Psychologist Vs Therapist Vs Counsellor | Who is the best?!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 103

  • @JLW667
    @JLW667 3 місяці тому +6

    1:04 Psychologist
    1:40 Psychologist Definition
    2:10 Counselors
    2:50 Counselor definition
    3:16 Psychotherapist/Therapist

  • @lauragore5489
    @lauragore5489 3 роки тому +50

    A lot of counselors use psychotherapy techniques too just to let you know I know too many and I was trained to be a counselor so I know this is true for me at least here in America

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  3 роки тому +9

      Very true! I suppose that raises the question as to whether that means you’re then a counsellor or psychotherapist 😃

    • @tilly704
      @tilly704 Рік тому +1

      you may use a technique , but have no clue what do you do… counsellors, should derivate to a psychologist…

    • @theGENIUSofART-understood
      @theGENIUSofART-understood 4 місяці тому

      @@tilly704 How do you reckon they have 'no clue what they do'? Is getting a degree the only way to understand a model?!

  • @darylhiggs9100
    @darylhiggs9100 9 місяців тому +5

    I'm 35 and currently completing my Ba in psych, to complete my master's in psychotherapy, but for some reason, I do feel a pull towards the clinical psych route also, and i feel that pull is purely related to the title and perhaps the associated status that come with it. something to discuss in analysis for sure, thanks for the Video

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  9 місяців тому +1

      Yep! I think we've all felt the pull towards the status and title! Personally however, when I moved away from clin psych I felt a massive relief- and it certainly allowed me to focus on a career path that was more aligned with my values! Wishing you the best mate :)

  • @heiltecn9ne
    @heiltecn9ne Рік тому +6

    The field can be confusing for example in Illinois therapists are taught to refer to themselves as counselors. I realize many people don’t know what the letters next to a counselors name mean such as lpc lcpc etc..

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому

      I would definitely agree! The lack of consistent language throughout the general profession (especially across borders) creates a lot of confusion for prospective clients and practitioners.

  • @naomidoesstuff6893
    @naomidoesstuff6893 Рік тому +4

    Thank you. This is simple to comprehend!

  • @nupurladdha1819
    @nupurladdha1819 Рік тому +11

    You’re so clear with your words, thank you for this! 🎉

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому

      It’s my goal to make mental health information accessible to all- so thank you Nupur! 😃

    • @theharshtruthoutthere
      @theharshtruthoutthere 10 місяців тому

      @@dipclinic2239 Turn to bible and allow GOD to be your therapist, psychologist and psychiatrist. No man nor women fits to be one. All are sinners and without glory, all are tempted and suffer the same.
      All are expected to REPENT AND BORN AGAIN, to LIVE HOLY AND GO AND SIN NO MORE.
      All are weak in the daily fight between their spirit and flesh.
      All these therapist, psychologist and psychiatrist, this world provides, can do is:
      to deceive and steal.
      They deceived you through all these “diagnoses” and they steal your money, through all the pills which you “need”.
      In short: they poison your mind and your overall health, leaving you with neither one.
      Therapist, Psychologist and Psychiatrist = Field where no human soul, never ever going to fit of being an help, no matter the among of years spend in “medical schools” or the decree gotten from there.
      ALL of us are daily deceived, no matter the walks of life.

  • @WindmillsOfTheMind
    @WindmillsOfTheMind 5 місяців тому

    Good video. Thank you. I've saved it to my playlist. I use the label 'psychotherapist' as I work under the model of Human Givens. However, HG embraces other approaches too.

  • @raikerthedestroyer4092
    @raikerthedestroyer4092 8 місяців тому +1

    I’m probably very behind but this video for me is needed as I have 14 years worth of trauma, that has been undealt with as I’m 23 and still have a bunch of mental health issues and my mom said that a psychologist is better then a therapist in terms of actual mental problems which I no doubt have. Considering that I freeze anytime I hear a scream or any time someone gets angry I cry or again freeze up and I can’t handle the idea of choking people, (both due to the law and I have deep rooted issues stemming from childhood) because of my mom and her leaving my dad looking for other men constantly throughout my childhood and never being there. Always in and out of my life because of drug addiction and general neglect and living with my grandparents wasn’t any better due to them turning down my emotional needs and shutting me down by threatening me but never doing anything bad. My only real saving grace was my (now gone since a couple years ago) nan (moms mom) and school but not due to any teachers intervention I just sat somewhere and cried until classmates found me which never took anyone too long.

    • @Ayesha-r9j2k
      @Ayesha-r9j2k 7 місяців тому

      Counsellors are better at treating trauma than psychologists.

