That epitaph by Mustafa Kemal Attaturk is just so beautiful. 😢 It just shows that nations may go to war, but the common people who have to do the fighting generally have a great respect for each other.
Well it has a lot to do with why this day was chosen. It is no celebration or glorification of war. The Turks and ANZACs had no beef with each other, but we all died for a cause that really didn't affect us either.
@@muharebe_istasyonu Sorry I didn't mean it that way. Our two countries had no beef with each other. We were only there because the British told us to be. But if we had not gone there, you would not have come looking for us either if that makes sense. The fact that the average ANZAC had more respect for Turkish troops than their own commanding officers is very telling
@@muharebe_istasyonuWe Serbs had resonable cause to fight against Turks because Turks are our invaders for several centuries. Even Istanbul (or Constantinopol) was invaded by Turks and becomed part of Turkey by force.
That was excellent. I learned so much. Those soldiers on both sides were incredibly tough and brave. Ataturk's statement is a testimony to his respect to the soldiers of both sides.
We Turks are waiting for you every year, our brothers from Australia and New Zealand, we come not only for the commemoration but also for the holiday. Our fighting ability is fierce, but our friendship and generosity are endless.
We will come each year but in peace and respect. I had two from my family land at Gallipoli. Both went on to fight in France . Australians have respected Turkish sovereignty and Soldiers ever since.
I am a history teacher in Australia and had the great privilege of teaching my year 9 students about World War 1 this term and the present ANZAC Day ceremonies that happen at Gallipoli Cove. The ANZAC sacrifice is so tragic, sad and for such a significant part, the losses so unwarranted. My students so admired the fact that the people who defeated the Gallipoli campaign were people that were defending their land, their people, their home. They then couldn’t believe that people that were attacked on their own home soil could be so welcoming, understanding and so gracious as to welcome the descendants and countrymen of those who had attempted to invade their land, to commemorate those who died trying to do that, year after year. The Turkish people demonstrate a respect and dignity that is truly beautiful each year they allow foreigners onto their soil to commemorate those who died trying to fell their countrymen. It was such a sad campaign for both sides of the conflict. While we never forget or truly understand what it may have been like to be there in 1915, know that young people in Australia are still taught about it and that they respect the Turkish people for the defence of their own country and the enormous respect they show us on ANZAC Day.
@@uUSQ-tn4hf You can rest easy, the British showed us as monsters and brought different nations from different geographies, including their colonies, for their own goals and threw them against us in Gallipoli, the Turkish nation knows this. Turkish soldiers understood this while fighting on the front. We understood and learned this from the Anzac letters. George bolinger, percival fenwick, Sydney harrie, John Taylor , reginold sawory, Eric moody, Joe murray.I know them all, I read their letters, their diaries, they died because of Churchill
You can rest easy, the British showed us as monsters and brought different nations from different geographies, including their colonies, for their own goals and threw them against us in Gallipoli, the Turkish nation knows this. Turkish soldiers understood this while fighting on the front. We understood and learned this from the Anzac letters.joe murray , John Taylor , Eric moody ,I know them all, I read their letters, their diaries, they died because of Churchill
Thank You for making this video for ANZAC day. More and more people disregard and dishonour these brave men. As long as Australians still keep the vigil on the 25th of April each year they will not be forgotten. Edit: I would never forget New Zealand, only have my experience as an Australian.
No one I know of or have seen disregards or dishonours these men. Not sure WTF you’re talking about. If anything, it’s the complete opposite. There is a lot of somber respect.
This is the most vivid description of the ANZAC assault we could ever hope for. Incredible. The battle ground is shown in every detail. No one has done it better. Well done Team!
My Grandfather landed on the first morning with the Australian 1st Div, 1st Bty, 1st Field Artillery Brigade. His Battery was the only 18pdr that remained ashore for the entire day, firing upwards of 500 shells ... silencing the Turkish Guns that were firing on the landing zone of the beach head. He survived 4 more months on Gallipoli before removal to a Hospital Ship for disentary. After recovering in England he was taken on strength and continued with the Australian 1st Division in France until the end of the war in 1918. What he saw and survived ... unthinkable!
My Grandads uncle died on Chunuk Bair. He was in the Auckland Infantry and his body was never found. His cousin was in the Auckland Mounted Rifles and is buried at Ari Burnu cemetery at Anzac cove
@@jammyscouser2583 My condolences for your uncle. I hope such pain never happens again. That person who commented is a complete idiot. Turks like that are very few. As a Turk, I know history well and as dear Ataturk said, I say that the Johns who died there are no different from our Mehmets.
I am from Kastamonu, a province in the Black Sea region of Türkiye. The only high school at that time in my province, Abdurrahman Pasha High School, was unable to graduate any students between 1914 and 1918 because all 120 of its students went to fight in the Gallipoli Campaign. Very few of those children and others who went to the war from this region were able to return. In fact, the famous folk song about this war, the "Çanakkale Türküsü," though the true author is unknown, is also from this region.
Superb video of the Anzac Campaign released today on Anzac Day... back from the dawn service and found this... Thank You for making this video... probably the most concise I've seen...
Had goosebumos as i started watching this with the clock here ticking into ANZAC day... AT GOING DOWN TO SLEEP AND IN THE MORNING I WILL REMEMBER. LEST I FORGOT RIP TO ALL WHO FELL FRIEND AND FOE, ALL THOSE WHO FOUGHT AND DIED DURING THAT GALLIPOLI CAMPAIGN, ASWELL AS EVERY ANZAC SOLIDER WHO HAVE GIVEN THE ULTIMATE SACRIFICE THERE AFTER. LEST WE FORGET 🍻
It was not the landing that was important. Nor was it the retreat before dawn months later. It was what happened during the months of battle that made the legend. We are not an arrogant people. We do not celebrate victories. We remember the fighting and the acts of heroism, comradeship and loss that we cannot forget. Anzac Day is our Memorial Day. Its not a holiday of fun, but a day of remembrance and quiet reflection. For many it's a day to weep. From enemies at the beginning of WW1 with Turkey and Germany, when we withdrew after stalemate, and the Turks took our fallen into their arms in admiration. Three times as many Turks lost their lives as we did at Gallipoli. Now out nations are bound together in mutual respect. As Emil Ataturk said, "...You, the mothers who sent their sons from faraway countries, wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
We had a memorial service for ANZAC day in London believing Australian and New Zealanders god bless all those who died, Churchill was war mad, he made many mistakes, my grandfather died in the First World War, my dad was wounded in the 2 world war very good film to understand what really happened, than you from Britain 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Anzac Day ceremonies are held every year in Le Quesnoy, Flers and Longueval, on the nearest Sunday to 25 April. The French also remember. Lest we forget.
