To sum up, the stages of human action are as follows: 1. simple volition (5:10) 2. intention (5:46) 3. deliberation and consent (6:33) 4. decision - act of the reason (7:02) 5. election - act of the will (7:09) 6. command - performed by the reason (7:20) 7. use - execution of the will (7:26) 8. fruition (8:01) Thank you for the video.
That's right. To fill it out yet further, simple volition is preceded by an a) apprehension of the end and intention is preceded by a b) judgment of attainability. Deliberation and consent are the intellectual and volitional components respectively of that stage. Finally, fruition has both intellectual and volitional components, sometimes called active and passive fruition. You can listen to these lectures for more: 1) soundcloud.com/thomisticinstitute/aquinas-on-the-stages-of-human-action-part-1-fr-james-brent-op & 2) soundcloud.com/thomisticinstitute/aquinas-on-stages-of-human-action-part-2-fr-james-brent-op.
This is a subject I think about a great deal. I have a degenerative illness which makes life very difficult at times, but with the Lord as my goal, I find that I am at peace most of the time, and a joy which does not require riches, lots of friends, parties, constant activity, sexual activity, etc. My life is improving even as my health fails.
Our hearts are restless until it rest unto Thee my Lord and my God! After a long sojourn in different places and all the different types of pleasure the known earth during that time can offer to seek the ultimate truth of what happiness this life can offer! K
Thank you, Father ! I chose to watch the TI discourses frequently, and judge there's been no mistake ! I send something every so often, but you are invaluable !
I think and believe evangelization is highly effective thru social media. This channel is a prime example. Please continue preaching and educating because I'm listening. 😊🙏
choosing my way to true happiness is a great definition of true freedom. Good explanation of interplay of intellect and will in our acts as free agents we must know Truth and go toward it
Thank you for concisely explaining the Steps of Human Action by St. Thomas Aquinas! Prior to watching, I had a great trouble digesting this topic because our learning module horribly translated and explained this topic in our native language. I even had a hard time researching this topic on the internet. After watching and reading the comments, everything became clear :)
Freedom exists not to do what you want but having the right to do what you ought. - Saint Pope John Paul II the stages of human action was such a good explanation. 5:47
I strongly recommend the book Human Action by Ludwig von Mises, and Man, Economy, and State by Murray Rothbard which deduce the entire science of economics from the single axiom of human action.
@@clavdiolizarraga1075 sure! Juan de Marianna is considered one of the best. Juan de Lugo was perhaps the first to combine scarcity and utility in a single theory of value. Martín de Azpilcueta Navarrus was the first economic thinker to state clearly and unequivocally that government price-fixing is a mistake. Luis de Molina is another. Fransisco de Vitoria was the founder of the school of Salamanca but his specialty was more in law. Overall though Jesus Huerta de Soto has an excellent lecture on youtube that he gave to some Spanish priests going more in depth on the achievements of the Spanish scholastics.
There are many obstacles in modern life which block us from wanting to know or do what is true and right. To have discovered this site means you are on the way or may start to be.
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:00 🌟 Human beings are driven by a quest for deeper happiness, not mere fleeting pleasure. 02:25 🤔 Freedom is about choosing the path to true and lasting happiness, not acting impulsively. 03:47 🙌 Freedom is meant to lead us towards the highest and most enjoyable good, not towards license. 06:08 💡 Human acts involve a complex interplay between intellect, will, and choice. 08:18 🤗 Our hearts are engaged in a continuous process of deliberation, decision-making, and reflection. 09:41 🕊️ Knowing the truth about what is truly good is essential for making meaningful and fulfilling choices. 10:10 🤔 The pursuit of the one true good leads us to lasting happiness and fulfillment. Made with HARPA AI
Yes, it does. Although Mises was the first to formulate the Human Action Model in today's Austrian terminology, he actually inherited the concepts in a much more verbose form from Carl Menger, who is generally considered the founder of Austrian Economics. Carl Menger, as well as many other influential social science thinkers of the day, studied under an anthropology professor named Franz Brentano, who is most famous for introducing Scholastic philosophy (of which Thomism had been the core for several centuries), to German speaking academia, which had largely abandoned Scholasticism after the Protestant Reformation.
We're uploading captions to all the videos as we speak. We're through almost the first forty, if that helps. You might also be able to find a free transcription program online for the task. There are currently no plans to share transcripts.
When you help things does it make you feel good? Or do you need something every time? Like money to help people in need. As all your time is precious & you don't like giving promos. Let me know truly what person you are in this subject? When you watch people for a certain time. You get the answer hey?
Why is truth becoming a figment of your imagination? Truth sell set you free. Some people might say when's that?🕵🏻♂️When you get to be on the list to get listen to.🥺😔
Well, now we know that Thomas is basically wrong. All human being's thinking is trapped in a neural network not of their own design. The Brain is God's Design, just like the bee's and bird's brains are also running on God's Design. So human's thinking is trapped in this neural network. Even if we design an AI Machine to think up new ideas for us, that AI design came out of human brains neural networks. So it's finite 'freedom', finite 'liberty' - confined to the design of the homo sapien neural network.
