When Nathan confronts her at the school that was a fabulous bit of acting on the part of Kevin McGarry and Erin Krakow. He conveys his weariness with trying to win her heart and also the fear that he may be permanently losing her this time. She shows how upset she is with leaving him, her career and the town she has come to love. I think it finally hits her that this is her last chance to make the choice to be with Nathan. Her relationship with Lucas no longer feels safe, it feels like a trap she has contrived for all three of them. This heartbreaking scene may be the best piece of acting I have seen on this show.
They both fought for the other to stay knowing they would be happy in Hope Valley. ❤️ I’m excited to see their story unfold. Thank you for watching and commenting.
Perfection! This is so powerful the way you've woven those scenes together. Nathan + Elizabeth just can't seem to let each other go! Bring on the fight for love. #GrantonEra
I’m so glad i found your channel!’ Your videos are amazing!! Speaking of “staying” …i just pray that Kevin McGarry has made a long term commitment to WCTH. We can NOT lose another Mountie!!
Well thank you for your kind words. I really appreciate that. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed the videos. I’m sure as they started going down this path they had conversations about commitment to the series knowing killing off another Mountie would be quite catastrophic for the show.
If he does leave WCTH, Elizabeth will probably go with him. No, she didn't go with Lucas, but looks like she didn't love Lucas as she thought she did, and Nathan is the one she loves, which is why I say she would probably go with him. But that's just me.
Esse vídeo ficou tão perfeito , que sempre volto a assistir, como vc juntou as cenas do antes com o depois qdo Elizabeth pensa em sair de HV e Nathan a confronta também! O olhar de Nathan para Elizabeth qdo ele pergunta " o que vc quer ? " Doeu no coração ❤❤❤👏👏👏
@LucyRosinina-ek2mi I guess if you look at this strictly as a Nathan vs Lucas and which of these men YOU prefer, we could all find something about either of these regarding their character which would appeal to us, or not. I love both of these guys. Each brings to the story of Hope Valley something good though different in the way they bring it. As for the story of Elizabeth, the main character, the question is, which one suits HER priorities. She left the city to come to a pioneer home. She left wealth and handsome wealthy “suitable” men to come to Hope Valley to live a more simple life contributing to the life of a small town. When he spoke to Elizabeth (remember they had remained close friends), though he may have had underlying feelings of love, he asked her what SHE wanted. She had already poured her heart out to him about why she loved Hope Valley and the details that made it so. He had seen the trepidation on her face while everyone is jubilant around her and Lucas. He was sensitive to her feelings, thus the question, “What do you want?” He apologized later and as Elizabeth said, “You were just trying to help,” Like I said, I love Lucas’s character, but he missed some very significant clues about where Elizabeth’s heart is. She moved away from wealth and preferred the simplicity of Hope Valley living in her simple home next to her friend. He tried to buy her a grand house (out of his desire to please her, which is a good thing. It just wasn’t what she wanted). He wants to make his mark on the world, seeking business, more wealth, etc ( he had a good heart for what and how he would use the money for. I am sure he would have continued to help people) but seeking all these things is the world Elizabeth had left. I have seen many Lucas fans say that Nathan is boring. But then, Elizabeth must be boring too because they both want similar things and they both are keenly aware of what means the most to each other. And they are friends and friends sometimes will make you face your fears or make you face the truth which is what he did with Elizabeth. If they had written Lucas as wanting the same things Elizabeth has shown she desires in her heart, I may have been firmly in Lucas’s corner right now making the same case for him. I like both these guys and they could have written either one suitable to her.
I don't see where Lucas wanting to build a nicer house was any different than Jack who also bought land & lumber & the land wasn't in town. Also, Lucas has said many, many times he wants to raise a family in HV. Lucas donated the building for the towns library, took Elizabeth to Virginia Wolfe's book reading, took her on an air balloon ride, went horseback riding, had a picnic by the pond, encouraged the writing of her book, gave her a birthday party in her home, etc, all things Nathan could do, but couldn't even get her to dinner. Yes, Lucas did other things for the town like the Christmas Festival, town dinner & these were appreciated. And I'm sorry, but Nathan is boring. He doesn't like Christmas crowds & he himself said he doesn't really like fishing. Hopefully he'll play with Little Jack.....guess you'll have to wait & see.
