You guys were the first people I watched and subscribed to on UA-cam. Hailey was so young and you guys could barely understand a word she said. When I subbed you guys were at thousands of subscribers and it's so amazing to see you guys at 4,000,000+ subscribers. When I first subbed to you guys the video "who falls asleep at their first movie" or something like that was a fairly new video. I remember that the first video I watched was of Annie, Hayley, and Caleb jumping around on the old trampoline. Annie was in a blue flannel and she sadly had a bloody nose. At first I was a bit skeptic if I liked your content or not but, then I continued watching your videos 24/7 and became addicted. I LOVE YOU GUYS AND I AM NOW MOTIVATED TO START MY OWN SUCCESSFUL UA-cam CHANNEL AND JUST LIVE LIFE LIKE THERE IS NO TOMORROW, I'M SO GLAD TO SEE YOU GUYS STRIVE!!
I cried out of happiness watching this!! I have been subscribed since 100,000 or so and I feel like part of the family! This makes me so happy and proud! You guys deserve it!
Caleb is probably looking down on his family crying his eyes out for he is so proud of them. I wish he was here with us on this journey to 4 mil physically, but I realize he will always be in all our hearts and on our minds every step of the way. stay strong bratayley
CONGRATS BRATAYLEY!!!!!! I TOOK LIKE 14 SCREENSHOTS!!!!!!!!! I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS!!!!!!! LUV YOU BRATAYLEY!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️💛💛💛💚💚💚💙💙💙💜💜💜❣️❣️❣️💕💕💕💞💞💞💓💓💓💗💗💗💖💖💖💘💘💘💝💝💝
To put it into perspective for Annie and Hayley, 4.5 million is the population of Ireland 🇮🇪 instead of fitting us in a room, I think you should come to Ireland just to make it real 😉
Congrats! But where are you gonna keep a horse? In your living room? Don't you think that might seem a bit weird? "We are back for another vlog! Oh, theirs the horse eating the sofa!" 😂
Anna Bandini at Amanda (Annie's gym friend whom parents own a horse ranch/stable) and they (Amanda and her parents) have horses and have been educating the family on horse care and horse things
I am so insanely proud of you and your entire family and friends!! You have achieved so much and it's actually crazy to think that maybe in 7 months or so you could be hitting 5 million😽😽 It feels like it was only yesterday I was watching your vlog "who falls asleep at their first movie?". These last 6 years have been such an incredible and emotional journey but we have all been so fortunate to watch all of you grow up right in front of our eyes!! Annie and Hayley are such talented and beautiful daughters who are such a credit to you both (Miss Katie and Mr Billy) Despite the circumstances which I can relate very much so you have all continued to have strength and spread your happiness in every direction you go💜 You have grown as a UA-cam channel and are recognised by everyone hugely. Yes you may have some spiteful people who may try bring you down maybe for the way that you parent your own children or maybe the way that your own children act on camera. But whatever they have to say you always continue to rise above it and that really does deserve some recognition for!! At the end of the day you can live your lives however you want to and you should never change just because someone told you too🙏🏻 Continue being who you all are and I am looking forward to your video in 16 and a half hours time. (I usually stay up until midnight to watch your videos as I live in the UK) But anyway I just want to thankyou for sharing the lives with us everyday as to me it always brings a little more happiness into my own life!! Congratulations once again for hitting the huge 4 million🎉 Lots of love and I will always continue being one of your 4 millions fans💜💜💜💜💜 @officiallybratayley @iamabakedpotato @officiallydadtayley @presshandstands @superhayley7
I am sad BUT SO HAPPY at the same time. I'm sad because I had a a bunny like Hayley does now and her name was Daisy. But the funny thing is when we went to the vet it was actual a boy but I stilled called him/her daisy. Sadly she did so I'm happy because its nice seeing Hayley be so happy to get a bunny. Care for your bunny as much as I did Hayley and love him/her so much!
I Can't believe that you guys just reached 4M It seems like it was just yesterday that Annie was Singing the 50 states Hayley learning gymnastics And Caleb singing baked potatoe You guys made it this far. You were through a tough time but still but on a brave face for us and kept on vloging And we helped you through that time too. You made me learn to celebrate life Never give up and Annie And Hayley Make me improve on gymnastics by watching these vlogs. I give credit to you Katie and Billy for filming and stay up late editing the videos. Just wanting to say thank you for making videos everyday for us Love you💜💜💜🐇🐴🆑⚾7
Everyone who is saying about Annie being mean to Haley and Annie getting all the attention Haley doesn't want to be in front of the camera all the time it is her decision and Haley did get to squish the tooth and strawberry and thought it was fun and they both deserve a horse and bunny for entertaining us for so long so peace out haters!
