Least we forget the 1st Minnesota on the second day charging the Confederates with 262 men. They were out numbered 3-4 to one. Only 47 returned after 15-20 minutes of fighting. They stopped the confederate advance long enough for reinforcements to plug the gap in the union line, but at a horrible cost of 82% casualty rate. Aftier that charge they were moved to the center of the union line only to then be involved in Pickets charge the next day. They suffered the highest casualty rate on any regiment. I was privileged to make that charge 125 years later on this battlefield. I was the 1st Sergeant of the 1st Minnesota Company A. I was one of the casualty.
Highest casualty rate in the Union Army. The 26th North Carolina is now believed to have suffered a casualty percentage of approximately 98% at Gettysburg, highest for any regiment in any single battle of the war This narrowly eclipsed the previously believed highest, the 1st Texas at Antietam, since it has been learned that the 1st Texas had sent men to find water before the battle and had fewer men than previously thought.
One of the times I went to Gettysburg, our guide was hired for 2 hours. He gave us an extra hour showing us Culps Hill because we were from NY and we had no idea he would do that. What a generous gift. I know my family and I would give a good tip, but I am not sure if he would accept extra money. But he deserved it. But it's a long time ago.
That's awesome, Ms. Prov😃👍 That was nice of your guide to throw you folks a little something extra. I went to Gettysburg with my aunt and uncle and their 2 daughters (my cousins) years ago 1 summer when I was a high school teen. We were touring with a park ranger duo in the Wheatfield and Peach Orchard mainly along with a part of Devil's Den. You could see Little / Big Round Tops in the distance
I had no idea about the 137th New York. I never came across this historical event in all my readings. I think Culps Hills is the least talked about location in Gettysburg. Hollywood should do a Gettysburg movie with the other parts of the battle field and a focus on the 137th New York. What an interesting fight scene that would be.
It really needs to be a miniseries! The movie Gettysburg was 4 hours long and left out so much. You don't heard much about the critical part the Col. George Armstrong Custer played in saving the battle for the Union! Yes, the same Custer of Little Big Horn fame years later.
Col. David Ireland is buried in Binghamton NY in a very simple grave and headstone. Thank you for bringing the importance of the 137th to light. Great job!
Highly recommend Fields of Flame and Glory By David Cluetz. It a regimental history of the 137th. I sat next to that monument one afternoon and ready the chapter describing what the regiment did July 2-3 1863. That was a special day.
Literally grew up 15 minutes from Gettysburg and knew what I thought was everything. Yet you taught me so much more. TY! I look forward to all your videos
Thanks for the video. My Great, great, great father was in the 137th. I was at Gettysburg once, but it was raining so hard I couldn't find or see anything. Need to get back. Thanks again.
I was just in Gettysburg this past week. It amazes me how much is still out there to be learned about the battle even after years of reading and visiting the park. Culps Hill has to be the most underrated and least understood aspect of the battle despite being one of the most critical areas and home to some of the toughest and most sustained fighting. Keep up the good work!
Just curious if you’ve read Ralph Peter’s “Cain at Gettysburg”. I have rudimentary knowledge about Gettysburg and this is the only historical fiction I’ve read about this battle. It’s been awhile but I believe part of the book covers Culp’s Hill from the Confederate POV.
David William Actually got it order again along with some more of his civil war books. I just finished David Poyer’s first book about the naval part of the ACW titled Fire On The Waters that might interest you.
@@TheHistoryUnderground I can’t even express how much I appreciate this Gettysburg series. That place is my addiction and due to many obstacles I haven’t been there for 6 years. Your videos are filling an empty spot for me 😊
Wow! Never knew about the 137th New York. I knew about the fight on Culps hill and how both flanks were attacked simultaneously. Never knew it was as intense as it was. Thanks for shedding some light on these forgotten heroes and how they saved the army of the Potomac from being over run
Of all the things I regret not doing in Gettysburg the climb up the tower on Culp Hill is number 1. My fear of heights kicks in at the first turn and before the second turn im almost paralyzed. Thanks for taking the trip.up there for me.
Once again you managed to do a great job of presenting a lesser known aspect of the battle. Your whole series has been far better than the high hopes I already had.
When my son graduated he and I took a history trip to visit Civil War battlefields that our ancestors had fought at such as Petersburg, Fredericksburg, Bull Run,Gettysburg, and Vicksburg.
I have been to Gettysburg multiple times since I only live about 3 hours away. I have heard, read and saw the movies about the 20th Maine. I have NEVER heard about the 137th NY. It was formed mostly from the Binghamton NY area. The strange thing is that I was born and raised in Binghamton and now live 1 town over from my hometown I have NEVER, NEVER, NEVER heard this story. I am amazed that this has never come up. THANK YOU for this video. I have a lot of research to do now.
I’ve heard that you can judge the bravery of a regiment by the number of casualties they take....30% casualty seems like an insane number! Unfortunately all too common in many of those battles! Great video! This to me was one of the best ones yet in this series!
@@billd.iniowa2263 I agree! The overall number of men and women who died as a result of the civil war is staggering.... but it could have and should have been much worse!