The problem is the "Lucas"that has been presented in season 8,the writers changed his character to make him fit Elisabeth.He was not ready for a family in Season 7,he said it himself,all of the sudden he want to marry a single mother in season 8,he had an adventurous side and all of the sudden,Hope Valley is everything for him,no consistency in the character.Same stuff with Elisabeth,in Season 8,she was like a school girl who has her first crush,Little Jack is sick she left him to go for a ride with Lucas,she wore a dress for a diner with him,she says she doesn't feel herself but she still goes,things that would have bothered her where now acceptable.Lucas was a bit manipulative in its approach towards Elisabeth: he sent her manuscript without her permission,she get mad and he said this is what she wanted; he made her believe he knew Virginia wolf's books although he has never read one ,he organized dates in disguise when she says she doesn't want a date,constantly pushing her boundaries.The real Elizabeth would have said no to Lucas in Season 8. If Nathan doesn't really like fishing i don't see where is the problem,it means he is willing to do something he doesn't like to please another person,he can sacrifice himself and find a compromise.And i don't think Elisabeth loves it either.Nathan and Elisabeth sees eye to eye where it matters to build a long lasting relationship.In a couple people sometimes love different things:one love summer,the other winter,one the soccer,the other hate it...that doesn't mean they are not meant for each other.I also think the character of Nathan is like an onion with a lot of layers and there is a lot to discover about him,who knew for example he could draw,in the first episode of the 10th season,he drew a dog on a paper because he wanted to pass an advertisement for adoption. We will see how the writers will approach things.@sharonnorton2708.
Well said! Her Heart what it truly wants Simple life in Hope Valley!! Elizabeth is just that...each person has a calling and Lucas has that calling for politics- is a good man and heart for making a differencetoo..However both Nathan and Elizabeth has same calling, noble one, to serve and protect & also make a difference in a community- Hope Valley is the lucky recipient!!Core and wholesome story of The Book! Teacher & the Mountie!
I honestly chose Lucas back in season 8. However, they had a lot of romance, but she has never allowed him to have any depth with her. They have often stayed on the surface. Never really getting into difficult topics. She definitely loves him, but won't let him fully in. Going back and rewatching scenes, I think she was actually afraid of having another great love, because she might lose it. She thinks that Nathan would become a great love, so she pushed him away. I don't think he is a great love yet, she just sees that he can be. She has a deep friendship with Nathan, but never allowed him in enough for romance. He carried a heaviness towards her because of his guilt. Once he confessed that Jack took his place, their relationship became so much closer and the negative tension was worked through and gone. She really hasn't let anyone in the way that she let Jack in. Not yet. I think she will find depth with Nathan. The simple things actually can become very romantic with your best friend, when you fully let them get close to you. They have a really solid foundation. Now they can explore romance. Hopefully they will do a good job portraying that though. They have to be able to move past this early connection and turn it into something deeper. Also, Elizabeth never let Nathan in enough to romance her, yet. So it can still be really sweet going forward.
Thank you for taking the time to watch my video. I appreciate it. I hope by the end of the new season, you'll be pleased with story of N&E growing together. The promos I seen so far look like it will be a very sweet story.
Loved the 2 videos! Brilliantly done. They just show how deeply Nathan and Elizabeth care for each other. So excited for season 12!!! Truly hope there will be a wedding for Nathan and Elizabeth!!!!!!!🎉❤
Don't know much about this show it looks like it's kinda good, and props on the background music .... Zombie by The Cranberries sounds like someone is playing a violin playing
Lucas in an interview stated 😂 He would not be returning for Elizabeth He will return occasionally for Governor duties Bill and Rosemary are lookin😢in white collar crimes
I don't like Lucas, think he might be the one who sent Hargraves, so it would possibly cause problems between Nathan and Elizabeth, but I don't think that scheme will work because Bill, along with Rosemary to get to the bottom of why he was there. Elizabeth told Lucas she was going to the wedding with Nathan and Lucas had the power of governor to try and cause trouble.
