This is Zhou Enlai just before the start of the Nanchang uprising in the 1st of August 1927 which was the first battle of the Chinese Civil War after the massacre of communists in Shanghai by forces loyal to Chiang Kai-shek. The scene is from the movie Axis of War: The First of August.
@@quakeknight9680 Communism is always full of idealism at the beginning, but after the establishment of a regime, it often tends to become bureaucratic. Then there is the beginning of totalitarian corruption.
Imagine losing a whole bunch of your comrades to your enemy's bloodlust, only to be greeted with this song. To say that it would inspire and radicalise me is an understatement.
I love that his reaction to what happened isn’t doubt, or fear, but resolve. He know what he has to do for his dead comrades. He knows what he has to do for his nation. Most importantly, when he goes outside, he sees he’s not alone.
@@indo-comrade1181 Well it's neither very bad nor good... It's actually somehow has become an emotional movie more than a political movie.... Here is shown the CPC uprising countering the Shanghai massacre... And how common soldiers have died leaving their fiance behind them... Yeah and the pre war situation was actually political i.e how the relations between the Ku-ming-tang party and communists.
If you ask me, it all depends on the key and composition. Sing it too high, and it sounds too soft, especially in English. Then again, that may just be because English is my default, and therefore sounds mundane to me. That all being said, you're missing out if you don't give the Spanish version its due praise.
This is the most powerful Chinese version and the only most powerful version I have heard in my entire life actually, instead of both the Hungarian and Russian ones... Really represents the left's struggle huh
The left is deemed evil by the right because the leaders were dictators. What they don't tell you is left wing revolutions lead to dictators because right wing governments try to crush them and they are forced to centralize power.
Current communism is bastardized. old communism was about getting rid of tyranny and actually did something about it. But both sides are just chess pieces of the elite.
In order to consolidate his control over the army, Chiang Kai-shek focused on internal fighting and crowded out the talented and powerful officers in the army. This was his failure.
My heart boils when i see working class suffer For the profits of few Let the words become action Lets rise up and retrieve what's ours Lets bring a oneness in world order ☭☭☭
The scene shows the establishment of People's Liberation Army and the start of the Chinese civil war in 1927. The civil war stopped In 1937 due to the Japanese invasion, then resumed in 1945 after the Japanese surrendered. The civil war has not ended officially till today.
@Nufu Thank you very much. Unfortunately,there is no political party in present Japan that aims for true equality. It is difficult to figure out where and what our comrades with a common will to achieve true equality are doing.
@@aonamayorom1529 China and Vietnam arenot communist, they are authoritarian capitalist states. If you say something bad about powerful private corporations like Vingroup or Alibaba, you would be asked by police or being jailed. That's fact.
@@cudanmang_theog Corporations are controlled by the state and Party. The CPC and CPV can crush these petty corporations at will to build new ones for the people.
@@cudanmang_theog You know nothing about China, I know you Viets hate China so you won't face the truth, making rumors will not change the fact, we Chinese won't get arrest for saying bad about any company, be a honest person, don't come out to lose your country's face.
Urby www.google.co.kr/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2019/01/14/china-is-losing-the-trade-war-in-nearly-every-way/amp/ well come on Every country hate you guys except North Korea 😂😂😂 think what you did in south chinese sea, you guys steal. Air pollution in Korea and Japan, you guys send it. Always steal the idea or technology of western countries. You always say 大國 but what you guys really do is just bully 😂😂😂 that is why people call chinese cockroach
@@idrislamont1064 just like every other countries, free medical care, free education, lower house price, lower living cost, more work opportunities, let people living in a safe environment ect
Red salute to and solidarity with the Chinese comrades, from India. Thank you for the wonderful ideology of Maoism. Naxalite movement is still strong in India.
I discovered this video in Spring 2017, loved it and watched it frequently, and I am just now realizing I had not liked it. Good thing I fixed that, it is inspiring.
Really...We all communists will love china... I am from India.... But communist party is strong in India... I want to see India to be a communist country...
@Crabman Coconut I know right. Ridiculous!!! America is only democratic country in the world no one knows democracy better than them. Long live the American sauger daddies
Самое интересное здесь в том, что националисты Чан Кайши повязали себе красные галстучки и зазвучала бессмертная музыка Дегейтера!) Неплохая информационная война континентального Китая против Тайваня!
