Shamima Begum loses UK citizenship appeal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 лют 2024
- Shamima Begum, the schoolgirl who left the UK to join Islamic State in Syria, has lost the latest round of her legal battle with the Home Office over its decision to remove her British citizenship.
Begum, who was born in the UK and raised in Bethnal Green, east London, was barred from entering the country and had her citizenship stripped in 2019 by Sir Sajid Javid, then home secretary, shortly after she was found by The Times in a refugee camp.
After a special immigration appeals commission (Siac) ruling decided to uphold his decision, her lawyers took the case to the Court of Appeal last year arguing that the Home Office had failed to consider if Begum, now 24, had been groomed or trafficked - an apparent breach of anti-slavery law.
The three judges in the Court of Appeal have now ruled in the Home Office’s favour.
Read the best of our journalism: www.thetimes.co.uk/
Subscribe to The Times and The Sunday Times UA-cam channel: ua-cam.com/users/subscription_...
Find us on Facebook: / timesandsundaytimes
Find us on Twitter: / thetimes
Find us on Instagram: / thetimes
#uk #shamimabegum
Did the Court of Appeal make the right decision?
Let us know in the comments? 👇
yes they did kick her out
Yes COA did make the right decision. She has a husband who is Dutch and an Is*** fighter who is currently in prison. Once he is released he will have the right to come here if she is allowed to return here. Her family who was seeking apologies from all and sundry needs to be returned to Bangladesh.
good as she was 15 yes but her views didnt change she had a chance with the people that went there to help people just like her at that time but they were the people the likes of her killed by ISIS she thought the Manchester bombing was fine she was not 15 then she is not sorry she just wants it easier
An outright YES!
thats another 10000 in uk left
Good grief, the courts have made the right decision for once
Absolutely amazing!!
Imagine one of your family members being groom at the age of 15 to jion isis, then being let down by her school and border police etc, she should have been returned at the 1st opportunity! Your being lead by the media and politicing, no humanity left, what sad world we live in.
Hurrah! At last a turnaround against tyranny.
I’m just as amazed as you!!! I honestly thought they’d let the terrorist supporter back in.
It doesn’t happen often enough !
Terrorism has consequences, go figure. Good riddance!
😂😂😂 véry good decision indeed..
What terrorism did she commit now?
@@chunhaylee She didn't "commit" terrorism. She did support it though. Try and keep up. I know its hard when you're low IQ.
Consequences … Like bombarding Iraq… 😂😂😂
That , should Not even be up for debate . To even consider this appeal is a total waste of time , money and human resources. Absolutely no remorse felt for these delusional human beings . They CANNOT BE TRUSTED period.
Good for the UK. Keep out undesirables.
They made the RIGHT DECISION...100% support for the decision.
She should be in jail. How many people died because of her
@@godbyoneyes in total isolation and only water and dry , old braed
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
Now she's lost appeal. She should be denied any more free legal aid.
She should never receive ANYTHING free from her former country!
@@kittykatz4001 l bet Labour let her back in.
Ah, but the poor solicitors. What will they do? They survive on appeals. Darned parasites.
Brother these are human right wing who advocate them for their wrong deeds ... I don't know what happened with them when sajjad and jawed mercilessly killed two inocent kids in india... I don't know why are they always with terrorists.....
She should honestly be denied the right to oxygen.
I live in Tower Hamlets. We dont want her back here. Safety for UK citizens must come first.
@@Senny_sen The same applies to paletinians who committed crimes on Oct. 7th, they should be banned from going to Western nations.
@Senny_sen Why do you have to bring the Palestinian Israel conflict into this...
It's as simple as this I'm not happy that my UK tax payers money is funding her very expensive appeals for these legal advocates to make money. Including her lawyer Daniel Fermer. I have no sympathy she has dual citizenship so let Bangladesh take her in. The Judge delivered the right decision on this ocasion.
e1 i live there too!!
@@Senny_sen Who are they and what exact "war crimes" have they committed? I bet you don't know.
