Binaural Audio - Winter, Vivaldi, The Four Seasons (H)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 січ 2013
- This movie was recorded on December 14, 2012 in Evanston, Illinois, at the Unitarian Church of Evanston. Select members of the Fifth House Ensemble performed for this production: Herine Coetzee Koschak - Cello, Eric Snoza -- Double Bass, Andrew Williams -Violin, and Clark Carruth-Viola
ImmersAV Technology is a new 3D audio / video production format that combines patented point-of-view Binaural Audio recording with High Definition video recording. The result is a truly immersive experience based on the synergy of sight and sound. Playback of this production requires headphones for optimum spatial audio reproduction. This production is also available in a format for "stereo-speaker" loudspeaker listening capable of creating a similar spatial experience to headphone listening.
Comments are welcomed via You Tube Comments and E-mail to:
Robert Schulein at schulein@ameritech.net
Contact The Fifth House Ensemble at: fifth-house.com
![If you can't hear this then you're not an audiophile [See description for link to followup video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/48PxwspDvrE/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm 8 years late to the party... Schiit Modius+Magnius on a Audeze LCD-X.
This sounds absolutely amazing. Someone coughed during the recording and I thought it was my kid behind me. He wasn't in the room. This is outstanding.
i looked around too when i heard that cough xD amazing
After all, it's the audience coughs that we buy the expensive gear for, right?
fellow LCD-X user ;)
Ahh audiophiles
Fiio K5 PRO + Hifiman Sundara here and it sounds heavenly good!
binaural recording+classic=perfection. this channel is criminally underrated.
Moondrop Blessing 2 has busted right on my ears and I love it.
Finally some (real) music; was getting bored of the 8hr-long relaxation sleeping chill out background music popping up all over the "tube"....
Well recorded, pretty low background noise, thx !
Good that you enjoyed it. Thanks for the positive comments
Those recordings make googling for the good stuff difficult.
Superb performance. If you want a laugh when I first started listening to this I forgot I had the speed set on 1.25 instead of normal and I could not figure out why they rushing this piece, but oh my god that 1st violinist is fast. Then it dawned on me, check your speed dimwit. What a difference. :) This recording does make you feel you are right there.
Excellent, its like sitting in front of them. All soundstage is available. Not only for width but also for depth. And im only using Sennheiser PX100 and Xonar ST.
I listened through Sennheiser's amazing HD598's and can say that the recording and performance were fantastic. Great job capturing the room.
I have the same ones, those engineers really did a nice job making it sound natural for voice, etc. didn't they? The common complaint is that they lack bass, but not with a good home receiver. It's just that people are used to exaggerated bass. I've been to live performance all my life and I love these phones.
Same headphones here. A great match for this video.
Listening on bose quiet comfort 2's :)
Sounds wonderful on my fiio
Q5 amp and Hifiman 4xx’s.
@@bdavis7981 using an amp, or in your case, home receive to power the 598's really helps with the balance of the bass. the warmth of voices are a great detail of these phonese!
sounds great on my 5 bucks knock off headphones. 10/10
Beautifully performed. I felt every note
Beautiful.Thank you.
Wow!!! That gave me waves of chills while listening. Beautiful!!
Beautiful recording and upload. Thank you! I'm listening with Beyerdynamic DT 770 Pro and it sounds flawless.
Hi George. Thanks for the positive comments. I believe that you have made an excellent choice in headphones.
Best regards,
Bob Schulein
Imagine being able to play like this. Insane.
Wow, amazing! Thank you!
1:53 lmaoo the off note had me cracking up
Amazing!! Thank so much to bring this treasure for us.
Viola slayed and the Double Bass just sliiidddeeess in there. So good.
very good!!!! relaxing, great for insomnia and anxiety!
Thank you. Stumbling upon this recording at 12:45 was a late balm I needed after hearing political news. Music is one of the greatest human expressions!
As if i was *THERE* ... awesome performance and the hall acoustic did the justice
Merci !!
Meravigliosi, bravissimi.
