Excellent stuff as ever, Bruce. Some Scottish folk might disagree with an Englishman, but my view is that the working classes of both Scotland and England have been treated like crap over the centuries. We only have what we have now because people have fought for it.
Absolutely,I remember reading about the treatment of Africans picking cotton and the white working class children ripped to pieces on looms processing the cotton,the peterloo massacre, Ireland,the Scottish clearances,scots miners etc!who are these "elites"?
Thank you for this important & extremely timely video. As a friend “across the pond” in America, there is a roll back on civil & human rights taking place around the world. Thank you, sir, for shedding light on this critical issue.
Thank you very much for speaking up, Bruce. I love your work & I'm very glad to see that you're not scared off by the disgusting politics & attacks on our liberties that we're lumbered with
Boy, do I agree with that. I knew you'd say that at the end. It matters a lot. They are unlikely to use a physical axe, but the tactics and strategy to get the money into the 'right' hands are the same. We still have one way to help stop it. We can still vote. In our own country, please.
In the 1980s I was a young conservative. I cheered when the miners were defeated. In the last month, at age 57, I've become a union rep fighting for safety and equality in my workplace. My mind was slowly changed by personal experience, by the news and by historians telling the stories of the past. We must believe minds can be changed and allow space for that to happen. Thanks Bruce.
As a former NUM official and trade union official for unison unite ect I have been fighting and warning that our very limited rights are under threat. This video shows that very little changes unless people stand up and fight. They will take your rights away, and blame you 🫵. History it's a circle.
Hi been warming people about your rights since the Tories came to power in 2015 ,warned about leaving the EU would affect your rights keep up with your work I will with mine
@viperscot1 100%, Blair's government also had a lot to answer for with loss of rights and intrusive laws but at least we gained significant rights and protections via the EU. I'm glad that I left 10 years ago and am now a Dutch national, it's shocking to see what's happened over there and very sad to see after serving the country you were born in. I will certainly raise a glass if Scotland ever gain independence.
How it grieves me, Mr. Fummey, that this is happening today. I, too, see this as the way things are trending, and fear that the last beheading on British soil will soon not be the LAST beheading on British soil. Because the powerful think that "rights" are what the strong give to the weak, and if they are opposed, they often feel that bloody constraint is what must follows. The trend you speak of is happening across the ocean, as well. Because the powerful are the same everywhere.
And the "something not good" will come regardless of who is (pretending) to run the country. The strings are being pulled from elsewhere in case you haven't noticed.
Many here in the US agree that we’re heading for something that’s not good & fear for our children as well. It feels like we’re all trapped in a bus that’s driving towards a cliff & being told there’s no way to steer nor apply brakes.
Some say that history doesn't repeat itself but it does rhyme. Thank you for this video! It shows that the struggles of the past have been reborn and battles that were fought and won now have to be fought again. It sure does sound like the past! Bruce, your history lessons are important and in this case, very relevant today!
72 years before this, one of my Jacobite ancestors was hung, drawn and beheaded at Tyburn. His body is in a cemetery at Kings Cross; his head somewhere in a Manchester garden...
Bruce, once again you have produced a gem. This is proper history, not simply stories of stirring battles between large armies, over regents’ whims. The Industrial Military Complex, first described by President Eisenhower, has been alive and well in Great Britain for centuries. Ably abetted by numerous Scots. And your comments about watching Strictly broke my heart; because they were true.
I had to find other sources online in order to know when Who were those beheaded and we took place? The presentation of the information was met more shock and racked. It was to inform and educate in this particular video.
Arrests are fictional. Do you use that fiction in attempts to cause/to cause behavior? Are you being kept as a slave until death because of behavior such as that?
On this topic although from North West England near me on the moors is the Hunger Walls, which are dry stone walls, that were built in exchange for food, they were made around this time and again during the Potato Blight.
