I heard ‘I don’t recall if I was home that day’ to then ‘we weren’t home and the dogs weren’t out that’s day’ So which was it, you were or weren’t at home??
If he was 'cursing at the kids', that tells me there were kids home without adults. My guess is a child tethered the dogs improperly while they were home alone.
My child is 14, he's not allowed to take our dog out ! He's not allowed to even answer/open the door unless it's his grandma or grandpa ! This kid is 10 years old and he's home without parental supervision???
My heart is breaking. Guy lives in a rooming house, seems like has few material possessions, just a beloved dog that should have passed on peacefully when it was her time. Instead he has to scoop up her intestines. And now he says he'll never have another dog after losing his heart dog so brutally.
hi.. i was rolling my eyes.. too he was telling pure liies and very dramatic..i think i started to rolling my eyes.. and screwing up my face... when he said he slept in the bed with the dog for 19 years...like the dog was his lover... be blessed
@@Cubanflowers he never said they were lovers. I have cats & they sleep with my hubby & I. To go to the vile & sick opinion the dog is his lover is messed up. Rolling YOUR eyes, you NEED COMPASSION! KINDNESS MATTERS!!!
I ended up tearing up too. At first I found the guy annoying, but 9 mins in after him describing what happened, as a dog owner I just couldn't help it😫😰🤧 Edit: I've never been moved by a PC story before; but jfc, those defendants are evil
Some of their story changed and didn't make sense. The plaintiff's story is straight forward and makes sense. The fact that they came into the courtroom with smirks on their faces, rolling eyes, laughing at testimony, being disrespectful and blaming everyone else instead of taking responsibility, pretty much sums it up. They even acted horrible on the way out.
@@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 hi.. its so incredible.. how i didn't see none of that bad character on display.. that you.. people are talking about.. be blessed
The defendant is a big liar. Saying nobody was home so she has no idea what happened but my dogs didn't do nothing. Well then why did she supposedly have the "vet lady" come by that same day to check whether only 1 of their 3 dogs had blood on it? How did the "vet lady" know which dog to check?
The fact the defendants had to pay so little to make amends for letting their dogs out, and they continue to insist after JM’s ruling is appalling. Courts need to consider emotional distress in cases like these, and not only calculate damages based on the idea that pets are simple property.
The problem with considering emotional distress in cases like this is there will be people who take advantage of it "They killed my support fish", "They stole my hamster". Suddenly a case about a gecko that got eaten by a cat becomes a 5k case because they've had that gecko for a decade because they talked about seeing the tail twitching. The sad truth of the matter is pets are considered property and much like if someone crashses into the car you and your deceased dad restored, you can't want an extra 3k because the memories with your dad increased the value and if you accidentally crashed into someones car, you might be okay paying the 1,250 for the damages but cry foul when they tack on that extra 3k for emotional distress.
Its not emotional distress but punative damages is what she should be awarding. Especially for owners in this case, because they are not going to fix the problem and are very negligent.
I had a German shepherd once that broke a couple of those "unbreakable" chains. People who say they're impossible for a dog to break have never seen a pissed off power breed in action
Insurance companies won't insure them...they have distinct rules saying that they won't cover certain breeds..ie Pitbulls. Insurance companies don't want the liability. The idiot owners need to put up fence and secure the animals better!! Its all their fault.
@@PrisonPreacher hi.. sweetie.. tell to me the obvious reason why.. i would love to know.. why you think.. i believe.. them for any other reason.. than they were telling to the judge the truth... be blessed
The defendants clearly lied. They said noone was home, then the dad says the plantiff yelled and cussed at his kids. So clearly the kids were there and the boy took the dog back in the house, like the plantiff said
If he was beating on that dog and trying to get it off of his dog for that long, he got a good look at the Pitbull. He knows exactly which dog it was that attacked his dog. If you have a dog capable of causing serious injury, you need to be vigilant 100 percent of the time. And if God forbid, your Pitbull attacks, TAKE RESPONSIBILITY. Show some remorse and take accountability for your dogs actions. The dog owners make things 100x worse by acting as if they did nothing wrong.
You could say the same for any situation If that is what you believe. However, when you are in a fight or flight situation with adrenaline It is normal for details to get fuzzy and not remember exactly. His first thought is to save his dog and get her help asap. You know the reason why we don’t only rely on eye witness testimony anymore? They used to. That is because It is not the most unreliable. As for that woman something is wrong with her. Even if she genuinely believes It wasn’t her dog she could at least try to be understanding and even the people in the audience felt bad. She is nuts.
