बोहोत बहोत बढ़े संगीतकार आये और आ कर चले गये पर शंकर जयकिशन के ज्ञान का कोई जवाब नहीं। यदि बढ़ते क्रम में एक लिस्ट बनाई जाय (सभी संगीतकारों की) तो शंकर जयकिशन का नाम प्रथम स्थान पर रहेगा । "प्यार हुआ..., या बे दर्दे दी बालमा तुझको मेरा मन याद...., या आवाज़ देके हमें तुम..., ये मेरा दिवाना पन है या मौहबत का सरुर ... और न जाने ऐसे सैंकड़ों गाने कितनी ही बार सुनो मन नहीं भरता । इस महान जोड़ी की तारीफ के लिए मेरे पास शब्द नहीं ।
Indian music industry without Shankar Jaikishan is disable. They were Genius. Their each songs . music. Were heart touching. No one has reached that height and no one has given to theirs extended high music like Shankar Jaikishan. Their heigh standard of music is Incomparable. Unbeatable. Untouchable. They music circle is incomplete without their contributions to Bollywood. They were the soul and heart ❤️. ❤️❤️
Mahan sangitkar jodi , Great trend setters in golden era. Sabse safal aur popular sangeet bananewale jadugar. Their contribution in taking Hindi Films Music to great height is immense. The variety , classical music , rhythm and bejod synchronization of various instruments in their music made them a class apart. Their music is immortal and will be heard for many more years to come.
प्रोफेसर साहब आपने तो ऐसा लगता हैं.....मानो संगीत कि जानकारी का जिगर सामने रख दिया हैं ...... आपकों बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद...... दिल ❤️ से लाखों नहीं करोड़ों प्रणाम 🙏🙏🪴🪴 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
फिल्म जगत के महान हस्तियों की अनसुनी कहानियां के बारे में जानकारी आप जैसे समीक्षकों द्वारा मिलती है। संगीत सम्राट शंकर - जयकिशन के बारे में आपने बहोत सारी जानकारी दी दिल❤ खुश हुआ।आपका धन्यवाद।🙏
Absolutely there won't be any musician like SJ. Their songs touched my entire life right from childhood, its still with me and shall be forever! I am attached to them. I cry for their absence deep inside even as on today!! Songs for all emotions!! Only by JS!!
Wrong mera naam jokar jaisa back ground music geeto ka music zabardast morre ang lag ja balma ye bhai Zara dekh ke chalo aap kaise keh sahte hai ke jeena yahan marna yahan. Ya. Jane kaha Gaye wo din ye he gaane hit hai Shankar jaikishan sunte sunte jindgi guzar gaie I love both of them
Shankarji of the duo SJ was indeed a chaste gentleman and had such a personality that Jaikishanji regarded him as his father & had a profound respect for him
Ramesh Dutt sahab, I've heard you for the first time today. I'm speechless with your simplicity, frankness, knowledge and your love for Bollywood and Music. Ofcourse I'm an ardent S-J fan, but you have one more fan in your long list of fans. 🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻 Qurbaaaaan.
आदरणीय प्रोफे साहेब. Behtarin jankari के लिए आपका हृदय से आभार। जैकिशन जी को संगीत की jankari विरासत में ही मिली थी। सब कुछ अपने गाँव बसंदा में बड़े भाई से भजन मंडली में सीख लिया। दोनों महान हस्तियों की स्मृति को नमन करता हूँ। लेख टंडन जी भी सीधे साधे दयालु इंसान थे।
SABSE PEHLA SHANKAR JI PRITVI THEATRA ME JOINED HUA THA . USKE BAAD HUSANLAL BHAGAT RAM JI KE SATH THODA ASSISTANT KAM KIYA THA PHIR RAM GANGULY KE SATH "AAG " ME KAM KIYA THA . BAAD ME JAIKISHAN JI KO MILA AUR PRITVI THEATRA ME AS A HARMONIUM PLAYER KA KAM MILA . BAAD ME " BARSHATH " INLOG MUSIC DIRECTOR BANGEYA .
Aap logon ki bajese hame sankar jaikishan ji ki yaad taza ho jati hai Krupa kar ke film Bejuban ke bare main kuch batayenge.mere pass samay bahat Kam hai.
