10 "Good" Video Game Factions That Are Secretly Evil

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
  • Do-gooders by day, terrifying monsters at night!
    For more awesome content, check out: whatculture.com/gaming
    Catch us on Facebook at: / whatculturegaming
    Find us on Twitter: / wculturegaming
    ----------
    Check out our merch store at: teespring.com/stores/wcg
    Why not join our Discord? / discord
    ----------
    WhatCulture Gaming Podcast now available!
    - iTunes: itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/i...
    - Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/75Wj1jp...
    WhatCulture Gaming Podcast is also available on Acast, Podbean, Podbay, Podcast Addict, and more to come!
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 274

  • @shareeclifton2265
    @shareeclifton2265 24 дні тому +116

    Preston is a good, sweet and brave man. I will hear no slander about him

    • @comradestannis
      @comradestannis 23 дні тому +29

      In the meantime, I'll mark this settlement on your map!

    • @adamgill9730
      @adamgill9730 21 день тому +6

      In my opinion, he is just an imitation of Kaz from the MGS series

    • @comradestannis
      @comradestannis 21 день тому

      @@adamgill9730 Kaz is an imitation of him.

    • @PKFlashOmega
      @PKFlashOmega 21 день тому +13

      Good companion and great guy who is unfortunately stricken with both understandable depression and PTSD while saddled with a terrible game mechanic.

    • @sunayocarissime5309
      @sunayocarissime5309 18 днів тому +5

      Again a guy with his heart in the right place but his brain is soup. Preston is a great guy, but even he has his flaws but those are usually countered by the Soul Survivor IF said SS sides with the Minutemen. That and its a classic case of, "taking something that was dismantled and corrupt and reforging it into something beneficial."

  • @TitusRedwind
    @TitusRedwind 24 дні тому +172

    Followers of the apocalypse aren't evil. They're just a bit incompetent.

    • @kingjamos2422
      @kingjamos2422 24 дні тому +20

      Yup. Dangerously incompetent. Which just makes them accidently make everything worse. Not to mention that they are quite naive to think that teaching those that have known nothing but violent survival how to better themselves couldn't go wrong. Often times it just bites them on the ass. They are essentially what you get when you introduce Steve Urkel to the wastelands. The "Did I do that?" moments become fatal without them really doing wrong. Calling them evil is a big stretch.

    • @Macrochenia
      @Macrochenia 24 дні тому +18

      @@kingjamos2422 Except that most of the stuff Caesar did was not a result of what he learned from the FotA. And it's not like there are any factions in the Fallout universe that have a track record that has less screw ups.

    • @orangefrisby2366
      @orangefrisby2366 24 дні тому +5

      Like communists 😅

    • @kingjamos2422
      @kingjamos2422 23 дні тому +8

      @@Macrochenia Agreed. They just have a tendency of messing things up. That's it. My point was that they are definitely not evil.

    • @st.anselmsfire3547
      @st.anselmsfire3547 23 дні тому

      They are basically university communists. They only see the good in Marx and literally cannot comprehend how this could go bad when selfish people take over. The Followers are the type of people who say that *true* communism has never been put into practice and don't really realize that's kind of a self-own in itself.
      And true communism has been put into practice - in the kibbutz in Israel. But no one wants to claim them either.

  • @Canadamus_Prime
    @Canadamus_Prime 23 дні тому +67

    For a number of these, you are painting the entire faction by the actions of one individual.

    • @alexnicklay8626
      @alexnicklay8626 20 днів тому +5

      They also included factions which arnt evil, the followers of the apocalypse, the companions and the minutemen are not even close to being evil, they aren't even hiding what they are doing either

    • @Canadamus_Prime
      @Canadamus_Prime 19 днів тому +4

      @@alexnicklay8626 Right? Inadvertently causing harm because people take advantage of you doesn't make you evil.

    • @alexnicklay8626
      @alexnicklay8626 19 днів тому +4

      @Canadamus_Prime 100% agreed, she picked the least evil faction in fallout 4 including the minor factions. There is a very good reason everyone who plays fallout 4 considered the minutemen the boring good guys, because every other faction is more nuanced and morally complicated than them.

    • @MGG87
      @MGG87 19 днів тому +5

      Nothing new for WhatCulture. Their lists are never accurate.

    • @Canadamus_Prime
      @Canadamus_Prime 19 днів тому +5

      @@alexnicklay8626 Haven't played Fallout 4, but the Followers of the Apocalypse have been in the franchise since the very first game and there couldn't be a faction LESS evil.

  • @kaitoking1945
    @kaitoking1945 24 дні тому +148

    I'll talk to Preston about this matter as soon as I'm done helping this settlement

    • @Ensensu2
      @Ensensu2 23 дні тому +8

      The only way Preston Garvey is evil is that he keeps annoying you with endless requests to help every single settlement.

    • @CyGogetenks
      @CyGogetenks 21 день тому +1

      ​@Ensensu2 honestly that's why I play with mods, because of that annoying quirk. There's a mod where the quests come through a radio station later after a certain quest is done. (Avoiding spoilers as best I can)

    • @Ioganstone
      @Ioganstone 21 день тому +1

      @@CyGogetenks Woah that's quite a confession

    • @Ioganstone
      @Ioganstone 21 день тому +2

      @@Ensensu2 If you check out the fandom page he is pretty open about his misconceptions about the Minutemen and the inability to protect Quincy. So this hubris of his is self-admittedly evil.

