*Changes* Mina's ad-lib start at "Can~" Jihyo's ad-lib start at "Ni~" Last post-chorus ad-libs sounds very diff Listening like 100 times, 0:31 sounds like Jihyo. The 0:28 is still hard to identify
really? i get the dolby atmos file, and inverted/filtered the 1st chorus with the 3rd and both ad-libs starts in Dive 😅 drive.google.com/file/d/18BsQ1U5M97qGUAlbeXzPO2fBApc-HF0J/view?usp=drivesdk
actually, filtering the ad-libs the usual way with audacity, the “can” and “ni” don’t seem to be present, also if you slow the audio down, they sound like nayeon, i think its just from her chorus
idk what think at this point, in normal audio sounds like Sana/Momo, but in Dolby sounds like Dahyun? to be fair sounds like Dahyun but the technique is not from her, is confusing 🥲
It might be Jihyo considering how she can sound similar when singing more nasally, like in eye eye eyes or even her "you're mine" part in Kura Kura which also sounded ambiguous before dolby atmos
0:28 it could be half of the members lol, only if they ever perform this adlib live i think it should be counted, otherwise it's better not to count it
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh Basing on the Dolby Atmos Files, all the ad-libs is not in the lead layer + it's so overshadowed by the other members parts so it's unlikely to see them sing it. I may be wrong nevertheless it'll be greater if they sing it. Also if they sing the other ad-libs except those two, there is a bigger possibility that it is the credited background vocalist
![TWICE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LIKE OOH-AHH to DIVE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Xmy1kE5igK4/mqdefault.jpg)
![TWICE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LIKE OOH-AHH to DIVE]](/img/tr.png)
![[KPOP IN PUBLIC] KISS OF LIFE (키스오브라이프) 'Midas Touch'// Dance Cover by HEARTLESS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t4-SYkZ8VyQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![*Updated* "Echoes of heart" by TWICE [トゥワイス] - Filtered Vocals/ad-libs](/img/n.gif)
*Changes*
Mina's ad-lib start at "Can~"
Jihyo's ad-lib start at "Ni~"
Last post-chorus ad-libs sounds very diff
Listening like 100 times, 0:31 sounds like Jihyo. The 0:28 is still hard to identify
really? i get the dolby atmos file, and inverted/filtered the 1st chorus with the 3rd and both ad-libs starts in Dive 😅
drive.google.com/file/d/18BsQ1U5M97qGUAlbeXzPO2fBApc-HF0J/view?usp=drivesdk
@@DDP121 Mine was also taken from dolby atmos and it starts at "Can" and "Ni"
I think that 0:28 is either Jeongyeon or Tzuyu
actually, filtering the ad-libs the usual way with audacity, the “can” and “ni” don’t seem to be present, also if you slow the audio down, they sound like nayeon, i think its just from her chorus
@@ServingVocals I'm not sure cause even without filtering it's pretty noticeable on the dolby atmos. I think we have a different stems?
I love your analysis, miss you girl. ❤️
The way 0:28 it can be
Chaeyoung
Tzuyu
Sana
Nayeon
Mina
Jihyo
If that adlib was actually from dahyun she can probably take 4th-1st place
idk what think at this point, in normal audio sounds like Sana/Momo, but in Dolby sounds like Dahyun? to be fair sounds like Dahyun but the technique is not from her, is confusing 🥲
both adlibs sound like tzuyu, I mean they are the same voice, I think they are the bg vocalist
I still think it's Momo. She might be overlapping on her part.
maybe it’s Sana, in my opinion, she’s close to her in terms of technique. I don't hear Tzuyu here at all. 🤔
@@lightborn it's not nearly as nasal as sana. i think it's tzuyu
I hear jihyo in the second adlib, and the first one Chaeyoung
0:31 bgv i think
0:31 sounds like Jihyo to me even tho at first listen I thought it's Dahyun
I agree. I think it’s jihyo
0:31 sounds soo weird, it may be jihyo like you said, now I'm between her and sana, soo ambiguous, and odd for any of them to sound like that
It might be Jihyo considering how she can sound similar when singing more nasally, like in eye eye eyes or even her "you're mine" part in Kura Kura which also sounded ambiguous before dolby atmos
how do you use dolby atmos to extract adlibs from a song?
0:28 it could be half of the members lol, only if they ever perform this adlib live i think it should be counted, otherwise it's better not to count it
@@GabrielAlves-ig6wh Basing on the Dolby Atmos Files, all the ad-libs is not in the lead layer + it's so overshadowed by the other members parts so it's unlikely to see them sing it. I may be wrong nevertheless it'll be greater if they sing it.
Also if they sing the other ad-libs except those two, there is a bigger possibility that it is the credited background vocalist
0:31 why does this sound like Jeongyeon 😭
Nope, it's sound so deferen for JY
So, is there an agreement that 0:31 could be Jihyo?
it sounds more like dahyun in the dolby atmos stems actually
@@lukec2129 This filter came from the dolby atmos, at first it sounded like Dahyun but listening a lot of times it start to sounds like Jihyo.
But, the end of the ad lib is more soft..