The Real Group Bach Invention in Am

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
  • Margareta Bengston and Katarina Henryson of The Real Group perform Bach's Invention for Piano in Am, BWV 784 live in concert.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 48

  • @TheStupidCaT
    @TheStupidCaT 9 років тому +94

    For those of you listening, but maybe don't have experience in singing:
    There are no words to describe how difficult it is to have that kind of vocal control over such a HUGE range. Both of them are covering more than 2 octaves, jumping intervals back and forth and hitting every note with precision. This is INSANE. So good.

    • @Usefulmusic
      @Usefulmusic 8 років тому +2

      +TheStupidCaT
      Old JS had Margareta Bengston and Katarina Henryson in when he wrote that one.

    • @RebornGuitarLearner
      @RebornGuitarLearner 6 років тому +4

      Not to mention the timing, and not getting distracted with the counterpart/separate melody of your partner.

    • @PastorB1978
      @PastorB1978 4 роки тому +4

      It’s funny that I was thinking the very same thing as I scrolled to the comments.
      I am an experienced singer and this, although thrilling, would be terrifying to perform.
      Magnificent!

    • @DanieltheTruebadour
      @DanieltheTruebadour Рік тому

      This is basically what i was going to say.
      I am a classically trained violinist from age.9 AND singer My first singing teacher determined to prepare me for the San Francisco Opera auditions.
      My ears are highly trained. As a composer my strength is in a cappella vocal writing. My studio singers are headed by a fellow who was short-listed to join the Swingle Singers.
      All that being said, I feel best qualified to wash the feet of these young women and would feel honored to do so. I understand just hiw devilishly difficult it is to do what they did almost effortlessly
      Hey, I'm kidding. There is NOTHING effortless about it. Just a great natural talent AND an Olympic work ethic. (I used to see my friend Raymond Gibbs vocalizing in the practice room, sweat pouring down his face. He became the youngest baritone on the roster of the New York Met. Ray was a true athlete. As are these two. 'Nuff said.

  • @paulomesquita4773
    @paulomesquita4773 5 років тому +13

    Brilliant! My late piano teacher has always dreamed of seeing the 2 part inventions sang in a duet. Wish she could have seen this performance!

    • @raphaelneves7666
      @raphaelneves7666 5 років тому +1

      Paulo Mesquita I hope we have good singers in heaven...

  • @spaceruler8452
    @spaceruler8452 10 років тому +10

    The world is wide. Wonderful harmony of the two women.

  • @hamstersrule1356
    @hamstersrule1356 6 років тому +9

    It sounds nice and simple but it is so complicated it is unbelievable how they not only did this but how they did it in such a beautiful way. Two truly talented and miraculous singers!

  • @adriannehocker6915
    @adriannehocker6915 8 років тому +11

    I have become a big fan in a short amount of time.

  • @chibashigety
    @chibashigety 7 років тому +3

    The greatness of Bach's well documented at the same time.

  • @lars-eriklarsson8067
    @lars-eriklarsson8067 3 роки тому +1

    Otroligt bra framfört

  • @Pakkens_Backyard
    @Pakkens_Backyard 8 років тому +5

    Bach would be proud :O

  • @Applepear733
    @Applepear733 8 років тому +1

    Instant-- i don't even know how to describe what I'm hearing, but the moment I heard it, I melted...
    This is gorgeous!

  • @zetacon4
    @zetacon4 6 років тому +1

    So very beautiful and just amazing control.

  • @Machineguntom3
    @Machineguntom3 8 років тому +1

    Awesome! Love this.

  • @songssavelives--bobbergner5326
    @songssavelives--bobbergner5326 2 роки тому

    Super! Just now working on various permutations of this myself.

  • @fantastiskchow8830
    @fantastiskchow8830 7 років тому +3

    Pitch perfect!

  • @ze_rubenator
    @ze_rubenator 10 років тому +7

    Dat vocal control

  • @TakluCal
    @TakluCal 3 роки тому

    Beautiful!

  • @fadguru
    @fadguru 6 років тому +1

    A cappella? YOU try that!!! Really neat group. Reminds me of the group, Rare Silk.

  • @rodrigoariassepulveda9630
    @rodrigoariassepulveda9630 8 місяців тому

    Great. What a good idea!!

  • @dharryg
    @dharryg 11 років тому

    AMAZING!!!!!!

  • @ehelwagen
    @ehelwagen 10 років тому

    Love this!!

  • @emilabraham3440
    @emilabraham3440 9 років тому

    amazing

  • @DolceMusicGroupZim
    @DolceMusicGroupZim 6 років тому

    I'm speechless,

  • @donalbaro
    @donalbaro 10 років тому

    Meravigliso!

  • @Anonymous-wj6bu
    @Anonymous-wj6bu 2 роки тому

    Holy- this is so impressive!

  • @lucaschmidt5686
    @lucaschmidt5686 7 років тому

    great

  • @marabochokla
    @marabochokla 10 років тому

    Wow

  • @ChuckBerndt
    @ChuckBerndt 7 років тому

    wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @thomasbaker9648
    @thomasbaker9648 7 років тому

    That is amazing. It sounds quite difficult.

  • @galahaadarturo2830
    @galahaadarturo2830 3 роки тому +1

    Este y ya. Mano izquierda y mano derecha de ismo Bach

  • @chibashigety
    @chibashigety 7 років тому

    バッハの偉大さも同時に証明された。

  • @map0909
    @map0909 6 років тому

    Is there a "voice" transcription for this?

  • @danielkim5218
    @danielkim5218 5 років тому

    처자들 노래 잘부르네~

  • @ChristineF1234
    @ChristineF1234 9 років тому

    Sjuuuukt bra!

  • @user-of2co6rj1k
    @user-of2co6rj1k 3 роки тому +1

    진짜 괴물이셨구나 소름이쫙돋아버리네

  •  8 років тому

    "( * / * )" Whooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo is singing? #TheRealGroup

  • @chibashigety
    @chibashigety 5 років тому

    低音部がより難しい

  • @lurvigaludde
    @lurvigaludde 2 місяці тому

    Great in all ways, but, JSB did not write to pianoes because they did not exist then..

  • @gn01223162
    @gn01223162 10 років тому

    挺酷的XDDDDDDDD

  • @ChristineF1234
    @ChristineF1234 9 років тому

    Sjuuuukt bra

  • @pbazant
    @pbazant 10 років тому +7

    Difficult as hell...

  • @AwesomeSmiley87
    @AwesomeSmiley87 3 роки тому +1

    It's just scatman?