I'll always support each member, even more now that they have chosen different paths. I know it hurts, and we feel like our world is falling apart, but know that the bright stars in the sky hold our love, and it wont fade. Lets be strong Banas
Is anyone here after the announcement? I’m so heartbroken, I thought b1a4 had it all figured out💔 thank you for being there for me in the early days of kpop when I was just a confused stan. Even if I moved on to other groups, b1a4 was always so special to me 😔
This song made me cry. I used to think if they ever disband one day, they will surely use this song as a farewell song. And months later, jinyoung used the lyrics in this song and posted it on his Instagram after leaving wm entertainment. Gosh it’s just so devastating. I feel like crying again. I can’t love another boy group like how I love B1A4 again. Never ever.. Take my word for it. :( I wish they can perform as 5 again. I love you forever B1A4 😢😢😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️✨✨✨✨
17suki7o i have listened to this song since last year :') and I have learned it by heart :') I performed it and no one knows B1A4 :') that was hurted a lot
Proud to be a BANA, and even though Jinyoung and Baro have chosen to leave their entertainment, they will always be B1A4, no matter what. Let's be strong for them, fighting!
4 people disliked because either they were crying too much and their vision was too blurry to see the difference between the like and dislike button, or they're jealous about the fact the boys have the amount of talent to produce a song like this
Not gonna lie, I cried when I first heard this song and now that I'm finally looking at the lyrics I can see why. One day when they disband and it's gonna happen, but hopefully not soon, this is the song they gave us to remember. To look back on all the fond memories and say it was fun, but all good things must end. I'm glad that even with all the ups and downs they've had, we've been there and shared in their happiness. So that when they go their separate ways, we'll still believe in them and support them. Love you always b1a4~
We thought the exact same thing... while listening to this song and reading the lyrics that is the exact same thought I had... but while reading your comment especially at the " this is the song they gave us to remember. To look back on all the fond memories and say it was fun, but all good things must end. " part, I cried agaaain... TT_TT
Bana Carat and the cruel truth came with jinyoung and Baro leaving wm. :( jinyoung posted the lyrics of this song in his Instagram :( my heart hurts so bad!! I’m sure all banas are devastated
I’m sorry for coming in late .. I was actually quite a fan in secondary school days just that I had to study and all.. but happy to say I’m still their fan and that hasn’t changed
I literally can't stop crying, I was listening to the whole album while making some work and then Together played on and I start crying, and I was like: "Why am I crying? I don´t even know what this song is saying" then I look for the translation and I'm crying even more. God bless this guys for making so beautiful song.
Listening on their 7th anniversary. I’m so happy and proud watching these boys become men. Love the connection between B1A4&BANA both make beautiful music together
I like b1a4. They are so sincere. Love this song. Indeed, they may not be forever as a group as they are growing older with military services coming soon. They will get married and their spouses may have different ideas for them to support and lead their family lives. However, I like what is in the song that " They have the beautiful and valuable memories to treasure." I also like the idea that "We have each other and we are happy. Never mind what others think of us." This song expresses the honest and true feelings of their hearts.
B1A4 made this song for BANA's they also sing with them they mention this on their anniversary in vapp i've been waiting for this song to come out and listening and learning the meaning of this lyrics makes me emotional.
forever bana..ur the best simply kpop boy group b1a4..i love the lyrics,i known im going to cry everytime i play this song,thank jinyoung ur such a good composer
I love this song! I don't know wether to be happy or sad when hearing this song. Its so sweet. Thank you for taking up your time to make this video and adding in the English lyrics ❤
I was lying in my bed watching gongchan crying while singing toether my eyes is red already from crying and I don't have any idea what the song is all about let alone the lyrics and meaning of it,then I searched and saw the English lyrics and cried even harder l feel like someone is squeezing my heart thank you so much my beautiful boys for making this song for us not to mention you record this together with banas, it's wonderful whatever happens in the future you already itched yourselves in our hearts saranghae
Feels trip ssooooong!!! It is so beautifuuul!!! Especially when you know the meaning of the lyriiicss... The music gave me goosebumps and the lyrics brought me to teaarss... Why does it feel like they're saying goodbye?? It saddens me so much to think that B1A4 isn't gonna be there forever... but thank you for this song B1A4, this will be the legacy you leave to us BANAs when the time has come for you to go your separate waaaays TT_TT
![[MV] B1A4 _ A lie(거짓말이야)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/x67c_lYqTQ8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[no0o0datrans] B1A4~ Together (Live Space Concert) [arabic sub]](/img/n.gif)
I'll always support each member, even more now that they have chosen different paths. I know it hurts, and we feel like our world is falling apart, but know that the bright stars in the sky hold our love, and it wont fade.