Lucy Hazlett we aren't talking about the camera but just overall the things the mum does not billy like my mum says" if u don't my Layla one(my sister) u r asking for trouble " because Haley is probably thinking like oh Annie got this but she doesn't show it
everyone is saying how they like hayley better than annie, because annie is "mean" to hayley. but, they're sisters. i guarantee if you have a sibling you aren't nice to them 24/7!! so stop hating on annie!! ❤️❤️
That makes me think of another vlog with two sisters who always seem to get along well, but one time in the background while their mom was talking I saw them punch each other in the arm. It was funny because it was random and in the background and you never see them do something like that usually.
thanks, someone had to say that! they are not perfect, just because they r youtubers doesnt mean they r perfect. They are like 2 normal sisters, it would not be normal if annie was nice to hay all the time lmao
I felt so happy when they got 4 million subscribers because they deserve it. And I feel like we all did a good thing by subscribing cuz we made there day. YOUR WELCOME BRATAYLEY WE LOVE U!!!!!!!! CONGRATULATIONS!!!
Khediga Omer omg yea! I've been watching this channel for 3 years, but I didn't have a UA-cam account. But I finally got one a couple months ago and this is the first channel I subscribed to ❤️✨🔥✌🏼
HALEY CYCHOSZ I live in Canada to. One time we got a foot of snow and we didn't have a snow day. The Niagara Falls are amazing by the way. If you ever have the opportunity to go see the Falls you deffinetly should
Mine eye colour is brown but I want like a Teal aqua eyes I LOVE U GUYS CONGRATS ON 4million I LOVE U ANNIE I FOLLOW U ON MUSIC LY AMD U AND UR FAMILY ALWAYS MAKE MY DAY !!!!!❤️🇨🇦💓🦄🌈😍😘👏🏻💋🎂🎊🎉🎁🎈
Yay!!! Now boost Annie's friend Sydney the Coral Girl! She's at 56,471. Her dad won't let her get a kitten until she gets to 100,000 subscribers. She goes and looks at kittens every month and then cries when she has to go home without one. Oh, and she's a level 10/elite gymnast so is technically eligible to try out for the olympic team, which is a goal of hers, but realistically she needs to develop more skills to get a spot on the team. Luckily she's young and has time. So, give her a subscribe and a boost! Please!!!
Fangirl I do too. I'm just saying it's sad because he wasn't down here with them to celebrate. I believe in that stuff but I'm just saying that I'm sorry for them.
to everybody hating on annie: 1. she does lessons, so if her parents say she can get a horse, then that's their choice, not yours. 2. she's only 12, she's gonna get sick of Hayley sometimes, everybody gets annoyed by their siblings, get over yourselves. 3. stop saying Annie's always on camera and Hayley's not, Hayley doesn't want to be on camera all the time, and Annie does + Hayley has to go to school, she can't vlog at school. 4. stop saying they don't deserve a horse and rabbit because they do nothing to deserve their subscribers, they take time out of their lives to make people smile, appreciate them, and when they have meet and greets, they smile for every single person. they have lost someone they love, leave them be, they've been through enough. they are doing this for caleb, he would have wanted them to be happy. have respect for them, after all they've been through, they deserve this.
Payton Welsh Then why does it say your new to UA-cam in your bio and the picture is of a 12 year old? You could not have been watching since you were 6
Yay Annie! Your shoe is winning! Annie: 3.5M Sam Gordon: 74 542 Kaycee Rice: 2.1M Wang Junkai: 3.4M Mademoiselle Gloria: 70 212 Lincoln Markham: 2.7N Sullivan Gwed: 106,903 Mark Thomas: 119 501 Can't wait to buy this awesome shoe! 😁 Super important question ...when does the shoe come out!!!???
Around 23:08- 23:10, after Miss Jill said "have all the kids gone?" The camera turned to Hayley and she said she hasn't gone but Ms.Katie turns away and says oh well. I feel bad for Hayley.
Wow this is crazy you have 4m sub's now! I was watching since I was supper young! I remember when you posted the 50 sub video when you put a pie in Annie's face! good times.. 😂 anyway all I mean to say is I'm a big big fan and congrats on 4m ( m = million ). btw I'm not that old only a year older then Annie..
