Homemade Gas Masks vs. Tear Gas Grenades

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @connordonnelly6746
    @connordonnelly6746 4 роки тому +560

    Everyone’s talking about how this is recommended during the Hong Kong protest...just wait till they see what’s going on now

  • @HarryBawlss
    @HarryBawlss 6 років тому +891

    Their beards compromised the seal.

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  6 років тому +240

      Probably. Still worked surprisingly wellx

    • @FirstLast-cc6cv
      @FirstLast-cc6cv 5 років тому +105

      Just an odd history fun fact: hitler once recieved severe chemical damage for this exact reason. His mustache was compromising the seal. And this is when his iconic mustache was born

    • @TeufelhundenGrunt
      @TeufelhundenGrunt 5 років тому +17

      Also they needed to add another plastic layer over their mouth to keep it from fogging up.

    • @spartanandrews2929
      @spartanandrews2929 5 років тому +1

      Okay. Delete the comment. That's cool.

    • @wedividedyou1424
      @wedividedyou1424 5 років тому +16

      @@spartanandrews2929 why the fuck would you delete any comment here? (exept your)

  • @tetanusv0dka173
    @tetanusv0dka173 8 років тому +1416

    Just a 'small' tip. Crushing up the activated carbon in a motar'npestle or ball mill would yield a higher surface area of carbon and thus end up being more effective in filtration

    • @eunjunshin9540
      @eunjunshin9540 8 років тому +43

      TetanusV0dka breathing is already difficult with the petals

    • @carsonrush3352
      @carsonrush3352 7 років тому +148

      The important surface area of the pellets is actually in the micropores and internal surfaces of the activated charcoal pellets, which can have anywhere from 300 to 1200 square meters of surface area per gram of pellets (the weight of a paper clip) (Source: "Transport Processes and Separation Process Principles" by Geankoplis). That means an amount of activated carbon weighing as much as 5 to 16 paper clips would have about the internal surface area of a football field. Each square nanometer of that football field could catch a molecule of spray. That's about 1% of a mole of spray molecules, but that's a conservative estimate.
      If you want to recharge the activated carbon, heating it up allows the adsorbed material to escape, thus preparing it to adsorb again. Just don't be nearby when the stuff comes out of your carbon. Maybe use a solar oven to heat it outside... On a windy day. Hopefully it releases slowly.
      Chemical engineering is a fun field :).

    • @Guru_1092
      @Guru_1092 7 років тому +43

      @Carson Rush
      I'd call you a nerd, but I'm going into analytical chemistry so I really can't say much. :P

    • @carolynmmitchell2240
      @carolynmmitchell2240 6 років тому +10

      Look into Robert Murray smiths video on graphene coated sand particles for filtration purposes, I think it might work as an excellent air filter

    • @JohnSmith-cu4rm
      @JohnSmith-cu4rm 6 років тому +6

      I also think hot glue would have been better than duck tape for the filtration can.

  • @matthewclausing3856
    @matthewclausing3856 6 років тому +250

    I am genuinely impressed at how well those worked, well done guys! I thought I would point out that one of the reasons military regulations insist that soldiers stay clean shaven is so that gas masks will create a total seal with their face. Civilians with beards are advised to either store an electric razor with their gas masks, or a large container of Vaseline. There is an Israeli company that makes gas masks for dogs, and in their instructions they say to shave/ trim all of the hair around the dog's neck where the mask will be creating a seal. Just food for thought.

    • @_hi_pwr
      @_hi_pwr 5 років тому

      What does the vaseline do?

    • @woahitsnick4965
      @woahitsnick4965 5 років тому +13

      JuanTheSwan I’m no expert but probably helps create a better deal by making sure your beard doesn’t flair up and mess up the seal

    • @valentinofontaine2444
      @valentinofontaine2444 5 років тому +8

      @@_hi_pwr
      is a grease like material,so when it makes contact with the edges of the mask it simply creates a seal
      so by putting you baird full of vaseline,you make sure the mask seals well

    • @bronsonleach3573
      @bronsonleach3573 Рік тому +2

      @@valentinofontaine2444 A diving mask works the best. Rubber on rubber is better than rubber on skin

    • @ApofKol
      @ApofKol Рік тому +1

      @@_hi_pwr You just mix it with adhesive and you can wax your face clean

  • @mertboyali509
    @mertboyali509 6 років тому +85

    9:05 "I CANT BELIEVE THAT WORKED!!" *Cough cough* *wheeze* *cough cough* "AUUGHHH!!!"

  • @handlemchandleson1
    @handlemchandleson1 5 років тому +1591

    love how this is recomended during the hongkong protests

    • @Khergitli
      @Khergitli 5 років тому +4

      Yeah lol

    • @mugwa5423
      @mugwa5423 5 років тому +59

      Hong Kong : goes batshit crazy on riots
      UA-cam algorithm : im gonna do whats called a pro gamer move

    • @sad_mugi_hours7550
      @sad_mugi_hours7550 5 років тому +2

      Grant Giles facs

    • @rampagerslife
      @rampagerslife 5 років тому +13

      i actually thought this was made for that until i realized this was 3 years ago

    • @scorn1111
      @scorn1111 5 років тому +5

      And chile too

  • @red_e454
    @red_e454 8 років тому +419

    "A bug bomb, but for people."