This scene is from s10 episode 11. Nathan is walking up to town after going on rounds with Bill. He sees Elizabeth and notices her reaction to the raising of the campaign banner ( @:56 seconds)
Not nice what Nathan is doing here. Begging an engaged woman to stay , Going behind Lucas’back . Just imagine if Lucas did that,But he is a man of honor,he would never do that .
@@cherijohnson5137 It is what it is ,nothing we can do about it . I’m so excited for Lucas’ storyline that I don’t care about what was with E .We have to move on. By the way no one talks about Henry’s visit to Abigail.Thats telling me we won’t see Lori.
I disliked this scene and in fact I didn't like season 10 and don't like how season 11 looks like and going forward with what they are doing to Elizabeth. It has become a soap drama and no longer a well written story. The only way fans will be happy is that they have somebody like Jack Thornton and not Nathan.
![Nathan + Elizabeth [WCTH] "not for a single second."](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vOAk_5J7TkY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Nathan + Elizabeth [WCTH] "not for a single second."](/img/tr.png)
![Elizabeth [WCTH] "The Hero"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JG26bBrGtzs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Elizabeth + Nathan [WCTH] "Steadfast"](/img/n.gif)
When Nathan confronts her at the school that was a fabulous bit of acting on the part of Kevin McGarry and Erin Krakow. He conveys his weariness with trying to win her heart and also the fear that he may be permanently losing her this time. She shows how upset she is with leaving him, her career and the town she has come to love. I think it finally hits her that this is her last chance to make the choice to be with Nathan. Her relationship with Lucas no longer feels safe, it feels like a trap she has contrived for all three of them. This heartbreaking scene may be the best piece of acting I have seen on this show.
That was an amazing scene between them. Thank you for watching and commenting ❤️
👍 💕
Well said, I agree!
beautifully done
Thank you 😊 I really appreciate it.
Beautiful!
Thank you! ❤
This is beautiful. Really cool to see how you put those two different scenes from different seasons together- brilliantly done. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you. So glad you enjoy it ❤️
Nathan and Elizabeth have always loved one another. Let the love between them finally blossom!
Thank you for watching and commenting on my video. Can’t wait to see what’s next for Nathan and Elizabeth. ❤️
Oh lovely seeing the two scenes just brilliant.They have gone full circle.Now its time for their love story.❤
They both fought for the other to stay knowing they would be happy in Hope Valley. ❤️ I’m excited to see their story unfold. Thank you for watching and commenting.
Perfection! This is so powerful the way you've woven those scenes together. Nathan + Elizabeth just can't seem to let each other go! Bring on the fight for love. #GrantonEra
Thank you! So many beautiful and powerful scenes between the two of them. ❤️
Perfeito! Que venha a luta pelo amor. E no final o amor vença. ❤❤❤
Espero que venha o próximo seriado logo .
Sou sua. Fã.
Elizabeth;justtell. me.
I’m so glad i found your channel!’ Your videos are amazing!! Speaking of “staying” …i just pray that Kevin McGarry has made a long term commitment to WCTH.
We can NOT lose another Mountie!!
Well thank you for your kind words. I really appreciate that. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed the videos. I’m sure as they started going down this path they had conversations about commitment to the series knowing killing off another Mountie would be quite catastrophic for the show.
If he does leave WCTH, Elizabeth will probably go with him. No, she didn't go with Lucas, but looks like she didn't love Lucas as she thought she did, and Nathan is the one she loves, which is why I say she would probably go with him. But that's just me.
This is so good! I loved the editing between the 2 pivotable & very similar scenes wth nathan and elizabeth.
Thank you. So glad you enjoyed it.
Awesome editing! Thank you! Perfect love casts out all fear!
Thank you 😊
AMEN!
I never realized the parallel with these scenes- such a great edit!