@@ramagobindaacharya358 dada what did you mean by aap ke paas samay kam hai ? Are you not well ? Hope you are in sound health. However, Due to frame to frame copy of the scenes, the producer of Knock on wood filed a case and the court had order to destroy the prints of Begunah by burning them. However, National Film Archive of India has got few reels of the film in which the scene of Jaikishan ji singing Ae Pyase Dil Bejuban is there with full song. Unfortunately till now the matter is pending for approval since they are in search of that particular Court Order. Unless it is found, cant say what will be the fate of the reels and us, the fans of SJ
@@ramagobindaacharya358 PICTURE BANNED KAR DIYA GEYA THA . BECOUSE WO PICTURE EK ENGLISH MOVIE KA CHORI KARKE BANAYA THA. HOLLYWOOD KA SABSE BADA BANNAR PARAMOUNT MOVIES UNLOG AMERICA SE AYA BOMBAY HIGH COURT ME CASE DALA AUR JEET GEYA THA AUR HIGH COURT KA ORDER KE MUTABIK REELS KO DAMAGED KAR DIYA GEYA . ITNA JANKARI MUJHE HEI .
Very nice, only one musician continuely given hit music 1950-60 10 yrs. European country told God gift of music to song- aaja madhur chandani mein.... film chori chori how sucha instruments played & made a sound
Prof. Saab, after listening to the songs composed by them(not all) I observed that after a certain period it was not difficult to identify which was the song composed by shankar and similarly by Jaikishen. I hope you will agree with me Another, point, it was Jaikishen who was the PRO who use to discuss the terms and conditions with producers. I think Shammi Kapoor said this.
I have seen that video where Shammi Kapoor said it. Shankar was a straight forward and a little bit hot temperament person. On the contrary, Jackishanji was soft spoken easy going and easy to deal with. The the most important thing is that together they were just wonderful and the Best music directors of all time.
SHANKAR JI KA DEATH KEISE HUI ? ISKE BARE KOI JANKARI ABHI TAK MILA NEHI . JAIKISHAN JI KA DEATH KA BARE FILM MAGAZINE, NEWS PAPER ME AYA THA BUT SHANKAR JI KA KOI DETAILS ME AYA NEHI . MY FAVOURITE MUSIC DIRECTOR SJ USKE BAAD O P NAYYAR SHAHAB THAN NOUSHAD JI S D BURMAN JI , SHALIL DA , HEMANT DA , MADAN MOHAN JI ROSHAN JI , KALYANJI ANANDJI KHAYYAM JI , LP
Shankar ji ki death tragedy thee. Many say that it was not normal, that is why his body was cremated before dawn. The doctor who gave death certificate, the cremation ground person, who allowed cremation fled from the spot since that day. Since no prominent person from industry pursued the matter, the case died itself. Shanker ji did not have any issue from his blood. His family was step family. Big names remained shut on this matter.
Shankar Jaikishan were surely good music directors but not only they, every music director had it's own wonderful style one can't undervalue Naushad the great, Ravi, Madan Mohan, Roshan, Chitr gupt, SD Burman etc.
Mera nasm joker ke Geet toh jivan jine ki kala hai aur baat rahi lata ji ki toh woh badi rajniti karne main mahir thi apne ko uch stan par rakhe ke liye ushe behtar gaayikaon par annay kiya hai aisa main nahi kehta uska itihaas kehta hai mera aisa maanna hai har us insaan ko haath do jo jab hum nahi rahenge toh yaad karega ke yeh insaan ne humein madat ki hai lata ji Ehsaan faramosh hai jo khud ke liye hi ji hai auron ke liye nahi aisa hi uska itihaas hai Ehsaan mere dil pe tumhara hai doston yeh dil tumhare pyar ka mara hai doston agar kaam insaniyat ka ho toh shankar ji Jaikishan ji shailendra ji Hasrat ji Rafi sahab mukesh ji manna dada kishore dada talat sahab suman tai ko aaj bhi pyar bhare nazron se yaad kiya jaata hai dusron ka hakh chinke nahi koi bada bharat Ratna Banta
Prof. Ramesh Dutt ji Iss me koi do rai nahin sangeetkar Shankar Jaikishan Bharati Cinema ke Itihas men unka naam sunehri akshar me likh jayega. Aap ka presentation bhi utna hi khubsurat hai. Sangeet jagat me kisi ko kisi se bada ya chhota kehna theek nahin hai. Shailendra ke baare me Gulzar ji jo kaha woh unki apni rai hai .
