Mujhe jitna samajh aya ye overall ek reservation system ke tarah hai. Jiska intial stage to accha rahega but kuch saalo baad iske wajah se 80% log corrupt ho jayengay jaise. ## Industry products cost bahut jada bada degi aur uske wajah se bahut bada inflation aa sakta hai. So ye system worth it nhi hai agar sabko pay kiya jaye to. Ye worth it tab hi hoga jab below poverty line walo ko paisa mile. But jab wo log grow kar jaye tab unko pay na kiya jaye.
Video was informative But, one cons I will tell you that 1. Some children can think that they may not require to study as in future they will get money by doing nothing (can be seen more for lower class section of society) So I think here it is good rather than given directly money , give them free food (cook or uncook), give them good medical facility and education... Hope it helped Cheers! Chaitanya Kadam
This happens in few countries of Europe ...citizen has an option to depend upon government for primary survival... long term gov educates and trains them for a better life
I don't think children will not study. Because when everyone is getting same amount money then it becomes new normal. Over the time that money will be just to fill his stomach so no one will dies of hunger. But i think it's human nature to pursue better life. So, now people don't have worry about food but still they have buy things, pay bills, rents, fees etc. So, they still have to work for better life.
In your dream if this possible starting from When Dev anand was born this policy has never been successfull or the promised yet to fullfill after your childrens childrens childrens children and childrens to come means even if you have 25 generations the way you think cannot be done,, free money is better diretly into your account
आपका हर वीडियो देखता हूं और मन में ख्याल आता है.... आप जैसे लोग पॉलिटिशन में क्यों नहीं होते तो मुझे रीजन भी मिल गया... कि आप जैसे लोग अगर पॉलिटिशन में आ गए तो वाकई में अपना देश सुधर जाएगा शायद इसीलिए आप लोग पॉलिटिशन में नहीं आ पाते
Dear Dhruv, I'm from Nepal, and currently in Dubai. From the last few months I'm watching your videos continuously and getting lots of information and thoughts. I want to request to make a video about current situation of Nepal Tourism, over all influence in economy, foreigners thoughts towards us and future possibilities. Thank you so much...
Not ,Possible ,who will decide who is Poor ,and Who is lower middle class ,by dress ? If the scheme is not universal ,beaurocrats will eat away money in classfying population in have and have not's.
Bro just think Person A is working 8hr /10hr a day and getting 20 k salary And So called poor / lower middle class gets 2 k free per person of family. So unfair , doesn't it??
If food will become free how farmer will earn If education will became free how teachers will earn If medical will become free how doctors and pharmacist will earn How they will earn there living
There are many arguments and counter-arguments on UBI schemes which you have covered. For a developing country like India, providing everyone with a basic income is unlikely to happen in the near future, given India's ever increasing debt and huge dependence of imports, especially for fossil fuels. However, another viable alternative to this policy could be Universal Basic Services- where instead of providing the citizens with financial aid, they are given free (or at a subsidized rates) access to basic services like Health care, transportation, internet data. This will form the foundation for a Public-Private partnership for various businesses and citizens will have access to better standards of living despite not getting any direct financial benefits. This theory is also under trial phase, but in my opinion, will be a more viable alternative to UBI keeping the Indian context in mind.
I recomend instead of giving ubi we should give everyone a universal basic utilities to everyone whether rich or poor. Ubu should include:- 1. Basic free electricity(eg 100 units free per month) 2. Basic free wifi( eg 30gb free per month) 3. Basic free school( I know public schools exist but I m recommending free private schools too. people will select school according to quality which will create more compeetikn among schools for quality. And govt should close public schools). 4. Basic free healthcare(same concept as schools including free medicines and free operations, surgeries etc) 5. Basic free house(a basic apartment house with 4 rooms alloted to everyone ). 6. Basic free water( no water bill till say 10000litteres per month) 7. Basic free food.( Providing free community langar in every city everyday) Instead of giving money we should give free basic utilities to every citizen of country.
Sabse jyada tax india mein hi vasool hota he. Kamai per tax aur fir se kuch karido toh bhi uske upper tax ... aur jo tax nahi bharta usse fir bhi GST vasool ho hi raha he.. To itna haq to indian public ko banta he. Ki basic requirements government unko free mein de. Jaise Bansal ji ne kahe he..
@@muntasirbaqui1531 bhai sab politicians agar apna black money jo Swiss bank mein jama kiye he gar india ko donate kare na toh apni economy world ki number 1 economy ho sakti he. World bank ka sara karja chuka sakte he hum hindustani.. ye baat kitni sach he ye sab jante he. Par koi isse jatana nahi chahta. Do u agree
Woh apni buraai khud toh karega nhi bhai You need to search at different sites to actually realize who is Dhruv Rathee He tells his viewers that," the people who believe Modi for whatever he says, that people are andhbhakt" But his viewers never check the given facts of Dhruv Rathee and are becoming andhbhakt themselves and calling others andhbhakt!! Please, go and check facts by yourselves, do not believe Dhruv. He always shows us one-sided story!!
Is that financial or psychological thought? Will the value of gold go down(which I don't think it will because the cost of extraction and making jewels are still high) , or people will lose interest in gold because it's "not cool/ fashionable" to have it
@@randomhuman97 if every person will have a KG of gold, there won't be demand like before & price will go down. 50℅ usage of gold is Jewelry purposes with so much abundance of gold in every household the value will be like Brass for common person. 37℅ of it's usage is electronics & 8% for coins : this part probably won't loss its value. ( I am not an economic expert this was just my POV, 1st line of my comment 😁 ) but one thing I know is one of the major factor deciding value is Supply Demand Chain. By giving it to everyone the demand is slashed by 50%
Gold was fixed as a standard for valuing the total reserves of nations. But the real thing that has to do anything with humans is their standard of living like we saw in the case of killing of elephant in Kerala. The standard of living can have a positive impact on Human Values.
Good Work.. Please make a video on current scenario of USA. I think In India politician play with Hindu-Muslim. And in Foreign politician plays with Black-white and win election by divide and Rule please Give your Comments on these.