    • @Nosirrbro
      @Nosirrbro 7 років тому +12

      Thats just a bomb

    • @zaxtonhong3958
      @zaxtonhong3958 7 років тому +5

      Actual bomb vs homemade gas masks

    • @CowboybubPercussion
      @CowboybubPercussion 6 років тому +1

      depends on the bomb, frag no, gas... anything not hydrogen ..... nuclear.... that would be ilegal testing but I would guess it would vaporise it... but it could potentially be tested for resistance against radiation...

    • @Anglesso
      @Anglesso 6 років тому

      A people bomb

  • @MrAqr2598
    @MrAqr2598 2 роки тому +19

    0:16~ Introduction
    1:21~ Making the Masks
    2:36~ Making the Respirators
    4:11~ Attaching the Respirators to the Masks
    4:59~ Final Touches
    6:16~ Explanation About the Fox Five Point Three Tear Gas Grenade
    7:13~ Testing the Gas Masks
    8:56~ Discussions After the Test
    0:00~ 10:03~ Directly Inhaling the Residual Gas and the Coughing/Sneezing Fit Immediately After

  • @tommapar
    @tommapar 8 років тому +1612

    Do "Home Made Gas Masks vs. Home Made Tear Gas"

    • @jderpz23
      @jderpz23 8 років тому +113

      tommapar88 home made gas mask vs home made mustard gas

    • @PokemonDiamondUS
      @PokemonDiamondUS 8 років тому +118

      Caleb Cavender the last episode of modern rogue.

    • @animationcrate
      @animationcrate 8 років тому +37

      Homemade gas mask vs homemade nuke

    • @DaxTheOtter
      @DaxTheOtter 8 років тому +30

      animationcrate homemade hazmat suits vs homemade nuke

    • @blake6509
      @blake6509 8 років тому +36

      Homemade hasmat vs military grade nuke.

  • @iaj1410
    @iaj1410 5 років тому +56

    2:18 the face on jason made me actually piss my pants. see you guys in court

  • @corensam
    @corensam 4 роки тому +87

    Suddenly becoming more relevant than before

  • @thesillverpocketwatch704
    @thesillverpocketwatch704 2 роки тому +21

    This was an absolute MR classic. So fun to revisit after all these years.

  • @nicholaistandard9233
    @nicholaistandard9233 5 років тому +412

    Hong Kong: *Wants to know your location*

  • @LamiaDomina
    @LamiaDomina 7 років тому +205

    As an action medic with a fair deal of field experience volunteering at political events where mace is often used - there are urban legends that need to be cleared up around maalox as treatment for OC. It *is* a useful tool when applied properly. It is *not* a miracle cure and should *not* be taken as a substitute for other treatment. Liquid antacid solution provides fast-acting but *temporary* pain relief from OC. It does *not* permanently denature capsaicin, nor will it remove it from your skin any more effectively than ordinary water. Liquid antacid solution should only be used for immediate pain relief before removing the OC resin with grease-cutting soap (If available; if not, with liberal amounts of clean water) as quickly as possible. Too many people assume that they're fine after applying maalox then wind up in even worse pain when it wears off and the OC has had time to work into their pores, at which point it's nearly impossible to wash off.

    • @tunjet1707
      @tunjet1707 5 років тому +9

      LamiaDomina thanks for the info but i’m now concerned about something:
      if it’s too late and it actually gets impossible to wash off, will it be stuck in your pores forever? a friend of mine “pranked” me and sprayed pepperspray in my face a while ago. I washed it as you said with grease splitting soap, but when i take a shower or my face gets wet, there are times that i feel like the thing is still there and the water activates it, and i’m not sure if it’s because of that or for a different reason

    • @pxolqopt3597
      @pxolqopt3597 5 років тому +2

      @@tunjet1707 I'm no doctor but I think it will eventually go away. Just wash it thuroughly every day and it may go away. Or maybe it will make it worse I don't know

    • @angelmelara2074
      @angelmelara2074 5 років тому +3

      I’m to lazy to read everything you just typed

    • @lxxwj
      @lxxwj 5 років тому +9

      @@angelmelara2074 congratufuckinglations, its not even that long

    • @angelmelara2074
      @angelmelara2074 5 років тому +1

      lxxwj thank you

  • @1999colebug
    @1999colebug 8 років тому +360

    I can make this better! First, use furnace filter instead of cotton (it costs like $2 per sheet and you only need one). Then with the carbon grind it to a finer powder. That filter will stop it from getting thru and it is designed to let the maximum amount of air thru.
    Also, furnace filter is sold everywhere duct work is (ace, hardware store, Home Depot, menards, resale shop, goodwill, etc.)
    E: I wrote this 4 yrs ago when I was 18. God I sound pretentious.

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +105

      ooh, good points!

    • @jefflee4527
      @jefflee4527 5 років тому +6

      Gonna keep this in mind

    • @Roodj1
      @Roodj1 5 років тому +18

      Ya, I thought they were going to grind the charcoal, makes more surface area for chemicals to bond with. And also use a better filter then cotton, like HEPA filters or even coffee filters.