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU GET A BUNNY!!!! - rabbits need unlimited alfalfa hay until they are 5 months old and then switch them to Timothy hay - rabbits need unlimited fresh water -rabbits need unlimited alfalfa based pellets until they are 5 months old and then only give them about a 1/4 cup of Timothy based pellets every day -rabbits need at least 2 cups of vegetables (lettuce, parsley, etc.) every day -PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT keep your rabbit in a store bought cage!!!!! I recommend building an NIC condo or cage (look at 101rabbits' video on that) they need much more room to run around then you would think!!! - you will need to get your rabbit spayed/neutered to prevent territorial behaviors and cancers - rabbits are very destructive so you should give them lots of toys to chew on (you can give them cardboard boxed or toilet paper rolls) PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE research rabbit care before getting your bunny!!!!! I recommend looking at 101rabbits' chanel, she is great! I see so many people getting rabbits and not knowing how to care for them! I hope you are not one of them :)
CONGRATULATIONS ON 4 MILLION SUBSCRIBERS BRATAYLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😄😃😆😅😇😭👏👍❤❤❤❤💕💕💕💜💜💜🆑 CELEBRATE LIFE!!! CALEB IS SO PROUD OF YOU GUYS!!!!!❤❤💜💜💕💕🆑🆑
MadMxie she lost when they went to Vegas for a gym meet they think that it got places on the cart with the food from room service and got mistaken as a napkin
I hope Annie knows horse shopping is a VERY detailed process. Horses are not like dogs and bunnies. Finding a right match can take YEARS much less a few weeks. I'm not hating, but this family needs to be mindful of the knowledge they must obtain (for their own safety and the safety of the horse) before they jump head first into this.
Since Annie and Hayley love to make slime so much. They should pick a couple random people that are subscribed to them a make slime for them and then send it to that person.
I have blueish green
SAME!
Bubbles Creations same
Bubbles Creations same
Bubbles Creatio
Bubbles Creations same💜💜💜💜
Congratulations guys! Jillian wants a horse now :-)
EvanTubeHD Hi I love you both!
EvanTubeHD hi
EvanTubeHD who's Jillian?
EvanTubeHD 🐎🐎🐎🎉
Mackenzie Fritz Evans adorable sister
Caleb will be having a party in heaven ❤️
xKayli SmithOfficialx 😭😭😢🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑🆑
xKayli SmithOfficialx 😭
xKayli SmithOfficialx true girl ☆
Bet he was glad that his friend was back also :3
xKayli SmithOfficialx you are so right
When Annie did the splits on the escalator that reminded me of the scene in elf 😂😂😂
Madisyn vogel I was doing that yesterday. Elf is a great movie
Madisyn vogel ikr😂😂
You guys were the first people I watched and subscribed to on UA-cam. Hailey was so young and you guys could barely understand a word she said. When I subbed you guys were at thousands of subscribers and it's so amazing to see you guys at 4,000,000+ subscribers. When I first subbed to you guys the video "who falls asleep at their first movie" or something like that was a fairly new video. I remember that the first video I watched was of Annie, Hayley, and Caleb jumping around on the old trampoline. Annie was in a blue flannel and she sadly had a bloody nose. At first I was a bit skeptic if I liked your content or not but, then I continued watching your videos 24/7 and became addicted. I LOVE YOU GUYS AND I AM NOW MOTIVATED TO START MY OWN SUCCESSFUL UA-cam CHANNEL AND JUST LIVE LIFE LIKE THERE IS NO TOMORROW, I'M SO GLAD TO SEE YOU GUYS STRIVE!!
Shorty4Life wow, that's so cute and amazing! 😍❤️
Shorty4Life your comment should be pinned by bratayley
Wow that is a lot of words
Shorty4Life same but i subbed to the when they where happy for 50
I cried out of happiness watching this!! I have been subscribed since 100,000 or so and I feel like part of the family! This makes me so happy and proud! You guys deserve it!
BTW my eyes are green! I wish they were a brighter green though, they are kinda dull!
Skylar Sawtelle that's so cool! I was here since 2 million but not nearly as long as you👍🏻
All that matters is you're apart of the Bratayley Family now!!!
Winnie Yo same but 1 million!😊
I was here since the very beginning!! 😂❤️
Annie was soo happy...i felt so good..😗😻❤💖
Keep Calm same
Yes I totally agree! SAME :) Also have a channel!
i know it showed how much they ALL actually cared because before i was like yea they care but now im so happy because it showed appreciaton :)
well duh she was happy she is getting a horse
I know right I feel so appreciated by all of them!! And I am SO HAPPY for Annie and Haley!!! 😂😂😍 Love them
OMG 4MILLION CONGRATULATIONS YOU TOTALLY DESERVE IT!!!!!👍👍👍👍
I no you are so right
Caleb is probably looking down on his family crying his eyes out for he is so proud of them. I wish he was here with us on this journey to 4 mil physically, but I realize he will always be in all our hearts and on our minds every step of the way. stay strong bratayley
Congrats on 4 Million, you guys honestly deserve it after what you do for us. We should all celebrate life!