In February and March I'll be visiting the major towns in Australia and New Zealand with my live show Scotland Made the World. It would be great to see you. Get info at www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx
Woah! I'm an American, I thoroughly enjoyed this video. I clicked to learn more about history but I did not expect the powerful words at the end. I applaud you, sir! Very moving stuff!
I have just recently become interested in Scottish History. I’m 73 years old, born and raised in Texas in the USA. I learned some things about Scotland in my world history classes in school. I have always been told that my ancestry was England. Some time ago I had my dna analyzed by a couple of places and discovered that I am somewhere I the neighborhood of 50% Scottish. So I am studying more about Scotland and my heritage. I appreciate your channel. Thank you!
I love your videos dude. You rock. My name is Randy Nesbit, i live in waxhaw, North Carolina. Your editing is getting better. I love hearing you say "let me tell you a story" lol
They are accountable. On election day. But so many people are tribal partisans, that you can't get the entrenched politicians out of office, because they won't vote for another party, even for just one election, to get the guy out.
What a very interesting video. Thanks Bruce for sharing. My Dad was very into his Scottish history and would have enjoyed your videos. He's got me passionate about Scottish history. I'm from Glasgow but now live in England. I have watched some of your other videos.
There is also thoughtcrime coined by George Orwell in his book 1984, but it is now an actual crime in the UK 7th March 2023. Clause 11 (formerly Clause 9 then Clause 10) of the Public Order Bill could criminalise any form of “influence” outside of abortion facilities - including in the form of silent prayer. Whether or not, you agree to use it in the case of abortion facilities, it does open the door for its use elsewhere!
...and a couple of years ago there was the case of the former police officer (whose name unfortunately I can't remember) who had a visit from his old comrades in order to "check [his] thinking".
Upcoming Live shows www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx A video about another great Scottish hero ua-cam.com/video/xF9ekmIB-aM/v-deo.html Buy me coffee at www.buymeacoffee.com/ScottishBruce
I'm 49 English not proud of some of our past We can only learn from our mistakes ..even more so when they are as truly wrong as in this and many more cases. I truly believe in peace love and unity .man woman and child should all be counted and as equals . May no other brother and or sister has to die for the Couse. Further more I've just found this channel and will be doing a bit of a dive so to my brothers and sisters as one peace and always much love ❤
Well Bruce, I think I can understand what your saying as I'm living in the States were having really crazy things going on here, and I really hope things get better for you and your country men and women, I just hope you keep up the good fight because that's what we're trying to do here, well Bruce I hope you have a great rest of your day, and go out for a good pint. Thanks for all your great videos and history, I've learned a lot, I hope you can make it to the state's sometime.
Hello my friend this is the first time I have commented on one of your videos, although I watch them all. I love the way you tell your stories. This one in particular. There should be a movie made about this story. 🤗🤗
I eagerly await the day the spirit of Freedom stirs the Free People to action. We’ve all given too much ground from generation to generation. There can only be so much pressure before the inevitable eruption. I pray that is soon.
Thank you for another great and informative video about important events in Scottish history. I think you make a great point about the "avalanche" of rollback. I only hope we can all find our way. I might be just an American, but I intend to vote and to encourage everyone I can find to also vote.
Thank you, I always find myself totally focused on you after hearing, "let me tell you a story." This was a great piece of history you shared with us today, and yes, relevant more than ever. The messed up thing is that history has all the answers we need! Now, I'm going re-watch your "Greatest Hero of Scotland," video! You're my favorite storyteller!