During my previous job at an NBFC, at an evening break with my colleagues, I casually asked them what they really wanted to work in/with. There were six of us and not one said it was the current job. Now, I work in a BPO. For me, personally, this scheme if implemented will be a dream come true.
the real question is, are these jobs that nobody wants to work at really required for society, not a lot of people would argue that fast food really adds a lot to our way of life, how many other big employers would fit that bill I wonder? jobs should make society better not just give the owning class more wealth.
according to me "GOVERNMENT SHOULD GIVE THIS BASIC INCOME TO THE PEOPLE JUST ONLY AND ONLY DURING THIS LOCKDOWN AND HAZARDIOUS COVID SITUATION SO THAT PEOPLE CAN SUSTAIN THEIR LIVES " AND AFTER SOME MONTHS THEY MUST STOP THIS ....!!!! YOU ARE AMAZING BHAIYA AAPNE TO MERA ECONOMICS MAI INTEREST BHADA DIYA !!! MAZA HI AA GAYA YE VIDEOS DEKH KE THANKS BHAIYA FOR SUCH INFORMATION ,.....
I was really scared of having a opinion without knowing the situation and history related just for the sake of speaking....u really helped me pave my mind in right direction
Its is a positive point, the implementation is negative due to hesitation of govt to distribute free money. If you see kejriwal model is closely relatable due to its free provision of services. Instead of providing Cash directly, services are provided free of cost. If basic necessities are provided free of cost without any administrative check or compliance check , the result can be optimised as only those people, who are in need, will be taking benefit of such services. However, purchasing power (cash) is also required to improve the happiness levels and consume those things that provide high amount of utility. Considering automation will take away jobs, govt should regulate tasks that cannot be automated and should be done manually.
there is no proper way to it, it is inevitably going to be adverserial to the economy because population growth is going to exponentially increase demand and therefore the threshold income would have to be contiguously increased thus causing inflation as a result of more money supply demand...
@@ramitkumar2918 what are your views on providing free facilities rather than free cash? Also, I personally believe that self reliance is a good measure if government promotes Farming, Animal Farming etc. (Things that are naturally recoccured) unconditional free utilities and necessities required to do Farming instead of cash?
The most commendable thing about sir dhruv rathee's research work is that he presents information on the basis of facts and in an unbiased manner. And unlike most youtubers who create crap content for the sake of entertainment that is sometimes threatening for the society , dhruv rathee's motive is creating awareness about the socio-economic environment. And he depicts all of these matters in a layman's language and the simplest form possible. And whenever I have to make myself updated with some recent event or happening I always look up to his youtube channel since it's easier to understand through his words I think he is making the best use of this platform. Truly amazing 👏
कांग्रेस लायी थी न्याय, जो यही स्कीम थी। मगर भारत की जनता ने उसे नकार दिया। तोह, इस का भारत मे कोई मतलब नही है। लोगो को चाहिए मज़ा, मौज, जाती , धर्म न कि विकास, पैसा।
Bhai ye v toh dekho ki negatives v hai isi chiz ke.toh zaroori nahi ki tumhe positives jyaada affect kare toh wahi majority people ko v kare. . . Aur yahi democracy hai public khud chunti hai aur public apne hisaab se sahi hi chuntti hai . .isiliye accept kro aur jab tak 5 saal na ho jaaye apne taraf se pura support do jab tak govt. Sahi hai.
actually, inflation arguement is flimsy. If you tax the rich, and use that money for UBI, the money isnt being printed, it is being redistributed. So inflation wont occur
See,I am not a Bhakt but I can tell you that the donation money received in PM CARES fund was well utilized,moreover the packages were much more time expensive than what was received in the fund.
UBI could be implemented in our country in short period to Handel the job loss during lockdown. But in long term, we must think about properly using man power of 1.3B people!
@nornalhuman !! Man automation!! With such a high population, and such an unemployment Level, we should not promote automation like US or so. Like..... If a work is done by 50 people, then they get some money, but if a 5 robot comes, it can do the same work. So, the company fires those 50 people, make more profit. At the end of the day, automation in our country gonna make the rich more reacher and poor more poor.
I sometimes feel that I waste time just getting Happy by the good and innovative solutions because This government doesn't have enough resources to access good thing (like this) 😪 Definitely we nee a video on how Govt. Can implement @Dhruv Rathee 's videos😂
This is a terrible idea. No one deserves free money. Our economy is already doing shit. Where will they get more money to support majority poor country. They become a burden to middle class and rich.
@@monumeena4386 unemployment ke lie government ko dosh deta hoon kyuki desh ke logo ne us government ko ye sochke vote kiya tha ki "agar hum isko vote karenge toh ye desh me unemployment kam ya khatam karne ke lie kuch karega"
@@mujahid_saqlaini agar bina govt. Ko love krke country se love kr skte ho to bina govt. Ko love krke employment bhi to kam kr skte ho,. But i can read ur name so its fine.
Yes, *Politicians failed* to eliminate *poverty of India* and they promise to lift our *living standards.* But nothing good happened for the citizens of *India and Kashmir.* I hope, they will not blame COVID, this time, for *Kashmir Crisis.*
Please do a video on inflation.. please.. aap bohot achese explain krte ho.. sare concepts clear hojate h .. I want to get clear view about .. how inflation takes place .. and everything regarding to Inflation
Very well explained! In my opinion I think UBI should be different for different sectors of the society, importance of UBI obviously cannot be overlooked for a poor family .
70% logo ke pas phone nhi hai pubg khelne ke liye na hi time hai. Sirf middle class khelti hai pubg. Baaki majority of population working class hai jo 12 ghante kaam krke sirf 200p-3000 rupaye mahina kamate hai. Poverty line ke below hai
मुझे लगता है कि एक बार स्कीम को पैलेट प्रोजेक्ट के तहत चलना चाहिये परिणाम को देखे और इन्सान महत्वाकांक्षी होता है और उसकी इच्छाएँ निरंतर बनी रहती है ग़रीब मध्यम वर्ग बनने की कोशिश करेगा और मध्यम वर्ग धनी वर्ग की कोशिश श्रेणी में जाएगा यही तो मैं वाले भारत में अधिक है मुझे लगता है स्कीम चलानी चाहिए।
If there was a universal answer to this question then there'd be no dictatorship present today. There is so specific set of rules for doing that. What people do to overthrow dictatorship depends on the conditions in their region!
all the positives are for short term. When everyone gets UBI then initially they may feel motivated but in the longer run they will become lazy. These types of schemes will not work for a longer time period.