В тот период это были очень близкие партии, особенно левое крыло гоминьдана ("революционной партии") - по полной аналогии с эсерами (левыми и правыми). Одним из трёх принципов основателя Сунь Ятсена (значит и гоминьдана) был социализм. Но в тот же период КПК входил в состав Гоминьдана в целом и военного училища в Наньчане в качестве особой партии - форма и знамёна были единые, а партии разные (как махновцы в своё время в составе Красной Армии). Раскол будет чуть позже.
Please not that e-n-l-g-i-s-h is a misspelling of "English". Are you a native Chinese speaker? I’m not going to judge you, because you can be a translator. Even if you may not be paid money, you can translate a lot of videos to keep the science message going. Martymer81 is a great example of this. Martymer81 is a Swedish UA-camr that fights against pseudoscience, particularly Christian apologeitcs and New Age woo. By translating his videos, you can ensure that only REAL science must be respected at all times.
It's kind of strange...... China used to be very "communist", but now, the kids don't even know what is Internationale, who is Marx, who is Lenin......
+Marlon Barbosa Yes they do have politic class in school but it is not relate to communism. I can promise that 99/100 Chinese never read communist books like
Eric Huang After all Mao fucked up , the Chinese leaders were forced to adopt capitalism , so to recover the society. Now , in my homeland China , what communism remains is the one party dictatorship 'communist party' which owns the 99% of the people. Communism is a great ideology, we human just fucked it up. Ants and robots may work it out.
wait a second these soldiers are clearly side with communist but why their hat have a kuomintang sun which is the opposite with communist and enemy at the same time?
+thi tran communist and kuomintang were fighting together against the old government. but the old leader of kuomintang dead, the new leader start massacre communist. this is the time communist start fight back
+thi tran the Chinese Red Army was formed out of defected members of the National Revolutionary Army, the military arm of the KMT. This is right after the Nanchang Uprising, which is the formation of the CCP, so they didn't have uniforms yet. So that's why they use the red scarves
No, at the moment of Nanchang uprising, the CCP had not begun to consider the KMT as enemy. At that time the CCP hoped that the left-wing of KMT will continue the cooperation with CCP and what they were against were only the fraction of the KMT who were anti-communist. Therefore it is more than normal that they kept the KMT symbol at that time.
+zhenyu wu the Nanchang uprising started the war between the CCP and KMT. The CCP helped the KMT in the Northern expedition in the First united front, but the Nanchang uprising showed Chiang was unwilling to deal with dissent.
+zhenyu wu because of the First United Front is why I think they use KMT uniforms. In both United fronts, the CCP fought under the flag and standards of the republic of china
Hmmm, i want to know if Karl Marx watch this song, he will be proud because its turns out that many countries in this earth that ideologies Communism. And Lenin, not much that i can say, but he was the most famous Communist people of Uni Soviet, But Mao Zedong, China, will not stand strong like a rock without him and his idoology, Communism!
![[Eng sub] The Internationale/Интернационал](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EOAt6sPlzaI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Eng sub] The Internationale/Интернационал](/img/tr.png)
This is Zhou Enlai just before the start of the Nanchang uprising in the 1st of August 1927 which was the first battle of the Chinese Civil War after the massacre of communists in Shanghai by forces loyal to Chiang Kai-shek. The scene is from the movie Axis of War: The First of August.
Thanks
Chiang Kai Shek was a good man
He was a good man my ass.
thank you
@@Admiral2Kolchak he is a punk(literally)
0% drugs
0% flex
100% sparking global proliteriat revolution
I HOPE SOON
@@quakeknight9680 Communism is always full of idealism at the beginning, but after the establishment of a regime, it often tends to become bureaucratic. Then there is the beginning of totalitarian corruption.
What Trotsky said about Stalin
Long live Chairman Mao!
@@ericlai1659 first, it's not communism because communism is stateless society. second, that's why all people need to understand marxism.
Zhou enlai is an inspirational man! China's rise is so inspirational , love from your neighbour India
在未来不分中印，我们都是朋友，我们不必在某些势力的影响下针锋相对，我们的孩子不会再问，妈妈为什么那个孩子是黄皮肤，黑皮肤或者白皮肤。
I am from your homeland bro.. Raised for the "Inkilab-e-Mazdur'
@@user-yn9pq1wv9g I love China red sute from indua
Thank you,comrade
RED SALUTE FROM KOLKATA INDIA
Imagine losing a whole bunch of your comrades to your enemy's bloodlust, only to be greeted with this song. To say that it would inspire and radicalise me is an understatement.