Another incredible history that absolutely deserves to be remembered. Things are no less moving backwards across the pond as well. You are not alone in the concerns you summarized with. Thank you for producing quality content always. Unrelated topic that sprung from your video… you drove by a great mural. Which made me curious? As an artist and a commissioner for the arts in my community, I find that I’m always interested in street art. We have many gorgeous ones locally as well. They all have meaning. Some historical, some depict modern relative issues, some to highlight an amazing event or person (s). My questions are… do you have many murals in Scotland? If so, are there intersting stories about Scotland represented in those artworks? What are they? I’d love to know! My daughter is in the middle of a semester at the University of Edinburgh. Shortly to take a weeks break and travel about. I think I will charge her with the task of showing momma some more art! I’ve seen some cute things from right around the dorms already. Thanks for reading my queries. Have a brilliant day! 🖤
Wow. I wish every history teacher would make history as personal and immediate as you. I can't think of more than a handful of the people I know who see themselves as part of the ongoing history of us, or ask themselves important questions such as 'how bad could this be' and 'is this forward or backward". You could write a bestselling book, but it would be far more effective to have a Netflix or Amazon series, with the promotion your messages need. There's a difference between learning history and learning to participate in History because you can use the lessons our past can teach everyone. Each day I feel we're further from being able to recover the progress someone else paid so dearly to accomplish. Thanks.
for my sins, i've not kept up with your videos for a little bit (do please blame the algorithm as much as one might me) but i must just say - a truly awesome step up in production quality. very cool camera work now in place!
Sadly this is so true and we are still moving in that direction. Let's hope it never gos backwards again. And we enshrine in law that we never do. Watching this world were you could vote and suddenly have an elected dictator. With freedoms and people jailed for having different political views. Democracy is a fragile thing. It dose not stay like that. Its threatened by others who want power. Let's hope people will wake up to that threat. Not just in nations over seas. But also at home. With even our own wee parliament now being questioned by some and others. Thanks again Bruce. For making people think. If nothing else it wakes people up and ti think how close we and others are to losing our own freedom. To a dictator in waiting.
When I saw that people at "Speaker's Corner" in Hyde park, the birthplace of the term, getting on one's soapbox, were being arrested for.....well, speaking, I knew things were getting bad. Free speech is under attack. We need to be more tolerant of what others say. We must allow everyone to have their say, even if we think it is crazy and hurtful. We just have to have the guts to say, "hey, that's crazy and hurtful!" But have to follow up with why we think so. We have to be willing to get on our own soapbox and voice our own opinions and let the people decide. Thanks for continuing to do so!
Excellent commentary, in one of my favourite towns. My personal favourite visit there was to the Old Town Jail, which is worth a post in itself . We are of one mind as to the potential for extreme policies.
Bravo Bruce! Well said and sung mate. We need to all ‘face the music and dance’ to the upholding of our democratic rights. I’m sure Irving Berlin would have approved of your use of his tune. Looking forward to the album! Cheers, Pete Hobart
Great video. My family recently visited sterling castle as well as the “beheading stone” on a nearby hill. I’d love you know the history of that stone!
Another absolutely brilliant video! Thank you so much - a superb, well observed, presentation - brilliantly thought out and presented as ever! Thank you Bruce! So nice to find some actual content on UA-cam!
What a presentation to events to date ,you Bruce are a modern influencer. I am a scot of old and proud, your video inspires and strengthens my gut feeling of shared humanity and outlook on current and past history. We Scots have have a long and past history of injustice, justice and why a lot is wrong in the world today. I will be following your other productions and will add to this your input and mine to my grand children the ethos and values, which are so much needed today. So many other peoples of the world require respite in abundance from the despots, autocrats and others. history is so relevant ta all despite our backgrounds from Christians ,Muslims, Buddhist or any other and we must embrace the past positively to go forward. to many lives have been lost and still are today due to greed, religion and racism and other factors. I am a Scottish nationalist, but can respect others view, I look at northern Ireland which itself requires a remedy but has the past of English domination hanging over it. the English people themselves are also honest decent and like us, but unable to carve their identity due to other factors of politics, fear of being castigated etc... history is amazing and can and should be a big factor in education without distorting the facts, well done Bruce.
