I love the fact The Master is his best film according to you. Yes, it's a polarizing film but it's fucking great. And I completely agree with you about how you felt regarding the movie. I distinctly remember watching it for the first time and being confused and not liking it that much. But there was something about it that stayed with me. Certain scenes, individuals moments, songs, score or the shots. I just didn't know but there was a certain mystique about it and I knew I wanted to revisit the movie. And when I did after almost 3 years, I absolutely loved it and can't wait to watch it over and over again. I think it's PTA's most layered and rich and detailed film to date.
I respect your list. The Master at #1? Respect. 1. Punch-Drunk Love 2. The Master 3. Magnolia 4. Inherent Vice 5. Boogie Nights 6. There Will Be Blood 7. Phantom Thread 8. Hard Eight I'm looking forward to see Licorice Pizza and where it will end up.
PTA is easily one of the best filmmakers of all time. So ranking his movies are damn near impossible but this is what I have at the moment. 1. Boogie Nights 2. There Will Be Blood 3. Magnolia 4. Licorice Pizza 5. Punch Drunk Love 6. Inherent Vice 7. Phantom Thread 8. The Master 9. Hard Eight
Nice work man. You get it. I like how you admit to not “getting” some of his films the first time through. I was that way with Inherent Vice and The Master. But those are the two movies Ive come back to the most. Now I can’t go a month without watching them. When my wife falls asleep and Im still up… I immediately put on a PTA film, knowing I’m going to wake up better for it. Absolutely love his work. Can’t wait to see LP.
My favorite filmmaker of all time. I have the same #8-#9 as you. I think Inherent Vice is by far the most underrated of all of them. I’ve grown to think The Master is his best
Altman and Scorsese are my two favourite filmmakers so I cannot escape the pull of a PTA movie. I try to. I loved Boogie Nights and Hard Eight a great deal. But where Altman had obsessions with joy though character and Scorsese, spiritual struggle, PTA kind of alienates me with the slow creep of his films. He has a dark vibe. Even in Punchdrunk love or Magnolia. Bless him. He's a great filmmaker but I have trouble feeling any optimism after most PTA films.
My list goes: 1. There Will be Blood 2. Phantom Thread 3. The Master 4. Magnolia 5. Punch Drunk Love 6. Boogie Nights 7. Hard Eight Haven't seen Licorice Pizza or Inherent Vice yet, but this is my list as of now
Its always fun doing these rankings with a director that doesn't really make bad films. With how good all these films are, I think the rankings say more about the person making the ranking than the comparative quality of the films, and that's more fun imo.
Fantastic work here. A couple deviations (IMO, IV overrated here while PDL underrated) but your read on PTA's filmography is similar to mine. As the list continued, I was rooting for "Phantom Thread" to be your #1. Doesn't feel like I have much company in saying that's his best.
I'll rank them in tiers: I. There Will Be Blood, Phantom Thread, Magnolia, Punch-Drunk Love II. Inherent Vice, The Master, Boogie Nights III. Hard Eight
Really good video and ranking. I just don't know why Hard 8 gets no love? I absolutely loved it, one of his more simple plots, but just really well done.
