On silence and the transformation of man | J. Krishnamurti

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 49

  • @easygoing2479
    @easygoing2479 4 роки тому +23

    9:52 - Excellent description of what 'transformation' is. I've found that once one feels this personal growth, there's no turning back. It seems impossible to 'un-experience' it.

    • @mavanijj
      @mavanijj 2 роки тому

      Yes you can’t go back or forward as well and there is no growth you feel are being unmovable😁

  • @ManuLuck82
    @ManuLuck82 2 роки тому +2

    In these 17 minutes JK distilled the core of his life teaching.

  • @mikewright902
    @mikewright902 5 років тому +6

    I just want to say that the silence 😂 he was talking about is for a clear mind . a clear view. And to observe this conditioning, self interest! And everything that thought has created requires great in word attention$$ break the pattern.!! More or less than!! Haha thanks 😊 guys 😁 gal's.

  • @goodearth5584
    @goodearth5584 6 років тому +8

    JK is absolutely right.the day one becomes sub-servient blindly, be it to a Guru or some one highly exalted, you loose your ability to think for yourself.Guru at best can only be a friend, a guide, someone who helps in removing obstacles in one's path, be it spiritual or otherwise; one has to be absolutely independent & willing to walk life without any crutches or support system; willing to face life in all its perplexities is basic for a seeker of truth.only from living can one experience life & learn & be free.even, if there is an entity called God above you, you are not free.the Self is all & we are that, one without a second.

  • @almostashish
    @almostashish 4 роки тому +5

    The most logical question ever.

  • @storiedivitavera1518
    @storiedivitavera1518 Рік тому

    it is difficult now , we have a lot of distraction.... this man , i want to tankyou every familiar it live now ... i dont know if somebody find something for himself , similar or... never know this man other than his word , but i only want to thank for the effort he has done , i know cant be really write , in the end was a normal man he do what he want do. , soo.. ty

  • @RaviPp521114
    @RaviPp521114 7 років тому +14

    If one fail with K, then no god can save us here ever !

  • @xrxs1020
    @xrxs1020 7 років тому +17

    He seems angry here. I've loved and read Krishnamurti for decades, but I've never experienced him like this. Even so, I appreciate the Krishnamurti foundation for releasing so much of his material.

    • @gianpaulov5353
      @gianpaulov5353 7 років тому +19

      Michael Waters he wants to make it clear that this is not an entertainment or lecture and requires deep thought and seriousness. People have always misunderstood him even after dedicating his whole life to free man from his miseries. This is not anger.

    • @longnest
      @longnest 7 років тому +9

      From what i have seen and read, k abhors giving special importance to any label. There were 2 labels here: Pivotal and closed group. His whole teaching has been based on independence and non attachment. He wants the listener to be serious rather than take the teachings superficially

    • @mikewright902
      @mikewright902 5 років тому +1

      I think what you seen was the question just being irritating I think he Expressed that in the beginning? I love his delivery.

    • @Mahesh.with.Honda.CB350
      @Mahesh.with.Honda.CB350 5 років тому +3

      Who said he can't be angry.whats your problem with anger

    • @prasadmulupuri8714
      @prasadmulupuri8714 5 років тому +4

      i think his irritation is with the practice of sitting quietly to achieve a result ie silence. He is against any practice. The questioner reduced his teaching, or so it might have seemed to him, to a mere practice of sitting quietly. He suggests the observation of our multi dimensional, self centered activity and not merely sitting quietly to achieve a result.

  • @SofaKing_Kong
    @SofaKing_Kong 4 роки тому +6

    haha love these moments of slight frustration:D the people just want the messiah and nothing less:D

  • @aanandc4167
    @aanandc4167 5 років тому +2

    Lovly.people listen ing around him they are not in his presence.

  • @jameslynn3702
    @jameslynn3702 2 роки тому +2

    The "Meditation that he is talking about, is just observe and look, without any mental comment. Correct me if I am wrong, but that is true Meditation. Meditation is all there is.

    • @TcSrinivas
      @TcSrinivas Рік тому

      Meditation he means to examine your thought without any judgement

  • @goodreason6462
    @goodreason6462 7 років тому +7

    9:16-9:46 "and we separate this sound from ourselves" don't take this as a theory but actually LOOK!!

  • @zohorahasin2251
    @zohorahasin2251 3 роки тому

    wonderful!

  • @leilamobasserii
    @leilamobasserii 2 роки тому

  • @Amila108
    @Amila108 2 роки тому

    ❤️🕉️☮️☮️☮️❤️

  • @krishnakumarr7042
    @krishnakumarr7042 6 років тому +2

    Amazing and divine!

  • @inthemomenttomoment
    @inthemomenttomoment 7 років тому +9

    Complete silence is only possible above the body. The body cannot hear total silence because, when you listen closely within,
    the body's making inner sounds through its natural vibrations. Supernatural consciousness is able to obtain total silence now.
    The brain that's freed from all causation and outside conditioning is able to receive the Silence it needs to hear the Living OM.

    • @DM-kv9kj
      @DM-kv9kj 7 років тому +7

      What utter nonsense.

    • @Avishekkedia
      @Avishekkedia 7 років тому +1

      Tom Ato some truth to what you say. The body will not know total silence because of its internal vibration.

    • @avrcharyulu1088
      @avrcharyulu1088 5 років тому

      the natural vibrations are different. The silence of the thoughts should be zeroed. It is the calmness of the mind in question.

    • @sanjay-hi
      @sanjay-hi 4 роки тому +1

      Should we try getting rid of our ears? No ears, no sound, total silence, no need to leave your body just destroy your ears...

  • @reddyda
    @reddyda 5 років тому +4

    When people laugh during his talks why does he say "don't laugh". It is better to allow laughter without control.

    • @Mahesh.with.Honda.CB350
      @Mahesh.with.Honda.CB350 5 років тому +3

      You're too childish dude

    • @reddyda
      @reddyda 5 років тому +1

      @@Mahesh.with.Honda.CB350 Observe yourself why you are judgmental

    • @prasadmulupuri8714
      @prasadmulupuri8714 5 років тому +4

      There is thoughtless laughter.

    • @reddyda
      @reddyda 5 років тому

      @@prasadmulupuri8714 Stimulus for laughter can be thoughtless activity like tickling or seeing someone else laugh. Laughter is contagious.

    • @sanjay-hi
      @sanjay-hi 4 роки тому

      Suppose you are going north taking certain path for 10 thousands or a million years, and now some body comes and says, it is going nowhere. Will you laugh at that person or think about it seriously....

  • @joydevghosh8017
    @joydevghosh8017 4 роки тому

    The questioner perhaps made the mistake of mentioning about a close circle which was clearly not liked by j k, as that was against his reputation.Also it is a mistake to make a partial reference to what j k said in the past without mentioning it's details.

  • @ilyasmoulayramdanemoulat1624
    @ilyasmoulayramdanemoulat1624 3 роки тому

    The mutation in resident evil

  • @pavanakumari5652
    @pavanakumari5652 3 роки тому

    Subtitles please !!!

  • @p.nagapavankumar8880
    @p.nagapavankumar8880 5 років тому +1

    Please give subtitles

  • @yevonvanzarovitch5203
    @yevonvanzarovitch5203 3 роки тому

    They is no God , Only Thought
    Understanding is not knowing
    They is no Death , Only cycle

  • @gc7304
    @gc7304 3 роки тому +2

    It's annoying people laugh everything.. In other videos also

  • @AtulKulkarni01
    @AtulKulkarni01 2 роки тому

    The questioner is trolling