That is a beautiful memorial statement that was read at the end of the video. I actually got a bit misty eyed. Also, the country of Turkey does have a special place in my heart as I lived there for about 2 years when my USAF enlisted dad was stationed at Incirlik Air Force Base in the southern region of Turkey during the early 1980s.
The order that turned the momentum to Ottoman favor “I don't order you to attack,” he said. “I order you to die. By the time we are dead, other units and commanders will have come up to take our place.” Mustafa Kemal Atatürk who gave that order to the soldiers re-captured the hills. He also moved his divison and 57th against the orders he was given earlier, knowing ANZACs would land on those exact areas but ignored by Limon Von Sanders and Pro-German Ottoman officers.
My great uncle Private Cyril Weller Thompson aged 20,a bootmaker from Inglewood,Victoria, Australia,lies at lone pine,Gallipoli,where he was killed in action,10/8/1915,every Anzac day,l remember him
All of these videos are of a quality like no others iv yet to see on UA-cam and iv seen many.. Just incredible , the background. The plans. The personal story's of real men with faces to put to,. Just magnificent. Exceptionally well done.. As good as they get on these subjects. I applaud you for the remarkable work...
What a tremendous waste of thousands of young lives, as was much of the entirety of the great war, although thats simply a massive misnomer. Excellent video, Bravo Zulu on doing such a great job.
A fantastic documentary, thank you. I visited Gallipoli and when you’re there you really appreciate how steep the hills are - advancing up them under fire would surely have seemed an impossible task. My great great uncle also lies at Ari Burnu cemetery, having died of wounds 11 Dec 1915. Lest we forget.
Thanks so much for this excellent video. My great uncle Charlie was among those 3rd Bde diggers ashore in the early hours of the 25th April, a member of 10th Battalion. To see so many names that he would have fought with has been quite surreal, in a very good way. Very much appreciated 🇦🇺
Best presentation of the anzac landings I have seen so far. I am especially impressed by the inclusion of mehmet şefik and the 27th regiment's actions which are largely ignored.
I am a new subscriber. I am sorry to have not discovered you before. Excellent efforts. This is my second viewing of your efforts. Keep up the great work please. This is the first viewing of the Aussies my favourite as an Aussie. Thank you. We do punch above our size by necessity.
This is an absolutely first class video. I watched your video about Oradur- Sur-Glane , and sad though it was , the presentation was brilliant. Thank you very much indeed.
my grandad was there lost his life under heavy machine gun fire , left my nan and four kids to feed,,, Churchills human cannon fodder,,,,,,,,,,, GOD BLESS THE FALLEN RIP XXX
My great great great grandfather was there maybe he was a ANZAC that place is a piece of history for Australia and New Zealand as a fellow Australian like myself in respectful to all ANZACS who died and survived
Hi I came to this video after hearing the song " The band played waltzing Matilda " I wanted to to see how the battle played out . This video has been very informative and well explained. Thanks for making it ,I now know what happened and when . Many thanks Frank
Superb video. I learned a bit about the Gallipoli campaign before, but learned much more here. Lots of good information. Great overview of the first day of the battle, especially the movements of the troops, the landings, the strategies, and the difficulties that both sides faced. I like how you include the testimonies too and had very helpful maps. Great work. Take care.
Amazing video! The birds eye view videos really help see the terrain better than all the paper maps and computer graphics can do alone. Looking forward so much to the next installment!
This is an interesting and informative video. I particularly like the overhead shots showing the topographical features. I've been to the area three times including trips to Cape Helles and Suvla Bay. I did the trips in the 1990s going before and after the tragic bush fire.
As an American that hobby-studies English and European history, I can't imagine a more despised man in the ANZAC community that Sir Winston Churchill. Personally, I admire many things about him, but, I doubt there was ever a kind word said about him, after Gallipoli.
It didn't really. British Intelligence had already done an extensive study in 1906 (google British Naval Intelligence Study 1906 and you can read the report for yourself) that predicted, with scary accuracy, what would happen if they tried to force the straits by Sea or Land in the event of war with the Ottomans. This information was well known yet the War Council ignored it ... and nearly everything the study predicted in 1906 happened in 1915.
My maternal grandfather took part in the later landing at Suvla Bay as a private in the Somerset Light Infantry. He was wounded, losing an eye. Evacuated back to England via a stay in Malta. It's strange to think I'm just two generations from this battle.
It’s brilliant idea that the audience of Turkish commanders voiced by Turkish person, but he is not able to speak fluently, I am here to serve our common history as a voicer for next time :) Amazing job! Appreciated!
That is so sad why they do that today in school we learn at school anzac day and we stand still then we give respect to the people who died I hope you rest and peace
I have a great granddad and he was a soldier and his names was Clive (I think that’s how his name was spelled) but if only I knew what he achieved during the war or rather what battle he was in I would be happy knowing who he was with the mates rest in peace Clive
Ben Türk'üm. Benim Dedem Çanakkale Savaşına katıldı ve sağ döndü. Evet unutmayacağız ve unutturmayacağız. Biz işgal için gelen herkes ile savaşmaya her zaman hazırız, en zayıf zamanımız da bile.
I really wonder at what Maclagan was thinking - Hamilton’s orders stressed the importance of the Sari Bair ridge, yet this was ignored. Further Maclagan ordered digging in on the SEAWARD edge of Second Ridge, these actions dooming the bridgehead as a stalemate. Keep in mind in the first 24 hours nearly 24000 Anzacs had been landed opposed by a mere 4000 Ottomans.
Wow, that statement by Ataturk nearly brought a tear to my eye. As a Brit i genuinely love both the Australians and the New Zealanders. I have always seen us, Canada and the American splitters (😂) as one big family.
Yep, that’s what the film has said. Two divisions involved in this landing, the 1st Australian that came ashore first, followed up by the NZ&A Division later that morning. Many of the New Zealanders didn’t complete their landing until the afternoon of that first day.
I continue to wonder why there wasn’t a concentration landing a bit further north onto the plains where an army could more easily concentrate and utilize artillery. Then having units going into the ridge country to help secure flanks and threaten the enemy from the heights would be a very difficult situation. Is there detail as to why a strategy similar to that wasn’t undertaken?