I disagree with his assessment of mera naam joker. Ae bhai zara dekh ke chalo, kaate na kate raina, sadqay heer hum fakeer, kehta hai joker are all fantastic songs. Personally, of all the RK banner albums, I would rate it below only to Shree 420, JSDMGBH, AWARA and Aah
Absolutely All songs were hit in fact Asha had great break in Mera Naam Joker! As you rightly claim Manna dey n Rafi's songs were masterpiece compositions!
I agree with you MERA NAAM JOKER music is excellent music I will name as one of the finest. Note the orchestra in the songs and compare With CIRCUS ORCHESTRA is played in circuses it is almost same in sound and it is masterpiece.
Akshaysharma1342 …… I agree with prof.Datt…. Compare with other RK Movies ,..Music of Joker” = songs are not of that high “Quality “! They also received Late & limited popularity ! Difficult to use the right word here:’ quality’ of these songs may be quite good,and appealing ,but it is not at the level of other RK Movies ! The Classic touch of Composition and sheer originality of musical phrases created by SJ for earlier RK Movies is not evident in MNJoker. I hope some Young Generation connoisseurs of SJ’s Music see what I have experienced so deeply when their Classic Movies came out in my teenage years…. I continue my Listening and thinking about SJ & our Cinema Music till now, that is me Starting my 80s !. 👍🔱🇮🇳🔱🚩🔱
Akshaysharma1342 …… I agree with prof.Datt…. Compare with other RK Movies ,..Music of Joker” = songs are not of that high “Quality “! They also received Late & limited popularity ! Difficult to use the right word here:’ quality’ of these songs may be quite good,and appealing ,but it is not at the level of other RK Movies ! The Classic touch of Composition and sheer originality of musical phrases created by SJ for earlier RK Movies is not evident in MNJoker. I hope some Young Generation connoisseurs of SJ’s Music see what I have experienced so deeply when their Classic Movies came out in my teenage years…. I continue my Listening and thinking about SJ & our Cinema Music till now, that is me Starting my 80s !. 👍🔱🇮🇳🔱🚩🔱
Asal me Shankar ji ka objection gate waqt daso dishao ke uchharan ko leke tha .Mannade ji ne apne interview me Abhijit Desai ko (book GANI BAJAWANI) pura kissa bataya .kafi bahas ke bad Raj Kapoor ke ashwasan par ki agar gana achha nahi laga to badme badal denge.Lekin Lataji ke gane me koi dikkat nahi hui.aur fil sabhi thik ho gaya.
@@shankerjaikishan yes The book name is GANI BAJAVANI by Abhijit Desai 2005 first edition but in Marathi .Very authentic and informative book with interview of many celebrities including Lata Mangeshkar mannade.....
Sir, with due respect to RK for giving break to SJ .They had merit therefore they scored fantastic music for many other producers /Films which were superhits coz of music.
Absolutely correct. Shanker Jaikishan paid back more than 10 times. Everyone knows that when they were charging even 5 lac, they were on payroll of RK. They were loyal to RK.
It is insult of Shanker Jaikishan to always relates with Raj Kapoor. Shanker Jaikishan became great due to their partnership with Mohammad Rafi. They themselves said, our bench, our main singer was Mohammad Rafi.
Not everyone knows. only Few like you know. Still there are large section of people who are not aware of even common news. And Jay saab, there are other videos also here.
Audience reject disgusting, boring, repeated storytelling, lacking innovative sooner or later. SJ copied from Opera House 60 to Jane Anjan 71 to lost of the creativity
This is very disgusting statement. Not only SJ, but every music director copied one or more song, it doesn't mean the empire of Shankar Jaikishan was erected on copied tunes. A sweeping statement like this is not fair.
