As a makeup lover, I'm always excited to see these reviews of new products. BUT, even though these shadows are gorgeous, a neutral palette is a neutral palette is a neutral palette. These would be great as a 1st high end palette for someone with nothing to start with.
I have both! I think it depends on what type of looks you want to go for. Modern renaissance is a lot warmer with deep reds and oranges. The texture of the shadows is super creamy and soft - almost to a fault since there is more kick-up. A little goes a super long way and blending is a dream. The packaging is nice and oblong with a soft velvet exterior. The tartelette in bloom has a slightly drier texture in the shadows, but its still so pigmented and blends well. The vanilla smell, compact cute packaging and a large mirror are all pluses. The layout with three potential looks is nice - so well planned. I find that I use the tartelette in bloom for every-day looks (and always bring for travel) whereas the modern renaissance is perfect for a night out/date/special occasion. Hope this helps! I had the exact same dilemma this summer and ended up getting both at some point lol.
You are seriously the BEST youtuber on UA-cam. You do in depth videos. I feel like I can trust you when you talk about things. I love how you set things up! You're amazing.
I'm a big fan of this palette! I agree I wouldn't call it unique but I definitely love it. I noticed the same thing about the scent! great video as always
This looks like a lovely sophisticated palette. What Cora +VintageorTacky might call a 'grown ass woman palette'! The packaging and potentially might floral scent (?) is stunning! There's only so many neutrals I need to m though in the end, and I've only just caved in to buy the original chocolate bar palette...!
+DB I love this palette. It's more of a sweet vanilla/marshmallow type scent. I honestly love it. And yes, this is a grown ass woman palette. I already foresee going through it quickly and repurchasing.
What an enjoyable and thorough review of this palette, as always. It's a pleasure to listen to your personal thoughts on this and see the look you created. I have the original Tartelette palette in addition to all the other palettes you compared it to, but I still think I need this one as well. I agree with your opinions, and this one has more appeal to me than the first one honestly. Tarte is so amazing with their packaging too!!
I love how you present the palettes and then show how to create a look, then compare with other palettes and finally your opinion. You are so professional. I love watching your videos because I can make a choice of palette. Example: the Stardust palette. I love it. Thank you💞
Excellent review! It has been a while since I felt like I really liked all aspects of a new palette enough to consider purchasing it and this one has hit all the right buttons. Thank you for the in depth video, you really are the best reviewer on UA-cam. :)
I just got the Stardust because of how much you loved it 😀 I have to say girls night and millennial are my hands down favorite matte colors I have ever put on my lids. This is a great review and I look forward to seeing more looks from you.
Baby Belle is so so cute xx How do you not have millions of viewers? You are the very first you tuber I began watching and you are still my favourite, my go-to before I try any product. You are so down to earth, so gorgeous, give such amazing reviews and tutorials.....thank you Emily, your efforts are so very much appreciated xxxx
You know what I most love about Emily's videos ..... its the comparison of the product/s to others already in the market and the analysis. Not every 'UA-camr' provides that.... and that's what make this channel unique :) Thanks Emily!
They do smell like vanilla!! I put it on my hand today to search when it came in the mail and could smell it, even made others smell my hand and they confirmed! A fun bonus! I love this but am thinking I should contemplate the too faced natural matte as well 😉 but the tarte shadows have been a standout for me so I was excited to purchase this one.
So timely! I just ordered this a few days ago and was having second thoughts. Searched for reviews and tutorials and couldn't find any from any of the youtubers I trust... Then this popped up! Thank you!
The minute I saw this on Tarte's Instagram, I felt like this filled an eyeshadow palette hole in my life! No holiday eyeshadow palette has really intrigued me this year but this one, this one stole my heart! I didn't want an all matte palette, and I'm so glad the shimmer shadows are strong on their own.
This video and Graveyard Girls review of this palette is what made me buy it last year. I used it for 9 months straight and loved it and still do. I only wish they added one more shimmer by removing a black. Thank you for this review, Emily.
What would I ever do without your honest, unbiased reviews?! Thank you so much for cutting out the useless talk and being so honest and straight forward. I really appreciate it! Love 😙
I love your videos especially the way you present your topics. You are clear and concise. You get right into it! I think viewers really appreciate that. I will continue to be a loyal subscriber. I trust your recommendations!! Thanks.
