I Played Every WW1 FPS Ever

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 чер 2024
  • Lets compare every World War 1 FPS Game Ever Made
    00:00 Beyond The Wire
    03:35 Isonzo
    06:21 Holdfast Frontlines
    08:07 Verdun
    10:55 Battlefield 1
    14:16 Tannenberg
    Podcast - ua-cam.com/channels/wth.html...
    Gaming Channel - / resonantupr. .
    Shorts Channel - ua-cam.com/channels/edq.html...
    ======================================================
    Business Enquiries- fps@resonantvideo.co.uk
    Twitter: / resonantyoutube
    Like my Facebook page-
    / resonantgami. .
    Production Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
    Royalty Free Music by audiomicro.com/royalty-free-music (for videos that make use of music tracks)
    Sound Effects by audiomicro.com/sound-effects (for videos that make use of sound effects)
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 553

  • @K-Nyne
    @K-Nyne 10 місяців тому +614

    Imagine how much the Verdun series would have benefited if all three games were put into one

    • @somepersonmcsomebody7501
      @somepersonmcsomebody7501 10 місяців тому +80

      Exactly. Instead, they just killed off the previous titles, and now they have like zero playerbase anymore.

    • @Paul-oe6qk
      @Paul-oe6qk 9 місяців тому +52

      I keep telling this on the forums but the devs dont listen

    • @Petrslav
      @Petrslav 9 місяців тому +25

      how would they have done that though? Tannenburg and Isonzo are different games and feel different. People would have been pissed if the DLC's felt that different, and if they updated the engine to modernize, people would have been pissed if that caused the game to feel different. theyre a small company making niche games. theyre always going to be smaller because the people that try it out probably want BF1.

    • @christianrowbotham7386
      @christianrowbotham7386 9 місяців тому +17

      It can only work with verdun and tannenberg but not with Isonzo because it has a different engine

    • @JagerFrostTroll
      @JagerFrostTroll 9 місяців тому +1

      Because they're greedy

  • @blaisechalmers1464
    @blaisechalmers1464 10 місяців тому +878

    I must say, having recently bought both Verdun and Tanneburg, I can safely say that I've had the most fun I've ever had playing an FPS. It's such a breath of fresh air playing a game and not having to worry about an anime cosplayer 360• no scoping me out of nowhere. I just wish I could play against more players. I'm super excited to get Isonzo after these two bangers.

    • @gogoplayz4887
      @gogoplayz4887 10 місяців тому +8

      I have played tannenburg I like ot

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +65

      Isonzo is unironically the best WW1 FPS ever made (BF1 isn't WW1).

    • @Tomofdahook17
      @Tomofdahook17 10 місяців тому +43

      I can’t believe how improved Isonzo feels over the previous 2. I loved Verdun especially. But I wish they would re-release all three games in one package in Isonzo’s engine.

    • @lan_daddyttv4710
      @lan_daddyttv4710 10 місяців тому +4

      ​@@arturoroldan4839Beyond The Wire

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +8

      @@lan_daddyttv4710 Nope. It's garbage and that's why is mega-dead.

  • @SkipsenPB
    @SkipsenPB 10 місяців тому +498

    I played Beyond the Wire when there was a free week and hundreds of players, and had an ABSOLUTE BLAST. Just sad that the game dies instantly once those free weeks are over. And yes, the bots are atrocious.

    • @paganposting5146
      @paganposting5146 10 місяців тому +26

      Yeah, I played BtW even outside free week and it was lovely.

    • @i-Melika
      @i-Melika 10 місяців тому +5

      Why didnt you buy it then

    • @ElZilchoYo
      @ElZilchoYo 10 місяців тому +6

      It's a niche genre of a niche setting. It was born dead.

    • @SkipsenPB
      @SkipsenPB 10 місяців тому +15

      @@i-Melika Because we all know it dies instantly, once the free week is over

    • @mr.schrodinger7219
      @mr.schrodinger7219 9 місяців тому +3

      ​@@ElZilchoYonah hell let loose is also a niche game and is quite successful

  • @sauceman2885
    @sauceman2885 10 місяців тому +340

    One of the reasons that I love battlefield one so much is that it can feel like you are in a war, intense barrages of explosions and gunfire, the screams and shouts of soldiers. It actually makes me feel immersed and like I’m in a war

    • @lakepodjoga
      @lakepodjoga 10 місяців тому +37

      No wonder it's the best game ever made

    • @justmike9756
      @justmike9756 10 місяців тому +15

      Best Battlefield for me, numbah two is bad company 2. My dad actually got me into these games. But yeah, Battlefield 1 is so good. And its better than Bf 2042. Even the graphics is beautiful.

    • @arian4562
      @arian4562 10 місяців тому +15

      The voice acting is some of the best

    • @sauceman2885
      @sauceman2885 10 місяців тому +14

      @@arian4562 the voices when they are on fire are disturbingly good

    • @luis6263
      @luis6263 10 місяців тому +6

      try hell let loose, you will love it

  • @chadsoucek4678
    @chadsoucek4678 10 місяців тому +177

    Isonzo is probably my favorite. Lots of different maps and playing in the mountains is insanely fun. The holdfast WW1 mode is also a lot of fun.