Like you,l can Remember EVERY CLANKING sound of my foot steps climbing those steps to view the panoramic awesomeness of the area in 1963 on the Centennial. HUZZAH
I just learned that a confederate group had a camp site here in my area 2 days before Gettysburg happened. Another great episode JD, keep doing a fantastic job.
Great video! For anybody wanting to learn more about Culp's Hill, I HIGHLY suggest getting a tour with Charlie Fennel. He is the go-to guide for Culp's Hill. Took a tour with him this past January and it was spectacular! It was supposed to be a two hour tour but ended up being closer to four and if it had gone longer, I wouldn't of minded at all.The tour was energetic, entertaining, and oh so interesting. Thanks again for the video. Hopefully with LRT being shut down at the end of this year will bring more interest to Culp's Hill.
You are doing an excellent job with this series n Gettysburg. I visited this area twice in the 1960's while in High School. Having spent summers in Rockland, Maine I can vouch that they are proud of the 20th and Chamberlain! Great Video...
I'm pretty sure that I heard JD muttering, "Dad gum, I really don't like heights" at each and every step up the tower! Thanks again, JD- awesome as usual. Time to start planning my trip to Gettysburg!
Great video and information. Chamberlain's charge has always been a fascinating part of the Battle for me. I have a large painting of it hanging in my library along with a replica and f his sword but I had no idea about the David Ireland charge. I'm only 30min away from here so I need to get back down there. Thanks for the video.
Thanks JD, Once again you amaze this good old boy in Canada. Thank you keep up the good work! Still could not fathom what these poor buggers went through.
I live on Birch St in Binghamton, NY. In my backysrd, on the Susquehanna stand a NYS Historical marker to David Ireland and the 137th NY. My property is exactly where they trained and camped! I have found dozens of relics of those days with my metal detector. My prize item.. An almost perfect button withe the imprint 137 ant the initals W.S. which was enclosed in a sewing kit. Also have buckles and a knife. Incredible video and thank you!
I have to agree with one of comments someone mentioned about not being taught all of the history of Gettysburg. That was so interesting n I agree give credit where credit is do. I also like to mention how helpful it is when you display the map up n showing in how the Confederate n the Union moving into each other. It definitely helps me n gives me much perception in how it all happens. My heart went out to you climbing those stairs. Wow, that was high up. I’d probably never had made it besides I don’t like heights. Hope you’ll have a wonderful Memorial weekend. I believe this is the time your supposed to be cleaning that huge rock in Georgia. ♥️♥️😊👍👍🇺🇸
I just got to visit some forts, both Civil war and Revolutionary, earlier this week in Georgia. Being there on the ground is such a humbling feeling. Love the history and enjoy your videos.
I'm from the Binghamton NY area, where the 137th were partially from. Every school trip to Gettysburg we made sure to visit their monument as well as some of their graves in the National Cemetery. Thank you for telling their story!! Great job with the video :)
@@TheHistoryUnderground there is a video on UA-cam called the rebel yell lives ..its a two part video that reconstructs what the rebel yell sounded like using recordings from two different Confederate soldiers....when you hear it, its absolutely chilling. When I tour battlefields, I can hear what it sounds like and its frightening.
Another action I hadnt heard of. I knew things got hot on Culp's hill, but I didnt realize it was so close there on the far right. BTW, using your car for a reference point REALLY helped alot JD. You might think of doing that more in the future. You may know which way North is while walking around, but we havent a clue. Panning the camera back along your route is a very good aid for us. Thanx. :-)
Excellent documentaries not only on the Civil War but on Normandy as well. It makes you wonder what those men of the 137th were thinking or talking about just before the battle started @ Culp's Hill. They did as they were told in front of an incredible force, & carried out there orders, incredible bravery.
I did the tour in July and it was brutal, drank a lot of water. Its common practice to dig in and build up in a defensive position especially in this case. The Union had the high ground and the advantage here, the terrain is brutal from what I remember. If the confederates had Artillery support on their advance it may have helped keep the Unions head down. A force ratio that I used was in the service was 3:1, that simple means when attacking a defensive position such as this the Commander will factor in the number of troops required to take this hill. There are other variables but 3:1 is a guide. Great commentary on this episode. Very keen on using the words "strategic withdrawal" and not a Retreat lol.
This is such great work. I kinda wish it was filmed in July, but you would have had tourists all over the place -- which is wonderful, but not so great for recreating history. JD, you are an inspiration to all of us amateur historians out there who love American history, and Civil War history in particular.
This is why I like watching you, your not likely to leave history out, when it belongs there. The 137th NY deserves much deserved attention, as well as others. Thanks you JD.
Just wanted to say a big thank you for this series on Gettysburg. Although being from the UK 🇬🇧 we did get some input at School about Gettysburg and the wider American Civil War. This was some 40 years ago for me 😳. It’s great to see these places I’ve only ever read about and never had the opportunity to cross the pond and visit. Your hard work is paying off in spades of great content. Top job 👍👏
The answer to that question is most assuredly no. Here’s the rub however; those not buried at Gettysburg were the ones who’s families could afford to have their bodies shipped back to their families. During the Civil War, a lot of times, people were temporarily buried on the battlefield, and at a later date, a family member would arrive to claim the body, at which time the body would be exhumed and returned to the family. Their customs were actually quite different than today’s customs as well.
