Steve Hackett - Eleventh Earl of Mar (Genesis Revisited: Live At Hammersmith)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лип 2019
- The song concerns the Jacobite rebellion of 1715. The Earl of Mar, John Erskine, led the rebel forces (in the name of the Great Pretender), but was an incompetent general, who threw away all strategic advantage by encamping around Perth for a week giving the opposing Royal forces time to get organised.
My pet gripe is that it was the SIXTH Earl of Mar, not the eleventh who was responsible! Apart from that the song is pretty accurate and sarcastic about our friend the Earl and his master
***
"One of the reasons we have so many different elements in one song, let alone an album, is that if the listener doesn't respond to one thing, he probably will to another thing. If you're going to lose them there, you'll catch them somewhere else.
There's another song in the middle of it as well which was intended to go somewhere completely different. It was a song by itself. I was working on the idea of wind, if you like. I had a title `The House and Four Winds' which I wanted to do as a whole kind of thing and that's what remains of it.”
~Steve Hackett interview with New Musical Express in December 1976
For support the channel:
www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
Thank you for sharing this performance. It makes me sad that the younger generations have no idea what music can like, but I am optimistic that one young person will watch this, have the spark ignited and make some beautiful music of their own.
I am a 16 year old who enjoys Genesis and it’s doppelgänger Marillion! There is hope out there my friend!
Not optimistic.
Fantastic
The great thing about Steve's whole "Revisited' project is that it keeps older Genesis music alive. And when revisiting this music - using todays equipment - Steve is able to be creative about it and to remain faithfull to the original. All at the same time! This is art in itself.
Also see: Dweezil Zappa (Plays Zappa)
One can only dream of how Genesis would have evolved over the years had Steve Hackett not left the band. Probably not as much commercial success. Simply an outstanding musician.
Some bands have ONE songwriter, Genesis had 5. There was little room to keep everyone happy and we were much much better off as the band split and flourished in it's many forms whether solo or down to the three writers of Genesis.
@Vince-lq3ve The 80s also changed Genesis as well Peter and Steve leaving. Chart music was very different in the 80s from the 70s following the success of the disco, punk, and new wave genres. They had to adapt to changing musical tastes, demographics and advances in music and recording technology or die. People didn't stop buying records at the age of 20 or even 30.
Early fans of rock and roll and 60s pop were entering their 40s and still wanted to buy music. The birth rate had started to fall from 1965 so there were fewer teenagers as the decade wore on but more people in their 20s and 30s who were born in the baby boom years.
This song is pure genius and thanks to Steve we still can hear ot live. ❤
What a fantastic, magical performance! The enthusiasm jumps jumps off the screen & out of the speakers. Thank you Steve /7 Band for keeping this wonderful music so alive
This lineup of musicians is my favorite, tho all excellent selections. Lee, Gary, Rob, Roger, and yes of course, Nad! Thanks To Mr Hackett for 50 plus years of pure musical delight, also, much thanks to Rulie your taste in music is spot on!!
What an huge opener for one of the best of Genesis albums, Wind and Wuthering. As more as I hear, more I realize this.
My favorite opening to ANY album.
Yeah i agree- i like it every bit as much as Trick of the Tail
My thoughts too!!!
THE best Genesis album!
And followed by One for the Vine!😊
I remember the very first time I heard this song. I bought "Wind and Wuthering" on 8-track cassette and played it during a long road trip on a gloomy, rainy day. It was the perfect way to listen to that album. This is a beautifully done version.
That central slow section is an absolute wonder. The mood created by the subtle notes and dreamy chord changes is astonishing.
Man, that’s one stage full of talent !
Fantastic performance of a great song. Nad Sylvan brilliant as always.
Awesome. From one of my favorite albums of all time.
What an amazing guitarist Steve has become
Always was! But he hasn't lost a step.
@@jeffwolinski2659 like a true artist, he has definitely grown. He's much better player these days than with Genesis.
@@breezewayrecords Perhaps at least partly because he can play his parts how he wants and doesn't get mixed out. Steve certainly has matured like a fine wine over many years.
Prog masterpiece.
One of the best and overlooked songs in the Genesis catalog. Not sure if Genesis the band actually ever perform this live so thanks for posting!
I've been a Genesis fan for years, saw them live many times But only after the Peter Gabriel, and Steve Hackett separation.
I am also one who generally hates substitute vocalists. I have watched all of these and love them.
Me too. Steve has put together a great band.
And Nad is a great vocalist, no doubt about that. His tone varies among Gabriel, Collins and Cat Stevens. Fits perfectly in my humble opinion.
Beautiful ! I never get tired of these videos....I grab a glass of wine, the iPad , UA-cam and headphones. Steve Hackett I see you will be in Michigan soon....would be like candy seeing you all on stage.
