But MC scaffolding can only bridge out 6 blocks before falling, platforms can bridge out infinitely and aren't effected by gravity, and technically if you stacked up platforms and scaffolding, the scaffolding is going to provide free movement where the scaffolding is while in terraria you have a sort of grid you travel across
if anyone wants to this challenge themselves, or if shardon wants to do a part two where the mechs are actually beaten, i've done a lot of digging and here are some potential items that could be used to help you ------------------------- ice sickle could be used, there is a frost scythe in mc dungeons spider armour could have been used in hardmode, there is spider armour in dungeons hornet staff could have been used, it's similar to the buzzy nest artifact from dungeons which spawns bees to fight with you spear (from minecraft dungeons) and trident can be used earlygame anchor and cutlass (from minecraft dungeons) could be used early hardmode huntress armour from the OOA could be considered hunters armour from minecraft dungeons and if you're willing to bend the rules a little bit more: butchers chainsaw can be considered mechanized sawblade from mcd toxic flask could be considered a splash potion of poison marrow can be considered the bone bow from mcd molten hamaxe can be the firebrand from mcd the witches broom mount could be considered similar to the cackling broom from mcd necro armour could be considered grim armour from mcd adamantite glaive (you could fish for the adamantite, but this is assuming you're allowed to use mythril/orichalcum anvils) (there are glaives in dungeons and afaik the adamantite glaive is the only glaive in terraria) beetle wings could have been used too if you are allowed to use orichalcum/mythril anvils, as elytra in real life are the coverings on the wings of beetles (which are present in the terraria texture) if you REALLY want to bend the rules: sinister sword from mcd kinda looks like a blood butcherer lol tsunami could be the bubble bow from mcd flaming mace could be considered the suns grace from mcd, could be useful in earlygame shroomite digging claws could be considered the maulers from mcd (which are described as a claw like weapon) weather pain could be considered the wind horn from mcd the volcano can be considered a netherite sword with fire aspect lol
I was considering trying destroyer with the ice sickle but I don't think I would be able to get close enough to do good damage. Might do more testing with this stuff if the video does well. Thanks!
@@lollovec Minecraft fan: "Wow, if you put some trapdoors next to a slab, it kinda looks like a chair!" Terraria enjoyer: "Which of these 45 different toilet variants should I use for my build?"
@@omegaotaku1342 minecraft fan: what weapon should i use to fight the ender dragon, wither, and warden? terraria fan: which of my over 500 weapons should i use to fight all of my like 12 bosses
Thing is night owl potions only increase the potency of other light sources. They don’t let you see if there no light around, which night owl vision in Minecraft does
Hey, I am here with a loophole for you "cheating" with the life crystals. There's a glitch is Minecraft where you can make the effects of a gapple permanent. I'm not sure if you can do it in 1.21, but its a loophole nonetheless.
the two maces you used in the thumbnail are from two different games, the mace it shows you holding is the one from minecraft dungeons, while it tries to portray it as the mace that has been added to minecraft recently.