I had read stories mostly from magazine Civil War Times Illustrated about special units hired to disinter bodies and reinter elsewhere. Bodies would be identified through letters, Bibles, pocket watches and other personal items.
I love your videos. So easy to understand the way you explain things that escape me. I never knew they fought at night? I was under the impression when nightfall came, they decided to cease fire
My 2X's Great Grandfather Russell Smith also fought on Culp's hill; he was part of the 123rd NY Co. F which also built breastworks on Culp's....most probably along side of the 137th. You briefly showed the 123rd monument which is depicted as Clio recording what happened during the 123rd fight on Culp's hill; so it wasn't forgotten. Just like the 137th........I would think that many regiments have similar stories/situations that weren't recognized or told....not only in Gettysburg but in many Civil War battles. I really appreciate you sharing what you have learned about the 137th. I find all this very interesting....many thanks!!!!
I am so grateful for all the privileges that I often take for granted, living in our great nation ... where so many brave men died for what they believed in. My prayer is that we always remember that we are Americans first and that we would choose to stand together in any difficulty that might face us. God bless America.
LOVE your Gettysburg series. Your selection of background music is GREAT. The high resolution videography is outstaning clear and in focus... what is amazing is you do it as a "selfie" ...damn great camera you have. Your voice delivery of the stories is PERFECT. 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 Keep up the outstanding videos!
If you've watched a few episodes and feel like I've earned it, be sure to subscribe so that you don't miss any new content when it comes out. Click here: ua-cam.com/users/thehistoryunderground Thanks!
This area, Culp's Hill or Hills is an area I have yet to explore. You have made me think about so many untold stories that are overshadowed by publications and movies, etc. When I was working on my book "Battery Wagner" I was totally unaware that a movie called Glory was being produced. At the time I was working on it, there were no dedicated books that I know of covering the fights on Morris Island other than the publications from veterans and regimental histories to tell the details of the 58 day siege.
Yet another amazing video! I wish I would have had someone like you to show me around. I would have understood more. The men of 137th N.Y definitely deserve a lot of credit. Keep up the awesome work and keep the videos coming!
Thank you for telling the story of David Ireland and the 137th NY. Every time someone starts singing the praises of JL Chamberlain and the 20th ME, I always say "Let me tell you about the extreme RIGHT of the union line...". We can't let the 137th NY be forgotten.
So true.. Thanks to a great tour guide during my one and only visit to Gettysburg I became obsessed with the battle on Culps hill. It actually became my favorite part of the battlefield!!
Next time you are at the battlefield rent a moped from Gettypeds, a rental shop right in town. My brother and I do it just about every year, and we have a great time touring the park.
My great great great grandfather William Thomas Roszell was there, 7th Indiana Inf. Reading some of his letters home still astonishes me. He was involved in a good portion of major points to include battle of Winchester, Groveton, second battle of bull run, was at reserve in Antietam, fought in Fredericksburg, the Mud March, battle of Chancellorsville, Gettysburg obviously, at the battle of wilderness he was wounded , and was sent to a field hospital causing him to miss spotsylvania, but volunteered and according to some of the letters respectfully demanded to be sent back to his brothers/friends sides and made it back to them may 25th 1864 and ended up less then a week later at cold harbor, and a few more smaller lesser known clashes. As I said his letters home to his parents and fiancé are truly astounding to read.
I tell anyone who asks why I go to these places, it’s about respect. I have respect for both sides. These men were fighting for what they believed in , no matter what you think about their morals or politics. I can respect their actions without supporting some of their motivations. Another good story and great video. I am enjoying the untold stories.
Thank You I had recently discovered this man when i googled my name out of boredom, He was a pretty interesting man . There is a book out about this man, I forget the exact title. It is about him and the 137th NY.
I've always been interested in the Civil War History, especially Gettysburg, and like everyone I always thought that 20 Maine's charge was unique. You sir have taught me one thing with this, The Battle of Gettysburg, while such a terrible waste of human life, wasn't just about the Big Picture, but that there are many aspects to that Picture. Nothing ever has been said about 137 New York's part in this at all, especially the almost parallel actions of both Regiments, I know Col. Chamberlain was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honour for his actions, but it seems that Col. Ireland also should have been so Honoured. I guess that is an oversight of History.
Thanks for sharing another of the “many” lesser known stories of Gettysburg. Unfortunately due to the moratorium on statues, a number of famous units or battles are forgotten to time.
Great video! I saw a different video about the saddle between the hills (I believe by the Battlefield Trust) and your video really helped paint a picture of the battle. I am moving to a place less than an hours drive from Gettysburg and I'm looking forward to seeing these places in person.
Finally got to watch this one after seeing the notification all day while driving back to Michigan. I'm beginning to get a picture of the battle of Gettysburg coming from a background of knowing almost nothing. Your videos are playing a big part of that. Thanks for another excellent video JD👍. Safe travels.
My great great grandfather fought there and was from NY. He kept a diary and one of his pages said “I saw old Abe today and he is a ugly cuss!” I can only imagine all the hell he went thru.
Great overview!. Never knew about 137 NY Sad how many times major events are forgotten about not on purpose necessarily but just because they are not recorded properly.