@Pichkalu Pappita Peak🤣🤣, He has long way to go. There will always be controversial issues in Indian politics and he can always make videos on those topics.
@Pichkalu PappitaI am watching him for 2yrs now. 2yrs back this guy was gaining 10k subs/month and had 70k subs in total(July 2017). But this guy is adding 300k subs every months now, and thats going to increase by time. He will reach 4M probably next month. By this rate he will double his subscribers before 2022. Can't say for 10M, those are too far in time.
@@ashaharika9565 Freedom of Information Act 2002 revised and renamed as Right of Information Act 2005 (RTI) - meant for gaining informations on public authority or authorities.. Interesting to know people R aware - but will be more interesting - if people know PM Care Funds is “ *public* *authority* “ as top 4 authority holders - Minister of Home Affairs, Minster of Defence, Minister of Finance & Prime Minister are T trustees.. So directly its a public authority technically as per RTI.. Now Govt claims its not a public authority - straight outta corruption
it wasn't brother, because as Dhruv Rathee said how do you justify the bracket of 20-30% poor ? How do you define poverty ? A better way would've been an income to all economic groups but in a way that poor get more while the rich get less.... maybe the lower class get 2000 pm, middle class get 1000 pm and rich get 500 pm.... for the rich class it could be an option... I think this would've worked out in India really well...
I think the side is tilted towards the negative side But in my opinion the money should be distributed to those who really need it For example : for those people who can’t even afford buying food for their livelihood A good implementation of UBI towards the poor people can help everyone. This is my opinion and I think this is a debatable topic. Thank you
For that the bureaucracy should be strengthened in such a way that the Rich elites pay taxes more sincerely. When RBI will have more money then they could spend it on public sectors
Yeah UBI is great but it will take time here in India. For now let's save our jobs first - I informed my team that I'm doing MBA from upGrad - they too are now giving me more responsibilities. Which makes me feel secure in terms of job.
Hi Salman, we are glad that we were able to help you upskill. All the best for your future. In case you need any assistance, just call us on the number 08066084582
@@a-samadkhan5778 Hi Samad, our career experts can guide you better and suggest career prospects for you, so please call the number 08066084582 for guidance.
@@kaydendoesntbreak bhakt ji aa gye, welcome sir, yaha aapko thoda ajeeb lag raha hoga kyuki sab logical baat karrahe hai, koi baat nahi aap seekh jaoge maybe later.
@@kaydendoesntbreak lol isme kaunsi bjp ki burai hai,mai dhruv 50 percent video dhikadunga jisme usne doosri countries,saaf safai ,development ki baat kari hai
that's the point u are not understanding about UBI. it isn't UBI if it's Given to select people only like farmers, poor people etc giving it everyone is the point it's like a service which the government provides to its people like roads which are made by the government and any Citizen can use them.
1:08 Why Basic Income?
4:27 Positive Arguments
6:27 Negative Arguments
11:48 Real Life Experiments of UBI
15:46 Where will Money Come From?
Dhruv in every video be like 👇👌..
Positive argument 👌👍💪
Tanks sir Jo aap humlog jaise log ko batate h
Respect bro for your excellent work 😎😎😎😎
Plz Make another part of this video
Thnx 😎
Mujhe jitna samajh aya ye overall ek reservation system ke tarah hai. Jiska intial stage to accha rahega but kuch saalo baad iske wajah se 80% log corrupt ho jayengay jaise.
## Industry products cost bahut jada bada degi aur uske wajah se bahut bada inflation aa sakta hai.
So ye system worth it nhi hai agar sabko pay kiya jaye to. Ye worth it tab hi hoga jab below poverty line walo ko paisa mile. But jab wo log grow kar jaye tab unko pay na kiya jaye.
Video was informative
But, one cons I will tell you that
1. Some children can think that they may not require to study as in future they will get money by doing nothing (can be seen more for lower class section of society)
So I think here it is good rather than given directly money , give them free food (cook or uncook), give them good medical facility and education...
Hope it helped
Cheers!
Chaitanya Kadam
This happens in few countries of Europe ...citizen has an option to depend upon government for primary survival... long term gov educates and trains them for a better life
I don't think children will not study. Because when everyone is getting same amount money then it becomes new normal. Over the time that money will be just to fill his stomach so no one will dies of hunger. But i think it's human nature to pursue better life. So, now people don't have worry about food but still they have buy things, pay bills, rents, fees etc. So, they still have to work for better life.
It depends on that children how he think about his future 🙂
In your dream if this possible starting from When Dev anand was born this policy has never been successfull or the promised yet to fullfill after your childrens childrens childrens children and childrens to come means even if you have 25 generations the way you think cannot be done,, free money is better diretly into your account
I accept this fact
dhruv you should attach public pole in 'i' button for such issues
heard this feature is removed by UA-cam
He can do it in community poll
@@zahirulalamlaskar No it's still there in community post.
Haryana main IAS rani nagar na resign da diya us par video banae chaiya dhruv rathee ko
Hahahaha kbi toh bhai mp k pichle sarkar k k lye kuch bole tera bhai pta chal jaayega ke ye kya h 😂😂🤣🤣🙏🏻🙏🏻
Jai hind
आपका हर वीडियो देखता हूं और मन में ख्याल आता है.... आप जैसे लोग पॉलिटिशन में क्यों नहीं होते तो मुझे रीजन भी मिल गया... कि आप जैसे लोग अगर पॉलिटिशन में आ गए तो वाकई में अपना देश सुधर जाएगा शायद इसीलिए आप लोग पॉलिटिशन में नहीं आ पाते
I feel like a serious student when I use to see your videos, source of lots of knowledge, information, ideas & many more things .
IZAAN AHMED Thank you 😊🙏
@@dhruvrathee half knowledge dekar pagal bana rha hai iska
@@rahulverma-os1bv how ? Can u explain.
@@RitikKumar-ue1ek bhai iski video mat dekha karo yeh half knowledge deta hai me bhaut time se dekh rha hu
@@rahulverma-os1bv Puri Aap bata do. UBI ke kaunse facts chhode hain yaha?
I think Negative points clearly have some logic.
But so do the positives it s pretty good debate topic.