I’m a bit confused why you could could use bombs. Sure there’s TNT from Minecraft and explosives from Minecraft dungeons but never just bombs. Wouldn’t it have been better to first build a house to get the demolitionist? I think some additional rules should be: you can allow shimmer as a crafting step and if there is a closer terraria item to the Minecraft item you are saying you can use, then you have to use the closer one. I.e bombs are not tnt because dynamite is tnt
Don’t know how helpful grappling hooks would be, but “technically” Minecraft did have an April Fools update where there was a potato grappling hook… also, if ya really wanna bend the rules: - Rod of Discord kinda acts a whole lot like infinite ender pearls - Endless quiver equipment is “kinda” like putting the infinity enchantment on a bow - there is a crossbow in Minecraft, so you could argue that the use of Hallow repeater is legal since it’s kinda like a crossbow - Jester arrows are kinda like putting the piercing enchantment on a crossbow - gravitation potions would be similar to the levitation effect given by shulkers - hellstone and ancient debris are both found in a hellish biome as well as netherite armor giving slight fire protection which is similar to hellstone armor giving you immunity to fire blocks - obsidian rose and/or obsidian skull is very similar to putting fire protection on armor - if you ever consider using traps, dart traps are like dispensers, wires are like redstone, explosives are like TNT, both have pressure plates and levers… - both Minecraft and Terraria have beehives (Bee Hive Trap, the one that drops down and spawns bees when broken), so you could technically collect a TON of beehives and use them on bosses - Cobalt shield, Paladin’s shield, Hero Shield, etc, “technically” all legal because Minecraft has a shield - Minecraft has rabbit stew, so for minor buffs you could catch a bunny and cook/eat it - the resistance buff in Minecraft (from beacons) could be similar to endurance potions / itonskin potions - the statement “as long as the end result is the same”, I’d apply that to fishing and say that “technically” even if you’re catching bait “the end result is the same”. If you do consider fishing, crates from fishing in Terraria are kinda like barrels in Minecraft - If you go into the dungeon, the alchemy table is kinda like the brewing stand in Minecraft (Both used for making potions) - As something for a TINY boost, if you’re lacking in equipment, the watch in Terraria and Clock in Minecraft are basically the same thing. You could make a watch, apply Warding or Menacing, and equip it for extra defense or damage - I’d argue that Wings are completely legal since Minecraft has the Elytra Edit: If you’ll only allow specific wings that match wings in Minecraft, the April Fools Poisonous Potato update in Minecraft had Elytras that could be crafted using a poisonous potato, so I’d say “Leaf Wings” would work since both wings have something related to nature and plants. As for Minecraft’s regular Elytra, best I can think up is maybe angel wings (Minecraft’s end dimension being theoretically in the sky, and angels theoretically come from the sky. It’s a big reach)
I don't really know where that would go cause you can beat the ender dragon with just wood or stone tools, it would be too easy. Just get iron stuff and then you can easily kill the dragon and beat the game. Then the wither is harder but not impossible. It could be done easily.
you could use the shield of cthulhu since there's sheilds in minecraft, and maybe even wings cause of the elytra (and with fireworks they basically act like wings)
cant use platforms, could use planter boxes, villagers in minecraft have a simlar thing they build with dirt and trapdoors, and you could say that the trapdoors are similar enough to platforms, when opened they make a bridge that is just wide enough to cross and fall through, scaffolding is a good analogue to platform blocks
Minecraft and Terraria are both Best Buds and they encourage their players to play the other game, the people that are fighting over Minecraft and Terraria are just fighting over nothing because Minecraft and Terraria are already friends, there is literally no reason for people to fight.
I did try to make a series of 2d minecraft from an indy dev, MineBlocks the game. pretty decent fan copy, devs working both on and off the game with its sequel. Maybe try to revive the series but with current world mentality, I have to wait.
The wall of flesh being the World border is actually a really cool idea. Also: 25:49 why haven't ya swapped to the iron minecart? It's faster and works with this challange.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I shouldn't be since I just checked but spears are in MC dungeon last I checked, so at 4:16 we can see you trashed the spear you had just gotten
if you were to include modded items, then if would just be normal terraria. there's probably already a terraria mod for minecraft, it just wouldn't make good content at all.