    • @lauracorcoran630
      @lauracorcoran630 3 роки тому +2

      Also you could probably make a even better gas mask with a halloween mask or a modified scuba mask and a plastic water bottle so you can take the top off

  • @schizophreniagaming1187
    @schizophreniagaming1187 5 років тому +136

    Hong Kong protestorts: *Write that down, write that down*

    • @dead-po7uf
      @dead-po7uf 5 років тому +2

      write*

    • @schizophreniagaming1187
      @schizophreniagaming1187 5 років тому

      @@dead-po7uf write, sorry about that

    • @dead-po7uf
      @dead-po7uf 5 років тому +2

      @@schizophreniagaming1187 lmao

    • @EZLN
      @EZLN 5 років тому

      Protestors not Protestants as in Christians

    • @markperry3517
      @markperry3517 4 роки тому

      5 years automatic jail term doing this in hk.

  • @thekingduckkun2013
    @thekingduckkun2013 4 роки тому +47

    Me:Can I watch Breaking Bad at my friends house?
    Mom: We have breaking bad at home
    Breaking bad at home 10:42

    • @TheJudoJoker
      @TheJudoJoker 4 роки тому

      Which one is Jesse and which one is Walt?

  • @peterwilson1380
    @peterwilson1380 7 років тому +13

    First off, huge fan. Second, damn good masks. Third is a couple of tips from research and a couple of people I know who've experimented with similar things:
    - Surgical sponges allow a better freedom of airflow while maintaining the padding effect.
    - The less movement from the charcoal the better, though a dense pack is obviously going to restrict flow.
    - Unless you have a baby-face (I say this as a fellow of the bearded brotherhood) then nothing short of a full head mask is going to provide a full seal.

  • @kaomungai2355
    @kaomungai2355 5 років тому +32

    10:05 When you walk in to the toilet that your friend just came out.

  • @ComradePhoenix
    @ComradePhoenix 4 роки тому +10

    4 years after the fact, and I never imagined this video would be relevant for a significant number of people.

  • @kittyofxcodeh700
    @kittyofxcodeh700 8 років тому +220

    When he walked out of the shed with the mask coughing it looked like a hotbox lmao

  • @Aneuo
    @Aneuo 5 років тому +23

    “Breathing slowly works!”
    *continues to laugh and shout*

  • @remsku8118
    @remsku8118 8 років тому +106

    I think it would be more practical if you used the lid of the charcoal container as the top filter and every time you change the charcoal, you just poke a few holes on the bottom of the container and screw it on the mask?

    • @javannapoli2018
      @javannapoli2018 7 років тому +9

      Jeppe77 that's, actually a really good idea haha

    • @mr.irishcat8904
      @mr.irishcat8904 6 років тому

      Jeppe77 ft

    • @boxcarz
      @boxcarz 5 років тому +7

      Make sure you don't forget the filter pad, you don't want charcoal dust in your lungs.

  • @therocknrollmillennial535
    @therocknrollmillennial535 5 років тому +29

    9:42 "I'm not gonna touch my face," he said, immediately after having touched his face.

    • @1224chrisng
      @1224chrisng 4 роки тому

      and that, my friend, is how you get the plague

  • @veganviking4929
    @veganviking4929 8 років тому +245

    Might have worked better to powder the charcoal.

    • @Booker8991
      @Booker8991 8 років тому +16

      Yeah, greater surface area, right?

    • @veganviking4929
      @veganviking4929 8 років тому +21

      Das Reich 88 True. Maybe not powdered but cut in half or lightly crushed and activate it with water first.

    • @birdplaygames
      @birdplaygames 8 років тому +18

      in gasmasks it's powdered. it will work but it can't be compressed

    • @Thalanox
      @Thalanox 8 років тому +6

      Why not just get the cotton covered in activated charcoal dust? Or, you could make a powder into a kind of mud with a little water, and then soak the cotton in the dust to impregnate the dust in the charcoal.

    • @Thalanox
      @Thalanox 8 років тому +12

      They're already using cotton.
      I'm saying that they could have powdered the charcoal into dust, and dunk the cotton into the dust. That'll help with the surface area issue.

  • @psycho5674
    @psycho5674 7 років тому +7

    "You're figuring the more you're breathing through the better, right?"
    "Uh, yeah and-"
    I'll never get over the fact that Jason didn't get to finish his statement

  • @elyeli6250
    @elyeli6250 8 років тому +33

    I used several large rockstar energy drink cans (with the resealable lids) for my filters. and used an old (and clean) vacuum cleaner hose to attach the filters to onto a carry case/satchel

    • @toddismyname6652
      @toddismyname6652 8 років тому +1

      Elijah Ellis that's really cool

    • @3rdHalf1
      @3rdHalf1 8 років тому +14

      Another way, to improve design would be, to create separate exhaling hole, to make breathing easier and to prevent re breathing of carbon dioxide.
      Basically, you could do it by cutting a hole in the mask and seal it with a peace of balloon rubber, from outside. So, the rubber flap seals the hole when inhaling and opens when exhaling(just like regular gas masks).

    • @carolynmmitchell2240
      @carolynmmitchell2240 6 років тому +1

      3rdHalf that's called a one way valve, and good idea.