Lucky Yes congrats bratayley!
Lucky YAYYYY #4MIL
Lucky 😙😜😕😙☹️😔😃😁😃😁😀😁😀☺️😅😍😗😀😘😙😃🤡☺️😂🤡😇😉🤓😂☺️😒😔😃😒😔😳😳😆😆😆😆😁😁😁😄
Congrats
Lucky YAS
YES IVE BEEN WAITING FOR YOU GUYS TO HIT 4 MIL!! CONGRATS❤😻
.
I actually cried when they hit 4 million!! congrats brataley!! U guys are the best keep doing what your doing!!
Bratayley*^
CONGRATS BRATAYLEY!!!!!! I TOOK LIKE 14 SCREENSHOTS!!!!!!!!! I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS!!!!!!! LUV YOU BRATAYLEY!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️💛💛💛💚💚💚💙💙💙💜💜💜❣️❣️❣️💕💕💕💞💞💞💓💓💓💗💗💗💖💖💖💘💘💘💝💝💝
My eyes are blue but everyone thinks their green so... there is also a spot of brown in each eye!!
Congrats Bratayley Fam on getting to 4 million subscribers.. We worked hard and it was a great success keep up the good work guys!!! You all earn it
AHHH YAYAYAYAY THEY DID IT IM SO PROUD OF THEM AND CALEB WOULD BE TOO
hayley is so freaking funny and adorable oml
Lily Lucero dont curse she is a child
@@lizzyrose1233wha- 😩
4Millllionnnnnnnnn!!!!!! Woooooooo I'm so proud of you guys whooooooo 🎉🎁🎊 YAYAYAY CONGRATS
Congratulations Bratayley for 4M subscribers hope you get to 6M bye the end of the year or 5M subscribers good job
OMG yay finally!!!! Congrats on 4 million subs! When i saw the title i literally threw my phone across my room!!!💞💞💞✨✨✨🎊🎊🎊🎉🎉🎉4️⃣
8 months later you guys have 5 million!!! I'm so proud of how you guys have come a long way and I can't wait to see what's more to come!😋
Micaela G 6 months 😋
To put it into perspective for Annie and Hayley, 4.5 million is the population of Ireland 🇮🇪 instead of fitting us in a room, I think you should come to Ireland just to make it real 😉
Leah Walshe omg yessss!! I'm from Ireland too!
Leah Walshe yasss I'm from ireland to!! 💗💗🇨🇮 happy Patrick's day
Leah Walshe no they should go to 🇺🇸
paris Benoit they live I America
Leah Walshe ya come to Ireland plz🇮🇪🇮🇪💚💚💚
Congrats! But where are you gonna keep a horse? In your living room? Don't you think that might seem a bit weird? "We are back for another vlog! Oh, theirs the horse eating the sofa!" 😂
Anna Bandini it's at Amanda's stables
Anna Bandini 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Anna Bandini at Amanda (Annie's gym friend whom parents own a horse ranch/stable) and they (Amanda and her parents) have horses and have been educating the family on horse care and horse things
Anna Bandini HAHA
At Amanda's house with their horses
OMG congrats on 4mill u guys you soooo deserve it!!!!!:-) Have a good day! And always remember to celebrate life🐎🐇
Hey It's Mai v
I totally agree
I love the close bond katie and Annie had..... I wish that would come back!
I am so insanely proud of you and your entire family and friends!! You have achieved so much and it's actually crazy to think that maybe in 7 months or so you could be hitting 5 million😽😽 It feels like it was only yesterday I was watching your vlog "who falls asleep at their first movie?". These last 6 years have been such an incredible and emotional journey but we have all been so fortunate to watch all of you grow up right in front of our eyes!! Annie and Hayley are such talented and beautiful daughters who are such a credit to you both (Miss Katie and Mr Billy) Despite the circumstances which I can relate very much so you have all continued to have strength and spread your happiness in every direction you go💜 You have grown as a UA-cam channel and are recognised by everyone hugely. Yes you may have some spiteful people who may try bring you down maybe for the way that you parent your own children or maybe the way that your own children act on camera. But whatever they have to say you always continue to rise above it and that really does deserve some recognition for!! At the end of the day you can live your lives however you want to and you should never change just because someone told you too🙏🏻 Continue being who you all are and I am looking forward to your video in 16 and a half hours time. (I usually stay up until midnight to watch your videos as I live in the UK) But anyway I just want to thankyou for sharing the lives with us everyday as to me it always brings a little more happiness into my own life!! Congratulations once again for hitting the huge 4 million🎉 Lots of love and I will always continue being one of your 4 millions fans💜💜💜💜💜 @officiallybratayley @iamabakedpotato @officiallydadtayley @presshandstands @superhayley7
Love you guys! Congrats on 4 million!!!