Thank you so much for this! I wanted something like the naked 3 but warmer toned and these two palettes look great. I love how detailed you are In your descriptions and you are always so pleasant!
em, please, you are so technical with makeup, could you do a video on blushes that suits diferent skin tones? and how to define your own skin tone? i´m tired of most youtubers that while talking about a blush they simply say "i-just-love-this-so-much!!! is-so-pretty!!!" but no actual talk on the thing. i still can´t find my right tone! :(
Emily, I think you are the most helpful youtuber when the time comes to decide what to buy! seriously, your references and comparisons are always so certain, thorough and accurate! I love that you give your honest opinion and make the extra effort to helps us choose amongst the seas of amazing products! much love and appreciation!
I love that you take an extra step and add in looks that you've done utilizing the palettes you review! As a baby in makeup, it's good to see how I could use the eyeshadows if I invested my money.
i like this palette better than the original probably because i prefer the warmer colors and they usually show up better on darker skin. I find the first palette gives me a lot of ash because of the cooler colors. awesome review thank you
Hi Emily, I have been contemplating buying the Too Face natural eyes matte palette, but was hesitant for the longest time, because I need just a tiny shimmer in my life to complete a palette. You've just helped me decide! The last palette I bought and still enjoy is the Chocolate bar original. Forever grateful for your reviews. Thank you! 👍🏼😊
Great review....and you even went above and beyond in finding similar shades in other palettes .... That's why you're my favorite gal around here. Bravo, Emily!!! Job well done!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Ordered this a few days ago from Ulta and can't wait for it to arrive. So glad you did a review on it and just solidified my love of this palette already :)
You always go just that extra step in all your reviews. You compare things that I'd never think to compare and yet it makes perfect sense when you do. You are a true professional in what you do. I'm a firm believer in having passion in what you do and in every video you embody that. Thank you for all your dedication. It does not go unnoticed.
I always appreciate the in-depth reviews with the comparison swatches. It makes me take a breath, slow down, and realize that there really isn't much new under the sun. There are only so many eye shadow shades in the spectrum and even if you have 20 slightly different browns (or whatever color family), trust me they all look pretty much the same on the eyes. And I say this as a person who has waaaaay too many palettes -- definitely my biggest makeup weakness! But I haven't bought a single new palette in months because I just keep repeating my mantra: "They all look the same on the eyes." lol
Mine came in the mail on Saturday (took 2 days to ship) and I love it! I love neutrals but didn't wanna pay extra for any of the Naked palettes. Plus this palette is easier to travel with than the Naked palettes because of the shape. I also have the original Tartlette palette... I love them both!
Great in depth review. Could you show your GRWM videos with a light and then a dark lipstick? (maybe that's too much to ask) Love the deeper tones on you but they are too dark for me. Would love to see how your eyes look with the lighter lip color. Thank you for all the work you do for us.
that's soo crazzy you said that- i'm glad i'm not the only one that was smelling it. i was showing it to my mom and got a whiff of it and i couldn't stop smelling it.... i'm soooo loving this palette. the 1st one is a big fav of mine also, TARTE is killing it!!!!!
I'm happy that someone finally made a comparison of this palette with other palettes, not only with the Tartelette 1. I love watching your reviews. They are always on point, as well as the suggestions are really helpful
Amazing review! I just got this palette and it's by far the best I've ever had - colour and formula wise. The packaging is beautiful and YES, it does smell sweet - like a vanilla/chocolate combo. I've never felt such a buttery formula, and I've spent more money on other palettes.
This looks amazing! A great balance between cool and warm and just enough shimmery shades to keep it interesting. After abstaining from buying other neutral palettes because they just weren't ABSOLUTELY perfect, this just might be the one! x
I kinda see a same color scheme with the tarte greatest glitz pallete with the warm toned, cool toned, and rose gold/berry tones! I think I'd rather get the greatest glitz because it's travel friendly and has a wider color selection to choose from each color scheme
I didn't order this because I was waiting for you to review it. Now I think I would probably skip this one and get Lorac unzipped. Nice review thank you so much Emily!😊
I'm so glad you mentioned comparisons! When I first saw the shades for this palette I also thought it looked very similar to the Lorac unzipped! I think I might still get it just for the the top 2 rows and that packaging is irresistible!
