How to change to ANY RELIGION or ANY CULTURE in Game with NO REBELS and NO UN-STATING!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 130

  • @harryellis910
    @harryellis910 2 місяці тому +136

    My god, a Roman Empire speed run from you would be somthing to see!

  • @VuleProductions
    @VuleProductions 2 місяці тому +96

    There is also an event when your advisor is of another culture. When that event fires you get an option between firing the advisor or having your heir change his culture to the cultrue of the advisor. Although it does have 800 MTTH

    • @juncheok8579
      @juncheok8579 2 місяці тому +7

      That's how I formed italy with aragon in my previous playthrough lol

    • @СтавридесКелевра
      @СтавридесКелевра 2 місяці тому +1

      Is there something like that for religion of an advisor?

    • @Sowaq
      @Sowaq 2 місяці тому +4

      ​@@СтавридесКелевраi dont think so, never happened for me but yeah.. i have only 1k hours so i might just be unlucky

    • @Caesar--
      @Caesar-- 2 місяці тому +4

      @@СтавридесКелевра theres one for your consort having a heretic religion that converts 1 province and a ruler having a diff religion but afaik thats it

  • @lolmaster438
    @lolmaster438 2 місяці тому +17

    This video explains my very shocked reaction when Commonwealth in my Britain game suddenly flipped Anglican. I didn't know what could've triggered it considering my distance from them, and no other nation had my religion. Very useful tip for monarchies though!

  • @MrBritishNinja
    @MrBritishNinja 2 місяці тому +20

    I subbed a week or 2 ago because you make good, succinct videos that don't waste my time spam my feed. That you share great strats and novel perspectives on the game just makes it better

  • @christianwhite8877
    @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +31

    The only thing unfortunate about this is it requires being a monarchy. And in some cases you need to find a way to remove your consort if you want to be able to do this, however it's also worth noting that you for the most part can't get much use out of this in Italy for example because you have to have a consort with a different culture be in charge of your nation or go with a civil war to do this

  • @sagisagmeister
    @sagisagmeister 2 місяці тому +6

    In Denmark runs you get an Bavarian Wittelsbacher on yout throne, a short time later you get an event to flip to Bavarian culture, its easier to get the hre emporer, because you dont have the 'non german' malus anymore. After you revoke, just culture switch back and form scandinavia.

  • @glarthir2213
    @glarthir2213 2 місяці тому +45

    I normally hate the "dont forget to like and subscribe" thing but in this case you are my favourite eu4 youtuber and i literally forgot, so i guess i cant complain anymore

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +17

      Haha yeah sadly there is actually a big difference in asking for it compared to not doing that xD

    • @quadrage
      @quadrage 2 місяці тому +1

      same

    • @LemonCake101
      @LemonCake101 2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah, we kinda 'have' to do it because it really works, and unfortunately people really do judge you based on sub count.

    • @CalvinNoire
      @CalvinNoire 2 місяці тому +2

      Most small channels don't have that phrase anymore. That's why I believe most of them are forgettable: the algorithm doesn't like it. Making them one hit wonders.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      @@CalvinNoire Who is a one hit wonder?

  • @bwanana252
    @bwanana252 2 місяці тому +3

    Love your videos, helps me to see new ways of playing and experimenting with this game after thousands of hours! Thank you Student

  • @hoi-polloi1863
    @hoi-polloi1863 2 місяці тому +3

    Nice, clever strategy, thank you! I do have to say though... the price using this technique is basically 4 stab, which translates to a bucket of Admin points. In my experience, money is easier to get than Admin. I'd be chary of taking a 4-stab hit unless I didn't have easy access to a province of my target religion.
    Oh, who am I fooling. I'm playing stubborn Catholic GB right now, trying as hard as I can to *not* change religion. ;D

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +4

      It's not the Money that is the biggest problem for switching with Rebels... it's Time!
      Time in which you cannot fight any war and cannot have any allies that call you in and luck that the Rebels path is working as intended and then alsl it costs a lot

  • @deaman69.
    @deaman69. 2 місяці тому +1

    Love your videos, I have over 3500 hours in the game, yet i still find myself surprised week after week by how much I don't know. Keep up the good work, subscribed!

  • @theslenderfox
    @theslenderfox 2 місяці тому +8

    Wow was just reading the community announcement

    • @Moragnth
      @Moragnth 2 місяці тому +1

      what announcement?