The way people compare these games in the stupid way they do even tho there are splash screen text that litreally tell you to "also try minecraft" in terraria and "also try terraria" in minecraft
It's your playthrough play how you want to you don't owe anybody any explanation as to why you do things. As long as you are having fun it's all that matters
"Terraria is just 2D Minecraft"❌
"Minecraft is 3D Terraria"❌
"Terraria 🤝 Minecraft"
This guy is the most intelligent person in this comment section
terraria is just 2D infiniminer
minecraft is just a copy of infiniminer
@@humanhuman7280 it got based, not copied, but yes, u tried to get a point
Minecraft music: 🗿 Terraria music: 🗿
Minecraft grapics: 🗿 Terraria graphics: 🗿
Minecraft gameplay: 🗿 Terraria gameplay: 🗿
Minecraft bosses: 🗿 Terraria bosses: 🗿
fax
I’d argue platforms are like scaffolding in MC
But MC scaffolding can only bridge out 6 blocks before falling, platforms can bridge out infinitely and aren't effected by gravity, and technically if you stacked up platforms and scaffolding, the scaffolding is going to provide free movement where the scaffolding is while in terraria you have a sort of grid you travel across
@@FunnyDonutGuy true
it's kinda more like rope
rope
there are plant pots in minecraft...
And in terraria plant pots work like platforms...
if anyone wants to this challenge themselves, or if shardon wants to do a part two where the mechs are actually beaten, i've done a lot of digging and here are some potential items that could be used to help you
-------------------------
ice sickle could be used, there is a frost scythe in mc dungeons
spider armour could have been used in hardmode, there is spider armour in dungeons
hornet staff could have been used, it's similar to the buzzy nest artifact from dungeons which spawns bees to fight with you
spear (from minecraft dungeons) and trident can be used earlygame
anchor and cutlass (from minecraft dungeons) could be used early hardmode
huntress armour from the OOA could be considered hunters armour from minecraft dungeons
and if you're willing to bend the rules a little bit more:
butchers chainsaw can be considered mechanized sawblade from mcd
toxic flask could be considered a splash potion of poison
marrow can be considered the bone bow from mcd
molten hamaxe can be the firebrand from mcd
the witches broom mount could be considered similar to the cackling broom from mcd
necro armour could be considered grim armour from mcd
adamantite glaive (you could fish for the adamantite, but this is assuming you're allowed to use mythril/orichalcum anvils) (there are glaives in dungeons and afaik the adamantite glaive is the only glaive in terraria)
beetle wings could have been used too if you are allowed to use orichalcum/mythril anvils, as elytra in real life are the coverings on the wings of beetles (which are present in the terraria texture)
if you REALLY want to bend the rules:
sinister sword from mcd kinda looks like a blood butcherer lol
tsunami could be the bubble bow from mcd
flaming mace could be considered the suns grace from mcd, could be useful in earlygame
shroomite digging claws could be considered the maulers from mcd (which are described as a claw like weapon)
weather pain could be considered the wind horn from mcd
the volcano can be considered a netherite sword with fire aspect lol
I aint reading allat
I was considering trying destroyer with the ice sickle but I don't think I would be able to get close enough to do good damage. Might do more testing with this stuff if the video does well. Thanks!
@@juliusrealGD That implies that you are literate to begin with.
And YOU CAN USE THE FROST ARMOR AS PREVIOUSLY STATED!!! HOW DID YOU FORGET?!?!?!
Also how could you beat the twins with an ice bow but can’t beat the destroyer with the ice sickle
Terraria is 2d minecraft people after realizing that there are more weapons in terraria:
Minecraft has like 15 weapons, Terraria has over 500
Terraria has the second amendment ngl
@@omegaotaku1342terraria has more toilets then "weapons in minecraft"
@@lollovec Minecraft fan: "Wow, if you put some trapdoors next to a slab, it kinda looks like a chair!"
Terraria enjoyer: "Which of these 45 different toilet variants should I use for my build?"
@@omegaotaku1342 minecraft fan: what weapon should i use to fight the ender dragon, wither, and warden?
terraria fan: which of my over 500 weapons should i use to fight all of my like 12 bosses
People when they realize terraria has a creeper costume and Minecraft has “also try terraria” splash text. Vice versa for splash text
Should have done it on mediumcore to drop items on death!
Nah, he had keepInventory on
@@IsabruhMomentthis made me chuckle
@@IsabruhMoment As any person with some amount of care for their mental health does.
i think a cloud in a bottle counts as a wind charge but reusable
honestly fair
In my opinion, the item that teleports you back to your base is just an enderpearl stasis so it’s fine
He could have used ninja Armour because it's in minecraft dungeons.