  • @JJake993
    @JJake993 10 місяців тому +150

    I can not get over how amazing BF1 is even today

    • @nonameman7114
      @nonameman7114 9 місяців тому +16

      The Trailer still gives me goosebumps

  • @nebiyuesayas5600
    @nebiyuesayas5600 10 місяців тому +80

    I think BF1 and the WW1 series (Verdun, Tannenberg, and Isonzo) are the only ones with any staying power, which kinda sucks because the others are somewhat creative. The problem is, WW1 is much harder to make a game about: too authentic and it's boring or frustrating, too many liberties and it's not WW1.
    Also, for the WW1 series, you went with the Belgian M1889, the Romanian M1893, and the Mannlicher M95 stutzen, which I point out because those are all my favorite guns from each game lmao. Just a neat coincidence :)

    • @antoniodelaugger9236
      @antoniodelaugger9236 9 місяців тому +4

      @@Dourkan budget is really the thing. The main reason indie games cant compete is they lack the scale in their games. If you can have hundreds of players like in battlebit in a ww1 game with an actual functioning commander system (so frontlines actually form like in BF 1942), you can easily have an authentic and fun WW1 experience without the need of arming players with SMGs and LMGs like in BF1 while appealing both casual plebes and people who appreciate historical authenticity.

    • @nickbuckley4371
      @nickbuckley4371 9 місяців тому

      Beyond the wire looked awesome I was excited but was kinda disappointed needs an overhaul

  • @nootnoot6404
    @nootnoot6404 10 місяців тому +70

    It's sad Isonzo isn't appreciated as it should be. I have about 100h on it, and it's a really fun game, that gives a good experience of an otherwise mostly ignored theater of war. The maps a pretty diverse, the weapon selection is well crafted, well balanced and the gameplay is quite easy to grasp.
    You have a number of classes you can take, which all have different attributes that actually impact the battlefield (building defenses, spotting from afar, calling in artillery, etc...) and pushes cooperation between teammates.
    I played verdun when it came out, and later when it died down, it's really not the same experience but you can sense that Isonzo really learned and expended on the lessons from the previous games

    • @David-mz8xk
      @David-mz8xk 9 місяців тому +1

      I plated it to the point that I got lvl 20 rifleman and lvl like 15 mountaineer. It runs sooooo bad on the ps4 and especially bad on other tvs. That's why I'm taking a little break.

    • @nawolith3840
      @nawolith3840 8 місяців тому +7

      Plus he talks about "not much content" but doesn't mention that with Verdun... besides Isonzo still gets updates and a has a roadmap.

    • @user-js4iv4vw6k
      @user-js4iv4vw6k 14 днів тому

      I really want to get Isonzo in 2024, is there anything specific I should know before playing? (I know it has a small playerbase and such, but anything else?)

  • @RHaenJarr
    @RHaenJarr 10 місяців тому +61

    I'm sick of the obsession with multiplayer. They make a nice game, it's too niche to keep a playerbase going, it dies down to only organized clan battles or nothing at all, rinse, repeat. And I keep seeing new games like this being announced. Why?
    I do like Isonzo a lot though.

    • @flyingsquirrell6953
      @flyingsquirrell6953 10 місяців тому +19

      Tbf in single player you are expecting to be treated as the main character and it’s hard to have the main character experience in the absolute depressing slog that is the First World War.
      Closest it came was ironically Valiant Hearts which used the depression to make you depressed.

    • @RHaenJarr
      @RHaenJarr 10 місяців тому +24

      @@flyingsquirrell6953 Not really, depends on how the game is built. It doesn't need to be built around a linear story.

    • @aryan_moudjahid
      @aryan_moudjahid 10 місяців тому +3

      ​@@RHaenJarrExactly

    • @chaoticclonestudios
      @chaoticclonestudios 10 місяців тому +3

      It's why i got verdun, Tannenberg, and isonzo. Even if they prioritize multiplayer, you can just run custom matches with bots

    • @flyingsquirrell6953
      @flyingsquirrell6953 10 місяців тому

      @@RHaenJarr But then you don’t get attached to the characters. I mean Storm of Steel in BF1 did it well but I could not imagine a whole game of that. I can imagine the feeling of impending destruction and doom would wear off after death 10.

  • @ACE1918
    @ACE1918 10 місяців тому +56

    You are missing a few if we include alternate history games. Codename Eagle, Iron Storm, Bet On Soldier, Darkest Of Days, Necrovision, and Necrovision Lost Company all come to mind. Also you may want to have a look at the modding scene as well.

  • @justeping9469
    @justeping9469 8 місяців тому +16

    For me Verdun, Tannenburg, and Isonzo captured the WWI feel to a T. The pacing the authentic true to life details, etc. It made you feel like you were actually fighting in the many battles of the Great War. The WWI mod for "Day of Infamy" called "Screaming Steel" was a great immersion also.

  • @ZombolicBand
    @ZombolicBand 10 місяців тому +120

    i still regularly play bf1 with a friend every week. And even tho i moved from pc to ps4, its amazing. i wish they would make more new maps though... or make a sequel.