I think your list is awesome. I'd put Licorice Pizza number 2 because it was just so fun to watch and I like how cute their love is for one another and how it always brings them back together
Dude!!! Literally what you say about Magnolia is what I tell people all the time. Like , exactly what I say… glad to know I share an opinion with someone
My top 3 and my least favorite were easy to rank but the rest were so hard lol. However, here’s my ranking 😂 1. There Will Be Blood 2. Punch Drunk Love 3. Phantom Thread 4. The Master 5. Magnolia 6. Boogie Nights 7. Inherent Vice 8. Licorice Pizza 9. Hard Eight
I guess everyone has their own PTA preferences. I tend to prefer his more "fun" movies set in 60s/70s SoCal, but that's just me: 1. Boogie Nights 2. Licorice Pizza 3. Magnolia 4. Punch Drunk Love 5. Inherent Vice 6. There Will Be Blood 7. Phantom Thread 8. The Master 9. Hard Eight
9. Hard Eight 8. Magnolia 7. Boogie Nights 6. Inherent Vice 5. There Will Be Blood 4. Licorice Pizza 3. The Master 2. Phantom Thread 1. Punch Drunk Love
Might as well 1: Phantom Thread 2: Punch Drunk Love 3: There Will Be Blood 4: Licorice Pizza 5: Magnolia 6: The Master 7: Boogie Nights 8: Inherent Vice 9: Hard Eight
Great Video! Pretty similar to my ranking 1. There Will Be Blood 2. The Master 3. Phantom Thread 4. Boogie Nights 5. Inherent Vice 6. Licorice Pizza 7. Magnolia 8. Punch Drunk-Love 9. Hard Eight
Haven't thought about what order I'd put them in, but I have the same top 5 - the two with Daniel-Day Lewis, the two with Joaquin Phoenix, and Boogie Nights are the top-tier Anderson imo
I haven’t seen all of these movies. I did watch Licorice Pizza yesterday. It’s a movie I didn’t enjoy. The movie almost felt pointless. It looks great, and the acting is really good. However, the pacing is just so off. The movie has no plot, and like you said, just felt like a series of moments. It went from one point to the next with no sense of time in between.
Finally someone who understands that watching Inherent Vice you need to apply the Tenet philosophy - don't try to understand it, feel it. Nice video, great justifications for the rankings.
I figured you would pick those films as the top 2. Either order is acceptable although my 1 is your 2. On a related note, I know there was always an unspoken competition/comparison between PTA and Tarantino, but even though I’m a big fan of Quentin’s his cannon pales in comparison to PTA’s. QT’s movies overall are more entertaining, but PTA’s films are exponentially more awe-inspiring to me. PTA’s films are more like moving pieces of art.
My list Least to most fav 9. Hard Eight 8. Inherent Vice 7. Punch Drunk Love 6. Magnolia 5. Boogie Nights 4 . Licorice Pizza 3. There Will Be Blood 2. The Master 1. Phantom Thread
I was more than happy with letting Magnolia be number 8 on your list slide. That's more than fair. Where it ranks on your list is where it ranks. But saying the William H. Macy's character could have been cut without losing anything it's just b******* and a 1/2 lol... Not just emotionally and comedically but also thematically as well his character is very important to the totality of that film
There Will be Blood The Master Inherent Vice Boogie Nights Licorice Pizza (only seen it once though) Magnolia Hard Eight Phantom Thread Punch-Drunk Love
1. Magnolia 2. There Will Be Blood 3. The Master 4. Punch-Drunk Love 5. Phantom Thread 6. Boogie Nights 7. Licorice Pizza 8. Inherent Vice 9. Hard Eight
We got the same top 4. 1. The Master 2. There Will Be Blood 3. Phantom Thread 4. Boogie Nights 5. Inherent Vice 6. Punch-Drunk Love 7. Hard Eight 8. Licorice Pizza 9. Magnolia
1. Punch-Drunk Love 2. Phantom Thread 3. The Master 4. Magnolia 5. There will be blood 6. Boogie Nights 7. Licorice Pizza 8. Inherent Vice 9. Hard Eight
My list would be: 1. Magnolia 2. Inherent Vice 3. Boogie Nights 4. Phantom Thread 5. There Will Be Blood 6. Licorice Pizza 7. The Master 8. Punch Drunk Love 9. Hard 8
I suppose it'd be for me... 1) Magnolia 2) Boogie Nights 3) Punch-Drunk Love 4) Inherent Vice 5) The Master 6) Phantom Thread 7) There Will Be Blood 8) Hard Eight Personal preference really, as accomplished as it is I just don't enjoy There Will Be Blood very much.
Great video. I’d stop using the word controversial so much though man. Using it once or twice is fine but using it so much makes it seem like you can’t find other words to use.
1. Magnolia 2. Boogie Nights 3. Punch-Drunk Love 4. There Will Be Blood 5. Inherent Vice 6. Hard Eight 7. The Master still haven't seen Phantom Thread or Licorice Pizza yet!
