Why Europe Is Starting To Control Its INTERNAL BORDERS Too

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 лис 2024
  • In this episode of General Knowledge I talk about how many European Union countries like Germany, France, The Netherlands, Austria, Switzerland, Hungary, Slovenia, Romania and Bulgaria are implementing controls and checkpoints within their internal borders. Suspending the Schengen and EU Ideal of a free movement of people within the continent. And understanding why this might mean a long-term change for Europe.
    ❤️ Become a member on Patreon & get your name in the credits + exclusive content! / generalknowledge
    Stay up to date on more content from me:
    🎶 Tiktok: / general.knowledge.yt
    🐦 Twitter: / gkonyoutube
    🖼️ Instagram: / genknowledge
    ▶ Join the Discord Server: / discord
    ▶ Business Contact: gilfamc@gmail.com
    #GeneralKnowledge

КОМЕНТАРІ • 503

  • @General.Knowledge
    @General.Knowledge  14 днів тому +36

    *Do you think Europe's internal borders should be open or closed?*

    • @SmellYaLatter
      @SmellYaLatter 14 днів тому +20

      If countries can't control the amounts that reach them by land, then close them. As for a start, actually patroling and pushing back on medditeranian migrant routes most likely would fix the issue to the point the land control exept the outter EU borders, wouldn't need such measures.

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 14 днів тому

      @@SmellYaLatter Is difficult when pro Russian states like Belarus and Serbia literally dump people over the border into EU countries.

    • @dantetre
      @dantetre 14 днів тому +10

      This is a very low quality content video compared to other General Knowledge videos. :/
      Inaccurate maps, outdated maps, misleading explanations because of not paying attention to details.

    • @DavidLimofLimReport
      @DavidLimofLimReport 14 днів тому +12

      Open

    • @Spino2722
      @Spino2722 14 днів тому +15

      @@DavidLimofLimReportnah closed

  • @dantetre
    @dantetre 14 днів тому +80

    0:15 Spain is a border State.
    Ceuta and Melilla is in Africa next to Marocco and they have a 3 layered, Nato-grade fences and barbed wires surrounding them!

    • @Aydin-Adam
      @Aydin-Adam 12 днів тому +15

      That's not a Schengen border. It's Spain and Morocco

    • @olbiomoiros
      @olbiomoiros 12 днів тому +9

      yeah well tax payer money should be going back to the tax payer in quality public services, not to refugees and immigrants on benefits.

    • @Highdragonprest
      @Highdragonprest 11 днів тому

      The Muslim occupation of spain and Portugal taught them better Muslims would try to bring back al'anderlous Muslim spain or however it's spelled

    •  9 днів тому

      @@olbiomoiros Migrants pay a lot more in taxes than what migrant management takes.

  • @mybuyinginsights
    @mybuyinginsights 14 днів тому +36

    Correction: no border controls don't mean free movement. The UK had free movement before Brexit but still had border controls.

    • @Serge-cm5my
      @Serge-cm5my 12 днів тому +5

      Different situation Ireland and UK are island nations.

    • @terra7066
      @terra7066 12 днів тому +7

      He's talking about the Schengen area not the E.U.
      The Schengen area is an agreement between several countries to create a common entry and exit policy to remove border controls.
      Some EU countries like Ireland , Cyprus or Bulgaria are not members and some non EU countries like Norway are.
      Before Trudeau became the Canadian Prime Minister Canada thought about becoming a Schengen State becuase only European countries can be EU members but there is nothing in the Schengen Treaty forbidding any country in the world to become a member State.
      The UK and Ireland never signed the Schengen treaty , the European Union doesn't have a common visa and border control policy , whoever enters Ireland from outside the EU is up to Ireland and was up to the UK , the UK as an EU member could not and Ireland can not refuse entry to an European Union citizen because they signed the treaty of the European Union that gives freedom of movement to all European citizens.
      Iceland as a Schengen State can not deny entry to a Greek but can deny it to an Irish , the Irish can also deny entry to an Icelandic but can not deny it to Greek.
      Immigrants from outside the European Union , including from the Schengen area , when the UK was an EU member were an UK choice and immigrants that enter Ireland are the Irish government choice the E.U doesn't have a toss to do it and neither the Schengen area because Ireland is not a member.
      If Ireland decides not to ask entry visas to the Afghans , Chinese , Namibian or anyone else it can , they are just not allowed to travel to the other E.U countries.
      The UK had and Ireland has it's own visa and border control policies to non E.U citizens.

    • @lazrseagull54
      @lazrseagull54 12 днів тому +4

      That's because the UK never joined the Schengen zone. You can normally drive from Portugal to Finland without a passport as there haven't been checkpoints on the motorways, train stations or other roads or footpaths etc. for decades but to get into the UK, you always needed to bring a passport or EU ID card as they had booths set up to check everyone at every port, airport and train station entering or leaving the UK, even when they were in the EU. This kind of thing would be a nightmare on the continent as people living in border towns would have to bring documentation and join a queue for a checkpoint just to get to work, school, go shopping or just to visit their friend across the road. They would have to split the entire town in two. There are residential roads where the traffic lane going one direction is in Germany and going the other direction is in the Netherlands with homes and shops on both sides. Train stations would have to make space to build seperate platforms for train lines that happen to cross a border. They would have to build fences along the borders through fields and woodlands. This would just be really awkward to implement. This plan to close borders for 6 months would likely only be the case on motorways and main roads that have space for such a thing and maybe they'd have border police do random checks on trains, Which is what usually happens when they close the borders. I just can't see them building fences all over the place.