Lets be strong Banas
Is anyone here after the announcement? I’m so heartbroken, I thought b1a4 had it all figured out💔 thank you for being there for me in the early days of kpop when I was just a confused stan. Even if I moved on to other groups, b1a4 was always so special to me 😔
This song made me cry. I used to think if they ever disband one day, they will surely use this song as a farewell song. And months later, jinyoung used the lyrics in this song and posted it on his Instagram after leaving wm entertainment. Gosh it’s just so devastating. I feel like crying again. I can’t love another boy group like how I love B1A4 again. Never ever.. Take my word for it. :( I wish they can perform as 5 again. I love you forever B1A4 😢😢😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️✨✨✨✨
I cried so much omg. But such sincerity and innocence in a song, it hurts. B1A4 always makes heartfelt music, it's wonderful.
17suki7o i have listened to this song since last year :') and I have learned it by heart :') I performed it and no one knows B1A4 :') that was hurted a lot
I miss B1A4 so much. It’s such a shame they are not together anymore. Always my most precious and favourite Boygroup.
Proud to be a BANA, and even though Jinyoung and Baro have chosen to leave their entertainment, they will always be B1A4, no matter what. Let's be strong for them, fighting!
4 people disliked because either they were crying too much and their vision was too blurry to see the difference between the like and dislike button, or they're jealous about the fact the boys have the amount of talent to produce a song like this
aquareayla or they thought it meant 'dis i like'
Ciara White OMG hahaha, so true
aquareayla that is so true
Not gonna lie, I cried when I first heard this song and now that I'm finally looking at the lyrics I can see why. One day when they disband and it's gonna happen, but hopefully not soon, this is the song they gave us to remember. To look back on all the fond memories and say it was fun, but all good things must end. I'm glad that even with all the ups and downs they've had, we've been there and shared in their happiness. So that when they go their separate ways, we'll still believe in them and support them. Love you always b1a4~
We thought the exact same thing...
while listening to this song and reading the lyrics that is the exact same thought I had...
but while reading your comment especially at the " this is the song they gave us to remember. To look back on all the fond memories and say it was fun, but all good things must end. " part, I cried agaaain...
TT_TT
Bana Carat and the cruel truth came with jinyoung and Baro leaving wm. :( jinyoung posted the lyrics of this song in his Instagram :( my heart hurts so bad!! I’m sure all banas are devastated
I’m sorry for coming in late .. I was actually quite a fan in secondary school days just that I had to study and all.. but happy to say I’m still their fan and that hasn’t changed
I literally can't stop crying, I was listening to the whole album while making some work and then Together played on and I start crying, and I was like: "Why am I crying? I don´t even know what this song is saying" then I look for the translation and I'm crying even more. God bless this guys for making so beautiful song.
Rosa Andrea Paz same 😭💞
Listening to this now is making me cry
Together , no matter what.
Here after the news ... we'll always be together .....
23 April 2011 always being my favorit memory. Yes, nothing ever last forever. Lovely 7 years memory. Just like found my first love
Listening on their 7th anniversary. I’m so happy and proud watching these boys become men. Love the connection between B1A4&BANA both make beautiful music together
I like b1a4. They are so sincere. Love this song. Indeed, they may not be forever as a group as they are growing older with military services coming soon. They will get married and their spouses may have different ideas for them to support and lead their family lives. However, I like what is in the song that " They have the beautiful and valuable memories to treasure." I also like the idea that "We have each other and we are happy. Never mind what others think of us." This song expresses the honest and true feelings of their hearts.
why am i even here? I'm just crying even more 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
B1A4 made this song for BANA's they also sing with them they mention this on their anniversary in vapp i've been waiting for this song to come out and listening and learning the meaning of this lyrics makes me emotional.