I agree. The Master is an incredible film. 1. Boogie Nights 2. The Master 3. Magnolia 4. There Will Be Blood 5. Punch Drunk Love 6. Inherent Vice 7. Hard Eight 8. Licorice Pizza 9. Phantom Thread
Oh wow. I 100% concur w your comments on The Master. Nice. Here's my list. I have not seen Licorice Pizza or Hard Eight. 1. The Master 10/10 2. Magnolia 10/10 3. Inherent Vice 9.5/10 4. There Will Be Blood 9/10 5. Boogie Nights 8.5/10 6. Phantom Thread 8/10 7. Punch-Drunk Love 6/10 To be honest, I was concerned about Licorice Pizza based on the trailer, so I was encouraged by your favorable comments. I will get to it asap. I never felt the desire to watch Hard Eight for whatever reason . . I ALWAYS like PTA's movies better upon repeated viewings.
There Will Be Blood is the greatest American film ever made. Yes. I said it, and I'll stand by it until the day I die. I can't wait for Licorice Pizza. 1. TWBB 2. The Master 3. Boogie Nights 4. Magnolia 5. Punch Drunk Love 6. Inherent Vice 7. Phantom Thread 8. Hard Eight
I knoow it's your opinion and all that jazz, but putting Magnolia8th is braindead. My man said the climax of how people were all connected wasn't great, the climax is that they were NOT
great video though! 9- Punch-Drunk Love 8- Hard Eight 7- Inherent Vice 6- Phantom Thread 5- Licorice Pizza 4- Boogie Nights 3- The Master 2- Magnolia 1- There Will Be Blood
There Will Be Blood, Boogie Nights and Punch Drunk Love are my favorite PTA films...Licorice Pizza was such a disappointment. You are spot on that their is no narrative connection to the random scenes. Perhaps the editing could have been better. The trailer is so much more entertaining that the 2 plus hours of this meandering (not even in a good PTA way) movie. Hoffman and Haim are solid actors but other than Alana, there is little depth to any characters. Penn and Cooper make cameo's but their scenes could have been cut to make room for more back story to Gary and his family/friends. It's as if the Cooper and Penn asked PTA if they could be in his next movie and he did them a favor and squeezed them in...both of their characters could have had PTA movies based on them alone. Oh yeah, Alana is 25 and Gary is 15 and that'll stay in your mind the whole time. I did enjoy the cinematography as a kid who grew up in SoCal in the 70s and 80s. All they hype and 5 star ratings are a bit much.
Youch!! Magnolia and hard 8 too low but I enjoyed your video Ok so my list: 1. Magnolia 2. Phantom Thread 3. Boogie Nights 4. There will be Blood 5. Hard Eight 6. Licorice Pizza 7. Punch drunk love 8. The Master 9. Inherent Vice
This list is different from mine and now I am mad 🤬😡
I love the fact The Master is his best film according to you. Yes, it's a polarizing film but it's fucking great. And I completely agree with you about how you felt regarding the movie. I distinctly remember watching it for the first time and being confused and not liking it that much. But there was something about it that stayed with me. Certain scenes, individuals moments, songs, score or the shots. I just didn't know but there was a certain mystique about it and I knew I wanted to revisit the movie. And when I did after almost 3 years, I absolutely loved it and can't wait to watch it over and over again. I think it's PTA's most layered and rich and detailed film to date.
bro, the topics interesting, and your editing style is great! I don't know how you aren't at 100k subs already!
I respect your list. The Master at #1? Respect.
1. Punch-Drunk Love
2. The Master
3. Magnolia
4. Inherent Vice
5. Boogie Nights
6. There Will Be Blood
7. Phantom Thread
8. Hard Eight
I'm looking forward to see Licorice Pizza and where it will end up.
Goofy
@@benrichards8381 what is your list?
mmmmm this feels so wrong
PTA is easily one of the best filmmakers of all time. So ranking his movies are damn near impossible but this is what I have at the moment.