I’m just watching and relaxing this during the pandemic on AirPods Pro and is amazing, I really enjoy it, so beautiful. Someone else during the pandemic?
With good guality beyerdynamic headphones this makes me want to listen live acoustic classic music, even I'm not into this kind of music :I
sound like you are ;) Go see some live and chances are it will be enjoyable
Que som magnífico belo belo !! 😮🇧🇷
Wow! Got a ticklish feeling on my head with the violin sound.
i listened with my studio beats 3 and it was phenomenal.very good soundstage
That violinist is changing things.
What do u mean
@@oscarwattsoboe he’s not playing original notes
@@AceDeclan oh I see
yes, but he is fire and this is art.
Yeah my left ear really enjoyed this
Was there a problem with your right ear?
Robert Schulein - Binaural AV Recordings No i'm sorry my headphone volume wasn't balanced but i fixed it now. Great video
Listening with Audeze Maxwell. Thank you for this beautiful Upload!
Nice. Any sound to the rear really sounds like it's from the rear. The right phones help. Sennheiser HD598 specialize in natural sound with special sound channels at a particular angle for naturalness. Perfect for quartets.
Amazing performance!
Tried these on my new open back headphones, feels like I'm in the room with them lol
Beautiful music. Beautiful performance. Beautiful sound. Beautiful video. What more can you ask!!??
I love my kbear ks1 iems. Amazing songs
Awesome. Listening on audio-technica ath m30x
This sounds so cool
Dillan,
Thank you very much for your positive comment. Did you can also know that this program can be listened to in binaural using conventional stereo loudspeakers. Please see: ua-cam.com/video/bNsnyYMpuHY/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/Lx7IMz5rH4g/v-deo.html
Best regards
Bob Schulein
Amei! Perfeito!
Bravo 👏🏽
WOW !!! on the fidelio X2, True to life ............
Stereo sucks! This is Real music!!! Thank you!
😍 respect from Brazil, favela's
great
Very Impressive recording. I'm using AKG Q701 with proper gears. The noise performance is perfect. Distortion perfect. If I have to nitpick, I think I can hear 60hz or 120hz hum and very tiny hiss when it's quite, the hum is louder, But the hiss and hum doesn't cover the weakest music signal at all, so excellent dynamic range. I think the low rolls off a bit too much, sounds a bit weaker. and since Q701 is big headset, so the image isn't as precious as in-ear headphone, especially hard to tell the position of the cello player. and overall image is very left heavy, but all of the above aren't important at all, I have to focus very hard to find flaws.
I think it might be bcs of the position of the head, or the room, or it's the youtube compression. But I really love your recording, it feels like I'm in concert hall on my expensive first row VIP seat. Also the sound stage is very wide and relaxing to listen to , that's why I revisit your videos.
Thankx again for your excellent recording.
hi! can you tell me what is best to hear binaural musicl, in-ear headphone or circunaural?
In-ear headphone will be the best.
tried both at same time. On ear has better far more details, using sol republic hd 2
Thank you for your comments
Frank the binaural microphone
That's really professional comment, I know about amp, but not much about recording.Let me try another 10 times to listen to this song with your suggestion :)
What I love the most is the coughing sounds, which makes me wants to turn around. I've share this video link in diy headphone forum, so they can know what they're missing from normal listening experience.
Does anyone know the name of the piece at the very beginning of the video?
Podoba mi się
you know what I'd love to hear in binaural audio? Carnival of Animals.
Wow!
Hey John, Thanks for the positive comment and subscribing to the ImmersAV technology channel.
Is this 100% true binaural audio or is it from some sort of processing to try and mimick /convert to binaural audio? I'm asking because sometimes it sounds like true binaural audio but sometimes it doesn't.
I could be very wrong but the "dummy" head in front is probably housing microphones in its ears giving a right to left panning.
SpookyAL that’s certainly likely.
Die Perücke gehört ja wirklich dem Kunstkopf.
1990 pro / G109 / Focusrite
Thank you. Very nice recording.
Du hast Recht.