    • @jstantongood5474
      @jstantongood5474 6 днів тому

      But UK was never part of Schengen. For non EU citizen residents or non EU tourists it was practically like going to the US. For EU citizens though you are correct.

    • @mybuyinginsights
      @mybuyinginsights 5 днів тому

      @@jstantongood5474Yes, EU citizens.

  • @adamk4775
    @adamk4775 13 днів тому +12

    Good well balanced video on a pretty difficult topic. Well done!

  • @no.6660
    @no.6660 14 днів тому +65

    I hate how these rights surrounding immigration were made a long time ago by people who couldn’t possibly imagine the modern situation

    • @joãoAlberto-k9x
      @joãoAlberto-k9x 13 днів тому +3

      Don't be a hater. Be gay.

    • @BonVoyage861
      @BonVoyage861 13 днів тому

      It was all planned. Some naive people think it's all just a mistake by governments..

    • @Victorvondoom9159
      @Victorvondoom9159 13 днів тому +13

      Yeah they should be all abolished

    • @Aydin-Adam
      @Aydin-Adam 12 днів тому

      Or....maybe the modern situation is exactly what they were hoping for when they got rid of border controls.... 🤔🤔🤔

    • @onegalghadaf
      @onegalghadaf 12 днів тому

      How was the situation before different

  • @Liggliluff
    @Liggliluff 13 днів тому +19

    Borders have been temporarily closed in the Schengen area many times now. Wikipedia even have a list of when it has happened per country. It was the most prominent in 2020.

  • @robinvivalavida
    @robinvivalavida 14 днів тому +26

    Thanks for the good information pretty man

    • @Eyad_Negm
      @Eyad_Negm 14 днів тому

      Did you finish the video in 1 minute???????

    • @robinvivalavida
      @robinvivalavida 14 днів тому +5

      @@Eyad_Negm I finish a lot of things in 1 minute

    • @Eyad_Negm
      @Eyad_Negm 14 днів тому

      @@robinvivalavida sure sure (I want to be the first comment 😶‍🌫️)

    • @NotinEzugo
      @NotinEzugo 11 днів тому

      @@robinvivalavidawtf 💀

  • @pollutingpenguin2146
    @pollutingpenguin2146 14 днів тому +233

    Because Germany and Sweden fucked up big time in 2015 and now they are having buyer’s remorse.

    • @Fluxwux
      @Fluxwux 14 днів тому +1

      Sweden are even giving migrants 35 000 USD per person, and entire families over 100k USD to revoke their citizenships and residency permits to permanently leave Sweden and the EU 😮

    • @hompanit8942
      @hompanit8942 14 днів тому +6

      😊👉👈

    • @reineh3477
      @reineh3477 14 днів тому

      If countries in south and east stopped the refugees, Germany and Sweden would not have these problems. My suggestion as a Swede, send them back to Denmark and Poland, if they don't want them they should have had stronger borders in the south.

    • @Pidalin
      @Pidalin 14 днів тому +19

      Yeah, here in Czechia, we are transit country, a lot of migrants go thru our country to Germany, we are happy for all of them who are not caught by our police and it's German problem then. 😀When our police shows how many of them caught again, people in comments are like "just let them go to Germany" 😀

    • @togerboy5396
      @togerboy5396 14 днів тому +23

      @@Pidalin Bro, keep that up and the German people might want the Sudetenland back. Who’s gonna help you if you anger all your allies?

  • @jstantongood5474
    @jstantongood5474 6 днів тому +1

    It’s so good to finally see your face General knowledge. After so many years.

  • @Pawel_Mrozek
    @Pawel_Mrozek 12 днів тому +10

    In the meantime, in Poland, while we are building a 1,000 km long and 50 km wide heavily fortified line on the border with Russia and Belarus similar to DMZ in the Korea: "Heh, please kids, what do you know about closing the border and control?"

  • @komocity269
    @komocity269 10 днів тому +6

    Here is a "revollutionary" idea that some may call it "the obvious thing to do"....
    Instead of creating internal EU borders .... why not share the bill to patrol and secure external EU borders?

    • @unstoppable5357
      @unstoppable5357 4 дні тому

      Politicall class are feeling white guilt and want to make EU population young by importing workers, jokes on us people who are applying for asylum in EU doesn't really work, they just collect welfare paycheck and commit crimes, actuall workers in Germany are Eastern Europeans and Turks. Which get almost no help from goverment to be honest. Instead Changing Education system (which is no mean education, just glorified doctrination camp) results in low birth rates.

  • @aurorasun-qs1pg
    @aurorasun-qs1pg 14 днів тому +128

    Good economic times: we can help refugees
    Bad economy: Sorry we need to take care of our own

    • @akas1255
      @akas1255 14 днів тому

      If they didn't let in the invaders, they could have just kept the good economic times rolling.

    • @balmashev93
      @balmashev93 14 днів тому +42

      Refugees should work and not just sitting at home

    • @cungzjohnjohn122
      @cungzjohnjohn122 14 днів тому +27

      Well it makes sense actually.

