The secret behind basic vs. advanced English | Interview with my head of content Christina

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 92

  • @rosinaiglesias-traductoral5827
    @rosinaiglesias-traductoral5827 2 роки тому +22

    The native versus non-native teachers subject is something I have discussed a lot since English started to be taught in Spain 40 years ago. My best teachers have always been non-native. Natives were only useful for conversation when Internet didn't exist. The only way to practice was traveling abroad, but most of us couldn't afford it. So we learnt a lot of grammar, but couldn't speak a word. Nowadays it is forbidden in Spain that an academy asks for a native because that discriminates most of the candidates.

    • @monicab464
      @monicab464 2 роки тому

      If it's true that it's forbidden to ask for native teachers then there has been great progress compared to some years ago. Job ads for English teachers used to be incredibly discriminatory in Spain.

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +4

      Yes, it's very discriminatory! Especially because it's not an "equal playing field". Many schools would take a native speaker with zero qualifications over a non-native speaker with all the qualifications. There are so many horror stories of native speakers becoming teachers who have absolutely no idea what they're doing because they have no teaching education. It's sad that some schools still allow it :(

  • @annavoytenko
    @annavoytenko 2 роки тому +7

    I believe other aspects like connected speech are way more important than adding a few fancy words. Thank you, Hadar, for bringing awareness to that topic! I agree with all the points you brought up. As a teacher myself, I notice some people trying to sweat about using more fancy words they picked up from short videos with minimum or no explanation at all. But what happens, really, is it sounds awkward being used in the "wrong" context. Awkward wording. Not only it confuses the person who hears it but leads to insecurities building up. We all should use the vocabulary we and our conversational partners are comfortable with. Delivering the message. Not boasting about knowing advanced phrases. Thank you so much! Discovering your channel a few years ago totally changed the way I practice English now and how I help others feel good about the way they speak!

  • @nancyl7989
    @nancyl7989 9 місяців тому

    I enjoyed this thought-provoking conversation. It also made me reflect regarding how hard we are with ourselves for not having the perfect english, but at the same time so forgiving when foreigners speak our native language even when it sounds choppy.

  • @amrhalabi2753
    @amrhalabi2753 2 роки тому +19

    Thank you so much Hadar and Christina for this episode.
    I think it's easy to fall into this trap because we want to sound fluent and advanced.
    Once I was obsessed with learning advanced vocabulary and then I had a chance to practice my advanced vocabulary with a native speaker who is teacher/polyglot and the poor lady was like "Amr please speak English, I don't understand you" 😂
    I sounded ridiculous instead of sounding advanced 😅

    • @eliot1197
      @eliot1197 2 роки тому +2

      Nice to meet Arabic person here.😂❤️
      and thanks for your story, it gives me a great nutshell.

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +3

      Thanks for watching!! I think it's great to expand our vocabulary, but also we have to expand our knowledge of how common and in what situations these words are used. One question though, after that interaction, did it cause you to become "taciturn"?? 🤣

    • @amrhalabi2753
      @amrhalabi2753 2 роки тому

      @@christina.hilton lol :D not taciturn per se, I felt a bit addled and diffident 😅

    • @jimmymcgill6138
      @jimmymcgill6138 2 роки тому +1

      @@christina.hilton taciturn, a common word used by Spanish speakers.

  • @MediaMagnetTV
    @MediaMagnetTV Рік тому

    the best teacher in the world. Thank you ma'am.

  • @linarojas4233
    @linarojas4233 2 роки тому +3

    Thank you Hadar and Christina for your reflexions about learning English process and help us to realize we need to be more kind with ourselves.

  • @VividEnglishUS
    @VividEnglishUS 2 роки тому +5

    Great conversation. From 19:47 - 21:29 I anticipated use of the word "edutainment" and was happy you both pivoted to the notion that learning can and should be fun. Agreed! ...and agreed that the "say this/not that" videos are designed to prey upon insecurities -- much like the "wear this/not that" and "eat this/not that" videos. It's a click-bait thing!

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +1

      Yep, exactly! And yes, we love to entertain 💃💃and there's a way to do that without preying upon insecurities, as you said!

  • @ekaterinaratsina4664
    @ekaterinaratsina4664 Рік тому +1

    Hi dear Hadar and Christina! I watched it several times and I can’t stop being amazed with the value that you are always bringing but especially in this video! Thank you for advocating for healthy language learning process and justice!