She “knows” her dogs were in the house and couldn’t have been out, yet has the vet come by to check her dog for blood stains? Yeah, that’s not fishy at all.
I dont agree with villainizing an entire breed of dog, but I watch TPC and Judge Judy every day, and it’s ALWAYS a Pit Bull… If youre gonna own a pit bull or another large/strong/muscular dog, then you need to need to be in full control at all times. There’s no excuse for why people or their pets should get mauled/bitten bc of your negligence
It IS always a pitbull. I think they're an ugly breed of dog and they were bred to be viscious and they have proven that, over and over again. There are millions of scarred children and adults.
I hate when people act like we shouldn’t be afraid of pit bulls. It’s not even villainizing the breed. Unfortunately, a pit pull’s bite most of the time causes way more damage that let’s say a yorkie. It’s just a fact. That’s why these dogs are always in the news, because they’re a powerful breed. It’s okay to point out that this is a strong dog. It’s ok to point that some people shouldn’t own them. That doesn’t mean that the breed is terrible. Just means you need to be careful because they can hurt like hell
I agree. At the end of the day they are animals who do animal things. I really feel for the dogs because I know quite a few people with pitbulls or pitbull mixes and they are the sweetest dogs ever. But that’s also because their owners made sure to do proper research, prevent situations that could make them reactive, and do extensive socializing and on/off leash training. Dogs will be dogs, but humans can chose not to act like trash and out others in harms way
@@coquigirl0789 Agreed! As JM says, it’s never the animal’s fault that it did what dogs do, it’s the human being who is responsible. And it’s not always a pit bull, it’s just that those are the ones that get reported the most!!!
I feel horrible for this poor plaintiff. I’m appalled that people are so stupid as to not be responsible dog owners. Whether you have a large or aggressive dog or a small one, keep them secure. A kid could walk up and get mauled since they don’t have a fence.
I almost started crying during this case...actually I did shed a tear.. I really did.. No dog deserves this.. He really did Ellie justice by advocating for her.. It's hard to not feel a way about pitbulls... But it's really the owners... And the way the defendant is acting... No remorse.. Rolling her eyes... It's just sad.... Rest in peace sweet dog... Rest in peace ❤️🕊️🕊️🕊️
I would think that if someone was saying your dog broke it’s collar or chain and attacked their dog your first line of defense ( if you truly believe they were lying) would be to point out your dog’s collar and chain are intact. Never heard word one about that.
I couldn't finish this one. That poor poor chihuahua. 😭 the defendents are heartless, incompetent, vile people with her rude eye rolling, the lies that "no one was home", not an apology to be said. No accountability. It's the chihuahua owners fault because he walked too close to their lawn ? 🙄 I literally cant...I hate this case.
It was their dog at first she said she didnt know if she was home then she said she wasnt then the guy wasnt home either so they just leave their kid's home alone with 3 pitbulls? Ridiculous
This is utterly heartbreaking and absolutely disgusting. These people are horrendous. This elderly dog suffered so immensely and would have been so terrified and in unimaginable pain. The defendants are such awful people.
After watching dozens of Pitbull cases I have never seen an intelligent Pitbull owner. Maybe everyone disappeared that day because they had warrants, lol.
I personally know a few responsible pitbull owners. I feel like we only see the irresponsible ones here because it is small claims court, but there are responsible pit bull owners out there.
We have a bull mix. 7 foot fences, muzzle because he got jumped by a loose dog as a puppy (ours was on a lead and tried to run away in fear) and he freaks out every time he sees dogs on a walk so as a measure in case we muzzle him as he is a big dog. But I do have to agree, we didn’t go out looking to get a pit bull yet he was the dog we fell for at the shelter but I do notice a trend in a lot of pit bull owners who go and get one with a big bad attitude and funny enough the dogs end up big and bad. The more damage a dog can do, the more vigilant the owner has to be and there’s a massive correlation between these damage-intensive dogs and denial-egotistical owners. I’ve known other great pit bull owners but most people that are attracted to them don’t do the job they need to do to contain and train them.
I am horrified listening to his story. That woman is lying and her witnesses are lying, also. The only reason someone needs dogs that violent is because they are doing something illegal.