I am sad BUT SO HAPPY at the same time. I'm sad because I had a a bunny like Hayley does now and her name was Daisy. But the funny thing is when we went to the vet it was actual a boy but I stilled called him/her daisy. Sadly she did so I'm happy because its nice seeing Hayley be so happy to get a bunny. Care for your bunny as much as I did Hayley and love him/her so much!
my bunny died last week:( she was 8 tho Ik how u feel
I Can't believe that you guys just reached 4M It seems like it was just yesterday that Annie was Singing the 50 states Hayley learning gymnastics And Caleb singing baked potatoe You guys made it this far. You were through a tough time but still but on a brave face for us and kept on vloging And we helped you through that time too. You made me learn to celebrate life Never give up and Annie And Hayley Make me improve on gymnastics by watching these vlogs. I give credit to you Katie and Billy for filming and stay up late editing the videos. Just wanting to say thank you for making videos everyday for us Love you💜💜💜🐇🐴🆑⚾7
Everyone who is saying about Annie being mean to Haley and Annie getting all the attention Haley doesn't want to be in front of the camera all the time it is her decision and Haley did get to squish the tooth and strawberry and thought it was fun and they both deserve a horse and bunny for entertaining us for so long so peace out haters!
Lucy Hazlett thank you!! Preach.
Lucy Hazlett we aren't talking about the camera but just overall the things the mum does not billy like my mum says" if u don't my Layla one(my sister) u r asking for trouble " because Haley is probably thinking like oh Annie got this but she doesn't show it
Lucy Hazlett agree
@Bratayley Annie and Hayley should do Room Tours
Thalia Rogers I know
Annie already did a room tour last Christmas
Thalia Rogers I agree
Yesssss!!!!!!!!!!!!! So happy for you!
Olivia C me too
Olivia C 4 million yassssss
Olivia C same
I think annie just forget caleb on her speech cause she's just so happy 😊.....don't worry Guys.......they all remember him..🆑🆑🆑...miss u caleb...
She did include him she did that sound that sounds like a donkey
Brown and # love you guys
Congratulations on 4million I love you guys
And for the question of the day my eyes are hazel
Annalee Caldera same
everyone is saying how they like hayley better than annie, because annie is "mean" to hayley. but, they're sisters. i guarantee if you have a sibling you aren't nice to them 24/7!! so stop hating on annie!! ❤️❤️
Grace L exactly all siblings have a rivalry
Grace I totally agree I have a sister and two brothers
Grace L yes it's just something in life that people need to realize is a thing nobody is perfect so shut up all of those people
That makes me think of another vlog with two sisters who always seem to get along well, but one time in the background while their mom was talking I saw them punch each other in the arm. It was funny because it was random and in the background and you never see them do something like that usually.
thanks, someone had to say that! they are not perfect, just because they r youtubers doesnt mean they r perfect. They are like 2 normal sisters, it would not be normal if annie was nice to hay all the time lmao
actually I just borrowed my whole families cell phones and make them subscribe to Bratayley xD
Flippin Bratayley this was 2 days away btw
Turquoise Turtle101 yeah I know I watched it on my TV screen and now I'm on my phone I get to comment and like.
Flippin Bratayley lmao I made all my friends sub to them 😂😂
So happy for you guys and it was great watching Annie and Haley grow up.
LOVE YOU GUYS ❤️
I felt so happy when they got 4 million subscribers because they deserve it. And I feel like we all did a good thing by subscribing cuz we made there day. YOUR WELCOME BRATAYLEY WE LOVE U!!!!!!!! CONGRATULATIONS!!!
Khediga Omer omg yea! I've been watching this channel for 3 years, but I didn't have a UA-cam account. But I finally got one a couple months ago and this is the first channel I subscribed to ❤️✨🔥✌🏼
Hahahha "a couple weeks?" it took me 2 years to find my pony
Hailey Black ikr! It's crazy already that they're getting a horse after a few weeks.