I love that his reaction to what happened isn’t doubt, or fear, but resolve. He know what he has to do for his dead comrades. He knows what he has to do for his nation. Most importantly, when he goes outside, he sees he’s not alone.
Tiananmen Square Massacre 1989
@@yap5995 That was a protest against market reforms. Thanks for proving my point.
@@yap5995 Shanghai Massacre 1927
I can't imagine romanticising political inspired violence.
Mantap perjuangannya Zhou Enlai dalam menegakkan keadilan, kebenaran,dan berani mengambil keputusan yang bijaksana
Fun Fact:
Zhou Enlai Pernah Ke Bandung
@@ONA_Waifunya_Yui-Chan ya iya dong saat ke konferensi asia afrika tahun 1955
THE NAME OF THAT OUTSTANDING MOVIE IS: "Axis of War: the First of August"
I already have watched this.... Thanks for that information...
@@souhardyaadhikari7822 how is that movie ?
@@indo-comrade1181 Well it's neither very bad nor good... It's actually somehow has become an emotional movie more than a political movie.... Here is shown the CPC uprising countering the Shanghai massacre... And how common soldiers have died leaving their fiance behind them... Yeah and the pre war situation was actually political i.e how the relations between the Ku-ming-tang party and communists.
One of the best versions of the Internationale hands down
There are three best renditions of Internationale. Russian, German and this one.
Mongolian or urdu
It's best in All languages
Equally
If you ask me, it all depends on the key and composition. Sing it too high, and it sounds too soft, especially in English. Then again, that may just be because English is my default, and therefore sounds mundane to me.
That all being said, you're missing out if you don't give the Spanish version its due praise.
I like the original french one tbh
This is the most powerful Chinese version and the only most powerful version I have heard in my entire life actually, instead of both the Hungarian and Russian ones...
Really represents the left's struggle huh
The left is deemed evil by the right because the leaders were dictators. What they don't tell you is left wing revolutions lead to dictators because right wing governments try to crush them and they are forced to centralize power.
Current communism is bastardized. old communism was about getting rid of tyranny and actually did something about it. But both sides are just chess pieces of the elite.
One of the Greatest versions of the Internationale I have heard to date
Some members of the Kuomintang were communists as the KMT was split into a nationalist lef right faction with the communists on the left.
At the time almost all the chinese communists were loyal KMT members. It was chiangs paranoia that ruined chinese unity
That explains the KMT sun on communist headgear.
The Revolutionary Committee of the Chinese Kuomintang (Left Kuomintang) still exists a part of the Chinese United Front in the PRC.
CPC was from the Left Side of the KMT until Chiang started the leftist purge during the White Terror in Shanghai.
KMT left is different from CCP. KMT leftists were led by Wang Jingwei who later became a traitor.
In order to consolidate his control over the army, Chiang Kai-shek focused on internal fighting and crowded out the talented and powerful officers in the army. This was his failure.
1 August 1927 - one of the most important days in our history!
Pla official birthday.
My heart boils when i see working class suffer
For the profits of few
Let the words become action
Lets rise up and retrieve what's ours
Lets bring a oneness in world order
☭☭☭
Respect from Russia our Chinese comrades!
Mao was the personality, but Zhou was the man who made things happen
Mao was also the one who almost fucked it all up. While his former allies were left cleaning up his mess.
Bra talking out his ass
The scene shows the establishment of People's Liberation Army and the start of the Chinese civil war in 1927. The civil war stopped In 1937 due to the Japanese invasion, then resumed in 1945 after the Japanese surrendered. The civil war has not ended officially till today.
Goosebumps!!!!!
☭☭☭☭☭☭
This is Great revolution of the strongest country in asia. And great senior for us.
From Japan ^^/
@Nufu Thank you very much.
Unfortunately,there is no political party in present Japan that aims for true equality.
It is difficult to figure out where and what our comrades with a common will to achieve true equality are doing.
@@aonamayorom1529 China and Vietnam arenot communist, they are authoritarian capitalist states. If you say something bad about powerful private corporations like Vingroup or Alibaba, you would be asked by police or being jailed.
That's fact.
@@cudanmang_theog Corporations are controlled by the state and Party. The CPC and CPV can crush these petty corporations at will to build new ones for the people.