    • @CyGogetenks
      @CyGogetenks 21 день тому +1

      @Ioganstone what? That I use mods? It's a offline FPS RPG, whoop de do, all they do is disable trophies, I'm no trophy hunter, I've been gaming since 89, right now I have a spouse with kidney failure, I want to game to relax, not get mauled to death just trying to enjoy the story of a game. So if a single player game can cheat, I cheat. Basically do when I new game plus the hell out of a game. When I play online I play fair, no mods or cheats. I never play on PC, other than one game and I don't buy mods. I don't condone cheating in online games, or using mods in online games, especially in tournament matches. I play for fun, offline, I don't do twitch streaming, don't care to. So yep, if it was about the fact that I use mods, then there ya go. If it was about the spoiler, I try not to spoil any detail of a game, in case they've not yet played it, or haven't watched a video on it. I try and give the games respect in that regard.

  • @anthonysmurthwaite6258
    @anthonysmurthwaite6258 24 дні тому +41

    The Dalish tribes aren't a single faction, they aren't even the only Dalish tribe in Origins there's at least 3 that play a significant role in quests I can think of

    • @saint-g7449
      @saint-g7449 24 дні тому +10

      The Dalish, in general, are separated as it is. Some attack anyone that get near their camp. While others trade with settlements. Each clan is different from one another.

    • @mbiesbjerg92
      @mbiesbjerg92 21 день тому +4

      and it was not really the clan that did it it was only Zathrian and as I remember it the clan did't know what he had done so i dont really think that they fit this catagori 🤔

  • @andrewwigley745
    @andrewwigley745 24 дні тому +45

    That one incident from a certain dalish tribe doesnt make all dalish tribes evil 😭

    • @cbordagesg2
      @cbordagesg2 23 дні тому +7

      Id also go a bit further. The actions of the keeper is not the fault of the tribe

    • @6Mourning6Star6
      @6Mourning6Star6 23 дні тому +7

      @@cbordagesg2 Fr though. The tribe had no idea of Zathrian's involvement with the werewolves. They didn't know it was his curse that made him seem immortal and made them think he had unlocked some secret history of the Dalish that involved their used to be long lived lifespans.

    • @derrickhaggard
      @derrickhaggard 22 дні тому +2

      @@6Mourning6Star6 Correct hence why I always go for the peaceful middle option which ironically ends with a fight which is ask Zathrian to end the curse because the innocent descendants of the guilty who actually did the crimes he mentioned and the Dalish Tribe are both suffering because of his vengeance and just letting go of the hate and ending the curse saves both from the curse. And like Alister says when Zathrian asks why I'm asking him to end the curse "Because we do what's right no matter what." And going for the option that saves both the humans and the elves is the option I'm going with.

  • @CedricPETIEU-hh3tk
    @CedricPETIEU-hh3tk 24 дні тому +77

    The Minutemen are not evil. This faction have betrayed. Actually, Preston Garvey IS the Minutemen.

    • @saint-g7449
      @saint-g7449 24 дні тому +5

      That's what she said.

    • @st.anselmsfire3547
      @st.anselmsfire3547 23 дні тому +5

      There's a settlement that needs your help. I'll mark it on your map.

    • @zambekiller
      @zambekiller 23 дні тому +2

      But they are evil more than half of them joined the Gunner's and became the very thing they swore to destroy

    • @zachlewis2751
      @zachlewis2751 23 дні тому +1

      ​@@st.anselmsfire3547fuck it! I'll destroy that settlement myself

    • @comradestannis
      @comradestannis 23 дні тому +1

      @@zambekiller that's... not the same thing, though.

  • @troperhghar9898
    @troperhghar9898 21 день тому +7

    My dad always taught me that "perfect is the enemy of 'good enough' and demanding a perfect answer while tossing away any option that costs you something leaves you with nothing"

  • @NemoEtNihil
    @NemoEtNihil 24 дні тому +19

    The fact that The Last of Us Part II frames the Fireflies as benevolent freedom fighters is just another aspect of that game that feels directly at odds with the first.

    • @OrkBoyChuck
      @OrkBoyChuck 22 дні тому +5

      The shifting perspectives from Abby and Ellie is your first clue that perspective makes the cycle of violence more tragic. It isnt at odds with the first game and actually enhances the experience.

    • @ombra711
      @ombra711 21 день тому

      You like the idiot who came up with this list just do not get it

    • @seaberry11
      @seaberry11 21 день тому +4

      The game wasn’t trying to frame the fireflies as benevolent. You were seeing things from Abby’s point of view. The same way you don’t see Joel as the murderous raider he was…because you played with him and Ellie in the first game. Joel was not a hero, the fireflies were not heroes, death creates a constant cycle of death. That is what these games are trying to say.

    • @joshrosario1269
      @joshrosario1269 21 день тому +3

      ​​@@seaberry11except we did see Joel as a murderous raider even in his point of view, we start the game with him being a odd jobs man doing criminal smuggling work, his own brother admonishes his past actions during the earlier days of the apocalypse, and even he views his actions as abhorrent albeit necessary for survival. Abby was a wilfully ignorant idiot that was willing to kill people who killed in self defense, especially considering the fact that the fireflies already tried like 8 different times with 8 different immune people and just killed them all without getting a cure, which is what was gonna happen with Ellie. At least joel kills out of necessity, in our playthrough and in the way they talk about the past, everything he did was for survival, abby had nothing to gain, there was no positive in what she did, just negative, what I'm trying to say is the second game sucked

    • @seaberry11
      @seaberry11 20 днів тому

      @@joshrosario1269 no, Abby was a child. She didn’t know the inner workings of the Fireflies, she just knew Joel killed her dad. Y’all only think the game sucks because she killed Joel. Which storytelling wise was the only logical conclusion after the end of part one. The story is great, the only problem was the way they setup the telling of the story. They should’ve did a back and forth between Ellie and Abby’s levels to tell the story. It would’ve given it a better cat and mouse feel. Saying Abby was “willfully ignorant” is weird. A child whose father was murdered and is looking for revenge…she doesn’t know, or frankly should care why Joel killed her father. It’s funny how you could make excuses for the way Joel lived because “survival” but call Abby ignorant. Joel had a place he could safely stay, he didn’t have to murder people, he could’ve went with his brother…who left him because he became so evil. Joel didn’t do those things for survival, he did them out of spite because his daughter died. That’s willful ignorance. That is also the point of the game, revenge is a never ending cycle.