    • @carolynmmitchell2240
      @carolynmmitchell2240 6 років тому +3

      3rdHalf the king of random has a video about making a one way valve using a marble and PVC pipe with a rubber gasket that the marble falls on top of.. I think it would be alot more sturdy then a rubber flap. Shit if I was designing a really nice mask I would use the solid state tesla one way valve, then you would not hear the flaps or whatever opening and closing and there would be no points of failure.

    • @boxcarz
      @boxcarz 5 років тому +1

      @@carolynmmitchell2240 The tesla valve only makes flow slower in the other direction, but doesn't stop it. You have to have moving parts if you're dealing with, say, phosgene. Though, I wouldn't trust a homemade gas mask with protecting me from an acutely poisonous gas anyway...

  • @toborer7895
    @toborer7895 5 років тому +114

    youtube recommending during the Hongkong protests:

  • @Skankhunt-dx3wj
    @Skankhunt-dx3wj 8 років тому +202

    this reminds me of 10 cloverfield lane

  • @christianaquilina5434
    @christianaquilina5434 4 роки тому +5

    8:20 is this how modern rogue tests their products for safty? Soon they ll start organising amature competitions like that!

  • @dj-d2030
    @dj-d2030 8 років тому +234

    You guys should make a book on how to do all of the stuff on the show.

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +56

      agreed!

    • @DrMakak
      @DrMakak 8 років тому +30

      Please do it and make it an e-book, I'll buy the shit out of it. Like a revised corrected version of "the anarchist cookbook".

    • @tino8442
      @tino8442 8 років тому +1

      DJ - D20 true

    • @epicpolyphony
      @epicpolyphony 7 років тому +5

      It's called the anarchist cookbook... -_-

    • @asshatmcgee149
      @asshatmcgee149 6 років тому +1

      epicpolyphony
      Yeah ,but one for the "modern age" would be nice

  • @carsonrush3352
    @carsonrush3352 7 років тому +3

    The important surface area of the pellets is actually in the micropores and internal surfaces of the activated charcoal pellets, which can have anywhere from 300 to 1200 square meters of surface area per gram of pellets (the weight of a paper clip) (Source: "Transport Processes and Separation Process Principles" by Geankoplis). That means an amount of activated carbon weighing as much as 5 to 16 paper clips would have about the internal surface area of a football field. Each square nanometer of that football field could catch a molecule of spray. That's about 1% of a mole of spray molecules, but that's a conservative estimate.
    If you want to recharge the activated carbon, heating it up allows the adsorbed material to escape, thus preparing it to adsorb again. Just don't be nearby when the stuff comes out of your carbon. Maybe use a solar oven to heat it outside... On a windy day. Hopefully it releases slowly.
    Chemical engineering is a fun field :).

  • @NDHURLER55
    @NDHURLER55 8 років тому +8

    Never, never, NEVER did I expect this to work! That is so cool!

  • @hughmungus2431
    @hughmungus2431 7 років тому +2

    2:19 THAT WAS GOLD JASON!!!!!

  • @jeanfrarugama3423
    @jeanfrarugama3423 8 років тому +53

    You guys need to have wayyyyyyyy more subscribers, this channel is great

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +7

      Thanks! We're only 2 months old, so help us spread the word?

    • @Dwarven_Soldier
      @Dwarven_Soldier 8 років тому +3

      The Modern Rogue takes determination to reply to old videos. Most big youtubers could take pointers

    • @kittyofxcodeh700
      @kittyofxcodeh700 8 років тому

      Better than gmm

  • @redactedredacted7473
    @redactedredacted7473 4 роки тому +5

    this video is more useful then i thought it was going to be when i first watched it

  • @thx2347
    @thx2347 8 років тому +308

    You guys remind me of myth busters, anyone else on the same page?

    • @Ignonym
      @Ignonym 6 років тому +15

      They're like the Mythbusters, but instead of busting myths, they just kind of bust things in general .

    • @MelonMafia1
      @MelonMafia1 5 років тому +2

      They're like Mythbusters but better

    • @divasko101
      @divasko101 5 років тому

      @@Ignonym your right

  • @Opi0id-z
    @Opi0id-z 6 років тому

    My upstairs neighbour likes making noise, loud music, partying etc, late WITH HIS WINDOWS OPEN and you guys gave me a great idea to stop their next party on a weekday. Cheers!

  • @soccerstar.
    @soccerstar. 8 років тому +61

    The 1 dislike is from someone who tried and fucked up

    • @aaronhanson7241
      @aaronhanson7241 8 років тому +10

      They probably got Sarin instead of Tear gas, rookie mistake

  • @BurgerDumpling
    @BurgerDumpling 5 років тому +37

    This is so relevant today with the protests in Hong Kong.

  • @exiiesaid8004
    @exiiesaid8004 8 років тому +18

    How do you only have 103k subs? Your channel deserves way more. Great videos guys, please keep them coming

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +9

      Thanks, Michael! We're only 2 months old, so help spread the word?

    • @Ben-mv9xc
      @Ben-mv9xc 8 років тому

      The Modern Rogue I like your Chanel a lot because your entertaining

    • @Daniel.Liddicoat
      @Daniel.Liddicoat 7 років тому

      1 year on and it's 550k

  • @AflacMan13
    @AflacMan13 8 років тому +1

    If you can't get a chem suit or one of those tychem suits... a rain suit works too. Duct tape the sleeves and openings shut. The rubber will stop the gas for a short time. The best prevention though... pre-disaster preparation and practice.