Thank you for doing this series, Gettysburg is my favorite travel destination. For the last ten years we have traveled there once and sometimes twice a year, every time I go I achieve a better understanding of the battle and actions of units and individuals. This video put the focus on the 137th NY and pointed out the contribution of this unit. Here's an interesting point: John Wesley Culp's family owned this property he chose to join the Confederates fought and died on this very hill July 2nd 1863 We will be traveling to Gettysburg again this fall and look forward to checking out the Park Services efforts to the Culp's hill restoration. Thanks again.
I've watched a lot of ABT's videos but I enjoy yours so very much more. I think that they try to include so much information that would be perfectly appropriate in an hour and a half video, in 35 minutes. If I was there in person and able to absorb the surroundings before and during it would be perfectly fine. You have the innate ability to casually speak and show with enough detail a broad view of the topic of your videos without creating a jumble. I can follow their videos but you make a video on the same topics, say the same things but is so much more enjoyable to watch. I still pause and go to Google maps as with everything historical I watch but I don't feel I need to rush that aspect because I've got 8 more 50 minute videos to watch that evening that I'm off. I normally work 6-7 days a week and get very little time in the evening. My long story short is your presentation is top notch and unmatched for the time and I thank you very much sir.
16th Maine's rear-guard action on the first day also comes to mind too ... I think of all the heroic actions by different regiments during the battle this one must be ranked as one of the most important.
Couldn't agree more regarding the 16th Maine. Even Chamberlain thought their actions on Jul 1st had been far overlooked. The Division Commander ordered the 16th to hold at all costs so the rest of the Division could pull back towards Gettysburg. The 16th casualty numbers were astounding in a very short period of time. Highly recommend reading up on the 16th.
Least we forget the 1st Minnesota on the second day charging the Confederates with 262 men. They were out numbered 3-4 to one. Only 47 returned after 15-20 minutes of fighting. They stopped the confederate advance long enough for reinforcements to plug the gap in the union line, but at a horrible cost of 82% casualty rate. Aftier that charge they were moved to the center of the union line only to then be involved in Pickets charge the next day. They suffered the highest casualty rate on any regiment.
I was privileged to make that charge 125 years later on this battlefield. I was the 1st Sergeant of the 1st Minnesota Company A. I was one of the casualty.
Don't forget they had two Medal of Honor winners as well; Marshall Sherman and Henry D O'Brian.
Highest casualty rate in the Union Army. The 26th North Carolina is now believed to have suffered a casualty percentage of approximately 98% at Gettysburg, highest for any regiment in any single battle of the war This narrowly eclipsed the previously believed highest, the 1st Texas at Antietam, since it has been learned that the 1st Texas had sent men to find water before the battle and had fewer men than previously thought.
1st Minnesota says hello about being the most overlooked regiment at Gettysburg
Wish I could give you more than just 1 thumbs up
🙂
They are overlooked at Chickamauga too
One of the times I went to Gettysburg, our guide was hired for 2 hours. He gave us an extra hour showing us Culps Hill because we were from NY and we had no idea he would do that. What a generous gift. I know my family and I would give a good tip, but I am not sure if he would accept extra money. But he deserved it. But it's a long time ago.
That's awesome, Ms. Prov😃👍 That was nice of your guide to throw you folks a little something extra. I went to Gettysburg with my aunt and uncle and their 2 daughters (my cousins) years ago 1 summer when I was a high school teen. We were touring with a park ranger duo in the Wheatfield and Peach Orchard mainly along with a part of Devil's Den. You could see Little / Big Round Tops in the distance
My late mom and dad were both native New Yorkers themselves. Mom was from Upper Nyack : Dad was from New Rochelle
@@michaelvaughn8864 Long Island. But upstate many many times.
@@SueProv Oh, wow!! 1 of my cousins I was in Gettysburg with back in '85 had a college BFF from Hempstead. Small world😂😂
@@SueProv Last I heard, she was living in Pulaski
Wow. Nice to hear a part of this history that wasn't taught in school. Prayers of peace now on this Memorial Day eve. 🙏🙏
Amen...
I had no idea about the 137th New York. I never came across this historical event in all my readings. I think Culps Hills is the least talked about location in Gettysburg. Hollywood should do a Gettysburg movie with the other parts of the battle field and a focus on the 137th New York. What an interesting fight scene that would be.
It really needs to be a miniseries! The movie Gettysburg was 4 hours long and left out so much. You don't heard much about the critical part the Col. George Armstrong Custer played in saving the battle for the Union! Yes, the same Custer of Little Big Horn fame years later.
I personally think Hollywood should stay off hollowed grounds,the movie they made there sucked I thought.
Col. David Ireland is buried in Binghamton NY in a very simple grave and headstone. Thank you for bringing the importance of the 137th to light. Great job!
Oh wow. Didn’t know that. Thanks!
Highly recommend Fields of Flame and Glory By David Cluetz. It a regimental history of the 137th. I sat next to that monument one afternoon and ready the chapter describing what the regiment did July 2-3 1863. That was a special day.
Oh wow. Thanks!
The left and right flanks were both pivotal in this battle,and the similarity is uncanny. Thx again 🖒.. cA
One needs to spend over a whole weeks time at Gettysburg to see it all !!