  • @andrewbyrne2173
    @andrewbyrne2173 20 днів тому +5

    I’ll just say just because one person is evil, that doesn’t make the entire faction evil. Particularly in the case of the Dalish. The elves were unaware one of their own was behind the werewolf creation.

  • @antonfowler6582
    @antonfowler6582 21 день тому +6

    In quincy ONE minute man joined the gunners and betrayed the minute men . This does not make them all evil just some of them .

  • @derrickhaggard
    @derrickhaggard 24 дні тому +24

    I knew The Fireflies especially their leader Marlene were villainous long before TLOU's final act in the hospital especially due to hearing how they massacred whole groups of innocent people simply because they refused to bow down to Marlene as their dictator queen, and then there's the revelation of "spoiler alert" of Marlene more then likely being the one who murdered Ellie's mom when Ellie was a baby. And then there's the whole Ellie being the key to a vaccine/possible cure right first as Joel when you're going back through the hospital on that violent rescue mission you find notes revealing that there were other immune individuals put through the same surgery and it didn't work which meant they died for nothing, meaning there was a 99% chance that Ellie was going to also die for nothing.
    And even if it worked given the other villainous crap the Fireflies especially Marlene pulled there was a high chance that Marlene was going to hold the cure to saving humanity hostage and only give it to the people who bow down to her and become her slaves.

    • @deadworld953
      @deadworld953 23 дні тому +8

      I keep having to point this out to people. I swear, if you put on scrubs and a surgical mask people will believe literally anything you say.

    • @davidtitleman8743
      @davidtitleman8743 22 дні тому +1

      Actually, in the show, Marlene did kill Ellie's mom, but it was a mercy kill. She was infected while giving birth to Ellie and would have turned. That's why Ellie is immune; she was literally born with the cordyceps, becoming a symbiosis rather than a parasitic relationship. Neil Druckmann worked on the show and said Ellie's backstory is canon to the games.
      On remakes, they took out the recordings that said the operation would have failed; I've no idea why they included that, guess it was a big mistake. The directors of both the game and the show said that if they did the procedure, they'd have the vaccine. Kinda railroading but . And In real life, doctors said they would never, ever do the procedure. Which I agree with.
      Where did they say they executed civilians, I must have missed that part? Even then, I agree with your last paragraph - the cure wouldn't help anyone. If the Fireflies wanted to help they should have learned from Jackson.

    • @ericlamb4501
      @ericlamb4501 21 день тому

      Honestly they didn't even need to cut Ellie's brain out either, they could have just done a spinal tap

    • @dreadcthulhu5
      @dreadcthulhu5 21 день тому

      @@deadworld953 *2020 has entered the chat*

  • @nemesis2345
    @nemesis2345 22 дні тому +9

    So in Far Cry 4 the happy ending comes from just waiting for Pagan

    • @BOTHthosearetaken
      @BOTHthosearetaken 20 днів тому

      Well yeah. That's the one where you get to eat crab rangoon

    • @valkyrieheart88
      @valkyrieheart88 11 днів тому

      FC5 is the same way. The least messed up ending is not arresting Seed at the beginning

  • @DMBLaan
    @DMBLaan 24 дні тому +18

    Another point against the Fireflys, killing Ellie for a "cure" is pointless because that not how you get a "cure" for a fungal infection. Fungus doesn't work the same way as a virus, their 2 completely different kinds of infection and can't be cured in the same way as the other. So yeah, if they killed Ellie, not only would they have killed the only person immune to the fungus, they also wouldn't have a cure for it either.

    • @NoHateLikeChristianLove
      @NoHateLikeChristianLove 24 дні тому +1

      But you can kill fungi, and find ways to stop them from taking hold, or releasing spores. From what I’ve heard it’s easier to cure a fungus because unlike a virus they don’t evolve constantly.
      That’s why C19 was so hard to get a hold on. Every infected person is a chance to evolve. Which is why people not taking full courses of antibiotics makes viruses more resistant to treatments. There’s no way to get a “one size fits all” type of treatment/cure.

    • @DMBLaan
      @DMBLaan 24 дні тому +6

      @@NoHateLikeChristianLove But this isn't what the Fireflys were doing. If they wanted to find a cure, they'd have done better keeping Ellie alive to run more, less invasive test.

    • @NoHateLikeChristianLove
      @NoHateLikeChristianLove 23 дні тому

      @@DMBLaan True. But you can find a “cure” in that you can find a version of medicine we do have that kills off the fungi in your body and prevents it from surviving in your body.

    • @ericlamb4501
      @ericlamb4501 21 день тому

      Honestly they probably wouldn't even need Ellie period, fungus is either the easiest thing or the worst for our bodies to fight, since, from birth, our immune system is made to fight it off and it really only becomes a problem if you have immune system disorders of any type. So, given the premise of The Last of Us, they'd just need to take our modern anti-fungal drugs, as well as the knowledge we have of what can kill fungal infections and mushrooms, and combine it and apply it. Especially given that they apparently have one of the last doctors capable of brain surgery, that they wouldn't think of that is just stupid. Not to mention they'd find it easier if they worked together with others.