This song is so good and it makes me sad. It feels like they are talking to us Banas ;-; the lyrics touches my heart so deep
Quinn Ace me too
This song was recorded with Banas voices
Kammy Kays I didn’t know. Thanks for telling us
And now Jinyoung and Baro has left. Forever B1A4 💕
I miss them 😔😔
forever bana..ur the best simply kpop boy group b1a4..i love the lyrics,i known im going to cry everytime i play this song,thank jinyoung ur such a good composer
A simple but so powerful message in this song.. beautiful
our idols offering a song to their fans. How lucky are we to be their fans?
this song came on shuffle on my drive home and i cried the whole way. couldn’t stop. it’s beautiful and sad and it makes my heart ache
I miss five of them 😭
This song evokes such Studio Ghibli/Totoro feels :')
Favorite song off the album !!!!!
Beautiful song and lyrics.. somehow it bring tears in my eyes.. so proud of this boys.. Thank you for the lyric by the way :)
So.. which banas are here again.. after the news that jinyoung and baro did not renew the contract??
:”/
smash that like button if u got emo at 0:01
This song is beautiful...
i've been loving this song in an album preview. the earcatching voices so rn i know who sang this, BANA. ah it's sweet
i miss them :'(
2021 and still here ❤️. BANA ❤️
Such a beautiful and special song💕
I love this song! I don't know wether to be happy or sad when hearing this song. Its so sweet. Thank you for taking up your time to make this video and adding in the English lyrics ❤
this is my favourite b1a4 song
I was lying in my bed watching gongchan crying while singing toether my eyes is red already from crying and I don't have any idea what the song is all about let alone the lyrics and meaning of it,then I searched and saw the English lyrics and cried even harder l feel like someone is squeezing my heart thank you so much my beautiful boys for making this song for us not to mention you record this together with banas, it's wonderful whatever happens in the future you already itched yourselves in our hearts
saranghae
I'm here again 💔
Feels trip ssooooong!!! It is so beautifuuul!!! Especially when you know the meaning of the lyriiicss...
The music gave me goosebumps and the lyrics brought me to teaarss...
Why does it feel like they're saying goodbye?? It saddens me so much to think that B1A4 isn't gonna be there forever...
but thank you for this song B1A4, this will be the legacy you leave to us BANAs when the time has come for you to go your separate waaaays
TT_TT
Together is such a meaningful song
Cry one's eyes out 😭😭😭 Thank you for your love B1A4 ❤️ BANA
I like this song from their album! Definitely a good love ballad + can be a theme song for a historical love drama lol.
This song is my heart. *_*
This song really moved me. Why am I so emotional today...
I'm crying omg this is so emotional
beautiful music and meaningful lyric.
Goosebumps
Everytime i hear this song, i cry... ㅜㅜ
đối vs mình bài này đỉnh nhất 😭😭😭 ko hiểu nhưng nge đau lòng sao á, #godjinyoung
I heard rumour that this song has BANAs singing in it too, does anyone know if that's true?
yes its true they mention it on their anniversay in vapp
aw yay thats so cute ^^
+Ciara White ikr ! i've been waiting for this after they said it. B1A4 said they where shock because BANA have a nice voice
Geez B1A4.. is that a compliment or an insult? Nah jk, i think the whole situations really sweet
lol no it's a compliment cause they finish it very well
thank you guys
Que música linda.
no wonder why Gongchan was crying in the showcase TT
lunyan I was wondering why he was crying , but after reading the sub iam😢😢,such an amazing song ( sorry for my english)
same (T T) and also this album is amazing
Baro
now i know why they are cryong while singing this :( ahhhh this song is so touching
Could you put this in soundcloud??would appreciate it:))))
😭
Can I have the engsub pls :') i'm a vietnamese but i can sing it in hangul :')
I hear feminine voice
it´s the fans (Bana)