back then, there's this way of movement that is always present in dance animation of virtual group that makes it so unnatural. that "way of movement" is slowly getting less and less as I watch virtual groups in different generations, it's becoming more natural akin to how humans dance movements. one of the reasons why this is so smooth imo.
@Saeram MR Removed i said similar because it's not completely the same, as siu needed to take a break while doing the highnote.. plus, the avatars' heads were not moving as hard as the demo (maybe to make it look realistic as they were 'singing') so.. i would say that it's similar, but not the same even if both are the final version
@@NitaCassie They were one of many people who did, yes. Under Freeminds cover video it says this: Choreography by: FreeMind 채다솜 @fm_dasomm_, 김태우 @kasper0524, 조나인 @nain_jerkfamily. So yes, Nain was part of this, you're right.
I really appreciate the effort made to produce the AI idol but I believe the technique is still underdeveloped. The movement of the demo is just much powerful.
It's not animation it's motion capture the people behind the idols are real dancers and singers but using motion capture, if you don't believe there's a short behind the scenes clip showing the real people doing the motion capture
Me too. It's really hard to dance with the same energy and smooth movements. But still. Practice makes Perfect😘💪 I think some stretching routine can help with better movements
@@maryjane0198 true! Who is your bias? Mine is siu🤭😁 I know the whole dance now, but when I actually try to do it it's hard, but like u said, practice makes perfect.
@@imgonnaslay. I'm totally new here so I'm trying to figure out who is who. But I'm obssesed with rap parts and her diction and dynamic (Marty?). Makes my heart dancing ❤️
fr but ig it's cuz they trynna promote MAVE as a real Kpop group. their content revolves around them in the practice room, them talking about training for their debut etc....
@@nightxmoon8294 Not really...it is ten times better with 'AI' (though there are real people behind the group, and too such much work or people behind it) because, 1. We can have privacy for the idols, 2. No underage idols, or diets. And 3., more promotion for animators, and a general good concept. But if you want real idols, go watch them.
That choreography was uploaded on the channel where they show the demo choreographies, probably being a group made with artificial intelligence, they preferred not to modify the choreography, as they usually do in many cases with other groups. 😚
@@seodan1306 pretty sure the demo is from Nain Choreography, the Freemind one was the final used for the motion tracking which is why they're doing the same dance. so the dance went through the same thing that regular kpop dances go through (which is demos, rough drafts, then finals)
@@seodan1306 That is not artificial intelligence. This is motion capturing. Artificial intelligence is intelligence-perceiving, synthesizing, and inferring information-demonstrated by machines, as opposed to intelligence displayed by non-human animals and humans.
this is a polished draft version, one of the choreographer wrote on insta. Its up to the company that hired them to modify or adjust to suit their mocap performer.
@@elmin82 girl… she’s talking about the girl on the right where there a real girls dancing and she’s in all white… there’s no girl in all white for the AIs bffr
If the body physics and movement are smooth like K/DA More, they will be amazing. Of course, K/DA is from a game company, can't compare with it. Whatever, humans are still better. This is just a first move. Future Mave may be very exciting.
@@SHITPICKLE112 I don’t even know much about gaming but Riot Games (K/DA’s company) is one of the biggest gaming companies worldwide and have branch offices all over the world.
KDA are cartoonish, MAVE are realistic. That is totally different. They can't be compared, they have different genres. Difference difficulty when making the 3d and animation.
Omg the demo dancers did so amazing they slayed this!!!! I'm shocked at how engaging it is to watch the professional dancers, they were so in sync and all the moves just hit so hard! Amazing work 💗
The thing I like is that this allows experts in their field to shine even brighter. Kpop is very selective especially with beauty standards so someone who is amazing at singing or dancing but does not meet kpop's beauty standards may not ever get the chance to debut as an idol. Or someone who wishes to be anonymous while being able to pursue kpop as a career. By being virtual, people don't have to balance all three and keep up with it at the same time rather it becomes more focused in each part of the field. This isn't trashing Kpop. There are very talented kpop idols who excel at all three. This is simply stating that it allows for more opportunities for those who may not have the chance to debut if they do not match all three to kpop standards.