Agree
She made her choice now live with it!
In the Quran and The Bible it's clear that Jesus is in heaven. But when it comes to Mohammed it's unknown what happened to him after death. So if he is in hell whoever believes him and his religion are going to hell...right. Think Muslims...
Well done ! she is an ungrateful traitor ....
The majority of its Muslim citizens will betray the UK given a chance.
If she wants to appeal again no British tax money should be used to defend her
How many appeals can this thing have?
But how will the poor starving barristers survive on just 3 million a year to drag this farce through the courts.
@@trucker4567 3 more. Supreme Court, then High Court, then European Human Right Court.
Plenty of NGO's that will foot the bill for her. Plenty of NGO's herding thousands of people like her into the UK, Europe and North America.
I thought british tax payer money was only for UK citizens and not for the entire world that isn't? She isn't a UK citizen.
Fabulous decision. Now she has the opportunity to assist in the building of her new land.
We should go further and recognise the Caliphate as a genuine state too.
until you or your children invaribly destroy that new land as well, forgotten the distant and recent history of your race?
which land would that be? Bangladesh? I think that is already built.
Champagne corks popping tonight
The Daily Telegraph reported that Begum had been an "enforcer" in IS's "morality police", and had tried to recruit other young women to join the jihadist group. The report said that she was allowed to carry a Kalashnikov rifle and earned a reputation as a strict enforcer of IS's laws
Why should the long suffering taxpayer keep funding appeal after appeal for this traitor ?, let her supporters foot the bill.
Well done Britain, get more assertive and clean your country from such elements
Excellent news for the people of the UK
If they can remove her citizenship they can remove anyone's. That's not good news.
The Daily Telegraph reported that Begum had been an "enforcer" in IS's "morality police", and had tried to recruit other young women to join the jihadist group. The report said that she was allowed to carry a Kalashnikov rifle and earned a reputation as a strict enforcer of IS's laws
@@j.dunlop8295can she speak Arabic?
@@Afghan31Every islamic people can speak Arabic. Isnt it🤔
They hate you (UK) just because you believe on something different from them. You hate us because you think we steal your jobs, we look different. Throw us out of your country if you want but don't let them takeover your country. They don't believe in freedom, equality, secularism, diversity or human-rights. They know only believe in one law (the S-Law), and their simple formula is just go to other countries to another countries as refugees & immigrants, marry there & increase their population to takeover them. And if you raise your voice against the attrocities they commit on your land they'll label you as an I-phobe & anti M-lings. Please do your own research on whats written in their fantasy book against non-believers. There's global nexus working to takeover the world because as per their book whole world was created by AL for M-lings so its thier duty to claim each & every corner of the world & convert everyone to their cult. In Myanmar, Thailand & Japan its Bu VS Iz, In the west its Ch VS Iz, In India its Hin VS Iz. They're doing the same all around the world. I m not saying just simply believe me just do the research.
SHE SHOULD LOSE HER UK CITIZENSHIP !!!!!!!!!
Well done! This is the perfect decision.
Best news I've heard all day. She should never set foot in the UK again.
yes, we as beacon of human rights and international law would rather arm and fund the genocide by Israel than let this girl back into the country after she went there as a minor helped by double agents working with our intelligence agencies.
Agree. Her whole family should follow her.
Maybe. This seems lenient to me. If she was a citizen when she committed these acts then instead of losing her citizenship and being banned from entry; she should be extradited and tried for treason.
@@santamanone yes. It seems over lenient to me too.
if you think she did all those crimes with criminal intent, The logical thing to do is have her brought in, submit proof, prosecute her.
Lets address the elephant in the room, the reason why you and your country feels so strongly about her is due to the fact that she is a non-white person. Had she been otherwise this whole landscape of the scenario would look much different. She would get ovation on her return. National TVs and newspapers would have portrayed her as an innocent who has fallen victim of ISI terror.
Probably be good for her entire family to move over there and support her.
I agree...they failed her here...