If dogs and other animals deliberate and make free judgments that can go against their instincts, then they need to be held accountable for their actions--judged and punished for misbehavior (e.g. the dog kills the neighbor's beloved cat).
@@lewis72 That's why we have courts and due process for dogs and cats to properly ascertain their moral culpability. And this is why we arrest lions when they viciously tear apart baby antelopes.
@@bestpossibleworld2091 "That's why we have courts and due process for dogs and cats to properly ascertain their moral culpability." - We don't have them. I don't know what made you think that we did. Dogs can not communicate, so how would they even work if we did have them ? You're dumber than I already thought you were. "And this is why we arrest lions when they viciously tear apart baby antelopes." - Again, we don't. You need to educate yourself. Furthermore, why should we ? How is that any different from a Human eating killing an animal to eat ?
To sum up, the stages of human action are as follows:
1. simple volition (5:10)
2. intention (5:46)
3. deliberation and consent (6:33)
4. decision - act of the reason (7:02)
5. election - act of the will (7:09)
6. command - performed by the reason (7:20)
7. use - execution of the will (7:26)
8. fruition (8:01)
Thank you for the video.
That's right. To fill it out yet further, simple volition is preceded by an a) apprehension of the end and intention is preceded by a b) judgment of attainability. Deliberation and consent are the intellectual and volitional components respectively of that stage. Finally, fruition has both intellectual and volitional components, sometimes called active and passive fruition. You can listen to these lectures for more: 1) soundcloud.com/thomisticinstitute/aquinas-on-the-stages-of-human-action-part-1-fr-james-brent-op & 2) soundcloud.com/thomisticinstitute/aquinas-on-stages-of-human-action-part-2-fr-james-brent-op.
Up
@@ThomisticInstitute How do you manage to make a fantastic video even better? 🤩
Thank you, so much
This is a subject I think about a great deal. I have a degenerative illness which makes life very difficult at times, but with the Lord as my goal, I find that I am at peace most of the time, and a joy which does not require riches, lots of friends, parties, constant activity, sexual activity, etc. My life is improving even as my health fails.
Thank you for your witness Teresa!
prayers for you Teresa
Our hearts are restless until it rest unto Thee my Lord and my God! After a long sojourn in different places and all the different types of pleasure the known earth during that time can offer to seek the ultimate truth of what happiness this life can offer! K
Our Hearts are restless until it rest unto Thee my Lord my God! St Augustine Bishop of Hippo 330AD
Thank you very much.
Thank you father Brent..
Thanks to all of you at The Thomistic Institute for all of this fine instruction. During this time of pestilence, God keep you healthy and safe!
It's our pleasure. Health and sanctity to you and yours!
Thank you, Father ! I chose to watch the TI discourses frequently, and judge there's been no mistake ! I send something every so often, but you are invaluable !
Thank you!
Thank you!
May our Lord Jesus Christ bless you!
Thank you Fr. James. God bless you and your ministry..
It's a joy! Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment. May the Lord bless you!
This is incredibly simple and easy to understand.
I think and believe evangelization is highly effective thru social media. This channel is a prime example. Please continue preaching and educating because I'm listening. 😊🙏
Very simple from St Thomas Aquainas to seek Happiness in Life; We should have Compassion in our hearts and Contentment in our mind!
These questions become ever more important the longer you live
choosing my way to true happiness is a great definition of true freedom. Good
explanation of interplay of intellect and will in our acts as free agents
we must know Truth and go toward it
Thank you for concisely explaining the Steps of Human Action by St. Thomas Aquinas! Prior to watching, I had a great trouble digesting this topic because our learning module horribly translated and explained this topic in our native language. I even had a hard time researching this topic on the internet. After watching and reading the comments, everything became clear :)
St. John Bosco Guide, Teacher and Model for Priests ua-cam.com/video/QxnYt9Q3YtI/v-deo.html
Freedom exists not to do what you want but having the right to do what you ought. - Saint Pope John Paul II the stages of human action was such a good explanation. 5:47
profound and perfect for a student. Thanks padres!
Amazing. Thanks.
You're welcome!
I strongly recommend the book Human Action by Ludwig von Mises, and Man, Economy, and State by Murray Rothbard which deduce the entire science of economics from the single axiom of human action.
SIMPLY EXCELLENT!
Cheers, thanks for watching! May the Lord bless you!
This was really good. Wow.
Fr. James is superb!
TO GOD BE THE GLORY....
this is basically proto praxeology right here, truly impressive economic insights for middle age thought
You can trace it back to St. Agostinho, confessions
Well the foundations of Austrian economics were made by Thomists in Spain during the renaissance
@@bradleymarshall5489 woah, can you please provide a few names?