If their faces had more expression rather than a dead-pan blankness, I think it would feel a lot more natural... Like yeah it's getting better with each one of their stages, but not by much.
I have the slightest suspicion that the 3d video is the real Mave girls, that the company decided to debut them as virtual characters but that in the dance practice video they showed us at real girls
@@MarMoon16 no soy muy fan del kpop sobre tdo cuando empece con k/da o XG y (G)-idol, pero incluso en algunos lyrics que vi tienen las fotos de las k/da y no de ellas XD
Official version's eyes don't look alive and lack of facial expression so personally I still like the Demo/Original version and I don't know how many times I've watched.
@@pinkstrwbxrry4400 I understand from your point too. I was expecting AI eyes could at least wink or blink so that the AI would look better like those in game or anime. Just personal point of view after all.
я готова плакать от мысли, что с этой разрывной песней и крутой хорео могли дебютировать настоящие девушки, они бы получили огромный буст на старте карьеры, но вместо этого мы смотрим на графику... поэтому нельзя какао пускать в кейпоп, они всё развалят в погоне за модой...
Watching this video i didn't even look at the virtual version once, watching humans is actually more satisfying, girls are amazing. I wish to know who the original singers are, kind of regret it's a virtual concept, this group would be amazing as humans with those skills.
For me it was more satisfying to watch the real girls, but it’s still very interesting and impressive that this motion capture group was created. I’m sure it took an extremely talented group of people to create them.
No shade but the demo dancers ate MAVE up. Edit: “tHEY’Re aI. THoSe ArE the CHorEOgRApHeRS.” This was a light, joke comment and the people taking it seriously need to touch grass IMMEDIATELY. They got ate up like I said. Humanity scored a point finally.
@@miichaverse I’m aware this is the final version and those are the choreographers. I called them the demo dancers simply because of the labeling of their side of the video. And none of that changes that they ate MAVE up so ok I guess?
@@cosmicalsims Ok??? That doesn’t change me preferring their version just like it doesn’t change those who prefer the AI version. Especially with the amount of money behind this AI group and the fluidity with which we’ve been able to see other AI performers dance with. So they got ate up like I said. Thanks. 🤭
If there is something I hope to see improved in future videos are the hair motion and the facial expressions. I was fooled for a split second that those were live dancers, but the head gave it away. They certainly nailed the dancing, but making the hair less stiff would be amazing! Looking forward to see more from this group. :)
I think the hair motion (in the demo version) is quit good but what makes them unreal is the missing hairshadow. At other body parts, they matched the light-shadow dynamics really good!
@Pink Strwbxrry wow lol, I remember somebody wrote they also created a dance practice with these virtual idols and I guessed this "demo" version was it...haha embarrassing 😄
The real dancers definitely give off more energy, it's popping off their movements. But the augmented reality performers don't mess up their makeup or their visuals or vocals with the effort of pulling off a similar choreo, even if they haven't gotten to depicting the same energy levels as the real dancer.
Are these the girls behind the avatars? They're just as beautiful and I prefer watching them. I didn't even compare I just spent the whole time watching them.
So from an animation perspective, I think it looks off likely due to the frame rates they choose to render at, you can tell at some moves it’s feels to fast or slow. Even if it’s motion capture if you don’t render at the correct frame rate it’ll look off.
Will they go on stage in the future, clearly I like the human version so much better. The Ai version is fun but as a human I don’t feel relate plus these girls are super talented, I like their dancing energy
They are both nice. I congratulate the cgi team, the singers and the dancers with their amazing synchronicity and teamwork, this is a technological feat. The dancers on the right were amazing as well.
while its close the trouble of mocapping dance choreos is the clipping with the arms and all thats why the vibe felt super different also its not the demo but the choreo rly ate
Thinking 'bout it, the vocals are from real people. The choreography is made by people,the dance movements are graphic which is also edited by people but when it's the real people being idols we find the smallest faults within them. We don't see the real talents within them. Since they just made the visuals according to their ideals there are no issues,sigh.
cool concept but kpop's selling point is the interaction between their stars and fans. It will be interesting to see how this ends up in a few years time.