2 YEARS!!!!?????
yup HAHA I wanted to find " the one" but now im so so so happy I waited
annie brateyley 🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕💏💏💏💏💩💩💩💩😘👌
Fatima эамади f u to
YAY!!! I'm so happy for you guys!!😍😍😍
I really love you Bratayley! ❤️😍 Congrats! 🎉 🙌🏽
I've been watching for 5 years and now you're at 4 mill!!!!
6 years
Alyssa Mazhar same I was watching for 5 years and was watching when they had toshi ❤️
Nice💜
Alyssa Mazhar same I've been watch scene like 5 years
Lol if in Canada we got that much snow it would not be a snow day😂We need like a foot of snow to get a snow day❄️#Canadian🇨🇦🇨🇦
Ikr!
#canadianproblems
Jeanette 6 here in uk 🇬🇧 we barely get snow. But it gets freezing
Well I saw short and tank tops, so it seems that they didn't really think a snow day was necessary either!
Caitlin Sykes ikr I live in U.K., the last time it snowed properly was like 3 or 4 years ago
In Canada their was 40inches of snow.All cars where covered. XD
Marsie Online that's true !! I live in Canada to !!
HALEY CYCHOSZ I live in Canada to. One time we got a foot of snow and we didn't have a snow day. The Niagara Falls are amazing by the way. If you ever have the opportunity to go see the Falls you deffinetly should
same in maine
HALEY CYCHOSZ Nope. We still go to school if its -40! But we don't go outside if its colder than -25
HALEY CYCHOSZ Summer can be very rainy but usually pretty nice. Just reminding you that earlier I was talking about degrees Celcius and not Fahrenheit
congrats 🎉🎊bratayley you guys deserved it
Congratulations for 4m subscribers u guys r the best congrats love u 😊😘
we did it I went to all my family members phones and subscribed to ur channel woohoo
ZNYIAH CAMPBELL me to XD lol
ZNYIAH CAMPBELL 😂😂😂 nice one
Mine eye colour is brown but I want like a Teal aqua eyes I LOVE U GUYS CONGRATS ON 4million I LOVE U ANNIE I FOLLOW U ON MUSIC LY AMD U AND UR FAMILY ALWAYS MAKE MY DAY !!!!!❤️🇨🇦💓🦄🌈😍😘👏🏻💋🎂🎊🎉🎁🎈
I love you bratayley
hayley reminds me a being a cool kid
annie reminds me of being a strong gymnast
your parents reminds me of being happy😊
who else hugged there phone when Annie hugged the camera 💕💕💕😂😂
Julia Zeltonowska i
Julia Zeltonowska meee!!!
Julia Zeltonowska me
Julia Zeltonowska me
Im so happy Bratayley gets 4M
Katy Ramirez me too !!
Katy Ramirez I'm not they are just bribing us and there lids
Katy Ramirez *kids
Stop
Katy Ramirez me too its going to be so fun that Hayley is getting a bunny and Annie a horse 🐴 🐰
Congrats guys
Congrats on the 4 million. I remember when you all didn't even have 1M
Yay!!! Now boost Annie's friend Sydney the Coral Girl! She's at 56,471. Her dad won't let her get a kitten until she gets to 100,000 subscribers. She goes and looks at kittens every month and then cries when she has to go home without one. Oh, and she's a level 10/elite gymnast so is technically eligible to try out for the olympic team, which is a goal of hers, but realistically she needs to develop more skills to get a spot on the team. Luckily she's young and has time. So, give her a subscribe and a boost! Please!!!
Patrick Horgan EVERYONE THUMBS UP THIS COMMENT FOR PEOPLE TO SEE IT
Patrick Horga she has 200k
Nvm you are talking about the coral girl
BabyZaria lol
Nope just checked. Only 56,503
I cried I was so happy for you guys love you bratayley
My eyes are hazel
OMG I AM SOOOOO HAPPY I HAVE THE SAME PHONE CASE AS BILLY THE ONE WITH THE THREE DOGS BUT I LIVE IN IRELAND 🇮🇪
And btw happy saint Patrick's day 🇮🇪
Mia Crowe happy paddys day🇮🇪
Mia Crowe Happy st.patricks day
My eyes are grey
Mia Crowe I LIVE IN IRELAND ASWELL ! AND HAPPY ST PADDYS DAY 🍀🍀🍀🍀
I'm very proud of you guys ❤️you deserve it ❤️❤️😘😘😍🌈🦄
A few weeks? That's really lucky. I've been asking for a bunny for 3 years now.
Mikayla I've been asking for a dog for almost 11 years, still don't have one at 18
at 18 why cant you just get your own dog if your looking after it
It's sad that caleb wasn't here when they hit 4 million😭💖🙏🏼 #4million
ItsTotally Bri yeah
Fangirl I do too. I'm just saying it's sad because he wasn't down here with them to celebrate. I believe in that stuff but I'm just saying that I'm sorry for them.