@@clavdiolizarraga1075 sure! Juan de Marianna is considered one of the best. Juan de Lugo was perhaps the first to combine scarcity and utility in a single theory of value. Martín de Azpilcueta Navarrus was the first economic thinker to state clearly and unequivocally that government price-fixing is a mistake. Luis de Molina is another. Fransisco de Vitoria was the founder of the school of Salamanca but his specialty was more in law. Overall though Jesus Huerta de Soto has an excellent lecture on youtube that he gave to some Spanish priests going more in depth on the achievements of the Spanish scholastics.
Why do something as important as this doesn't have many views
There are many obstacles in modern life which block us from wanting to know or do what is true and right. To have discovered this site means you are on the way or may start to be.
Brilliant!!!
Love this!
Cheers!
I found this while researching Mises and his book Human action. Once again Catholicism and Austrian economics cross paths
You should watch their video about reductionism...
Hermoso naguara!🔥
Truth
You never said Who is one one, true Love, he who IS love... and then, of course, there’s baseball ⚾️ Thank-you so much! God bless your lent.🙏🏼✝️💜
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
00:00 🌟 Human beings are driven by a quest for deeper happiness, not mere fleeting pleasure.
02:25 🤔 Freedom is about choosing the path to true and lasting happiness, not acting impulsively.
03:47 🙌 Freedom is meant to lead us towards the highest and most enjoyable good, not towards license.
06:08 💡 Human acts involve a complex interplay between intellect, will, and choice.
08:18 🤗 Our hearts are engaged in a continuous process of deliberation, decision-making, and reflection.
09:41 🕊️ Knowing the truth about what is truly good is essential for making meaningful and fulfilling choices.
10:10 🤔 The pursuit of the one true good leads us to lasting happiness and fulfillment.
Made with HARPA AI
Does this have anything to do with Mises vision of Human Action?
I had the same thought. The type of reasoning seems very similar. A praxeological path to happiness perhaps.
Yes, it does. Although Mises was the first to formulate the Human Action Model in today's Austrian terminology, he actually inherited the concepts in a much more verbose form from Carl Menger, who is generally considered the founder of Austrian Economics. Carl Menger, as well as many other influential social science thinkers of the day, studied under an anthropology professor named Franz Brentano, who is most famous for introducing Scholastic philosophy (of which Thomism had been the core for several centuries), to German speaking academia, which had largely abandoned Scholasticism after the Protestant Reformation.
Freedom goes with it Responsibility without it its license! Without regard to principles! K
Is there a way to find a print version of this talk? Thanks for all you do!!!
We're uploading captions to all the videos as we speak. We're through almost the first forty, if that helps. You might also be able to find a free transcription program online for the task. There are currently no plans to share transcripts.
@@ThomisticInstitute Thanks. I reverted to my old school days, took out a pencil and made some notes. Appreciate you very much.
@@timfairchild4272 Cheers!
Health is the greatest wealth and time is the greatest gift! Gautama Buddha
When you help things does it make you feel good? Or do you need something every time? Like money to help people in need. As all your time is precious & you don't like giving promos. Let me know truly what person you are in this subject? When you watch people for a certain time. You get the answer hey?
I asked forgiveness from GOD...
Why is truth becoming a figment of your imagination? Truth sell set you free. Some people might say when's that?🕵🏻♂️When you get to be on the list to get listen to.🥺😔
Very famous American philosopher stated that" knowing the truth will set you free it is not the truth set you free!"
I don't think there's any coincidence that this bears the title of von Mises' monumental treatise.
Is joking about health a joke to you? Not for me
Well, now we know that Thomas is basically wrong. All human being's thinking is trapped in a neural network not of their own design. The Brain is God's Design, just like the bee's and bird's brains are also running on God's Design. So human's thinking is trapped in this neural network. Even if we design an AI Machine to think up new ideas for us, that AI design came out of human brains neural networks. So it's finite 'freedom', finite 'liberty' - confined to the design of the homo sapien neural network.
1:14
"The animals do not deliberate about what to do or how to do it."
- Where's the proof for this assertion ?
Dogs appear to have some limited use of reason. More research is shedding light on this.
If dogs and other animals deliberate and make free judgments that can go against their instincts, then they need to be held accountable for their actions--judged and punished for misbehavior (e.g. the dog kills the neighbor's beloved cat).
@@bestpossibleworld2091
They are already.
@@lewis72 That's why we have courts and due process for dogs and cats to properly ascertain their moral culpability. And this is why we arrest lions when they viciously tear apart baby antelopes.
@@bestpossibleworld2091
"That's why we have courts and due process for dogs and cats to properly ascertain their moral culpability."
- We don't have them. I don't know what made you think that we did. Dogs can not communicate, so how would they even work if we did have them ?
You're dumber than I already thought you were.
"And this is why we arrest lions when they viciously tear apart baby antelopes."
- Again, we don't. You need to educate yourself.
Furthermore, why should we ? How is that any different from a Human eating killing an animal to eat ?
"Axiom- man acts, lmao bottom text" - Ludwig von Mises