I fail to see why this is a good demonstration of binaural audio advantages. Using ORTF, you would get just as good precise location and spread for this ensemble. Yes, the omnidirectional mics would pick up more back ambience of the venue, but often that is not an advantage. Here the hall does sound good, and the mics sound like they have good qualities, so I am not saying this is a bad recording. I use binaural audio for ambient sounds for video, where sounds come all around the listener and are all important Unlike in this example, and give a good sense of place.
Me & my Stax like this. :)
Anyone catch that cough at 2:51? Lmao
that was the cherry of the experience
How to know if your stereo headphones work with class and elegance
Fantastic!!! Thank you for this great moment! Is there any CD of this performance?
No CD for sale, however did you know you can download this file from UA-cam. Use MacX UA-cam Downloader
Can I download an uncompressed version of the audio anywhere?
@@jacobsteingart457 They are literally allowing you to download it for free, so be greatful.
❤🧡💛💚💙💜
❤🧡💛💚💙💜
❤🧡💛💚💙💜
what is that (L) and (H) versions? there are two versions uploaded
H for headphones, which is this video. S for stereo speakers as mentioned in the description.
☀️⭐✨
It’s a shame that the audio and camera recordings do not line up. You hear to much on the left for the camera position due to the binaural microphones being to the right.
does surround sound work?
Great video and audio.
I'm using a AKG 712Pro with a LGv20.
Thank you Jeremiah for your complements. Your choice of headphones is a good one. Enjoy!
Sounds flat. I have reasonably decent headphones, Sennheiser HD599, seems the problem is the microphone used in the recording rather than my heaphones. I can hear the space in the soundstage, you can separate the instruments no problem, but the individual instruments are not recorded well.
They are well recorded. HD599 isn't that neutral.
@@lopezalemanaxelariel7480 I have enough experience of going to classical concerts to know when a recording is getting close to the experience of being there, unfortunately, this is not it.
@@RussellChapman99 Yeah, I have too. It all depends on the headphones cause if you're gonna listen to binaural recordings you need a really neutral, either diffuse field or close to Harman headphones to really recreate the sound waves they way it's intended. HD 599 have high bass, low mids that are too aggressive so it masks details and doesn't sound "natural" also they have a peak at 9/10k that makes everything sound overly sharp and unnatural. I say this cause I tried them by myself before.
@@lopezalemanaxelariel7480 I was discussing this with a friend who is fairly high up at Chandos Records. In the last few days, we went into the recording studio, somewhere in deepest Essex, a county in England and did some sound tests on this recording and came to the conclusion, it is nothing special.
Actually I don't think it's the recording or your headphones. I'm going to say this is performance practice. I've actually given many hundreds of hours of classical music performance as a double bass player. Because Vivaldi is a Renaissance composer, many who play the bass and cello understand that they're not playing on instruments that were built in the same way as the instruments Vivaldi wrote for. Modern instruments are a lot louder and a lot easier to play with small nuance in volume. Consequently many performers when playing Renaissance music will make a conscious effort to mimic those older instruments. Even people who play period instruments need to change their play style because certain materials have been completely replaced and are no longer easily acquired. Believe it or not if you set up a farm to harvest cat gut, you're going to get a lot of push back from the public. Even the bows themselves are made of pernambuco a new world wood unavailable to Vivaldi and his contemporaries.
All that being said, that is in no way a universal approach. Perhaps even the majority would say let's let's take advantage of several hundred years of technological improvement to generate a sound that is better in tone and quality. And a lot of us make that decision because we know that many people in the public will hear this inferior sound and say to themselves that didn't sound as nice as my headphones so live music isn't worth the trouble.
And finally I'm not trying to sound like I'm throwing shade, but this is not the single greatest performance of Vivaldi to ever be captured on tape. I'm not attacking the musicianship but I am saying these are artists doing a job. And when the job is in the recording studio or at a famous music hall, it's a lot different than when it's in a church. and when you're playing for a bunch of blue hairs who you know can't hear you because they're hearing aids are going off you don't have the same zeal and energy. I'm sure your job has some great days and some bad days, well if you're a performer and try to make the bad days and the small insignificant gigs.