  • @rency1803
    @rency1803 2 місяці тому +5

    My favorite EU creator

  • @SteevnJShareef
    @SteevnJShareef 2 місяці тому +2

    My MVP from Parabellum right here!

  • @sasi5841
    @sasi5841 2 місяці тому +5

    I have known about this event for years but didnt know how to trigger it

  • @Torero2901
    @Torero2901 2 місяці тому +1

    I gave you like number 814, (Holy) Roman Empire Restoration, nice.
    Up to those magical 10 k subs!

  • @christianwhite8877
    @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

    i guess a better way to rephrase my question about republics is this. when is considered 'early game' in regards to when it's still worth flipping to republic, and when is a point in time when it's worth going monarchy/theocracy (for either question if there's not a good answer for an exact time, specifying an age (such as age of discovery as an example) could work)

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      So as I said this is really not dependent on Time... it depents on Government Reforms and it really depends on your autonomy, your Privileges and your crownland when you get to the point where it is worth it to become a Theocracy
      But if you want to have a digged down number to rely on even though you know that it is Reform based then I'll tell you that 1550 is a reasonable moment to become a Theocracy

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT thanks. at least now i understand the correct point in time for that, also unfortunately i don't yet have the dlc for that privilege (waiting for a steam sale)

  • @AkihabaraWasteland
    @AkihabaraWasteland 2 місяці тому +2

    He's done it again.

  • @cinnanyan
    @cinnanyan 2 місяці тому +3

    This could be really useful when I want to get the mandate of heaven but my nation is Hindu

  • @ondrejrichtr6835
    @ondrejrichtr6835 2 місяці тому +1

    nice try on the pronunciation of z Poděbrad.. 😅 of course, great video as always!

  • @ИльяЦыбульский-у3г
    @ИльяЦыбульский-у3г 2 місяці тому +1

    I would say that the most difficult oart is to have a young enough heir when your ruler dies.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      not really... if he get's 15 then just disinherit him and within a year you will typically get a new one (also there are a lot of events that give an heir and you can also always introduce an heir manually if you have 90+ legitimacy)

    • @ИльяЦыбульский-у3г
      @ИльяЦыбульский-у3г 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT I may be really unlucky, but often I am not getting an heir for 4-5 years in a row even if I have some marriages. But risks worth it, yeah.

    • @Hippowdon121
      @Hippowdon121 Місяць тому +1

      u can extend consort regencies by 5 years at the cost of legitimacy, in the government tab

  • @Stephen64138
    @Stephen64138 2 місяці тому +1

    Very interesting video! I will have to try that for sure!

  • @VivaChandles
    @VivaChandles 2 місяці тому +1

    Let’s get our man to 10k

  • @efthymakisemanouil
    @efthymakisemanouil 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for the tips.

  • @abdullahkaanturker4656
    @abdullahkaanturker4656 2 місяці тому +1

    I got both those events in my plc gameplay because somehow i ended up with burgundian dynasty that was orthodox.

  • @LemonCake101
    @LemonCake101 2 місяці тому +1

    Student Rome time!!!

  • @BrotdiebDerEchte
    @BrotdiebDerEchte 2 місяці тому +1

    🐐

  • @jacksonmckinney
    @jacksonmckinney 2 місяці тому +20

    I've always hated flipping. I really hope they curtail it in Eu5

    • @willfreakman86
      @willfreakman86 2 місяці тому +1

      Why is that?

    • @lkdominator4088
      @lkdominator4088 2 місяці тому +15

      If you hate it. Just don't do it. It's unfair to take away fun from other people bc you don't like it. Even tho it is easily ignored.

    • @notlucas6859
      @notlucas6859 2 місяці тому +5

      i love switching religions, but i hate the way u do it in eu4. i hope they make it way easier in eu5, or more realistic or smth

  • @colossicus555
    @colossicus555 Місяць тому +2

    Might be an odd one but when playing as the united states, for example, is there some way to have an elected ruler not be english and also not your current nation's religion seems like that's the only possibility

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  Місяць тому +1

      Yeah they are typically the primary culture and religion when a republic or when you choose a local one from Elective Monarchy... otherwise if you have a Dynasty from before that was English than you need to change your Dynasty somehow or trigger some rare events for converting the heirs culture

  • @TheJonnyjoh
    @TheJonnyjoh 2 місяці тому +6

    Hmm... I'm wondering now if you could use this technique to convert Trebizond to Islam, since Trebizond is the only Nation that can royal marry muslim nations.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +5

      Sure

    • @tarunyadav3567
      @tarunyadav3567 2 місяці тому +5

      you can but as trebizond its easier to just conquer a few sunni provinces lol

  • @wolffrdu6463
    @wolffrdu6463 2 місяці тому +1

    Actually, the trebyzon can royal mary into other religions that aren’t christian

  • @whaleofdarkness
    @whaleofdarkness 2 місяці тому +2

    A shame that you can't become Norse this way. It's so much RNG to do it.