    • @raikerthedestroyer4092
      @raikerthedestroyer4092 7 місяців тому +1

      @@Ayesha-r9j2k ah gotcha thanks!

    • @Ayesha-r9j2k
      @Ayesha-r9j2k 7 місяців тому

      @@raikerthedestroyer4092 please take care of yourself. You deserve a good , balanced and enriched life . Life is too short to live and mostly too beautiful to enjoy if we understand, form new perspectives and grow as a person . I am so sorry to read whatever you have been through in your life . But believe me there is a lot to be grateful for , I am grateful for your Nanna’s presence in your life who comforted you when you were very vulnerable. I am sending you prayers and best wishes for your complete healing and recovery. God bless you Ameen

    • @DCH_420
      @DCH_420 5 місяців тому

      Try a focusing oriented therapist. Somatic techniques will probably be very helpful for releasing implicit memories trapped in your body. I wish you the best on your journey.

    • @misschina
      @misschina 4 місяці тому

      I have seen all three and have a similar story. Severe trauma and borderline. I’m am now well into my recovery and training to be a therapist. Therapists are wonderful people who will allow you to express all your feelings and can help to repair a lot of broken relationship wounds including relationship to self. I’m still working through my trauma and have seen a psychiatrist to understand the deeper effects of trauma and for medication to help with mood regulation. I am currently seeing a psychologist and looking to do EMDR. I adjust my treatment based on how I’m feeling and where I am at. It is important to have good support for trauma as the effects can deeply impact my life. It’s your journey and your path to healing. I make the choices about what is best for me. I also recognise that healing is not linear. It’s a long hike through varying terrain with different levels of difficulty and different guides to support my journey. 💜

  • @annabellerichmond-wright3678
    @annabellerichmond-wright3678 11 місяців тому +2

    Thanks for this explanation. Is it possible that a professional can work as both a counsellor and psychotherapist?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  11 місяців тому +1

      Absolutely! I'm a psychotherapist who also provides person-centered counselling for some clients :)

    • @LHLK-q2v
      @LHLK-q2v 6 місяців тому

      @@dipclinic2239 all psychotherapists provide person centered counselling

  • @madalayne
    @madalayne Рік тому +3

    This is a very informative video, thanks! I just wanted to inform you that the audio is out of sync between the left and the right ear, so it sounds doubled in a way

  • @ektaprakash1547
    @ektaprakash1547 8 місяців тому

    What to do next after finishing MSc. Counseling and family therapy?

  • @YFX_movies
    @YFX_movies 9 місяців тому +2

    Thanks for the video mate. I'm thinking of becoming a counselor. Do you think it's a good job?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  9 місяців тому +1

      Like any job, there are benefits and challenges- personally I find it to be an incredibly rewarding, enjoyable and well-balanced job :) I'd certainly recommend it as a career path but do be sure to do your own research also!
      All the best,
      Mike

  • @5r6v
    @5r6v 7 місяців тому +1

    which ones better for healing severe borderline personality disorder and mild schizophrenia?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  7 місяців тому

      Hi! Schizophrenia often requires a combination of psychological and pharmacological intervention and so I'd often advise both a psychiatrist and psychologist :)
      All the best!
      -M

    • @LHLK-q2v
      @LHLK-q2v 6 місяців тому

      @@dipclinic2239 a psychotherapist for cognitive therapy often works with a psychiatrist for borderline, narcissistic disorders.

  • @AvuzwaKeei
    @AvuzwaKeei Рік тому +2

    Hi, I have a question, how does someone with a Master's in Clinical Mental Health Counseling become a Counselling psychologist?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +1

      Hi! In the UK, 'Counselling Psychologist' is a legally protected title. Therefore, to hold this title you would need to complete a (usually 3 year) Doctorate degree in Counselling Psychology at university which led to registration with the Health and Care Professions Council :)
      All the best!
      Mike

    • @AvuzwaKeei
      @AvuzwaKeei Рік тому

      @@dipclinic2239 Thank you.

  • @lablab657
    @lablab657 Рік тому +9

    In France, the main differences between a psychotherapist , psychologists and psychiatris
    1) psychologist do not have a degree in psychology. They have a diploma in private or public schools ( not uni) and mostly follow one path of psychology ( like Freudian psychology).
    2) psychotherapist and psychiatris both have a degree in psychology. They basically do the same thing but psychiatrist also went to med school so they are the only one that can prescribe you medicines. They are usually working in hospitals.
    Idk if consellors exist in France

    • @luxembourgeliteproductions7434
      @luxembourgeliteproductions7434 Рік тому +4

      Your description is not correct at all.
      In France (and most European countries), a psychologist needs to have a bachelor's and a master's degree in Psychology. 5 years of psychology.
      A Psychotherapist is a psychologist or a medical doctor who finished a psychotherapy training whose criteria are set by the law.
      A Psychiatrist is a medical doctor with a specialisation in psychiatry.
      Counsellors don't exist in France.