    • @brynyardley5353
      @brynyardley5353 15 днів тому

      The fire flies are not evil tbh and their not trying to find a cure but a vaccine ,

  • @JeighEssdott
    @JeighEssdott 24 дні тому +8

    The companions weren’t that bad, now the Dark Brotherhood, for instance…but the DB never posed as good, Astrid literally kidnaps you and forces the player to Deactivate one of three people she’s captured before the start of the DB quest, so never mind lmao

  • @wesleycolvin7158
    @wesleycolvin7158 24 дні тому +56

    To be honest, if you're dealing with a group called 'The Iron Hand' or 'Brotherhood of the Apocalypse', their name alone kind of implies that they may not have your best interests at heart. The Minutemen aren't evil because everything happened in the past as a major aspect of the backstory, not the group at present in the story.

    • @zachlewis2751
      @zachlewis2751 23 дні тому

      There are iron hands in the wh 40,000 ip! Guess if they baddies?

    • @bdk336
      @bdk336 22 дні тому

      @@zachlewis2751 Everyone is baddies in WH40k

    • @morgantaylor84
      @morgantaylor84 21 день тому

      @@zachlewis2751 If they're Imperium, yes probably. The only truly objectively good factions in the Imperium are the Ultramarines, the Imperial Guard (at least the lower ranks) and the Daemon Hunters among the Inquisition. There are other "good" factions as well outside the Imperium, the Eldar (that aren't the Dark Eldar) are good, but a-holes and the Tau are generally good if a bit extreme in their methods in the leadership.
      Oh and before you bring them up, no the Nids and Orkz aren't "good" but they aren't "evil" either.

    • @CyGogetenks
      @CyGogetenks 21 день тому +2

      I agree about the Minutemen, yes their faction prior to the Lone Survivor was a corrupt mess that had one surviving member left, though he was forward with what occurred in Quincy. Not to the detail perhaps as notes and reports did, though he was forthcoming with the betrayal from within.

    • @TheReqyem
      @TheReqyem 21 день тому +4

      The followers of the apocalypse are the "good" faction in fallout new vegas.

  • @evolancer211
    @evolancer211 23 дні тому +5

    You know the fireflies are bad cause they want to go directly into Elle's brain, instead of trying non life threatening things first

  • @tubensalat1453
    @tubensalat1453 24 дні тому +15

    I never slaughtered any civilians after I became a werewolf. Isn't the standard route out of the city and then you handle some silver hands? (Also I'd hate to accidentally remove traders from this traveling salesman sim.)

    • @animewitch1416
      @animewitch1416 24 дні тому +3

      You don’t even have to leave the city on your own. If you stay near the guild hall, no one will attack you and you automatically get teleported to the silver hand base after a few minutes.

    • @Viglin123
      @Viglin123 24 дні тому +1

      Aren’t Silver Hands good guys?
      Monster hunters ?

    • @TinKnight
      @TinKnight 23 дні тому +6

      ​@Viglin123 Only if you call the Companions evil. It's mostly about perspective. But the Silver Hand also capture & torture Companions & other lycathropes, & seemingly do so just for giggles/joy. Most people would consider gleefully torturing & flaying someone to be bad, no matter the crime.

    • @KevinSeth666
      @KevinSeth666 21 день тому +1

      You can also re-enter the Underforge and leave through the back exit

    • @KevinSeth666
      @KevinSeth666 21 день тому

      @@Viglin123 They used to be solely werewolf hunters but they are just another group of bandits by the time you meet them in the game. I mean they attack you even if you aren't a werewolf

  • @slamwisebamgee
    @slamwisebamgee 24 дні тому +25

    Honestly, the Stormcloaks are worse than the Companions. Companions are basically your run-of-the-mill mercenary band (plus lycanthropy), whereas the Stormcloaks are known for anti-elf sentiment and their own stronghold regularly discriminates against the elves within the city. I'd take the Companions (who only give their lycanthropy to people who consent to it) over a xenophobic group like the Stormcloaks (even if I think their side of the Civil War questline is more interesting) any day.

    • @briwanderz
      @briwanderz 20 днів тому

      I'd say all of Skyrim is racists... How many kaajit get to live in solitude? Are there any living in the blue palace? If you play a kaajit they all make rather racist comments... As do most all Nords against any race "Skyrim belongs to the Nords" (including your followers) but about the companions you are right, other then hiding the lycanthropy, they are very straightforward about what they do and might be the only ones who don't care what race you are.

  • @renamoda5450
    @renamoda5450 24 дні тому +8

    There is a settlement that needs your help.

    • @frostdemen1
      @frostdemen1 24 дні тому +4

      Disregard that because another settlement needs your help.

    • @tubensalat1453
      @tubensalat1453 24 дні тому +2

      I marked both on your map.

  • @joshrosario1269
    @joshrosario1269 21 день тому +3

    11:30 Caesar didn't learn about the roman empire from follower teachings, he found books in the grand canyon and then decided romans were cool. Saying that ceasar learned how to rule under followers of the apocalypse teachings feels intentionally misleading ngl

  • @friskdacatarchival
    @friskdacatarchival 18 днів тому +2

    Lets be real here, if the Minutemen WERE evil, theyd be horribly inefficient at really doing much harm.
    Theyre literally just a few people with guns and a lot of willpower.

  • @dragonstryk7280
    @dragonstryk7280 23 дні тому +4

    Okay, several of these are a stretch, biggest one being the Alliance and The various Fallout factions. For the Alliance, they've literally been at war for generations against invading races, and yeah, splinter factions happen, it doesn't make the Alliance itself evil, it just shows that they're, y'know, human. For Fallout, everyone not a Vault Dweller from a control vault has serious issues because Fallout. I mean, it makes sense, several CENTURIES of horrible crap is going to have some folks not particularly becoming the paragons of virtue. And again, a theme that keeps coming up is 'Oh look, a splinter group within X faction did Y, and that makes the faction evil'.

  • @KronosCuteTiger
    @KronosCuteTiger 22 дні тому +4

    The Dailish had nothing to do with it, the crime lays solely on the leader. He did it as revenge for the forced naughtys of his daughter.