  • @xiaoyanli7043
    @xiaoyanli7043 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you so much Hadar and Christina for this video. I am a non-native speaker and is also a medical doctor practicing in the US. I recently discovered your channel because I want to improve my English. I am a very fluent speaker, but often feel so bad about myself when I made even the slightest mistakes in pronunciation or grammar. I am so glad to hear your thoughts on this issue. After all, language is for people to communicate and share ideas.

    • @hadar.shemesh
      @hadar.shemesh  2 роки тому

      That's right! We have to stop fearing making mistakes because it's a natural part of speaking a second language.

  • @anajimenez7719
    @anajimenez7719 Рік тому

    I totally agree with you guys, I hate how those basic vs advance videos make people feel dumb. People on those videos make it hard because when they use the "basic" vocabulary they have this silly image whereas when they use the "advanced" one they look intelligent

  • @yeroca
    @yeroca 2 роки тому +3

    As a native speaker who has been working with a non-native speaker to improve her English for several years, I can attest to the truth of what was said here. A native speaker's (at least this native speaker's) sense of how pronunciation works can be really off and wrong, despite best intentions.
    My advice to anyone who wants to work on their English with an uncertified native speaker is to work together with the native speaker to find good pronunciation teaching materials, such as Hadar's Accent's Way English and Josh's English Hacks to find specific advice for the problems you are facing. Do NOT waste time having the native speaker come up with their own explanation. This may cause you a lot of wasted time, learning the pronunciation based on an incorrect understanding. I wish we had started doing that earlier.
    My first glimpse into realizing that I had significant misunderstandings was watching Rachel's English videos, which are also quite good.

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +1

      Yep, we need to educate ourselves in order to teach! That knowledge isn't intuitive.

  • @stepstopracticeenglish
    @stepstopracticeenglish Рік тому

    Totally agree! Another day I watched one ref. "You are Welcome" and I love using YAW, which is considering... rather only say "No prob", which is even worse than say "No problem".

  • @liora80
    @liora80 Рік тому +1

    Amazing content!!! I am doing many of these mistakes such as learning more vocabulary to feel that I am making a progress in my speaking... BUT it doesn't serve me... So thank you for lighting things that I haven't seen before.
    One of the most important videos that I have ever watched in that subject of learning a language.
    Thank you!

  • @ravindradhumal8201
    @ravindradhumal8201 2 роки тому +2

    That was fantabulous, having Christina online. eye opening for critices.knowlegable for us. Thanks teacher Hadar..

  • @annarybina8818
    @annarybina8818 2 роки тому +1

    I greatly appreciate such gripping discussions on your channel! Find them both educational and entertaining🔥

  • @eh9039
    @eh9039 Рік тому +1

    Thank you so so much! This is just what I needed to hear from you guys. I was killing myself over all the BASIC vs ADVANCED contents popping up on Instagram 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️

  • @hanifebrahimi7858
    @hanifebrahimi7858 2 роки тому +1

    I love your accent, attention and the way you teach.

  • @renewal_of_the_heart
    @renewal_of_the_heart 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for such a great interview! I totally agree that you can’t teach the rules you haven’t learned (as a native speaker of English).
    So thank you for so many gooooood ideas :)

  • @estebanarango2852
    @estebanarango2852 Рік тому

    My main goal always was being able to comunicate my ideas, they know I'm not a non-native spiker

  • @panagiotispavlopoulos409
    @panagiotispavlopoulos409 Рік тому +1

    Awesome interview!!! Thank you Hadar and Christina for sharing your thoughts with us 🤩

  • @luisacuellar861
    @luisacuellar861 2 роки тому +5

    Thank you so much for creating this kind of content for us 💕

  • @bustomi4136
    @bustomi4136 Рік тому

    Finally I heard someone talked about this. I have been in a learning illusion in so so long time. I thought my English is never enough to interact with anyone speaking English.. hahaha.. but here, right here. you guys really pointed things out which is true. I hope I heard it earlier years ago. Thank you for your dedications. GBU

  • @jaganav
    @jaganav 2 роки тому

    Exquisite discussion. You're eyes in this video speak more than your words. You should be proud of how you change your student's lives. I hope you both are well. BTW, I'm still waiting for the TED talk 😉 😘

  • @leolvosMaguirre218
    @leolvosMaguirre218 2 роки тому +1

    great insights that heals my suffering from native teachers

  • @gusnarabustos2323
    @gusnarabustos2323 Рік тому

    I love her, she excelent and have learnt a lot with her

  • @marioluiscarbajofabra
    @marioluiscarbajofabra Рік тому

    I loved Hadar, but now I love Christina too.
    Great video, and I agree. Non-native teachers have helped me a lot. You, for example.
    I'm only a beginner, but I watch all your videos.
    I see you next time, in the nex video. Bye.

