If they want to have more ball in play time, stop the clock when the ball is in touch, after tries, during penalty kicks, when setting up for a scrum, etc.
John Bull Hayes as a prop could easily go the whole 80 minutes and he spent most of career pre current substitution rules. Helps he was naturally built larger (started out as a lock) but only needed to bulk up a bit to become a loosehead prop. I think modern centres are glorified flankers weight wise and need to come down in weight to be high 70’s to mid 80’s in weight. Most of the complaining about the scrum comes from Kiwis and to a lesser extent Aussies. Wildkard rightly called out John Kirwan last season for complaining about the scrum. And I say that as a back scrums actually tend to take 20-40 seconds.
Funny how people are against 20min red cards but it wasn't that long ago where red cards were only for deliberate grub plays/tackles. The 20min red won't reward that... in fact that can still be called a red. 20min red is for the guy who did deliberately tackle the guy but poor technique lead to it. Imo Sam Cane Rugby World cup card would've been a 20min red. He doesn't return but he has a replacement come in.
130kg boys coming down to 110? I dont think so..but would it be a plus in their personal health..yes definitely, does it look like even 15s gets more agility driven..maybe
If they want more ball in play and ball in hand - take away the reliance on penalties. Lower the points and/or stop allowing them for every error. Then teams won't play for them like they do now.
I think they need to lose the rule where it's a penalty & yellow card for a failed, reflexive attempt at an intercept. If it's a cynical knockdown then ok, otherwise no penalty.
I don't agree. There are players, mostly wingers who do gamble already. I think it's fair. Don't be too greedy and kill momentum for a team. Rugby set defenses are already hard. That will just encourage poor behavior
If they want to have more ball in play time, stop the clock when the ball is in touch, after tries, during penalty kicks, when setting up for a scrum, etc.
Yeah, give lazy players more excuses to take a breather. Great idea 😐
That would result in matches taking longer.
John Bull Hayes as a prop could easily go the whole 80 minutes and he spent most of career pre current substitution rules. Helps he was naturally built larger (started out as a lock) but only needed to bulk up a bit to become a loosehead prop.
I think modern centres are glorified flankers weight wise and need to come down in weight to be high 70’s to mid 80’s in weight.
Most of the complaining about the scrum comes from Kiwis and to a lesser extent Aussies. Wildkard rightly called out John Kirwan last season for complaining about the scrum. And I say that as a back scrums actually tend to take 20-40 seconds.
great update mate
Which end of year tests you watching g
Nah g 20 min red card bad gotta teach people to tackle
Funny how people are against 20min red cards but it wasn't that long ago where red cards were only for deliberate grub plays/tackles. The 20min red won't reward that... in fact that can still be called a red. 20min red is for the guy who did deliberately tackle the guy but poor technique lead to it. Imo Sam Cane Rugby World cup card would've been a 20min red. He doesn't return but he has a replacement come in.
130kg boys coming down to 110? I dont think so..but would it be a plus in their personal health..yes definitely, does it look like even 15s gets more agility driven..maybe
it's perfectly valid for the team that doesn't have the put-in to focus on defence. this rule needs to change back
But 30 seconds is a long time 🤨
I am already starting to lose faith in Rugby Union ! Officiating , WRU !
If they want more ball in play and ball in hand - take away the reliance on penalties. Lower the points and/or stop allowing them for every error. Then teams won't play for them like they do now.
30 seconds for a scrum has been in law forever. Nothing changing there!
if world rugby keep changing laws to sideline specific styles I will soon stop watching rugby.
1st comment
I think we'll come to regret the game speeding up to much. Let attack coaches do their thing, they don't need help
I think they need to lose the rule where it's a penalty & yellow card for a failed, reflexive attempt at an intercept.
If it's a cynical knockdown then ok, otherwise no penalty.
I agree, it is hurting creativity
I don't agree. There are players, mostly wingers who do gamble already. I think it's fair. Don't be too greedy and kill momentum for a team. Rugby set defenses are already hard. That will just encourage poor behavior
Call for every CLUB to reject NEW rules....Keep Rugby Union the same...