The lack of visual blood on the dog that attacked is not evidence that there wasn't an attack. Once when we were playing with our two dogs in the snow, one dog cut its foot on ice. It didn't start bleeding until we got home. The living room carpet was bloody everywhere before we took the injured dog to get stitches. We returned home to perfect looking carpet. The dog we left behind "cleaned " our carpet. In this case the other dogs could have licked the blood off the dog that did the biting.
The defendants are grasping at straws, tons of BS...3 pits, no fence, outside unsupervised!! Guilty, irresponsible owners!! Next time it will be a HUMAN BABY!! What lame excuses will you pull out of your hat then??!!
I would move if I still had my little baby and pitbull owners moved in. Dead serious. If this happened to her I wouldn’t ever be able to forgive myself or unsee/hear it.
This guy definitely has PTSD from this. The way he held it together telling his side you can totally tell he was fighting through his emotions re-living this traumatic event. The way the defendant doesn’t show any compassion or remorse speaks value on her credibility and selfishness.
Can I just say that not once did anyone of the defendants apologize at all or offer any kind of apology for what happened !?! People like that shouldn’t own any dog!! And not properly securing your pets in your yard? That goes for any breed of dog, not just pitbulls. Those defendants were just so rachet and no remorse at all.
The defendants second witness started off strong but fell short right away. He not only admitted that the three dogs were kept outside which confirmed the plaintiffs story, he also confirmed the defendant is a liar since she said the dogs are kept in the house.
The law needs to catch up to the reality that companion animals are more than property. We develop an emotional relationship with them -- love -- that makes them irreplaceable. That is their purpose. Of course we feel anguish if they die in such horrible circumstances.
You got to remember this case is old. If the dog was born in 93 and was 19 when she died, that would place the incident in 2012. Had the dog not been attacked, she could have made it if her only health problem was hearing loss.
@kimeyon1 This episode is old, and he said she was "on the way" to being the oldest dog. Clean out your crusty ears instead of being quick to call people liars🙄
Poor dog, what a brutal end to a long life. The defendant makes me irate. Where is the responsibility? Where is the care and concern, the human decency? Thank goodness for karma.
My heart goes out to this man...that is a horrible thing to endure, I can't even imagine. Watching your dogs stomach be ripped out right in front of you! Oh my God
From what the lady said about keeping their pitbulls in the house most of the day, that in itself is a huge problem! They need to be out getting some kind of exercise at least 3 - 4 times a day! This would take care of some of their aggressiveness. But, they must be trained to an extent! If the young son can come out & give the dog a command & the dog stops what it's doing, then they could have done it before the man's little dog got torn apart!
MY WHOLE INSIDES WENT TO SHREDS 😭😭😭😭HEARING THE DOG WAS DIMOLISHED BY THE OTHER 🐕 DOGS HOPE THE MAN IS DOING WELL OVER THESE DAYS🫡 GOD BLESSS u SIR❤️🩹
hi. ask the britons..and the irishman... as i know you are.. born to the 'united' states and have absolutely no idea.. that axe is proper word.. and has been around since long before.. king james bible was written.. AXE and u shall receive.. written clear as glass there....and the britons.. and irishman still use it... be blessed
@Cubanflowers Some of my ancestors were Britons, and I don't say "axe" unless I'm planning to chop down a tree. Perhaps in the 1700s, people could only hear how the people around them mispronounced a word, but this is the 21st century, and we can hear the proper pronunciation by flipping on the TV.
![Myon Burrell sentenced to prison [RAW]](/img/n.gif)
The way the defendant is rolling her eyes while the plaintiff is talking about his dogs guts getting tore out is plain sick. Sick woman.
Yes it is pathetic 😢
Imagine having to live near people like these defendants. what tell this country has become..
Pure meanness...
Meanwhile the women nehind her are crying. What rotten defendants!
Sick af! smdh
They say no one was home, but the children were able to tell them what had happened? Anyone else catch that? 🤔🤔
They didn’t tell one truth in the whole case. Lie after lie
I heard ‘I don’t recall if I was home that day’ to then ‘we weren’t home and the dogs weren’t out that’s day’
So which was it, you were or weren’t at home??
They are both liars.
Doesn't sound like the plaintiff was lying @@nikkirene00
I caught that right away and I was shocked JM didn't call them out for it.
If he was 'cursing at the kids', that tells me there were kids home without adults. My guess is a child tethered the dogs improperly while they were home alone.