1. Boogie Nights
2. There Will Be Blood
3. Magnolia
4. Licorice Pizza
5. Punch Drunk Love
6. Inherent Vice
7. Phantom Thread
8. The Master
9. Hard Eight
for me, hard eight and inherent vice are very mediocre and are by many miles his worst films
Nice work man. You get it. I like how you admit to not “getting” some of his films the first time through. I was that way with Inherent Vice and The Master. But those are the two movies Ive come back to the most. Now I can’t go a month without watching them. When my wife falls asleep and Im still up… I immediately put on a PTA film, knowing I’m going to wake up better for it. Absolutely love his work. Can’t wait to see LP.
My favorite filmmaker of all time.
I have the same #8-#9 as you. I think Inherent Vice is by far the most underrated of all of them.
I’ve grown to think The Master is his best
1. The Master
2. There Will Be Blood
3. Inherent Vice
@@chadanderson9872 I mean I don’t totally agree but I’m glad someone finally put some respect on Inherent Vice
Altman and Scorsese are my two favourite filmmakers so I cannot escape the pull of a PTA movie. I try to. I loved Boogie Nights and Hard Eight a great deal. But where Altman had obsessions with joy though character and Scorsese, spiritual struggle, PTA kind of alienates me with the slow creep of his films. He has a dark vibe. Even in Punchdrunk love or Magnolia. Bless him. He's a great filmmaker but I have trouble feeling any optimism after most PTA films.
underrated channel, just subscribed bro
My list goes:
1. There Will be Blood
2. Phantom Thread
3. The Master
4. Magnolia
5. Punch Drunk Love
6. Boogie Nights
7. Hard Eight
Haven't seen Licorice Pizza or Inherent Vice yet, but this is my list as of now
My number one PTA: Phantom Thread
Great video, really enjoyed it!
Its always fun doing these rankings with a director that doesn't really make bad films. With how good all these films are, I think the rankings say more about the person making the ranking than the comparative quality of the films, and that's more fun imo.
just found your channel, really underrated
Nice video bro keep up the good work!
Fantastic work here. A couple deviations (IMO, IV overrated here while PDL underrated) but your read on PTA's filmography is similar to mine. As the list continued, I was rooting for "Phantom Thread" to be your #1. Doesn't feel like I have much company in saying that's his best.
Magnolia firmly at #1 for me
SAME
I’m so happy your microphone sounds good holy shit you have no clue how rare that shit is
(Also Magnolia is my number one so how dare you)
MINE TOO I LOVE MAGNOLIA SM
I'll rank them in tiers:
I. There Will Be Blood, Phantom Thread, Magnolia, Punch-Drunk Love
II. Inherent Vice, The Master, Boogie Nights
III. Hard Eight
Great ranking!
Really good video and ranking. I just don't know why Hard 8 gets no love? I absolutely loved it, one of his more simple plots, but just really well done.
really great video
such a solid review.
I think your list is awesome. I'd put Licorice Pizza number 2 because it was just so fun to watch and I like how cute their love is for one another and how it always brings them back together
How is pedophilia cute lmao
Are you okay?
Dude!!! Literally what you say about Magnolia is what I tell people all the time. Like , exactly what I say… glad to know I share an opinion with someone
Great top 3! I am glad you found phantom thread to be a comedy as well. I laugh so hard at that movie...I love it!!!!
My top 3 and my least favorite were easy to rank but the rest were so hard lol. However, here’s my ranking 😂
1. There Will Be Blood
2. Punch Drunk Love
3. Phantom Thread
4. The Master
5. Magnolia
6. Boogie Nights
7. Inherent Vice
8. Licorice Pizza
9. Hard Eight
I guess everyone has their own PTA preferences. I tend to prefer his more "fun" movies set in 60s/70s SoCal, but that's just me:
1. Boogie Nights
2. Licorice Pizza
3. Magnolia
4. Punch Drunk Love
5. Inherent Vice
6. There Will Be Blood
7. Phantom Thread
8. The Master
9. Hard Eight
9. Hard Eight
8. Magnolia
7. Boogie Nights
6. Inherent Vice
5. There Will Be Blood
4. Licorice Pizza
3. The Master
2. Phantom Thread
1. Punch Drunk Love
Might as well
1: Phantom Thread
2: Punch Drunk Love
3: There Will Be Blood
4: Licorice Pizza
5: Magnolia
6: The Master
7: Boogie Nights
8: Inherent Vice
9: Hard Eight
Great Video! Pretty similar to my ranking
1. There Will Be Blood
2. The Master
3. Phantom Thread
4. Boogie Nights
5. Inherent Vice
6. Licorice Pizza
7. Magnolia
8. Punch Drunk-Love
9. Hard Eight
Haven't thought about what order I'd put them in, but I have the same top 5 - the two with Daniel-Day Lewis, the two with Joaquin Phoenix, and Boogie Nights are the top-tier Anderson imo
I haven’t seen all of these movies. I did watch Licorice Pizza yesterday. It’s a movie I didn’t enjoy. The movie almost felt pointless. It looks great, and the acting is really good. However, the pacing is just so off. The movie has no plot, and like you said, just felt like a series of moments.