Wonderful historical coverage video about Gelupuli war 1916 was that the British Empire campaign failed to occupy the Gelepoli peninsula ...stubborn, fanatic resistance of Ottoman empire troops rescued military attitude for Ottoman empire favor. I think the campaign ( amphibians mission) failed from the first moment for two reasons 1- firepowers of ANZAC troops was not decisive due to lack of machine guns and artillery covered. 2- Generally amphibians campaigning is not practiced upon previous naval failure results. surprises Eliminate was lost
Very good video, very informative with the mappings, one movie I had watched called The Water Diviner with Russell crowe, about him trying to find his three sons after they went off to Gallipoli, the battle scenes took me by surprise in that movie it was quite a brutal fight. Also, I was wondering if you could do a video on fighting and tactics early on in 1914 before trenches were thought up, such as the battle of the frontiers and such, there isn't much for information on that period of the war.
So glad for the first time that a doco doesn't say it was a bloodbath on the beach, there were supposedly only about 60 Turks on the hills above the Anzac landing. Maps also show that we never landed on the wrong beach, see the doco "Gallipoli from Above by Hugh Dolan"
Also read Hugh Dolan's book '36 Days - The Untold Story Behind the Gallipoli Landings'. What is important to note is that Hugh Dolan had a keen desire to understand the truth surrounding the events of 25th April 1915 which spurned the Anzac tradition as his Great Grandfather was engaged in that event. He says that like many Australians he had been raised to believe that the British had been in control of Australian troops; that the British sent the Australians to the wrong beach; and to a beach that they knew nothing about; and that the British sent the Anzacs to a murderous slaughter in the dawn of 25th April 1915. He had believed the popular rhetoric that was Lions (Anzac troops) were led by Donkeys (British Officers) and that the whole Gallipoli campaign was a bungled operation. He knew, of course, that because the Gallipoli campaign failed to achieve the objective the whole campaign has been severely criticised as being ill-conceived and poorly planned and executed. But he wanted to know if this was correct or even a fair assessment? And, does the evidence support this assessment? Most of the Anzac mythology was created using the diaries of Charles Bean, the Herald newspaper war correspondent. Charles Bean showed in his diaries that he was aware of some of the military intelligence that went into planning the Anzac landing, but he did not include it in his official history: which is the bible of Anzac mythology. That was partly because the military intelligence was kept secret until 1965. The result is that the success or failure of the Anzac landing has been judged on whether it achieved the targets outlined in the original British battle plan prepared by Sir General Ian Hamilton, the commander of the 80,000 Allied forces. Being a serving career military intelligence officer Hugh Dolan understood that knowing the plans for the Anzac landing would be crucial to fully appreciate what actually happened on 25th April 1915. What Hugh Dolan discovered overturned everything he believed and what he had been told could not be further from the truth. Hugh Dolan concludes his documentary by emphasising these points: 1. The British did not send the Anzacs to Gallipoli to be slaughtered. 2. Anzac casualties were comparatively light. 3. It was not a dawn landing for the Anzacs and the major landing was done under the cover of darkness. 4. The Anzacs landed on the correct beach (‘Z’ beach). 5. The landing was imaginatively planned by Australian Officers and was a successful operation. Hugh Dolan has stressed that if Australians want to properly acknowledge the events of the Anzacs at Gallipoli then they must get the record right and not perpetuates myths that may be popular. This is what Hugh Dolan has outlined in his documentary mentioned and in his book. Around 5am on 25th April 1915, the Australian Lieutenant General William Birdwood contacted Sir General Ian Hamilton to advise him that 5,500 Anzacs had already landed on ‘Z’ beach - and dawn wasn't until 5.20am. The Anzacs had landed under the cover of darkness. This was before Sir General Ian Hamilton had even commenced his planned British attack which was to commence at 7am after heavy bombardment from the British Naval guns. By the time the Australian war correspondent Charles Bean landed on ‘Z’ beach shortly after dawn on 25th April 1915, 8,500 Anzacs had already made it to shore. It is important to note that Sir General Hamilton planned for British troops to land on the southern part of the Gallipoli peninsula and for them to move northwards towards the forts protecting the entrance to the Dardanelles and for the Anzacs to land on the northern part of the Gallipoli peninsula and move southwards to the fort. The Anzacs were to land on beaches between two points - Fisherman’s Hut and Kaba Tepe and the whole sector was called ‘Z’ beach and was five kilometers long. Responsibility for planning the Anzac landing was with the Australian Major General William Bridges. Major General William Bridges was 54 years old and a professional soldier. His headquarters were aboard a converted cruise liner named Minnewaska which was anchored in Limnos Harbour about 2 kilometers from ‘Z’ beach. On 13th April 1915 Major General Bridges gathered his staff to plan the Anzacs landing on ‘Z’ beach. Major Charles Villiers-Stuart was amongst the staff gathered and as Intelligence Officer for Anzac Command it was his job to know everything about ‘Z’ beach. At that time he knew virtually nothing and the only information he had from air recognizance was that there were no Turkish guns protecting ‘Z’ beach which led to the assumption that it was unprotected. Major Charles Villiers-Stuart decided to go and have a look for himself. However, due to the ship’s distance from the shore and the five kilometer length of shoreline he was unable to see into the rocky terrain to determine if there were any guns protecting the beaches. As a consequence the ship was diverted to the island of Tenedos. Tenedos was the base for a squadron of the British Royal Navy Air Service. Commander Charles Samson of the Royal Naval flying Squadron was approached by Major Charles Villiers-Stuart and was asked to fly him over the Gallipoli Peninsula so that he could see what defences the Turks had. On 14th April 1915 Commander Charles Samson flew Major Charles Villiers-Stuart over the Gallipoli Peninsula and in particular the hills and gullies of ‘Z’ beach. What Major Villiers Stuart saw changed everything for him. He was able to see the full extent of the Turkish defences and this concerned him greatly. He sat in the back seat of the two-man biplane with a pair of binoculars and a 1/40,000 scale map. He was able to determine the strength and position of the Turkish forces on the ridges behind Anzac Cove. When Major Villiers-Stuart returned to his headquarters on board ship he studied his sketches and the notes that he gathered from his flight over ‘Z’ beach. He then made an accurate and detailed model of ‘Z’ beach. On this model he showed exactly where Turkish guns and tents for their troops were located. He knew how many Turkish soldiers were assigned to each tent so he was able to establish the number of Turkish soldiers who would be defending ‘Z’ beach and where they would be located. At the subsequent intelligence briefing, Major Villiers-Stuart told his superiors that Sir General Hamilton's assumptions about the northern beaches being relatively unprotected were wrong. ‘Z’ beach was defended by several batteries, barbed wire and entrenchments. Major Villiers-Stuart explained in detail the model he had created and the detailed map he drew of the Turkish defences to Major General Bridges. Major General Bridges became extremely concerned when he realised that his troops were going to get slaughtered by the 32 artillery barrels pointing at them when landing and then running up the beach. The original Hamilton plan had been for the Anzacs to attack at the same time as the British, about 7am. Major General Bridges then