  • @jeremiahdevlin1499
    @jeremiahdevlin1499 8 років тому +70

    what about coffee filters as a holder for the charcoal?

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +38

      I like it.

    • @jeremiahdevlin1499
      @jeremiahdevlin1499 8 років тому +7

      Also have a couple of ideas for improvements but this goes to show how quick a gas mask can be thrown together with easy attainable items.

    • @orestisgrivas5434
      @orestisgrivas5434 8 років тому +15

      Modern tear gas is acidic,so a layer of baking soda or paper towels dampened with a saturated solution of baking soda would probably work great.Edit : Baking soda works on the police gas,not something you got off amazon.That's similar to pepper spray.

    • @carolynmmitchell2240
      @carolynmmitchell2240 6 років тому +1

      Orestis Grivas thankyou, maybe passing some baking soda water through the charcoal and then drying it will be effective?

  • @samson5erb312
    @samson5erb312 5 років тому +10

    10:05 is what I sounded when I got my first blunt.

  • @MrJdmboy10
    @MrJdmboy10 8 років тому +734

    Scroll to the comment section and listen to their voices and they literally sound like the Mythbusters

    • @anubisent4522
      @anubisent4522 7 років тому +1

      Ehhh sorta for me

    • @kbroh8236
      @kbroh8236 7 років тому

      BurgerBandit iopl

    • @retrofuzion1126
      @retrofuzion1126 7 років тому +1

      They kind of do

    • @kashy7309
      @kashy7309 7 років тому +1

      BurgerBandit Omg it actually does!

    • @pwnzus
      @pwnzus 7 років тому +4

      They sound like them but on helium

  • @jackmclellan7899
    @jackmclellan7899 4 роки тому +7

    Love how this is recommended during the riots and looting

  • @michaelaustin8982
    @michaelaustin8982 8 років тому +21

    I saw this on a movie "10 Cloverfield lane" they made a full hazmat suit from a shower curtain.

    • @aaronhanson7241
      @aaronhanson7241 8 років тому

      And it worked completely fine in the movie?

    • @michaelaustin8982
      @michaelaustin8982 8 років тому +4

      Well, they never actually needed it, but I can imagine it would have... You get to see some of the process used to make the suit. The mask on the other hand you really only see the finished product and that it came from bottles.

    • @RCSJ11
      @RCSJ11 8 років тому

      Michael Austin Didn't the girl need to use the suit once? She took it off when she was out of the bunker but then she got gassed and had to put the mask on and seal her suit. I always wondered if that thing would work in reality.

  • @zacharymorin5696
    @zacharymorin5696 7 років тому +2

    Ooh, this is the first time I've actually seen Zevia anywhere. Love that stuff!

    • @jerbear7952
      @jerbear7952 4 роки тому

      Zachary Morin i noticed that two :) awesome

  • @KingEhrys98
    @KingEhrys98 8 років тому +389

    Pause at 2:19. That's a profile picture if I've ever seen one.

    • @poptimusoime9166
      @poptimusoime9166 8 років тому +38

      lmfao it was perfect

    • @blake6509
      @blake6509 8 років тому +2

      Stephen Hedger oh yes.

    • @mindeltpk
      @mindeltpk 7 років тому +37

      I know that this is about 4 months late, but here's a quick thing I did for that image - i.imgur.com/9iVzTVz.png (it is 516x556 px image so for most profile pictures it should be perfect)

    • @KingEhrys98
      @KingEhrys98 7 років тому +6

      my god its beautiful.

    • @ethanhackwell441
      @ethanhackwell441 7 років тому

      Stephen Hedger tr

  • @nymalous3428
    @nymalous3428 4 роки тому +10

    I wasn't really interested in this episode when it premiered... now, in light of all of the unrest in the world, I'm suddenly keen to know how to make my own homemade gas mask.
    ...maybe I would also be interested in an episode on how to make my own tear gas too...

    • @mackenziebenedict8403
      @mackenziebenedict8403 2 роки тому

      you said that 2 years ago, jesus fuck I wonder what you think now

    • @cavemancult1999
      @cavemancult1999 2 роки тому

      @@mackenziebenedict8403 I'd say he overreacted lmao

  • @ogzephyr4166
    @ogzephyr4166 8 років тому +22

    This needs way more attention

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +1

      thanks! help us spread the word? :-)

    • @ogzephyr4166
      @ogzephyr4166 8 років тому

      The Modern Rogue
      Of course, sharing this to so many people!

    • @chipmunkafy7782
      @chipmunkafy7782 8 років тому

      like 0 people

  • @ralphtrump9487
    @ralphtrump9487 7 років тому +3

    Brillant! I love this video; however I would have done it slightly different. I would have used powered activated charcoal mixed with water containing colliodal silver. Next I would have saturated cotton gauze in the mixture and hanged it up to allow to dry. Then I would have layered the infused gauze in the can.
    I believe you hearing the pellets rattling is an indication that you were creating large enough gaps for a small amount of gas to rush pass the pellets unimpeded. The colloidal silver should keep the gauze sterile while drying and give you added protection from biological warfare as well.