Absolutely beautiful! Sets the stage perfectly going forward! Thank you for sharing your amazing gift with us!
Thank you so much. Glad you enjoyed it ❤️
Beautiful ❤️. I love the parallels.
Thank you ❤️
Simplesmente fantástico parabéns a série é os roteiristas explendindo Nathan e Elizabeth juntos fantástico
Love 💘 ❤️ this video . I believe this is the 😔 part 😢😢 especially Allie not want to leave Hope Valley 🙏 😔 ❤
Beautifully thought out. Really showcases how much they belong together. You got the good parts too! ❤️
Thank you so much. ❤️ I really wanted to show how tied together their story has been over the years.
So beautiful! You are incredibly talented!
Casal perfeito, Eles se completam, são 2 excelentes atores. Parabéns!
This is brilliant! Well, done!
Thank you 😊
Well cool you're posting your videos here too!
Esse paralelo ficou incrível ❤❤❤❤❤
Nathan e Elizabeth vai ser UMA família linda com as crianças
Esse vídeo ficou tão perfeito , que sempre volto a assistir, como vc juntou as cenas do antes com o depois qdo Elizabeth pensa em sair de HV e Nathan a confronta também! O olhar de Nathan para Elizabeth qdo ele pergunta " o que vc quer ? " Doeu no coração ❤❤❤👏👏👏
This is perfect 😍
Thank you very much ☺️
This is so beautiful!
Thank you very much 😊 and thank you for your support ❤️☺️
Amo essa série
Awwww. ❤❤❤
Dar pra ver o quanto se amam mas Elizabeth precisa se libertar do .
Medo e dizer sim para o Nathan
@LucyRosinina-ek2mi I guess if you look at this strictly as a Nathan vs Lucas and which of these men YOU prefer, we could all find something about either of these regarding their character which would appeal to us, or not. I love both of these guys. Each brings to the story of Hope Valley something good though different in the way they bring it. As for the story of Elizabeth, the main character, the question is, which one suits HER priorities. She left the city to come to a pioneer home. She left wealth and handsome wealthy “suitable” men to come to Hope Valley to live a more simple life contributing to the life of a small town.
When he spoke to Elizabeth (remember they had remained close friends), though he may have had underlying feelings of love, he asked her what SHE wanted. She had already poured her heart out to him about why she loved Hope Valley and the details that made it so. He had seen the trepidation on her face while everyone is jubilant around her and Lucas. He was sensitive to her feelings, thus the question, “What do you want?” He apologized later and as Elizabeth said, “You were just trying to help,”
Like I said, I love Lucas’s character, but he missed some very significant clues about where Elizabeth’s heart is. She moved away from wealth and preferred the simplicity of Hope Valley living in her simple home next to her friend. He tried to buy her a grand house (out of his desire to please her, which is a good thing. It just wasn’t what she wanted). He wants to make his mark on the world, seeking business, more wealth, etc ( he had a good heart for what and how he would use the money for. I am sure he would have continued to help people) but seeking all these things is the world Elizabeth had left. I have seen many Lucas fans say that Nathan is boring. But then, Elizabeth must be boring too because they both want similar things and they both are keenly aware of what means the most to each other. And they are friends and friends sometimes will make you face your fears or make you face the truth which is what he did with Elizabeth. If they had written Lucas as wanting the same things Elizabeth has shown she desires in her heart, I may have been firmly in Lucas’s corner right now making the same case for him. I like both these guys and they could have written either one suitable to her.
I don't see where Lucas wanting to build a nicer house was any different than Jack who also bought land & lumber & the land wasn't in town. Also, Lucas has said many, many times he wants to raise a family in HV. Lucas donated the building for the towns library, took Elizabeth to Virginia Wolfe's book reading, took her on an air balloon ride, went horseback riding, had a picnic by the pond, encouraged the writing of her book, gave her a birthday party in her home, etc, all things Nathan could do, but couldn't even get her to dinner. Yes, Lucas did other things for the town like the Christmas Festival, town dinner & these were appreciated. And I'm sorry, but Nathan is boring. He doesn't like Christmas crowds & he himself said he doesn't really like fishing. Hopefully he'll play with Little Jack.....guess you'll have to wait & see.