So is spear
4:04 This really bothers me because night owl potions are basically night vision potions.
Thing is night owl potions only increase the potency of other light sources. They don’t let you see if there no light around, which night owl vision in Minecraft does
@@roughanddrygobeyond4112 oh
The Shine buff would act kind of like the Glowing status effect, anyways-- only snag is that Glowing comes from Spectral Arrows
@@accuratejaney8140 The Glowing effect literally just outlines your character.
@@accuratejaney8140 Commands can give you a glowing potion. So he used "cheated" items which technically wasnt disallowed in the rules
The life crystals are like absorption in Minecraft
They're more like health boost, which is unobtainable without commands
Neither of those are items
7:00 "That has gotta be the most usele- huh!
Explosives might be your best bet. I'm not sure what it would take to nuke bosses like plantera and beyond, but they'll 1000% get you a destroyer kill
There are boots in Minecraft, so hermes/dunerider/sailfish/flurry boots, rocket boots, & their upgrades are allowed in my book.
Also water walking boots, lava waders, etc. are allowed as far as I'm concerned, because they're also boots.
@@andrewnapolitano8565Water walking is literally just frost walker so yeah i agree it's valid
That's a reach
The furthest you can go is probably Hellstone boots.
lmao that texture pack is hilarious
Hey, I am here with a loophole for you "cheating" with the life crystals. There's a glitch is Minecraft where you can make the effects of a gapple permanent. I'm not sure if you can do it in 1.21, but its a loophole nonetheless.
I literally started laughing when he said du du du du du what a nice day guys fits perfectly for the merchant
Hey, ive been watching some of your vids, it has helped me and im in love with ur channel now
the two maces you used in the thumbnail are from two different games, the mace it shows you holding is the one from minecraft dungeons, while it tries to portray it as the mace that has been added to minecraft recently.
Funny thing is that terraria and Minecraft recommends each other to play
He got the Dream luck 3 ice mimics in that short of a time you can almost not believe it
3:37 using emerald gemspark walls as a green screen is actually genius
The intro is sick
I’m a bit confused why you could could use bombs. Sure there’s TNT from Minecraft and explosives from Minecraft dungeons but never just bombs. Wouldn’t it have been better to first build a house to get the demolitionist? I think some additional rules should be: you can allow shimmer as a crafting step and if there is a closer terraria item to the Minecraft item you are saying you can use, then you have to use the closer one. I.e bombs are not tnt because dynamite is tnt
Don’t know how helpful grappling hooks would be, but “technically” Minecraft did have an April Fools update where there was a potato grappling hook…
also, if ya really wanna bend the rules:
- Rod of Discord kinda acts a whole lot like infinite ender pearls
- Endless quiver equipment is “kinda” like putting the infinity enchantment on a bow
- there is a crossbow in Minecraft, so you could argue that the use of Hallow repeater is legal since it’s kinda like a crossbow
- Jester arrows are kinda like putting the piercing enchantment on a crossbow
- gravitation potions would be similar to the levitation effect given by shulkers
- hellstone and ancient debris are both found in a hellish biome as well as netherite armor giving slight fire protection which is similar to hellstone armor giving you immunity to fire blocks
- obsidian rose and/or obsidian skull is very similar to putting fire protection on armor
- if you ever consider using traps, dart traps are like dispensers, wires are like redstone, explosives are like TNT, both have pressure plates and levers…
- both Minecraft and Terraria have beehives (Bee Hive Trap, the one that drops down and spawns bees when broken), so you could technically collect a TON of beehives and use them on bosses
- Cobalt shield, Paladin’s shield, Hero Shield, etc, “technically” all legal because Minecraft has a shield
- Minecraft has rabbit stew, so for minor buffs you could catch a bunny and cook/eat it