  • @PowerMelone
    @PowerMelone 8 років тому +20

    i bet 100 dollars that these two will at least have 1.5 mio subs on december 1st 2017
    every video i watched i found awesome! its allready one of my favourite channels.
    greetings from Austria

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +9

      oh, man... I'd love for that to be the case.

    • @luiiisnick2148
      @luiiisnick2148 8 років тому +3

      Kann echt gut sein, dass der Channel richtig hochgeht.
      Der Content is wirklich gut und bespaßend! :D
      LG weiterer Österreicher

    • @gomey60
      @gomey60 8 років тому +5

      You know hes probably right.
      Its pretty high quality and likeable.

    • @jordanthecommander6977
      @jordanthecommander6977 7 років тому +2

      *cracks knuckles* time to make 1.1 million UA-cam accounts.

    • @jasperbryant8993
      @jasperbryant8993 7 років тому +2

      Der Dicke it's December 24 2017 and no

  • @zahn_1244
    @zahn_1244 4 роки тому +1

    "I think I need to leave, it's burning like lava"
    "Eh not that bad"

  • @xxpainexpertxx4481
    @xxpainexpertxx4481 8 років тому +69

    *breaking bad theme plays*

  • @gtb81.
    @gtb81. 4 роки тому +1

    needs an exhale valve (a woopy cushion flap should work for this, also needs a valve for the intake) also crushing up the charcoal (this will require a better particulate filter on top and bottom) and making a larger filter can for more surface area and ease of breathing.

  • @ethanpeters3047
    @ethanpeters3047 8 років тому +73

    inb4 someone pokes eyeholes in the mask.

  • @chrisl3780
    @chrisl3780 5 років тому +1

    The charcoal filters were gas mask used in WW1, you would have a large can with the charcoal with a tube connected to the mask

  • @MichaelEdlin542
    @MichaelEdlin542 8 років тому +570

    Fun fact, tear gas can't be used in warfare as it is deemed a chemical weapon and so is unethical. However it is perfectly legal to be used against protesting civilians. Sound about right to me?

    • @LastBastion
      @LastBastion 8 років тому +39

      more like riot mob tbh, even rubber bullet is still hurt a lot and can be lethal at close range. blank ammo still hurt a lot tho.

    • @Embattled5211
      @Embattled5211 8 років тому +118

      Michael Edlin The reason it's vanned in warfare, because the rules were made EXTREMELY general on PURPOSE. They know that if the rules were too specific, then there may have been technicalities that were legal, but against the idea of the law. (ex. a liquid that turned into gas after exposure to hot climate, that contained unconventional toxins, like red phosphate. Would be just as legal as this tear gas, but a mich deadlier effect on the soldiers.)

    • @MichaelEdlin542
      @MichaelEdlin542 8 років тому +17

      That makes sense actually! Still a bit weird the whole concept of it, but that would explain it

    • @Embattled5211
      @Embattled5211 8 років тому +22

      Michael Edlin
      I suppose it's a counter to the popular argument against the 2nd Ammendment right to bear arms. "They didn't know we would have these types of weapons".

    • @h4sh583
      @h4sh583 7 років тому +2

      used in Syria recently

  • @user-yl4hb8dg9l
    @user-yl4hb8dg9l 5 років тому +2

    the problem is that you forgot to pad the charcoal down. When you breathe in, the charcoal "dances around", and that is bad because now your airflow is bigger in between the pellets because of the bigger spaces between the pellets. That is also why it works better when you inhale slowly, because the pellets arent dancinng around so much

  • @madlad9822
    @madlad9822 5 років тому +3

    Tips:
    Crush the charcoal
    Use more
    Compress it a little better with cotton
    Reduce the number of holes
    Use a layering in between
    shave the beards

    • @bronsonleach3573
      @bronsonleach3573 Рік тому

      Beard don't need shaving. Just get a rubber diving mask it seals on that. Rubber on rubber is better than rubber on skin. Look it up

  • @xenon639
    @xenon639 6 років тому +1

    1:49 - "It's going to work great"
    8:10 - "It's very bad, it's very, very bad"

  • @savageboiduh3175
    @savageboiduh3175 5 років тому +4

    10:18 me before my friend even tells the joke😂

  • @levilevis9032
    @levilevis9032 5 років тому +1

    2:20 Jason looking like an early 3d videogame character

  • @thkiller1
    @thkiller1 8 років тому +10

    Shouldn't you be using carbon powder instead of pellets?

    • @kortax5559
      @kortax5559 8 років тому

      Wouldn't the powder fall through the air holes?

    • @thkiller1
      @thkiller1 8 років тому +2

      Jacob Andrews Don't know about this setup. Powder is usually preferred due to it's larger surface area -> it works as a better filter.

    • @ajeje1996
      @ajeje1996 8 років тому +1

      Maybe you could press it into a tissue or something

    • @wolffang489
      @wolffang489 8 років тому +1

      Large grain powder in a fine mesh would probably work.