I had to subscribe to your channel. I love your accent. Your videos are super interesting. I learn so much from your videos. I love history. I love Scotland. Definitely on my bucket list to visit. Sending lots of Aloha from Honolulu. ❤🌺 tha gaol agam air Alba.💙thank you Bruce for being awesome. 🥰
We're seeing more of these kinds of things even here in America. Recently 3 men who had been arrested and convicted for a plot to kidnap the Governor of Michigan had their convictions overturned because it was discovered that more than 20 FBI agents did all the planning, purchasing and recruiting, illegally entrapping 3 men that they had duped into a scheme they would not have thought up on their own.
Is that what happened January 6 because that video of CCTV sure looks like it was a major scheme of illegal activities on the part of the capital coppers! What really happened there?
Hiya Bruce! Thank you for sharing these stories and connecting the dots, showing cycles in history. Speaking of patterns in history, I wonder, will you do a video on Mary Barbour and the 1915 rent strikes somewhere down the line? I know there's a whole can of worms that can be opened when talking about Glasgow tenements, but would love to hear you tell that particular story. Either way, I appreciate the work you're doing!
This story could apply to so many places for ao many who met unfortunate ends trying to make a better world. And the march towards authoritarianism continues in many of our countries. Another great lesson Bruce!
Excellent stuff as ever, Bruce.
Some Scottish folk might disagree with an Englishman, but my view is that the working classes of both Scotland and England have been treated like crap over the centuries.
We only have what we have now because people have fought for it.
Of course
Absolutely,I remember reading about the treatment of Africans picking cotton and the white working class children ripped to pieces on looms processing the cotton,the peterloo massacre, Ireland,the Scottish clearances,scots miners etc!who are these "elites"?
I think you'll find the UK is hardly unique.
The world over. By the way, we don't just disagree due to Nationality.
My comments are being ethnically cleansed from the comments section !
Well researched and delivered by a skilled natural orator.
Thank you
Thank you for this important & extremely timely video. As a friend “across the pond” in America, there is a roll back on civil & human rights taking place around the world. Thank you, sir, for shedding light on this critical issue.
Thank you very much for speaking up, Bruce. I love your work & I'm very glad to see that you're not scared off by the disgusting politics & attacks on our liberties that we're lumbered with
this is becoming a world wide issue, as long as there are 100 of us
Boy, do I agree with that. I knew you'd say that at the end. It matters a lot.
They are unlikely to use a physical axe, but the tactics and strategy to get the money into the 'right' hands are the same.
We still have one way to help stop it. We can still vote.
In our own country, please.
Agree remember they can take your citizenship away so making you a nobody a nothing
If voting changed anything they would soon stop voting
In the 1980s I was a young conservative. I cheered when the miners were defeated. In the last month, at age 57, I've become a union rep fighting for safety and equality in my workplace. My mind was slowly changed by personal experience, by the news and by historians telling the stories of the past. We must believe minds can be changed and allow space for that to happen. Thanks Bruce.
True
@@ScotlandHistoryTours It wasn't the miners who were defeated. It was Scargill and his kremlin masters.
Cheerd for performing slave labor? Are you sure?
@@markrainford1219Nonsense snowdrop
It was the whole working population. The miners were just a stepping stone to zero hours contracts and much else
Very thought provoking Bruce, Scotland can do better than that...
As a former NUM official and trade union official for unison unite ect I have been fighting and warning that our very limited rights are under threat. This video shows that very little changes unless people stand up and fight. They will take your rights away, and blame you 🫵. History it's a circle.
get involved bro 🎤🐥
Feds
Oligarchs are running things. Imo Tories are fascists now. In bed with Russia.
Hi been warming people about your rights since the Tories came to power in 2015 ,warned about leaving the EU would affect your rights keep up with your work I will with mine
@viperscot1 100%, Blair's government also had a lot to answer for with loss of rights and intrusive laws but at least we gained significant rights and protections via the EU. I'm glad that I left 10 years ago and am now a Dutch national, it's shocking to see what's happened over there and very sad to see after serving the country you were born in. I will certainly raise a glass if Scotland ever gain independence.