decided on something completely unorthodox and which had not been practised in modern military history. He proposed a plan to have his Anzac troops land differently to the way Sir General Hamilton had planned for his British troops to land. It was Sir General Hamilton’s plan to land his troops at daybreak after heavy bombardment of the hills and shores by the British Naval guns. In contrast to this, Major General Bridges opted for a surprise landing under the cover of darkness and before any naval bombardment. Major General Bridges’ plan was meticulous and carefully planned right down to the placement of carpet on the decks of the warships to muffle the sound of the men's hobnail boots. Velvet was put around the oarlocks of the rowing boats to also muffle any sound. Major General Bridges sought and gained permission from Sir General Hamilton for his new plan and to change his orders instead of landing and advancing across the Gallipoli peninsula to Maidos on the Dardenelles, his new objective was to land and draw the Turkish forces onto them, giving the British the breathing space to land the main attack in the south. He reasoned to General Hamilton that the naval bombardment would alert the Turks to the imminent landing of troops and as a result they would be fully ready to fire at the landing troops. It must be noted that the British flew 18 photographic missions over the beaches where their troops were going to land. Sir General Hamilton is reported as saying when he saw them that he expected to lose 50% of his troops during the landing. Unlike the Australian Commanders who altered their plans based on the photographic evidence they had, Sir General Hamilton did not deviate from his original landings plan. (This may raise serious questions but it must be understood that General Hamilton had a large fleet of battle ships at his disposal. He rightly would be expected to use the guns on these ships to bombard the Turkish positions with a view to knocking out as many of their guns as possible and also kill as many of the Turkish soldiers as possible before attempting to land his own troops. He could not use the guns on his battle ships once the landing of his troops was underway). Hugh Dolan produced a number of aerial maps drawn by Major Villiers-Stuart and they were dated 20th April 1915 in the Major's own handwriting. Concluding, it appears to me that Hugh Dolan has presented crucial and compelling evidence to completely justify the position he now holds. However, the traditional beliefs had been 50 years in the making before official documents were released and a nation had already been built based on those beliefs. I can't see them being changed now in the way Hugh Dolan believes they should be changed.
@@mark703 Thanks. When you next see Hugh will you please thank him from me for his service to our country. I learnt so much from his book and I get angry when I read denigrating posts based on myth and ignorance. For information, I honour all people who fight to defend their country. My grandfather and a number of uncles were killed in France during WWI as soldiers of the British armed forces. My father served in WWII with the RAF. My eldest brother did National Service with the RAF and my youngest brother did National Service as a conscript with the Australian Army in 1968. I was called up in 1965 in the first intake of National Service conscription for service in Vietnam. Luckily for me I failed my medical examination. A classmate of mine from school was also called up and we met when we had our medical examinations. He passed his medical, went to Vietnam and was killed at the battle of Long Tan in August 1966 at the age of 21. It shook me as I realised that I could have been alongside him if I had passed my medical. So here I am at 79 years of age having had the opportunity to have lived a long and fulfilling life and having had the opportunity to benefit from the research done by experts.
That epitaph by Mustafa Kemal Attaturk is just so beautiful. 😢 It just shows that nations may go to war, but the common people who have to do the fighting generally have a great respect for each other.
Well it has a lot to do with why this day was chosen. It is no celebration or glorification of war. The Turks and ANZACs had no beef with each other, but we all died for a cause that really didn't affect us either.
@@glenchapman3899 We Turks had a reasonible cause, we defended our fatherland against invaders.
@@muharebe_istasyonu Sorry I didn't mean it that way. Our two countries had no beef with each other. We were only there because the British told us to be. But if we had not gone there, you would not have come looking for us either if that makes sense. The fact that the average ANZAC had more respect for Turkish troops than their own commanding officers is very telling
@@glenchapman3899 You're right mate im sorry, the only reason of this nonsense was British Empire.
@@muharebe_istasyonuWe Serbs had resonable cause to fight against Turks because Turks are our invaders for several centuries. Even Istanbul (or Constantinopol) was invaded by Turks and becomed part of Turkey by force.
That was excellent. I learned so much. Those soldiers on both sides were incredibly tough and brave. Ataturk's statement is a testimony to his respect to the soldiers of both sides.
We are glad you enjoyed the video!
We Turks are waiting for you every year, our brothers from Australia and New Zealand, we come not only for the commemoration but also for the holiday. Our fighting ability is fierce, but our friendship and generosity are endless.
We will come each year but in peace and respect. I had two from my family land at Gallipoli. Both went on to fight in France . Australians have respected Turkish sovereignty and Soldiers ever since.
I am a history teacher in Australia and had the great privilege of teaching my year 9 students about World War 1 this term and the present ANZAC Day ceremonies that happen at Gallipoli Cove. The ANZAC sacrifice is so tragic, sad and for such a significant part, the losses so unwarranted. My students so admired the fact that the people who defeated the Gallipoli campaign were people that were defending their land, their people, their home. They then couldn’t believe that people that were attacked on their own home soil could be so welcoming, understanding and so gracious as to welcome the descendants and countrymen of those who had attempted to invade their land, to commemorate those who died trying to do that, year after year. The Turkish people demonstrate a respect and dignity that is truly beautiful each year they allow foreigners onto their soil to commemorate those who died trying to fell their countrymen. It was such a sad campaign for both sides of the conflict. While we never forget or truly understand what it may have been like to be there in 1915, know that young people in Australia are still taught about it and that they respect the Turkish people for the defence of their own country and the enormous respect they show us on ANZAC Day.
@@uUSQ-tn4hf You can rest easy, the British showed us as monsters and brought different nations from different geographies, including their colonies, for their own goals and threw them against us in Gallipoli, the Turkish nation knows this. Turkish soldiers understood this while fighting on the front. We understood and learned this from the Anzac letters. George bolinger, percival fenwick, Sydney harrie, John Taylor , reginold sawory, Eric moody, Joe murray.I know them all, I read their letters, their diaries, they died because of Churchill
You can rest easy, the British showed us as monsters and brought different nations from different geographies, including their colonies, for their own goals and threw them against us in Gallipoli, the Turkish nation knows this. Turkish soldiers understood this while fighting on the front. We understood and learned this from the Anzac letters.joe murray , John Taylor , Eric moody ,I know them all, I read their letters, their diaries, they died because of Churchill
ua-cam.com/video/hoMPbyW30PM/v-deo.htmlsi=DcK-4Cm7d0jIZ2CB
Thank You for making this video for ANZAC day. More and more people disregard and dishonour these brave men. As long as Australians still keep the vigil on the 25th of April each year they will not be forgotten.
