yeah and from some of the comments 1-the dancers who said jiyeon slapped hwayoung were normal netizens who haven't met T-ara before and they were sued and they admitted their fault 2- if hwayoung posted that fake article in the internet with her real last name won't it be the same as she's saying it with her on mouth ? then why didn't she simply said it ? 3- if what the agency said about hwayoung refusing to go on stage because she wanted them to make her an actress then why did she signed up for an acting contract with the new agency she's gonna be in ? 4- how would someone come up with a story like that ? just like all anti-s do hunni :) 5- those videos that you guys call " prove that they bullied her " if someone else was in hwayoung place you guys will be saying owh how cute their relationship they have bla bla and that funny and owh they look close, but because its hwayoung and T-ara it turned to be bullying ? lot of kpop idols do worst then that to their members and it considered cute and close relationship ugh this is so annoying people get over something that happened over two years ago support both T-ara and hwayoung
Xanath jo - donniejuanvaldez is right; that is one of things I consider in my analysis of the scandal on the Discussion tab of my channel. I have researched the case in depth and written a fair and truthful account of how it developed, which includes many things that most people don't know or haven't thought about. It is long, but I can give you the short version here: T-ara did not bully Hwayoung and she has never claimed that they did. Click here to see it. ua-cam.com/channels/l3R_JIJ80MIfhW5IIAu8nw.htmldiscussion
In the last clip, you can clearly see that there are 5 other members standing next to her and the paper said to dance on one of them. There's obviously a reason she picked Jiyeon, they were pretty close. I don't think T-ara bullied Hwayoung, I think the company did.
In the end, what seems to have happened is that Hwayoung was lazy once, and Jiyeon was struggling, in and out of the hospital, and barely sleeping, and got upset with her for it. Hwayoung expressed that she didn't appreciate that, Jiyeon was still (reasonably) upset, and Hwayoung's contract was terminated because she wasn't working well with the group (even if their music in that era was amazing). The internet and Hwayoung's sister blew the whole situation out of proportion, and things went horribly downhill from there.
Unconfirmed rumors are still rumors ... but hard working of T-ara is the truth ... they are the best girls group of Korea, but why haters bullying T_ara ... one year already, fans should forget the past and support 6-ara !!❣
First of all, I feel that if really Hwayoung was being bullied by T-ara, she was just not keep quiet. All this news is only haters said and create it. As you can see, Hwayoung was so happy and enjoy together with T-ara. It's true that Jiyeon and Eunjung shouldn't have post on social media to let fans and everyone see that they are angry with Hwayoung that time, but common sense if you are angry did you think that much?? But after the incident, they are still forgive Hwayoung and nice to her. Besides that, Hwayoung herself also said that she was not bullied by T-ara. Even she have mentioned in *Taxi* program that "there will sometimes happened between girls". But what I feel it doesn't mean that she said T-ara the one who make her suffer and bullied her. T-ara and Hwayoung all the best and I will always support you. 💪💞😘
i know jiyeon and other members are so close to her but when come to practice they are very strict especially Soyeon,she always care about the other members.
So in my opinion there are 3 sides ppl are taking Hwayoungs side which means some of them are beleiving that the T ara mmbrs were bullying her T ara side which means that T ara didnt bully her and it was hwayoung who was bullying and there is a lot of proof to this and I can accept to this fact(but not 100%) Neither side and blamed CEO for their actions
thế này mà chúng nó kêu t-ara ăn hiếp hwayoung. cho là trên sân khấu Than mật đi v s k nói ra ở nhà như thế nào cứ đưa ra Bằng chứng trên sân khấu k v. một số clip đc fan quay trộm cho thấy các thành viên trong nhóm k hề An hiếp hay bắt nạt j hết mà còn rất thân mật nhưng mà tại s cô hwayoung đó lại tố cáo đồng đội mình bắt nạt mình chứ k hiểu nổi