My child is 14, he's not allowed to take our dog out ! He's not allowed to even answer/open the door unless it's his grandma or grandpa ! This kid is 10 years old and he's home without parental supervision???
My heart is breaking. Guy lives in a rooming house, seems like has few material possessions, just a beloved dog that should have passed on peacefully when it was her time.
Instead he has to scoop up her intestines.
And now he says he'll never have another dog after losing his heart dog so brutally.
100%
Before she even speaks, the defendant keeps rolling her eyes.
Most humans would have decency to at least wait and let him tell his story. 😢
hi.. i was rolling my eyes.. too he was telling pure liies and very dramatic..i think i started to rolling my eyes.. and screwing up my face... when he said he slept in the bed with the dog for 19 years...like the dog was his lover... be blessed
She is doing that because she knows a lot of it is true.
Cattle prods work
Thousands of pet owners sleep with there dogs in their bed, I slept with mine for 16 yrs@@Cubanflowers
@@Cubanflowers he never said they were lovers. I have cats & they sleep with my hubby & I. To go to the vile & sick opinion the dog is his lover is messed up.
Rolling YOUR eyes, you NEED COMPASSION! KINDNESS MATTERS!!!
I'm in tears over this poor dog.
I know. Me too.
The lady is lying see in her face. She also have smirked on her face.
The whole audience was aghast during his testimony. What a horrible way to lose a beloved pet.
Me too. 😢
I ended up tearing up too. At first I found the guy annoying, but 9 mins in after him describing what happened, as a dog owner I just couldn't help it😫😰🤧
Edit: I've never been moved by a PC story before; but jfc, those defendants are evil
They are there worst kind of people and pet owners. That poor dog died so brutally and the defendants won’t even own up to it and apologize
Some of their story changed and didn't make sense. The plaintiff's story is straight forward and makes sense. The fact that they came into the courtroom with smirks on their faces, rolling eyes, laughing at testimony, being disrespectful and blaming everyone else instead of taking responsibility, pretty much sums it up. They even acted horrible on the way out.
Exactly. The defendants are disgusting. 😡
Pure trash
The defendant and her family act offended that they're actually being held accountable for this, nasty attitudes by all of them.
hi.. wouldn't you be if..it wasn't your dogs who did this!????.. be blessed
@@Cubanflowers wah wah
Definitely!!!
@@Cubanflowersno. I wouldn't act like them EVER. No compassion, laughing, rolling their eyes. Absolutely gross...whoever's dog did this.
@@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 hi.. its so incredible.. how i didn't see none of that bad character on display.. that you.. people are talking about.. be blessed
I feel so bad for this gentleman and for his dog, to have such a beautiful life and taken away in such a brutal moment. Just brings tears to my eyes.
F’n pitbulls
They’re disgusting
Defendants are liars and cowards
Not sure you watch this show enough
That is true of this defendant but that is by no means true of all defendants
@@emmalemonade4550 i meant in the context of them being the defendants in question since we are talking about this specific case
What else would expect from them....
Normal black behavior
These defendants are some of the foulest people I’ve ever seen.
They disgust me
I cried when he was telling the story of his dog bein attacked. It was so real and the tears in his eyes.... broke my heart. Hope he is better now ❤
The defendant is a big liar. Saying nobody was home so she has no idea what happened but my dogs didn't do nothing. Well then why did she supposedly have the "vet lady" come by that same day to check whether only 1 of their 3 dogs had blood on it? How did the "vet lady" know which dog to check?
That's a great question 🤔 I didn't think of you are so right bout that
Right?
Whoa! Good point!!!? My goodness...your right!
The fact the defendants had to pay so little to make amends for letting their dogs out, and they continue to insist after JM’s ruling is appalling. Courts need to consider emotional distress in cases like these, and not only calculate damages based on the idea that pets are simple property.
The problem with considering emotional distress in cases like this is there will be people who take advantage of it "They killed my support fish", "They stole my hamster". Suddenly a case about a gecko that got eaten by a cat becomes a 5k case because they've had that gecko for a decade because they talked about seeing the tail twitching.
The sad truth of the matter is pets are considered property and much like if someone crashses into the car you and your deceased dad restored, you can't want an extra 3k because the memories with your dad increased the value and if you accidentally crashed into someones car, you might be okay paying the 1,250 for the damages but cry foul when they tack on that extra 3k for emotional distress.