I honestly can appreciate the talent and effort needed to model and render these virtual idols, however, I actually don't get WHY people would rather "watching" them perform than watching an actual human being. It looks uncanny and devoid of emotion. It doesn´t even have the charm of vocaloids or gorillaz it's just... sad
Okay I like the group and I LOVE the song and dance but the whole time I had my eyes on the actual dancers. I think it's because I'm able to form a better connection when it's real ppl. I think I'll be a big fan of the music but not so much the group itself. I like the AI concept but we'll see
The pro about AI idol is, the company can put different singers and different dancers as one in AI model. Also, look from original person doesn't matter for them because they can make perfectly figure to AI model. So, a benefit more to company than real singers themselves.
They are not AI. They are virtual idols. Artificial intelligence is intelligence-perceiving, synthesizing, and inferring information-demonstrated by machines, as opposed to intelligence displayed by non-human animals and humans.
my confusion is still in how the "main dancer" position of this group works... is that member's dance moves more smooth because more time is spent on their animation? XD
Animation version is like a puppet show when its compared to the original dance by real human. It lacks of passion, vibe and face expression. Great jobs, cheer to the girls.
If they could reveal MAVE members and dance like how these real dancers did, the approach would have been greater to the public. The song is catchy. The real people dancing makes you feel the song more than the CGI did and part of dancing is the facial expressions and the CGI doesn't give you that. I've always seen K-pop as a whole performance including the emotions of the performers which is seen on their faces. I hope the MAVE members will be revealed soon or if not, then I don't know how long this group will last or will soon flop.
![[FreeMind] MAVE: (메이브) - Pandora (Choreography fix ver.)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t_qBGemF90U/mqdefault.jpg)
![[FreeMind] MAVE: (메이브) - Pandora (Choreography fix ver.)](/img/tr.png)
It's very fun to see how physics affects the vibe of the dance even when the choreography was literally similar
because it's not demo ver, it's final ver
back then, there's this way of movement that is always present in dance animation of virtual group that makes it so unnatural. that "way of movement" is slowly getting less and less as I watch virtual groups in different generations, it's becoming more natural akin to how humans dance movements. one of the reasons why this is so smooth imo.
@Saeram MR Removed i said similar because it's not completely the same, as siu needed to take a break while doing the highnote.. plus, the avatars' heads were not moving as hard as the demo (maybe to make it look realistic as they were 'singing') so.. i would say that it's similar, but not the same even if both are the final version
I think is just the facial expressions and hair movements, the dance is really good on the AI version
@@assTssa It's definitely good, but they aren't AI. They are animated and made with CGI. AI would be like Saejin from Superkind. Mave is all animated.
I'm sorry but even when not comparing I could tell that I liked the one with real dancers more. The power and energy I can feel emitting from them.
Also wish there was one with real dancers!
I agree the energy of the video on the right is much higher than the left
YUHHHHH
Okay so I’m not the only one who thinks Mave has no stage presence… for obvious reasons
@@Ponytheft They don't even have any talent what are u even talking-😭💀
THIS LOOKS SO HARD! Who's behind that it's very talented. This girls WERE AMAZING! ONLY MOLY, THIS LOOKS AMAZING.
ikr it takes a lot of skill to do choreography at such a pace and speed with near perfection ,so i prefer watching the demo
The girls that dance the demo are also the ones that choreographed it☺️ so yes they’re incredibly talented 😍
@@michellinkapawlowski1795 isn't that nain who choreographed this?
@@NitaCassie They were one of many people who did, yes. Under Freeminds cover video it says this: Choreography by: FreeMind 채다솜 @fm_dasomm_, 김태우 @kasper0524, 조나인 @nain_jerkfamily. So yes, Nain was part of this, you're right.