Hwayoung không nói mk bị bắt nạt mà ẻm chỉ im lặng và đóng vai nạn nhân....2010 khi Hwayoung vừa được thêm vào nhóm thì tình cảm của họ rất tốt nhất là với Jiyeon do họ cùng tuổi với nhau... Sảy ra scandal là do lỗi của cả 2 bên Hwayoung mắc bện ngôi sao quá sớm ,luôn trễ nải lười biếng trong các buổi tập , thậm chí còn tuyên bố không lên sân khấu khi chỉ còn vài giờ nữa thì comeback bắt đầu , Hyomin, Boram, Ahreum và Eunjung phải chia nhau học thuộc rap.... về phía T-ARA thì các chị đã thừa nhận " lúc đó chúng tôi còn quá trẻ nên không làm chủ được cảm xúc bản thân, còn bắt nạt là thực sự không có" : Hyomin said. Quyết định đuổi Hwayoung là từ phía MBK , T-ARA hoàn toàn không có tiếng nói điều này có thể thấy rõ trong việc thay đổi thành viên liên tục " chúng tôi không muốn Hwayoung rời nhóm, chúng tôi đac ở cạnh nhau rất lâu" : Soyeon nói... Sao sự việc Hwayoung xé hợp đồng ,sau vài ngày ẻm có quay lại xin lỗi và mong muốn tiếp tục cùng T-ARA như CEO của MBk đã từ chối " chị ấy đã chăm sóc em rất tốt " Ahreum nói về Hwayoung.... Về phía Qri và Eunjung cả hai đã đăng tải tâm trạng về sự không muốn Hwayoung rời nhóm... những chứng cứ tố T-ARA bắt nạt điều sai sự thật chúng đã được cắt ghép rất nhiều.... thực sự nếu scandal này sảy ra vào 2014 cùng thời điểm với SNSD thì chẳng ai có thể ghét T-ARA cả...sau vụ Jessica rời SNSD thì càng thấy rõ sự thật nội bộ của các nhóm nhạc hàn quốc.
I wish people would just let it go no one can truly know what happened wether it was bullying or not the thing is that im sure all of them are just wanting all of it to stop-.- though it does seem that they arent sincere:/
Part of me wants to believe all of these are rumors, but another part of me believes that all these pretentious get along-ness are only presented when the cameras are rolling.
I think both of Hwayoung and Tara have faults, and did bad things to each other. Don't just blame everythings on only Hwayoung or only Tara. They was so young, and both of them make mistakes to each other.
I was actually shipping them they were so cute but know hatters maked them sad how can some people be that much stupid dont just watch a part of the video and make a judgement but the whole show if you were a true fan !!and for the rice cake in the show even eunjung was punished and she eat it the only true "proof" not for the bully but for them having problem with each other was the tweets buuut it was a simple fight a misunderstoond about the concert even brothers and sisters do fight !!!!
Chill down hatters are u happy know u ruined a very clore relation ship anyway i.truely hope that hwayoung re integre the group that would be awesome ♥
you refuse to believe the rumors because of broadcast shows that show hwayoung and the other members being friendly? do you notice it's a BROADCAST show. they can't show their true selfs in it -.- Hwayoung even posted a statement saying how when the cameras are rolling we're suddenly really good friends, but when it's off i'm a complete outcast don't trust a celebrities character but what you see in a show -.-
that statement was not from Hwayoung, plz say the truth plz =.= and do you know that all the things that people call "prove" were also cut from BROADCAST shows and fancams???? so can I call that the act too????
Hwa young wrote that in the dorm they treat her like transparent and when the camera is on they put their hands around her and act like they are really good friends or rather best friend ._. Just saying . If I'm not wrong .
![[VIDEO PROOF] TRUE or NOT T-ARA bully HWAYOUNG?](/img/n.gif)
yeah and from some of the comments
1-the dancers who said jiyeon slapped hwayoung were normal netizens who haven't met T-ara before and they were sued and they admitted their fault
2- if hwayoung posted that fake article in the internet with her real last name won't it be the same as she's saying it with her on mouth ? then why didn't she simply said it ?
3- if what the agency said about hwayoung refusing to go on stage because she wanted them to make her an actress then why did she signed up for an acting contract with the new agency she's gonna be in ?
4- how would someone come up with a story like that ? just like all anti-s do hunni :)
5- those videos that you guys call " prove that they bullied her " if someone else was in hwayoung place you guys will be saying owh how cute their relationship they have bla bla and that funny and owh they look close, but because its hwayoung and T-ara it turned to be bullying ? lot of kpop idols do worst then that to their members and it considered cute and close relationship
ugh this is so annoying people get over something that happened over two years ago
support both T-ara and hwayoung
7amdowh2 know the truth comes out
Fuck 🐍 hwayoung fib
.............😶
Only t-ara now
T-ara like Hwayoung were bullied by their CEO
Dont think so... the problem started between the girls
Xanath jo - donniejuanvaldez is right; that is one of things I consider in my analysis of the scandal on the Discussion tab of my channel. I have researched the case in depth and written a fair and truthful account of how it developed, which includes many things that most people don't know or haven't thought about. It is long, but I can give you the short version here: T-ara did not bully Hwayoung and she has never claimed that they did. Click here to see it.
ua-cam.com/channels/l3R_JIJ80MIfhW5IIAu8nw.htmldiscussion
HWAYOUNG BULLYING RAT
It's so cute to see them hugging each other *-*
In the last clip, you can clearly see that there are 5 other members standing next to her and the paper said to dance on one of them. There's obviously a reason she picked Jiyeon, they were pretty close. I don't think T-ara bullied Hwayoung, I think the company did.