@@Fribee83Judge Judy does award monetary damages exceeding the value of the dog!!
Its not emotional distress but punative damages is what she should be awarding. Especially for owners in this case, because they are not going to fix the problem and are very negligent.
Dogs are considered property in the eyes of the law@@Fribee83
Usually she awards the value of the item at the time of the loss too - I guess in this case a 19 year old dog would likely have no cash value though.
Defendant should get her dogs taken away. She’s clearly incompetent & not a good owner
those people always have pit bulls
I had a German shepherd once that broke a couple of those "unbreakable" chains.
People who say they're impossible for a dog to break have never seen a pissed off power breed in action
You're right, look what they said about the Titanic.
A chain is only as strong as its weakest link.
Once an animal has been classified as vicious...
Should be mandatory a $100k insurance policy be in place per animal....
Insurance companies won't insure them...they have distinct rules saying that they won't cover certain breeds..ie Pitbulls. Insurance companies don't want the liability. The idiot owners need to put up fence and secure the animals better!! Its all their fault.
💯% in agreement.
I've never cried during a court case but this has me in tears
Me too 😢
Exactly terrible 😞😞
Literally 😔
I couldn't even listen to the whole story, So upsetting.
It was absolutely intentional that the defendant’s did not bring the only eye witness to court.
The defendants need to take responsibility for what their dog did. End of story .
the fact she started her testimony by talking about how someone told her the "cables wont break" to me shows she knew there was an issue
JM likes to dole out Rough Justice, but in this case, there needs to be some street justice.
Just plain facts.
hi. she also doesn't like to listen... i believe the defendants!... be blessed
@Cubanflowers Of course you do, and it's pretty obvious why.
@@CubanflowersI suppose u condone other dogs just attacking another dog if it was a human would u feel the same way I wonder
@@PrisonPreacher hi.. sweetie.. tell to me the obvious reason why.. i would love to know.. why you think.. i believe.. them for any other reason.. than they were telling to the judge the truth... be blessed
The Addams family jacket and the shiny kanekalon wig…….. I already knew…. A mess
😂
@@AbadScratchingHabit 😭😭😭😭 I know her scalp sweating
😂
They need those dogs removed from home. They are not a good rescue home at all.
The defendants clearly lied. They said noone was home, then the dad says the plantiff yelled and cussed at his kids. So clearly the kids were there and the boy took the dog back in the house, like the plantiff said
This was so difficult to watch! The poor little elderly dog! And the owner of the pit bull kept rolling her eyes. Such a heartless woman.
Why the hell do you need 3 pit bulls
That’s like saying why do you need anything? Because they want to. SIMPLE
@@keiariabailey8739
🙄🤡
It's a status symbol in the hood.
@@PrisonPreacher He was their neighbor, so he was also in the hood 😒
@@nenew24 fr fr no cap
If he was beating on that dog and trying to get it off of his dog for that long, he got a good look at the Pitbull. He knows exactly which dog it was that attacked his dog. If you have a dog capable of causing serious injury, you need to be vigilant 100 percent of the time. And if God forbid, your Pitbull attacks, TAKE RESPONSIBILITY. Show some remorse and take accountability for your dogs actions. The dog owners make things 100x worse by acting as if they did nothing wrong.
There was a way to get the dog off of the other dog. You have to look it up. It can be hurtful.
You could say the same for any situation If that is what you believe. However, when you are in a fight or flight situation with adrenaline It is normal for details to get fuzzy and not remember exactly. His first thought is to save his dog and get her help asap.
You know the reason why we don’t only rely on eye witness testimony anymore? They used to. That is because It is not the most unreliable.
As for that woman something is wrong with her. Even if she genuinely believes It wasn’t her dog she could at least try to be understanding and even the people in the audience felt bad. She is nuts.
OR…stop buying pitbulls as pets
@@wildfirefly22what
@@wildfirefly22everything you said I agree with but like what did the first person say for you to say all that?
Sounds like the kids was home and the dog got out and they don't wanna take the blame
That's how I felt
😢 I've never cried so much on an episode 😢 poor L.E. Rip sweetie
They need to fix that fence…they keep saying he is lying but it sounds like they are the liars…poor doggie
She “knows” her dogs were in the house and couldn’t have been out, yet has the vet come by to check her dog for blood stains?
Yeah, that’s not fishy at all.