How it grieves me, Mr. Fummey, that this is happening today. I, too, see this as the way things are trending, and fear that the last beheading on British soil will soon not be the LAST beheading on British soil. Because the powerful think that "rights" are what the strong give to the weak, and if they are opposed, they often feel that bloody constraint is what must follows. The trend you speak of is happening across the ocean, as well. Because the powerful are the same everywhere.
Wasn't Lee Rigby in Britain?
Very well put sir!
Totally agree Bruce. We’re headed for something that’s not good and I fear for my children and theirs. All the best. 🇦🇺🇦🇺
😢
And the "something not good" will come regardless of who is (pretending) to run the country. The strings are being pulled from elsewhere in case you haven't noticed.
@@fredgillespie5855
Oh I’ve noticed and it’s the whole world not just Scotland.
Many here in the US agree that we’re heading for something that’s not good & fear for our children as well. It feels like we’re all trapped in a bus that’s driving towards a cliff & being told there’s no way to steer nor apply brakes.
Here speak the voice of fear and anger
Jings Bruce! Your videos are always great, and often thought provoking, but now and again you come out with a belter. This is one of those.
Wow, thanks!
Excellent and powerful video. Thought provoking in these times when Human Rights are targetted on a regular basis by our own government
Lovely to hear from you Bruce.Love from UK.
I live in UK
Some say that history doesn't repeat itself but it does rhyme. Thank you for this video! It shows that the struggles of the past have been reborn and battles that were fought and won now have to be fought again. It sure does sound like the past! Bruce, your history lessons are important and in this case, very relevant today!
And it rhymes badly!
Pretty sure that’s a Mark Twain quote.
72 years before this, one of my Jacobite ancestors was hung, drawn and beheaded at Tyburn. His body is in a cemetery at Kings Cross; his head somewhere in a Manchester garden...
important freedoms get pulled back regularly.its quite scary
😢
And then they surge ahead of any pullback.
Our gov are all globalist satanic bastards.
Bruce, once again you have produced a gem. This is proper history, not simply stories of stirring battles between large armies, over regents’ whims.
The Industrial Military Complex, first described by President Eisenhower, has been alive and well in Great Britain for centuries. Ably abetted by numerous Scots.
And your comments about watching Strictly broke my heart; because they were true.
Aye
Back WW2, some in Europe were probably relieved that was the case.
@@anthonyferris8912: I think most of us would see WW 2 as a bit of an exception to the usual wars.
Fantastic video with a great message that is so important to the health of our democracy
I had to find other sources online in order to know when Who were those beheaded and we took place?
The presentation of the information was met more shock and racked. It was to inform and educate in this particular video.
Another excellent video Bruce. Inspirational indeed👍
Many thanks
People being arrested for standing silently in the street as well Bruce…
😢
@@ScotlandHistoryTours...very prescient and sobering, given what has emerged in Russia...cheers ..E..😮
Arrests are fictional. Do you use that fiction in attempts to cause/to cause behavior? Are you being kept as a slave until death because of behavior such as that?
But not if they demonstrate for Gaza.
@@bunk95I can confidently say that I don’t have a clue what you are trying to communicate
Your warning resonates with your viewers across the pond, as well. Thanks.
On this topic although from North West England near me on the moors is the Hunger Walls, which are dry stone walls, that were built in exchange for food, they were made around this time and again during the Potato Blight.
😢
Great history well told. Shared.
Thank you
Bruce, Superb video. Thanks for showing how history isn’t just boring stories in dusty books. History is connected to our experiences every day.
True dat
God bless Scotland forever ! Cheers from Australia
In February and March I'll be visiting the major towns in Australia and New Zealand with my live show Scotland Made the World. It would be great to see you. Get info at www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx
Woah! I'm an American, I thoroughly enjoyed this video. I clicked to learn more about history but I did not expect the powerful words at the end. I applaud you, sir! Very moving stuff!