    • @mildlydispleased3221
      @mildlydispleased3221 14 днів тому +24

      @@balmashev93 They're not allowed to work at first due to stupid asylum laws. Let them work and they will.

    • @jstressman
      @jstressman 13 днів тому +15

      The first caused the second.

  • @HahnJames
    @HahnJames 12 днів тому +3

    Good video. Great channel.

  • @YourD3estinY
    @YourD3estinY 13 днів тому +7

    The map in 0:35 is outdated Croatia has been part of Schengen since the beginning of 2023.

  • @MateuLeGrillepain
    @MateuLeGrillepain 14 днів тому +25

    Guys I spent too much time in Hawaii and I have forgotten what a land border is

    • @beth7935
      @beth7935 14 днів тому +3

      Lol, I'm an Aussie from our island state so I never knew what they were in the first place.

    • @Long_Live_Asir
      @Long_Live_Asir 13 днів тому +3

      @@beth7935Island/ continent state.

    • @jerryberry5480
      @jerryberry5480 13 днів тому +3

      Me who have lived in both Philippines and Australia. I have never thought anything about land borders lol.
      The only time I’ve ever experienced crossing a "land" border was going from Italy to France

    • @vardekpetrovic9716
      @vardekpetrovic9716 13 днів тому +2

      @@jerryberry5480 You are too young to remember when Australia bordered indonesia in western papua. Oh the young.

  • @dexterie
    @dexterie 2 дні тому

    Já tens mais um patreon :)
    Been following this channel for a while now and I really appreciate its content. Congrats :)

  • @AustrianPainter14
    @AustrianPainter14 12 днів тому +4

    It doesn’t take rocket scientist to understand why

  • @northbreeze0198
    @northbreeze0198 13 днів тому +2

    "Here's why", yeah BC it was hard to figure that one out myself :D

  • @tonysutcliffe5032
    @tonysutcliffe5032 11 днів тому +3

    Close the border's we cannot just continue to let millions of free loading gimigrants in.

  • @pieterjan29
    @pieterjan29 14 днів тому +7

    Here in Belguim we dont do on border checks for 2 reasons. 1 we cant afford it and 2 we are like the cause they check the borders XD

    • @pmichelazzo
      @pmichelazzo 13 днів тому +2

      And 3, we will not spend time with such bullshit since we have thousands of beers to taste 😉

    • @Battle.Tomato
      @Battle.Tomato 13 днів тому

      4.You need to check your highways

    • @pieterjan29
      @pieterjan29 13 днів тому

      @Battle.Tomato
      Oh believe me the road is a small problem. Big problem is the uncontrolled migration and the port of Atwerp importing drugs that goes to the rest of Europe.
      They are shooting and bomb front doors in the bigger citys.

    • @lamiss5619
      @lamiss5619 4 дні тому

      You are way too nice and friendly for this nonsense

  • @Unclekase
    @Unclekase 13 днів тому +7

    About time really. Few years late but better late than never

    • @Victorvondoom9159
      @Victorvondoom9159 13 днів тому

      Not really this is not what should have happened internal EU border controls should have never happened and are ultimately useless if people are just stopped in another EU member state, what should have happened a long time ago was massive pushbacks on all external EU borders and not allowing the migrants in the EU in the first place, but this was stopped by lef wing criminals who care more about the invaders then about Europeans

  • @Sofus.
    @Sofus. 14 днів тому +65

    Here in Denmark we have had border control since the beginning of 2016, I live near the border and there have not been any major problems.

    • @pablix_
      @pablix_ 14 днів тому +6

      Denmark was always selfish.

    • @ryboi1337
      @ryboi1337 14 днів тому +13

      ​@@pablix_borders are selfish? 😂

    • @mildlydispleased3221
      @mildlydispleased3221 14 днів тому +9

      What a stupid argument. There weren't major problems before 2016 either. "I've been drinking my own urine and I haven't been attacked by tigers, that must mean it's working."

    • @felliceteii6944
      @felliceteii6944 13 днів тому +2

      @@pablix_ How?

    • @vardekpetrovic9716
      @vardekpetrovic9716 13 днів тому

      No problem? What about the immigrant death squads from sweden that is murdering people for money in denmark?

  • @mariajoaoferrazdeabreu150
    @mariajoaoferrazdeabreu150 12 днів тому

    Great video.

  • @TweedleDean
    @TweedleDean 12 днів тому +3

    I'm not European but the Canada/US border has not been the same since September 11, 2001. Prior to that, Canadians could enter the US simply by showing some ID, not even photo ID was necessary (I think i used my birth certificate). Since then, a passport is required. The level of friendliness disappeared thanks to something that had nothing to do with Canada!
    I like the mug updates at the end.. nice job tying it in to the video's topic! ☕

  • @ThrE3-GeS
    @ThrE3-GeS 14 днів тому +3

    as a map nerd like you i have to point out that you said bulgarias border to türkiye is controlled yet on the map the border to türkiye is not highlighted in red.
    i know an argument could be made cuz it‘s not shengen, but bulgaria and romania are only part of the airspace and internal maritime borders of the shengen area, yet their land borders are highlighted in red.

  • @phaephi
    @phaephi 10 днів тому +6

    The world belongs to everybody as long as you are a human beings you have the right to move around earth we are of the eart we live on the earth and we are buried in the earth

    • @Wherearethenukes45
      @Wherearethenukes45 10 днів тому +5

      Nope. Europe for europeans.