    • @LHLK-q2v
      @LHLK-q2v 6 місяців тому

      @@luxembourgeliteproductions7434 a psychotherapist does not need to be a psychologist or a medical doctor they can be trained in specific psychotherpys of which there are many, most psychologists and psychiatrists do not have the intensive training in the specific therapys that a certificed psychotherapist has for example in transactional analysis, hypnotherapy, reality therapy, etc which each take at the minimum 18 months of training to complete each.

    • @luxembourgeliteproductions7434
      @luxembourgeliteproductions7434 6 місяців тому

      @@LHLK-q2v He was talking about France where my statement is correct. The only exception to my statement is the psychoanalysist, who can also be a psychotherapist. So, only medical doctors, psychologists and psychoanalysists can become a psychotherapist.

  • @bettina4374
    @bettina4374 Рік тому +1

    Thank you very much. Are you referring to the system in Great Britain or the US? I just wanted to add ‘Neuropsychologist’. We have ‘Cognitive Neuropsychologists’ in the US.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +1

      Hi Bettina, yes this is referring to the UK system. Unfortunately neuropsychologist still isn’t a legally protected title in the UK- and so it is often clinical psychologists with specialist training who fill this gap 🧠

  • @hanniballuvr
    @hanniballuvr 2 роки тому +3

    Thank you for this video, it was super informative :)

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  2 роки тому

      Thank you for watching Ashley! Glad you found it useful 😃

  • @lonewalker1595
    @lonewalker1595 Рік тому +2

    Hello, thank you for information. I was wondering if you could confirm what international counseling bodies are excelling and their certifications we need to do to become a counselor?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +2

      Hi 👋🏼 These typically range from country to country rather than a single international body. In the UK, some of the leading registered bodies are the BACP, BABCP, UKCP & NCS 😃

    • @lonewalker1595
      @lonewalker1595 Рік тому

      @@dipclinic2239 and what about US and Canada?

  • @Cool_Ace
    @Cool_Ace 2 роки тому +2

    I like this explanation thank you.

  • @tyrantmusic4187
    @tyrantmusic4187 Рік тому +1

    How does a psycho therapist change the patient behaviour

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +1

      Great question! There are a number of ways depending on the therapist and the mode of psychotherapy they use.
      If we take CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) we utilize a range of techniques including motivational interviewing, setting goals, overcoming negative beliefs, enhancing confidence, finding solutions to challenges and many more :)

  • @sereneamani1713
    @sereneamani1713 3 місяці тому +1

    Hopefully all viewers realize that you are speaking of the UK specifically. I'll have to retrace my steps to determine how I arrived at this channel. Good advice though if you live and work in the UK.

  • @solesurvivor005
    @solesurvivor005 10 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for the video. Quick Question: a 3 year diploma in counselling or 6-8 years of study to become a neuropsychologist, what are your thoughts on this? P.S: decision is to be made by a person who is changing his career in 30s.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  10 місяців тому +2

      Hey! It very much depends on what you want to do as a career (be a talking therapist or complete neuropsychological assessments/work in cognitive research).
      I would say a counselling diploma has more short term opportunity, as you can complete this and then specialise into different therapeutic modalities.
      Ultimately, I'd have a think about what you want to be doing in 10 years time and allow this to shape your decision.
      Best of luck with whatever your choice is!
      M :)

  • @Lawzika
    @Lawzika Рік тому

    Thank you ever so much for making this video!

  • @lorid3661
    @lorid3661 8 місяців тому

    I currently live in New York City and operate a private practice under the title of Licensed Clinical Social Worker. Which requires a masters degree in SW and 6000 hours of direct therapeutic practice with clients. I also have a masters degree in psychology. I’m thinking about moving to the UK in a few years. Is there a direct transfer of career in the UK? If so, what would be the requirements? Any direction would be helpful and much appreciated.

    • @LHLK-q2v
      @LHLK-q2v 6 місяців тому

      look up openings in the the UK for jobs and see what there is, private practice in the UK as in New York is very competitive.

  • @soniaballing1304
    @soniaballing1304 3 роки тому +4

    Though the others two are essential but the Psychologist is the best!