I really appreciate the effort made to produce the AI idol but I believe the technique is still underdeveloped. The movement of the demo is just much powerful.
THANK YOU! It's much better. The demo looks incredible. I really want to know who the dancers are.
Yep. They did something wrong.
lets appreciate how cool the animations are, it's almost accurate as how the real people dance
It's probably mocapped with clean up. (Cleaning up mocap data is still hard)
Rather than the dance movement, I'm more creeped out by their never blink/unnatural face the whole time..
I know, just stating how cool it is, imagine how long it took them to make that.
It’s motion capture tech
It's not animation it's motion capture the people behind the idols are real dancers and singers but using motion capture, if you don't believe there's a short behind the scenes clip showing the real people doing the motion capture
The demo people had a lot of energy, I am currently practicing this song and it's hard af,
Me too. It's really hard to dance with the same energy and smooth movements. But still. Practice makes Perfect😘💪 I think some stretching routine can help with better movements
@@maryjane0198 true! Who is your bias? Mine is siu🤭😁 I know the whole dance now, but when I actually try to do it it's hard, but like u said, practice makes perfect.
@@imgonnaslay. I'm totally new here so I'm trying to figure out who is who. But I'm obssesed with rap parts and her diction and dynamic (Marty?). Makes my heart dancing ❤️
They should have kept the formations and dance on the last chorus. Girlie doesn't need a break to breathe to belt out those notes lmao
fr but ig it's cuz they trynna promote MAVE as a real Kpop group. their content revolves around them in the practice room, them talking about training for their debut etc....
They gotta have to make it realistic yk like real idols
@@nightxmoon8294 Not really...it is ten times better with 'AI' (though there are real people behind the group, and too such much work or people behind it) because, 1. We can have privacy for the idols, 2. No underage idols, or diets. And 3., more promotion for animators, and a general good concept. But if you want real idols, go watch them.
LMAO- NAH I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE
that's not demo ver, its final ver lol
That choreography was uploaded on the channel where they show the demo choreographies, probably being a group made with artificial intelligence, they preferred not to modify the choreography, as they usually do in many cases with other groups. 😚
@@seodan1306 but i think the demo is from Nain Choreography, the one in Freemind is for the motion tracking for the animation
@@seodan1306 pretty sure the demo is from Nain Choreography, the Freemind one was the final used for the motion tracking which is why they're doing the same dance. so the dance went through the same thing that regular kpop dances go through (which is demos, rough drafts, then finals)
@@seodan1306 That is not artificial intelligence. This is motion capturing. Artificial intelligence is intelligence-perceiving, synthesizing, and inferring information-demonstrated by machines, as opposed to intelligence displayed by non-human animals and humans.
this is a polished draft version, one of the choreographer wrote on insta. Its up to the company that hired them to modify or adjust to suit their mocap performer.
The one with full white outfit took my soul,. I'm in love with her 😭 , they slayed.
@@elmin82 girl… she’s talking about the girl on the right where there a real girls dancing and she’s in all white… there’s no girl in all white for the AIs bffr
@@elmin82 오른쪽 영상은 안무가 영상입니다 😂😂 너무 귀여워
@@elmin82 the girls on the right is real theyre a dance group
@@elmin82 They are actually real though the girl in the white is named Haeun Kim all of them are professional dancers
@@elmin82bro the girls on the right are real
If the body physics and movement are smooth like K/DA More, they will be amazing. Of course, K/DA is from a game company, can't compare with it. Whatever, humans are still better.
This is just a first move. Future Mave may be very exciting.
@@SHITPICKLE112 nop
@@SHITPICKLE112 I don’t even know much about gaming but Riot Games (K/DA’s company) is one of the biggest gaming companies worldwide and have branch offices all over the world.