But real life experience is good enough to know
Ha bhai sahi kaha
I think negative points clearly have some logic
Please check my channel. I made a video on corruption.
Please support small UA-camr🙏🙏
Sir Please make a video on "Inflation" 🙂
mobile gamers aren't gamers
@@the360gaming5 but they know to play games so, they are gamers.
@@the360gaming5 konsi dictionary me bola hai aisa?
No
Please check my channel. I made a video on corruption.
Please support small UA-camr🙏🙏
Dear Dhruv,
I'm from Nepal, and currently in Dubai. From the last few months I'm watching your videos continuously and getting lots of information and thoughts.
I want to request to make a video about current situation of Nepal Tourism, over all influence in economy, foreigners thoughts towards us and future possibilities.
Thank you so much...
This incentives should be given to those..who actually need this...
Like poor and lower middle classes
Not ,Possible ,who will decide who is Poor ,and Who is lower middle class ,by dress ?
If the scheme is not universal ,beaurocrats will eat away money in classfying population in have and have not's.
Bro just think
Person A is working 8hr /10hr a day and getting 20 k salary
And So called poor / lower middle class gets 2 k free per person of family.
So unfair , doesn't it??
@M & M correct bro
@C U P I D I totally agree.
You have commonsense which is not common now a days
@@wricheekadhikari7912 toally agree with ypu Instead of wasting time and money on regulations,better find a way to implement it universally .
All human being should get these three things free
1 food to survive
2 education
3 medical care
Exactly! Money is not needed to be given if these things are done
If you give free food to people, the main objective of earning a living vanishes... Causing unproductiveness.
Medical and education should be free... I support that.
What abt shelter
If food will become free how farmer will earn
If education will became free how teachers will earn
If medical will become free how doctors and pharmacist will earn
How they will earn there living
Make a video on failure and success of lockdown.
Good topic
He will surely do one on the fails of lockdown!
@@harshjha6735 chup andhbhakt
Jakar Sudhir thihari ki video dekh
@@harshjha6735 wo to fail ho hi chuka 3 lock down ke jb migration hua labourers ka. Bs ab dekho case kis teji se bdte. Achaa ho agar case bade
There are many arguments and counter-arguments on UBI schemes which you have covered. For a developing country like India, providing everyone with a basic income is unlikely to happen in the near future, given India's ever increasing debt and huge dependence of imports, especially for fossil fuels. However, another viable alternative to this policy could be Universal Basic Services- where instead of providing the citizens with financial aid, they are given free (or at a subsidized rates) access to basic services like Health care, transportation, internet data. This will form the foundation for a Public-Private partnership for various businesses and citizens will have access to better standards of living despite not getting any direct financial benefits. This theory is also under trial phase, but in my opinion, will be a more viable alternative to UBI keeping the Indian context in mind.
I recomend instead of giving ubi we should give everyone a universal basic utilities to everyone whether rich or poor.
Ubu should include:-
1. Basic free electricity(eg 100 units free per month)
2. Basic free wifi( eg 30gb free per month)
3. Basic free school( I know public schools exist but I m recommending free private schools too. people will select school according to quality which will create more compeetikn among schools for quality. And govt should close public schools).
4. Basic free healthcare(same concept as schools including free medicines and free operations, surgeries etc)
5. Basic free house(a basic apartment house with 4 rooms alloted to everyone ).
6. Basic free water( no water bill till say 10000litteres per month)
7. Basic free food.( Providing free community langar in every city everyday)
Instead of giving money we should give free basic utilities to every citizen of country.
atleast accomodation n electricity
Providing healthcare facilities,housing, food and water will cost more money than it would for ubi
Sabse jyada tax india mein hi vasool hota he. Kamai per tax aur fir se kuch karido toh bhi uske upper tax ... aur jo tax nahi bharta usse fir bhi GST vasool ho hi raha he.. To itna haq to indian public ko banta he. Ki basic requirements government unko free mein de. Jaise Bansal ji ne kahe he..
Really appreciated sir
@@muntasirbaqui1531 bhai sab politicians agar apna black money jo Swiss bank mein jama kiye he gar india ko donate kare na toh apni economy world ki number 1 economy ho sakti he. World bank ka sara karja chuka sakte he hum hindustani.. ye baat kitni sach he ye sab jante he. Par koi isse jatana nahi chahta. Do u agree
This channel should have more subscribers than T-series🤗🤗
@@vishalgaur1206 yes i blowed my mind after watching that🤣🤣🤣
Carry 20.5 M subscribers ✌
I am glad that there are few comment sections on youtube where logic is given the first place
I think you have never visited any good youtube channel
Whatever
let's play pubg together I am getting bored😢
Id 5348ba23
User name - ilovecarry
@@sushilkumarray266 Pubg kahan se ghusaad di beech mein? Khud jaake khel overrated chinese mobile game which requires no skill. "Mobile gamers"
Twitter is so negative about Dhruv, I didn't find anything wrong here
Woh apni buraai khud toh karega nhi bhai
You need to search at different sites to actually realize who is Dhruv Rathee
He tells his viewers that," the people who believe Modi for whatever he says, that people are andhbhakt"
But his viewers never check the given facts of Dhruv Rathee and are becoming andhbhakt themselves and calling others andhbhakt!!
Please, go and check facts by yourselves, do not believe Dhruv.
He always shows us one-sided story!!
@@nischay5231 but I have seen his videos, never found him doing that, koi Dhruv ka video hai to batao, I'm new to all this, may be you can help.
@@nischay5231 to economy down kese Hua? Modi ne psu ke shares privatized Kar diye, ye phir kya tha?
@@nischay5231 ye modi ne kya Kiya coronavirus se bachne k liye
@@TheOpposition modi ne hindu vs Muslim karke India ko Pakistan jaisa Bana diya jo religion k liye economy down he
Laziness and inovation may depend on person to person.
True that. Not all rich people are lazy and not all poor people are hardworking... it's just a prejudice.
Exactly
So can spellings
We really need a video on the topic ‘inflation’. And thanks for explaining UBI so beautifully. You are a gem💯
i am in canada. i got my 2000 dollars every month since march.. govt giving to all workers.. i was labourer in factory
Bhai Canada ham bhi Jana chahate h par visa kaise milega .Kuch help Kar sakte h kya aap
You left your work? Because of the consistent income?