  • @BEEETRUS
    @BEEETRUS 2 місяці тому +1

    W the student

  • @spacecryptoleninism
    @spacecryptoleninism 2 місяці тому +2

    Any tips on how to get an heir of the culture you want to swap to for the event? I know there is an advisor event to swap heir culture but the MTTH is rather long for it.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +3

      Exact same as with Religion... get a Consort from a Nation with that culture...

  • @Rebrado10
    @Rebrado10 2 місяці тому

    So you can only get religions if:
    - They exist (no Norse)
    - You can marry with someone of said religion.
    A bit broad definition for "Any religion"

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому

      Maybe you should rewatch the last Part of the video then ;)
      Also I think I didn't Mention foreign Rulers from Elective Monarchy which is also not tied to Royal Marriages

  • @christianwhite8877
    @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

    I have a question. Which Latin culture is the best for aragon to shift into first (between the culture of Sardinia (which aragon doesn't own all of and is low development). The culture of Sicily (which aragon owns basically all of but doesn't help form any specific Italian formable aside from two sicilies), or just wait until after integrating Naples and shift to there culture) and when to do so?, Or is Venice the better choice to become an Italian signoria sooner to form Italy and culture shift to be able to make use of the Italian formables?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Aragon is better... and maybe you should just use the tactic of the video you are commenting below right now ;)
      Just wait for a ruler with no consort and then royal marry nations with your desired culture until you get a consort of that and then go on as in the video... otherwise Piedemont culture is the best italian formable

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      That can work if also applied with your aragon video (though I lack the dlc that would allow me to also claim Portugal). The problem is I'd need to find a way around the death of the first ruler and second ruler (the hair of Aragon has a consort if I recall correctly, and the first ruler starts with one). And the sooner I accomplish this the better for monarch points it will be. Also it doesn't have to be any particular sub culture for the signoria to be possible, though like you said some are more valuable than others (Tuscan gives stability and tech/idea cost in addition to adviser cost. Through mostly it's for the diplomat. The culture of Naples for a free tolerance and reform progress. The piedmont culture will help with missionary strength and both admin efficiency and goods produced, though most of them also will provide permanent claims outside of Italy) I just don't know how long it might take for it (though Sardinia-piedmont would definitely be the first choice for the admin efficiency, it would help a considerable amount with restating and the national ideas would also help)

  • @Pjong91
    @Pjong91 2 місяці тому +2

    So if i want be become Nahuatl as portugal. Can i make a nation with that religion a vassel and force them to switch religion. So i can RM them to get a concort thats nahuatle, then make that consort the ruler of my country and wait for the event?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +4

      idk if their ruler changes the religion as well on enforcing but if not... then yes

  • @StrategySphere
    @StrategySphere 2 місяці тому

    Great insight. Randomly used it to change culture and form Netherlands. However this didn’t work as Nahua Aztec trying to change to Mayan… so maybe not every religion can change?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      It should work with every religion maybe you missed some trigger conditions or you were just unlucky

    • @StrategySphere
      @StrategySphere 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT could be! Will (casually) try again :)

  • @JoaoMagc1998
    @JoaoMagc1998 Місяць тому +1

    Can this trigger for Bohemia after you don't convert with the Hussite leader event, but still take him as a leader? I'm trying this, but the event doesn't really comes

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  Місяць тому +2

      Yes it works, it might take about 20 years though (and of course you need +2 Stability)

  • @sethyboy0
    @sethyboy0 2 місяці тому +1

    Looks like the culture event needs your heir to be the culture too? That’s a lot more difficult since you can’t use just the consort.
    Cool video though. There’s gotta be some kinda bullshit you can pull off with this.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah but you can just let that Regent overtake completly if your heir dies while in Regency and you can also use the foreign Ruler from Elective Monarchy

    • @harz632
      @harz632 2 місяці тому +3

      You could cheese this as a theocracy, take a foreign dynasty as your heir and when he ascends the throne do it again for his heir, then swap to monarchy, via goverment reform.
      This does require enough government reform to get to the point where you can switch to a monarchy.