बोहोत बहोत बढ़े संगीतकार आये और आ कर चले गये पर शंकर जयकिशन के ज्ञान का कोई जवाब नहीं। यदि बढ़ते क्रम में एक लिस्ट बनाई जाय (सभी संगीतकारों की) तो शंकर जयकिशन का नाम प्रथम स्थान पर रहेगा । "प्यार हुआ..., या बे दर्दे दी बालमा तुझको मेरा मन याद...., या आवाज़ देके हमें तुम..., ये मेरा दिवाना पन है या मौहबत का सरुर ... और न जाने ऐसे सैंकड़ों गाने कितनी ही बार सुनो मन नहीं भरता । इस महान जोड़ी की तारीफ के लिए मेरे पास शब्द नहीं ।
Shankar jaikishan hindi film k sabse mahan sangeetkar
Bahut sundar presentation sir
Indian music industry without Shankar Jaikishan is disable. They were Genius. Their each songs . music. Were heart touching. No one has reached that height and no one has given to theirs extended high music like Shankar Jaikishan. Their heigh standard of music is Incomparable. Unbeatable. Untouchable. They music circle is incomplete without their contributions to Bollywood. They were the soul and heart ❤️. ❤️❤️
Shankar Jaikisan... the greatest musician of all time
I totally agree with Pro. Ramesh Dutt, he has beautifully explored the different, different aspects of SJ's musical and personal journey. 👌👌👌👌👌👏👏👏👏👏
They came,they composed and they conquered....this is very apt description of the Legendary composers Shankar Jaikishan.
Correct
Ever since my childhood they have been my favorite music directors and two Ghandharvas sent by God to give us wonderful music.
Mahan sangitkar jodi , Great trend setters in golden era. Sabse safal aur popular sangeet bananewale jadugar. Their contribution in taking Hindi Films Music to great height is immense. The variety , classical music , rhythm and bejod synchronization of various instruments in their music made them a class apart. Their music is immortal and will be heard for many more years to come.
मुझे ऐसा लगता है आपकी मैफिलका एक हिस्सा बनकर शंकरजयकिशनजीके बारेमे
मै सुनता रहू। उस सूनहरी यादोमे खो जाऊ
ऐसा मुझे लगता है।
Shankar Jaikishen donon ki jodi apni misaal ap hain ❤❤
प्रोफेसर साहब आपने तो ऐसा लगता हैं.....मानो संगीत कि जानकारी का जिगर सामने रख दिया हैं ...... आपकों बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद...... दिल ❤️ से लाखों नहीं करोड़ों प्रणाम 🙏🙏🪴🪴 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Beautiful postof great legends of Golden Era.
Thanks for sharing the post. ❤
फिल्म जगत के महान हस्तियों की अनसुनी कहानियां के बारे में जानकारी आप जैसे समीक्षकों द्वारा मिलती है। संगीत सम्राट शंकर - जयकिशन के बारे में आपने बहोत सारी जानकारी दी दिल❤ खुश हुआ।आपका धन्यवाद।🙏
Most popular musical master minds Shanker Jaikishan ,no one comes near to them .
Absolutely there won't be any musician like SJ. Their songs touched my entire life right from childhood, its still with me and shall be forever! I am attached to them. I cry for their absence deep inside even as on today!! Songs for all emotions!! Only by JS!!
Jo sangeet 60-70 saal baad bhi nayi generation ko bhi magnet ki tarah apni aur khinch leta hai, wo naam hai- Shanker-Jaikishan.
Shukriya DK saab.. mein gaayak to nahin...lekin 72 baras tak aate aawaaz mein dararein padh hi jaati hain..
बेहतरीन सँगीत की जोड़ी।क्या उनका सगीत था,उनकी धुन की जितनी तारीफ कर वो कम है।
Koti koti pranam
Khoobsurat tribute, with great insights
Wrong mera naam jokar jaisa back ground music geeto ka music zabardast morre ang lag ja balma ye bhai Zara dekh ke chalo aap kaise keh sahte hai ke jeena yahan marna yahan. Ya. Jane kaha Gaye wo din ye he gaane hit hai Shankar jaikishan sunte sunte jindgi guzar gaie I love both of them
Shankarji of the duo SJ was indeed a chaste gentleman and had such a personality that Jaikishanji regarded him as his father & had a profound respect for him
I have a paper cutting in which Jaikishan ji has expressed his regards for Shankar ji. will share soon with a video clip
न हुआ है न होगा, जैसे शंकर जयकिशन हुए। वो तो लोगों के रोम रोम में संगीत के माध्यम से बसे हैं❤❤❤❤❤
Nice narration on shankerji and Jaikishan ji.