Edit: I would never forget New Zealand, only have my experience as an Australian.
'More & more people disregard & dishonour these brave men...' if this is so, they are fools whose opinions can be ignored.
Just got back from my dawn service. Nz here too bruh
@@AtraaHaha, Yes we certainly can’t forget the brother country across the pond.
ANZAC, Australia and New Zealand mate. Been to the dawn service this morning, it's growing in size every year. Regards from New Zealand.
No one I know of or have seen disregards or dishonours these men. Not sure WTF you’re talking about. If anything, it’s the complete opposite. There is a lot of somber respect.
This is the most vivid description of the ANZAC assault we could ever hope for. Incredible. The battle ground is shown in every detail. No one has done it better. Well done Team!
Thank you for your comment!
From a grandson of an ANZAC with 9th btn, thank you for this look into the past. I now understand further what my grandfather went through.
As a Turk, I wish all heroes to rest in peace. 🇳🇿❤🇹🇷❤ 🇦🇺
bu kadar geniş olma
@@CIHANOZEL-ij6vd ne diyon ya
As a Turk i hate our enemies, you should change your sick mind.🇹🇷
@@muharebe_istasyonu saçmalama
@muharebe_istasyonu enemies?
My Grandfather landed on the first morning with the Australian 1st Div, 1st Bty, 1st Field Artillery Brigade. His Battery was the only 18pdr that remained ashore for the entire day, firing upwards of 500 shells ... silencing the Turkish Guns that were firing on the landing zone of the beach head. He survived 4 more months on Gallipoli before removal to a Hospital Ship for disentary. After recovering in England he was taken on strength and continued with the Australian 1st Division in France until the end of the war in 1918. What he saw and survived ... unthinkable!
My Grandads uncle died on Chunuk Bair. He was in the Auckland Infantry and his body was never found. His cousin was in the Auckland Mounted Rifles and is buried at Ari Burnu cemetery at Anzac cove
Prodphetic bye cumtz grow up its on
There is no such thing called Anzac Cove, you named it. İts our land and named Kaba Tepe.
@@muharebe_istasyonu 1985 yılındaki Anzak Günü'nde "Anzak Koyu" adı Türk hükümeti tarafından resmen tanındı.. Time to lose the hatred buddy
@@muharebe_istasyonuaww my bro thats the fat shut down. Its okay
@@jammyscouser2583 My condolences for your uncle. I hope such pain never happens again. That person who commented is a complete idiot. Turks like that are very few. As a Turk, I know history well and as dear Ataturk said, I say that the Johns who died there are no different from our Mehmets.
I am from Kastamonu, a province in the Black Sea region of Türkiye. The only high school at that time in my province, Abdurrahman Pasha High School, was unable to graduate any students between 1914 and 1918 because all 120 of its students went to fight in the Gallipoli Campaign. Very few of those children and others who went to the war from this region were able to return. In fact, the famous folk song about this war, the "Çanakkale Türküsü," though the true author is unknown, is also from this region.
Kemal recognized just how vital was the Sair Bair Ridge - Maclagan didn’t, thus setting the scene for a bloody stalemate.
Superb video of the Anzac Campaign released today on Anzac Day... back from the dawn service and found this... Thank You for making this video... probably the most concise I've seen...
Awesome, thank you!
Had goosebumos as i started watching this with the clock here ticking into ANZAC day...
AT GOING DOWN TO SLEEP AND IN THE MORNING I WILL REMEMBER. LEST I FORGOT
RIP TO ALL WHO FELL FRIEND AND FOE, ALL THOSE WHO FOUGHT AND DIED DURING THAT GALLIPOLI CAMPAIGN, ASWELL AS EVERY ANZAC SOLIDER WHO HAVE GIVEN THE ULTIMATE SACRIFICE THERE AFTER.
LEST WE FORGET 🍻
It was not the landing that was important. Nor was it the retreat before dawn months later. It was what happened during the months of battle that made the legend.
We are not an arrogant people. We do not celebrate victories. We remember the fighting and the acts of heroism, comradeship and loss that we cannot forget. Anzac Day is our Memorial Day. Its not a holiday of fun, but a day of remembrance and quiet reflection. For many it's a day to weep.
From enemies at the beginning of WW1 with Turkey and Germany, when we withdrew after stalemate, and the Turks took our fallen into their arms in admiration. Three times as many Turks lost their lives as we did at Gallipoli. Now out nations are bound together in mutual respect.
As Emil Ataturk said, "...You, the mothers who sent their sons from faraway countries, wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Thank you for your comment!
We had a memorial service for ANZAC day in London believing Australian and New Zealanders god bless all those who died, Churchill was war mad, he made many mistakes, my grandfather died in the First World War, my dad was wounded in the 2 world war very good film to understand what really happened, than you from Britain 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Thank you for this video, to Aussies this is an extremely important moment in our history. Lest we forget.
The Band Played Waltzing Matilda.
Thank you for this post. All fallen will be remembered x
Anzac Day ceremonies are held every year in Le Quesnoy, Flers and Longueval, on the nearest Sunday to 25 April.
The French also remember.
Lest we forget.
Thank you.
From the United States and grandson of two Pacific War veterans, on this ANZAC Day, lest we forget.
That is a beautiful memorial statement that was read at the end of the video. I actually got a bit misty eyed. Also, the country of Turkey does have a special place in my heart as I lived there for about 2 years when my USAF enlisted dad was stationed at Incirlik Air Force Base in the southern region of Turkey during the early 1980s.
The order that turned the momentum to Ottoman favor “I don't order you to attack,” he said. “I order you to die. By the time we are dead, other units and commanders will have come up to take our place.” Mustafa Kemal Atatürk who gave that order to the soldiers re-captured the hills.
He also moved his divison and 57th against the orders he was given earlier, knowing ANZACs would land on those exact areas but ignored by Limon Von Sanders and Pro-German Ottoman officers.
Superb video, clearly presented. Well done to BattleguideVT and the Gallipoli Association
Thanks for liking
My great uncle Private Cyril Weller Thompson aged 20,a bootmaker from Inglewood,Victoria, Australia,lies at lone pine,Gallipoli,where he was killed in action,10/8/1915,every Anzac day,l remember him
All of these videos are of a quality like no others iv yet to see on UA-cam and iv seen many.. Just incredible , the background. The plans. The personal story's of real men with faces to put to,. Just magnificent. Exceptionally well done.. As good as they get on these subjects. I applaud you for the remarkable work...
