Even if you were a communist - "Die Internationale" is in itself a human statement and I am sure other political opinions can give great music a fair cut. Great piece, loved the Chinse vocalist giving French a go. Peace everyone!
This is not a communist song, but a ballad for the human struggle. Against government, against metaphysical systems, against just plain old marginalization. Things that no person deserve to wrangle with.
Well, the lyrics are written by an anarcho communist and the song is composed by a communist, because the idea of communism itself is just what you have explained, a hope for the humanity
But that is Communism. Communism is the doctrine of the Liberation in f the working class. China a Socialist state lead by a Communist party. It is moving towards socialism. So it only makes since that the Communist party of China uses the International as it's anthem.
I am an American economist and was in China 12 years. China ad America both have mixed economies. That is both public and private sectors are important. The difference is the USA is more tilted the private sector compared to the situation in China. I have been a non-partisan math oriented economist for 35 years. I give objective analysis and let policymaker make policy decisions. Anyone can be political. Not everyone can do objective mathematical analysis. We all have our individual roles to play. The Chinese economy did not do well until it adopted a mixed economy. There is nothing great about people starving to death, like what happened sometimes under Mao.. An economy that is extreme to the right or extreme left does not work China is not defeated. Having a mixed economy starting in 1978, helped it. Vietnam switched to a mixed economy in 1986 Things got better there also. Being a dogmatic extremist helps no one. Take care..
The economies of China and American currently operate similarly, but the underlying political economy is very different. The American political system is dominated by the capitalist class, and seeks to perpetuate the capitalist mode of production to continue the power of that class. The Chinese system is dominated by the Communist Party, which is a Marxist-Leninist vanguard party, which aims to advance the interests of the worker class and achieve a Communist economy. In order to achieve a Communist economy, the party is currently focused on developing a strong industrial economy, and is using a mode of production similar to capitalism to do so. This political economy is what is being referred to when the countries are referred to as Capitalist or Communist, rather than the economy itself.
@@junelawson5719 Politically they are different and I think I made that clear. I am an economist and care little for polities. I have worked around a lot of politicians of different parties simultaneously. They know I am non-partisan and basically a mathematician. You and I agree I think. You might never understand a non-partisan economist. That is okay and these posts are limited in explaining anything. If YOU do not LOVE math, you cannot understand me. No worries.
@@newaddress456 I'm not sure I fully understand your role and I may have misunderstood, but here's one for you if you're interested. What do you think is a good compromise on landlords given that rent seeking on undeveloped land is most likely sub optimal economic behaviour. What incentive can be put in place to either make land holders make more productive use of their land, or make renting land more affordable so consumers have more to spend on goods? Or is there some better third option? The situation in my country for example is almost 200,000 properties are vacant on a country of 7 million or so, and the current incentive seems to be to keep them off the market and trickle properties onto the market at a much lower rate than demand to keep prices inflated. No need to response but if you do, cool beans. This stuff is interesting, and I tried to keep my question somewhat open ended in case you have some perspective I don't expect myself.
China has been a mixed economy for a long time. The first recorded official debate about the economic development model happened in 21 B.C., in the imperial court of Han Dynasty. The debate was recorded and published later on. Its tile is "Discourses on Salt and Iron".
CIA backed color revolution? It was defeated. What do you feel about American massacre of Koreans during the Korean war? and the cultural genocide since the occupation of Southern part of Korea?
I've got to give it to China, they can make the Internationale sound far more beautiful than it already is!
I've searched for this video for months, thank you for uploading!
Wonderful. Arise ye slaves...G'day from Australia 🇦🇺. Tovarich 😊😊😊
This is fucking beautiful
GOOSEBUMPS!!!...😮😮😮
Great version 👍
Thank you for uploading this masterpiece ! Greetings from France !
simply amazing voice, almost as good as amazing grace
Her French is perfect ! Wonderful.
Nope. She pronounces forçats as [foʁka]...
@@mark_fi maybe her text processor didn't have the 'ç' 🙂
En vrai il y a un petit accent mais très léger, franchement elle chante très bien en français.
She graduated from Fudan University majored in French study. It's not surprising.
装逼的语言
Even if you were a communist - "Die Internationale" is in itself a human statement and I am sure other political opinions can give great music a fair cut. Great piece, loved the Chinse vocalist giving French a go. Peace everyone!
Коммунизм жив! 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
至今不悟岂止是傻？
Bravo!!!
More beautiful French than some native speakers I know, +500 social credit
that's not funny
What television is this?
This is not a communist song, but a ballad for the human struggle. Against government, against metaphysical systems, against just plain old marginalization. Things that no person deserve to wrangle with.