KDA are cartoonish, MAVE are realistic. That is totally different. They can't be compared, they have different genres. Difference difficulty when making the 3d and animation.
imo kda was alot more stiffer but then again KDA was made for a video game vs Mave
Game companies dont have very good animations most of the the time. Cinema does.
Omg the demo dancers did so amazing they slayed this!!!! I'm shocked at how engaging it is to watch the professional dancers, they were so in sync and all the moves just hit so hard! Amazing work 💗
Wow the energy from the demo is just so much better
the girl with all white really killed the choreo. I love how shes powerful but fluid at the same time
the choreographer looks like an idol omg
The thing I like is that this allows experts in their field to shine even brighter. Kpop is very selective especially with beauty standards so someone who is amazing at singing or dancing but does not meet kpop's beauty standards may not ever get the chance to debut as an idol. Or someone who wishes to be anonymous while being able to pursue kpop as a career. By being virtual, people don't have to balance all three and keep up with it at the same time rather it becomes more focused in each part of the field. This isn't trashing Kpop. There are very talented kpop idols who excel at all three. This is simply stating that it allows for more opportunities for those who may not have the chance to debut if they do not match all three to kpop standards.
우와 아바타로는 잘 안보였던 안무 디테일이 데모에서는 넘넘 잘 보여요!!!
Imagine if Iz*One continue their DD-DANCE concept 🥲
If their faces had more expression rather than a dead-pan blankness, I think it would feel a lot more natural... Like yeah it's getting better with each one of their stages, but not by much.
진짜 사람이 모션이 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
Considering how janky a lot of motion captured live stages look this is pretty damn impressive.
its kind of sad to see such great, powerful dancers and singers put in so much effort just to be replaced with AIs on stage
노래도 좋고 안무도 너무 좋음 ㅜㅜ
노래 중독성 미치겠네..
Why would you need an ai group when the dancers killed it already 😵💫
I LOVE THE CHOREO SO MUCHHHHH
I have the slightest suspicion that the 3d video is the real Mave girls, that the company decided to debut them as virtual characters but that in the dance practice video they showed us at real girls
The demo version is not this one. It's the other one.
The real people performance had way more energy and impact in it.
i love the purple light!!! it made like their hair has light a purple fade ! its so pretty
Este grupo tiene mucho potencial!!
Por favor que debuten como personaaa las necesitooo!!!😭😭💘
No se puede, el concepto del grupo es ser virtuales
Re siii, si fuera un grupo con chicas reales la romperian seguro
@@barbarabaez3971 ese es el punto, ser virtuales,
@@MarMoon16 no soy muy fan del kpop sobre tdo cuando empece con k/da o XG y (G)-idol, pero incluso en algunos lyrics que vi tienen las fotos de las k/da y no de ellas XD
pero la canción ta re buena si
Those kicks, movements, energy and presence from the dancers are just ❤️
mave would either be popular if they weren't ai or go unnoticed-
The demo snapped hard, I wasn't ready for it
I just really like the dancers in the demo
Both options are very cool. The dance is complex and impressive. The song is very beautiful.
Plot twist: The dances are the real voices behind the AL
The demo is amazing!
Боже это великолепие.....я влюбилась в эту группу😭💗💗💗💗
Хотелось бы узнать кто поет эти песни
Надеюсь когда группа распадется мы хотя бы узнаем о героях которые будут все за занавесом 😍
Очень позитивно настроены, хахаха
Official version's eyes don't look alive and lack of facial expression so personally I still like the Demo/Original version and I don't know how many times I've watched.
Cause they aren’t real people
@@이수민-m4f9y yeah, that's a great let down for a great song
the video on the right is the final version used for motion capture
Not trying to be rude or anything, but I don’t know why anyone would expect for ai characters eyes to look alive. 😂
@@pinkstrwbxrry4400 I understand from your point too. I was expecting AI eyes could at least wink or blink so that the AI would look better like those in game or anime. Just personal point of view after all.
good thing they use animated avatars, cause there is no way in hell anyone can sing live decently while dancing this choreo lmao
I Like the demo
за реальными людьми все же приятнее наблюдать 😭😭😭
я готова плакать от мысли, что с этой разрывной песней и крутой хорео могли дебютировать настоящие девушки, они бы получили огромный буст на старте карьеры, но вместо этого мы смотрим на графику... поэтому нельзя какао пускать в кейпоп, они всё развалят в погоне за модой...