- the resistance buff in Minecraft (from beacons) could be similar to endurance potions / itonskin potions
- the statement “as long as the end result is the same”, I’d apply that to fishing and say that “technically” even if you’re catching bait “the end result is the same”. If you do consider fishing, crates from fishing in Terraria are kinda like barrels in Minecraft
- If you go into the dungeon, the alchemy table is kinda like the brewing stand in Minecraft (Both used for making potions)
- As something for a TINY boost, if you’re lacking in equipment, the watch in Terraria and Clock in Minecraft are basically the same thing. You could make a watch, apply Warding or Menacing, and equip it for extra defense or damage
- I’d argue that Wings are completely legal since Minecraft has the Elytra
Edit: If you’ll only allow specific wings that match wings in Minecraft, the April Fools Poisonous Potato update in Minecraft had Elytras that could be crafted using a poisonous potato, so I’d say “Leaf Wings” would work since both wings have something related to nature and plants. As for Minecraft’s regular Elytra, best I can think up is maybe angel wings (Minecraft’s end dimension being theoretically in the sky, and angels theoretically come from the sky. It’s a big reach)
I'd say that unholy arrows are closer to the piercing enchantment than jester's arrows.
the quiver used to be in older minecraft so enchantment or not he could use it
i would love this to be a series!!
respect to the creators of the minecraft texture pack really nice!
4:53 “that’s what she said”
I will let myself out
Cloud in bottle = wind charge and wings = elytra
Also use the hellstone to netherite texture pack
Would hellstone not be netherite?
Maybe soon try minecraft but only terraria weapons
(im a terraria fan and minecraft fan)
I don't really know where that would go cause you can beat the ender dragon with just wood or stone tools, it would be too easy. Just get iron stuff and then you can easily kill the dragon and beat the game. Then the wither is harder but not impossible. It could be done easily.
terraria:play mine craft too
minecraft: play terraria too
Minecraft no
Mine craft yes
Minecraft dungeons came in clutch
you could use the shield of cthulhu since there's sheilds in minecraft, and maybe even wings cause of the elytra (and with fireworks they basically act like wings)
In Minecraft story mode there's rope and asphalt and in dungeons there was an artifact that does what the desert staff thing does
You can also make a flaming mace/flail since there's fire aspect
cant use platforms, could use planter boxes, villagers in minecraft have a simlar thing they build with dirt and trapdoors, and you could say that the trapdoors are similar enough to platforms, when opened they make a bridge that is just wide enough to cross and fall through, scaffolding is a good analogue to platform blocks
Fun fact: minecrafts supports terraria and terarria supports minecraft by their mini texts
There are boots of swiftness in minecraft dungeons so Hermes boots would work
Next play the mincraft mod that makes minecraft into terraira but 3d
Minecraft and Terraria are both Best Buds and they encourage their players to play the other game, the people that are fighting over Minecraft and Terraria are just fighting over nothing because Minecraft and Terraria are already friends, there is literally no reason for people to fight.
I did try to make a series of 2d minecraft from an indy dev, MineBlocks the game. pretty decent fan copy, devs working both on and off the game with its sequel. Maybe try to revive the series but with current world mentality, I have to wait.
The wall of flesh being the World border is actually a really cool idea.
Also: 25:49 why haven't ya swapped to the iron minecart? It's faster and works with this challange.
Minecraft 2.0 Update Looks FIRE 🔥🗣💯
the platforms in terraria are the same as bamboo scafolding so you can use it
31:10 you could use dynamites to instantly kill the destroyer
Dart traps=dispenser with an arrow
real amazing content.
Now do minecraft only with terraria items only
It's not a magic mirror, it's just a bind to TP to spawn, obvs.