    • @blueriver6264
      @blueriver6264 10 місяців тому +3

      i think the sequel to bf1 is bfv

    • @lakepodjoga
      @lakepodjoga 10 місяців тому +29

      @@blueriver6264 ye but it doesn't compare in terms of quality to BF1

    • @sergeantbigmac
      @sergeantbigmac 10 місяців тому +3

      @@blueriver6264 I mean yes technically, but I gather from subtext by sequel the OP meant another WWI set game or another less covered historical conflicts ala Korean War, Banana Republic civil wars of the 1920s, etc.

    • @sugarflame1833
      @sugarflame1833 10 місяців тому +12

      Why did you downgrade to ps4 from pc?

    • @Srrrgp
      @Srrrgp 10 місяців тому +3

      bf1 is great. i had hopes for bfv to be similar and no. bfv is not that bad...but bf1 is just superior. and I just play better in bf1 lol i can't see people in bfv

  • @AstraAstarte
    @AstraAstarte 10 місяців тому +22

    Isonzo, Verdun and Tannenberg are all made by the same developer and i enjoy all 3 games so much, i usually just play it in custom matches against bots

    • @GoogleGebruiker
      @GoogleGebruiker 9 місяців тому +1

      Same

    • @nickbuckley4371
      @nickbuckley4371 9 місяців тому +4

      They are awesome but should be one game

    • @gothia1715
      @gothia1715 8 місяців тому +1

      @@nickbuckley4371 Agree. Thats their biggest problem. A small playerbase spreaded over three diferent games...

    • @sure1994
      @sure1994 5 місяців тому

      they cant do it cuz unity engine, i hope they do real time shooter thing next time and hope it will be godot engine (unreal engine too much money but maybe focus entertainment can help them)@@nickbuckley4371

  • @santiagorojaspiaggio
    @santiagorojaspiaggio 10 місяців тому +22

    Beyond The Wire has such amazing sound! What are you talking about? And while the game had people it was very fun, and it felt realistic. The only reason why i had to uninstall it, is because i prefered Squad and Post Scriptum, and i couldn't occupy that many space on my computer.

  • @scientificconsideration8294
    @scientificconsideration8294 9 місяців тому +16

    Beyond The Wire was by far the most fun for me when it was still active, since it really is just Squad in WW1. Great audio, incredible details in the gun models, and a really intense feeling when playing against dozens of players inside super crammed trenches or small villages. Sad to see the approx. 15 players that still play this game only on saturdays, tho. Like trying to ride a dead horse...
    Tannenberg and Verdun are classics, but I doubt the series will ever be majorly successful since the playerbase is already split between three reasonably similar games (with Isonzo).
    BF1 was the most arcadey but also by far the most popular, so that goes to show what modern audiences want in a multiplayer FPS. One of the reasons Beyond the Wire dies, I guess.
    Holdfast was super fun and increadibly chaotic when hundreds of guys on both sides just ran into each other, but the players eventually migrated back to the classic linebattles since it is a little less hectic than the MGs and artillery of the WW1 Frontlines mode.

  • @SANGSAFE
    @SANGSAFE 10 місяців тому +27

    To get immersed when playing Bf1 I just tell myself that it’s not the actual WW1 but some steampunk version of WW1 in a parallel world.

    • @sergio24m
      @sergio24m 10 місяців тому +18

      operations feels way more ww1-ish than conquest btw, i suggest you give it a try

    • @skye_music
      @skye_music 10 місяців тому +4

      @@sergio24m Operations were amazing in that game. I remember I was mowing down enemies with the machine gun while in the trench.

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +3

      Just play Isonzo duh......

    • @markai2002
      @markai2002 10 місяців тому +4

      ​@@arturoroldan4839Bf1 is better than Isonzo

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +5

      @@markai2002 No, it's an unaccutate arcade game, not a WW1 game.

  • @stefanb5189
    @stefanb5189 7 місяців тому +7

    i played verdun since it was playable on steam. At the beginning of the games life when you had loads of full servers the gameplay was insane, especially when they increased the max playercount on a server. The hail mary pushes, the frantic respawning to releave a foothold in the enemy trench, working out the perfect path through nomansland, getting ungodly amounts of kills with a forward deployed mg08/15, comebacks from your last line of defence or even slugging out a victory by capping just one trench that changed hands 10000 times already. In those times Verdun oftentimes felt like a 30min cs 1v3 clutch

    • @ZackaryWilliams77
      @ZackaryWilliams77 29 днів тому

      One of my favorite memories of Early Access Verdun was playing in Flanders. I remember at the time it was such a nightmare to cross compared to later in the game's life with the new squads. I remember just basically starting from my trench on the far right [Entente Side] on the absolute edge of the map. I would crawl all the way to the enemy trench, then allow my squad to spawn in, and we were able to make some headway on the first trench. But I always enjoyed doing it. I remember a guy coming with me slowly crawling, only to get sniped. You get that "Oh shit I'm in danger now" feeling, especially knowing you have to spend 3 minutes crawling again if you die.