Yes this palette absolutely smells like yummy marshmallows...i have been enjoying this since i bought it and can't wait to recreate the pretty looks you did with it!! Thank you! 😀💗
Well, I was watching another UA-camr do the same review, but you came up on the recommended and I clicked right over to you! I knew yours would be such an easy review to listen to.
Love your reviews! I have had this palette in my Ulta shopping cart waiting to hear more about it. Also wanted to say how beautiful and BIG Belle is. Too sweet!
I just wanna say that I love you! I am 41 and have always loved makeup but was never that good with it. I have been watching you for a few months now and my makeup look has improved so much. Thank you for what you do. Have a happy thanksgiving :)
I randomly started searching this palette to try something new and because the colors looked really pretty. I'm so glad I bought this based on your judgement emily! I bought it for my birthday in June and have been using it every time I do my eye makeup. I love this! My every day go to palette now!
Yes! I noticed the sweet smell too! I love it the smell and I love every single shade in this palette. I feel like if I was going to make a palette these are the shades I would go for. I would add a nice gold shade too but other than that I think this palette is everything I need! Thanks for the review. I especially thank you for comparing it to the too faced palette because I was considering getting that one too for the similar shades. I doubt I would wear any of those pops of purple regularly
Thanks for the great review, Emily! I've been enjoying your videos for a while now but have never commented and I wanted to let you know how much I really enjoy them. They're my late night, quiet time treat :-) Keep up the great work! As far as the palette goes, I agree that it is beautiful and of very good quality and of course, gorgeous packaging, which I'm a sucker for. What puzzles me is Tarte's marketing of this palette. Why make a palette with a gorgeous bright package, call it "In Bloom" and then offer another set of basically all neutral colors? Why not take that concept, put at least a few brighter colors in there (along with some neutrals for versatility), call it IN BLOOM and release it in Spring instead? Or if it has to be these colors, then maybe call it something less confusing? Just my two cents, but I wonder if anyone else thought of this...
I bought the In Bloom for my daughter for Christmas. I tagged her in an Instagram photo just to get her reaction to it. She was like "eh...boring." So...guess it will be mine! And the Too Faced Matte....amazing!
Finally a palette that has more mattes than shimmers! I hate how all brands only do majority shimmer with a few mattes or all matte. This is really clever regardless of the un-uniqueness of the colors.
HI Emily! I really like this palette although at first glance, it reminds me a lot of the original Too Faced Natural Eyes, my favorite. Of course the Tarte has more shades but just making me wonder if I need both. Such a pretty palette! Thanks for the great review and comparison! xo
Yes i got the new tarte contour palette and it swells like sweet vanilla! Nice addition tarte. If makeup smells cheap like that makeup smell i dont want it.
I FINALLY bought this palette. I am so in love. I almost want to throw out my drugstore palettes. lol. I'm 48 and w older lids. skin tone is neutral to warm and w blue hazel eyes. I also have dark brown hair w violet. I need something simple but w impact. I need my shades laid out as well. This palette was made for me. My daughter at 16 looks stunning in the ABH Modern palette. It's also gorgeous too. But this palette was just easier for me. Plus too many red shadows make my eyes look bloodshot.
oh gosh thats beautiful...I luv watching u...u r one of the most knowledgeable people on u tube...what r u planning for yourself when u reach a million subscribers u r almost there sweetheart and congratulations
Amazing! Your comparisons are always great, Emily, but these ones here are even more impressive! Love that you picked up the "Relevant" shades and showed them on film. Super duper helpful as always :)
You are my go to UA-camr on reviews! I was looking for a matte eyeshadow palette - wishing i 'd see the tartelette somewhere!- your video came up and i was soooo satisfied with this review! Thorough, precise! Keep up the good work Emily!
i always love watching your reviews before i purchase high end palletes because i like your taste and your opinions on the palletes and other makeup products are so spot on! i enjoy watching your reviews very much! Thank you for being so honest! :)
You are looking amazing in this video! I am loving the hair and how your eye makeup have that sultry sleepy look! Your eyes look amazing with that more almond shape
This is my go to channel for reviews, especially eyeshadow palettes, and this review was so great and so in depth, will definitely be getting this, thank you so much Emily
great review Emily! I hope more palettes come out like this because for myself and how I apply my makeup I fine I prefer to have more matte than shimmery shadows in a palette.