What a tremendous waste of thousands of young lives, as was much of the entirety of the great war, although thats simply a massive misnomer. Excellent video, Bravo Zulu on doing such a great job.
Great video. I have seen many docos on Gallipoli, but none as informative and well made as this one. Thanks keep up the great work 👍
Splendid. I am in Canberra, Australia, and it is Anzac day. Respect.
Thank you, currently writing this from the ANZAC service in Christchurch :)
A fantastic documentary, thank you. I visited Gallipoli and when you’re there you really appreciate how steep the hills are - advancing up them under fire would surely have seemed an impossible task. My great great uncle also lies at Ari Burnu cemetery, having died of wounds 11 Dec 1915. Lest we forget.
Thanks so much for this excellent video. My great uncle Charlie was among those 3rd Bde diggers ashore in the early hours of the 25th April, a member of 10th Battalion. To see so many names that he would have fought with has been quite surreal, in a very good way.
Very much appreciated 🇦🇺
Glad you enjoyed it
Five star documentary, thank you.
Wow, thank you!
Best presentation of the anzac landings I have seen so far. I am especially impressed by the inclusion of mehmet şefik and the 27th regiment's actions which are largely ignored.
I am a new subscriber. I am sorry to have not discovered you before. Excellent efforts. This is my second viewing of your efforts. Keep up the great work please. This is the first viewing of the Aussies my favourite as an Aussie. Thank you. We do punch above our size by necessity.
This is an absolutely first class video. I watched your video about Oradur- Sur-Glane , and sad though it was , the presentation was brilliant. Thank you very much indeed.
The inscription is profound and genuine, an edict we need now.
Excellent. 3D topography and photography bring this area to life.
my grandad was there lost his life under heavy machine gun fire , left my nan and four kids to feed,,, Churchills human cannon fodder,,,,,,,,,,, GOD BLESS THE FALLEN RIP XXX
My great great great grandfather was there maybe he was a ANZAC that place is a piece of history for Australia and New Zealand as a fellow Australian like myself in respectful to all ANZACS who died and survived
Wonderfully made video. I love the transition from maps to video to help set the scene.
Awesome.. so glad Dans doing this. Best and most respectful war channel on here. Appreciated here in Oz.
Brilliant video Dan. I look forward to more of this series. Thank you for your efforts at Battle Guide!
Great job, never knew about this
That Ottoman,New Zealand and Australia,had this Big Battle!
Thanks
My great grandfather was a lighthorseman at Beersheba and Gallipoli and he served with Australian 9th light horse regiment in the first world war
Hi I came to this video after hearing the song " The band played waltzing Matilda " I wanted to to see how the battle played out .
This video has been very informative and well explained.
Thanks for making it ,I now know what happened and when .
Many thanks Frank
Well presented. This is the first time I have been able to fully comprehend the lie of the land fought over 109 years ago.
Such a beautiful video. Attention to detail and supporting the event with real videos were brilliant.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Brilliant analysis of that first day. Many thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it
A beautiful memorial by kamal
Absolutely beautiful. How are you doing?
Superb video. I learned a bit about the Gallipoli campaign before, but learned much more here. Lots of good information. Great overview of the first day of the battle, especially the movements of the troops, the landings, the strategies, and the difficulties that both sides faced. I like how you include the testimonies too and had very helpful maps. Great work. Take care.
Thanks for the kind words Alex.
@@BattleGuideVT Anytime! Keep up the nice work. I appreciate the videos that you make :).
My grandfathers brother died at salonika (kia) Killed in action thank you for yet another great production...
Excellent presentation! Well done!
Thank you kindly!
Keep the videos coming! Really well done!
Thanks Jack!
Amazing video! The birds eye view videos really help see the terrain better than all the paper maps and computer graphics can do alone. Looking forward so much to the next installment!
Anzac Day here today and many people attended the memorial services. So sad that so many lives were lost on both sides. Interesting video thank you.
We are glad you enjoyed the video!
This video was the first time I truly began to understand what happened on the first day.
Glad you got value out of it Sean
This is an interesting and informative video. I particularly like the overhead shots showing the topographical features. I've been to the area three times including trips to Cape Helles and Suvla Bay. I did the trips in the 1990s going before and after the tragic bush fire.
Nicely done my friend. Thanks.
Thank you kindly!
🎶Gallipoli
Left their letters in the sand
Such waste of life, Gallipoli🎶
As an American that hobby-studies English and European history, I can't imagine a more despised man in the ANZAC community that Sir Winston Churchill. Personally, I admire many things about him, but, I doubt there was ever a kind word said about him, after Gallipoli.
Excellent video from BG and Dan Hill. Particularly liked the use of film clips from Anthony Asquith's 1931 film, Tell England.
Glad you enjoyed it
@@BattleGuideVTI Enjoyed it too. As someone that loves history, this channel needs more subs.
We are glad you enjoyed the video!
There is a hope for no more wars. Just Peace.
You never be forgotten Aussies and kiwis soldiers
Outstanding. Thank you.
You're very welcome!
The idea made sense on paper, but war is war.
I made sense by did not work how they what’d it.
It didn't really. British Intelligence had already done an extensive study in 1906 (google British Naval Intelligence Study 1906 and you can read the report for yourself) that predicted, with scary accuracy, what would happen if they tried to force the straits by Sea or Land in the event of war with the Ottomans. This information was well known yet the War Council ignored it ... and nearly everything the study predicted in 1906 happened in 1915.
Really well done. Great visuals. Loved the transitions. Thank you!!
Thank you!
I really like your presentations
Thankyou
My maternal grandfather took part in the later landing at Suvla Bay as a private in the Somerset Light Infantry. He was wounded, losing an eye. Evacuated back to England via a stay in Malta. It's strange to think I'm just two generations from this battle.
Once again Battle Guide has shown that no one does this better. 😍
Interesting. Never knew they got off the beach in the attack. Gallipoli is a good movie but Mel joins the battle later on so the beach is all we see.
It’s brilliant idea that the audience of Turkish commanders voiced by Turkish person, but he is not able to speak fluently, I am here to serve our common history as a voicer for next time :) Amazing job! Appreciated!
Another great tribute documentary 🙏
Great documentary. Just as an aside. I was Alec Campbell s personal assistant up to and on Anzac Day. The last Anzac.
Amazing film making
That is so sad why they do that today in school we learn at school anzac day and we stand still then we give respect to the people who died I hope you rest and peace
It was an amazing video! Helped me out to better understand the assault ♥ By chance, do you have the music used for this video?
The ANZACs were victims of Britain's insatiable ambitions. We Turks only defended our lands, Now they are resting in peace in our country as our boys
Lovely video! Hopefully you will covering the Italian campaign in the mountain ranges as well?