  • @henklooose2372
    @henklooose2372 Рік тому

    Thanks for sharing. So many thumbnail-clickbait-fishers out there. I don't like it either. But on the other hand, it's business and they create the content/thumbnails/catchy trendy topics, which "works" best (generate the most clicks. They are the currency of UA-cam). I can't and won't blame them for that. But Yeah, UA-camrs should be aware of their responsibility too. But at the end, it's all up to me. UA-cam is a business, so marketing is a big part of that. For me it's fine, and like in the "real world". Companies want to sell their products, UA-camrs their Videos. So, it's my responsibility, to decide which product I am going to buy (which channel I am going to follow) or not. BTW: I just watched the first 15 Minutes, so my comment is related to Christinas anger. And , yes, I can totally understand her "anger" and I these typical "Thumbnail-Headline-Combination", which are playing with the feeling of "Oh, really, I have to stop saying This and That, otherwise I sound uneducated", is somehow unfair. But at the,....the now the story, it marketing.
    Thanks for the Video and now I will watch the rest of the interview - dwell time is also important(: The good thing is, on the long run, quality matters most.

  • @ivanrevkov843
    @ivanrevkov843 2 роки тому +2

    Basic vs Advanced is exactly what Marina Mogilko does.

    • @hadar.shemesh
      @hadar.shemesh  2 роки тому

      I know. I never said I support that type of content. I said we have different teaching styles and philosophies. But she was still wronged. And those videos - while helpful to some - were disturbing to others. And I made that video to show those who felt bad about them that they are not alone.

  • @gedr7463
    @gedr7463 Рік тому

    I agree. Thanks. I am learning English with You

  • @jhonguerrero236
    @jhonguerrero236 Рік тому

    I'm into actually your videos about English and also i have elevate my English with your videos

  • @JohnSnow-g3n
    @JohnSnow-g3n 2 роки тому +6

    Christina is amazing! Is she a native speaker? Does she have a UA-cam channel? Thank you for the video!

    • @DawnPeacock
      @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому +1

      Yes, she's a native English speaker. I don't think she has a YT channel...

    • @JohnSnow-g3n
      @JohnSnow-g3n 2 роки тому +1

      @@DawnPeacock I love her pronunciation! 💚

    • @DawnPeacock
      @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому +1

      @@JohnSnow-g3n Yes, Christina has a nice voice and enunciates very clearly. 😊

    • @SwapperTheFirst
      @SwapperTheFirst 2 роки тому

      @@DawnPeacock I can hear some Slavic accent (speech patterns, intonation), most probably Russian.
      Also her name suggests it.

    • @DawnPeacock
      @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому

      @@SwapperTheFirst Umm, Christina Hilton? 🧐 I think you're...being humorous??

  • @supponphuaphanprasong3334
    @supponphuaphanprasong3334 Рік тому

    Thank you, this episode is very useful, it is changed my perspective.

  • @asdruvalperezgt4074
    @asdruvalperezgt4074 Рік тому +1

    I loved this conversation! ❤

  • @nahumyanez6931
    @nahumyanez6931 Рік тому

    Thank you so much for these videos, my English has improved a lot after following your channel, 🙏🏼

  • @franckemmanuelkouame6067
    @franckemmanuelkouame6067 2 роки тому

    Yep we can have some words for which we don't know the meaning but it's scare during a learning process.

  • @ashima8701
    @ashima8701 2 роки тому +2

    Thanku so much 🤗🥰

  • @mainumbyayala1104
    @mainumbyayala1104 Рік тому

    Notable entrevista. Lamento no saber el suficiente ingles como para expresarlo en ese idioma. Muchas gracias.