  • @christianwhite8877
    @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

    I have a question. If you start as Savoy is it worth becoming a republic via Tuscany?, I know all the Italian formables are formable once you have level 10 admin tech (assuming you meet all the other requirements) I'm just trying to think of a way to form the best possible Italy with the best government possible for doing so and can benefit the most from being protestant even after getting Italian ideas (also I do have leviathan and origin, which means great projects can be taken into account (I don't know if I'm patient enough to wait 20 years for the king of Aragon to die and release Naples if I play as them. I know that republics are at least arguably one of the best government options even if you have so many reforms to take and that theocracy's can be considered worth while later in the game, but I don't know if monarchy is as good a type of government and I don't know if Milan having the military dictatorship is that good early on)

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Republics are simply better in early game especially with Italian Signoria + Sortition Combinations... the only advantage Monarchies have are PUs and the HRE

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT is tech 10 considered early game enough? or by that point is it better to stay monarchy or become a theocracy?

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      I just looked into stuff for Naples. According to the wiki every 15 years you could get an event to become a republic (Italian signoria) but part of the conditions are that it must not be the age of discovery or the age of Revolutions (which means it could be too late for the choice to matter much), however I don't know if it could fire sooner or not

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Theocracy is valuable after Tier 9 Reform... so whenever you reach that

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      It can only fire in the Age of Refomation

  • @vladislavkorol902
    @vladislavkorol902 2 місяці тому +2

    Does local noble from elective monarchy also grabs culture/religion from capital?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +3

      No, but the foreign Noble would work

  • @Caesar--
    @Caesar-- 2 місяці тому +3

    So all i need to do is pray that i luck my way into having a hussite consort and then lucking my way into getting her as my queen regent then luck my way into getting this 2 year pulse event? Guaranteed in my book!

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Getting the Consort is no luck if you break the Marriage (or Savescum) and letting her take over the Throne isn't too bad ad well as woman live way longer than Generals in this Game... but I never said that it is guarenteed done in 1 year or something... all I can say is that converting through rebels takes wayyy longer and is also very dependent on luck

    • @Caesar--
      @Caesar-- 2 місяці тому +1

      @thestudentYT soo savescum or sit there spending stab over and over or just get lucky? I see no wins here 😭😭 props for finding all this shit tho its certainly interesting 😂

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah sure but come on bro, the chances to get a Consort are like 50/50 and not like 1%

  • @KofteG61
    @KofteG61 2 місяці тому +1

    I knew when I saw the poll you somehow changed religion to Hussite

  • @SergeyS8934
    @SergeyS8934 2 місяці тому +1

    Hey, Student. Few months ago you start series with "tutorium videos", first one was about PU's, but there wasnt 2nd one? Or missed something? One of popular topic in comments for next video was Trade - most difficult theme in UE4 IMO, I myself have some questions which just cant find detailed answer for. Is "tutorium" work in progress or will be no more? Thx
    P.S. - was right with prediction about Hussites :)

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      It is technically still open so ask your questions about Trade in the comments under the 1st Episode and I might anwser them... but I have only one upload slot per week and a lot of stuff planned while having no time for all of that really xD... so we'll see when it comes again

    • @SergeyS8934
      @SergeyS8934 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT Yeah, totally get it. Just thought that not many people will see answer to question in comments compare to video itself.
      Just waiting for other stuff planned and sill cant believe there so much unique "exploit" stuff in 12 (?) year old game.
      About questions - most obvious the whole steering sistem (last lemon cake video also got thinking), and niche stuff - imagine you Byzantine and reconquered whole Constantinople node, while having 99 or 100% trade power in it. Is it worth it build marketplace in provences in that note or not (you already has 100%), does it influences trade value, clear income or not etc.

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      @@SergeyS8934 I will only answer questions in the video that I read under the last video's comments... honestly I won't ever remember your question otherwise if you ask it here

    • @SergeyS8934
      @SergeyS8934 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT Theyre not that important and dont wanna waste your time :D

  • @ThalattaHaralus
    @ThalattaHaralus 2 місяці тому +1

    Playing as Sonora and I want to convert to Nahuatl. I let the rebels siege down my capital, but still haven't converted, it said I need to be in pagan religious group, so do I need to let them spread to most of my country first, or use pretenders and convert via event?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      The event would be not possible if you are still a Siberian Tribe but you just have to let the Rebels enforce their demands on you while having it as majority Religion

    • @bobdole7281
      @bobdole7281 16 днів тому +1

      Actually, you can't rebel convert to any of the Mesoamerican religions.