  • @ComaDave
    @ComaDave 24 дні тому +5

    Life as a child labourer in Kyrat would be especially brutal, considering there's only one kid in the entire country. 🤔

  • @spiritwolf3103
    @spiritwolf3103 24 дні тому +7

    Day 11 of asking for 'Games where the bad ending is the canon ending.' Please include Shadow Hearts series.

  • @shadowki5687
    @shadowki5687 17 днів тому +2

    I refuse to accept any slander against the Minutemen and my boy Preston Garvey

  • @dastemplar9681
    @dastemplar9681 20 днів тому +2

    You can argue that the Minutemen is just history repeating itself. Countless times we have seen nations and armies rise with good intentions, but they always seem to fall for the same reasons.
    The Minutemen became too powerful to keep the corruption in check and lead to its own demise. It stopped being an army of the people, by the people, for the people. Now that’s not to say there’s no good people in the Minutemen nor that the idea of the faction’s existence isn’t a good cause. It’s just a vulnerable system that could be easily tainted by human ambition and greed. I mean, after all…
    War, war never changes…

  • @NicoBlack69
    @NicoBlack69 18 днів тому +3

    Yeah, this is about what I expected from a Watchculture vid.

  • @kcollier2192
    @kcollier2192 24 дні тому +15

    Wait - someone actually finished any quest line in Skyrim? Inconceivable!

    • @JeighEssdott
      @JeighEssdott 24 дні тому +4

      Yo my favorite quest was the Nightingales quest…the armor you get by the end of the quest is 💰

    • @piotrdworowy183
      @piotrdworowy183 23 дні тому +2

      I've finished them all, almost: never joined the Vampires ,so this quest line I kinda did not.

    • @piotrdworowy183
      @piotrdworowy183 23 дні тому +3

      ​@@JeighEssdottI thing Nightingale armor looks the best in the whole game.

    • @JeighEssdott
      @JeighEssdott 23 дні тому +2

      @@piotrdworowy183 that with a Blades sword or the Ebony blade, makes a badass combination

    • @piotrdworowy183
      @piotrdworowy183 23 дні тому +1

      @@JeighEssdott Always with Nightingale "sword" and that gold one - I forgot the name - probably the reward from Meridia 🤔

  • @ARC_Nemisis
    @ARC_Nemisis 20 днів тому +3

    The Followers, Minutemen, and Dalish are really being judged based on one member than as a whole here. Caesar read some books and went nuts thinking he was the best thing in the wasteland since The Chosen One. Pretty sure it was only one Minuteman member who betrayed the rest of his squad and the town to the Gunners (feel free to corect me if im wrong). And the Dalish leader was the only one of the Dalish who knew what he did, and he kinda had some deep motivations for why he cursed those people. In general most of these factions are still good, though I'd say the Dalish are more neutral since they're kinsa xenophobic and Isolationist.

  • @ReicantheJester
    @ReicantheJester 24 дні тому +16

    Also, the fireflies in TLoU, their "doctors" had mostly veterinarian experience and not actual human doctors and Ellie was not the first immune person they found, but since they had no clue what they were doing and were looking blindly for some sort of cure, all the other immune people they came across died on the operating tables and they were no closer to a cure for it, meaning Ellie would have died for absolutely nothing.
    if you do a video of games where some factions or races are experiencing peak irony for their own actions you could look at the Elves in the Witcher series, how they were driven out of their homelands, abused, killed or treated like lower worth beings by the humans, you may look to what the Aen Seidhe did to a species of reptilian people that were there even before the elves were, the Vran. If you side with Iorveth in Witcher 2, you will hear him point out some of these things when you reach Loc Muinne.

    • @sond.lollipop8919
      @sond.lollipop8919 24 дні тому +7

      THIS! I’ve said this for years and starkly defended Joel for his choice. There was NO guarantee for even a chance they could get a cure from Ellie’s brain like they hoped they could.

    • @JMoore-uc1zp
      @JMoore-uc1zp 24 дні тому +3

      ​@@sond.lollipop8919same bro no one listens to audio tapes or reads records and it shows ellie would have died for absolutely nothing and joel seen that and wasnt letting that happen

    • @NoHateLikeChristianLove
      @NoHateLikeChristianLove 24 дні тому +1

      @@JMoore-uc1zpAt the same time you can’t blame Abby for wanting revenge for killing all the doctors there.

    • @Shoelessjoe78
      @Shoelessjoe78 24 дні тому

      ​@@sond.lollipop8919But Joel is also a psychopath and murderer or did you forget that part of the story.
      There are no "good guys"...

    • @kingjamos2422
      @kingjamos2422 24 дні тому

      @@sond.lollipop8919 I saw it as more of a case of Joel being in the wrong... and so were the Fireflies. There are no heroes, just men driven to extremes in a destroyed world. Which was kind of the point. Joel wasn't a hero to begin with, he was just a man seeing the one thing left in this world that makes life worth living in danger. He wasn't about to lose a daughter again. Love can make monsters of us all.

  • @giantnerd14
    @giantnerd14 24 дні тому +3

    I don't think Followers of the Apocalypse failures don't make them evil, just naive and unorganized.

  • @CharlesGriswold
    @CharlesGriswold 13 днів тому +1

    In vanilla Skyrim the only joinable factions that are even arguably good guys are the College of Winterhold and the Empire. With the Dawnguard expansion, the Dawnguard can also be regarded as being good guys.
    I guess there is also the Bard's College, but they hardly count as a real faction. I wish someone would expand them into the same kind of fully-realized faction as the rest of the joinable factions.