Tell us how are you spending it
@@ombeer6785 Why do all sikh people want to go to canada?
@@ralfjones9816 Canada is our 2nd Punjab
Sir, I want to work in Canada please help
Kitne acche se apne involved economic cycle bhi samjaya cleared ,gain confidence in myself 🙏
Dhruv bhai, we need a detailed video on "Inflation"
Awesome explanation.. You are the "Great Explainer" Of our generation.
Your videos are like E- learnings, I sit with pen and paper to jot down key takeaways.
P.S : Good job 👍🏻
Same here bro
When all the Job Losses due to automation and AI will be so large than most of the people are unemployed then the negative effects won't matter.
@@shrodingerscat8940 true very true
Exactly my thoughts. Glad that you are thinking sensibly.
No
you should make more such detailed video, this one was awesome :)
@Stoic Aand or tatte
Make a video on PM CARES FUND eagerly waiting ..🙂
Nobody know that what happen with that fund, if dhruv know then he surely make a video
@@SmartyTripplets election time pe kaam ayega
PMO refuse to disclose information about PM care fund.. i have seen some where in news
@jignesh Solanki how much u donated in PM cares fund☺️
@@dharmendramaurya181 1000/-
My point is :
If every person on earth will have 1 kg of GOLD, then value of Gold will not be like Gold :D
Is that financial or psychological thought?
Will the value of gold go down(which I don't think it will because the cost of extraction and making jewels are still high) , or people will lose interest in gold because it's "not cool/ fashionable" to have it
appne is thought bahut badi baat kahi hai 👌
@@randomhuman97 if every person will have a KG of gold, there won't be demand like before & price will go down. 50℅ usage of gold is Jewelry purposes with so much abundance of gold in every household the value will be like Brass for common person.
37℅ of it's usage is electronics & 8% for coins : this part probably won't loss its value.
( I am not an economic expert this was just my POV, 1st line of my comment 😁 )
but one thing I know is one of the major factor deciding value is Supply Demand Chain. By giving it to everyone the demand is slashed by 50%
Gold was fixed as a standard for valuing the total reserves of nations. But the real thing that has to do anything with humans is their standard of living like we saw in the case of killing of elephant in Kerala. The standard of living can have a positive impact on Human Values.
Actually this is a null and idiotic comparison currency gets its value from resources and gold gets its value from scarcity
Yes, definitely make a video on inflation mentioning the effects on inflation because of agricultural subsidies, etc as well
Yes . Right 👍👍
video on inflation is required
Done
One more positive : Crime rates decrease ho sakti hai
just a possibility who knows
Paisa kisko nahi chaiye bro.. Jitna jyada utna kam, 1000rs doge to 10000 ka crime hoga
Crime is something complex man.
It may reduce. But not in a big rate
You are right poverty today pushes people to steal and other related crimes
Yeah
Good Work..
Please make a video on current scenario of USA. I think In India politician play with Hindu-Muslim. And in Foreign politician plays with Black-white and win election by divide and Rule please Give your Comments on these.
Yes @dhruv Give your Comments on these topic or make a video on these
True, will consider :)
@@dhruvrathee I'll wait for that matter
"The HINDU " article covered all these things.. Black -white amiracans
you should make a video on "Inflation".
There is a deep video on the topic "Inflation" on facttechz UA-cam channel
Ya
Ya
@@DJDANISHARHAM99
Kyu mdarse me nahi padhaya jata hai😂😂😂😂😂
@@namanraj4099 Aise bol raha hai jaise school me roz 3 period inflation pe hota hai
During my previous job at an NBFC, at an evening break with my colleagues, I casually asked them what they really wanted to work in/with. There were six of us and not one said it was the current job. Now, I work in a BPO. For me, personally, this scheme if implemented will be a dream come true.
the real question is, are these jobs that nobody wants to work at really required for society, not a lot of people would argue that fast food really adds a lot to our way of life, how many other big employers would fit that bill I wonder? jobs should make society better not just give the owning class more wealth.
"PM CARE FUND" is not under RTI:PMO,,,,, PLEASE make a video
Yes I also just read the news
@@GauravSharma-vn8wt i also read...
Yes
Yes definitely
Definitely 👍
You deserve more than 10 million subscribers ❤️ from 🇧🇩
UBI is been experimented in sikkim since from 2019....its called 1 family one job out here....
Even my elder sister is getting 12000 every month
Which government ruling there
12000 or 1200??
Please Talk about its experience in a Video i am Subscribing amd waiting !!
And i see many negative points of ofoj
especially inflation and laziness among the youth ,
No innovation!
Its 12000
1 person will be entitled to get job out of one family
Its government job not permanent
according to me "GOVERNMENT SHOULD GIVE THIS BASIC INCOME TO THE PEOPLE JUST ONLY AND ONLY DURING THIS LOCKDOWN AND HAZARDIOUS COVID SITUATION SO THAT PEOPLE CAN SUSTAIN THEIR LIVES " AND AFTER SOME MONTHS THEY MUST STOP THIS ....!!!!
YOU ARE AMAZING BHAIYA AAPNE TO MERA ECONOMICS MAI INTEREST BHADA DIYA !!!
MAZA HI AA GAYA YE VIDEOS DEKH KE THANKS BHAIYA FOR SUCH INFORMATION ,.....
They should do it forever
Just watched whole video it's awesome :)
Surrre, 30 seconds after releasing you watched the whole video 😝😝
@@dhruvrathee haha
@@dhruvrathee lol
Yes i think i took too long 🤣
@@dhruvrathee😂😂😂😂😂😂 you are right
I was really scared of having a opinion without knowing the situation and history related just for the sake of speaking....u really helped me pave my mind in right direction
Negetive points way outweigh positive points
But if implemented properly
UBI can revolutionise our lives
Has anything in this country ,properly implemented ever.
UBI ko Bhul Jayeye , Yaha Train Sahi Station Par nahi pahuchi hai ,Paisa kya Pahucega.
Its is a positive point, the implementation is negative due to hesitation of govt to distribute free money.
If you see kejriwal model is closely relatable due to its free provision of services.
Instead of providing Cash directly, services are provided free of cost.
If basic necessities are provided free of cost without any administrative check or compliance check , the result can be optimised as only those people, who are in need, will be taking benefit of such services.