@@cudanmang_theog they are no way capitalists I think they have their own feature of socialism
@@cudanmang_theog You know nothing about China, I know you Viets hate China so you won't face the truth, making rumors will not change the fact, we Chinese won't get arrest for saying bad about any company, be a honest person, don't come out to lose your country's face.
LONG LIVE COMMUNISM!
LONG LIVE HUMAN BEING!
long live nature too
傻b
Go to China and live there
Keep crying about communism
@@freestyleboy287 *sigh*
the dumbest and oldest argument ever
Now that's the sound of a proletarian revolution alright.
I'm learning about this in history as part of the WWI unit
No, this was a civil war of China before WWII.
As a true communist, this song makes me feel that my life is meaningful.
Am I true communist?
🥰
we are.
Cool, true communist and loves anime, just like Lenin 😂
@@freestyleboy287 lmao if u hate communism why u here
Respect to china and all of its people
Is that supposed to be Zhou Enlai?
I was wondering the same thing!
lonfdsgfxd Yes,you're right.That's our minister.
zhou enlai is the best premier forever
But just a movie,Now Chinese is lessbody sing intenationale,and most people don't know that
yes
This channel is a gem
"We shall be masters of the world"
Congratulations China ;)
Roblox Expert yes congratulation for defeating by US x)
@@blucekang7147 they were not defeated
Urby www.google.co.kr/amp/s/www.forbes.com/sites/kenrapoza/2019/01/14/china-is-losing-the-trade-war-in-nearly-every-way/amp/ well come on Every country hate you guys except North Korea 😂😂😂 think what you did in south chinese sea, you guys steal. Air pollution in Korea and Japan, you guys send it. Always steal the idea or technology of western countries. You always say 大國 but what you guys really do is just bully 😂😂😂 that is why people call chinese cockroach
Urby 最有趣的是你们在独裁政府下唱这首歌 😂😂 你们甚至不能选择你们的领导者。你们还是奴隶。你为什么唱这首歌？ 😂😂😂😂😂
Bluce Kang 最諷刺的是，現在中共也沒有人張嘴唱國際歌。
He seems surprised and deeply touched to see that his men reached the same conclusion he did. Am I misled?
Perfect
Yes misled by kmt.
The Internationale starts at 0:44
自由平等进步革命
为一个不再被宗族和宗教社会压迫的世界而奋斗！为一个不再被旧社会和旧制度压迫的世界奋斗！为全人类的解放而奋斗！
Those people’s great grandchildren are some of the greatest hackers and Dota players the world has ever seen
Yet some of them are still serving their country with their lives
@@xingling1073 I have a question is China still building socialism?
@@idrislamont1064 yes
@@xingling1073 What is their strategy?
@@idrislamont1064 just like every other countries, free medical care, free education, lower house price, lower living cost, more work opportunities, let people living in a safe environment ect
Red salute to and solidarity with the Chinese comrades, from India. Thank you for the wonderful ideology of Maoism. Naxalite movement is still strong in India.
@@cedar4539 millions of fascists and landlords that is.
solidarity comrade! another Indian communist here
同志们好，来自中国的问候
Hello, comrades. Greetings from China
Your not a communist with that flag larper western degenerate
This makes me proud to be Chinese
@@blucekang7147 yes we are
How can you be on here
@@codybuilam6086 never heard of vpn?
@@mikeoaksbig2233 but thought your government also blocked VPN
@@codybuilam6086 apparently not? how about opening your eyes and not believe in everything the media sells you?
This video helped me when I felt like I couldn't go on .
Beautiful
I discovered this video in Spring 2017, loved it and watched it frequently, and I am just now realizing I had not liked it. Good thing I fixed that, it is inspiring.
精神永存，印度需要马克思主义，我并不是怂恿什么，只是客观的表达，印度的工人农民兄弟的真正需要。
@@user-yn9pq1wv9g ?
@@user-yn9pq1wv9g america needs Marxism too 😭
@@4orks976 world needs Marxism
@@4orks976 a lot of places need Marxism.
When you already did the homework due for tomorrow and you accept to share them with your classmates
Collectivise the knowledge, not just your answers
The blood in OUR heart.
☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭ Im American but this warms my heart snd the Chinese civil war is so inspiring
Tang Dynasty brought me here.
To communism xD?
Imperial Guardsman I'LL MAKE MOTHER RUSSIA PROUD.
what was that
+a Lachmaz Chinese Band
从来就没有什么救世主 也不靠神仙皇帝
要创造人类的明天 要靠我们自己
Maan....