    • @Wherearethenukes45
      @Wherearethenukes45 10 днів тому +5

      Stop supporting the great replacement

    • @Wherearethenukes45
      @Wherearethenukes45 10 днів тому +3

      A country without anti immigration laws is no longer a sovereign nation, and therefore not a country anymore.

  • @Pidalin
    @Pidalin 14 днів тому +8

    Random police checks close to border were completely normal always, it's nothing new, people now react like if they built iron curtain again or something. 😀

    • @bridaw8557
      @bridaw8557 11 днів тому

      Yes. Just because the “EU” exists now, it is a new idea. In the past, you were checked for passport on the trains, planes, and road borders. It’s much safer for everyone, even those looking to enter.

    • @Pidalin
      @Pidalin 11 днів тому +1

      @@bridaw8557 Yes, but I meant checks already in EU and schengen, we are in schengen since I think 2007 or 2006 here in Czechia and it was always normal that you just passed border and then you could be randomly checked by german police or vice versa by our police, it's nothing new. Police is still located on border even when we are all in schengen, maybe you don't see them directly, but they are definitely somewhere near.

    • @JakkeJakobsen
      @JakkeJakobsen 11 днів тому +1

      ​@@bridaw8557I've been stopped by customs officers and/or police officers at the Norway/Sweden borders 10s of times the last 15 years. This is nothing they've just started with.

    • @ToxiCisty
      @ToxiCisty 3 дні тому

      Take care of me I’m from a third world country! You have to white liberal!

  • @zimsuk
    @zimsuk 14 днів тому +3

    You missed Denmark was the first to do it in 2016 and have been doing it since (temporarily 🤨)

  • @SenseAddict
    @SenseAddict 12 днів тому +3

    Me as a tourist might be disappointing but this solution proven that crimes are getting serious in Europe

  • @wizbobliverpool2034
    @wizbobliverpool2034 8 днів тому +1

    Hi! Quick question- why did you go away from videoscribe videos? And are video scribe videos monetised?

  • @pax_carburendiana
    @pax_carburendiana 7 днів тому +1

    Europe is not a single entity. It never was.

  • @Ivanculina1
    @Ivanculina1 12 днів тому

    Good Job

  • @weamibrahim2146
    @weamibrahim2146 12 днів тому +1

    3:48 Bulgaria and Romania aren't part of land Schengen yet. You mention it later, but here you say it as if border controls aren't supposed to be there

  • @callyral
    @callyral 9 днів тому +2

    What exactly is a border check like? I've only ever traveled to one other country and that was by plane. Like what documents would they ask you for if it's different for each country
    Edit: Maybe they would just ask for passport?

  • @ScarletRebel96
    @ScarletRebel96 14 днів тому +17

    We all know why to be honest , when your a country and bad talk and mistreat your own citezins who are already struggling while letting thousands if not millions of others in then this kind of thing is inevitable

  • @abcdefg4160
    @abcdefg4160 12 днів тому +1

    Correction: Croatia is in the Schengen area.

  • @dantetre
    @dantetre 14 днів тому +4

    3:45 Romania is not a full member of Schengen, it has to be controlled on land, a.k.a. on the Hungarian-Romanian border...
    Same is true between Greece and Bulgarian.

  • @PapilioArgiolus
    @PapilioArgiolus 11 днів тому

    Thanks so much for very informative video 😊 Subscribed your channel 🥰
    Greetings to your Nowegian gf :)
    The Mooms are a character created by Tove Jansson from Finland 🇫🇮 my home country.

  • @joshuaatkins6452
    @joshuaatkins6452 11 днів тому +1

    Please allow the Jet Lag channel to be exempt from this😂😂😂

  • @realhawaii5o
    @realhawaii5o 14 днів тому +7

    For some reason, I've been randomly checked at the borders of Latvia as of recent. As I'm Portuguese, so from Schengen, it doesn't affect me that much, but it's still rather silly.

  • @Got-lander
    @Got-lander 14 днів тому +1

    Big time border checks in the Suwałki gap between Lithuania and Poland.

  • @gui18bif
    @gui18bif 4 дні тому +1

    Drugs, crime and different rules between states

  • @bottleflaskan802
    @bottleflaskan802 14 днів тому +33

    Only 10 years to late🤷‍♂️

  • @pieterjan29
    @pieterjan29 13 днів тому +1

    Sad thing I realized now is that Belguim doesn't do border controlls because we are like the cause of it. Like uncontrolled migration ,failed send back policy, and the large import of Drugs by the port of Antwerp.

  • @samsonsoturian6013
    @samsonsoturian6013 14 днів тому +51

    "Migration expert" is a scam. Treat them as such.

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 14 днів тому +18

      If they study migration patterns and behaviour for years, why would they not be an expert?

    • @joshygoldiem_j2799
      @joshygoldiem_j2799 14 днів тому +2

      Source?

    • @Hardcore_Remixer
      @Hardcore_Remixer 9 днів тому +2

      ​@@archstanton6102 If their advice is bad then either they are not expert or they are a traitor, regardless not worth trusting.

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 9 днів тому +2

      @Hardcore_Remixer What are youbtalking about? Why woukd their advice be bad?
      Oscar Schindler was called a traitor, now is seen as a hero.