I have just recently become interested in Scottish History. I’m 73 years old, born and raised in Texas in the USA. I learned some things about Scotland in my world history classes in school. I have always been told that my ancestry was England. Some time ago I had my dna analyzed by a couple of places and discovered that I am somewhere I the neighborhood of 50% Scottish. So I am studying more about Scotland and my heritage. I appreciate your channel. Thank you!
interesting stuff !!!.... gawn yersel big man.
Thanks!
Thanks so much
I love your videos dude. You rock. My name is Randy Nesbit, i live in waxhaw, North Carolina. Your editing is getting better. I love hearing you say "let me tell you a story" lol
I appreciate that!
Great wee informative vid Bruce aw the best 👍
Thanks 👍
Well said big man.Great bit of history with a real warning for us all.Many can feel it.Lets hope for humanity.Not the death cult.
Great video Bruce, I live I Stirling and never knew this stuff.
Glad to help
We, unfortunately, are told lies constantly by our politicians would be great if they actually had to be held responsible for these lies...
They are accountable. On election day. But so many people are tribal partisans, that you can't get the entrenched politicians out of office, because they won't vote for another party, even for just one election, to get the guy out.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Thank you for discussing important topics Bruce.
What a very interesting video. Thanks Bruce for sharing. My Dad was very into his Scottish history and would have enjoyed your videos. He's got me passionate about Scottish history. I'm from Glasgow but now live in England. I have watched some of your other videos.
You hit the nail on the head more and more are seeing but its worse than people think
Freedom and equal rights for all !
I had not realized that about a diminution of rights in Great Britain! This is deeply alarming.
Throughout the western world.
This is a really special video, Bruce
Thanks for daring to speak out on this important matter
🏴 🦄 🏴
Relevant in so many ways. Leaders seem to keep using the same playbook
Love all your videos Bruce, but especially well done for this one 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I appreciate that!
The current situation is why you fight against a surveillance state. We have the same problem here in the States
😢
There is also thoughtcrime coined by George Orwell in his book 1984, but it is now an actual crime in the UK 7th March 2023. Clause 11 (formerly Clause 9 then Clause 10) of the Public Order Bill could criminalise any form of “influence” outside of abortion facilities - including in the form of silent prayer. Whether or not, you agree to use it in the case of abortion facilities, it does open the door for its use elsewhere!
😢
...and a couple of years ago there was the case of the former police officer (whose name unfortunately I can't remember) who had a visit from his old comrades in order to "check [his] thinking".
Upcoming Live shows www.brucefummey.co.uk/shows.aspx
A video about another great Scottish hero ua-cam.com/video/xF9ekmIB-aM/v-deo.html
Buy me coffee at www.buymeacoffee.com/ScottishBruce
I'm 49 English not proud of some of our past
We can only learn from our mistakes ..even more so when they are as truly wrong as in this and many more cases.
I truly believe in peace love and unity .man woman and child should all be counted and as equals .
May no other brother and or sister has to die for the Couse.
Further more I've just found this channel and will be doing a bit of a dive so to my brothers and sisters as one peace and always much love ❤
Well Bruce, I think I can understand what your saying as I'm living in the States were having really crazy things going on here, and I really hope things get better for you and your country men and women, I just hope you keep up the good fight because that's what we're trying to do here, well Bruce I hope you have a great rest of your day, and go out for a good pint. Thanks for all your great videos and history, I've learned a lot, I hope you can make it to the state's sometime.
Love history, stand firm.
Hello my friend this is the first time I have commented on one of your videos, although I watch them all. I love the way you tell your stories. This one in particular. There should be a movie made about this story. 🤗🤗
Thank you so much for taking the time to comment
I eagerly await the day the spirit of Freedom stirs the Free People to action. We’ve all given too much ground from generation to generation. There can only be so much pressure before the inevitable eruption. I pray that is soon.
Brilliant stuff again, Bruce. Very apt. Well told
Thank you kindly
Thank you for another great and informative video about important events in Scottish history. I think you make a great point about the "avalanche" of rollback. I only hope we can all find our way. I might be just an American, but I intend to vote and to encourage everyone I can find to also vote.