Hwayoung don't want to be singer and dancer why she join t-ara?
In the end, what seems to have happened is that Hwayoung was lazy once, and Jiyeon was struggling, in and out of the hospital, and barely sleeping, and got upset with her for it. Hwayoung expressed that she didn't appreciate that, Jiyeon was still (reasonably) upset, and Hwayoung's contract was terminated because she wasn't working well with the group (even if their music in that era was amazing). The internet and Hwayoung's sister blew the whole situation out of proportion, and things went horribly downhill from there.
Unconfirmed rumors are still rumors ... but hard working of T-ara is the truth ... they are the best girls group of Korea, but why haters bullying T_ara ... one year already, fans should forget the past and support 6-ara !!❣
1:09 ji yeon so cute
ji yeon i love you
This is adorable. -3 I refuse to believe the rumors.
hwayoung fat snake bullying
@@yngrenebae4438 ;-;
If jiyeon bullys hwa there's no way hwa want to joke with jiyeon like that. And there's no acting at all.
First of all, I feel that if really Hwayoung was being bullied by T-ara, she was just not keep quiet. All this news is only haters said and create it. As you can see, Hwayoung was so happy and enjoy together with T-ara. It's true that Jiyeon and Eunjung shouldn't have post on social media to let fans and everyone see that they are angry with Hwayoung that time, but common sense if you are angry did you think that much?? But after the incident, they are still forgive Hwayoung and nice to her.
Besides that, Hwayoung herself also said that she was not bullied by T-ara. Even she have mentioned in *Taxi* program that "there will sometimes happened between girls". But what I feel it doesn't mean that she said T-ara the one who make her suffer and bullied her. T-ara and Hwayoung all the best and I will always support you. 💪💞😘
Thank you so much. I love SJ too, especially Hee+beom
trust t-ara hwayoung is not be bullied
i know jiyeon and other members are so close to her but when come to practice they are very strict especially Soyeon,she always care about the other members.
HATERS GONNA HATE
OK
Hate 🐍fib fuck hwayoung
Đó chỉ là quá khứ
Mọi thứ đã bị phá bỏ
or in fancams
because the members of any group won't act out of place in front of fan cams
they'll esp act nicer to each other
Tara Jiyeon Hwayoung love you ♥♥♥♥
Looking at this, it is easy. T-ara's company posted hate
well they are infront of CAMERASSS
Zậy mà nói ji bắt nạt hwayoung. Giỡn ầm ầm. Iu 2 unnie.
All I see is love between them!
I miss Hwayoung :(
hate hwayoung
because you fan t ara
Lee Qritiful nghĩ s mày đi nhớ con Hwa cave đó z.. khùng
Minyeon Couple - Hwayoung yêu T-ara.
I hate 🐍 cos behind camera she very fib
you hate t-ara ?
21/05/2017 T-ara như thế này rồi, chắc chị em nhà đó vui lắm nhỉ 😏
It doesn't have to do with the members, it has to do with the CEO.
So in my opinion there are 3 sides ppl are taking
Hwayoungs side which means some of them are beleiving that the T ara mmbrs were bullying her
T ara side which means that T ara didnt bully her and it was hwayoung who was bullying and there is a lot of proof to this and I can accept to this fact(but not 100%)
Neither side and blamed CEO for their actions
Jiyeon😘😘😘😘
yêu thương nhau v ma bảo bắt nạt, con đỉ. Chắc các unnie t6 sốc lắm
this gonna ask the director of CCM .