  • @clover4522
    @clover4522 10 місяців тому +8

    The WW1 Game Series is definitely some of the most fun FPS games ive played in a long time. I love the bot modes in them too, my favorite is definitely Verdun

  • @seannewberry7148
    @seannewberry7148 10 місяців тому +24

    Just a few things, 1. OWI was just the publisher they didn’t release they just recently bought it and have only released 2 updates so far under their jurisdiction, one the bots for the short coming of the player base and a hotfix. 2. The weekends have play sessions hosted by the community in the last weeks we had around 70-80 players at one time anyone is welcome and they are usually around 1pm EST. 3. Bots, are a short coming release by RSI team and not OWI, and they are piss poor, OWI in 2.0 will be releasing a major update and fixes to the game since majority of RSI left the team.

    • @I_enjoy_some_things
      @I_enjoy_some_things 10 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, Beyond The Wire is sweet. The sensitivity is a thing in every one of these OWI games.

    • @medievalarmorexptert6827
      @medievalarmorexptert6827 10 місяців тому

      Holy fuck its him

    • @seannewberry7148
      @seannewberry7148 10 місяців тому

      who is this man??? Its a fellow SERB>???@@medievalarmorexptert6827

    • @ZackaryWilliams77
      @ZackaryWilliams77 29 днів тому

      I do hope they're able to bring life to Beyond the Wire. With the minimal time I played it I enjoyed it a lot. I'm a huge fan of Squad/Post Scriptum so having a game like that set in my favorite conflict was a match made in Heaven.

  • @Tavernadolobo
    @Tavernadolobo 10 місяців тому +9

    I disagree with the sound design part of Beyond the Wire. The sound is one of the only good things of this game. The guns and explosions are very punchy and sound really satisfying

  • @OW3NS93
    @OW3NS93 10 місяців тому +9

    Now for every modern World War II FPS out there: Hell Let Loose, Post Scriptum, Enlisted, Battlefield V, COD Vanguard and WW2, World War 2 Online, Red Orchestra 2, Forgotten Hope 2, and Darkest Hour!

    • @RandMV
      @RandMV 10 місяців тому +5

      it'll be an endless list 💀

    • @dragoconte
      @dragoconte 10 місяців тому

      RED ORCHESTRA 2 !!!!

    • @gustthestupidnoob2393
      @gustthestupidnoob2393 10 місяців тому +1

      Cod 1 2 3 a d waw, alot of bf games

  • @Trenches1066
    @Trenches1066 9 місяців тому +10

    i would say beyond the wire was not as bad as you think. It was extremely immersive on a full server. sad that it died. there really is not another ww1 game series now besides the ww1 game series. now outside of Verdun,Tannenburg and Isonzo if you want ww1 as the setting your either playing a indie game or a RTS

  • @ReprobiCrucesignati
    @ReprobiCrucesignati 10 місяців тому +17

    In BF1 there was a gamemode where you could only use bolt action rifles. Too bad nobody played it...

    • @Ihavpickle
      @Ihavpickle 10 місяців тому +10

      I've actually played a couple of servers that's only bolt action

    • @sugarflame1833
      @sugarflame1833 10 місяців тому

      I wish I could try those servers

    • @moedarambla7507
      @moedarambla7507 10 місяців тому +1

      I played it and loved it !

    • @VoIkov
      @VoIkov 6 місяців тому

      Had a full server like that on Verdun...one of the greatest gaming experiences ever

  • @gammelgun9272
    @gammelgun9272 10 місяців тому +11

    i like the Video but you are not giving Beyond the Wire enough credit, its a fantastic ww1 game and probably one of the best ww1 games if they would still be working on it, they just never fixed a lot of the bugs, performens is ass and the content they did add wasnt really amazing, you have like 6 allied factions and only 2 central powers factions and both are german, they didnt even add the ottomans when they added Australian forces, they never even talked about adding Austria, italy or russia
    For a while they really werent connected with the community at all and the game got a bit COD'ish
    Overall tho the gore, gunplay, melee (wich is still bugged), sound (i think the sounds are awsome) and maps just make this game so great, i have never played a game where CQB was this much fun, just people shooting stabbing or clubbing each other, getting your saber out and slashing away, flamethrowers wiping out an entire squad, unloading your entire Revolver into a medic that sort of stuff
    this game didnt deserve this

    • @byblezt6427
      @byblezt6427 10 місяців тому +1

      i played beyond the wire a weekend that they made it free and it was full of players, i had a lot of fun and for me the game was awesome, and for me the game looked way better than what he played in the video idk why it looks for me so different lol.
      Then i supose when the free weekend ended the servers were empty again and the game definetly died.

    • @gammelgun9272
      @gammelgun9272 10 місяців тому

      @@byblezt6427 yea i honestly dont get how the game is just completely dead, not even a handfull of full servers like in post scriptum or isonzo, actually 0 players, really a shame this gams just had the potential

    • @resonantreports
      @resonantreports  10 місяців тому

      I made a full video on this but All I have heard is people saying how good the game is... yet none of these people play the game.