Fantastically worded tribute to SJ here by Prof Rameshji here @1:22 very well done Rameshji with top class wordings. PERFECT.
नमन आपके ज्ञान को और आपके माधुर्य वाणी को
Ramesh Dutt sahab, I've heard you for the first time today. I'm speechless with your simplicity, frankness, knowledge and your love for Bollywood and Music. Ofcourse I'm an ardent S-J fan, but you have one more fan in your long list of fans. 🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻
Qurbaaaaan.
Shankar jaikishan bhagwan they.un jaisa Sangeet koi nahe
Professor sahab aap ko koti koti naman
आदरणीय प्रोफे साहेब. Behtarin jankari के लिए आपका हृदय से आभार। जैकिशन जी को संगीत की jankari विरासत में ही मिली थी। सब कुछ अपने गाँव बसंदा में बड़े भाई से भजन मंडली में सीख लिया। दोनों महान हस्तियों की स्मृति को नमन करता हूँ। लेख टंडन जी भी सीधे साधे दयालु इंसान थे।
Nice narration. As far as I remember only Shankar assisted MD Ram Ganguli in Aag.
in case of Husnlal Bhagatram you may be right, but both of SJ assisted Ram Ganguly
SABSE PEHLA SHANKAR JI PRITVI THEATRA ME JOINED HUA THA . USKE BAAD
HUSANLAL BHAGAT RAM JI KE SATH THODA ASSISTANT KAM KIYA THA PHIR
RAM GANGULY KE SATH "AAG " ME KAM KIYA THA .
BAAD ME JAIKISHAN JI
KO MILA AUR PRITVI
THEATRA ME AS A HARMONIUM PLAYER
KA KAM MILA . BAAD ME " BARSHATH "
INLOG MUSIC DIRECTOR BANGEYA .
Gem of the music Ham rahen ya na rahen per hamari nishaniya rahegi.
Thanks sir for the rare detailed information
Shailendra saab had passed earlier in 1966 I. e much before death of jaikishen saab
अत्यंत रोचक जानकारी मिली। शुक्रिया❤
Wah...... बेहतरीन जानकारी
Very nice presentation !
Aap ne bahut baariki se sabh bataya.Thanks a lot.
Thanks for beautiful narration,my favourite music director
saab aapki awaz bahut achhi hai apne bhi shastriya gayan sikha hoga
Aap ko koti koti naman shree s.j. jaisa koe nahi hai
Mera naam joker ka sangeet sadabahar hai aur gaane Aaj bhi top par hai
A good presentation. Prof Surender Bhutani in Warsaw (Poland)
Evergreen Shankar Jaikishan
Aap logon ki bajese hame sankar jaikishan ji ki yaad taza ho jati hai Krupa kar ke film Bejuban ke bare main kuch batayenge.mere pass samay bahat Kam hai.
Bejubaan or Begunaah?
Sorry Begunha jis film main jaikishan ji bhi acting ki thi hero kishor kumar the.
@@ramagobindaacharya358 dada what did you mean by aap ke paas samay kam hai ? Are you not well ? Hope you are in sound health. However, Due to frame to frame copy of the scenes, the producer of Knock on wood filed a case and the court had order to destroy the prints of Begunah by burning them. However, National Film Archive of India has got few reels of the film in which the scene of Jaikishan ji singing Ae Pyase Dil Bejuban is there with full song. Unfortunately till now the matter is pending for approval since they are in search of that particular Court Order. Unless it is found, cant say what will be the fate of the reels and us, the fans of SJ
@@ramagobindaacharya358
PICTURE BANNED KAR DIYA GEYA THA .
BECOUSE WO PICTURE EK ENGLISH MOVIE
KA CHORI KARKE BANAYA THA.
HOLLYWOOD KA SABSE
BADA BANNAR
PARAMOUNT MOVIES
UNLOG AMERICA SE AYA BOMBAY HIGH COURT ME CASE DALA AUR JEET GEYA THA
AUR HIGH COURT KA ORDER KE MUTABIK REELS KO DAMAGED KAR DIYA GEYA .
ITNA JANKARI MUJHE HEI .
Both are the gems of India.