It went from one point to the next with no sense of time in between.
Yea UA-cam!
Finally someone who understands that watching Inherent Vice you need to apply the Tenet philosophy - don't try to understand it, feel it.
Nice video, great justifications for the rankings.
I'm offended that you brought up Tenet when describing a PTA film
Tenet was very easy to understand. They literally take the time to have like 4 separate characters explain it to you in great detail.
Hard eight is his most accessible film.
I figured you would pick those films as the top 2. Either order is acceptable although my 1 is your 2.
On a related note, I know there was always an unspoken competition/comparison between PTA and Tarantino, but even though I’m a big fan of Quentin’s his cannon pales in comparison to PTA’s. QT’s movies overall are more entertaining, but PTA’s films are exponentially more awe-inspiring to me. PTA’s films are more like moving pieces of art.
My list
Least to most fav
9. Hard Eight
8. Inherent Vice
7. Punch Drunk Love
6. Magnolia
5. Boogie Nights
4 . Licorice Pizza
3. There Will Be Blood
2. The Master
1. Phantom Thread
I was more than happy with letting Magnolia be number 8 on your list slide. That's more than fair. Where it ranks on your list is where it ranks.
But saying the William H. Macy's character could have been cut without losing anything it's just b******* and a 1/2 lol... Not just emotionally and comedically but also thematically as well his character is very important to the totality of that film
There Will be Blood
The Master
Inherent Vice
Boogie Nights
Licorice Pizza (only seen it once though)
Magnolia
Hard Eight
Phantom Thread
Punch-Drunk Love
Your top 2 are definitely correct. #3 is a bit harder. Maybe Phantom Thread but maybe Punch Drunk Love. I don't know.
For me the best is phantom thread, and I did not like #1 & 2
Did anyone feel like PDL was 5 minutes? It pulled me in so much that the hour and a half went by so quickly.
Bold take, Cotton
Here's mine:
1 - There Will Be Blood
2 - Magnolia
3 - Boogie Nights
4 - Phantom Thread
5 - Licorice Pizza
6 - The Master
7 - Punch-Drunk Love
8 - Inherent Vice
9 - Hard Eight
1. Magnolia
2. There Will Be Blood
3. The Master
4. Punch-Drunk Love
5. Phantom Thread
6. Boogie Nights
7. Licorice Pizza
8. Inherent Vice
9. Hard Eight
The best part of licorice pizza is the cute love story
We got the same top 4.
1. The Master
2. There Will Be Blood
3. Phantom Thread
4. Boogie Nights
5. Inherent Vice
6. Punch-Drunk Love
7. Hard Eight
8. Licorice Pizza
9. Magnolia
1. Punch-Drunk Love
2. Phantom Thread
3. The Master
4. Magnolia
5. There will be blood
6. Boogie Nights
7. Licorice Pizza
8. Inherent Vice
9. Hard Eight
Based the master at 1
My list would be:
1. Magnolia
2. Inherent Vice
3. Boogie Nights
4. Phantom Thread
5. There Will Be Blood
6. Licorice Pizza
7. The Master
8. Punch Drunk Love
9. Hard 8
I suppose it'd be for me...