When they played this, my favourite Genesis song at Knebworth way back, the ground shook from the keyboard and guitar part at the end of the song. That incredible sound I will never forget. Those huge mirrors above the stage were reflecting and bouncing light way out into the darkness. My most favourite weekend fun and craziness. Thank you Steve Hackett.
That mirror show, a delight. The lights were in a fan shape behind the stage during the climax in "In the Cage."
@@rappleba2496 .....Awesome!....So many of us sharing wonderful sound and light. A very treasured moment.
Wind and Wuthering was my introduction to Genesis way back as a young kid. I was always dancing in my booster seat!
Magnificent !
Loved this song & album the very 1st time I heard it. Great memories. Thank you for posting this & all the other progressive masterpieces on your site. God Bless you for your kindness.
Nad is Majestic 👍🏻
Vivent Genesis et les années 80.
C'était la belle époque.
De la musique de grande qualité, et une vie sécurisée.
Oui , je suis nostalgique.
Et je l assume.
Genesis est une légende, et quel plaisir de voir Steve et sa bande reprendre ces merveilles mélodiques
Finally I know the lyrics! Loooooove this song!
Absolutely fantastic! I got the chills listening to this as I have every time I've heard it over the past 45 years
Brilliant!
Waited over 40 years to see him, counting down the days till I see Steve in Seattle in October!
Well worth the wait. Saw them last year in Nottingham, UK. Absolutely brilliant. Musicianship of the highest order.
I looked for dates in South Florida . And none are stated.😥
jeff bauer ya lived in Tampa for 15 and Denver for 25 , never came through either! Now back in Colorado and would have liked to see him at red rocks amphitheater, that’s y I’m flying to Seattle, Steve has 10 years on me and one of us is gonna kick the bucket sooner or later lol
jeff bauer
Jeff sorry to bother u again but ur name sounds really familiar and I’m sure there’s more than one J.B. Out there, original grew up in Toledo, just wondered.
I’m only 14 but Hackett is the true genesis holder! He keeps the spirit alive! I’ve been to I think two shows and they’ve been fantastic! Enjoy the show my friend! I’m seeing him in NYC in September!
I'm taking my son tomorrow to the town hall in NYC, He is gonna be 21 Nov 15 th and he knows a bit about Genesis but nothing about Steve Hacket, I'm hopeful that it'll inspire him to listen more.
For me, LAST OF BIG GREAT MAGESTIOUS ALBUMS OF GENESIS ALONG WITH SECONDS OUT 1968 - 1977
From "from Genesis to revalation " to Seconds Out.1968 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1976 1977
The first album, really? Come on, Duke and ATTWT have more bombastic moments. We Cant't Dance, too now that I think about it.
Nat Sylvan has a great voice
That instrumental from 5:47 to 6:10 is pure magic. It takes me off this earth. Just beautiful. The most beautiful 23 seconds of prog music ever!!
The part from 0:00 to 7:52 is pretty good too! 🙂
😜🤗
😂
Nad Sylvan se empolga e quase derruba o microfone fixo no palco é puro êxtase. Amo vocês todos
Great!
this is awesome you know
I really enjoyed this. The music is spot on, which with any Genesis song, you want to hear it like it is on the album. My only wish, although he does a good job, I miss the voice and wish it was mor like Phil.. Again Nad Does a nice job with it, even acting out what Peter might do, but still something just missing. Steve should contact that guy from The Farm. If you really want to hear Phil again, check them out here on UA-cam, just search the Farm Genesis and should find it. Close your eyes and you think Phil is singing.
Thank you for posting - and for the info. I have always wondered (and never bothered to investigate) what it was all about. 'Eleventh' does sit more comfortably than 'Sixth'; call it 'artistic licence!'
Cette chanson , je l'ai écouté des dizaines de fois .
Mais comme elle belle!!
Merci , mille fois merci. 😃😃😃
que magníficamente intrepretada Eleventh Earl of Mar, fantásticos. Que energía y vitalidad.
Great song!! I Love wind and wuthering
Nad rules.
Como fã e colecionador do Genesis desde sua criação, Steve vem mantendo, cada nota musical, tal qual o original.. É um deleite ouvi-lo...
Very good! I love this!
That guitar the bassist is playing has got to be one of the oddest custom builds ever. Left-handed bass & twelve string.
Absolutely fabulous
Nad has really come to interpret these songs with consistency and captures both Phil and Peter in his performances. Let’s not forget English is NOT his mother tongue!
Nad is amazing!! Not just his voice and singing capabilities, but his stage presence is also awesome. Such a captivating performer!