Her parents live now in India ..so she can join them
@@angelamary9493 How nice, she can join them.
@@angelamary9493 no not india ... dont spread fake news
And cousins of cousins
The U.S. needs to learn from this
Germany too!!!!
Agreed. The U.S. needs to learn from this.
About time Britain showed some backbone.
Choose wisely. Shamima did not. Now she’s been held accountable for her decision. Bye bye Shamima
Ba'Bye. Good riddance!
So making a wrong choice at age 15 means banishment for life? Is this Tsarist Russia?
@@glendathegoodwitch6987 she was 15 years old
👋👋👋👋👋 See Ya 👍
She should be happy to live in an Islamic country -- among fellow Muslims, not worrying about mistakenly eating non-Halal foods. Why would she want to live in a liberal non-Islamic democracy like the UK?
Why would any of em?
Democracy lol we wish
@@bobcat2378😂 right
Freebies for ever, probably, en route to making UK an izlamik country?
Yes it's very strange, a mystery.
She has gotten away much to easy for a traitor! 😎
Let this be a lesson about joining a cult.
Definately the right decision, this female knew exactly what she was doing and enjoyed doing it, I hope there are no more appeals, she has cost the tax payer enough already
You are absolutely right, took the words out of my mouth.
No she was a child that was groomed by a Canadian intelligence agent.
of course there will be..her parasite of a lawyer is making millions out of her and will keep going as long as he can..he should be booted out aswell
To be fair she was only 15 that is a child in the eyes of the law, so she would not know what she is doing that age. Don't get me she should not come back to the UK, there is no way she can be trusted.
Just saying it was not her fault from the start.
@@jameswatson5807 British-Israelis are allowed to return after fighting for the IDF, which is committing genocide.
Very perfect judgement.
She should be kicked out.
Dont worry shamiema, your brothers are working hard for Islamic republic of United Kingdom, Soon the day will come muslim sufferings will end in england, And you can return back to your country.
Cheers to Great Brittan from the US!!
Time for all the countries to start enforcing rules to protect their own people and country.
TRUE. But the reality is that European politicians are not interested in the well-being of their own people. If they had been interested in the well-being of Europeans, they would never have allowed the illegal and massive immigration of African and Muslim immigrants into their respective countries. Europe is a colony of the United States. And the United States is under the power of the Israelis. Israelis, fearing the disappearance of the state of Israel, have encouraged the United States to enter wars in the Middle East to destroy potential enemies of the state of Israel. This has generated a large number of refugees and the United States and Israel have decided that all those refugees will go to Europe. Many of the ONG are financed by Jews.
india CAA
Well overdue , sick of seeing it and the B S protests are getting intolerable.
I'm from Bangladesh & I support UK 🇬🇧 Government decision. Extremists have no place In this world.
What about andbakts
@@sawanbarseas long as they dont kill and convert or attack they are fine to go...but for some killing converting and attacking atent crimes crimes are worshiping an idol or a cow . Yeah they woud surely cry
@@arghyadeepdas4125😂 your comment makes me laugh..not at your comment but at you as a human being
@@ShivKamalUpadhaya lol explain ur humour
@@sawanbarse
Andhemomins are the real problem Andhbhakts contribute to the nation's unlike Momin's
Why was a child of 15 allowed to travel out of the country alone? Obviously the parents were aware of her destination.
She stole her older sister’s passport and ran away with friends. I’ve noticed her family isn’t fighting the decision to keep out of the UK. They must not want her back either.
It’s in articles, she used her older sister’s passport without her knowledge.
She stole her older sister's passport.
MUSLIM women are not like our women. They are possessions. Slightly higher than a dog, but not important.
They are married so young. The parents are making usually those deals.
How many £100's millions are our friendly British Muslim Human Rights lawyers going to make off this, from British taxpayers.
It's money well spent, to establish present law, holding future terrorists to their actions!
They are not Brits but unwanted immigrants
@@j.dunlop8295 BS, they fight for them to stay in the UK. Nice try.