    • @medievalarmorexptert6827
      @medievalarmorexptert6827 10 місяців тому +1

      @@resonantreportsits like when you only really got bots to shoot at since every UA-camrs calling the game shit no one wants to buy it or hop on. Wheather its a worthy investment is debatable lol

    • @vinz4066
      @vinz4066 9 місяців тому

      ​@@resonantreports
      Its greatest Problem is the almost non existing Player Base. But IT IS a good Game. Your rewiew Just Sounds like Something Personal.

  • @TheMatti36
    @TheMatti36 10 місяців тому +424

    BF1 Has only one problem: it has nothing to do with ww1

    • @bisaodosgames3467
      @bisaodosgames3467 8 місяців тому +7

      😅😅😅😅

    • @matthewjones39
      @matthewjones39 8 місяців тому +30

      What?

    • @bisaodosgames3467
      @bisaodosgames3467 8 місяців тому +39

      @@matthewjones39 There are a lot of weapon prototypes

    • @matthewjones39
      @matthewjones39 8 місяців тому +119

      @@bisaodosgames3467 They need to make the game fun.

    • @novosibirsk-burgersoup
      @novosibirsk-burgersoup 8 місяців тому +66

      I always thought it was like ww 1.5, like the interwar period had a great war

  • @tripokemon22
    @tripokemon22 10 місяців тому +6

    I loved this video! Ive played Isonzo, Tannenberg, Verdun, and Battlefield 1 and they are all some of my favorite games of all time. Also i had to put this here but its Infinite Warfare not Infinity Warfare. Still an absolute awesome video! Keep up the good work!

  • @Harryhas26
    @Harryhas26 10 місяців тому +8

    Battlefield 1 without the experimental weapons could have been perfect. The amount of automatic weapons killed the WW1 vibe for me.

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +7

      And black soldiers in armies that didnt use them, and wrong uniforms, vehicules, map designs, etc...
      BF1 would need a total overhaul to get anywhere close to a game like Isonzo.

    • @Harryhas26
      @Harryhas26 10 місяців тому +7

      @@arturoroldan4839 Yeah you saw the beginnings of the forced diversity and whacky quirky uniforms that were so prevalent in Battlefield 5.

    • @Bubhba
      @Bubhba 10 місяців тому +1

      @@arturoroldan4839the thing is there were actually some black german soldiers and the black frenchies made sense cause of like colonies and the 369th and the brits too.

    • @arturoroldan4839
      @arturoroldan4839 10 місяців тому +9

      @@Bubhba There were ZERO black combatants in the Kaiserliche, it was literally illegal for non-ethnic germans to be allowed to be used in combat roles, and there was even a law from August 1914 that did not allow black men to willingly enlist.
      In WW1 there were 5 black men in the entire army, three kettledrummers and two in logistic battallions.
      What Battlefield 1 did was disgusting and unforgivable, literally MILLIONS of german men died or were terribly injured for life and all of that to be representent as africans in media.
      DISGUSTING.

    • @Bubhba
      @Bubhba 10 місяців тому

      @@arturoroldan4839 yeah i searched it up right after i posted this comment lol

  • @Litfilmz
    @Litfilmz 8 місяців тому +2

    All battlefield needs to do to save it self is make a Vietnam game that gives off the same vibe and gameplay as battlefield 1

  • @jayvonwebb4864
    @jayvonwebb4864 7 місяців тому +1

    Nothing will beat the sounds of you getting a kill in bf1, so satisfying

  • @yeahman.9262
    @yeahman.9262 10 місяців тому +4

    This video highlights a big problem in this era of multiplayer only games. As soon as a player base leaves the game, if there is no way to play against bots, it’s literally unplayable. But even then the bots have to be held to a certain standard. The WW1 series is an example of better bots while Beyond the Wire is an example of absolute dogshit.

  • @Noimcuban
    @Noimcuban 10 місяців тому +3

    i was in a full 150 player lobby in holdfast frontline last week. you just gotta catch em lol

  • @NightStalker_MJ
    @NightStalker_MJ 5 місяців тому +2

    12:15 that’s the thing, you gotta sacrifice historical accuracy for fun

  • @mattcolton2347
    @mattcolton2347 9 місяців тому +2

    Damn I feel old but anyone remember "the trenches" half life 1 mod. It was absolutely amazing back in the day

  • @leightonbailey5169
    @leightonbailey5169 8 місяців тому

    Installed verdun a while ago and recently tannenburg and Isonzo. Verdun is amazing and I normally play as the ANZACs but I like to see the other nations running around too.

  • @gogoplayz4887
    @gogoplayz4887 10 місяців тому

    Great video

  • @deathrowlemon7367
    @deathrowlemon7367 9 місяців тому +1

    “Squad is just so high in quality”
    - bought the game this year

  • @8bitSpartan141
    @8bitSpartan141 10 місяців тому +10

    There is one other ww1 fps you didnt mention that's a little rough called rising front. Also what I dont understand is why they don't combine verdun, tannenburg and isonzo into one updated game. Could maintain them altogether and you wouldn't need to split the already small playerbase.