Very well presented 🇦🇺
Thank you
Lest we Forget.
Great video. Great visuals
Much appreciated!
i cannot be more proud from being turk because of words of ataturks about anzacs.
Lets hope nobody dies because of war
Incredible.
Pointless campaign that saw many Australians and New Zealanders die needlessly.
Amazing work! thank you
Thank you too!
I have a great granddad and he was a soldier and his names was Clive (I think that’s how his name was spelled) but if only I knew what he achieved during the war or rather what battle he was in I would be happy knowing who he was with the mates rest in peace Clive
Lest we forget 🌺
Ben Türk'üm. Benim Dedem Çanakkale Savaşına katıldı ve sağ döndü. Evet unutmayacağız ve unutturmayacağız. Biz işgal için gelen herkes ile savaşmaya her zaman hazırız, en zayıf zamanımız da bile.
I really wonder at what Maclagan was thinking - Hamilton’s orders stressed the importance of the Sari Bair ridge, yet this was ignored. Further Maclagan ordered digging in on the SEAWARD edge of Second Ridge, these actions dooming the bridgehead as a stalemate. Keep in mind in the first 24 hours nearly 24000 Anzacs had been landed opposed by a mere 4000 Ottomans.
Did the Allied command have any idea what that terrain looked like once off the beach? That never had any chance of success.
It would be great if you did a video on the Cape Helles landings too.
Wow, that statement by Ataturk nearly brought a tear to my eye. As a Brit i genuinely love both the Australians and the New Zealanders. I have always seen us, Canada and the American splitters (😂) as one big family.
Australasian troops NOT ONLY. Australians BUT. New Zealanders as well, hence the term ANZAC. My Great Grandfather lost a son at Gallipoli.
Correct, but not in the initial landings, that was only Australians, the New Zealanders came ashore later
Yep, that’s what the film has said. Two divisions involved in this landing, the 1st Australian that came ashore first, followed up by the NZ&A Division later that morning. Many of the New Zealanders didn’t complete their landing until the afternoon of that first day.
Let a thousand blossoms bloom
Great respect for the brave ANZACS
I continue to wonder why there wasn’t a concentration landing a bit further north onto the plains where an army could more easily concentrate and utilize artillery. Then having units going into the ridge country to help secure flanks and threaten the enemy from the heights would be a very difficult situation. Is there detail as to why a strategy similar to that wasn’t undertaken?
Your Cologne tank battle video was the best
What was it you particularly liked about it?
@@BattleGuideVT the story. The footage. Just seemed more in depth I guess.
Thanks we always appreciate feedback.
Thank you to the Turks for remembering our soldier. I know the respect the Aussies and the Turks had for each other.
Wonderful historical coverage video about Gelupuli war 1916 was that the British Empire campaign failed to occupy the Gelepoli peninsula ...stubborn, fanatic resistance of Ottoman empire troops rescued military attitude for Ottoman empire favor. I think the campaign ( amphibians mission) failed from the first moment for two reasons 1- firepowers of ANZAC troops was not decisive due to lack of machine guns and artillery covered. 2- Generally amphibians campaigning is not practiced upon previous naval failure results. surprises Eliminate was lost
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! It's awesome to see viewers diving deep into the historical content.
Very good video, very informative with the mappings, one movie I had watched called The Water Diviner with Russell crowe, about him trying to find his three sons after they went off to Gallipoli, the battle scenes took me by surprise in that movie it was quite a brutal fight. Also, I was wondering if you could do a video on fighting and tactics early on in 1914 before trenches were thought up, such as the battle of the frontiers and such, there isn't much for information on that period of the war.
Check out our Mons video. ua-cam.com/video/cN3dibBVHiI/v-deo.html&ab_channel=BattleGuide
Lest We Forget
So glad for the first time that a doco doesn't say it was a bloodbath on the beach, there were supposedly only about 60 Turks on the hills above the Anzac landing. Maps also show that we never landed on the wrong beach, see the doco "Gallipoli from Above by Hugh Dolan"
Also read Hugh Dolan's book '36 Days - The Untold Story Behind the Gallipoli Landings'. What is important to note is that Hugh Dolan had a keen desire to understand the truth surrounding the events of 25th April 1915 which spurned the Anzac tradition as his Great Grandfather was engaged in that event. He says that like many Australians he had been raised to believe that the British had been in control of Australian troops; that the British sent the Australians to the wrong beach; and to a beach that they knew nothing about; and that the British sent the Anzacs to a murderous slaughter in the dawn of 25th April 1915. He had believed the popular rhetoric that was Lions (Anzac troops) were led by Donkeys (British Officers) and that the whole Gallipoli campaign was a bungled operation. He knew, of course, that because the Gallipoli campaign failed to achieve the objective the whole campaign has been severely criticised as being ill-conceived and poorly planned and executed. But he wanted to know if this was correct or even a fair assessment? And, does the evidence support this assessment? Most of the Anzac mythology was created using the diaries of Charles Bean, the Herald newspaper war correspondent. Charles Bean showed in his diaries that he was aware of some of the military intelligence that went into planning the Anzac landing, but he did not include it in his official history: which is the bible of Anzac mythology. That was partly because the military intelligence was kept secret until 1965. The result is that the success or failure of the Anzac landing has been judged on whether it achieved the targets outlined in the original British battle plan prepared by Sir General Ian Hamilton, the commander of the 80,000 Allied forces. Being a serving career military intelligence officer Hugh Dolan understood that knowing the plans for the Anzac landing would be crucial to fully appreciate what actually happened on 25th April 1915. What Hugh Dolan discovered overturned everything he believed and what he had been told could not be further from the truth.
Hugh Dolan concludes his documentary by emphasising these points: 1. The British did not send the Anzacs to Gallipoli to be slaughtered. 2. Anzac casualties were comparatively light. 3. It was not a dawn landing for the Anzacs and the major landing was done under the cover of darkness. 4. The Anzacs landed on the correct beach (‘Z’ beach). 5. The landing was imaginatively planned by Australian Officers and was a successful operation. Hugh Dolan has stressed that if Australians want to properly acknowledge the events of the Anzacs at Gallipoli then they must get the record right and not perpetuates myths that may be popular.
This is what Hugh Dolan has outlined in his documentary mentioned and in his book. Around 5am on 25th April 1915, the Australian Lieutenant General William Birdwood contacted Sir General Ian Hamilton to advise him that 5,500 Anzacs had already landed on ‘Z’ beach - and dawn wasn't until 5.20am. The Anzacs had landed under the cover of darkness. This was before Sir General Ian Hamilton had even commenced his planned British attack which was to commence at 7am after heavy bombardment from the British Naval guns.