Very nice, only one musician continuely given hit music 1950-60 10 yrs. European country told God gift of music to song- aaja madhur chandani mein.... film chori chori how sucha instruments played & made a sound
Mai bar bar kahta hun ki jahan lata ji hain wahan melody hai
आदरणीय महोदय. कभी आप हमें शंकर जैकिशन जी और mohd रफी साहेब की संगीत यात्रा और association से परिचित करायें। सादर।
कमाल हो जायगा ।
Prof. Saab, after listening to the songs composed by them(not all) I observed that after a certain period it was not difficult to identify which was the song composed by shankar and similarly by Jaikishen.
I hope you will agree with me
Another, point,
it was Jaikishen who was the PRO who use to discuss the terms and conditions with producers.
I think Shammi Kapoor said this.
I have seen that video where Shammi Kapoor said it. Shankar was a straight forward and a little bit hot temperament person. On the contrary, Jackishanji was soft spoken easy going and easy to deal with. The the most important thing is that together they were just wonderful and the Best music directors of all time.
@@dhiranprajapati647
Very rightly said.
I also heard Raj kapoor affectionately calling Shankar Ghenda (rhino)...
Excellent
SHANKAR JI KA DEATH KEISE HUI ?
ISKE BARE KOI JANKARI ABHI TAK MILA NEHI .
JAIKISHAN JI KA DEATH KA BARE FILM MAGAZINE, NEWS PAPER ME AYA THA BUT SHANKAR JI KA KOI DETAILS ME AYA NEHI . MY FAVOURITE MUSIC DIRECTOR SJ
USKE BAAD O P NAYYAR SHAHAB
THAN NOUSHAD JI
S D BURMAN JI , SHALIL DA , HEMANT DA , MADAN MOHAN JI
ROSHAN JI , KALYANJI ANANDJI
KHAYYAM JI , LP
Shankar ji ki death tragedy thee. Many say that it was not normal, that is why his body was cremated before dawn. The doctor who gave death certificate, the cremation ground person, who allowed cremation fled from the spot since that day. Since no prominent person from industry pursued the matter, the case died itself. Shanker ji did not have any issue from his blood. His family was step family. Big names remained shut on this matter.
There will none to fill up this great SJ pair ai am great fan of them till this date there is musian to replace them in our film industry ❤
Great music director
Shanker jaikishen rank well above others. Who are ten steps behind
Anchor kaun hain yeh ? Badi kamaal ki awaaz hai.... 👏 👏 👏
Shankar Jaikishan were surely good music directors but not only they, every music director had it's own wonderful style one can't undervalue Naushad the great, Ravi, Madan Mohan, Roshan, Chitr gupt, SD Burman etc.
Mera nasm joker ke Geet toh jivan jine ki kala hai aur baat rahi lata ji ki toh woh badi rajniti karne main mahir thi apne ko uch stan par rakhe ke liye ushe behtar gaayikaon par annay kiya hai aisa main nahi kehta uska itihaas kehta hai mera aisa maanna hai har us insaan ko haath do jo jab hum nahi rahenge toh yaad karega ke yeh insaan ne humein madat ki hai lata ji Ehsaan faramosh hai jo khud ke liye hi ji hai auron ke liye nahi aisa hi uska itihaas hai Ehsaan mere dil pe tumhara hai doston yeh dil tumhare pyar ka mara hai doston agar kaam insaniyat ka ho toh shankar ji Jaikishan ji shailendra ji Hasrat ji Rafi sahab mukesh ji manna dada kishore dada talat sahab suman tai ko aaj bhi pyar bhare nazron se yaad kiya jaata hai dusron ka hakh chinke nahi koi bada bharat Ratna Banta
wah
Prof. Ramesh Dutt ji Iss me koi do rai nahin sangeetkar Shankar Jaikishan Bharati Cinema ke Itihas men unka naam sunehri akshar me likh jayega. Aap ka presentation bhi utna hi khubsurat hai. Sangeet jagat me kisi ko kisi se bada ya chhota kehna theek nahin hai. Shailendra ke baare me Gulzar ji jo kaha woh unki apni rai hai .