    • @Hardcore_Remixer
      @Hardcore_Remixer 9 днів тому +2

      @@archstanton6102 And I don't deny that he is a hero for having saved the lives of many Jews. Though, the notion of hero and traitor depends to what you regard as 'the objective'. He was obviously a traitor to the nazy because he was a hero for the Jews.
      Also, back to our current situation in EU, the fact that we opened our borders to 3rd worlders without ensuring they assimilate to our culture caused the rise of crime rate and endangered our national security.
      So, those who advised this either:
      - had no idea that their advice was bad, case in which theh do not deserve to be called experts
      - knew that what they were suggesting will bring harsh consequences, case in which they betrayed us, the very people they were supposed to serve with good advice. And no, they're not heroes because we were not putting anyone in extermination camps (which we thankfully don't even have). They didn't save anyone, but only doomed us.

  • @weamibrahim2146
    @weamibrahim2146 12 днів тому +1

    I love the way you address this sensitive topic concisely, but without a hint of bias or opinion

  • @brahmhenkins8732
    @brahmhenkins8732 5 днів тому

    It's such a shame and pity that human nature brings an end to good things. I'm afraid that free movement in the Schengen area will come to an end for a long time, if not for the rest of our lifetime.

  • @isaiahkerstetter3142
    @isaiahkerstetter3142 10 днів тому +1

    Local autonomy eases the burden of a centralized system. If the EU allows its constituent nations to protect themselves and seek their own interests, they can avoid the volatile political climate and foreign policy changes that come every 4 years in my little centralized soft empire: U.S.A.
    Let your nations be themselves. If our States were more autonomous, the whole world wouldn't hold it's breath with fear everytime we have a national election.

  • @clement2780
    @clement2780 13 днів тому

    provinces too; travellers on bus tours river cruises , ocean excursions should be rxempt

  • @a6mzero474
    @a6mzero474 14 днів тому +12

    I m from Germany from a border region, de controls aren t effective, we have a very leftside chancllor who had to do the controls of the border because of inner pressur, but he did it in a way that migrants still can come in without problems

    • @azelucy1798
      @azelucy1798 13 днів тому +3

      Yeah germany cant do shit borders are huge that would be so expensive

    • @Victorvondoom9159
      @Victorvondoom9159 13 днів тому

      I mean Germany shouldn't have to do any border controls it has only internal EU borders so that shouldn't be the problem at all because the migrants should be stopped before setting foot on EU soil the fault of this is the NGOs financed by the left wing German government and them attacking frontex and border states who do pushbacks actually solving the problems

    • @Hardcore_Remixer
      @Hardcore_Remixer 9 днів тому

      ​​@@azelucy1798 But could still be enforced by sending the illegal migrants away instead of giving them freebies when spoting them inside Germany.

  • @DanielK0428
    @DanielK0428 13 днів тому +17

    Good decision finally. People in the west finally noticed that Europe is Europe and not Africa

    • @Natogoon
      @Natogoon 11 днів тому +2

      Internal border restrictions is economic suicide for the already faltering European economies.
      We need more cooperation on matters of security and defense to create a rock solid external border, patrolled by a pan-European border force, and keep our internal borders open for trade.

    • @abeeceedee1842
      @abeeceedee1842 8 днів тому

      It would be smarter to work together economically and work on unity and free movement. The internal border controls can be removed if we deport all illegal immigrants and reprocess previous applications.

    • @RandMantearTheDragon
      @RandMantearTheDragon 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@Natogoonin the 2000's EU and US about the same. Now the US is double EU. And dgp per actual European is down and has no children to earn money to pay for twice the elderly. So EU has already committed economic suicide.

  • @FinnishKnight
    @FinnishKnight 12 днів тому +1

    I'm glad european countries are finally realizing the risks of immigrants. It's a shame that in countries like Sweden it's too late

    • @jacobwitt2070
      @jacobwitt2070 11 днів тому +1

      I wouldn't say "too late" but it would require an economically intensive solution, and it wouldn't happen without them being labelled racist or xenophobic.

  • @UserVVV69
    @UserVVV69 12 днів тому +2

    After immigrants destroyed their contries they just realized to close the borders 😂

  • @DLeadVox
    @DLeadVox 9 днів тому +1

    💛💛💛

  • @eden0115
    @eden0115 13 днів тому +7

    The best part of living in Japan is that is a completely isolated archipelago 😂

    • @joãoAlberto-k9x
      @joãoAlberto-k9x 13 днів тому +2

      It is a neocolony from U.S.A. as many others lands of the Earth.

    • @d3nny_s3mpai
      @d3nny_s3mpai 13 днів тому +7

      ​@@joãoAlberto-k9x "Colony of U.S.A"
      Dood you sound just like my incompetent dad 🤔

    • @joãoAlberto-k9x
      @joãoAlberto-k9x 6 днів тому +1

      @@d3nny_s3mpai Have you father? Very interesting.
      Don't worry. Be gay in your colony.

    • @joãoAlberto-k9x
      @joãoAlberto-k9x 6 днів тому +1

      Of or from is a colony or neocolony. I knew "your" neocolony many years ago. Where i am now is a neocolony too. I traveled all the world. My ❤ to you.