By the time the Australian war correspondent Charles Bean landed on ‘Z’ beach shortly after dawn on 25th April 1915, 8,500 Anzacs had already made it to shore.
It is important to note that Sir General Hamilton planned for British troops to land on the southern part of the Gallipoli peninsula and for them to move northwards towards the forts protecting the entrance to the Dardanelles and for the Anzacs to land on the northern part of the Gallipoli peninsula and move southwards to the fort. The Anzacs were to land on beaches between two points - Fisherman’s Hut and Kaba Tepe and the whole sector was called ‘Z’ beach and was five kilometers long. Responsibility for planning the Anzac landing was with the Australian Major General William Bridges. Major General William Bridges was 54 years old and a professional soldier. His headquarters were aboard a converted cruise liner named Minnewaska which was anchored in Limnos Harbour about 2 kilometers from ‘Z’ beach. On 13th April 1915 Major General Bridges gathered his staff to plan the Anzacs landing on ‘Z’ beach. Major Charles Villiers-Stuart was amongst the staff gathered and as Intelligence Officer for Anzac Command it was his job to know everything about ‘Z’ beach. At that time he knew virtually nothing and the only information he had from air recognizance was that there were no Turkish guns protecting ‘Z’ beach which led to the assumption that it was unprotected. Major Charles Villiers-Stuart decided to go and have a look for himself. However, due to the ship’s distance from the shore and the five kilometer length of shoreline he was unable to see into the rocky terrain to determine if there were any guns protecting the beaches. As a consequence the ship was diverted to the island of Tenedos. Tenedos was the base for a squadron of the British Royal Navy Air Service. Commander Charles Samson of the Royal Naval flying Squadron was approached by Major Charles Villiers-Stuart and was asked to fly him over the Gallipoli Peninsula so that he could see what defences the Turks had. On 14th April 1915 Commander Charles Samson flew Major Charles Villiers-Stuart over the Gallipoli Peninsula and in particular the hills and gullies of ‘Z’ beach. What Major Villiers Stuart saw changed everything for him. He was able to see the full extent of the Turkish defences and this concerned him greatly. He sat in the back seat of the two-man biplane with a pair of binoculars and a 1/40,000 scale map. He was able to determine the strength and position of the Turkish forces on the ridges behind Anzac Cove. When Major Villiers-Stuart returned to his headquarters on board ship he studied his sketches and the notes that he gathered from his flight over ‘Z’ beach. He then made an accurate and detailed model of ‘Z’ beach. On this model he showed exactly where Turkish guns and tents for their troops were located. He knew how many Turkish soldiers were assigned to each tent so he was able to establish the number of Turkish soldiers who would be defending ‘Z’ beach and where they would be located. At the subsequent intelligence briefing, Major Villiers-Stuart told his superiors that Sir General Hamilton's assumptions about the northern beaches being relatively unprotected were wrong. ‘Z’ beach was defended by several batteries, barbed wire and entrenchments. Major Villiers-Stuart explained in detail the model he had created and the detailed map he drew of the Turkish defences to Major General Bridges. Major General Bridges became extremely concerned when he realised that his troops were going to get slaughtered by the 32 artillery barrels pointing at them when landing and then running up the beach.
The original Hamilton plan had been for the Anzacs to attack at the same time as the British, about 7am. Major General Bridges then decided on something completely unorthodox and which had not been practised in modern military history. He proposed a plan to have his Anzac troops land differently to the way Sir General Hamilton had planned for his British troops to land. It was Sir General Hamilton’s plan to land his troops at daybreak after heavy bombardment of the hills and shores by the British Naval guns.
In contrast to this, Major General Bridges opted for a surprise landing under the cover of darkness and before any naval bombardment. Major General Bridges’ plan was meticulous and carefully planned right down to the placement of carpet on the decks of the warships to muffle the sound of the men's hobnail boots. Velvet was put around the oarlocks of the rowing boats to also muffle any sound. Major General Bridges sought and gained permission from Sir General Hamilton for his new plan and to change his orders instead of landing and advancing across the Gallipoli peninsula to Maidos on the Dardenelles, his new objective was to land and draw the Turkish forces onto them, giving the British the breathing space to land the main attack in the south. He reasoned to General Hamilton that the naval bombardment would alert the Turks to the imminent landing of troops and as a result they would be fully ready to fire at the landing troops. It must be noted that the British flew 18 photographic missions over the beaches where their troops were going to land. Sir General Hamilton is reported as saying when he saw them that he expected to lose 50% of his troops during the landing.
Unlike the Australian Commanders who altered their plans based on the photographic evidence they had, Sir General Hamilton did not deviate from his original landings plan. (This may raise serious questions but it must be understood that General Hamilton had a large fleet of battle ships at his disposal. He rightly would be expected to use the guns on these ships to bombard the Turkish positions with a view to knocking out as many of their guns as possible and also kill as many of the Turkish soldiers as possible before attempting to land his own troops. He could not use the guns on his battle ships once the landing of his troops was underway).
Hugh Dolan produced a number of aerial maps drawn by Major Villiers-Stuart and they were dated 20th April 1915 in the Major's own handwriting.
Concluding, it appears to me that Hugh Dolan has presented crucial and compelling evidence to completely justify the position he now holds. However, the traditional beliefs had been 50 years in the making before official documents were released and a nation had already been built based on those beliefs. I can't see them being changed now in the way Hugh Dolan believes they should be changed.
@@mikefairsea5898 Well written Mike, Hugh is a friend and a great person to sit and chat with.
@@mark703 Thanks. When you next see Hugh will you please thank him from me for his service to our country. I learnt so much from his book and I get angry when I read denigrating posts based on myth and ignorance.
For information, I honour all people who fight to defend their country. My grandfather and a number of uncles were killed in France during WWI as soldiers of the British armed forces. My father served in WWII with the RAF. My eldest brother did National Service with the RAF and my youngest brother did National Service as a conscript with the Australian Army in 1968. I was called up in 1965 in the first intake of National Service conscription for service in Vietnam. Luckily for me I failed my medical examination. A classmate of mine from school was also called up and we met when we had our medical examinations. He passed his medical, went to Vietnam and was killed at the battle of Long Tan in August 1966 at the age of 21. It shook me as I realised that I could have been alongside him if I had passed my medical. So here I am at 79 years of age having had the opportunity to have lived a long and fulfilling life and having had the opportunity to benefit from the research done by experts.
Don't forget the kiwis. They were there, too.
Indeed, though they didn't land in the opening wave (we cover their involvement in the video).