ItsTotally Bri yeah i wonder what caleb would of gotten
Macayla Donovan he probably would get a cat
ItsTotally Bri stop talking
You should buy Squishys off silly Squishys or creamiicandy!! They have really slow rising Squishys!!
i love this family i have been with this family for 2 years and my eyes are blue
to everybody hating on annie: 1. she does lessons, so if her parents say she can get a horse, then that's their choice, not yours. 2. she's only 12, she's gonna get sick of Hayley sometimes, everybody gets annoyed by their siblings, get over yourselves. 3. stop saying Annie's always on camera and Hayley's not, Hayley doesn't want to be on camera all the time, and Annie does + Hayley has to go to school, she can't vlog at school. 4. stop saying they don't deserve a horse and rabbit because they do nothing to deserve their subscribers, they take time out of their lives to make people smile, appreciate them, and when they have meet and greets, they smile for every single person. they have lost someone they love, leave them be, they've been through enough. they are doing this for caleb, he would have wanted them to be happy. have respect for them, after all they've been through, they deserve this.
congratulations
Meath Athletic 🎉
I have the strawberry squishy. Congrats on the 4m love you guys
I am so proud of you Bratayle congratulations to 4 million subscribers
Over the years the comments section has really changed
omg good job I been a fan since the first vlog🤗🤗🤗
Sariyah Greene same
The color of my eyes are blue and congrats Bratayley I have been with you guys since your guys second month of vloging
Payton Welsh
Then why does it say your new to UA-cam in your bio and the picture is of a 12 year old?
You could not have been watching since you were 6
1000 Subs No Videos ikr 😂
Sorry, but I think you are lying.
Payton Welsh same but first month
Yay Annie! Your shoe is winning!
Annie: 3.5M
Sam Gordon: 74 542
Kaycee Rice: 2.1M
Wang Junkai: 3.4M
Mademoiselle Gloria: 70 212
Lincoln Markham: 2.7N
Sullivan Gwed: 106,903
Mark Thomas: 119 501
Can't wait to buy this awesome shoe! 😁
Super important question ...when does the shoe come out!!!???
do u remember wen hayleys hair was up to her ears and annie didnt have front teeth and caleb had short hair if only he saw this
josh sykes yup ;(
josh sykes WAAAAAAA :(
josh sykes yeah
josh sykes YASSS those were the days (I love nowadays as well ❤️)
ILysm STOP HATING ON THEM
Around 23:08- 23:10, after Miss Jill said "have all the kids gone?" The camera turned to Hayley and she said she hasn't gone but Ms.Katie turns away and says oh well. I feel bad for Hayley.
Omal4 but she still went
Omal4 you mean katie not miss jill
Omal4 she said that because that women (forgot her name) was already going and I wasn't just Haley, they still got there turn.
Omal4 yeah she did do that cause Hayley went "uh no" and then mrs.katie went "oh well" but to me it look liked Hayley went after words
Omal4 ok she said oh.... well you will go right now
Annie is sooooooo pretty!!!
So is Hayley
You guys deserve this success, because you guys are incredible and talented and I send my congratulations direct from Brazil!
BRATAYLEY is the BEST
I love u gues and I hope u get your bunny and horse
Wow this is crazy you have 4m sub's now! I was watching since I was supper young! I remember when you posted the 50 sub video when you put a pie in Annie's face! good times.. 😂 anyway all I mean to say is I'm a big big fan and congrats on 4m ( m = million ). btw I'm not that old only a year older then Annie..
Lia G me too..i'm a year older than her
Lia GTA247 umm.. imnot sure but i think they put a pie in Caleb's face when the hit 50 subs
Army Trassh u suck
Oviously ur not cause they put a pie in Caleb’s face I found. A liar
Congratulations on 4 million subscribers
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU GET A BUNNY!!!!
- rabbits need unlimited alfalfa hay until they are 5 months old and then switch them to Timothy hay
- rabbits need unlimited fresh water
-rabbits need unlimited alfalfa based pellets until they are 5 months old and then only give them about a 1/4 cup of Timothy based pellets every day
-rabbits need at least 2 cups of vegetables (lettuce, parsley, etc.) every day
-PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT keep your rabbit in a store bought cage!!!!! I recommend building an NIC condo or cage (look at 101rabbits' video on that) they need much more room to run around then you would think!!!