The problem is the "Lucas"that has been presented in season 8,the writers changed his character to make him fit Elisabeth.He was not ready for a family in Season 7,he said it himself,all of the sudden he want to marry a single mother in season 8,he had an adventurous side and all of the sudden,Hope Valley is everything for him,no consistency in the character.Same stuff with Elisabeth,in Season 8,she was like a school girl who has her first crush,Little Jack is sick she left him to go for a ride with Lucas,she wore a dress for a diner with him,she says she doesn't feel herself but she still goes,things that would have bothered her where now acceptable.Lucas was a bit manipulative in its approach towards Elisabeth: he sent her manuscript without her permission,she get mad and he said this is what she wanted; he made her believe he knew Virginia wolf's books although he has never read one ,he organized dates in disguise when she says she doesn't want a date,constantly pushing her boundaries.The real Elizabeth would have said no to Lucas in Season 8.
If Nathan doesn't really like fishing i don't see where is the problem,it means he is willing to do something he doesn't like to please another person,he can sacrifice himself and find a compromise.And i don't think Elisabeth loves it either.Nathan and Elisabeth sees eye to eye where it matters to build a long lasting relationship.In a couple people sometimes love different things:one love summer,the other winter,one the soccer,the other hate it...that doesn't mean they are not meant for each other.I also think the character of Nathan is like an onion with a lot of layers and there is a lot to discover about him,who knew for example he could draw,in the first episode of the 10th season,he drew a dog on a paper because he wanted to pass an advertisement for adoption.
We will see how the writers will approach things.@sharonnorton2708.
Well said! Her Heart what it truly wants Simple life in Hope Valley!! Elizabeth is just that...each person has a calling and Lucas has that calling for politics- is a good man and heart for making a differencetoo..However both Nathan and Elizabeth has same calling, noble one, to serve and protect & also make a difference in a community- Hope Valley is the lucky recipient!!Core and wholesome story of The Book! Teacher & the Mountie!
Could not have said it better myself
@@Aurora-ob9ixcould not have said it better myself
so beautiful ❤
where did you get your scenes from??
THEY HAVE TO GET TOGETHER IN S11 THEY JUST HAVE TOO #TEAMNATHEN #GRANTUSAFAMILY
This is beautifully done
Thank you. So glad you enjoyed it.
Espero Nathan e Elizabeth juntos. Recife Pe
This is beautiful
Thank you ❤️
TEAM NATHAN💕💕💕💕. THEY BELONG TOGETHER ❤❤
Yes they do
I’m definitely team NATHAN!!! ❤ Any more of Lucas in romance with Elizabeth and I’m done!!!! Bad enough we lost Jack but Nathan is lovely ❤️
Lindos Nathan e Elizabeth ❤❤ Brasil rs.
Eles tem tudo pra certo juntos que lindo de ver❤
Não vejo a hora de ver a NOVA temporada Nathan e Elizabeth juntos
I honestly chose Lucas back in season 8.
However, they had a lot of romance, but she has never allowed him to have any depth with her. They have often stayed on the surface. Never really getting into difficult topics. She definitely loves him, but won't let him fully in.
Going back and rewatching scenes, I think she was actually afraid of having another great love, because she might lose it. She thinks that Nathan would become a great love, so she pushed him away. I don't think he is a great love yet, she just sees that he can be. She has a deep friendship with Nathan, but never allowed him in enough for romance. He carried a heaviness towards her because of his guilt. Once he confessed that Jack took his place, their relationship became so much closer and the negative tension was worked through and gone. She really hasn't let anyone in the way that she let Jack in. Not yet.
I think she will find depth with Nathan. The simple things actually can become very romantic with your best friend, when you fully let them get close to you. They have a really solid foundation. Now they can explore romance. Hopefully they will do a good job portraying that though. They have to be able to move past this early connection and turn it into something deeper.