No sé por qué me dieron ganas de toser a la mitad del invierno.
Delicious. Is it possible to download the audio? Pleaaasseeee :):):)
Yes you can download bothe the audio and video from this movie using MacX UA-cam Downloader
Thank you! :)
バイノーラルで聴くと新鮮だ。
1:52 what is that sound?
Hi Sus,
Could you please describe the sound that you hear? Is it non musical? Do you hear it every time you play the video?
Yes, I think is a mistake of the cello more than a "sound" in the record. Because it sound that someone put the bow in a wrong place. It sound like an harmonic that doesn't exist in the real piece.
It was a sharp note on the cello.
man that sneeze at 2:13 sounded very realistic
It was sooooo real my brain didn't even register it the 1st time
Using a set of AKG HD25's here - everything is nice and tight, although perhaps a tad compressed - the strong light and shade of this composition has been lost to a degree. Has any post-compression (or in-recording compression for that matter) been added? The spatial reproduction is just superb - just like being there. SO much so that I think I would rather listen to (Classical at least) music in this manner over standard recordings any day. If I was to nitpick I'd say that the instruments perhaps feel a little "low", like I'm sitting on a balcony a little above them - I can see from the video that the audience is raised slightly, so this may in fact be accurate! But it's a little odd in isolation of the video.
Hi Aidan,
Thank you for your detailed comments. We did not add any compression to the original digital audio recording. I also do not believe that such is added by UA-cam as a result of the uploading process.
Better for Sleep salam Indonesian people
hardware is nothing without a great software. i am listening to my affordable beyer dynamic DTX501p. won't break your bank. try it..
2:27 did someone just "cof cof" in my left ear?
The applauses at wrong time is pretty annoying!
I disagree. I think the applauses were timed quite well, or am I missing something?
@@peter-andrepliassov4489 No applause between movements.
@@simurg754 I've always disagreed with that rule. Personally, I always welcome applauses between movements.
Why is there a hairdresser dummy in front of the camera?
Microphone
01:54
Wow Amazing on My self Made Speakers. (4 ways and +1/-2 dB on 28 to 25Khz ) And they have so fcking Big Dynamik Range I scared At high levels peaks.
C'est beau mais j'aurais aimé les micros plus loin pour avoir plus d'effet binaural de distance. A moins que mon oreillene soit pas normale et l'analyse de mon cerveau pas comme le commun des mortels... Difficile de résumer en une oreille commune.
Quel niais, j'avais écouté avec un casque circum aural 😅 Ca fonctionne beaucoup mieux avec un bon casque intra !
awesome recording but the people coughing and suckin boogers up into their noses is so distracting lmao!
Smoky Mcdope420 it is my experience that live classical performances always require at least one “cougher”
@@gbaines4284 they should be fucking hung
AirPods 2 100/10
2:13 Who coughed ? it ruins the song... And whats with the mannequin in front of the camera?
the mannequin is used for the binaural recording, you can google by yourself how its done
Ha! I was in the library, headphones on, and I heard the cough and immediately turned and looked at the person sitting next to me.
It felt so real. I'm glad they coughed because it shows you just how much every detail enhances your experience.
I believe that's Mortimer Snerd. Mr Snerd loves classical music.
Don't be so sensitive. It was a cough that didn't affect anything.
Daniel Soares she coughed once and another series of cough. Still not ruining. But if I was her, I would hold my breath
heard someone cough...
I would like Rock gigs to be recorded with binaural dummy head, but the problem is it can't be placed in the audience, because it would be smashed into pieces. ;D
Someone was coughing in the recording
sunrainism that’s just part of the orchestra concert experience
It is mandatory to have a cougher at classical musical performances.
G Baines Indeed, I sometimes wonder if certain people think “I’ve got an irritating cough, I must find a concert to go to.”
To listen to the solo violin is a torture (( 'Cmon, man, make som practice
I'm sorry, but the lead violin was... fairly out of tune/sloppy on any of the complicated section. Overall, the binaural aspect is VERY well done
Что за гомосеки там кашляют слева постоянно?