- you will need to get your rabbit spayed/neutered to prevent territorial behaviors and cancers
- rabbits are very destructive so you should give them lots of toys to chew on (you can give them cardboard boxed or toilet paper rolls)
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE research rabbit care before getting your bunny!!!!! I recommend looking at 101rabbits' chanel, she is great! I see so many people getting rabbits and not knowing how to care for them! I hope you are not one of them :)
I have black eyes but when the sun gets in my eyes they go light brown !!!! 😂 😄 😀 💖
You can't have black eyes you have dark brown
Congratulations bratayley but can you guys film Hayley a bit more because it feels like Annie is always on all about her
Seval Kaya Katie and Billy have already said a bunch of times that Hayley doesn't like to be on camera as much.
McDobs still doesn't mean Annie has to have everything
CONGRATULATIONS ON 4 MILLION SUBSCRIBERS BRATAYLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😄😃😆😅😇😭👏👍❤❤❤❤💕💕💕💜💜💜🆑 CELEBRATE LIFE!!! CALEB IS SO PROUD OF YOU GUYS!!!!!❤❤💜💜💕💕🆑🆑
Our school didn't cancel when we got 25in of snow
Emilyvlogs that sucks
Emilyvlogs do you live in canada?!?!
Rylie Gerber no but I live in ny
Good job for reaching 4 million.
I liked this video the second she said "Ariana Grande"
Watching this in 2019 and now they have 7.3 million subscribers!!! It’s crazy how this was only 2 years ago and they have all grown so much
Omg who else loved Sam and Cat😮
brateyldy sucks
Olyvia Mills I did
Nour-anne Alahmadieh that is not nice to say, I've heard a lot of people say if you can't say anything nice then don't say nothing at all
I still do!!!
I feel like this whole comment section is triggered 12 year olds 😂
TianiIsAUnicorn yessss😂😂😂
TianiIsAUnicorn and then you have me a 14 yr old lool
TianiIsAUnicorn dude she is 13 but yeah HAHAHAHAH WHOLE COMMENT SECTION WAS TRIGGERD.
TianiIsAUnicorn it is😂😂
Aaliyah Grijaldo she is 12
I CAN'T be the only one who hugged the screen back! 😂💕
Horse time!!!!
your right
monch4433 and bunny time!!
monch4433 bunny time And horse time
I feel bad for the horse they get because they'll probably never go out to see it.
monch4433 yea
You should see what's going on here in Canada! 🇨🇦
Manahil Khokhar yes!!!
Manahil Khokhar I know It's all melting right now and it's a giant puddle everywhere.
I'm in Canada to!! 🇨🇦❤️
Manahil Khokhar ikr 😂🇨🇦
Manahil Khokhar me too
Has anyone wondered where the heck Annie is going to keep her horse?🐴
Brightbooks 88 she is going to keep it at her friend (Amanda's) stable
CONGRATS 🎉🎉 I hope you will continue to be an AMAZING youtuber who we will always support and love you guys. ❤❤❤❤❤
Did Annie ditch her blankie? Haven't really seen it in barely any videos, probably cause I don't watch their videos often.
MadMxie no she hasn't had it and I was thinking the same thing. I think she lost it but I'm not sure
MadMxie she lost it in Los Vegas
MadMxie she lost when they went to Vegas for a gym meet they think that it got places on the cart with the food from room service and got mistaken as a napkin
MadMxie They went on vacation and Annie lost it
MadMxie no she didn't ditch it she did lose one in vegas but she has another
if you can have anything in the world what would it be
Nyla Cardoso a owl!!!!
For Caleb to come back!!!!
Nyla Cardoso infinite wishes
SuperPenguinPlayz 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Nyla Cardoso Caleb back
I hope Annie knows horse shopping is a VERY detailed process. Horses are not like dogs and bunnies. Finding a right match can take YEARS much less a few weeks. I'm not hating, but this family needs to be mindful of the knowledge they must obtain (for their own safety and the safety of the horse) before they jump head first into this.
Since Annie and Hayley love to make slime so much. They should pick a couple random people that are subscribed to them a make slime for them and then send it to that person.
Anyone else wondering how they are going to keep a horse in their yard
Sophie Honl they are keeping it at Amanda's house
all these people sating that annie is mean to hayley obviously doesnt have siblings 😂
Giorgia xoxo ikr
Giorgia xoxo true 💕
100% true
Giorgia xoxo I'm not stating it even though I don't have siblings but my friend does and he is mean to me
Keep going well everyone is different some people are more mature than others it don't really matter 😇😈
In march your 4million and you've just hit 5 million this october within 6months bratayleyyy is my favorite
Now your on 5 million