Love your work, Bruce. Even more food for thought 🌞
Thank you kindly
Bruce, I bow to your sincerity and your knowledge mate!!
A brilliant and prophetic piece was that...
Thank you, I always find myself totally focused on you after hearing, "let me tell you a story." This was a great piece of history you shared with us today, and yes, relevant more than ever. The messed up thing is that history has all the answers we need! Now, I'm going re-watch your "Greatest Hero of Scotland," video! You're my favorite storyteller!
Food for thought Bruce. Thank you.
Thanks Bruce for another excellent video. I am Canadian, and all Canadians should heed your warnings, for we too are headed down that same road.
Thank you so much!! I had no idea about the placard and arrests in this present day!! We needed this, thank you again from 🇺🇸
Yeah, the Murdoch press chooses what a lot of us do and don't hear.
Fascinating, as always. Thanks, Bruce.
Thank you Bruce very well done on your final words...
This makes me so sad. So glad you have presented the Truth in such a witty way that your message cannot be misunderstood.
Another incredible history that absolutely deserves to be remembered.
Things are no less moving backwards across the pond as well. You are not alone in the concerns you summarized with.
Thank you for producing quality content always.
Unrelated topic that sprung from your video… you drove by a great mural. Which made me curious? As an artist and a commissioner for the arts in my community, I find that I’m always interested in street art. We have many gorgeous ones locally as well. They all have meaning. Some historical, some depict modern relative issues, some to highlight an amazing event or person (s).
My questions are… do you have many murals in Scotland? If so, are there intersting stories about Scotland represented in those artworks? What are they? I’d love to know!
My daughter is in the middle of a semester at the University of Edinburgh. Shortly to take a weeks break and travel about. I think I will charge her with the task of showing momma some more art! I’ve seen some cute things from right around the dorms already.
Thanks for reading my queries. Have a brilliant day!
🖤
Hmmm, I'd have to research that
Wow. I wish every history teacher would make history as personal and immediate as you. I can't think of more than a handful of the people I know who see themselves as part of the ongoing history of us, or ask themselves important questions such as 'how bad could this be' and 'is this forward or backward". You could write a bestselling book, but it would be far more effective to have a Netflix or Amazon series, with the promotion your messages need. There's a difference between learning history and learning to participate in History because you can use the lessons our past can teach everyone. Each day I feel we're further from being able to recover the progress someone else paid so dearly to accomplish. Thanks.
Great content! Thought provoking and engaging!
Steady on, Bruce, the year is still young.
That last part I know you were talking about Scottland but to me you were also talking about USA. Good video.
UK
Your narration, the history, the deliberation with which you tell it, brilliant.
Ah thanks
I mourne the loss of freedom of speech, in England. I remember it well.
Love your stuff. Absolutely love it.
Yay!!! A new story!! I love these videos.
Just discovered this channel and subbed for the accent. Hopefully the content will be as good.
This was fascinating!!!!
for my sins, i've not kept up with your videos for a little bit (do please blame the algorithm as much as one might me) but i must just say - a truly awesome step up in production quality. very cool camera work now in place!
Top tier video, Bruce. You do powerful work making old injustices vivid and important today. 👊
Excellent stuff!!
Thank you for this Bruce. Insightful as always!
I found it fascinating listening to you. Keep up your great work.
Your delivery is magnetic. I hung on every word.
Ah thanks
Well said! Thank you for that. ATB. Nigel
Sadly this is so true and we are still moving in that direction. Let's hope it never gos backwards again. And we enshrine in law that we never do. Watching this world were you could vote and suddenly have an elected dictator. With freedoms and people jailed for having different political views. Democracy is a fragile thing. It dose not stay like that. Its threatened by others who want power. Let's hope people will wake up to that threat. Not just in nations over seas. But also at home. With even our own wee parliament now being questioned by some and others. Thanks again Bruce. For making people think. If nothing else it wakes people up and ti think how close we and others are to losing our own freedom. To a dictator in waiting.