  • @davidfletcher6703
    @davidfletcher6703 22 дні тому +2

    It was only a portion of the Minutemen who caused the fall of Quincey

  • @venkelos6996
    @venkelos6996 6 днів тому +1

    I'm inclined to say that the modern day Companions also descend from what might be considered a not too lofty, or honorable, history. From Yssgramor, at the start, the goals of the Atmorans, and his own kin, specifically, wasn't exactly laudable, coming to wipe out an entire breed of Elves, and possibly already being under the sway of Alduin, and the Dragons. Leaving Atmora was necessary, and certainly you can't always find conveniently empty, and bountiful, land, but the Companions were, if not the bad guys, then at least not the good ones, right from the start.

  • @jh9794
    @jh9794 24 дні тому +2

    The fireflies creating the cure was not only unlikely but not even certain amungst themselves. Never mind they were asshole to everyone, not them.

  • @ShadowEX7
    @ShadowEX7 21 день тому +2

    I would’ve added the Stormcloaks from Skyrim. While the Empire isn’t perfectly good, they’re trying to hold everyone together in the face of an enemy whose only goal is to destroy all humanity. Meanwhile, the Stormcloaks are mostly just agitators, willing to go to war with their former allies while they largely ignore their real enemies who’ve orchestrated this war!

  • @Preston_Garvy
    @Preston_Garvy 11 днів тому +2

    I was not made aware, and I’m not affiliated with those corrupt individuals that are a part of this organization task to help the settlements of the commonwealth and would like to say I am tasked with making a better place therefore, I will be marking the settlements that need help on both of our maps

  • @Saintphoenix86
    @Saintphoenix86 24 дні тому +2

    in wasteland you are never led to believe that the patriarch is good though, ever, its clear from the start who he is and he will tell you himself, but chaos requires a strong pragmatic hand to reign in

  • @Juggtacula
    @Juggtacula 24 дні тому +4

    It wasn't that the Dalish were evil. It was Zathrian, their leader who was evil and they were simply following his lead while not knowing how vile he truly was.

    • @Bowen_Landry
      @Bowen_Landry 23 дні тому +2

      and even he wasn't evil. he did it to their predecessors, because they tortured and raped his daughter, also tortured and killed his son. so is it's wrong for the curse to remain on their ancestors. but not evil.

    • @Juggtacula
      @Juggtacula 22 дні тому +2

      @Bowen_Landry His initial revenge was justified, but what made him evil is he forced the Lady of the Forest into a wolf to create Witherfang against her will, which created the curse. And he knew the entire time that the curse would continue forever until he broke it. Also he made himself immortal in the process and wanted to keep the whole thing secret.

    • @derrickhaggard
      @derrickhaggard 22 дні тому

      @@Bowen_Landry You meant descendants. And that reason is why I took the middle option aka asking Zathrian to end the curse granted it ended in a fight because while yes having the curse remain on their descendants is wrong what they did to his daughter and son was evil. Like he stated he was just a good man twisted by centuries of vengeance, and hatred hence why he was surprised why me, the party which consisted of Alister, Adrianna, and the party's main healer whose name I forgot are willing to not kill him right then and there.

  • @chadnorris8257
    @chadnorris8257 5 днів тому

    The old Minutemen suffered from being a loose alliance of settlements with a bunch of different motives, and desires. Something easily taken apart, piece by piece. They rely on charismatic leaders to hold them together, which brings their longevity into question when Nate eventually leaves, or dies.

  • @BOTHthosearetaken
    @BOTHthosearetaken 20 днів тому +1

    I never beat dishonored because a few minutes in my internal evil radar went off and i realized they were baddies
    The only winning move was not to play
    So i didn't

  • @devinco1
    @devinco1 24 дні тому +5

    I live a little over an hour north of Colorado Springs- can confirm the bandits, Patriarch, secrets, etc.

  • @schonnj
    @schonnj 17 днів тому +1

    The Fallout universe has no lack of "good guys that were actually evil"; the Enclave, the Institute, arguably purist Brotherhood of Steel, and Vault-Tec itself. While the Minutemen fell into disorder and resorted to banditry after their General died, they never pretended to be good after the fall.

    • @dorerd
      @dorerd 6 днів тому +1

      I agree with this. The Minutemen who turned to banditry, however, were the ones residing on the Libertalia and turned to raiding only after weeks of not getting paid for the honest work they were doing for Bunker Hill and the traveling merchants and not being able to feed themselves. The Quincy massacre was caused by the betrayal of a single minuteman named Clint. The rest of the Minutemen helping Quincy died in defense of the residents and their sacrifice allowed many to escape. You can find many sacrificed Minutemen between Quincy and Sanctuary who gave their lives to protect the remaining citizens who fled.
      Definitely a poorly researched video.

  • @cameronhermann9400
    @cameronhermann9400 19 днів тому

    I never considered the Fireflies as “good guys.” In the DLC Ellie and Riley debate the morality of both sides killing each other and blowing up food and resource depots.

  • @Lilith87
    @Lilith87 18 днів тому +1

    The Minutemen isn’t evil. The people that were in the Minutemen were evil.

  • @obnoxiouszubat6014
    @obnoxiouszubat6014 18 днів тому +1

    Zathrian was the one in the wrong, not the entire clan and definitely not all of the Dalish

  • @stitchfan08
    @stitchfan08 23 дні тому +1

    I would say the survivors in dying light 2 since the ones u meet at the start tries to kill Aiden so many times and the pk treat you with respect and keep there word

  • @i_duditz2076
    @i_duditz2076 20 днів тому

    Hate the newer cut off endings. Love the videos💕💕

  • @wolfsokaya
    @wolfsokaya 21 день тому

    If one checks the lore of the Alliance, one can find many horrible deeds.

  • @SiegeTF
    @SiegeTF 6 днів тому

    I was always anti-firefly, funny thing is; my best friend, an Emergency room doctor, disagrees with me wholesale. The bit in TLAU2 Where it's conformed that they needed to kill Ellie should have been replaced with them only needing to perform a biopsy, but *wanting* to kill her so nobody else could get the cure!

