I'm sure you didnt get his message so I'm going to quote it for you: "His Sonatas are all great and no mortals should criticized a genius, you are not Medtner sir or madam!" - Aleksey Gunko. He's right, you know.
@@milton3204 well, there are quite a few objective factors that are good for judging melodies or motivic paradigms. Even though elaborating these, like rhythmical symmetry and climaxial clarity among others, would go completely beyond the scope, I think that such a statement as the beginning one of this discussion is quite rational and - even more importantly - judgement should not be demonized under all circumstances (just as nothing should be).
Très belle oeuvre. L'interprétation est très belle aussi.
My favorite Medtner sonata of the bunch. Proves that when he wanted to be, Medtner could be as great a melodist as Rachmaninoff.
I'm sure you didnt get his message so I'm going to quote it for you:
"His Sonatas are all great and no mortals should criticized a genius, you are not Medtner sir or madam!" - Aleksey Gunko.
He's right, you know.
Or his Piano Concerto No.1!
@@milton3204 well, there are quite a few objective factors that are good for judging melodies or motivic paradigms. Even though elaborating these, like rhythmical symmetry and climaxial clarity among others, would go completely beyond the scope, I think that such a statement as the beginning one of this discussion is quite rational and - even more importantly - judgement should not be demonized under all circumstances (just as nothing should be).
Bravo 💐💐💐
Beautifull interpretation
Завораживающе