I was very interested in this palette, but what made the review was the comparison between other palettes! I have many of the others you mentioned (still on the fence on Vegas Nay Too Faced). Thanks so much for that!
Thanks for this comparison video. I think i like the tarte the bloom this year which I find is better than last year as it's not all matte shades. I like a few shimmers too. :)
I got this palette in the mail today but not had the chance to open it yet. I can't wait to check it out tomorrow after seeing this review. Tarte has come a very long way in the eye shadow department. I like the idea of a few shimmers thrown in although I love the original Tartlette palette with all matte shades. I love how your mind works comparing the shades with other palettes. That's one reason you're #1 on my UA-camr list! I was hoping to see a bit more of baby Belle there on the end.
This is a great video Emily!! Thank you soooo much for sharing it with us all. I was interested in this palette. I am looking for pinky and purpley shades. I really liked that you talked about the Lorac palette. I will check the Lorac palette first! Thanks again!
Amazing video!! So informative!! Thank you for comparing it to other palettes. I can't wait to get my hands on it and create some looks. I think the colors would work well with the original Tartlette as well.
out of this one, original tartelette, rainforest after dark, and noir, which would u pick if u could only pick one? what order would u put them in? I'm planning on getting one, but I just can't pick!
Great video! I love that you compared the palette to so many other palettes, it helped a lot :) I'm really interested in getting this palette since I dont have the first one. The colors are gorgeous!
Thank u for the info. Looks like a really nice all over palette. If I didn't have the first one I would probably LOVE that one. I do love that Shimmery Taupe shade!
Great review Em! This looks like a great palette. It actually appeals to me more than the original because it has those three shimmery lid shades; however knowing I have enough similar shades between my lorac unzipped and Stardust palettes, I'm going to skip for now.
Thank you so much for doing the comparison on these! I have the three other palettes that you mentioned and I wasn't sure if the Tarte one would be too redundant to add to my collection. You saved me some $$ :)
So nice to hear someone talk about makeup who's not super ditzy and annoying. love your videos!
Love the comparisons with other palettes! What a great feature -- always appreciate your thoroughness!
+skylar blannin Agreed
This. Is. So. Good!! No one else (that I know of) does these types of reviews- pros and cons, comparisons, and tutorials! Perfection! Thank you!
+Erin Pender I know right
As a makeup lover, I'm always excited to see these reviews of new products. BUT, even though these shadows are gorgeous, a neutral palette is a neutral palette is a neutral palette. These would be great as a 1st high end palette for someone with nothing to start with.
I agree- there is a lot of neutral palette overload on the market! Hope my comparisons helped
Love love love watching your reviews. You are so mellow and calming. You relax me. Lol 😄
+Heidi L. aw thank you! :D
emily? tarte bloom vs mordern renasance which is better
I have both! I think it depends on what type of looks you want to go for. Modern renaissance is a lot warmer with deep reds and oranges. The texture of the shadows is super creamy and soft - almost to a fault since there is more kick-up. A little goes a super long way and blending is a dream. The packaging is nice and oblong with a soft velvet exterior.
The tartelette in bloom has a slightly drier texture in the shadows, but its still so pigmented and blends well. The vanilla smell, compact cute packaging and a large mirror are all pluses. The layout with three potential looks is nice - so well planned.
I find that I use the tartelette in bloom for every-day looks (and always bring for travel) whereas the modern renaissance is perfect for a night out/date/special occasion.
Hope this helps! I had the exact same dilemma this summer and ended up getting both at some point lol.
Emily thank you :) ended up buying the aBH because some of the taste ones i had dupes for
Jennifer Saha cb
You are seriously the BEST youtuber on UA-cam. You do in depth videos. I feel like I can trust you when you talk about things. I love how you set things up! You're amazing.
I'm a big fan of this palette! I agree I wouldn't call it unique but I definitely love it. I noticed the same thing about the scent! great video as always
+Alexandria S (Alexandria'sMakeupmusings) oh good I'm glad I'm not just imagining things!! :D thanks for watching!
+Alexandria S (Alexandria'sMakeupmusings) I'm doing a giveaway on my channel, where I give away the Tarte Pallete she used in this video, go enter :p
I love love love the Lorac Unzipped Gold, and have been eyeing the Tartlette 2, but now I am thinking maybe Lorac Unzipped original!