  • @18videowatcher41
    @18videowatcher41 6 днів тому

    You have a good point about the Minutemen, but I choose to believe that they can be better. I will be the one to redeem them.
    Also, the Companions being less than honourable never occurred to me. I'm seeing it now, though.

  • @Jacob_White
    @Jacob_White 20 днів тому +1

    Funny how to get to best Farcry 4 ending is to literally not play the game

  • @inkscratch
    @inkscratch 24 дні тому

    I'm always so jarred by the abrupt ending to the videos 😂

  • @ryanrowe1975
    @ryanrowe1975 19 днів тому +1

    Good list

  • @fluffybunpup7603
    @fluffybunpup7603 24 дні тому

    I definitely needed this video

  • @SagePalom
    @SagePalom 23 дні тому +1

    I disagree with the dalish on this list. First of all it's only that group of dalish (whichvis the only group you encounter if your Warden isn't a dalish). But they all didn't know the werewolfs origins except for Zatzrian himself. So it's not an evil faction but only some good persons lead by an evil guy.

  • @felixfontanez2825
    @felixfontanez2825 24 дні тому +2

    Can we NOT stop the videos without a proper sign off…. What’s up with that?

  • @Lubble-
    @Lubble- 24 дні тому

    The good thing about Farcry 4 is it's canon that Ajay took over as the leader of Kyrat, meaning he killed the other leader much like many players do when you meet them in the world

  • @StArShIpEnTeRpRiSe
    @StArShIpEnTeRpRiSe 11 днів тому

    Minutemen are worse than Nuka World Raiders.
    Think about it.
    Nuka World Raiders only take settlements which YOU the player choose to them.
    But at the start of the game, you get Sanctuary as your own private settlement. Then Preston come, march in, and take the settlement for the Minutemen even without asking if you like it or not.
    Then he just give random orders to you to take settlements by force.
    Worst of all, if you destroy the Institute with the Minutemen, even if you turn on the alarm for evacuation, you basicly do what the Gunners did in Quincy.

  • @Kelly-ws2zn
    @Kelly-ws2zn 19 днів тому

    Truth is evil lurks in the shadows and don't reveal themselves until they are in a position that they take advantage of, it's the main reason I suffer from trust issues

  • @AgentZer085
    @AgentZer085 19 днів тому +3

    To say the Followers of the Apocalypse are evil because of Caesar is possibly the most idiotic New Vegas take I’ve ever fucking heard. Please do not let whoever wrote this list make another video for you.

  • @mathewdewsbury9456
    @mathewdewsbury9456 23 дні тому

    What about Atlas Corporation from Call of Duty Advanced Warfare? Or Mantel from Haze?

  • @MrSDegnan
    @MrSDegnan 12 днів тому

    The Iron Hand Gnomes aren't necessarily evil, it's Wulbren that's the evil one.

  • @chibiprussia5574
    @chibiprussia5574 24 дні тому

    Peacekeepers in Dying Light 2 -
    Few in the PKs will not screw you over

  • @cvvtrevor2577
    @cvvtrevor2577 18 днів тому +1

    ill never betray preston

  • @briwanderz
    @briwanderz 20 днів тому +2

    The minutemen are far from evil... There was a few bad people in the group out of what hundred or more years of doing good? If you consider them starting with the actual minutemen around 1776, that'd be 500 years of defending people, or even just when they were active, it's still over 100 years, and you want to say the whole group is evil because a few bad people??

  • @TheMarcHicks
    @TheMarcHicks 24 дні тому

    Thankfully, if you get Barcus to lead the Ironhand Gnomes going forward, there is a good chance they'll actually end up being good guys.

  • @RicoRaynn
    @RicoRaynn 21 день тому +1

    I disagree about the Minutemen, at least when it comes to the timeframe the player interacts with them.
    My biggest one was from Dragon Age 2. You spend the whole narrative learning that the mages are basically treated like expendable slaves by the city and the Templars.
    Yet, if you support the mages in the end, their damn leader gets desperate enough to use blood magic and turn himself into a raging demon which is exactly what the Templars were constantly warning everyone could happen. Yeah, you could argue the whole ‘self filling prophecy’ line, but still.
    That jack ass move by the NPC really stabs the player in the back and makes you look like an idiot.

  • @xXDuckshotXx
    @xXDuckshotXx 21 день тому

    The Sons of Korhal from StarCraft. Arcturus Mengsk starts out as a benevolent rebel fighting against the corrupt Confederacy, but ends up turning the Zerg loose on an entire planet just to seize power

  • @justinisp9361
    @justinisp9361 23 дні тому +1

    Going back to Dragon Age: Origins, if you did a reverse of this with evil factions that are secretly not all bad, Bhelen's faction with the dwarves is actually the better faction. Yeah, he's an evil despot tyrant, but he actually forces the dwarves of Orzammar to be more progressive, destroying the caste system in the process as he allows the Casteless into the military (And turns various undesirables into mindless golems when he's not assassinating them) and pretty much allying with his neighbors above ground.
    Harrowmant, meanwhile, dies on the throne some time after the game, failing to do anything because he's too old and weak to force the other nobles to do anything.

  • @rileyoaks8346
    @rileyoaks8346 9 днів тому

    When you actually live in Colorado Springs

  • @emo565
    @emo565 24 дні тому +1

    There’s a few entries on this list I disagree the daleish and the companions. There leader was the only one who even knew of the curses origins. No one else in the camp knew. As for the companions there a mercenary group. If your joining a mercenary group you should know what to expect, ie there killers and hired muscle.