    • @carsonrush3352
      @carsonrush3352 7 років тому +3

      The important surface area of the pellets is actually in the micropores and internal surfaces of the activated charcoal pellets, which can have anywhere from 300 to 1200 square meters of surface area per gram of pellets (the weight of a paper clip) (Source: "Transport Processes and Separation Process Principles" by Geankoplis). That means an amount of activated carbon weighing as much as 5 to 16 paper clips would have about the internal surface area of a football field. Each square nanometer of that football field could catch a molecule of spray. That's about 1% of a mole of spray molecules, but that's a conservative estimate.
      If you want to recharge the activated carbon, heating it up allows the adsorbed material to escape, thus preparing it to adsorb again. Just don't be nearby when the stuff comes out of your carbon. Maybe use a solar oven to heat it outside... On a windy day. Hopefully it releases slowly.
      Chemical engineering is a fun field :).

  • @freakingepicgamer2002
    @freakingepicgamer2002 7 років тому

    Thanks, guys! Nothing adds more to my wholesome house than the Fox Five Point Three tactical pepper spray grenades.

  • @michaelcrosby6703
    @michaelcrosby6703 8 років тому +138

    to do a control test, you need to be in their without the homemade gas mask.

    • @GgnoudpPvP
      @GgnoudpPvP 8 років тому +4

      their

    • @titaniumworks3274
      @titaniumworks3274 8 років тому +3

      Michael Crosby at the end

    • @michaelcrosby6703
      @michaelcrosby6703 8 років тому +6

      They walked in when the tear gas had allready been dispersed and when they had the door open. That is not a control test. They need to be in there with the door closed and with a new can.

    • @Excludos
      @Excludos 8 років тому +35

      Michael Crosby It's good enough when, even after most of the gas has been vented, they still couldn't enter the room without the gas masks. That's a very legit control.

    • @Thalanox
      @Thalanox 8 років тому +8

      They mentioned videos of other people being sprayed with the gas in the open. That is enough of a control, if you believe that such things happened.

  • @fcohex6148
    @fcohex6148 4 роки тому

    Consider also crushing those charcoal pellets a bit to increase their individual surface area, and reduce the airspace between the pellets.

  • @thomasponsonby2024
    @thomasponsonby2024 8 років тому +16

    well i new it wasnt going to perfect but i would rather have one of them than nothing

    • @kdogpayne452
      @kdogpayne452 8 років тому +2

      Ravenous Crow where tho

    • @BobtheHat
      @BobtheHat 8 років тому

      Thomas Ponsonby true

  • @quinntaylor1170
    @quinntaylor1170 5 років тому +1

    Jason walks out and immediately touches his face with his hands that weren't gloved the entire time

  • @3rdeye7thdimension
    @3rdeye7thdimension 8 років тому +36

    I remember when I was young and found the anarchist cookbook.

    • @teamcybr8375
      @teamcybr8375 7 років тому +1

      OuijaXIII Same.
      Did you ever see the RTAA boiling gasoline video? It was a story about finding the cookbook as a kid.

    • @MLGRDR
      @MLGRDR 6 років тому +1

      Lucky

    • @MLGRDR
      @MLGRDR 6 років тому +2

      @@teamcybr8375 I did. The guy was named Burnie and he was trying to make Napalm if I remember correctly.

    • @teamcybr8375
      @teamcybr8375 6 років тому

      @@MLGRDR Yep. Burnie Burns.

    • @mystichavin5330
      @mystichavin5330 6 років тому +2

      wait. thats illegal

  • @Duck-mm6jp
    @Duck-mm6jp 6 років тому +1

    You need to have the activated charcoal very fine and compact to prevent the chemicals from slipping through, an exhale valve could help as well

    • @Duck-mm6jp
      @Duck-mm6jp 6 років тому

      How to tell if it’s compact enough is checking if you can hear it clanking in the filter

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  6 років тому

      the exhale breaths seemed to flow out over the cheekbones rather well... as soon as we started inhaling, the seal would re-establish nicely.

  • @hunterjones6958
    @hunterjones6958 8 років тому +17

    looks like they are trying to make a homemade fallout shelter

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +12

      heh. it eventually became a chicken coop, but I see what you're putting down.

    • @Peter-rn5kl
      @Peter-rn5kl 8 років тому +1

      try using Gauze Bandage with smaller pieces of charcoal.

  • @jx592
    @jx592 6 років тому

    Certainly not tangible for thermonuclear war or intense radiation. Or even nerve gas or probably bugs too. But for tear gas and pepperspray it seems to keep them stable enough to fight the worst of its effects

  • @jefferybarnett
    @jefferybarnett Рік тому +4

    I don't remember this episode of breaking bad

  • @The18x18x
    @The18x18x 7 років тому +1

    thanks for putting the ad at the end of the video

  • @renaudjacob3244
    @renaudjacob3244 8 років тому +4

    7:29 When tha squad hotbox

  • @bradmunro7732
    @bradmunro7732 6 років тому

    Improvement for the gasmasks grind up the pellets increases surface area. Could work

  • @marcustulliuscicero9512
    @marcustulliuscicero9512 5 років тому +3

    2:19 is now my desktop background.