This looks like a lovely sophisticated palette. What Cora +VintageorTacky might call a 'grown ass woman palette'! The packaging and potentially might floral scent (?) is stunning! There's only so many neutrals I need to m though in the end, and I've only just caved in to buy the original chocolate bar palette...!
How does in bloom compare to the original chocolate bar would you say? can I resist that gorgeous watercolor casing...?? xxx
+DB oh good question. I am now wondering the same. both look great. I widh I had the In bloom one now that I see it instead of the Tartlette. lol
Simply Kala's Life I like the look of in bloom much more than the original too - more variety!
DB yep exactly
+DB I love this palette. It's more of a sweet vanilla/marshmallow type scent. I honestly love it. And yes, this is a grown ass woman palette. I already foresee going through it quickly and repurchasing.
What an enjoyable and thorough review of this palette, as always. It's a pleasure to listen to your personal thoughts on this and see the look you created. I have the original Tartelette palette in addition to all the other palettes you compared it to, but I still think I need this one as well. I agree with your opinions, and this one has more appeal to me than the first one honestly. Tarte is so amazing with their packaging too!!
Interesting comparison between the Tarte & Stardust palette... I don't think I would have spotted the similarities.
I am soo excited for this palette!!!! super neutral I agree, but as a lover of the Tartelette palette, I need this!
I love how you present the palettes and then show how to create a look, then compare with other palettes and finally your opinion. You are so professional. I love watching your videos because I can make a choice of palette. Example: the Stardust palette. I love it. Thank you💞
There are just SO many amazing palettes coming out recently! Got to love the holidays!
Thank you for justifying my purchase lol I totally trust your judgement!
Excellent review! It has been a while since I felt like I really liked all aspects of a new palette enough to consider purchasing it and this one has hit all the right buttons. Thank you for the in depth video, you really are the best reviewer on UA-cam. :)
I just got the Stardust because of how much you loved it 😀 I have to say girls night and millennial are my hands down favorite matte colors I have ever put on my lids. This is a great review and I look forward to seeing more looks from you.
Baby Belle is so so cute xx How do you not have millions of viewers? You are the very first you tuber I began watching and you are still my favourite, my go-to before I try any product.
You are so down to earth, so gorgeous, give such amazing reviews and tutorials.....thank you Emily, your efforts are so very much appreciated xxxx
You know what I most love about Emily's videos ..... its the comparison of the product/s to others already in the market and the analysis. Not every 'UA-camr' provides that.... and that's what make this channel unique :) Thanks Emily!
They do smell like vanilla!! I put it on my hand today to search when it came in the mail and could smell it, even made others smell my hand and they confirmed! A fun bonus! I love this but am thinking I should contemplate the too faced natural matte as well 😉 but the tarte shadows have been a standout for me so I was excited to purchase this one.
So timely! I just ordered this a few days ago and was having second thoughts. Searched for reviews and tutorials and couldn't find any from any of the youtubers I trust... Then this popped up! Thank you!
The minute I saw this on Tarte's Instagram, I felt like this filled an eyeshadow palette hole in my life! No holiday eyeshadow palette has really intrigued me this year but this one, this one stole my heart! I didn't want an all matte palette, and I'm so glad the shimmer shadows are strong on their own.
This palette is beautiful!!! I always LOOOVE your reviews, Emily!! 💗💗💗💗
This video and Graveyard Girls review of this palette is what made me buy it last year. I used it for 9 months straight and loved it and still do. I only wish they added one more shimmer by removing a black. Thank you for this review, Emily.
Loved the style of this video! The similarities between other palettes and the quickie eye tutorial are a hit with me!
What would I ever do without your honest, unbiased reviews?! Thank you so much for cutting out the useless talk and being so honest and straight forward. I really appreciate it! Love 😙
I love your videos especially the way you present your topics. You are clear and concise. You get right into it! I think viewers really appreciate that. I will continue to be a loyal subscriber. I trust your recommendations!! Thanks.
Thank you so much for this! I wanted something like the naked 3 but warmer toned and these two palettes look great. I love how detailed you are In your descriptions and you are always so pleasant!
em, please, you are so technical with makeup, could you do a video on blushes that suits diferent skin tones? and how to define your own skin tone? i´m tired of most youtubers that while talking about a blush they simply say "i-just-love-this-so-much!!! is-so-pretty!!!" but no actual talk on the thing. i still can´t find my right tone! :(
this is officially on my christmas list
Emily, I think you are the most helpful youtuber when the time comes to decide what to buy! seriously, your references and comparisons are always so certain, thorough and accurate! I love that you give your honest opinion and make the extra effort to helps us choose amongst the seas of amazing products! much love and appreciation!