Actually he was born in the USA to an American Father and Swedish mother. Grew up with both languages.
@@davidkent9574
Thanks for the clarification.
100% superb.... that got me through Uni, to some extent. Such an autumn song and album cover.
Stupenda
This song imo, is one of their best. Arena rock and chamber music as one - that's classic Genesis. Btw, it's nice to the beautif guitar part in the mix. ❤❤
Magnificent
Fantastic great 👍🏻
Brilliant
Amazing
Nad is the best
Such a great song!!
Nad is fantastic!
( does Steve ever look up from his Guitar ever??? 🤔)
Loveeeee
That guitar glissando still slays me....
for the wider read fan, one of the best prog rock tracks of all time and certainly one of the very best album openers - only true classics such as Close to the Edge opening are in the same league - in some respects, the finesse shown on Trick of the Tail / Wind and Wuthering makes me wonder if PG leaving was the best thing that ever happened to the band - there is a meme of PG facepalming the first time he hears this track...
Although I love Selling England...I 100% agree. ATOTT & W&W are just the absolute best of Genesis in my opinion. And this is an awesome opening track.
Hatur nuhun kang rulie arifin
Siaaao. sami sami kang
What a cover !!!!
Well done Nad, you give the song more presence, I bought it back in 76 and hung up my Genesis boots in disappointment.
Also to make clear this is a Phil Collins song after Gabriel left.
Yeah I don’t really like the Collins era too much, besides wind and wuthering.
I always know - Steve is the hidden power part of Genesis ... gentlemen caps down!
La magia de la música música de una espiritualidad única culto mucho concepto forever génesis
Finally someone playing both necks of a double neck guitar!! If you don't play both , then don't bother. It's not there just to look badass!
Fantastiskt
John Erskine was the 23rd Earl since the first creation of the title, and the 6th Earl under the seventh creation of the title.
However, he was the 11th Earl under the Jacobite reckoning, which is the reason that is the title of the song.
Are you still taking requests? How about "Shadow Of The Hierophant" and "The Lamia"?
Love it but where's the drums?
Nad!!! Brillantee
I dig it. Just wish he’d leave the sax at home.
Sadly I have to agree, I’m not big on the wind instruments myself.
Roger King must drive Banks nuts. He plays so well you would think its tony.
BTW, it's Roger King, not Kings.
Daddy Oh Daddy You Promised You Promised......
Nad Sylvan as Bonnie Prince Charlie
Can't really understand why hackett left genesis. As he still plays so many of their songs ??????
From what I've heard...Tony Banks told Steve...no more solo albums and Steve felt like his input wasn't being used..
Steve said he wanted autonomy. He wasn’t getting the input in Genesis that he wanted.
Nad is better on the Gabriel songs.
jeff bauer I was just thinking exactly that. He has the Gabriel down cold. He just doesn’t have the right voice for the Phil stuff.
Except this isn't a Gabriel song. This is from Wind and Wuthering which was the second album after Gabriel left Genesis
Doug Steeves i know. It’s one of my favorite albums. I think that Nad sounds less impressive on this song v some of the Gabriel songs. He absolutely kills the Gabriel songs
Have to agree with that
Totally agree. The worst part of this song is the drummers vocal fills.
Как ФИО бассиста?
Juara...
Excellent, but have to say the usually brilliant Nad, seems a bit over animated with the vocals on this one, deviating wildly from the original. Not complaining, just noticed thats all. He sounds and looks half drunk !
He’s calmed down a lot since 2013, but he was quite the…sight back then. Then again Phil Collins and Peter Gabriel were weirdos on stage so I think we got the best of both worlds with Nad!
Poor Phil Collins had no idea what he was singing about in the 70's on pieces like this. .
Gruntol5 the lyrics are crazy. Superb writing.
I don’t think he cared as long as the $$$ was pouring in...😜
@@FREISTUDIOS This was 1977,the money was NOT pouring in.
What a ridiculous dance on Sylvan's...
I wanted to go ans see him in Paris, nothing is done for handicapped people to access and parc there adapted cars for the La Seine musicale in Paris
SHAME
Karaoke at it's best.
Don't know what rhe complaining is about. Nad does a great job.
Nad is so quite most of the time, but he's rocking this one. Still don't care much for him doing this music, but he's okay, I guess. He did a hack job on Phil's wonderful bridge vocal, though...
Hhhnb b ❤❤😂🎉😢😮😅c
Nad is wonderful on the Gabriel stuff but im afraid leave the Phil stuff only Phil can do it !!
The band is sooo good, but drumming....ahi ahi ahi
Vocals…….eh.
The singer spoils it. Get the singer from IQ.
Gotta get rid of that singer
Nad is terrible
Brilliant!