This gave me goosebumps
Why its a real movie on UA-cam search it up then
No other platforms have this movie
0:44
gave me the chills 0-0
今年刚考上研，励志要为共产主义事业奋斗终生！为中华之崛起而奋斗终生！为往圣继绝学，为万世开太平
加油💪
民族复兴 矢志不渝
希望10年后还可以听见你说同样的话
@@mitchluke1929 Mandate of heaven
If Lenin can see us now!!
He will, In heaven while sheding tears of Joy
Really...We all communists will love china... I am from India.... But communist party is strong in India... I want to see India to be a communist country...
@@souhardyaadhikari7822 me too
@@souhardyaadhikari7822 do u called me in the chat
@@dr.nandinibanerjee5921 Yes, ami chai communist bangla... I want it back
This is the best song i ever heard
WORKERS AND PEASANT OF ALL LAND UNITES!!!
The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win. Working Men of All Countries, Unite!
ey put that in max volume wear headphones i swear its good
the founding of a republic
It's a TV series in China. Several actors in The Founding of the Republic also played in this TV series.
Joshua Christoper Siahaan A People's Republic🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
@Crabman Coconut I know right. Ridiculous!!! America is only democratic country in the world no one knows democracy better than them. Long live the American sauger daddies
@@thegodfather1373 What a joke. You have no freedoms except your freedom of speech and guns. Thats it. Everything else is a lie, a coverup
@@justsomecommie2638 no, one more thing, the freedom to die
When you put a book on Tiananmen Square in the fiction section:
Proud to be from China,to all the haters out there,they are just jealous,ignore them.
When communism makes you the most powerful nation in the world
EsPiri Reis And the hungriest.
And they are not x)
communism with Chinese (capitalist) chartists
@@blucekang7147
3rd powerful in terms of military and predicted to be the top economies power soon. Yep I say they are impressive
Hamza Baig China will eventually fall because of its lack of international relations.
Самое интересное здесь в том, что националисты Чан Кайши повязали себе красные галстучки и зазвучала бессмертная музыка Дегейтера!) Неплохая информационная война континентального Китая против Тайваня!
В тот период это были очень близкие партии, особенно левое крыло гоминьдана ("революционной партии") - по полной аналогии с эсерами (левыми и правыми). Одним из трёх принципов основателя Сунь Ятсена (значит и гоминьдана) был социализм. Но в тот же период КПК входил в состав Гоминьдана в целом и военного училища в Наньчане в качестве особой партии - форма и знамёна были единые, а партии разные (как махновцы в своё время в составе Красной Армии). Раскол будет чуть позже.
Respect from somewhere in asia
What movie is this?
1:14-1:15-1:19: Arise💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿
Arise!!!!!!!!!
Beutyfull
The struggle for fairness must continue. G'day from Australia 🇦🇺
what is the film name? i want to watch complete this film
Because it's zhou enlai, this video is available in ENLGISH SUB lol
The movie:
[经典电影 2010-08-18 HQ] 八月一日 6/7
傻b
Just so good !!
Whats the film name??
gotta love the "enlgish" subtitles!!
Please not that e-n-l-g-i-s-h is a misspelling of "English".
Are you a native Chinese speaker?
I’m not going to judge you, because you can be a translator. Even if you may not be paid money, you can translate a lot of videos to keep the science message going. Martymer81 is a great example of this.
Martymer81 is a Swedish UA-camr that fights against pseudoscience, particularly Christian apologeitcs and New Age woo.
By translating his videos, you can ensure that only REAL science must be respected at all times.
@@einsteingonzalez4336 r/whoosh
@@einsteingonzalez4336 em lad are you ok
@@Frankgaming1 I'm said this because I needed to promote Martymer81.
@@einsteingonzalez4336 I actually really like the guy from a bit of the video I watched but why are you promoting him
Hai to socialist china
China isn't Japan
Hai means yes in Japanese
@@melli7193 probably he meant "hail to Socialist China"
@@Antonio-uz1qq oh good point. I just remembered that not everyone has perfect spelling lol
@@melli7193 lol
What's the name of this movie?
What movies is this from?
When you are breaking the chain from The League.
CCP National Congress brought me here.
Thanks I have never heard of the movie Axis of War
whats name of Film i wnat to watch i love Chinese movies
Axis of War is the Name of the movie
Don't let emperial forces and capitalism do it again
This makes me proud to be Chinese 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳 (I'm Uruguayan and white as hell)
Wow
It's kind of strange...... China used to be very "communist", but now, the kids don't even know what is Internationale, who is Marx, who is Lenin......