I love that you take an extra step and add in looks that you've done utilizing the palettes you review! As a baby in makeup, it's good to see how I could use the eyeshadows if I invested my money.
i like this palette better than the original probably because i prefer the warmer colors and they usually show up better on darker skin. I find the first palette gives me a lot of ash because of the cooler colors. awesome review thank you
Hi Emily, I have been contemplating buying the Too Face natural eyes matte palette, but was hesitant for the longest time, because I need just a tiny shimmer in my life to complete a palette. You've just helped me decide! The last palette I bought and still enjoy is the Chocolate bar original. Forever grateful for your reviews. Thank you! 👍🏼😊
Can't wait to duplicate this look for Christmas card pictures Saturday! Thanks Emily!
I'm also in love with the Unzipped palette. So flattering to my medium skin tone as well.
Great review....and you even went above and beyond in finding similar shades in other palettes .... That's why you're my favorite gal around here. Bravo, Emily!!! Job well done!! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
YASSSSS! I've been stalking every single video on this palette!
Ordered this a few days ago from Ulta and can't wait for it to arrive. So glad you did a review on it and just solidified my love of this palette already :)
You always go just that extra step in all your reviews. You compare things that I'd never think to compare and yet it makes perfect sense when you do. You are a true professional in what you do. I'm a firm believer in having passion in what you do and in every video you embody that. Thank you for all your dedication. It does not go unnoticed.
I always appreciate the in-depth reviews with the comparison swatches. It makes me take a breath, slow down, and realize that there really isn't much new under the sun. There are only so many eye shadow shades in the spectrum and even if you have 20 slightly different browns (or whatever color family), trust me they all look pretty much the same on the eyes. And I say this as a person who has waaaaay too many palettes -- definitely my biggest makeup weakness! But I haven't bought a single new palette in months because I just keep repeating my mantra: "They all look the same on the eyes." lol
Do you have the chocolate bar? I can't decide between that and the naked palette
Mine came in the mail on Saturday (took 2 days to ship) and I love it! I love neutrals but didn't wanna pay extra for any of the Naked palettes. Plus this palette is easier to travel with than the Naked palettes because of the shape. I also have the original Tartlette palette... I love them both!
Great in depth review. Could you show your GRWM videos with a light and then a dark lipstick? (maybe that's too much to ask) Love the deeper tones on you but they are too dark for me. Would love to see how your eyes look with the lighter lip color. Thank you for all the work you do for us.
that's soo crazzy you said that- i'm glad i'm not the only one that was smelling it. i was showing it to my mom and got a whiff of it and i couldn't stop smelling it.... i'm soooo loving this palette. the 1st one is a big fav of mine also, TARTE is killing it!!!!!
I'm happy that someone finally made a comparison of this palette with other palettes, not only with the Tartelette 1.
I love watching your reviews. They are always on point, as well as the suggestions are really helpful
Amazing review! I just got this palette and it's by far the best I've ever had - colour and formula wise. The packaging is beautiful and YES, it does smell sweet - like a vanilla/chocolate combo. I've never felt such a buttery formula, and I've spent more money on other palettes.
This looks amazing! A great balance between cool and warm and just enough shimmery shades to keep it interesting. After abstaining from buying other neutral palettes because they just weren't ABSOLUTELY perfect, this just might be the one! x
I kinda see a same color scheme with the tarte greatest glitz pallete with the warm toned, cool toned, and rose gold/berry tones! I think I'd rather get the greatest glitz because it's travel friendly and has a wider color selection to choose from each color scheme
I didn't order this because I was waiting for you to review it. Now I think I would probably skip this one and get Lorac unzipped. Nice review thank you so much Emily!😊
I'm so glad you mentioned comparisons! When I first saw the shades for this palette I also thought it looked very similar to the Lorac unzipped! I think I might still get it just for the the top 2 rows and that packaging is irresistible!