1) Magnolia
2) Boogie Nights
3) Punch-Drunk Love
4) Inherent Vice
5) The Master
6) Phantom Thread
7) There Will Be Blood
8) Hard Eight
Personal preference really, as accomplished as it is I just don't enjoy There Will Be Blood very much.
im glad someone else has magnolia at the top spot!!
Please do the same for Quentin Tarantino
I will just switch boogie nights with Punch drunk love. And the master with Phantom thread
Great video. I’d stop using the word controversial so much though man. Using it once or twice is fine but using it so much makes it seem like you can’t find other words to use.
1. Magnolia
2. Boogie Nights
3. Punch-Drunk Love
4. There Will Be Blood
5. Inherent Vice
6. Hard Eight
7. The Master
still haven't seen Phantom Thread or Licorice Pizza yet!
Yes! The Master #1. So good. So fucking good. Best movie of the 21st century imho. There will be blood might be Number 2 haha.
youtube
I agree. The Master is an incredible film.
1. Boogie Nights
2. The Master
3. Magnolia
4. There Will Be Blood
5. Punch Drunk Love
6. Inherent Vice
7. Hard Eight
8. Licorice Pizza
9. Phantom Thread
There Will Be Blood is #1 for me!!! I think it's the best movie of the 21st century.
Oh wow. I 100% concur w your comments on The Master. Nice.
Here's my list.
I have not seen Licorice Pizza or Hard Eight.
1. The Master 10/10
2. Magnolia 10/10
3. Inherent Vice 9.5/10
4. There Will Be Blood 9/10
5. Boogie Nights 8.5/10
6. Phantom Thread 8/10
7. Punch-Drunk Love 6/10
To be honest, I was concerned about Licorice Pizza based on the trailer, so I was encouraged by your favorable comments. I will get to it asap.
I never felt the desire to watch Hard Eight for whatever reason . .
I ALWAYS like PTA's movies better upon repeated viewings.
Did you ever get a chance to watch Licorice Pizza?
1. There Will Be Blood
2. Punch-Drunk Love
3. The Master
4. Boogie Nights
5. Phantom Thread
There Will Be Blood is the greatest American film ever made. Yes. I said it, and I'll stand by it until the day I die. I can't wait for Licorice Pizza.
1. TWBB
2. The Master
3. Boogie Nights
4. Magnolia
5. Punch Drunk Love
6. Inherent Vice
7. Phantom Thread
8. Hard Eight
I knoow it's your opinion and all that jazz, but putting Magnolia8th is braindead. My man said the climax of how people were all connected wasn't great, the climax is that they were NOT
great video though!
9- Punch-Drunk Love
8- Hard Eight
7- Inherent Vice
6- Phantom Thread
5- Licorice Pizza
4- Boogie Nights
3- The Master
2- Magnolia
1- There Will Be Blood
The Master doesn’t scream “fun” movie to me.
There Will Be Blood, Boogie Nights and Punch Drunk Love are my favorite PTA films...Licorice Pizza was such a disappointment. You are spot on that their is no narrative connection to the random scenes. Perhaps the editing could have been better. The trailer is so much more entertaining that the 2 plus hours of this meandering (not even in a good PTA way) movie. Hoffman and Haim are solid actors but other than Alana, there is little depth to any characters. Penn and Cooper make cameo's but their scenes could have been cut to make room for more back story to Gary and his family/friends. It's as if the Cooper and Penn asked PTA if they could be in his next movie and he did them a favor and squeezed them in...both of their characters could have had PTA movies based on them alone. Oh yeah, Alana is 25 and Gary is 15 and that'll stay in your mind the whole time. I did enjoy the cinematography as a kid who grew up in SoCal in the 70s and 80s. All they hype and 5 star ratings are a bit much.
Youch!! Magnolia and hard 8 too low but I enjoyed your video
Ok so my list:
1. Magnolia
2. Phantom Thread
3. Boogie Nights
4. There will be Blood
5. Hard Eight
6. Licorice Pizza
7. Punch drunk love
8. The Master
9. Inherent Vice
LP is terrible it was like watching a David O Russel film.
Licorice pizza is a trash movie