Salute you you sir
Ramesh sir had commented by golden heart about the golden era
बढ़िया 👌
Good
Aap jo bole sabhee u tube me bol chuke hai...lekin Laxmi pyare ne vo mukam hasil kiya ya nahi iske baare bataayiye
I disagree with his assessment of mera naam joker. Ae bhai zara dekh ke chalo, kaate na kate raina, sadqay heer hum fakeer, kehta hai joker are all fantastic songs. Personally, of all the RK banner albums, I would rate it below only to Shree 420, JSDMGBH, AWARA and Aah
Absolutely All songs were hit in fact Asha had great break in Mera Naam Joker! As you rightly claim Manna dey n Rafi's songs were masterpiece compositions!
I agree with you MERA NAAM JOKER music is excellent music I will name as one of the finest. Note the orchestra in the songs and compare With CIRCUS ORCHESTRA is played in circuses it is almost same in sound and it is masterpiece.
Akshaysharma1342 …… I agree with prof.Datt…. Compare with other RK Movies ,..Music of
Joker” = songs are not of that high “Quality “! They also received Late & limited popularity ! Difficult to use the right word here:’
quality’ of these songs may be quite good,and appealing ,but it is not at the level of other RK Movies ! The Classic touch of Composition and sheer originality of musical phrases created by SJ for earlier RK Movies is not evident in MNJoker. I hope some Young Generation connoisseurs of SJ’s Music see what I have experienced so deeply when their Classic Movies came out in my teenage years…. I continue my Listening and thinking about SJ & our Cinema Music till now, that is me Starting my 80s !. 👍🔱🇮🇳🔱🚩🔱
Akshaysharma1342 …… I agree with prof.Datt…. Compare with other RK Movies ,..Music of
Joker” = songs are not of that high “Quality “! They also received Late & limited popularity ! Difficult to use the right word here:’
quality’ of these songs may be quite good,and appealing ,but it is not at the level of other RK Movies ! The Classic touch of Composition and sheer originality of musical phrases created by SJ for earlier RK Movies is not evident in MNJoker. I hope some Young Generation connoisseurs of SJ’s Music see what I have experienced so deeply when their Classic Movies came out in my teenage years…. I continue my Listening and thinking about SJ & our Cinema Music till now, that is me Starting my 80s !. 👍🔱🇮🇳🔱🚩🔱
Asal me Shankar ji ka objection gate waqt daso dishao ke uchharan ko leke tha .Mannade ji ne apne interview me Abhijit Desai ko (book GANI BAJAWANI) pura kissa bataya .kafi bahas ke bad Raj Kapoor ke ashwasan par ki agar gana achha nahi laga to badme badal denge.Lekin Lataji ke gane me koi dikkat nahi hui.aur fil sabhi thik ho gaya.
Thanks for adding new information. Can you say where the book may be available. ?
@@shankerjaikishan yes The book name is GANI BAJAVANI by Abhijit Desai 2005 first edition but in Marathi .Very authentic and informative book with interview of many celebrities including Lata Mangeshkar mannade.....
If you desire I can try to send the book to you .I will search on book store and let you know .
@@Junglee64 okay sir.
Sir, with due respect to RK for giving break to SJ .They had merit therefore they scored fantastic music for many other producers /Films which were superhits coz of music.
Absolutely correct. Shanker Jaikishan paid back more than 10 times. Everyone knows that when they were charging even 5 lac, they were on payroll of RK. They were loyal to RK.
No scope for Lata in Mera naam joker
9-10 gane to c ramachandra bhi dete the before1949
Shanker Jaikishan without Rafi is ............
It is insult of Shanker Jaikishan to always relates with Raj Kapoor. Shanker Jaikishan became great due to their partnership with Mohammad Rafi. They themselves said, our bench, our main singer was Mohammad Rafi.
Interesting but your mumbling in the sentences spoiled it for me. Spoilt by your singing 😡
Why you give Lata she was cheater.
How boring. these people waste everybody's time with such stupid anecdotes which everyone knows about.
Not everyone knows. only Few like you know. Still there are large section of people who are not aware of even common news. And Jay saab, there are other videos also here.
Audience reject disgusting, boring, repeated storytelling, lacking innovative sooner or later. SJ copied from Opera House 60 to Jane Anjan 71 to lost of the creativity
This is very disgusting statement. Not only SJ, but every music director copied one or more song, it doesn't mean the empire of Shankar Jaikishan was erected on copied tunes. A sweeping statement like this is not fair.
Excellent work 👍👍👏👏❤