Fun fact: in terraria the title screen might say try Minecraft and in Minecraft the title screen might say try terraria
Bro, went off screen mining 21:00 😂😂
you could've used iron skin, potions of turtle master give resistence and its functionally the same thing just without the slowness
There are health boosts in minecraft so it's fine to use health crytals
6:49 heart crystal = absorption
It's a potion effects it doesn't grand permanent heart
the doll was the totem of dying
terrraira: also try minecraft
minecraft: also try terraria
THEY HOMIES!!!
You actually can use hook, because in first April snatshot we can vote for using fishing rods like grappling hook.
do you mean April firstt
Imagine you have to defeat the moon lord with iron armour and a wooden bow or iron sword with only 10 hearts 😂😂😂😂
you could cheese prime on minecart even daytime
Correct me if I'm wrong but I shouldn't be since I just checked but spears are in MC dungeon last I checked, so at 4:16 we can see you trashed the spear you had just gotten
I don't think Minecraft has bombs, other than TNT, but that's more like dynamite than bombs.
Imagine that Modded minecraft have copper tools :D
You actually can use hooks, since there is one on the aprils fools update
Stampy did do terraria so the world name works
He said he can't use platforms slabs close to platforms at least I think
Grappling hook from this year's April fools update?
You should beat terraria 3ds edition?
Gungir got to it first 😔
This challenge is depressing
That mace is the mc dungeons mace
id argue that you could use anything thats kind of like a modded item in minecraft
if you were to include modded items, then if would just be normal terraria. there's probably already a terraria mod for minecraft, it just wouldn't make good content at all.
platforms are basically scaffolding
He knows minecraft has campfires right
idk the rules seem a little too loose with bombs being allowed instead of dynamite and lead being used since it's "basically iron"
The way people compare these games in the stupid way they do even tho there are splash screen text that litreally tell you to "also try minecraft" in terraria and "also try terraria" in minecraft
32 minutes so if I watch it twice it will be 64 minutes + 24 minutes.
you can fish to get the hard mode ores. and some minecraft dungeons accessories were over looked.
I don't believe any animals/items in mc work as bait
@@ShardonOk It’s too bad that mojang changed their mind about the firefly you could have used them.
@@user-qp1xx7sc6p negative. Bug net is a special tool I believe
should've used my steve video for the character smh
Looks better than mine no doubt!
couldnt u use platforms since they are technically stairs?
Shardon you could have used wooden tools XD (i play to much Minecraft)
I used a wooden sword for early game but it didn't really get shown off too much. No wooden pickaxes sadly
He can use accessories because of Minecraft dungeons there's three accessory slots
It's your playthrough play how you want to you don't owe anybody any explanation as to why you do things. As long as you are having fun it's all that matters
WHY DIDN'T YOU GET FROST ARMOR FOR THE MECHS. AAAAAA
Since when was a lead pickaxe a thing
GOD I love Minecraft dungeons
will you do 1.2 items only in the future?
Would be too easy tbh
@@ShardonOk1.1 or 1.0 items?
I love nymph 😘 why she fall😭
What happened to the spear in the beginning it is a Minecraft dungeons weapon
Didn't start using mc dungeons items in the video for a while
How can I download the minecraft resource pack?
21:02 what tremendous luck to have ice mimics spawn
ps. loved your content. pls make more hehehhee
Could've used iron skin potion since potion of resistance does the same thing
There is no potion of resistance unless you count the turtle master potion and im pretty sure iron skin does not give you slowness
@@donneler Also even if we are talking about Potion of the Turtle Master, the closest Terraria equivalent would be Endurance Potion, not Ironskin.
@@donneler It's amazing how someone can so confidently say something so wrong.
That music in menu, it it a mod? I would love that
Yup just terraria dubstep theme or something like that. It's downloadable in steam workshop
omg bombs don't exist in minecraft 💀
but dynamite does
Ok now do it the other way around (:
The platforms could have been scaffolding from Minecraft because their fundamental the same
goated world name
dude turned cheats on when the world was generated
9:38 I would have said we’re on life steal
Is hellstone netherite?
4:12 spear is a mcd weapon
15:00 ninja armor is a mcd armor piece