If this song was performed by real human idols it would be a massive hit
Watching this video i didn't even look at the virtual version once, watching humans is actually more satisfying, girls are amazing. I wish to know who the original singers are, kind of regret it's a virtual concept, this group would be amazing as humans with those skills.
For me it was more satisfying to watch the real girls, but it’s still very interesting and impressive that this motion capture group was created. I’m sure it took an extremely talented group of people to create them.
No shade but the demo dancers ate MAVE up.
Edit: “tHEY’Re aI. THoSe ArE the CHorEOgRApHeRS.” This was a light, joke comment and the people taking it seriously need to touch grass IMMEDIATELY. They got ate up like I said. Humanity scored a point finally.
Those are literally the choreographers. This isn’t a demo
@@miichaverse I’m aware this is the final version and those are the choreographers. I called them the demo dancers simply because of the labeling of their side of the video. And none of that changes that they ate MAVE up so ok I guess?
I mean yes??? They're humans the ai aren't going to have the same energy that's a given
@@cosmicalsims Ok??? That doesn’t change me preferring their version just like it doesn’t change those who prefer the AI version. Especially with the amount of money behind this AI group and the fluidity with which we’ve been able to see other AI performers dance with. So they got ate up like I said. Thanks. 🤭
@@patrickkumi 🤦♀️
I love this part: 0:01
(Edited)
If there is something I hope to see improved in future videos are the hair motion and the facial expressions. I was fooled for a split second that those were live dancers, but the head gave it away. They certainly nailed the dancing, but making the hair less stiff would be amazing! Looking forward to see more from this group. :)
I think the hair motion (in the demo version) is quit good but what makes them unreal is the missing hairshadow. At other body parts, they matched the light-shadow dynamics really good!
@@einbaum1450 the demo version is real people though, so of the hair movement is going to be good.
@@pinkstrwbxrry4400 upsi, so you mean they only changed the faces?
@@einbaum1450 Mave, is the ai or virtual idols so they aren’t real people, while the demo version is actual people.
@Pink Strwbxrry wow lol, I remember somebody wrote they also created a dance practice with these virtual idols and I guessed this "demo" version was it...haha embarrassing 😄
The real dancers definitely give off more energy, it's popping off their movements. But the augmented reality performers don't mess up their makeup or their visuals or vocals with the effort of pulling off a similar choreo, even if they haven't gotten to depicting the same energy levels as the real dancer.
Are these the girls behind the avatars? They're just as beautiful and I prefer watching them. I didn't even compare I just spent the whole time watching them.
Lagunya candu banget.. andai mereka beneran debut real idol
Es lo mismo 🤯
I love the dance so much
Why they didn't just make it real these dancers in mv looks great and they dance so well it will be a blast if they're the one performing.
I love this song so much, BUT I can't help but to think that this sounds so much like an AESPA Song
I was thinking the same.
Я не могуууууууууууу , это прекрасно
So from an animation perspective, I think it looks off likely due to the frame rates they choose to render at, you can tell at some moves it’s feels to fast or slow. Even if it’s motion capture if you don’t render at the correct frame rate it’ll look off.
The human version is the best
Will they go on stage in the future, clearly I like the human version so much better. The Ai version is fun but as a human I don’t feel relate plus these girls are super talented, I like their dancing energy
the choreo is soooooooo good omg
the heck if they had such talented artist they should of debuted them instead of this ai nonsense
This is cool, have to say I’d like the ones on the right more though, more emotion
pretty sure the dancers here are also the mocap models for mave
They are both nice. I congratulate the cgi team, the singers and the dancers with their amazing synchronicity and teamwork, this is a technological feat. The dancers on the right were amazing as well.