@@Travis_22it is important for the law to be properly defined and guidelines in the judgment to clarify what the limitations are, if the legislation is subject to interpretation. This government, and the Tory government of the time could have properly drafted the original legislation but did not. This current Tory government could have tightened the legislation by statutory instrument but it didn’t. It has left the courts to set the parameters of the legislation and its interpretation. To do so you need lawyers on both sides to help set those parameters in case law. To blame human rights lawyers for doing their job is rather ignorant. Blaming the tories for yet again, failing to do their job, is much more appropriate. Time and again, governments do a lazy job in legislation drafting and just hope that it all works out. Just read the 3 .factortame cases and the reasons for these cases being heard and you would know that it could have been avoided if the legislation that brought about the circumstances in those cases was properly written, and/or changed when it became apparent that it needed changing.
The latest legislation that leaves many doors open to court cases and many hours of legal fees is the Rwanda Bill.
The government wastes millions and millions on cases like these. It also wastes billions on other things too so one case where human rights lawyers on legal aid on one side is a drop in the ocean in comparison.
@@amayastrata4629 Cool story, lib.
Absolutely No Appeal! No Ten Year Grace Period!
Keep her out
guess she will just come back in a small boat then.
She'll get a free house when she gets here too.
Yeah our southern borders in the usa. Smh
pretty clear that someone who takes the time and effort to join ISIS is likely to present a risk to national security on return.... its amazing the legal cogs are still turning on this case
but she was not an adult but a child at the time.
she was a minor, less than 18, double agents that were working for our intelligence agencies helped her and her friends to get there
You people hardly know anything about them. They hate you (UK) & everyone else, just because me/you believe on something different from them. You people hate us because you think we steal your jobs & we look different. Throw us out of your country if you want but don't let them takeover your country. They don't believe in freedom, equality, secularism, diversity or human-rights. They only believe in one law (the S-Law), and their simple formula is just go to other countries as refugees & immigrants, marry there & increase their own population to takeover them. And if anyone raise your voice against the attrocities they commit on your land they'll label you as an I-phobe & anti M-lings. Please do your own research on whats written in their fantasy book against non-believers. There's global nexus working to takeover the world because as per their book whole world was created by AL for M-lings so its thier duty to claim each & every corner of the world & convert everyone to their cult. In Myanmar, Thailand & Japan its Bu VS Iz, In the west its Ch VS Iz, In India its Hin VS Iz. They're doing the same thing all around the world. I m not saying just simply believe me but do the research. Please
She was 15. Also, there is no indication that she did any crimes aside from joining ISIS.
@@jameswatson5807 Some 'children" get tried as adults. This occurs if their crimes are particularly heinous and they demonstrated insight and intelligent planning in pursuit of their criminal goals. I would suggest this is what occurred in this situation.
Excellent decision. Traitors should not be given any rights
Like a bad smell that will not go away .
And in the time it's taken to hear these appeals, how many tens-of-thousands of people have entered our country that basically share her views?
We can apparently revoke citizenship but have no real recourse over “legitimate” asylum claims.
Although she is responsible for her own actions. Many a young women fell into this love jihad trap from the west and far east, before they could realise what they were getting into, its game over by then.
On a diff note, this is abt conversions to islam for selfish gains. watch the kerela story trailer. Thousands of indian women were befriended , deceived and made to venture into the caliphate during the time and are lurking in prison now.
Very true .
Agree
And are people like her and even worse than her
Hopefully this will make other young Britons think twice before they decide to go abroad and join any criminal organizations.
No, we want them all to go and not be allowed re-entry.
You presume wrong, God Bless Israel and its beautiful people and damn you and yours.@@mohammedayyaz9056
@@mohammedayyaz9056 All islamic t-e--rorist organizations, hezbollah, al qaeda, isil, isis, PA, huthis and a thousand others.
@@mohammedayyaz9056 Sounds like you're a Hamas supporter.
Wow. Whatever gave you that idea??? But if you're asking I am a Liverpool football fan...
