
Now Punjab employees are getting atleast 12% DA than that of Central employees n also there is no Rural allowance n RFA now as Manpreet withdrew both the allowances.
ਇਕ ਲੱਖ ਅੱਸੀ ਹਜ਼ਾਰ ਕਰੋੜ ਰੁਪਏ ਦੇ ਕਰਜ਼ੇ ਵਿੱਚ ਬਾਦਲ ਨੇ 30000 ਕਰੋੜ ਬਿਨਾਂ ਮਤਲਬ ਦਾ ਸਿਰ ਚੜ੍ਹ ਲਿਆ ਤੇ ਉਹ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦਾ ਰਾਖਾ ਬਣੀਆਂ ਰਿਹਾ
Jyotiji from Print to here?? Good news but you still have a problem with interviews. I did mention on the print that even youngsters are able to interview better than you. As Editor in Chief, you have not improved yet.😢
Please improve.
Both anchors are interruptimg both the guests. The guests both are talking sense. I have lived in Punjab from 1996+1999. Sad to see the state of the affairs in Punjab. Please stop playing victim and elect good leaders
Thank you doing these insightful conversations…enough of tamasha need ground work. We missed IT revolution and we will miss manufacturing too now which is already is shambles
Punjab needs to hit rock bottom before it can really recover.. only post falling below Bihar, Bengal it will wake up from balle balle! Even Karnataka doesn’t want manufacturing or IT now, so what are you talking about?? Kejriwal Freebies model is the way forward in the age of AI!!
I think it’s time media stops bashing Punjab for no rime and reason. The Bureaucrats have ruined the country for too long. The state may be bankrupt (govt) people aren’t. Punjabis are ruling around the world. Punjab was in chardikala and will always be. These drawing room discussions have no meaning.
You're in cuckooland my friend
They are talking about the avg Punjabi not the Rich ones who take away 88% of the subsidy
Bro just get out of this bubble , they're talking about 95% Punjabi not 5% and some Punjabi singers are doing good that doesn't mean Punjabis are rulling the world
I ain’t in no cuckooland. I live in a small village in Doaba farming , doing alright for myself.all I am saying is the bashing has to stop. There’s nothing wrong with the people, the people are in chardikala and will always be. Talking about deficit, has anyone looked at UPs deficit ???
And what the heck is “Balle Balle” mode. Never heard of it , sounds like lack of vocabulary at the spokesman’s end. Little education might have helped , but I guess it’s too late now
Only non punjabis and Bollywood gives it balle balle mode. Real Punjabis have never been in this. They have always struggled economically. Center has always sidelined Punjab.
Why didn’t Manmohan fix Punjab ? When I was growing up in Mumbai, Sikhs had the highest respect for being protectors and provider, today their value is worth like a Bihari Panipuri seller who only run Dhabbas and protest to beg for money. No one today thinks they are protectors and most feel uncomfortable being around aggressive and insecure Punjabi. You were much better as Jokers than your current form
@@tejas6718 I don’t really care how much respect you have. Was Manmohan Singh Punjabi ? Didn’t look like one
@@Tom-ds5uk ok, so what was he ? from China ?
Pls let the speaker speak rather than asking 100 questions
Centre is not going to listen to Punjab because it has only 13 Mp's
If this interview had a national audience in mind, a little less Punjabi would have been helpful.
Punjab has made the noise already , that’s how they didn’t let farm laws passed. That’s what it was “the noise”. I am using the lighter word not to trigger the so called Bharat mata caring Punjabis.
That was not Punjab alone . Please do your homework !
For most of the part yes they were
@@DerDhu 99% punjab
Waste of time and energy cheap gossip program. No beginning no end. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
I have never seen balle balle doing Punjabi in my life such a patronizing phrase from outdated Tribune.
🙏🏻💐💐💐💐🙏🏻
Punjab is pure hell hole.
Chandigarh inke pass hota to kya hota
@@TheDeviced kya haal h waha
@@TheDeviced oh i see
Punjab's destruction was set in with the advent of so called green revolution ,for which Punjab was chosen leaving other bigger states.