  • @Kaito028
    @Kaito028 14 днів тому +68

    It's one thing if countries accept immigrants, but it's another thing if the immigrant population wants to assimilate into the culture and value of those countries.

    • @hompanit8942
      @hompanit8942 14 днів тому

      huh, isnt the goal with immigrants to assimilate em into society?

    • @KINduz3jp
      @KINduz3jp 14 днів тому +9

      💯

    • @Jo-vp5kr
      @Jo-vp5kr 14 днів тому

      Some current illegal migrations are allegedly orchestrated by states to cause internal instability and distract populations (i.e., boats sitting idle in the Mediterranean; Eastern European migrations with specific gender-based roles: men for labor, women for sex work; increased criminal-related migration, unlike the predominantly student-based migrations of the '80s and '90s).

    • @stuarttunstead6616
      @stuarttunstead6616 13 днів тому +2

      Surely you would want them to assimilate into the culture and values of their new home country?

    • @ysb08
      @ysb08 13 днів тому +4

      Integration is allways better than assimilation. Why should people stop speaking their native tongue and stop living their culture and/or religion because they settled in another country? As long as you live accordingly to law, basic culture and speak the language or English youre fine

  • @DenshaOtoko2
    @DenshaOtoko2 9 днів тому +1

    I guesse Portugal and Greece or Malta?

  • @robertyoung2661
    @robertyoung2661 7 днів тому +1

    In exchange for the trillions of euros that flow East and South, sadly very little is coming in return.

  • @Pan_European_Paganist_Movement
    @Pan_European_Paganist_Movement 12 днів тому +2

    We really need an explanation why... 🙄

  • @WPGJetsf3sion2008
    @WPGJetsf3sion2008 4 дні тому

    Finally they're doing the right thing and I'm not conservative.

  • @ChristaFree
    @ChristaFree 9 днів тому +3

    In the 80s the EU didn't exist. I lived there. There used to not be any visa requirements for travel but there was always borders where you had to show a passport. France was the first country to require a visa, if I remember correctly, but we knew a back country road from Germany to France. There was never any of this open travel between countries without having to give a passport at the borders. The exception were those back country roads, but there were very few of those. The visa requirements started because Palestinian terrorists were blowing up Europe in the 80's, they've been terrorists for decades. I got taught how to look for a car bombs when I was in the 7th grade.
    Europe was way better then, pre EU, than it is now. My last trip was in 2018 and I don't think I'll ever return. It wasn't safe walking alone after dark, couldn't even leave my hotel room. What a shame, it used to be great. I grew up there.
    You're kinda off on your facts honey.

  • @SkyTheHusky
    @SkyTheHusky 13 днів тому

    Correction: Romania and Bulgaria's border checks are imposed by Austria, even if they have nothing to do with said borders. Romania and Bulgaria do not want these border checks.

  • @WhitRose97
    @WhitRose97 13 днів тому +2

    This makes a lot of sense now. I have traveled twice in the past year and experienced border checks. I took a bus from France to Poland with 0 checks. On the return trip we were stopped and passport check not once, but twice within Germany and a third time upon arrival in France. I took a bus to Italy from France last month without a border check on the way there but on the way back into France we had to pull over and every single person and bag (including our luggage under the bus) was taken off the bus and checked.

  • @yorgunsamuray
    @yorgunsamuray 13 днів тому +2

    Well, not in a very short time...but I assume that EU will disband one of these days. It might turn into a purely economic union like the old EEC, but I think it'll eventually happen.

    • @tealkerberus748
      @tealkerberus748 12 днів тому

      Or the conflict with Russia will inspire them to work more closely together. Monitoring movement across borders is aimed at controlling people who are not citizens, not those who are. It's a very effective way to slow down spies and saboteurs - now they have to have adequate fake ID to travel from one country to the next, whereas before they could go wherever they pleased once they got inside the EU.

  • @Feynman.R
    @Feynman.R 11 днів тому +1

    This is very sad

  • @lukesalazar9283
    @lukesalazar9283 14 днів тому +6

    Good.

  • @PatSmashYT
    @PatSmashYT 13 днів тому +13

    When your capital is only like 40% the native population, then there is a serious issue

    • @musicmann83
      @musicmann83 10 днів тому +3

      Not really. We are all human, grow up

    • @Scr3wgermanyandtheeu
      @Scr3wgermanyandtheeu 10 днів тому +2

      @@musicmann83 then by your logic america shouldnt be for native americans. Europe for its natives, europeans.

    • @Scr3wgermanyandtheeu
      @Scr3wgermanyandtheeu 10 днів тому +2

      @@musicmann83 found the great replacement supporter

  • @joshuacollins5022
    @joshuacollins5022 10 днів тому +1

    But when America does it we're racist 😒

  • @HistoryPhilologistDude
    @HistoryPhilologistDude 14 днів тому +5

    why don't you mention Switzerland?

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 14 днів тому +11

      Not part of EU and their situation has not changed.

    • @noahbrock349
      @noahbrock349 14 днів тому +2

      @@archstanton6102 Although it is in Schengen. The EU and Shengen are not synonymous. Ireland is in the EU but cannot be a member of Shengen since it shares a Common Travel Area with Britain.

    • @HistoryPhilologistDude
      @HistoryPhilologistDude 14 днів тому +1

      @@archstanton6102 Switzerland is a "European Country"! Check out the title! ;)

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 14 днів тому +1

      @noahbrock349 thanks for clarification. I had not realised this.
      Andorra is not but both neighbours are.