Agreed
Literally grew up 15 minutes from Gettysburg and knew what I thought was everything. Yet you taught me so much more. TY! I look forward to all your videos
My wife is lucky I don’t live 15 minutes from Gettysburg!!🤣
Thanks for the video. My Great, great, great father was in the 137th. I was at Gettysburg once, but it was raining so hard I couldn't find or see anything. Need to get back. Thanks again.
I was just in Gettysburg this past week. It amazes me how much is still out there to be learned about the battle even after years of reading and visiting the park. Culps Hill has to be the most underrated and least understood aspect of the battle despite being one of the most critical areas and home to some of the toughest and most sustained fighting. Keep up the good work!
Just curious if you’ve read Ralph Peter’s “Cain at Gettysburg”. I have rudimentary knowledge about Gettysburg and this is the only historical fiction I’ve read about this battle. It’s been awhile but I believe part of the book covers Culp’s Hill from the Confederate POV.
@@mako88sb I enjoyed that book a lot.
David William Actually got it order again along with some more of his civil war books. I just finished David Poyer’s first book about the naval part of the ACW titled Fire On The Waters that might interest you.
Indeed, Culp vs Culp on CULPS HILL, and Maryland (US) vs Maryland (CS )troops
engaged.......the irony and
consequence of war
JD you absolutely never disappoint 😊
I am loving this “trip” to Gettysburg
Appreciate that.
@@TheHistoryUnderground I can’t even express how much I appreciate this Gettysburg series. That place is my addiction and due to many obstacles I haven’t been there for 6 years. Your videos are filling an empty spot for me 😊
You definitely went to Gettysburg at the right time with the leaves down. Great video and love watching them. Thank you.
Wow! Never knew about the 137th New York. I knew about the fight on Culps hill and how both flanks were attacked simultaneously. Never knew it was as intense as it was. Thanks for shedding some light on these forgotten heroes and how they saved the army of the Potomac from being over run
👍🏻
Thank you for filling in gaps in our history of Gettysburg
👍🏻
Of all the things I regret not doing in Gettysburg the climb up the tower on Culp Hill is number 1. My fear of heights kicks in at the first turn and before the second turn im almost paralyzed. Thanks for taking the trip.up there for me.
Once again you managed to do a great job of presenting a lesser known aspect of the battle. Your whole series has been far better than the high hopes I already had.
When my son graduated he and I took a history trip to visit Civil War battlefields that our ancestors had fought at such as Petersburg, Fredericksburg, Bull Run,Gettysburg, and Vicksburg.
I have been to Gettysburg multiple times since I only live about 3 hours away. I have heard, read and saw the movies about the 20th Maine. I have NEVER heard about the 137th NY. It was formed mostly from the Binghamton NY area. The strange thing is that I was born and raised in Binghamton and now live 1 town over from my hometown I have NEVER, NEVER, NEVER heard this story. I am amazed that this has never come up. THANK YOU for this video. I have a lot of research to do now.
Thank you I appreciate hearing about these brave men..🇺🇸🗽☮️
These vids are getting better every time, the production quality and narrative are first class.....keep up the good work ;)
🙏🏼
I’ve heard that you can judge the bravery of a regiment by the number of casualties they take....30% casualty seems like an insane number! Unfortunately all too common in many of those battles! Great video! This to me was one of the best ones yet in this series!
Surprising it wasnt higher, given the short range of the muskets. But of coarse there's alot of cover there.
@@billd.iniowa2263 I agree! The overall number of men and women who died as a result of the civil war is staggering.... but it could have and should have been much worse!
Thanks!
@@Headstoneman Why “should” it have been worse?
I didn’t know about the 137th New York on Lower Culp’s Hill. Thank you for the great history lesson 👍🏻
👍🏻
I would love to see him do an episode on the MD vs MD battle at culps hill too
Me too.
Ironically, two relatives named CULP...fought on Culps Hill from two opposing Maryland Regiments ...who would ever have thunk it!!!!!!
Another fine video, JD! The more you study the American Civil War, the more you learn about the unsung heroes.
Absolutely. Thanks.
As someone who has climbed those towers several times, I felt that pause when you started lol
😅
Like you,l can Remember EVERY CLANKING sound of my foot steps climbing those steps to view the
panoramic awesomeness of the
area in 1963 on the Centennial.
HUZZAH
The foresight to build up earthworks is what kept that flank from falling
Great videos. My son and I will be visiting Gettysburg for the first time in October. We are so looking forward to the trip!
Awesome!
Great to hear about other units going above and beyond. What a generation hard as nails just so sad it had to come to war.
🇺🇸
I just learned that a confederate group had a camp site here in my area 2 days before Gettysburg happened. Another great episode JD, keep doing a fantastic job.
Great video! For anybody wanting to learn more about Culp's Hill, I HIGHLY suggest getting a tour with Charlie Fennel. He is the go-to guide for Culp's Hill. Took a tour with him this past January and it was spectacular! It was supposed to be a two hour tour but ended up being closer to four and if it had gone longer, I wouldn't of minded at all.The tour was energetic, entertaining, and oh so interesting. Thanks again for the video. Hopefully with LRT being shut down at the end of this year will bring more interest to Culp's Hill.
You are doing an excellent job with this series n Gettysburg.
I visited this area twice in the 1960's while in High School.
Having spent summers in Rockland, Maine I can vouch that
they are proud of the 20th and Chamberlain! Great Video...