  • @SlickDaRippa
    @SlickDaRippa 6 років тому

    another thing is to use two filters, try doing two cans with one on each cheek, even more stuff to filter, and more clean-ish oxygen to breath, as well as putting in an exhale port that way you can breath EVEN easier

  • @jamesshaffer4755
    @jamesshaffer4755 8 років тому +4

    Hey you messed up you should crush the charcoal so there is more surface area to obsorbe

    • @Maxxplayne
      @Maxxplayne 8 років тому

      that might block the air flow..

    • @jamesshaffer4755
      @jamesshaffer4755 8 років тому +1

      The reason I said to crush the charcoal was to add surface area to bond to but the blocking airflow thing may be a slight problem

    • @carsonrush3352
      @carsonrush3352 7 років тому

      The important surface area of the pellets is actually in the micropores and internal surfaces of the activated charcoal pellets, which can have anywhere from 300 to 1200 square meters of surface area per gram of pellets (the weight of a paper clip) (Source: "Transport Processes and Separation Process Principles" by Geankoplis). That means an amount of activated carbon weighing as much as 5 to 16 paper clips would have about the internal surface area of a football field. Each square nanometer of that football field could catch a molecule of spray. That's about 1% of a mole of spray molecules, but that's a conservative estimate.
      If you want to recharge the activated carbon, heating it up allows the adsorbed material to escape, thus preparing it to adsorb again. Just don't be nearby when the stuff comes out of your carbon. Maybe use a solar oven to heat it outside... On a windy day. Hopefully it releases slowly.
      Chemical engineering is a fun field :).

  • @biosaber585
    @biosaber585 6 років тому +1

    "Feel like I'm about to commit a murder" how far you two have come

  • @kamilhernandez2543
    @kamilhernandez2543 5 років тому +4

    -Hong Kong protesters: *IS IT POSSIBLE TO LEARN THIS POWER?*

  • @adolfludendorf7415
    @adolfludendorf7415 4 роки тому +1

    Tear gas is a particulate, activated carbon (charcoal) is used against vaipour like chlorine gas so that explains the result

  • @warrdogg3376
    @warrdogg3376 8 років тому +13

    Didn't you do this on hacking the system

  • @nvshf6732
    @nvshf6732 4 роки тому +1

    Love how this is on my recommended during a pandemic. We need face masks but gas masks still work.

  • @josephchilders7292
    @josephchilders7292 6 років тому +4

    10:06 when somebody lights a cigarette next to me.

  • @davideasterling2729
    @davideasterling2729 2 роки тому

    Trying to breathe in, while covering the the vent on the filtration cannister, was how we checked for a proper seal on our gasmask in boot camp. If it sucked down onto your face, you knew you had a good fit and a proper seal... Then they made us take it off in a room filled with CS gas!

  • @raegun420
    @raegun420 5 років тому +6

    "Wats in the canista" smoke r6

  • @thecrosscloud9127
    @thecrosscloud9127 6 років тому +1

    Brian:*touchs face* "yeh im not gonna touch my face or anything" 9:38

  • @johnbrandes8345
    @johnbrandes8345 4 роки тому +6

    So sad that the basics of this could be altered for the events of now (2020)...

  • @LegendConsole
    @LegendConsole 6 років тому

    Awesome! Hope this keeps the smoke in as good as it keeps it out.

  • @andreibarra2451
    @andreibarra2451 8 років тому +36

    the one in the red shirt looks like the guy from scam school. the one with the spiky hair

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +53

      It's probably because I'm the guy from Scam School.

    • @andreibarra2451
      @andreibarra2451 8 років тому +3

      The Modern Rogue hahaha

    • @andreibarra2451
      @andreibarra2451 8 років тому +6

      I really like your videos. I also like the card tricks

    • @ModernRogue
      @ModernRogue  8 років тому +9

      awesome!

    • @enavincorporated
      @enavincorporated 8 років тому

      The Modern Rogue wow. I remeber you :D hello

  • @xx_demon999_xx
    @xx_demon999_xx 7 років тому

    If u thin the 1st layer some more and add a thin layer on top it works better because the charcoal doesnt move

  • @Jigpi
    @Jigpi 8 років тому +9

    Holy shit how have I not found you sooner 😂 you plus the guy from scam school is the best combo!

  • @jon11383
    @jon11383 6 років тому

    BRIAN!!!!! I just finished reading all of the current books in the Gentleman Bastards series (the first book is the Lies of Locke Lamora) and it is my favorite book series I have ever read and you are in for a real rollercoaster. HAVE A GREAT TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @_comrade9163
    @_comrade9163 5 років тому +8

    imagine someone in hong kong sees this

    • @gaviningrave1731
      @gaviningrave1731 5 років тому

      here i am, but the police updated there tear gas by importing it from china, so the mask is a bit useless now

  • @RileyMeta
    @RileyMeta 7 років тому

    You should retry this, but with the cotton pad on top taped into place. It could help with the filtering and movement of the Activated cotton.

  • @christopherconnor5027
    @christopherconnor5027 8 років тому +6

    looks like the suits from 10 cloverfield lane

  • @Fluffisnoterm
    @Fluffisnoterm 7 років тому

    Yo Shwood and Murphy. One thing I dug is that antacid is completely ineffective against pepper spray of any grade, because the burning is not caused by a acid compound (ergo capsaicin not being an acid). Your best is something that can dissolve fat soluble substances, like veggie oils or milk.