    • @roo99710
      @roo99710 10 місяців тому

      Would be too large i think

    • @Thomazbr
      @Thomazbr 6 місяців тому

      Isonzo is built in a different engine.
      I assume they will make a Gallipoli game next, but I hope the guys at WW1 games make a "Great War" game where it's just all the maps from Isonzo, Verdun and Tannenberg

  • @deinoguy856
    @deinoguy856 10 місяців тому +4

    Two world war games id reccomend you to play are easy red 2 and rising front , easy red 2 being a ww2 squad based 1st and 3rd person fps with like 5 6 campaigns and custom maps missions mods etc with squad ai commands and inv, the other is like a sandbox ww1 game with different factions and building

  • @Matt9Xx
    @Matt9Xx 7 місяців тому +1

    Verdun, isonzo and tannenberg need merging into 1 game

  • @furiaxciega
    @furiaxciega 10 місяців тому

    Hello, very good video of this compilation of games, although you failed to mention in Tannenberg if there were people playing, I think he was the only one who did not say anything about it, on the other hand, I would like it if you could make a video with the most active games of the second world war or similar and that you consider good that are of the style to these that you put.

    • @resonantreports
      @resonantreports  10 місяців тому +2

      all the WW1 games except BF 1 are dead, but Isonzo, tannenberg and Verdun have bots

  • @jamesjesse9773
    @jamesjesse9773 10 місяців тому +2

    Don't forget Battlefield 1918
    It was a mod for Battlefield 1942.

  • @titanschannel585
    @titanschannel585 9 місяців тому +1

    I love the WW1 series, even if the playerbase is not that big, the devs are a small team and are passionate about what they do, and even with the small map selection, all the matches play differently increasing replayability

  • @goosefootjones7196
    @goosefootjones7196 10 місяців тому +8

    Beyond the wire was fun for me. Nothing better than holding a MG position and yelling with a French or German accent to motivate ur fellow teammates lol

  • @Empirehog
    @Empirehog 10 місяців тому +4

    Are BF1 Hard-core servers still populated?
    I used to predominantly play as "Recon" but use scopeless rifles to make as much of an authentic experience as possible.

    • @oliverpohlproductions8291
      @oliverpohlproductions8291 10 місяців тому +1

      Ah, perfect timing for your comment. You have to use the filter and press on all options to make them blank, then have server size set for full server's and ones below 10+. I played Arab snipers server a couple hours ago, so damn fun, It's like hardcore, but with a bit more base stuff in it.

    • @Dourkan
      @Dourkan 9 місяців тому

      Back to basics is sadly extinct. A shame because with the mechanics of the game, an all rifle no scopes server could easily be more ww1 like.

  • @123four...
    @123four... 9 місяців тому +2

    Dang, I didn't realize beyond the wire was so dead. I had a really fun time a few years ago playing it. Me and a friend whenever we were Germany would be the "Danger Close Battalion" and just call in the most absurdly dangerous artillery strikes while trying to avoid getting murdered.

  • @jBread28
    @jBread28 10 місяців тому +1

    Holdfast Frontlines servers are completely full for a couple hours of the day and empty for the rest

  • @randomclipsmilitary9056
    @randomclipsmilitary9056 10 місяців тому +2

    Lol Beyond the Wire is a great game but it died quickly because OWI isnt updating it frequently. Also no crap your gun was being put down because its a window

  • @figonkus4223
    @figonkus4223 10 місяців тому +1

    I played on a full Server in Holdfast just yesterday and it is quite fun. You just need luck so that people are on

    • @ll3v0ra93
      @ll3v0ra93 10 місяців тому

      Fr, holdfast is very time dependent, bc the community is so close knitted. I always see the same people when I’m on, just gotta work out what times the servers r populated and also don’t try and play during private events bc public servers r died.

  • @meta_cross1099
    @meta_cross1099 9 місяців тому +1

    5:01 "Don't worry boys we will get them eventually boys... we will get them eventually" - World war 1 in a nutshell.

  • @nickbuckley4371
    @nickbuckley4371 9 місяців тому +1

    The verdun series should be one game and we have a awesome alternative to bf1

  • @123four...
    @123four... 9 місяців тому +2

    Maybe I'm tripping but I also never thought beyond the wire was poorly made. The only real issue I found was the optimization, other than that it was really fun.

  • @henryfurgason8626
    @henryfurgason8626 10 місяців тому

    I preordered Isonzo and played it everyday after school, it was my favorite game. It was quite sad seeing fewer and fewer servers, and now none, at least on xbox.

  • @dienkhungtung
    @dienkhungtung 10 місяців тому +1

    Verdun game series still accurately portrait WW1

  • @Xray6631
    @Xray6631 10 місяців тому +2

    It bums be out beyond the wire didn’t take off, easily my favorite game in the genre although it had its flaws and lack of content the way the game felt and played was so satisfying and addicting but the moment after the servers dropped below 100 players after the free weeks ended it died but I don’t agree with you when you say the graphics are bad this game won a lot of rewards for good graphics

  • @adrian_2268
    @adrian_2268 10 місяців тому +2

    I have hundreds of hours on beyond the wire. I had a really fun time playing it, if it wasn't because of the dead servers I would still play it.