🙏🏼
This for me is what sets your content above others, I loved the stories you told in this, especially about the lesser known men and units.
Thanks! A pity that this regiment hasn't got the attention that it deserves.
I'm pretty sure that I heard JD muttering, "Dad gum, I really don't like heights" at each and every step up the tower! Thanks again, JD- awesome as usual. Time to start planning my trip to Gettysburg!
Ha!
Dat Damn Tower gets Higher and Steeper every year!
Great video and information. Chamberlain's charge has always been a fascinating part of the Battle for me. I have a large painting of it hanging in my library along with a replica and f his sword but I had no idea about the David Ireland charge. I'm only 30min away from here so I need to get back down there. Thanks for the video.
Awesome! It’s certainly worth checking out.
Thanks for sharing the story of the 137th NY, Culps Hill was a bloodbath. The videos have been outstanding JD!
🙏🏼
Years ago spent one afternoon at Gettysburg and thought I had it covered . Your series on Gettysburg is changing my future travel plans.
Awesome 👍🏻
Thanks JD, Once again you amaze this good old boy in Canada. Thank you keep up the good work! Still could not fathom what these poor buggers went through.
Great tribute to the 137th NY ! Keep up the good work !
👊🏻
We are just loving your work. After we watch there are discussions and further studies about it. Thank you
Thank you for giving Col. Ireland's 137th New York(and Culp's Hill) their props!
👍🏻
I live on Birch St in Binghamton, NY. In my backysrd, on the Susquehanna stand a NYS Historical marker to David Ireland and the 137th NY. My property is exactly where they trained and camped! I have found dozens of relics of those days with my metal detector. My prize item.. An almost perfect button withe the imprint 137 ant the initals W.S. which was enclosed in a sewing kit. Also have buckles and a knife. Incredible video and thank you!
Wow!!!
I have to agree with one of comments someone mentioned about not being taught all of the history of Gettysburg. That was so interesting n I agree give credit where credit is do. I also like to mention how helpful it is when you display the map up n showing in how the Confederate n the Union moving into each other. It definitely helps me n gives me
much perception in how it all happens. My heart went out to you climbing those stairs. Wow, that was high up. I’d probably never had made it besides I don’t like heights. Hope you’ll have a wonderful Memorial weekend. I believe this is the time your supposed to be cleaning that huge rock in Georgia. ♥️♥️😊👍👍🇺🇸
Thanks! And yes, there will be a Currahee update soon 🙂
I just got to visit some forts, both Civil war and Revolutionary, earlier this week in Georgia. Being there on the ground is such a humbling feeling. Love the history and enjoy your videos.
I'm from the Binghamton NY area, where the 137th were partially from. Every school trip to Gettysburg we made sure to visit their monument as well as some of their graves in the National Cemetery. Thank you for telling their story!! Great job with the video :)
I'm hoping to see some documentary videos on Spotsylvania Courthouse and the Wilderness. The Gettysburg videos are excellent.
Definitely plan on both of those someday.
@@TheHistoryUnderground there is a video on UA-cam called the rebel yell lives ..its a two part video that reconstructs what the rebel yell sounded like using recordings from two different Confederate soldiers....when you hear it, its absolutely chilling. When I tour battlefields, I can hear what it sounds like and its frightening.
Job well done. I like your boots on the ground narrative. I'm re-reading my copy of "They Met at Gettysburg "...🇺🇸🎩🇺🇸
Thanks!!!
Another action I hadnt heard of. I knew things got hot on Culp's hill, but I didnt realize it was so close there on the far right. BTW, using your car for a reference point REALLY helped alot JD. You might think of doing that more in the future. You may know which way North is while walking around, but we havent a clue. Panning the camera back along your route is a very good aid for us. Thanx. :-)
Thanks. I try to do that where I can to give some points of reference.
Excellent documentaries not only on the Civil War but on Normandy as well. It makes you wonder what those men of the 137th were thinking or talking about just before the battle started @ Culp's Hill. They did as they were told in front of an incredible force, & carried out there orders, incredible bravery.
I did the tour in July and it was brutal, drank a lot of water. Its common practice to dig in and build up in a defensive position especially in this case. The Union had the high ground and the advantage here, the terrain is brutal from what I remember. If the confederates had Artillery support on their advance it may have helped keep the Unions head down. A force ratio that I used was in the service was 3:1, that simple means when attacking a defensive position such as this the Commander will factor in the number of troops required to take this hill. There are other variables but 3:1 is a guide. Great commentary on this episode. Very keen on using the words "strategic withdrawal" and not a Retreat lol.
Ha! Thanks.
This is such great work. I kinda wish it was filmed in July, but you would have had tourists all over the place -- which is wonderful, but not so great for recreating history. JD, you are an inspiration to all of us amateur historians out there who love American history, and Civil War history in particular.
Thanks! I appreciate that. And yeah, I try to film during times when the pressure is the lowest. Plus, I hate the heat (lol)
This is why I like watching you, your not likely to leave history out, when it belongs there. The 137th NY deserves much deserved attention, as well as others. Thanks you JD.
👍🏻
excellent overview of the Union right flank on Culp's Hill. thanks
Thanks! Love that story.