Haryana and western UP were also chosen for same purpose the problem was Punjab never overcame the transition from agriculture to higher industrial sectors!! Haryana diversified its economy with Gurgaon as IT and financial services hub and now see how much revenue just one district is contributing to Haryana’s economy!! Similarly UP diversified into many sectors and still doing the likes of Kanpur Noida Meerut all came as major business hubs! On contrary Punjab never came over it’s agricultural hierarchy now blame it on militancy period, or lack of govt vision to facilitate new industries with subsidies or grants instead they continued and increased subsidies to farmers even by taking loans now we are in a mess with mass migration and low industrial base and farm Unions opposition to any land reforms
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 Haryana has the benefit of being closer to the capital.With the opening of market, MNC's came to Gurgaon, because it was near national capital, not because of any initiative by the farmer.Besides every central govt.irrespective of the patry it belongs to , have always been biased in allocations as far as Punjab is concerned
@@ninderkaurdhindsa8656 You might be right but till the early 1980’s Punjab cities like Ludhiana Jalandhar were all did better in industrial growth and economic prosperity than Haryana as a whole, but ever since the economic liberalization in 1990’s the state govts of Punjab never initiated any reforms to attract investment of new industries like IT Telecom Pharmaceuticals Organic and Inorganic chemicals automobiles and industrial parts etc which became the growth engine of Indian economy for next 25 years on contrary all govts supported subsidies on diesel, electricity fertilizer and most importantly the MSP and farmers income support all by taking huge debts making our economy go from bad to worse ✌️ now blaming everything on central govt won’t make sense because all these actions come under state govt jurisdiction!! All industries of Ludhiana and Jalandhar moved out due to increased electricity costs and lower supply, bad law and order during the militancy period which were direct consequence of govt policies of free subsidies to agriculture sector!
ਮੈਡਮ ਰਿਚੀਕਾ ਖੰਨਾ ਤਾਹਨੂੰ ਲਗਦਾ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਜੇ ਕਣਕ ਝੋਨਾ ਪੈਦਾ ਨਾ ਕਰੇ ਤਾਂ ਭਾਰਤ ਦੀ ਖਾਦ ਸੁਰੱਖਿਆ ਤੇ ਕੋਈ ਅਸਰ ਨਹੀਂ ਪਵੇਗਾ
She's correct as MP, UP, Haryana all have started contribution unlike Green Revolution time when these states were not properly linked with water canals, agricultural ecosystem etc which Punjab, Haryana and Western UP enjoyed due to canal system, agricultural land economy established by British post partition.
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 ਭਰਾ ਜੀ ਨੇ 75% ਕਣਕ ਸੇਂਟਰ ਪੂਲ ਵਿੱਚ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਹਰਿਆਣਾ ਦੀ ਹੈ ਇਸ ਵਾਰ ਵੀ ਦੂਜੇ ਰਾਜਾਂ ਵਿਚੋਂ ਕੋਟਾ ਪੂਰਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਹੋਇਆ ਇਸ ਵਾਰ, ਆਉਣ ਵਾਲੇ 4,5, ਸਾਲਾਂ ਵਿੱਚ ਇੰਪੋਰਟ ਕਰਨੀ ਪਿਆ ਕਰਨੀ ਹੈ ਮੋਸਮੀ ਬਦਲਾ ਤੇ ਜ਼ਮੀਨ ਦੀ ਉਪਜਾਊ ਸ਼ਕਤੀ ਦਾ ਡਿੱਗਣਾ ਉਤਪਾਦਨ ਘਟਾਵੇਗਾ,80, ਕਰੋੜ ਲੋਕਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਮੁਫ਼ਤ ਰਾਸ਼ਨ ਤੇ 150 ਕਰੋੜ ਲੋਕਾਂ ਦਾ ਢਿੱਡ ਭਰਨਾ ਐਨਾ ਆਸਾਨ ਨਹੀਂ ਜਿੰਨਾ ਦਰਸਾਈਆਂ ਜਾ ਰਿਹਾ
@@BaljeetSinghKhosa-d7fPaji Pata ni tusi kittoh data vekheya? FCI di official website ch UP top supplier aa wheat da india ch followed by MP, then Punjab and Haryana!! Baki eh gal twadi theek aa k sarkar apni stockpile low kardi payi 35 million tons toh 22 ch agyi aa GOI de storage te eh kehnde hor low karni aa capacity excess hogyi si 🙏 Punjab nu rice te wheat crop toh hatna pena cheti because Sade groundwater level neeche jayi jande te apne bande pumps free bijli ale use karna chadte ni paye!
@@kamaljeetsingh1467 center pull which Is waar v addi wheat dey lagbhag Punjab d hai ji baki state da Kota pura nahi ho sakya, duniya nu bhukmari da dar hai dost ehe bhram hai ki bohot hai bohat hai
Diversification gonna take a decade, and Punjabi farmers trying different crops.
🙏
Best way to constraint on voter looter party to maintain certain economic level of state while ruling , if they failed than e.c.i.may put bar that party for certain period, than only all the party will participate to bring some slogan to discourage free bee togather.
Sir, mantrana ke liye bula liya na maan saab nu. Now punjab need a hard administrator for 10 yrs to settle state for longer peace.
Ikhattar Saun=7100 not 71000
Punjab thinks it is Desh Ka Damaad. Why should Punjab farmers get any more than what other states get
Are these journalist serious about Punjab?