  • @aguypassingby1945
    @aguypassingby1945 2 роки тому +1

    U're great guys!) I am really enjoying it

  • @brendaacevedo8745
    @brendaacevedo8745 Рік тому

    I am curious about where Christina is from? Does anybody know?

  • @КатяНипорка
    @КатяНипорка 2 роки тому +1

    Is usage of the word 'like' in almost every sentence considered to be advanced English?:)

  • @gD-cp3cg
    @gD-cp3cg 2 роки тому

    It was the episode of update or what !!! Great video so true !!!
    Me if I am honest I like to watch your videos on you tube and that is it.
    I received your email but for me it is too much so I prefer choose different sort of content than always listening or watching the same people.
    I like to watch Vanessa, bob the canadian, Rich Roll, Huw Richards on the gardening, DW doc, Mossy Bottom, Lukes english podcast, to the point english with Ben, Lewis Howes, Feel better live more ... Ohhh and my best Simon Sinek a bit of optimism.
    I am sure learning is not about be better than others it is live with others !!!

  • @DerechoMegara12
    @DerechoMegara12 Рік тому

    Thank you so much

  • @aqeel994
    @aqeel994 2 роки тому

    Hi Hadar and Chritina how are you doing. I enjoyed this discussion and learn a lot. Thanks keep doing such kind of helpful videos. Thanks

  • @jeffryalmontedely
    @jeffryalmontedely 2 роки тому

    Hello Hadar, I really like your way you teach.

  • @natalie_b
    @natalie_b 2 роки тому +1

    Girls, thanks a lot for this video! I wanna sounds like you! Your speech without any brakes when you try to memorize English words, you use language so naturally.
    How to archive this kind of level? I’m stuck on my Intermediate level. I really do push my efforts to jump on new level. I’m trying to listen everyday podcasts, shows and everything in English. And i understand everything but i cannot use all this words on your own. You’re absolutely right about this. Like a dog - you understand everything but you can’t answer 😂 Second thing I’m trying to read a lot of English books without adaptation. It’s hard for me, but I think this can be valuable for future. I compare when I was a kid I read a lot of books on my mother-tongue language and then in school I had a higher language skills than other kids and of course my grammar was excellent as well.
    Does it really help me to advance my level? What do you think?

    • @ekaterinaratsina4664
      @ekaterinaratsina4664 Рік тому +1

      Dear Natalya! I can see you are passionate about the language🙂 if you want to speak, the only way is to speak more… unfortunately, at some point I was trapped with the same thought that I need to listen more, watch more and do more grammar exercises in order to speak. But it doesn’t work this way🤷‍♀️ so, start talking, even to yourself, out loud, give all that knowledge you have to finally shine out🤗

    • @natalie_b
      @natalie_b Рік тому +1

      @@ekaterinaratsina4664 thank you for your advice! Yeah I absolutely agree. I can’t find a good teacher for practice. I’ve learned for 5 years in a different schools. And since 2022 i stopped cuz I don’t see any result. I can speak of course but not fluently at all 😣

  • @anamarinarivera2404
    @anamarinarivera2404 Рік тому

    I need your courses. I have years that I trying to advance in this language

  • @DawnPeacock
    @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому

    ...Came back and finished the conversation this morning. It's interesting: As you know, I FULLY agree with you about the harmfulness of the videos that imply it's bad to use "basic" English. But durning the second half of the conversation, you said that native speakers are not criticized for mistakes. That's not my experience at all. Outside the ELT world, native English speakers tear each other apart for mistakes...sometimes actual mistakes (e.g., their/they're/there), and sometimes for violating made-up rules clung to by sticklers (e.g., don't split an infinitive). It's pretty vicious sometimes jaja 😅Haven't you seen this?

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому

      That's true! But inside the ELT industry, we aren't held to the same standards and I'd say we're granted a lot more leniency when it comes to making mistakes (grammar, typos, etc.). I also don't see people criticizing native speaking teachers if they teach a concept incorrectly, but I see it quite commonly for nonnative teachers

    • @DawnPeacock
      @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому +1

      @@christina.hilton Then you should come hang out with me. This video will be like therapy for you because you get to see me criticize a native speaking teacher for 48 minutes jaja ua-cam.com/video/im6S0HBHwSw/v-deo.html (actually I partially agree with him so it's not all criticism) 🌞🌞 But joking aside, I wonder which change you would like to see: do you want people to stop pointing out the mistakes of non-native-speaking teachers? Or would you rather see people criticize native-speaking teachers more?