However, purchasing power (cash) is also required to improve the happiness levels and consume those things that provide high amount of utility.
Considering automation will take away jobs, govt should regulate tasks that cannot be automated and should be done manually.
there is no proper way to it, it is inevitably going to be adverserial to the economy because population growth is going to exponentially increase demand and therefore the threshold income would have to be contiguously increased thus causing inflation as a result of more money supply demand...
@@ramitkumar2918 what are your views on providing free facilities rather than free cash?
Also, I personally believe that self reliance is a good measure if government promotes Farming, Animal Farming etc. (Things that are naturally recoccured) unconditional free utilities and necessities required to do Farming instead of cash?
The most commendable thing about sir dhruv rathee's research work is that he presents information on the basis of facts and in an unbiased manner.
And unlike most youtubers who create crap content for the sake of entertainment that is sometimes threatening for the society , dhruv rathee's motive is creating awareness about the socio-economic environment.
And he depicts all of these matters in a layman's language and the simplest form possible. And whenever I have to make myself updated with some recent event or happening I always look up to his youtube channel since it's easier to understand through his words
I think he is making the best use of this platform.
Truly amazing 👏
कांग्रेस लायी थी न्याय, जो यही स्कीम थी। मगर भारत की जनता ने उसे नकार दिया। तोह, इस का भारत मे कोई मतलब नही है। लोगो को चाहिए मज़ा, मौज, जाती , धर्म न कि विकास, पैसा।
kitna paisa pahuchta ye b sawaal h
Bhai ye v toh dekho ki negatives v hai isi chiz ke.toh zaroori nahi ki tumhe positives jyaada affect kare toh wahi majority people ko v kare.
.
.
Aur yahi democracy hai public khud chunti hai aur public apne hisaab se sahi hi chuntti hai
.
.isiliye accept kro aur jab tak 5 saal na ho jaaye apne taraf se pura support do jab tak govt. Sahi hai.
bhimta
@@vinitpathak9789 hr govt 19-20 Hoti h acchi baat h ki Modiji ne conventional politics n ki isliye kuch logo Ko buri lgti h
@@viktiwari18 Aur communal politics ki isliye kuch logon ko acchi lgti hai
मोदी जी ने 2014 में UBI का महाप्रयोग करने की कोशिश की थी लोगों को 15 लाख देने का वादा करके
अभी तक pending में पड़ा है
Ujale mei teer marne ki aadat hai..kbhi nhi milega sir ji ...bol bachchan...modi ji
Neta logon pe agar bharosa karoge toh Sirf cutega, ghanta kuch milega😂
8:21
Yes please make a separate video on Inflation...
I'm very curious to know.
Me too
RBI mei jitna gold rkha hai usse jyda currency chhap di to inflation ho gya. 4% ke andar inflation is kind of okay.
I think the Negative side's arguments are stronger when comes to Practical. Bro, we need video on Inflation Also!
actually, inflation arguement is flimsy. If you tax the rich, and use that money for UBI, the money isnt being printed, it is being redistributed. So inflation wont occur
His opinion is satisfy me everytime❤️
Have your own opinion 😄
But sad part is our beloved PM is always opposite to his opinion.
@@Noone-gz8li He is our beloved supreme leader. Har har modi.
Money change every one's mind...
Everyone I have read a news that
PMCARE FUND IS NOT UNDER RTI
There will be no information available that how many rupees had been or will be donated
RTI- rare toons india😂😂
See,I am not a Bhakt but I can tell you that the donation money received in PM CARES fund was well utilized,moreover the packages were much more time expensive than what was received in the fund.
@@yashchandan1_9 don't lie because I know u are bhakt
@@yashchandan1_9 But you are just hoping that you don't really know it. Besides we have the right to know don't you think.
@Yash Chandan : how do you know so much?!
We actually need people like you in our society, keep it up 👍
UBI could be implemented in our country in short period to Handel the job loss during lockdown.
But in long term, we must think about properly using man power of 1.3B people!
Agreed,
It should implement to jobloss people, specially graduate.
Long term : poor class and graduate people mandatory.
Man Power is an advantage for China India it's a burden
Did u not hear about Automation?
@nornalhuman !! Man automation!!
With such a high population, and such an unemployment Level, we should not promote automation like US or so.
Like..... If a work is done by 50 people, then they get some money, but if a 5 robot comes, it can do the same work. So, the company fires those 50 people, make more profit.
At the end of the day, automation in our country gonna make the rich more reacher and poor more poor.
@@keepexploring8980 There is no way to stop automation... Specially in globalised economy
Dhruv: *Free UBI for all..*
FM: *1000 Ka loan take it or leave it* 😹😹😹
😂😂
Right
True 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😄😄
Bhai mere chainall par dhruv ki deleted vedio hai jaake dekho
I sometimes feel that I waste time just getting Happy by the good and innovative solutions because This government doesn't have enough resources to access good thing (like this) 😪
Definitely we nee a video on how Govt. Can implement @Dhruv Rathee 's videos😂
Correct bro
Bro u know network marketing
@@nirmal1114 i wish :)
This is a terrible idea. No one deserves free money. Our economy is already doing shit. Where will they get more money to support majority poor country. They become a burden to middle class and rich.
@@t-.-t.
Did you forget that our economy is a demand driven economy?
Dhruv Bhai Se Seekho Ki Ad Ko Kaise "Implement" Kare Videos Mein 😂
Yaa ryt
Government giving free money.
Mr beast: *ight imma head out
It cell
"you can love your country without having to love your government." 🇮🇳
George Floyd per video banao
I wish your all community follows this point
India will be great again
Fir employment ke liye govt ko kyu dosh dete ho
@@monumeena4386 unemployment ke lie government ko dosh deta hoon kyuki desh ke logo ne us government ko ye sochke vote kiya tha ki "agar hum isko vote karenge toh ye desh me unemployment kam ya khatam karne ke lie kuch karega"
@@mujahid_saqlaini agar bina govt. Ko love krke country se love kr skte ho to bina govt. Ko love krke employment bhi to kam kr skte ho,. But i can read ur name so its fine.
Dhruv , still waiting for you to become the next Prime Minister of India
😂😂
😆😆😆😆😆😆
Yah explain Achcha karta hai
Mtlb ye nahi pm banega😂
Bhai ise jhuut bolna nahi aata hai.