The packaging itself makes me want to buy it. But the colors just speaks to me, so gorgeous *.*
Yes this palette absolutely smells like yummy marshmallows...i have been enjoying this since i bought it and can't wait to recreate the pretty looks you did with it!! Thank you! 😀💗
The in bloom palette was my first palette I bought. I love it. It's so versatile and almost fool proof
Well, I was watching another UA-camr do the same review, but you came up on the recommended and I clicked right over to you! I knew yours would be such an easy review to listen to.
haha I was literally thinking about buying this earlier today. you've got great timing!
Love your reviews! I have had this palette in my Ulta shopping cart waiting to hear more about it. Also wanted to say how beautiful and BIG Belle is. Too sweet!
I just wanna say that I love you! I am 41 and have always loved makeup but was never that good with it. I have been watching you for a few months now and my makeup look has improved so much. Thank you for what you do. Have a happy thanksgiving :)
I randomly started searching this palette to try something new and because the colors looked really pretty. I'm so glad I bought this based on your judgement emily! I bought it for my birthday in June and have been using it every time I do my eye makeup. I love this! My every day go to palette now!
Yes! I noticed the sweet smell too! I love it the smell and I love every single shade in this palette. I feel like if I was going to make a palette these are the shades I would go for. I would add a nice gold shade too but other than that I think this palette is everything I need! Thanks for the review. I especially thank you for comparing it to the too faced palette because I was considering getting that one too for the similar shades. I doubt I would wear any of those pops of purple regularly
I like to do a shimmer on my lid and outer corner and mattes for the crease and transition colors. I use either for under my brow bone.
Great review! I have to say, seeing the Tartelette palette in person, it's even more beautiful! We, at my Ulta, literally FLIPPED over it.
Thanks for the great review, Emily! I've been enjoying your videos for a while now but have never commented and I wanted to let you know how much I really enjoy them. They're my late night, quiet time treat :-) Keep up the great work!
As far as the palette goes, I agree that it is beautiful and of very good quality and of course, gorgeous packaging, which I'm a sucker for. What puzzles me is Tarte's marketing of this palette. Why make a palette with a gorgeous bright package, call it "In Bloom" and then offer another set of basically all neutral colors? Why not take that concept, put at least a few brighter colors in there (along with some neutrals for versatility), call it IN BLOOM and release it in Spring instead? Or if it has to be these colors, then maybe call it something less confusing? Just my two cents, but I wonder if anyone else thought of this...
I bought the In Bloom for my daughter for Christmas. I tagged her in an Instagram photo just to get her reaction to it. She was like "eh...boring." So...guess it will be mine! And the Too Faced Matte....amazing!
+amyyonfire lol. Can I bee your daughter. lol kidding. I would want it for Christmas. hehe
Awww
She tried out MINE this weekend, but I was like "too late!"
+amyyonfire it's not even Christmas yet 😂 same tho!
I returned the TF natural matte. Even tho I loved the unique warm colors, it was way too dusty and not pigmented enough. I'm bloom is great
Finally a palette that has more mattes than shimmers! I hate how all brands only do majority shimmer with a few mattes or all matte. This is really clever regardless of the un-uniqueness of the colors.
HI Emily! I really like this palette although at first glance, it reminds me a lot of the original Too Faced Natural Eyes, my favorite. Of course the Tarte has more shades but just making me wonder if I need both. Such a pretty palette! Thanks for the great review and comparison! xo
Yes i got the new tarte contour palette and it swells like sweet vanilla! Nice addition tarte. If makeup smells cheap like that makeup smell i dont want it.
I FINALLY bought this palette. I am so in love. I almost want to throw out my drugstore palettes. lol. I'm 48 and w older lids. skin tone is neutral to warm and w blue hazel eyes. I also have dark brown hair w violet. I need something simple but w impact. I need my shades laid out as well. This palette was made for me. My daughter at 16 looks stunning in the ABH Modern palette. It's also gorgeous too. But this palette was just easier for me. Plus too many red shadows make my eyes look bloodshot.
Your eyeshadow looks are so incredible! You always blow me away! GORGEOUS!! Thanks for your reviews as well!
Great review, as always Emily. Thanks for the comparison...I may hold off on this as I have the Tartlette and Lorac palettes....Belle is way too cute!