    • @HistoryPhilologistDude
      @HistoryPhilologistDude 14 днів тому +1

      @@archstanton6102 Norway isn't EU too but in Europe.

  • @babulapiderazi1924
    @babulapiderazi1924 13 днів тому +5

    Because its based

  • @roberthancox
    @roberthancox 12 днів тому +25

    If you are unable to control who enters and leaves then you are no longer a sovereign state and therefore no longer a country.

    • @lazrseagull54
      @lazrseagull54 12 днів тому +10

      That's been outdated for decades. It's like saying if you don't have a city wall with a Knight at the gate controlling who enters and leaves, then you are no longer a city.

    • @TMandarinka
      @TMandarinka 12 днів тому

      no country on earth had border controls until 1914

    • @jackismname
      @jackismname 11 днів тому +3

      You may technically be correct but like if any of these countries wanted to they could (and obviously are) close their borders.

  • @ferretyluv
    @ferretyluv 10 днів тому

    Anyone who’s ever tried to do a roadtrip across Europe knows they’ve always had hard borders. Those damn vignettes are so annoying. We don’t even need a special vignette to go to Canada or Mexico, just a passport, so why are your Euro highways so garbage?

  • @MuriKakari
    @MuriKakari 4 дні тому

    So wait, does that mean we can actually get passport stamps now?

  • @OctavioOrtiz-q4f
    @OctavioOrtiz-q4f 7 днів тому +1

    Could you do a video on South Yemen the only communist country in the Arabian peninsula

  • @romancernjak
    @romancernjak 3 дні тому

    Croatia has been Schengen since Jan 2023

  • @piellamp
    @piellamp 11 днів тому +1

    u scored a banger against aston villa keep it up bro

  • @Aydin-Adam
    @Aydin-Adam 12 днів тому +1

    in September 2018 I was stopped at a border checkpoint in a small border town on the France-Italy border in the Alps. So, they've been largely open but there has been some control for a while. Mainly looking for smugglers who tend to take roads less frequently traveled, where there aren't cameras monitoring the roads

  • @thecrazyyoutuber2017
    @thecrazyyoutuber2017 14 днів тому

    Interesting

  • @johnhemphill1938
    @johnhemphill1938 14 днів тому

    I didn't hear the alarm

  • @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co
    @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co 14 днів тому +1

    Is that your dog in the background?

  • @askadia
    @askadia 14 днів тому +12

    In my opinion, we European should have one union-level police body, consisting in police units from single member states, that patrols external EU borders, and reports directly to an European law enforcement agency. During hard times (and another Trump presidency on the horizon), we should unite more, not get fragmented like whimsical schoolboys.

    • @joshygoldiem_j2799
      @joshygoldiem_j2799 14 днів тому +2

      NOOOOOOO NO NO NO NO NO think about the right-wingers😆😆

    • @SmellYaLatter
      @SmellYaLatter 14 днів тому +1

      @joshygoldiem_j2799 think of what lol? Majority of EU's right wing blocks starting with EPP as center right, have very little objections in getting countries more unilateraly involved with policing outter EU borders. The 2021 Belarussian border crisis proved that Frontex and NGO were either toothless or actively putting border countries and the EU in danger with their decision making "skills" when confronted with methods of hybrid warfare such as artificially induced migrant border crisis.

    • @puraLusa
      @puraLusa 14 днів тому +1

      That would be a good idea but certain borders are impossible to do that, like the ones who literally cross someone's house etc. It's why the concept of open borders between members started. Also, between certain members even when there were strict borders the locals would cross daily without any check, cause it's impossible to control big borders.

  • @weamibrahim2146
    @weamibrahim2146 12 днів тому +1

    0:43 map is outdated tho

  • @taldje7672
    @taldje7672 12 днів тому +1

    random like if you look midle eastern or not

  • @fortheloveofmusic860
    @fortheloveofmusic860 9 днів тому +3

    They all do it under pressure of right wing parties. In Germany the centrist-left wing government did afraid to lose ground to the conservative and far right parties. France the same.
    In The Netherlands it's being implemented by our far right-populist government because they convinced themselves we have an asylum seekers crisis (the influx hasn't been as low as it has been in years, but it suits their asylum-seekers-and-muslims-are-to-blame-for-everything framing).

  • @C5Dynamite
    @C5Dynamite 12 днів тому +2

    Islam is right about women

    • @santaanna5002
      @santaanna5002 4 дні тому

      How is this relevant to anything that's been said in the video

  • @sunny2355
    @sunny2355 12 днів тому +1

    They shall BORDER CHECK everyone !!!!!

  • @pietjepuk7463
    @pietjepuk7463 14 днів тому +49

    Why? Look at what happened in Amsterdam tonight...

    • @archstanton6102
      @archstanton6102 14 днів тому +10

      You mean after the taxi was trashed and Palestinian flag burnt the night before?

    • @edelweiss7928
      @edelweiss7928 14 днів тому +7

      No actually that was a rare good thing

    • @noahbrock349
      @noahbrock349 14 днів тому +15

      @@pietjepuk7463 Exactly. The terrible consequences of open borders.