As a pitbull owner, it is irresponsible to not have a fence and them just chained in the backyard
I agree 10,0000%
Not responsible to own a pitbull.
That applies to any dog not just a pitbull
It is totally irresponsible to take your small old dog to pee in an unfenced area where you know it's 3 pitbulls that live there.
I dont agree with villainizing an entire breed of dog, but I watch TPC and Judge Judy every day, and it’s ALWAYS a Pit Bull… If youre gonna own a pit bull or another large/strong/muscular dog, then you need to need to be in full control at all times. There’s no excuse for why people or their pets should get mauled/bitten bc of your negligence
AMEN! I couldn’t have said it better myself!!!
It IS always a pitbull. I think they're an ugly breed of dog and they were bred to be viscious and they have proven that, over and over again. There are millions of scarred children and adults.
I hate when people act like we shouldn’t be afraid of pit bulls. It’s not even villainizing the breed. Unfortunately, a pit pull’s bite most of the time causes way more damage that let’s say a yorkie. It’s just a fact. That’s why these dogs are always in the news, because they’re a powerful breed. It’s okay to point out that this is a strong dog. It’s ok to point that some people shouldn’t own them. That doesn’t mean that the breed is terrible. Just means you need to be careful because they can hurt like hell
I agree. At the end of the day they are animals who do animal things. I really feel for the dogs because I know quite a few people with pitbulls or pitbull mixes and they are the sweetest dogs ever. But that’s also because their owners made sure to do proper research, prevent situations that could make them reactive, and do extensive socializing and on/off leash training. Dogs will be dogs, but humans can chose not to act like trash and out others in harms way
@@coquigirl0789 Agreed! As JM says, it’s never the animal’s fault that it did what dogs do, it’s the human being who is responsible. And it’s not always a pit bull, it’s just that those are the ones that get reported the most!!!
I feel horrible for this poor plaintiff. I’m appalled that people are so stupid as to not be responsible dog owners. Whether you have a large or aggressive dog or a small one, keep them secure. A kid could walk up and get mauled since they don’t have a fence.
I almost started crying during this case...actually I did shed a tear.. I really did.. No dog deserves this.. He really did Ellie justice by advocating for her.. It's hard to not feel a way about pitbulls... But it's really the owners... And the way the defendant is acting... No remorse.. Rolling her eyes...
It's just sad....
Rest in peace sweet dog... Rest in peace ❤️🕊️🕊️🕊️
The defendant and her crew look like a bunch of liers.
You can see in that man's eyes he really sad for his dog 😢
Nobody sees the stupid defendant smiling and smirking when he is telling the story of how his dog got attacked by her dog 😢
Yea she is someone that you don't wanna be around.
What do you mean by ‘nobody sees…’..??
Read the comments and see how many people are saying exactly THAT…!
That awful woman was almost laughing when he described what was happening. Very worrying when the pit bull knows a let go command.
WOMAN, fence your DARNNNN yard!!. it will only cost you about $569!!!
I would think that if someone was saying your dog broke it’s collar or chain and attacked their dog your first line of defense ( if you truly believe they were lying) would be to point out your dog’s collar and chain are intact. Never heard word one about that.
I couldn't finish this one. That poor poor chihuahua. 😭 the defendents are heartless, incompetent, vile people with her rude eye rolling, the lies that "no one was home", not an apology to be said. No accountability. It's the chihuahua owners fault because he walked too close to their lawn ? 🙄 I literally cant...I hate this case.
Today this guys sweet dog, tomorrow it could be a kid.
My goodness 😔💔 They are disgusting humans for not caring about this .
non human
Poor dog .. people take care of pets....this dog didn't have to die.
@@margaretakins6829he didn’t have to die like that!
@@margaretakins6829 You’re pathetic.
It was their dog at first she said she didnt know if she was home then she said she wasnt then the guy wasnt home either so they just leave their kid's home alone with 3 pitbulls? Ridiculous
Pit bull owners always feel like their dogs are so sweet. Being vicious is in their DNA. It only takes one moment for them to turn.
This is utterly heartbreaking and absolutely disgusting. These people are horrendous. This elderly dog suffered so immensely and would have been so terrified and in unimaginable pain. The defendants are such awful people.
After watching dozens of Pitbull cases I have never seen an intelligent Pitbull owner. Maybe everyone disappeared that day because they had warrants, lol.