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  3 роки тому +1

      Thanks for watching Sonia! I’ll definitely agree that psychologists are great 🙌🏽

    • @LHLK-q2v
      @LHLK-q2v 6 місяців тому

      psychologists are basicly assessors who run tests which determine the diagnosis according to the DSM???

  • @Yessir-cz2xs
    @Yessir-cz2xs Рік тому +1

    Hello I was wondering if you know a good way to tell apart Autism and BPD. Also why and where does derealization come from and why it never goes away. Hope it’s no bother. It can be maybe a bit rude to just ask especially since it’s unrelated.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +1

      Hi! Thanks for the questions!
      Both autism and EUPD (BPD) require in-depth clinical examination to explore whether a diagnosis is present or not (and so I couldn't comment on that part of your question).
      In relation to derealization, there's a range of biological, psychological and social factors that contribute to its presence. In essence your brain detaches you from your surroundings as a way of managing trauma.
      Many people recover from derealisation, and I'd always recommend anyone to speak with a suitably qualified mental health professional if they need further support with this :)

    • @Yessir-cz2xs
      @Yessir-cz2xs Рік тому

      @@dipclinic2239 thank you for the answer! 🙏

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому

      You're welcome! :) @@Yessir-cz2xs

  • @theremoteinfluencer
    @theremoteinfluencer 4 місяці тому

    Good video. Helpful info. What's your take on online therapy?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  4 місяці тому +1

      I'm personally a big fan of online video therapy. It demonstrates increased accessibility, similar (and sometimes improved) effectiveness than f2f therapy, and anecdotally I find people are often more comfortable in their own environment. There are of course some draw-backs, but I can't see many arguments against it :)
      Thanks for the question!
      - M

    • @theremoteinfluencer
      @theremoteinfluencer 4 місяці тому

      @@dipclinic2239 You're welcome. Keep up the great work.

  • @pugninja7037
    @pugninja7037 Рік тому

    So counsellors are GP Doctors , all tools surface level..
    Pscychtherapist neurologist specific area/field.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому

      GP's and Doctors may use aspects of counselling skills (i.e. active listening, paraphrasing, incorporating empathy) but this wouldn't make them counsellors.
      Counsellors complete specific courses to support peoples emotional well-being. Psychotherapists do the same but focus on specific modes of therapy such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)

  • @EricFrank-p1q
    @EricFrank-p1q 15 днів тому

    If you’ve had childhood sexual trauma, who would be the best to talk to and see?

  • @HypnotherapySessions
    @HypnotherapySessions Рік тому

    How about holistic counselling?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому

      What is your definition of holistic counseling? :)

    • @HypnotherapySessions
      @HypnotherapySessions Рік тому

      @@dipclinic2239 I am asking you, hence left the comment.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +1

      @@HypnotherapySessions I think all approaches should place an emphasis on bio-psychosocial factors. And this is often utilised by registered practitioners :)

  • @wanjirulinet
    @wanjirulinet 9 місяців тому +1

    Am a counselling psychologist and am proud to be one😊

    • @BanashreeMalakar23
      @BanashreeMalakar23 9 місяців тому +1

      Hello ma'am 👋, can u tell me that is it hard to become a psychologist? And how many time it takes to became one??

    • @wanjirulinet
      @wanjirulinet 9 місяців тому

      @@BanashreeMalakar23 it's a continuous learning .you learn everyday koz Yoh get different clients with different disorders so you need more research

    • @Faithsavage1986
      @Faithsavage1986 8 місяців тому

      I am seeing a regular counselor but all she does is sit there and listen to me. I have complex trauma. Who should I see to actually help me get to the bottom of this pain inside?😢

    • @sotiriosnovatsis4529
      @sotiriosnovatsis4529 6 місяців тому

      @@Faithsavage1986If you feel that your counsellor isn’t helping, then explain that to them. Tell them why. Counsellors are meant to help you self-reflect and see the solution that lies within you. If you feel that’s not happening, then tell them.
      Talk to them about how you feel about the way the sessions are conducted.