Thank you so much for doing this series.
🙏🏼
Just wanted to say a big thank you for this series on Gettysburg. Although being from the UK 🇬🇧 we did get some input at School about Gettysburg and the wider American Civil War. This was some 40 years ago for me 😳. It’s great to see these places I’ve only ever read about and never had the opportunity to cross the pond and visit. Your hard work is paying off in spades of great content. Top job 👍👏
Again, you are my favorite history teacher! At 69 y.o. I am learning so much. Were all the men who were killed at Gettysburg buried on those grounds?
Well when Lincoln gave his famous address he (and others) were commemorating the new cemetery there. So I'd say yes.
The answer to that question is most assuredly no. Here’s the rub however; those not buried at Gettysburg were the ones who’s families could afford to have their bodies shipped back to their families. During the Civil War, a lot of times, people were temporarily buried on the battlefield, and at a later date, a family member would arrive to claim the body, at which time the body would be exhumed and returned to the family. Their customs were actually quite different than today’s customs as well.
@@ThatIsJustCrazyTalk Ok, well I was temporarily right anyway, lol. Thanx for correcting me. :-)
I had read stories mostly from magazine Civil War Times Illustrated about special units hired to disinter bodies and reinter elsewhere. Bodies would be identified through letters, Bibles, pocket watches and other personal items.
A good research project for someone who wants to write a book leading to a movie. Thank you for the tour and narration, all new to me.
Thank you so much for this information. Please keep educating us with more.
Thanks! Feel free to share these out and help spread the knowledge 🙂
I love your videos. So easy to understand the way you explain things that escape me. I never knew they fought at night? I was under the impression when nightfall came, they decided to cease fire
Thanks! Always learning something 😁
Not Always, remember the 54th
Mass waited till night to assault the parapets at Battery Wagner
on Morris Island,SC in 1863
This was awesome! My great-great-grandfather fought with the 28th Pennsylvania on Culp’s Hill.
I subscribed a while ago and my compliments on your presentations. They truly have all the ingredients of a professional.
My 2X's Great Grandfather Russell Smith also fought on Culp's hill; he was part of the 123rd NY Co. F which also built breastworks on Culp's....most probably along side of the 137th.
You briefly showed the 123rd monument which is depicted as Clio recording what happened during the 123rd fight on Culp's hill; so it wasn't forgotten.
Just like the 137th........I would think that many regiments have similar stories/situations that weren't recognized or told....not only in Gettysburg but in many Civil War battles. I really appreciate you sharing what you have learned about the 137th. I find all this very interesting....many thanks!!!!
I am so grateful for all the privileges that I often take for granted, living in our great nation ... where so many brave men died for what they believed in. My prayer is that we always remember that we are Americans first and that we would choose to stand together in any difficulty that might face us. God bless America.
LOVE your Gettysburg series. Your selection of background music is GREAT. The high resolution videography is outstaning clear and in focus... what is amazing is you do it as a "selfie" ...damn great camera you have. Your voice delivery of the stories is PERFECT. 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 Keep up the outstanding videos!
If you've watched a few episodes and feel like I've earned it, be sure to subscribe so that you don't miss any new content when it comes out. Click here: ua-cam.com/users/thehistoryunderground
Thanks!
You've earned every penny you get. Happy to be subscribed to The History Underground and support your work.
This area, Culp's Hill or Hills is an area I have yet to explore. You have made me think about so many untold stories that are overshadowed by publications and movies, etc. When I was working on my book "Battery Wagner" I was totally unaware that a movie called Glory was being produced. At the time I was working on it, there were no dedicated books that I know of covering the fights on Morris Island other than the publications from veterans and regimental histories to tell the details of the 58 day siege.
Thank you; I have long held that the story of Col Ireland the 137th NY needs to be told
👍🏻🇺🇸
Excellent video. I visited Gettysburg in 2019 and climbed that tower also. Hope to make it back there.
Very cool!
Yet another amazing video! I wish I would have had someone like you to show me around. I would have understood more. The men of 137th N.Y definitely deserve a lot of credit. Keep up the awesome work and keep the videos coming!
Thank you for telling the story of David Ireland and the 137th NY. Every time someone starts singing the praises of JL Chamberlain and the 20th ME, I always say "Let me tell you about the extreme RIGHT of the union line...". We can't let the 137th NY be forgotten.
I’ve never heard this story. Thank you for telling it
So true.. Thanks to a great tour guide during my one and only visit to Gettysburg I became obsessed with the battle on Culps hill. It actually became my favorite part of the battlefield!!
Me too!
I am sure there are MANY more stories like this that have been forgotten. Thank you for keeping the memory alive. Excellent job!
🇺🇸
Next time you are at the battlefield rent a moped from Gettypeds, a rental shop right in town. My brother and I do it just about every year, and we have a great time touring the park.
Nice!
My great great great grandfather
William Thomas Roszell was there,
7th Indiana Inf. Reading some of his letters home still astonishes me. He was involved in a good portion of major points to include battle of Winchester, Groveton, second battle of bull run, was at reserve in Antietam, fought in Fredericksburg, the Mud March, battle of Chancellorsville, Gettysburg obviously, at the battle of wilderness he was wounded , and was sent to a field hospital causing him to miss spotsylvania, but volunteered and according to some of the letters respectfully demanded to be sent back to his brothers/friends sides and made it back to them may 25th 1864 and ended up less then a week later at cold harbor, and a few more smaller lesser known clashes. As I said his letters home to his parents and fiancé are truly astounding to read.