  • @gilbertthebushwacker8704
    @gilbertthebushwacker8704 10 місяців тому +2

    You shouldn't take Battlefield 1 as a WW1 shooter. Just take it as a funny arcadey steampunk shooter

  • @lukeburton4493
    @lukeburton4493 7 місяців тому

    Isonzo had an surge of players after a free weekend and a major sale, around 1,000 players conccurently, the free weekend saw highs of 8,000 players at one time

  • @Elevator829
    @Elevator829 10 місяців тому +1

    you missed Screaming steel which is a Day of Infamy mod, but that is the nieche of the neiche. Pretty cool though

  • @Therealmilkmanfr
    @Therealmilkmanfr 10 місяців тому +1

    7:44 literally describes irl countries going into WW1

  • @jjrj8568
    @jjrj8568 5 місяців тому

    Isonzo is by far the best; Verdun's Flanders map was great, but all maps of Isonzo capture the gorgeous scenery and madness of the Italian Front.

  • @KaijuTurtle
    @KaijuTurtle 9 місяців тому

    I bought Verdun in early access back in 2014 and despite my limited gaming time I still enjoy popping on for a few rounds now and again. I wish there were more active players because I either end up in with the hardest of the hardcore or complete noobs, which is either maddening or kind of pitiful respectively.

  • @crimson6397
    @crimson6397 7 місяців тому

    Verdun is the GOAT of WW1 titles imo. Simply because you can spawn around 200 bots or so and have a massive battle.

  • @KBKriechbaum
    @KBKriechbaum 7 місяців тому

    When he said he cannot shoot the window because his gun gets put down you know this guy is disqualified.

  • @Malpaise_Legate
    @Malpaise_Legate 9 місяців тому +1

    There was something about Isonzo that was really promising. It seemed like it had everything going for it, along with a decent budget to pull it off by comparison to previous titles in the WW1 franchise.
    My only issue with Isonzo was the weapon locomotion in this game. The player character emphasizes the recoil impulse of the rifle to a degree that feels... "cartoony." The jerk when firing looks like someone is holding the rifle in both hands, but not pressing the stock firmly against their shoulder. A weird flip-up on the muzzle end, with a rebounding wiggle from the action end. Rifles do not do that when firing with a proper stance, and I noticed it immediately. Verdun and Tannenberg managed to do this much more accurately, and it was strange to see it done this way so far into this franchise.
    It's a shame that Verdun is the only game to maintain much of it's player base, and get plenty of returning players. Isonzos gameplay was actually quite good. In my opinion, a bit better than Tannenberg, while still being more motion-driven than Verdun. Sadly, it looks like its servers will be left to slowly die out.

  • @heymrzanzeeba
    @heymrzanzeeba 8 місяців тому +1

    Had 'Beyond the Wire' been cheaper, had more support, been heavily streamed/promoted and included better bots then I think it could have easily superseded the competition. It would have straddled the line perfectly between the realism of Verdun and the arcadey-fun of BF1.

  • @abdulhamid_han_ii6825
    @abdulhamid_han_ii6825 6 місяців тому

    The creators of Verdun, Isonzo and tannaberg should of combined it all into one game to save the player base

  • @Trenches1066
    @Trenches1066 9 місяців тому +1

    You forgot RISING FRONT. its getting steam workshop and constant updates its def worth everyone's time if you like ww1 games

  • @nickbuckley4371
    @nickbuckley4371 9 місяців тому

    Imagine if the three games isonzo tannenburg and verdun are one game with isonzo graphics it would be awesome

  • @jmatthews8702
    @jmatthews8702 8 місяців тому

    Verdun when it was full with players was fun and very challenging

  • @therealevilmudbug
    @therealevilmudbug 8 місяців тому

    A WW1 version of Day of Defeat would be amazing

  • @xxelitewolfxx1337
    @xxelitewolfxx1337 8 місяців тому

    Verdun definitely was one of my favorites, I had a blast progressing through every class and squads, so much good memories from that game

  • @bignickenergy2042
    @bignickenergy2042 6 місяців тому

    Beyond the wire has a community play day every Saturday!

  • @nolanbirt2138
    @nolanbirt2138 10 місяців тому +1

    BF1 destruction is amazing in every way

  • @Legamster3584
    @Legamster3584 8 місяців тому

    Iron storm, darkest of days, codename eagle, the trenches: are we jokes to you?

  • @rayshiffer5026
    @rayshiffer5026 10 місяців тому

    Isonzo was a great game when I played it on release, but as far as I recall everyone left in 2 weeks, and I quite in 1 month, it was a good game, but little content
    I also played verdun, but didn't last long on it eightor.

  • @magikaros
    @magikaros 10 місяців тому +1

    The fact that these are the only WW1 games is just sad

  • @Deadvalley200
    @Deadvalley200 9 місяців тому

    I believe there are a few mods for old battlefield games that are centered around WW1

  • @sampaz3790
    @sampaz3790 6 місяців тому

    Isonzo is the best ww1 game currently. The devs regularly release free maps. Easy to get into populated servers.

  • @tincho5960
    @tincho5960 8 місяців тому

    PLEASE play the modifcation for "Day of Infamy" called "Screaming Steel", It's a very good mod set in WW1 too!!!
    You'll not regret it, I assure!