    • @basvriese1934
      @basvriese1934 14 днів тому

      lol, that is in no way relevant at all. Some Isreali's got triggered because a lot of people in Amsterdam support palestine. These Isrealis then did vandalism which resulted in backlash from the local populace. I hope you are aware that these Isreali football supporters are almost guaranteed to have come by plane and thus have been checked when entering the country. What happened has absolutely nothing to do with border controls...

    • @SmellYaLatter
      @SmellYaLatter 14 днів тому +18

      ​@@archstanton6102 a burnt rag doesn't mean you're free to beat people up lol

  • @hufflepuffjoh
    @hufflepuffjoh 10 днів тому

    0:35 I'm sorry but you coukd uave used a more uo to date version of the map. Croatia is now part of Schengen. And of course the UK is not EU anymore

  • @luizbomfim2840
    @luizbomfim2840 14 днів тому +12

    A questão é muito simples. Você deixa a porta da sua casa aberta? Todos podem entrar? Não né. Fim da discussão.

  • @JxH
    @JxH 14 днів тому +1

    Brexit is contagious.

  • @ann-mariturkia7828
    @ann-mariturkia7828 14 днів тому

    That's not a guy fishing on the cup, it's a woman 😅 Too-Tiki is her name

  • @dcseain
    @dcseain 4 дні тому

    As an American, this feels petty on the part of the EU members.

    • @branko4033
      @branko4033 12 годин тому

      Last time I checked, illegal immigration wasn't exactly welcome in the States, was it?

    • @dcseain
      @dcseain 8 годин тому

      @@branko4033 It used to be, but people near the Mexican Border and the rural states we on the coasts refer to as "flyover states" are strongly opposed. As most of the "illegal"(more properly "undocumented") are refugees, refusing them goes against everything we were founded on, and for a Christian majority nation, it's also unChristian, IMHO.

    • @branko4033
      @branko4033 5 годин тому

      @@dcseain
      You may have a point there, even though you can't blame everything on flyover country and the rednecks.
      MAGA is not exactly without support in the coastal states, is it?
      And, while the US is a federation, a state in and as of itself, the EU is a loose confederation of nation-states. State lines controls in the US, if they existed, may be seen as petty. Border controls between nation states who don't always see eye to eye is something completely different.

  • @destro4157
    @destro4157 14 днів тому +10

    I want to ask why didnt they just guard their outer border ?

    • @General.Knowledge
      @General.Knowledge  14 днів тому +12

      They do! Frontex monitors the EU's external borders.

    • @Frahamen
      @Frahamen 14 днів тому +2

      They very much do.

    • @JxH
      @JxH 14 днів тому +5

      Installing fence posts into the Mediterranean Sea is very difficult. They tend to just tip over and sink.

    • @destro4157
      @destro4157 13 днів тому +2

      Oh ok thanks guys

    • @abeeceedee1842
      @abeeceedee1842 8 днів тому

      They care more about public relations than effective border defense. They often take in illegal immigrants to look humanitarian.

  • @Iomhar
    @Iomhar 12 днів тому +1

    Schengen is dead.

  • @EdT.-xt6yv
    @EdT.-xt6yv 10 днів тому +1

    David benatar's ANTINATALISM,,,

  • @PaulSmith-zt7ix
    @PaulSmith-zt7ix 14 днів тому +1

    Please do episode on Mediterranean boat patrols and ocean immigration

  • @alter-nator
    @alter-nator 7 днів тому +1

    Schengen made sense before 2015

  • @stiglarsson8405
    @stiglarsson8405 4 дні тому

    I do love the idea of Shengen free travle area.. its like USA, exept they have states and we (EU+associated) have countrys, all with our own legslation/rules.. kinda our own laws/rules for living in a specefik country! And who can use that countrys kinda social systems!
    At first.. Schengen is soo good, that we dont need to pay for custome control anymore.. so lower budget for custom control and less personel! It was a misstake!
    Its still this that every country need to know who is living in there country.. who have legal causes to be there, have acces to social systems, and who shall pay taxes/fees to that country!
    In anyway there is a lot of people that doe honest jobs in one country but lives in another.. the prime country to know is probably Luxemburg.. half of there working force lives outside Luxemburg.. becuse they cant afford living there!
    Another thing with open borders is that criminals altso can use that.. so crime gangs/drug dealers can live in one country and manage gang members in different countrys!
    Then to another topic.. tax avoidant, one can move to/register in another country with lower taxes.. or one can move to another country and tell your tax agency that you moved out.. but never register in the new country! Those seldome become a problem.. if one is rich enough, and have private insurance!
    An other big problem is refugees.. or rather they is a problem.. Schengen was not set up for them.. it was set up for us Schengen area citicens!
    And they come to Greece, Italy and Spain as there first destination.. its owerveling for those countrys to handle all refugees and many of those refugees have set there sight on more prosperus countrys.. or one where there is a relative!
    Soo whats my conclusion.. spend more money on border/custom control.. to make Schengen work, use more intelligens, foto every car that pass a border! Foto everyone that pass the border by hiden cameras/use AI to keep tracks of any suspicius person!

  • @z0phi3l
    @z0phi3l 14 днів тому +5

    unpopular opinion, but this whole open borders thing was never going to work, no matter what the EU claimed

  • @1Pasha1492
    @1Pasha1492 14 днів тому +1

    💜❤️💜