To read when he writes about the “Mud March” a few comical points when he’s describing how terrible a go it was.
I tell anyone who asks why I go to these places, it’s about respect. I have respect for both sides. These men were fighting for what they believed in , no matter what you think about their morals or politics. I can respect their actions without supporting some of their motivations. Another good story and great video. I am enjoying the untold stories.
Thank You I had recently discovered this man when i googled my name out of boredom, He was a pretty interesting man . There is a book out about this man, I forget the exact title. It is about him and the 137th NY.
The bravery of men on both sides just astounds me. All were so selfless in giving their lives if needed for the cause each of them believed in.
Excellent Vlog....Thanks Again....
Thanks!
I absolutely love your videos. I am visiting Gettysburg myself for the first time later this month.
I've always been interested in the Civil War History, especially Gettysburg, and like everyone I always thought that 20 Maine's charge was unique. You sir have taught me one thing with this, The Battle of Gettysburg, while such a terrible waste of human life, wasn't just about the Big Picture, but that there are many aspects to that Picture. Nothing ever has been said about 137 New York's part in this at all, especially the almost parallel actions of both Regiments, I know Col. Chamberlain was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honour for his actions, but it seems that Col. Ireland also should have been so Honoured. I guess that is an oversight of History.
Thanks for sharing another of the “many” lesser known stories of Gettysburg. Unfortunately due to the moratorium on statues, a number of famous units or battles are forgotten to time.
Great video! I saw a different video about the saddle between the hills (I believe by the Battlefield Trust) and your video really helped paint a picture of the battle. I am moving to a place less than an hours drive from Gettysburg and I'm looking forward to seeing these places in person.
EXCELLENT video along with all the others! Thank you for bringing Gettysburg into focus.
Finally got to watch this one after seeing the notification all day while driving back to Michigan. I'm beginning to get a picture of the battle of Gettysburg coming from a background of knowing almost nothing. Your videos are playing a big part of that. Thanks for another excellent video JD👍. Safe travels.
Thanks! Travel safe!
I have been to Gettysburg a few times and I really get overwhelmed with what these men endured. Your videos are wonderful. Keep up the good work.
Thank you so much!
My great great grandfather fought there and was from NY. He kept a diary and one of his pages said “I saw old Abe today and he is a ugly cuss!” I can only imagine all the hell he went thru.
Great overview!.
Never knew about 137 NY
Sad how many times major events are forgotten about not on purpose necessarily but just because they are not recorded properly.
Thanks for sharing. Enjoy your long weekend.
Thank you for doing this series, Gettysburg is my favorite travel destination. For the last ten years we have traveled there once and sometimes twice a year, every time I go I achieve a better understanding of the battle and actions of units and individuals. This video put the focus on the 137th NY and pointed out the contribution of this unit.
Here's an interesting point: John Wesley Culp's family owned this property he chose to join the Confederates fought and died on this very hill July 2nd 1863
We will be traveling to Gettysburg again this fall and look forward to checking out the Park Services efforts to the Culp's hill restoration.
Thanks again.
Great catch! I’ve studied a lot about Gettysburg, but did not know there had been a “refusal of the line” on Culp’s Hill(s), too!
Thanks. Feel free to share it out! Would love to see more people learning this story.
Nice History Lesson History Underground..... Never knew about this part of the Fight in Detail before...Thank You.....
I've watched a lot of ABT's videos but I enjoy yours so very much more. I think that they try to include so much information that would be perfectly appropriate in an hour and a half video, in 35 minutes. If I was there in person and able to absorb the surroundings before and during it would be perfectly fine. You have the innate ability to casually speak and show with enough detail a broad view of the topic of your videos without creating a jumble. I can follow their videos but you make a video on the same topics, say the same things but is so much more enjoyable to watch. I still pause and go to Google maps as with everything historical I watch but I don't feel I need to rush that aspect because I've got 8 more 50 minute videos to watch that evening that I'm off. I normally work 6-7 days a week and get very little time in the evening. My long story short is your presentation is top notch and unmatched for the time and I thank you very much sir.
Another great video. This entire Gettysburg series has been outstanding!
Glad you like them! Hopefully people are sharing them out so that others can learn as well. Thank you for watching.
Thank you... I must endeavor to visit Gettysburg...
Excellent content much appreciated.
👍🏻
16th Maine's rear-guard action on the first day also comes to mind too ... I think of all the heroic actions by different regiments during the battle this one must be ranked as one of the most important.
Couldn't agree more regarding the 16th Maine. Even Chamberlain thought their actions on Jul 1st had been far overlooked. The Division Commander ordered the 16th to hold at all costs so the rest of the Division could pull back towards Gettysburg. The 16th casualty numbers were astounding in a very short period of time. Highly recommend reading up on the 16th.
Love this series brother, keep it up.
👍🏻
JD.
Thank you so much for your videos.
I have been fascinated by military history my whole life and your videos are the greatest.
🙏🏼
That tower is always good for working off a hearty lunch.
You got that right!