Also, Elizabeth never let Nathan in enough to romance her, yet. So it can still be really sweet going forward.
Thank you for taking the time to watch my video. I appreciate it. I hope by the end of the new season, you'll be pleased with story of N&E growing together. The promos I seen so far look like it will be a very sweet story.
Loved the 2 videos! Brilliantly done. They just show how deeply Nathan and Elizabeth care for each other. So excited for season 12!!! Truly hope there will be a wedding for Nathan and Elizabeth!!!!!!!🎉❤
Diretor está esperando o que pra que possa fazer todo o público feliz estamos aguardando. Recife pe
Com certeza esperando tanto por esse dia chega.nathan lindooooooo.
Don't know much about this show it looks like it's kinda good, and props on the background music .... Zombie by The Cranberries sounds like someone is playing a violin playing
Espero que sim Nathan e Elizabeth juntos
Quero muito os juntos são lindos 😊
Que lugar lindo ❤
I will watch but if Lucas returns as a love interest I am out again. There is no chemistry between Elizabeth and Lucas.
Thank you for watching. Looks like that won't be an issue moving forward.
It won't be going back to Lucas. Erin, Kevin, and Chris have all said that Nathan and Elizabeth are endgame.
Lucas in an interview stated 😂 He would not be returning for Elizabeth He will return occasionally for Governor duties Bill and Rosemary are lookin😢in white collar crimes
Will not happen. ❤
Totally agree!
Beautiful story❤
Is there any way to make a version with no background music? I would really, really love that!!
Por favor ELES TEM K FICAR JUUUNNNTOOOS❤❤❤❤A KIMICA ENTRE ELES E DEMAIS....NAO ERA ASSIM C O LUCAS
Lindo Nathan e Elizabeth
Nathan e Elizabeth
Maravilha
Me too! The have changed my mind I don lkevLucas
Maravilha muito bom
Eles sentem muito amor PELO outro vemos em seus olhares
Lindos
I don't like Lucas, think he might be the one who sent Hargraves, so it would possibly cause problems between Nathan and Elizabeth, but I don't think that scheme will work because Bill, along with Rosemary to get to the bottom of why he was there. Elizabeth told Lucas she was going to the wedding with Nathan and Lucas had the power of governor to try and cause trouble.
This is a nice compilation but the music is abrasively loud!!!!!!!!😢😮😢
No amor vale
What is Nathan staring at in 1:00
This scene is from s10 episode 11. Nathan is walking up to town after going on rounds with Bill. He sees Elizabeth and notices her reaction to the raising of the campaign banner ( @:56 seconds)
Nathan trás de volta a lembrança do Jack .
Cut all the cello and violin strings. I’m running out of tissues 😅
Não
Continuo Lucas e Elisabeth juntos.
Na minha opinião o policial deve ser transferido para outra cidade.
Ele vai ser sempre a sombra do esposo dela que faleceu
Not nice what Nathan is doing here.
Begging an engaged woman to stay ,
Going behind Lucas’back .
Just imagine if Lucas did that,But he is a man of honor,he would never do that .
Story is unbelievable anymore.
I thought that too but in the beginning of that season she started to give him long looks and hints that she was still interested.
@@cherijohnson5137
It is what it is ,nothing we can do about it .
I’m so excited for Lucas’ storyline that I don’t care about what was with E .We have to move on.
By the way no one talks about Henry’s visit to Abigail.Thats telling me we won’t see Lori.
You never know, the directors might change their minds, and forgive 🙏 never say never 💕
Eles juntos,nao transmitir amor. Parecem forçados. Se eles ficarem juntos, que decepção da autora. Paro se assistir. Natham tinha que ter outro amor.
The author of the books wrote a story between a teacher and a Mountie. She won't be disappointed by Elizabeth and Nathan.
I disliked this scene and in fact I didn't like season 10 and don't like how season 11 looks like and going forward with what they are doing to Elizabeth. It has become a soap drama and no longer a well written story. The only way fans will be happy is that they have somebody like Jack Thornton and not Nathan.
Nathan e Elizabeth