I personally know a few responsible pitbull owners. I feel like we only see the irresponsible ones here because it is small claims court, but there are responsible pit bull owners out there.
That's because pitbulls are vicious, killer dogs that no one should own.
Doh!
The responsible Pittbull owners don't make it to court
We have a bull mix. 7 foot fences, muzzle because he got jumped by a loose dog as a puppy (ours was on a lead and tried to run away in fear) and he freaks out every time he sees dogs on a walk so as a measure in case we muzzle him as he is a big dog. But I do have to agree, we didn’t go out looking to get a pit bull yet he was the dog we fell for at the shelter but I do notice a trend in a lot of pit bull owners who go and get one with a big bad attitude and funny enough the dogs end up big and bad. The more damage a dog can do, the more vigilant the owner has to be and there’s a massive correlation between these damage-intensive dogs and denial-egotistical owners. I’ve known other great pit bull owners but most people that are attracted to them don’t do the job they need to do to contain and train them.
The way the defendant acts, so uncaring, totally did not care... she just makes me sick. The plaintiff is not lying, the only liar is you.
Next time it could be someone’s child!! Fix the damn fence!!
Problem is, if the drive in the dog is strong enough, they will go through the fence.
The defendant stands there rolling her eyes, and making faces the whole time the plaintiff was talking.
She ties then up instead of walking them...
Yes no wonder why they are crazy
The judge missed that the defendant said the plaintiff was yelling at his children. Sounds like the kid was home and probably let the dogs out.
I am horrified listening to his story. That woman is lying and her witnesses are lying, also. The only reason someone needs dogs that violent is because they are doing something illegal.
The lack of visual blood on the dog that attacked is not evidence that there wasn't an attack. Once when we were playing with our two dogs in the snow, one dog cut its foot on ice. It didn't start bleeding until we got home. The living room carpet was bloody everywhere before we took the injured dog to get stitches. We returned home to perfect looking carpet. The dog we left behind "cleaned " our carpet. In this case the other dogs could have licked the blood off the dog that did the biting.
I’m so sorry about this poor little doggy. My heart is aching for his owner. The defendant is despicable
The defendants are grasping at straws, tons of BS...3 pits, no fence, outside unsupervised!! Guilty, irresponsible owners!! Next time it will be a HUMAN BABY!! What lame excuses will you pull out of your hat then??!!
I am glad plaintiff won but if I had a little dog I wont walk it anywhere near where Pitbulls live
I would move if I still had my little baby and pitbull owners moved in. Dead serious. If this happened to her I wouldn’t ever be able to forgive myself or unsee/hear it.
hi.. and that is why he should have lost.. he was a negligent lie.. be blessed
You are going to lose someone you love very much in the most horrific way possible.....will you still be blessed then
@@nunya8010 hi.. are you trying to lay curse on me? if so.. return to sender..7 times 7 times 7 times 7 times!. be blessed
Terrible, terrible people. Shame on them.
All things considered, the defendants got off pretty easy.
There's a reason they keep pit bulls tied up outside ..... they're probably selling drugs
Way, WAY too easily
This guy definitely has PTSD from this. The way he held it together telling his side you can totally tell he was fighting through his emotions re-living this traumatic event. The way the defendant doesn’t show any compassion or remorse speaks value on her credibility and selfishness.
Can I just say that not once did anyone of the defendants apologize at all or offer any kind of apology for what happened !?! People like that shouldn’t own any dog!! And not properly securing your pets in your yard? That goes for any breed of dog, not just pitbulls. Those defendants were just so rachet and no remorse at all.
The defendants I tell ya they are lying lying lying !!!
I was crying during his testimony. May he try to find peace after those 19 years of love and friendship
The defendants are evil and disgusting
Big liars!
My dog lived for 19 years too. All teeth and good hearing
This poor guy. I feel so bad.😢😊
17:45 He wasn’t home to know if the dogs were outside and his KIDS told him what happened. Cause they were the ones that went and retrieved the dog!!
The defendant saying that the "dog went to the restroom" speaks volumes.
The defendants second witness started off strong but fell short right away. He not only admitted that the three dogs were kept outside which confirmed the plaintiffs story, he also confirmed the defendant is a liar since she said the dogs are kept in the house.
The trauma that he witnessed and went through to me is pain and suffering. What he described was horrible.
I agree. Even though the dog is property the incident itself caused pain and suffering.