  • @cylzyl6363
    @cylzyl6363 2 місяці тому +1

    so if i need to marry, how would that work with religions that can´t royal marry each other?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      I said that in the end of the video XD nothing that I say in a video is irrelevant...

    • @cylzyl6363
      @cylzyl6363 2 місяці тому +2

      @@thestudentYT u did and don´t get me wrong, i like your content and watched most of your videos. the title was just kinda suggesting something else

  • @simonst1806
    @simonst1806 2 місяці тому +2

    If you are the emperor cant you dissolve the empire if you switch to sunni?

    • @StrategySphere
      @StrategySphere 2 місяці тому +1

      Yes, you should be able to - saw either PlayMaker or Florry do this on video.

  • @stalingaming9304
    @stalingaming9304 2 місяці тому +1

    (respectfully) is the trade guide still in the works?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Yes... but I have just one upload slot per week and I have a lot of videos planned already so sadly I don't know when it will come

    • @stalingaming9304
      @stalingaming9304 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT no worries! take your time, i’m just glad you make great stuff 💖🖤

  • @vanish7744
    @vanish7744 2 місяці тому +2

    Is it possible to get the desired regent religion/culture if I play vanilla (without DLC)?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +3

      Honestly I think the only way would be through pretender Rebels that spawn in the Province with the desired Religion or culture

    • @vanish7744
      @vanish7744 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT I see, is it possible to speed up the process of pretender rebel spawning?

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      @@vanish7744 A Civil War Desaster would give it instantly (and gives insane Stability boost once it's done)

  • @rasplay5761
    @rasplay5761 2 місяці тому +1

    no ottos for roman speed run, ok?)

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +5

      Sure not... I hate playing Ottomans (and also I think they are not the fastest)

  • @christianwhite8877
    @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

    Out of curiosity (Because I forget the answer). Is the religious turmoil disaster worth doing or is it better to avoid?, To clarify I mean for either the tolerance or missionary strength

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      Not worth doing

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT i just thought of something. because i don't have winds of change. the mission tree of Venice includes a mission for increased bonus stats if you use a lottery type election (sortition/Venice government). if i tried Venice and did that mission i could have become an Italian signora with sortition (the only problem is culture shifting for certain rewards and being unable to make use of the hre immediately), though it says I'd need every reform tier to have a chosen option for that mission (tbh it's still possible but I'm not going to try that in ironman for at least a while)

    • @christianwhite8877
      @christianwhite8877 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT another unorthodox option for Italy I've thought of is republic Aragon. after you integrate Naples you can form two sicilies via culture shift (which is a cheaper one because of owning so much of Naples) and become an Italian signora (the mission tree gives you 50 reform progress which basicly makes it free, and you should already go sortition because of the first ruler of the republic of Aragon) and you get better national ideas. from there you could easily annex what remains of Italy (Tuscany would have it's missions be much easier because of economic reasons. Sardinia-piedmont would be well worth it for the admin efficiency and goods produced alone but it also gets missionary strength), you also have an opportunity for a few achievements and can be well on the path for forming Rome (you don't get the better rulers from Venice but you still get a strong Rome formed earlier than most other starting nations without the problems of most starting nations)

  • @marshal7607
    @marshal7607 2 місяці тому +1

    can you show me other examples? like ming change religion to Shia,etc...

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +1

      why?

    • @marshal7607
      @marshal7607 2 місяці тому +1

      @@thestudentYT it would be fun. ain't it... would like to see fun campaign.. no need to edit tho

  • @trivane626
    @trivane626 2 місяці тому +1

    Does this work with converting to pagan religions

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +5

      Yes, as long as you get a ruler (or a regent) with that religion

  • @edgeman1135
    @edgeman1135 2 місяці тому +1

    Just go bankrupt as an OPM

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  2 місяці тому +2

      Sure... that's wayyyy easier xD

  • @Alorand
    @Alorand 2 місяці тому +1

    I no longer begrudge any UA-camr asking for subscribers - I have been unsubscribed from at least half a dozen channels - some of which my former favorites.

  • @WolfSpiritMan
    @WolfSpiritMan 16 днів тому +1

    So... This cannot be used to flip Aztecs to Anglican? 🥲

    • @thestudentYT
      @thestudentYT  16 днів тому +1

      No, because Christian Religions don't allow Marriages with non-Christians