  • @user-lm3nr1yc2t
    @user-lm3nr1yc2t 24 дні тому

    Most video games leave clues to let you know a person or group is evil

  • @MaxWeb2599
    @MaxWeb2599 24 дні тому

    That's why it's the best option to leave pagan min alive.
    At least for so long till he gives you the land.

  • @Demsky83
    @Demsky83 17 днів тому

    Far Cry 4 also affectionately known as my last Far Cry.

  • @mrflawless1165
    @mrflawless1165 24 дні тому +1

    FOR THE HORDE!!!

  • @ianbredeweg9979
    @ianbredeweg9979 24 дні тому +1

    Followers of the apocalypse are not evil at all🙄 they just are way to trusting and incompetent. And the Alliance isn’t necessarily the goodest guys in WoW, but for the most part they are and their leaders that do have murderous intent to the horde have VERY good reason (sacking of Stormwind in the first war as well as the entirety of the second war, bombing of Theramore, burning of Teldrassil, all cataclysmic events brought on by, that’s right, the horde.)

  • @splitsecondmagician
    @splitsecondmagician 16 днів тому

    CVTs have durability issues in my opinion. Especially in mountainous or hilly areas.

  • @aJohnnyBenton
    @aJohnnyBenton 23 дні тому

    No Atlas from Bioshock?!

  • @shinijoker42
    @shinijoker42 11 днів тому +2

    Preston and the Minutemen aren't evil. Lol. You're either crazy or just doing this for views or have never played Fallout 4 before. I really hope you do one day and enjoy the game.
    My other theory is you're a Gen 1 Synth.

  • @khrisbreezy3628
    @khrisbreezy3628 24 дні тому

    Reminds me of the church in Grandia 2 (spoilers btw) where the literal pope becomes a vessel for the villain near the end lol

    • @derrickhaggard
      @derrickhaggard 24 дні тому

      The Alliance definitely has those extremists elements in it.

  • @powerpete4266
    @powerpete4266 24 дні тому +1

    New Yevon in Final Fantasy X-2 is another one, joining them just ruins the entire game for you, much better with the Youth Group tbh

  • @theSelfishMan
    @theSelfishMan 24 дні тому

    The United races of thestra in the vanguard MMO. Practically every quest for them was either covering up for a failed experiment or killing political opponents or some crazy thing like that

  • @popcorneilous
    @popcorneilous 23 дні тому

    I ended up marrying aya in skyrim. Then i played the expansion and my vampire companion killed her and her body wouldnt disappear like other bodies so everytime i came home our adopted children would scream everytime about the dead body.

  • @Alphakennyone_899
    @Alphakennyone_899 24 дні тому +6

    Damn I'm so early

  • @Sam-Fisher
    @Sam-Fisher 24 дні тому

    Nice

  • @williams100292
    @williams100292 19 днів тому

    To call the Alliance "secretly evil" is at best a gross overstatement and at worst blatant lies. The Alliance has only ever sought peaceful relations with the other factions of Azeroth, including the Horde. Time and again, it is the Alliance who is attacked or provoked, and any darker actions taken are outliers compared to the overtly aggressive and evil actions of the Horde.

  • @howlphantomwolf
    @howlphantomwolf 17 днів тому

    Most of these seem less "evil" and more "poorly executed".

  • @trentthehehim3936
    @trentthehehim3936 17 днів тому +1

    Yup just as I thought. “ Look your good guys are AKTUALLY EVIL because of their sketchy past.” Bullshit. 😂😂

  • @alexnicklay8626
    @alexnicklay8626 20 днів тому +26

    You should actually review your work before you post it, this video is incredibly deceiving and just plain wrong on some of yiur factions listed, you definitely need to do better research

    • @taitherapper4949
      @taitherapper4949 5 днів тому

      Damn 📠

    • @JasonAndrews1995
      @JasonAndrews1995 4 дні тому

      Care to elaborate?

    • @alexnicklay8626
      @alexnicklay8626 4 дні тому +1

      @JasonAndrews1995 most the factions on their list aren't even remotely evil and the part about the minutemen isn't even factually correct.

  • @LoganH0076
    @LoganH0076 24 дні тому +1

    I’ve mentioned this before, but I’d love to see chapters in these videos that just show the game’s name. That way if there’s a video with high spoiler potential, I can still watch the video and just skip the games I don’t want spoiled. Great video though ☺️

  • @southernpanda33
    @southernpanda33 23 дні тому

    The dalish weren’t “evil” they were mad. 😂😂😂😂

  • @schipperkeandcats3469
    @schipperkeandcats3469 20 днів тому

    But zatrian clan dident even know he was responsible for werewolves dalish elvers are nomad clans and every clan is difrent in how they deal with outsiders

  • @TheGrrrudy
    @TheGrrrudy 23 дні тому

    typical horde thing to say :)

  • @loka7783
    @loka7783 20 днів тому

    I, for one, always knew the Alliance in World of Warcraft was evil. If you start a character as human (y'know the biggest race among the Alliance) One of your first missions is: racial bullying. Specifically you are tasked with stealing candles from the non-hostile kobolds. The kobolds see these candles as minor religious artifacts. Plus, if you add in a short story from the Tales from the world of Azaroth, kobolds have racial fear of the dark.

  • @Malbeefance
    @Malbeefance 7 годин тому

    The followers aren't evil. The followers are naive if not stupid. The followers foolishly believe all humans will just suddenly and miraculously will turn in to good little citizens as soon as they have the follower's boon.

  • @deontrayperkins8843
    @deontrayperkins8843 21 день тому

    Enough with the Preston hate i been posted the fix for him for 5 years now all have to do is move him to the castle assign him to a artillery piece at the castle fast travel anywhere come back to the castle and he is fix like a normal companion

  • @ramors4715
    @ramors4715 23 дні тому

    Always knew Alliance from WoW was evil. No matter how one looks at it.