It's a song about enslaving people and killing their countries royal families if the Royal families don't abide by the nwo
Well, the lyrics are written by an anarcho communist and the song is composed by a communist, because the idea of communism itself is just what you have explained, a hope for the humanity
McCarthyism still lingers in your brain 😂 this is a world Communist song wether you believe it or not
But a repressive regime like CCP cannot deserve to sing this Internationale. That is a comedy.😂😂😂
But that is Communism. Communism is the doctrine of the Liberation in f the working class. China a Socialist state lead by a Communist party. It is moving towards socialism. So it only makes since that the Communist party of China uses the International as it's anthem.
Be a communist
🚩🚩🚩
I completely agree
@@leoastner888 you go!!!
Rextreff ?
@@leoastner888 be a communist!!
не нужно быть коммунистом, что бы быть человеком
至今不悟岂止是傻？
Ei liitytty yhteen ja enemmistö kansoista on hävinnyt pelin.
用桌的你
I am an American economist and was in China 12 years. China ad America both have mixed economies. That is both public and private sectors are important. The difference is the USA is more tilted the private sector compared to the situation in China. I have been a non-partisan math oriented economist for 35 years. I give objective analysis and let policymaker make policy decisions. Anyone can be political. Not everyone can do objective mathematical analysis. We all have our individual roles to play. The Chinese economy did not do well until it adopted a mixed economy. There is nothing great about people starving to death, like what happened sometimes under Mao.. An economy that is extreme to the right or extreme left does not work China is not defeated. Having a mixed economy starting in 1978, helped it. Vietnam switched to a mixed economy in 1986 Things got better there also. Being a dogmatic extremist helps no one. Take care..
The economies of China and American currently operate similarly, but the underlying political economy is very different. The American political system is dominated by the capitalist class, and seeks to perpetuate the capitalist mode of production to continue the power of that class. The Chinese system is dominated by the Communist Party, which is a Marxist-Leninist vanguard party, which aims to advance the interests of the worker class and achieve a Communist economy. In order to achieve a Communist economy, the party is currently focused on developing a strong industrial economy, and is using a mode of production similar to capitalism to do so. This political economy is what is being referred to when the countries are referred to as Capitalist or Communist, rather than the economy itself.
@@junelawson5719 Politically they are different and I think I made that clear. I am an economist and care little for polities. I have worked around a lot of politicians of different parties simultaneously. They know I am non-partisan and basically a mathematician. You and I agree I think. You might never understand a non-partisan economist. That is okay and these posts are limited in explaining anything. If YOU do not LOVE math, you cannot understand me. No worries.
@@newaddress456 I'm not sure I fully understand your role and I may have misunderstood, but here's one for you if you're interested.
What do you think is a good compromise on landlords given that rent seeking on undeveloped land is most likely sub optimal economic behaviour.
What incentive can be put in place to either make land holders make more productive use of their land, or make renting land more affordable so consumers have more to spend on goods? Or is there some better third option?
The situation in my country for example is almost 200,000 properties are vacant on a country of 7 million or so, and the current incentive seems to be to keep them off the market and trickle properties onto the market at a much lower rate than demand to keep prices inflated.
No need to response but if you do, cool beans. This stuff is interesting, and I tried to keep my question somewhat open ended in case you have some perspective I don't expect myself.
China has been a mixed economy for a long time. The first recorded official debate about the economic development model happened in 21 B.C., in the imperial court of Han Dynasty. The debate was recorded and published later on. Its tile is "Discourses on Salt and Iron".
为什么一个中国人要用法语唱国际歌呢？？ 装逼吗
有必要这么狭隘吗？国际歌本来就是法语的，而且中国共产党最早也是受法国影响的，不是苏联。
@@bearpolo3618 本少在蒙特利尔天天说法语 法语比法国人都好 我遇到中国人从来不说法语 装什么老逼啊
作为一个中国人你为何如此狭隘呢？这是国际歌！
無知。這不是國歌。
啥叫国际？
6.4天安門事件にはどう感じるんだろうか。おかしな国の方々。
what about the U.S Capitol Building on 2021.1.6 ? the us goverment kill their citizen immediately
The same way you feel about wartime comfort girls in Korea, Unit 731, the Rape of Nianjing and others... (And I'm not even Chinese)
What? Not happen anything in tiananmen..
(+100) ¢
CIA backed color revolution? It was defeated. What do you feel about American massacre of Koreans during the Korean war? and the cultural genocide since the occupation of Southern part of Korea?
Two atomic bombs, still haven’t learned the lesson.