  • @martal5154
    @martal5154 2 місяці тому

    I wouldn't want anyone to associate counselling only to a person centred approach, which can be wonderful. The therapeutic relationship is proven to be central in all therapies. Even so, there are counsellors who trained in other humanistic approaches, CBT counsellors, and more. Counselling isn't just about being with the client and paraphrasing, although it is an essential part of it, there is challenge, when appropriate, and infinite tools taken from different theories and life in general. There will certainly be a different depth in training, the understanding of certain concepts, and the ability to work with different levels of difficulties, but the explanation provided in the video does not feel very accurate.
    Perhaps, unless one undertakes all trainings, including hours of placement, it is hard for anyone to faithfully portray the differences.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  2 місяці тому

      Thanks for your comment :) I think the key difference to note here is you are talking about 'counselling' as a practice rather than 'Counsellors' as a profession.
      As I mentioned below, counsellors may well utilise different theories, but are not typically as trained in psychotherapy (CBT for example) as psychotherapists who have trained specifically in that modality.
      I have undertaken training as a counsellor and as a CBT psychotherapist (and also within health psychology), accumulating placement hours in all of them. There will always be a nuance and I'm glad we are continuing to find the scope and maintaining discussions of each :)
      All the best,
      - M

    • @martal5154
      @martal5154 2 місяці тому

      @@dipclinic2239 Hi, I agree it is good to talk and understand things. Thank you for your reply.
      You certainly know much more than I ever will, and clearly have the experience to understand what I cannot. It would be impossible to disagree that, as I also stated before, there certainly is a difference in depth of training and understanding of theories and struggles. My point was that whoever seeks answers in the video may believe counsellors, in practice, mostly listen and paraphrase, and may sometimes use other tools. I am not sure I can agree with that but remain open to the possibility I may have the wrong perception, of course. :)

  • @dilembicyclem
    @dilembicyclem Рік тому +1

    Isn’t a counsellor a type of psychotherapist?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  Рік тому +2

      Hi Jasmeen, typically all psychotherapists will be able to offer counselling- however not all counsellors can offer psychotherapy (I.e. cognitive behavioural therapy)
      The terms are however used interchangeably which often leads to confusion!

  • @carlybbyindanger
    @carlybbyindanger 10 місяців тому

    Fantastic video ❤

  • @queenz4882
    @queenz4882 9 місяців тому

    Sure👍

  • @YvonneChandler-n8o
    @YvonneChandler-n8o Місяць тому

    0:11

  • @theGENIUSofART-understood
    @theGENIUSofART-understood 4 місяці тому

    I'm counselling a psychotherapist. :)

  • @aps-pictures9335
    @aps-pictures9335 9 місяців тому +1

    Psychologist is now a protected title in the UK

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  9 місяців тому +1

      'Psychologist' still isn't currently a protected title in the UK.
      The following are however protected by the HCPC by law: Practitioner psychologist, Registered psychologist, Clinical psychologist, Forensic psychologist, Counselling psychologist, Health psychologist, Educational psychologist, Occupational psychologist, Sport and exercise psychologist :)
      All the best!

  • @nimosayeda4592
    @nimosayeda4592 Рік тому

    What's the difference between someone with a bachelor's in Psychology with a concentration in Clinical Psychology VS someone with a Master's in Clinical Psychology? What qualifications does the one with a bachelor's hold?

    • @xo_you_know9983
      @xo_you_know9983 Рік тому +2

      I think that qualifications depend on the country/state's regulations. A real difference is that the Master's degree has more exposure to patients under supervision than the one with a bachelor.

    • @nimosayeda4592
      @nimosayeda4592 Рік тому

      @@xo_you_know9983 Alrighty thanks!! :D

  • @SakanderKumar-n6e
    @SakanderKumar-n6e 2 місяці тому

    More valuable

  • @johnCjr4671
    @johnCjr4671 6 місяців тому +2

    Therapist and Counselor just seem to be playing the Friend role for people who are not able to share difficulties with freinds or Family ? Psychologists seem to be more insightful due to their in depth knowledge of the human psyche ?

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  5 місяців тому +3

      Thanks for the comment John! I would argue that non of the professions aim to replace the role of friendship or family as this often sits outside of the ethical scope of therapy. Different practitioners do indeed have varied insights and approaches, but I would say they all have a significant insight within their respective areas.
      All the best!
      -M

  • @Jean-ni6of
    @Jean-ni6of 11 місяців тому

    BSA

  • @KellyEmelianchik-Key
    @KellyEmelianchik-Key 5 місяців тому

    Do some additional research on counseling. Counselors use models and are highly trained on models.

    • @dipclinic2239
      @dipclinic2239  5 місяців тому +3

      Hi Kelly, thanks for your comment. My original training was in counseling, and I also work with and teach counselors so I'm very familiar with their skills/work. As mentioned, counselors utilize a person-centered model, but to say they're highly trained in other therapeutic models outside of PCT (unless they have done additional training) would typically be inaccurate. All the best, - M