PM needs to big lier
Wah bc, phir to shashi tharoor angrez hua! Illogical species
Very good analysis and explanation!
Another suggestion: A video on the concept of a so-called “Universal Healthcare” would be exciting!
Dhruv Rathee, pLease make video on Kashmir poverty and economic Loss. Because Lockdown has now compLeted aLmost 10 Months.
Agree dear ❤️❤️❤️
Yes,
*Politicians failed* to eliminate *poverty of India* and they promise to lift our *living standards.*
But nothing good happened for the citizens of *India and Kashmir.*
I hope, they will not blame COVID, this time, for *Kashmir Crisis.*
Agreed
agree
meta khyaal he ki
abou 50 years old ko UBI ka faeda zroor milna chahiye
on dimaabd
Improving employment facilities is still the best way to achieve everything which ubl promises
First we have to bring rhe north eastern states fertility rate down. Thats the need of the hour.
Much 3:22
I would love to watch a video on inflation...
We can think of UBI later
First we can use the money for
01) Making population 100% literate
02) Education 100% free
03) Health 100% free
Regarding UBI, I think Negatives are having more weight and implementing UBi In an economy can be dangerous
hmm true
Negative effect : tiktokers ki jansankhya badh jaayegi
😨😱😱😱😱
😅😅😅😅
well said bhai😂
🤣
Aur laand hilane walo bhi.
Dhruv :- namskar dosto
Me : Ha to kaise ho dosto 😀
👇👇
Shuru krte h bina back@#@ ke 🤣
Bahut tez ho rahe ho😀😀
Chaliayeeee shuru kartee haii👐😂
To keise he ap log
Carry minati ke gaali galoog karne wale fans educational videos dekhne kaise aagaye
Please do a video on inflation.. please.. aap bohot achese explain krte ho.. sare concepts clear hojate h .. I want to get clear view about .. how inflation takes place .. and everything regarding to Inflation
Actually it depends upon the situation and the mentality.
True
Please check my channel. I made a video on corruption.
Please support small UA-camr🙏🙏
Very well explained!
In my opinion I think UBI should be different for different sectors of the society, importance of UBI obviously cannot be overlooked for a poor family .
One more negative point --- log elite pass purchase krne lagenge ..
,😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😃😃
😂😂😂👀
👅
In that way all money would go to china
70% logo ke pas phone nhi hai pubg khelne ke liye na hi time hai. Sirf middle class khelti hai pubg. Baaki majority of population working class hai jo 12 ghante kaam krke sirf 200p-3000 rupaye mahina kamate hai. Poverty line ke below hai
Bhai bhai bhai 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sabse phele me purchase karuga 😂😂
मुझे लगता है कि एक बार स्कीम को पैलेट प्रोजेक्ट के तहत चलना चाहिये परिणाम को देखे
और इन्सान महत्वाकांक्षी होता है और उसकी इच्छाएँ निरंतर बनी रहती है ग़रीब मध्यम वर्ग बनने की कोशिश करेगा और मध्यम वर्ग धनी वर्ग की कोशिश श्रेणी में जाएगा यही तो मैं वाले भारत में अधिक है मुझे लगता है स्कीम चलानी चाहिए।
Demerits are more accurate.. Giving money can never make someone Live (long term)..
Interviewer- What z ur Hobby.?
Me- searching Job..
😐🤨
Join in Kashmir stone pelting
Join in gau rakshak dal to lynch people.
@@nrr9960 lynching people force them to say jai sri ram.
@@tarasmarndi6347 this job market has almost collapsed.
@@nrr9960 or bjp it cell
तुम सब लोग अब सोच रहे हो मोदी जी ने तो 6 साल पहले ही 15 - 15 लाख रूपए देने को बोल दिया था 😂😂😂😂😂
Negetive impact jayada hoga
It is not about modi and all..ye subse upr thik krna chaiye..gov is more than bjp and congree
मेरे चैनल को Sabscribe करो i have dhruv's deleted videos.
hahahah
Hahahaha Modi hai to mumkin hai .
Yeah to jumla tha
I agree with UBI that if everything becomes expensive so UBI should also increase .
Positive sides are more strong , but it's good for small country
Dhruv Rathee Why can't u make a video about "how to overthrow dictatorship from power'
Y....... don't we need 3000cr statue ?? .....
@UCN0tzLLEVNHg8LOTZKHQpXg kis lovde ki baat kar Raha tu
@@aarzu8683 modi...modi...modi....modi....modi....modi
🚩🚩🚩
If there was a universal answer to this question then there'd be no dictatorship present today. There is so specific set of rules for doing that. What people do to overthrow dictatorship depends on the conditions in their region!
@@gagan_sikhi hmm mmm🙈🙉🙊
all the positives are for short term.
When everyone gets UBI then initially they may feel motivated but in the longer run they will become lazy.
These types of schemes will not work for a longer time period.
Negative side is right .........UBI should only be Implimented in super advanced nd Developed Countries
Negative are more powerful than positive
Dhruv capabilities will cross 10millions soon...
@Pichkalu Pappita Peak🤣🤣,
He has long way to go. There will always be controversial issues in Indian politics and he can always make videos on those topics.
I cannot believe modi tung
@Pichkalu PappitaI am watching him for 2yrs now.
2yrs back this guy was gaining 10k subs/month and had 70k subs in total(July 2017). But this guy is adding 300k subs every months now, and thats going to increase by time. He will reach 4M probably next month.
By this rate he will double his subscribers before 2022. Can't say for 10M, those are too far in time.
Druv: UBI
Nirmala tai: mere syllabus me nhin tha
😂😂😂👌
Best comment i read so far 👌👌👌
*le nirmala tai -maine to aaj hi suna
m pyaz nhi khati g
Ha that was funny
Bro inflation par video bnao
Or pm care fund ki detail par
Kaha spend hua dono par video bnao
Kharcha election me hoga Mla khareedne ke liye
Pm care fund is out of RTI... So no one can get its details....