Well done! We need to see this more often.
GB showed some spine against these hurtmongers.
Why does she keep trying, just accept that the door is closed!
Why did UK even spent so much time and money behind her.
Duh.
It's their own law. They have to.
Na Duh, they could have let her rot there. You dont negotiate with terrorists.
It's hardly a negotiation.
They just have to appear to look democratic by going through with the trial.
And whatever money spent on this is pennies compared to other projects anyhow, so no big deal.
It's just a sideshow at best, and a forgettable one at that.
I love stories with a happy ending! Screw her! Traitor!
My faith in our courts and legal system has been restored !!!!!! 😀
Woooh there tiger, one step at a time.
....a little
Until the next case
A long way to go before that is the case .
Really?
Totally the right decision 👏
I disagree. They let her live when they shouldn't, death penalty should have been handed down to her.
her audacity to ask for the citizenship after what she did 🤯🤯🤯
She stays where she chose to move to. She stays where she belongs.
How is she even allowed to request after being refused multiple times. She's a wrongun of the first order.
I left school 40+ years ago. 🤣@@NormanCollier-nf7nu
She is being used as a political football. Sooner or later she will be allowed in, the un wants them back in there own countries of birth
You make your choices and then you live with them. Funny how so many people just don't seem to understand that.
Today Bangladesh is more radicalized country than ever before
How much has that cost the UK taxpayer?
Millions
Always less than what was sent to Ukr.
Why are you British
Certainly , the correct decision,,on the basis of national security for Britain..
Well done.👏
Good Decision. And the UK should support other countries too if they make similar decisions that will benefit protecting their own people.
Absolutely the correct decision. Keep her out of
Nope, correct decision would have been the death penalty.
AND THAT IS WHAT I CALL JUSTICE!!
It's Common flamin sense first , then justice .
There is no justice, she should be in jail if not death sentence for what she did, if there was a a justice, but here, she is only revoked citizenship!! It's ridiculous.
The only injustice is that the decision took so long, forcing the UK public to live in uncertainty all this time. At least justice has finally been done.
Very well done
Best decision
The best news we have had in a while .Who has paid for all this court costs?
You have
The fact that she was even allowed to step foot in the UK and fight a case for citizenship despite being a Jihadan
100% agree with the decision. Thank you for the news. Best regards from California.
YES!!! Marvellous Decision. Made MY DAY 👏👏👏 🫡🫡🙏🙌❤️
Should not be allowed any more appeals.
This decision has to be final.
if you give them a food they will swallow your whole hand
Excellent.
Brilliant
As a child of immigrants and a Canadian citizen I am on the side of the Court here. She forfeited her citizenship. Citizenship is not just a right to all the benefits of a country, you are duty bound to protect your country of Citizenship no matter what. Your country of cultural origin should no longer be a consideration. Too many immigrants don't understand this.
Well done UK!!
first good decision by UK after decades of nonsense
Good! She is not needed in UK
“Ms Begum is the author of her own misfortune” - Exactly right.
Begum is not a family name.
Court should declare the ruling last and final forever.
Great decision.
We need to stop her wasting our money on these legal prceedings
Good call!
Good decision. Bangladesh doesn't want her either.
What a great result
In other words..."No."
YESS
keep her out.
atlast someone doing the right law...
Hurrah!....650,000 to go this year who also shouldn't be here....
Well done. Judgement are absolutely right.
GOOD, GOOD & GOOD!!!!
Good keep her out
Why don't we do the same thing in this country?
I didn't think the UK Government was capable of making a sane decision.
She keeps appealing, how much money and how much more money will be spent to her continuing appeals.
Play stupid games. Win stupid prizes. Looks like this is just the consequences of her own actions. Oh well.
Now you just have to get rid of the rest of them.
Right on!
Well done UK
Thank God, please keep terrorists out!
Take her out...plenty of people agree with me🎉🎉🎉
A rare win for civilization.
We don't need her sort here.
Excellent
This is so awesome.