  • @Sormanification
    @Sormanification 2 роки тому

    Oohhhh that basic/advanced speaker trend is really bumming me out

  • @franckemmanuelkouame6067
    @franckemmanuelkouame6067 2 роки тому

    You are more afraid when you must pass a test language for achieving a goal.

  • @canadatoday-2770
    @canadatoday-2770 Рік тому

    Could you post the episodes where native speakers made crucial mistakes in their speech? You two are not native speakers , would be interesting NNS VS NS

    • @hadar.shemesh
      @hadar.shemesh  Рік тому

      Christina is a native speaker. Born in Florida. But why does it matter?

    • @canadatoday-2770
      @canadatoday-2770 Рік тому

      @@hadar.shemesh I wish I could believe you, but Christina has tiny errors in her speech which are very typical for a non- native speaker, that is why it matters a lot

    • @canadatoday-2770
      @canadatoday-2770 Рік тому

      @@hadar.shemesh It is like teaching the math equation with errors and saying it is ok to get 3 instead of 2 in your solution, oh, it is a typo

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton Рік тому

      @@canadatoday-2770 lol - and a good reminder that native speakers are constantly making mistakes too, we just aren't as critical of them unless we suspect they are NNS 😉😉

    • @danielaprzybyszewska7397
      @danielaprzybyszewska7397 Рік тому

      @@canadatoday-2770 I personally know Christina and I can assure you that she was born and raised in the US. But if you claim you find errors even in her speech, what can nns expect? Maybe we should all stop opening our mouths.

  • @franciscojose6496
    @franciscojose6496 2 роки тому

    Channel 100%

  • @josemolina3109
    @josemolina3109 2 роки тому

    Hello Hadar how are you thank you for your class ingles

  • @ЮлияЮлия-ы7л5г
    @ЮлияЮлия-ы7л5г 2 роки тому +1

    Does Cristina know Russian?❤ I think yeah!!!

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +1

      I don't! Maybe it will be my next language to learn 🤔

    • @ЮлияЮлия-ы7л5г
      @ЮлияЮлия-ы7л5г 2 роки тому +1

      @@christina.hilton sorry, I was really sure about your knowledge of Russian 😂! By the way, I saw the videos about “use this instead of this” and never thought about them from that point of view. You’re absolutely right! Is was interesting interview. You’ve opened my eyes😘

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому

      @@ЮлияЮлия-ы7л5г hahaha I have been asked the question before, don't worry😆I'm glad to hear that!!!

  • @DawnPeacock
    @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому +1

    I share Christina's anger! I find it upsetting to see these videos telling people to replace "basic" words with fancy ones. When you learn a fancy a word out of context and try to use it, it's probably going to end up sounding odd. Preying on people's vulnerability and causing more anxiety in language learners - UNCOOL.

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +1

      Totally uncool!!!

    • @DawnPeacock
      @DawnPeacock 2 роки тому

      @@christina.hilton you might appreciate my commentary at around the 27-second mark in this video, ua-cam.com/video/D0zKPZtuq6Q/v-deo.html where I make the same point you do in this interview: NO, you don't need to memorize a bunch of fancy ways to say something (in this case, ways to respond to "have a nice day" - and in fact, if you try to, it could end up sounding awkward). 🌞🌞 Curiously, just last week I made a short from that video where I explicitly ask, IS IT OK TO USE BASIC PHRASES? (Spoiler: the answer is YES 😊😊) Maybe "basic" needs a re-branding. In some situations basic has a negative connotation...but in others, it's POSITIVE. Like, a basic wardrobe. Kitchen basics. Basic = essential. 💛

  • @Doublej53
    @Doublej53 Рік тому +1

    good good good

  • @aster1035
    @aster1035 2 роки тому +1

    I fully understand all those who are so-called 'native speakers' without any special licence earn a lot of money as English teachers in Asia. My friend-used-to-be is one of that kind, which drastically made me irritated and finally disconnected from her. Even her significant other, who had not been involved in language teaching, followed her course and has been an English teacher ever since.

    • @christina.hilton
      @christina.hilton 2 роки тому +1

      yeppppp, that REALLY pisses me off!! It is such a disservice in the industry.