Eric Huang no way. they still study “politics” as a subject at school.
I lived in China for 13 years before I went to Canada. That subject... did not teach anything about communism, I remember, but laws and economy...
+Marlon Barbosa Yes they do have politic class in school but it is not relate to communism. I can promise that 99/100 Chinese never read communist books like
+Marlon Barbosa I am not.
Eric Huang After all Mao fucked up , the Chinese leaders were forced to adopt capitalism , so to recover the society. Now , in my homeland China , what communism remains is the one party dictatorship 'communist party' which owns the 99% of the people. Communism is a great ideology, we human just fucked it up. Ants and robots may work it out.
Name film?
سوشل ازم زندہ باد
Long live revolution 🇵🇰🇵🇰
Pakistan is fascist
@@zurdddtk3025 but not all its citizens.
wait a second these soldiers are clearly side with communist but why their hat have a kuomintang sun which is the opposite with communist and enemy at the same time?
+thi tran communist and kuomintang were fighting together against the old government. but the old leader of kuomintang dead, the new leader start massacre communist. this is the time communist start fight back
+thi tran the Chinese Red Army was formed out of defected members of the National Revolutionary Army, the military arm of the KMT. This is right after the Nanchang Uprising, which is the formation of the CCP, so they didn't have uniforms yet. So that's why they use the red scarves
No, at the moment of Nanchang uprising, the CCP had not begun to consider the KMT as enemy. At that time the CCP hoped that the left-wing of KMT will continue the cooperation with CCP and what they were against were only the fraction of the KMT who were anti-communist. Therefore it is more than normal that they kept the KMT symbol at that time.
+zhenyu wu the Nanchang uprising started the war between the CCP and KMT. The CCP helped the KMT in the Northern expedition in the First united front, but the Nanchang uprising showed Chiang was unwilling to deal with dissent.
+zhenyu wu because of the First United Front is why I think they use KMT uniforms. In both United fronts, the CCP fought under the flag and standards of the republic of china
what movie
Btw what is the ñame of that movie?
This is what i listen to while nobody's looking
...
best version
i want to say that there's no way soldiers in the NanChang uprising are that attractive.
What is films name
Beautiful 👍🙏🙏👍
Respect
What´s the film ?
May I know the name of the movie? I want to see this mass heroic movie..
The establishment of the army of Chinese working class
This movie is called Axis of War: The First of August
*u may Not Rest now,There are deep thoughts near by.*
0:14-0:21
Movie?
Axis of War: The First of August
0:45
Blood steering beats
Long live comrades, battle hasn't ended yet☭☭☭✊
What's the film name
What movie is this
Lal salam comrade zhou enlai ✊✊
Hmmm, i want to know if Karl Marx watch this song, he will be proud because its turns out that many countries in this earth that ideologies Communism.
And Lenin, not much that i can say, but he was the most famous Communist people of Uni Soviet,
But Mao Zedong, China, will not stand strong like a rock without him and his idoology, Communism!
What show is this?
这是90年代或以後的《南昌起義》(或同样题材的电視剧或电影)的一幕吧！比改革開放前的作品更偏離史實，鏡头更过分美化和教條化。先不提只突出周恩來一个人，那些军人的制服也太乾净，举止太像預先安排好的檢阅式了! 《國际歌》当時(1927)並不普及，红軍也未建軍，雖说藝術加工，不用全部跟足史實，但如此虚幻的影像，比過往的主旋律电影更难令人共鸣，過往雖高大全，但是仍然有血有肉，令人感动的。
首先，这是08年的片子。另外，这段本质上就是叙事，反应的是27年7月31日夜间，起义开始之前在指挥部军官集结的时候的场景，如果唐生智和张发奎的制服很干净，那么贺龙叶挺的制服也应该干净，应为到此时为止唐生智和叶挺还没有正式开打
吹毛求疵
法国自由女神油画 还穿着连衣裙上战场， 甩着奶子呢， 不照样世界名画? 有没得谁说不现实? 油画起草独立宣言， 都他妈的穿搭跟赴高级晚宴一样， 哪像将军像战争的样子呢。。
周恩来？
Looks like it
yes
Yangtze Him,not it.
Succeed Internationel shush 🤫
日本人也认识？
What movie is this from