  • @favGModplz
    @favGModplz 8 місяців тому

    I remember when Verdun was new and everyone was playing it. It was an absolute BLAST

  • @IrexParrotTR
    @IrexParrotTR 9 місяців тому +1

    I expected this video to be 2 seconds long to be honest 😂

  • @averageperson613
    @averageperson613 10 місяців тому +1

    Battlefield 1 is not a WW1 game it's a WW2 game that is WW1 themed

  • @laremare
    @laremare 8 місяців тому

    You honestly should've played Screaming Steel, which is a free WW1 mod for Day of Infamy, a WW2 shooter by the developers of Insurgency (and it's sequel Sandstorm). It's a bit dead, because there's generally like 30 concurrent players, most of whom are playing the PvE mode of the main game, but it's not a big deal. The gameplay is more similar to hardcore CoD with small maps and teams, and the PvE mode is playable with just a few human players.

  • @luvs2spwge680
    @luvs2spwge680 9 місяців тому +4

    Bf1 is the most immersive. It’s not like ww1 but it makes it fun and exciting. I think the gun balance in the game is awesome. My favorite shooter of all time

    • @luvs2spwge680
      @luvs2spwge680 9 місяців тому

      Also the maps are really well done

  • @briappa6670
    @briappa6670 9 місяців тому +2

    It is very sad that so little is said about WW1, and consequently very little games are set in the conflict. In my opinion it was just as, if not even more interesting than WW2 and I think we should talk more about it.

  • @tangyorange6509
    @tangyorange6509 10 місяців тому +1

    I just love Verdun, that’s it’s that’s all I have to say

  • @devonwilson6273
    @devonwilson6273 9 місяців тому

    there is usually atleast 1 full match for isonzo so thats a plus lol 😂

  • @mishmash4760
    @mishmash4760 9 місяців тому

    I honestly think BF1 is one of if not the best multiplayer fps I have ever played in my entire life, the sound track, the visuals, the weapons, the maps, the cinematography, it is a genuine masterpiece and I think it will be a long will before a game rivals it in all those aspects. I think the only other game I can say that was on its level was RDR2

  • @riccardoliberini2114
    @riccardoliberini2114 9 місяців тому

    I have already seen that footage from Isonzo

  • @BarBokhva
    @BarBokhva 9 місяців тому

    there need to be more ww1 fps games.

  • @Thomazbr
    @Thomazbr 6 місяців тому

    I think they're probably going to make like a "Gallipoli" game next, but one might hope that after making three games in the same time period, they instead combine all theaters into a single game.

  • @conallmclaughlin4545
    @conallmclaughlin4545 9 місяців тому +1

    Isonzo deserves more payers, it's sad seeing it soo empty these days

  • @nawolith3840
    @nawolith3840 8 місяців тому

    Glad you talk so much about these games, but i think, that you treat Isonzo unfairly compared to Verdun and Tannenberg. Starting off with it feels a bit random, when you coudlve gone chronologically Verdun-> Tannenberg-> Isonzo. That way it would've been easier to highlight what the series did improve/not improve/keep/not keep over these games. For example Isonzos maps really have *height* compared to the earlier games and motions (including firing or bolting your gun) feel a lot more real comapred to the quick speed in the earlier titles. Jsut two small examples. And as for the "too little content" note: Isonzo is getting updates every few months (with four maps (+ weapons) already since launch) and a roadmap with at least 4 more on the way. And that brings me to my question? What is "enough" content for MP only? The WW1 Gameseries games never had that big of a fanbase, it sticks around well enough and you can find full servers in EU and US.

  • @NuclearHendrix
    @NuclearHendrix 5 місяців тому +1

    You missed one called Rising Front.

  • @robertshi5161
    @robertshi5161 8 місяців тому

    Ever heard of The Trenches? It was a Half Life 1 mod that was dope.

  • @chrismarsh4781
    @chrismarsh4781 9 місяців тому

    Verdun, Tannenberg, and Isonzo are amazing games. Ive played all of them extensively and dont regret getting any of them even a little. The one thing that hurts them is one of the things that makes them so good. They've isolated each title. What I mean by that is Verdun is exclusively the western front, Tannenberg is exclusively the eastern front, Isonzo the Italian front. It limits the content, obviously if you had French soldiers fighting in Russia it wouldn't be historically accurate and would kill the immersion. Their decision to do it that way made it so they could make each game stay true to history in a way few games do which I for one really like and appreciate. Easily the best WW1 game out there, they can make one more covering the events that happened in the middle east. Bet they call it Gallipoli, and hope they find a way to honor T.E. Lawrence.

  • @King-me
    @King-me 10 місяців тому +2

    I would love if you would play in a Beyond the wire community event, the game is better with players.. sadly there are mostly none.

  • @cobrageneral556
    @cobrageneral556 10 місяців тому +1

    1:56 they have nothing to do with post scriptum,PS was made by Periscope Games.

  • @itorca
    @itorca 10 місяців тому

    Rise of flight???? Red barron? Flying circus? medal of honor 1914? Uhhh i feel lied too

  • @ricc_2088
    @ricc_2088 9 місяців тому

    Verdun is fire I love it. Wish all the titles were combined into one game. The game would have benefited 100x.