The law needs to catch up to the reality that companion animals are more than property. We develop an emotional relationship with them -- love -- that makes them irreplaceable. That is their purpose. Of course we feel anguish if they die in such horrible circumstances.
Oldest dog alive is 33 years old actually. Still alive too. My poor pup died of old age at 21 years old. What a shame
This exact thing happened to me and my little dog Lucy that got attacked and died. I can't listen to this without crying
Obviously the kid was home alone. Parents need to stop pretending their kids are angels, kids make mistakes.
Man thus guy made me cry
Same 😪😢
Spike, a 23 year old Chihuahua from Ohio is the World's Oldest LIVING dog.
I had to look it up too. He sold his story to the judge to have her tugging at her heart in the beginning
You got to remember this case is old. If the dog was born in 93 and was 19 when she died, that would place the incident in 2012. Had the dog not been attacked, she could have made it if her only health problem was hearing loss.
@kimeyon1 This episode is old, and he said she was "on the way" to being the oldest dog. Clean out your crusty ears instead of being quick to call people liars🙄
I'm in tears for this poor man, I lost my furry best friend due to a crazed dog attacking my chihuahua 😢
Damn just Tell the Story just dragging along sorry for your loss really detailed in your story telling
"Oh please help me", that had me done for. I'm bawling.😢 So sad.
the plaintiff needs to move a way from these people. They are monsters.
Defendant is nasty woman, during this sad, horrible story, she is laughing 😢🤯😤😡
Right?! She literally started laughing then tried to cover it up with a cough. She’s a horrible woman.
Poor dog, what a brutal end to a long life. The defendant makes me irate. Where is the responsibility? Where is the care and concern, the human decency? Thank goodness for karma.
This lady 😡 regardless how can she not feel bad for this man and his dog. Evil person
My heart goes out to this man...that is a horrible thing to endure, I can't even imagine. Watching your dogs stomach be ripped out right in front of you! Oh my God
This breaks my heart... wow... 19 years old and beautiful.... and this horrible experience..
I was almost crying listening to the man’s story and I think they were laughing 😢
I am so sorry for the loss of your beloved dog.
Plaintiff should have gotten a lot more. P&S, punitive damages..etc, something. If this happened to me I would be traumatized for life
What a sweet, old dog to have met such a terrible demise.
Defendants are liars . That's why they didn't bring the 10 year old
Why didn’t he bring a witness that saw everything so he say
@@elysenightwalker3864 some sworn affidavits would have helped but I don't think he has a lot of money.
They thought saying they weren’t home was a defense but that backfired on them.
Sheronda your dog did it stop it lol fix the fence and those bangs………..
I agree with the statement the judge said, it's not the dogs that are the problem but the owners.
No, it's the dogs.
I am sick to death of hearing this nonsense. It is BOTH!
I got emotional watching this. Just like the lady in the background behind the defendant..... this was really horrifying
From what the lady said about keeping their pitbulls in the house most of the day, that in itself is a huge problem! They need to be out getting some kind of exercise at least 3 - 4 times a day! This would take care of some of their aggressiveness. But, they must be trained to an extent! If the young son can come out & give the dog a command & the dog stops what it's doing, then they could have done it before the man's little dog got torn apart!
MY WHOLE INSIDES WENT TO SHREDS 😭😭😭😭HEARING THE DOG WAS DIMOLISHED BY THE OTHER 🐕 DOGS HOPE THE MAN IS DOING WELL OVER THESE DAYS🫡 GOD BLESSS u SIR❤️🩹
Did you AXE him? Why is ASK so difficult to say?
hi. ask the britons..and the irishman... as i know you are.. born to the 'united' states and have absolutely no idea.. that axe is proper word.. and has been around since long before.. king james bible was written.. AXE and u shall receive.. written clear as glass there....and the britons.. and irishman still use it... be blessed
@@Cubanflowers
Except they're not Irish or Brit,,, just lazy 🙄🤡
People from different regions with different cultures pronounce words differently. I hope that helps.
@Cubanflowers Some of my ancestors were Britons, and I don't say "axe" unless I'm planning to chop down a tree. Perhaps in the 1700s, people could only hear how the people around them mispronounced a word, but this is the 21st century, and we can hear the proper pronunciation by flipping on the TV.
If you decide to own (and continue to feed) a “vicious” dog make sure you have a decent fence at least. Smh.