@Viewer just viewer CAA + NRC = Kick out Islam from india 😘
@Viewer just viewer han ae to suruat h
@@ashaharika9565 Freedom of Information Act 2002 revised and renamed as Right of Information Act 2005 (RTI) - meant for gaining informations on public authority or authorities.. Interesting to know people R aware - but will be more interesting - if people know PM Care Funds is “ *public* *authority* “ as top 4 authority holders - Minister of Home Affairs, Minster of Defence, Minister of Finance & Prime Minister are T trustees.. So directly its a public authority technically as per RTI.. Now Govt claims its not a public authority - straight outta corruption
when Elon musk says something
it becomes concrete..
his prediction is of another level
Of course
Negative points are really logical. But Rahul Gandhi's idea was logical.
U re right 👍👍
it wasn't brother, because as Dhruv Rathee said how do you justify the bracket of 20-30% poor ? How do you define poverty ? A better way would've been an income to all economic groups but in a way that poor get more while the rich get less.... maybe the lower class get 2000 pm, middle class get 1000 pm and rich get 500 pm.... for the rich class it could be an option... I think this would've worked out in India really well...
@@akshitmitra6598 it can possible by proper implementation of government everything is possible if it can done by planning and honesty
That thumbnail with old 1000 note,lmao😂. Miss those good old days...
🤓🤓
दोस्तों Dhruv की एक वीडियो मेरे चैनल पर है, वह वीडियो ध्रुव के चैनल से हटा दी गयी है। कहीं मेरे भी चैनल से न हट जाए, जाओ जल्दी जाके देखो।
UBI का दोनो पक्ष अच्छा भी है और बुरा भी। भारत मे वर्तमान की परिस्तिथियों को देखते हुए मजदूरों को देना चाहिए वो भी कोरोना के खत्म होने तक।
I think the side is tilted towards the negative side
But in my opinion the money should be distributed to those who really need it
For example : for those people who can’t even afford buying food for their livelihood
A good implementation of UBI towards the poor people can help everyone.
This is my opinion and I think this is a debatable topic.
Thank you
This topic can be a good "Jumla" for 2024 election, like 2014 "Jumla" of 15lakh.
Sahi bole ho bhai
BJP campaigned about Universal Basic Income but they didn't know the exact term for it
Please check my channel. I made a video on corruption.
Please support small UA-camr🙏🙏
Tell Me Where Rs 15 Lakh Is Mentioned In Electoral Mandate Of BJP 2014
Show proof modi said it.... Idiots.
Negatives are more strong especially in our country, India. People are very lazy here and our country will not be prosperous anymore.
Jo job krega use hi milna chahiye UBI jo khali rhega use nhi milni chahiye
News jobs will arise..dont be neomania
Yes please make a video on inflation.
Edited: 'in' to 'on'
I usually have a hard time understanding Hindi, but your videos are worth watching. Much love from Kerala.
Dear Dhruv, leave aside UBI just hope that they dont take away more money from us.that will be more than enough.
For that the bureaucracy should be strengthened in such a way that the Rich elites pay taxes more sincerely. When RBI will have more money then they could spend it on public sectors
India me Bina automation k hi itni unemployment h , automation k bad to satyanash ho Jayega
kaisa?????? in bhao style...🤣
@Kavish Chandra well in the long run technology is almost always cheaper than manual labor including better quality and reliability and repeatability
Yeah UBI is great but it will take time here in India. For now let's save our jobs first - I informed my team that I'm doing MBA from upGrad - they too are now giving me more responsibilities. Which makes me feel secure in terms of job.
Yes, does an MBA actually help? Isn't it just a fad. I'm just in college I'm not sure.
haha, wait till you start working in a corporate bro - MBAs are treated like 'son in law'.
Hi Salman, we are glad that we were able to help you upskill. All the best for your future. In case you need any assistance, just call us on the number 08066084582
@@upGrad_edu what are the career options after bsc in mathematics/msc in mathematics ..
@@a-samadkhan5778 Hi Samad, our career experts can guide you better and suggest career prospects for you, so please call the number 08066084582 for guidance.
Dhruv sir, india me Ubi ki jarurat hai mujhe negative effects dekh ke lagta hai ki sirf most poverty wale indians ko milna chahiye 👍👍
This video should be on trending page
Who agrees
We should share the video for that and leave a like and comment!
Hi Dhruv, request you to please make a video on USA's current situation.
Yes
yes, please.
Yes
Yes
ACAB
Now I don't need to watch news anymore, dhruv's video is Enough to understand the current situation.
Keep it up👍👍👍👍
Chal be ye sirf BJP ki burai karta hai. Kabhi unke kisi ache kam ko appreciate nahi karta
@@kaydendoesntbreak bhakt ji aa gye, welcome sir, yaha aapko thoda ajeeb lag raha hoga kyuki sab logical baat karrahe hai, koi baat nahi aap seekh jaoge maybe later.
@@kaydendoesntbreak lol isme kaunsi bjp ki burai hai,mai dhruv 50 percent video dhikadunga jisme usne doosri countries,saaf safai ,development ki baat kari hai
Andhbakht soch raha hai yeh kya keh raha hai😂
@@sahilsani123 exactly bhai!!!
For carry fan I recommend you watched Dhurve all video,
Your intelligence level go high
Me too saying this
No i dont want to be anti-national like dhruv
@@rohiniswami6602 🤣🤣🤣🙏
@@rohiniswami6602 are bhai😝
u think all carry fans are stupid?
Please make a video on George Floyd's death and riots in USA 🇺🇸...
Yess
He will surely make it wait
Yes
Yes
Yes
Modi ji : Aatmnirbhar bano
UBI : hold my 1000 rs 😀😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣
Dosto mere chainall KO sabsribe Karo.
@@FANTASTIC01 Kehna kya chahte ho?
@@parthasarathimandal3602 thoda dimaag lagao
But I think we should start ubi with giving to farmers as they can become a independent
that's the point u are not understanding about UBI. it isn't UBI if it's Given to select people only like farmers, poor people etc giving it everyone is the point it's like a service which the government provides to its people like roads which are made by the government and any Citizen can use them.
@@namangoyal3734 yes....
bhai log poor logo ko rakhte he kam karne k liye aur kisan k name par fayda vo lete h
aur itna to de rahe he.. koi farming ki chiz me subsity.. 2000 aate h 3 month me... sab kuch to unko nahi de sakte na
1000 rupees per month doesn't make you independent abhinav shandilya
The way you explained is really amazing 🔥👏🏻