Belle at the end just melted my heart she is the best 😘
oh gosh thats beautiful...I luv watching u...u r one of the most knowledgeable people on u tube...what r u planning for yourself when u reach a million subscribers u r almost there sweetheart and congratulations
Amazing! Your comparisons are always great, Emily, but these ones here are even more impressive! Love that you picked up the "Relevant" shades and showed them on film. Super duper helpful as always :)
You are my go to UA-camr on reviews! I was looking for a matte eyeshadow palette - wishing i 'd see the tartelette somewhere!- your video came up and i was soooo satisfied with this review! Thorough, precise! Keep up the good work Emily!
i always love watching your reviews before i purchase high end palletes because i like your taste and your opinions on the palletes and other makeup products are so spot on! i enjoy watching your reviews very much! Thank you for being so honest! :)
You are looking amazing in this video! I am loving the hair and how your eye makeup have that sultry sleepy look! Your eyes look amazing with that more almond shape
This is my go to channel for reviews, especially eyeshadow palettes, and this review was so great and so in depth, will definitely be getting this, thank you so much Emily
great review Emily! I hope more palettes come out like this because for myself and how I apply my makeup I fine I prefer to have more matte than shimmery shadows in a palette.
You're always full of beauty! I needed more of the ending ☺️ bubba is so sweet.
Once again, yet another brilliant review. Thorough and thoughtful. You never disappoint! Appreciate your comparisons with other palettes too
Thanks for the review Emily! I wish they would bring the mattenificent palette back, it's amazing
Agree! I love that thing.
I was very interested in this palette, but what made the review was the comparison between other palettes! I have many of the others you mentioned (still on the fence on Vegas Nay Too Faced). Thanks so much for that!
Ugh I want it! It has my favorite type of colors. The original Tartelette palette had too many purples and deep shades for me.
Thanks for this comparison video.
I think i like the tarte the bloom this year which I find is better than last year as it's not all matte shades. I like a few shimmers too. :)
I got this palette in the mail today but not had the chance to open it yet. I can't wait to check it out tomorrow after seeing this review. Tarte has come a very long way in the eye shadow department. I like the idea of a few shimmers thrown in although I love the original Tartlette palette with all matte shades. I love how your mind works comparing the shades with other palettes. That's one reason you're #1 on my UA-camr list! I was hoping to see a bit more of baby Belle there on the end.
This is a great video Emily!! Thank you soooo much for sharing it with us all. I was interested in this palette. I am looking for pinky and purpley shades. I really liked that you talked about the Lorac palette. I will check the Lorac palette first! Thanks again!
I have this palette and love it. I'm going to try the look you did tomorrow. Thanks for sharing. Your baby is adorable.😀
Amazing video!! So informative!! Thank you for comparing it to other palettes. I can't wait to get my hands on it and create some looks. I think the colors would work well with the original Tartlette as well.
out of this one, original tartelette, rainforest after dark, and noir, which would u pick if u could only pick one? what order would u put them in? I'm planning on getting one, but I just can't pick!
Great review! I really love all the comparisons with the other palettes.
And your baby is sooooooo cute!!
I bought this a month ago and I haven't stopped using it. I love it too much.
Tq so much Em...love the comparisons, it was so nice of you to compare this one to other palettes as well..love your review, really appreciated it.
Great video! I love that you compared the palette to so many other palettes, it helped a lot :) I'm really interested in getting this palette since I dont have the first one. The colors are gorgeous!
Great review!! I think this palette is better than the first. I like the variety of mattes and shimmers. It does not disappoint.
Thank u for the info. Looks like a really nice all over palette. If I didn't have the first one I would probably LOVE that one. I do love that Shimmery Taupe shade!
I'M SO GLAD YOU NOTICED THE SCENT TOO. I thought I'd gone insane. It smells so nice!
REALLY enjoyed this comparative review! It provided so much information. Please do more like this. Thank you!
This is the only review I've seen comparing tartelette bloom with TF natural matte when I desperately need the comparison. YES.
will you review the carli bybel pallete ?!
Yes yes yes please review that!
Agree!
Can't wait for mine to be here Carli palette. Pass on tarte I got the first one. Carlis is 12.00
Yes please. I just ordered that one 😊
Great review Em! This looks like a great palette. It actually appeals to me more than the original because it has those three shimmery lid shades; however knowing I have enough similar shades between my lorac unzipped and Stardust palettes, I'm going to skip for now.
Thank you so much for doing the comparison on these! I have the three other palettes that you mentioned and I wasn't sure if the Tarte one would be too redundant to add to my collection. You saved me some $$ :)