The DEMO is still MUCH BETTER than the AI stuff !!!
Congrats girls !!!
Oh wow, i'm impressed when human can do the dance when pandoraaa
while its close the trouble of mocapping dance choreos is the clipping with the arms and all
thats why the vibe felt super different also its not the demo but the choreo rly ate
비교 영상 어케 편집 햇어요 대단하다
This isn’t the demo. It was a cover. The actual demo changes a lot of the official choreography.
that is not the demo, it’s just the dance practice
와 데모 짜릣행
Thinking 'bout it, the vocals are from real people. The choreography is made by people,the dance movements are graphic which is also edited by people but when it's the real people being idols we find the smallest faults within them. We don't see the real talents within them. Since they just made the visuals according to their ideals there are no issues,sigh.
the choreo looks to much better on humans.
Nain choreography is not the Demo version?
cool concept but kpop's selling point is the interaction between their stars and fans. It will be interesting to see how this ends up in a few years time.
I honestly can appreciate the talent and effort needed to model and render these virtual idols, however, I actually don't get WHY people would rather "watching" them perform than watching an actual human being. It looks uncanny and devoid of emotion. It doesn´t even have the charm of vocaloids or gorillaz it's just... sad
판도라~~이 부분 춤이 너무 좋던데 여기서 나왔구나
그건 나인이 안무에용
Okay I like the group and I LOVE the song and dance but the whole time I had my eyes on the actual dancers. I think it's because I'm able to form a better connection when it's real ppl. I think I'll be a big fan of the music but not so much the group itself. I like the AI concept but we'll see
อันที่1คือคน:ตัวปอลมอัน2คือ:คือตัวจริงครับผมฮาๆ
아직 인간의 그것도 전문댄서를 따라올려면 한참 멀었네요.
사람이 낼 수 있는 특유의 강약표현과 손가락 디테일이 아직 제대로 구현이 안됨.
빠른 동작에서 프레임이 뚝 뚝 끊어져서 똑같은 동작을 하고 있는데도 뚝딱거리는것처럼 보임.
Is not a demo it's a true
on official it's a robot on demo They are real
The pro about AI idol is, the company can put different singers and different dancers as one in AI model. Also, look from original person doesn't matter for them because they can make perfectly figure to AI model. So, a benefit more to company than real singers themselves.
They are not AI. They are virtual idols. Artificial intelligence is intelligence-perceiving, synthesizing, and inferring information-demonstrated by machines, as opposed to intelligence displayed by non-human animals and humans.
wow the choregraphy is so amazing but yet complicated too haha 😂😮
my confusion is still in how the "main dancer" position of this group works... is that member's dance moves more smooth because more time is spent on their animation? XD
i wanna fan Demo version.
2023년이 이정도. 2033년은 어떨까?
ARE YOU READY FOR CHANGE??!
조나인은 진짜 싸비 안무를 디따 잘짜네
this giving off aespa vibe this should be aespa song and don't get me wrong the song and the dance are good
omg they are soo good!❤❤ Are they the real girls behind the original choreography?
But pay close attention, the first one is very similar to Zena (MAVE) when the 2 dance videos are put together
Wow is Hard dance practic.OMG!! My fav is real human version
For anyone wondering, the dance demo is from Freemind
W O W
They both are mave
I kinda wish mave was a full human group with an AI concept instead of the idols being AI :c
They AtE
Animation version is like a puppet show when its compared to the original dance by real human. It lacks of passion, vibe and face expression. Great jobs, cheer to the girls.
If they could reveal MAVE members and dance like how these real dancers did, the approach would have been greater to the public.
The song is catchy. The real people dancing makes you feel the song more than the CGI did and part of dancing is the facial expressions and the CGI doesn't give you that. I've always seen K-pop as a whole performance including the emotions of the performers which is seen on their faces. I hope the MAVE members will be revealed soon or if not, then I don't know how long this group will last or will soon flop.