Democracy without individual rights is a dangerous thing.
When I saw that people at "Speaker's Corner" in Hyde park, the birthplace of the term, getting on one's soapbox, were being arrested for.....well, speaking, I knew things were getting bad. Free speech is under attack. We need to be more tolerant of what others say. We must allow everyone to have their say, even if we think it is crazy and hurtful. We just have to have the guts to say, "hey, that's crazy and hurtful!" But have to follow up with why we think so. We have to be willing to get on our own soapbox and voice our own opinions and let the people decide. Thanks for continuing to do so!
😪
I always enjoy your videos - educational and interesting - in addition to a great presentation style
Excellent commentary, in one of my favourite towns. My personal favourite visit there was to the Old Town Jail, which is worth a post in itself . We are of one mind as to the potential for extreme policies.
Bravo Bruce! Well said and sung mate. We need to all ‘face the music and dance’ to the upholding of our democratic rights. I’m sure Irving Berlin would have approved of your use of his tune. Looking forward to the album!
Cheers, Pete
Hobart
Great video. My family recently visited sterling castle as well as the “beheading stone” on a nearby hill. I’d love you know the history of that stone!
Another absolutely brilliant video! Thank you so much - a superb, well observed, presentation - brilliantly thought out and presented as ever! Thank you Bruce! So nice to find some actual content on UA-cam!
Many thanks!
Thank you Bruce .
What a presentation to events to date ,you Bruce are a modern influencer.
I am a scot of old and proud, your video inspires and strengthens my gut feeling of shared humanity and outlook on current and past history. We Scots have have a long and past history of injustice, justice and why a lot is wrong in the world today. I will be following your other productions and will add to this your input and mine to my grand children the ethos and values, which are so much needed today.
So many other peoples of the world require respite in abundance from the despots, autocrats and others.
history is so relevant ta all despite our backgrounds from Christians ,Muslims, Buddhist or any other and we must embrace the past positively to go forward.
to many lives have been lost and still are today due to greed, religion and racism and other factors.
I am a Scottish nationalist, but can respect others view, I look at northern Ireland which itself requires a remedy but has the past of English domination hanging over it.
the English people themselves are also honest decent and like us, but unable to carve their identity due to other factors of politics, fear of being castigated etc...
history is amazing and can and should be a big factor in education without distorting the facts, well done Bruce.
Very timely sir!
I had to subscribe to your channel. I love your accent. Your videos are super interesting. I learn so much from your videos. I love history. I love Scotland. Definitely on my bucket list to visit. Sending lots of Aloha from Honolulu. ❤🌺 tha gaol agam air Alba.💙thank you Bruce for being awesome. 🥰
I love your videos. ❤
We're seeing more of these kinds of things even here in America. Recently 3 men who had been arrested and convicted for a plot to kidnap the Governor of Michigan had their convictions overturned because it was discovered that more than 20 FBI agents did all the planning, purchasing and recruiting, illegally entrapping 3 men that they had duped into a scheme they would not have thought up on their own.
Fiction is being used to market humans slaves, what they’re forced to do and where they are?
Is that what happened January 6 because that video of CCTV sure looks like it was a major scheme of illegal activities on the part of the capital coppers! What really happened there?
You never fail! It's so sad to watch history repeat itself.
🥲
Hiya Bruce! Thank you for sharing these stories and connecting the dots, showing cycles in history. Speaking of patterns in history, I wonder, will you do a video on Mary Barbour and the 1915 rent strikes somewhere down the line? I know there's a whole can of worms that can be opened when talking about Glasgow tenements, but would love to hear you tell that particular story. Either way, I appreciate the work you're doing!
This story could apply to so many places for ao many who met unfortunate ends trying to make a better world. And the march towards authoritarianism continues in many of our countries. Another great lesson Bruce!
Indeed
Absolutely great video! It is disgusting to see our rights being stripped from us! We are reaching a breaking point
A timely post Bruce.
Aye