thế này mà chúng nó kêu t-ara ăn hiếp hwayoung. cho là trên sân khấu Than mật đi v s k nói ra ở nhà như thế nào cứ đưa ra Bằng chứng trên sân khấu k v. một số clip đc fan quay trộm cho thấy các thành viên trong nhóm k hề An hiếp hay bắt nạt j hết mà còn rất thân mật nhưng mà tại s cô hwayoung đó lại tố cáo đồng đội mình bắt nạt mình chứ k hiểu nổi
Hwayoung không nói mk bị bắt nạt mà ẻm chỉ im lặng và đóng vai nạn nhân....2010 khi Hwayoung vừa được thêm vào nhóm thì tình cảm của họ rất tốt nhất là với Jiyeon do họ cùng tuổi với nhau... Sảy ra scandal là do lỗi của cả 2 bên Hwayoung mắc bện ngôi sao quá sớm ,luôn trễ nải lười biếng trong các buổi tập , thậm chí còn tuyên bố không lên sân khấu khi chỉ còn vài giờ nữa thì comeback bắt đầu , Hyomin, Boram, Ahreum và Eunjung phải chia nhau học thuộc rap.... về phía T-ARA thì các chị đã thừa nhận " lúc đó chúng tôi còn quá trẻ nên không làm chủ được cảm xúc bản thân, còn bắt nạt là thực sự không có" : Hyomin said. Quyết định đuổi Hwayoung là từ phía MBK , T-ARA hoàn toàn không có tiếng nói điều này có thể thấy rõ trong việc thay đổi thành viên liên tục " chúng tôi không muốn Hwayoung rời nhóm, chúng tôi đac ở cạnh nhau rất lâu" : Soyeon nói... Sao sự việc Hwayoung xé hợp đồng ,sau vài ngày ẻm có quay lại xin lỗi và mong muốn tiếp tục cùng T-ARA như CEO của MBk đã từ chối " chị ấy đã chăm sóc em rất tốt " Ahreum nói về Hwayoung.... Về phía Qri và Eunjung cả hai đã đăng tải tâm trạng về sự không muốn Hwayoung rời nhóm... những chứng cứ tố T-ARA bắt nạt điều sai sự thật chúng đã được cắt ghép rất nhiều.... thực sự nếu scandal này sảy ra vào 2014 cùng thời điểm với SNSD thì chẳng ai có thể ghét T-ARA cả...sau vụ Jessica rời SNSD thì càng thấy rõ sự thật nội bộ của các nhóm nhạc hàn quốc.
Because....CAMERA!!!!
Ohohoho, i wonder why they're so kind to her... oh wait, there are cameras, that's why.
Elif Korkut 4 years later... Only idiot who still believe a false rumor
the korean only hates t-ara.... but they have so many fansvaround the world
i'm not even Queen's, but even since all rumors spread, i really didn't believe it...
Then you say 'fake' to Hwayoung because she looks so happy with Jiyeon as you can see.
All this hate from a stupid controversy that happened/started what? 3 years ago? shit is old guys. move on
Hwayoung out not because of Jiyeon or other T-ara member
but because of herself, what she ever did to the CEO
it was just dream some of our dreams won't real
But still, why did Hwa Young got kicked out of the company?
Cos her fib everyone
I'm like t-ara because hwayoung only..
Up to you but i hate her cos her fib her is 🐍
I wish people would just let it go no one can truly know what happened wether it was bullying or not the thing is that im sure all of them are just wanting all of it to stop-.- though it does seem that they arent sincere:/
Part of me wants to believe all of these are rumors, but another part of me believes that all these pretentious get along-ness are only presented when the cameras are rolling.
I think both of Hwayoung and Tara have faults, and did bad things to each other. Don't just blame everythings on only Hwayoung or only Tara. They was so young, and both of them make mistakes to each other.
I was actually shipping them they were so cute but know hatters maked them sad how can some people be that much stupid dont just watch a part of the video and make a judgement but the whole show if you were a true fan !!and for the rice cake in the show even eunjung was punished and she eat it the only true "proof" not for the bully but for them having problem with each other was the tweets buuut it was a simple fight a misunderstoond about the concert even brothers and sisters do fight !!!!
what about fancam?
did you see it with your eyes?
Chill down hatters are u happy know u ruined a very clore relation ship anyway i.truely hope that hwayoung re integre the group that would be awesome ♥
you see it in your dreams:)
Eunjung casanova, take your wife! huh >
เหมือนฮวายองพยายาม สนิทกับวง แต่รู้สึกวงไม่ได้รู้สึกจริงๆว่าฮวายองเป็นสมาชิก
ลับหลังมันตอแหลนี่ชอบตะวาดสตาฟไร้มารยาทกับช่างแต่งหน้าและช่างทำผมเรียกสตาฟหลายคนเหมือนเป็นคนใช้
Prq ja sabiam como ela realmente era
you refuse to believe the rumors because of broadcast shows that show hwayoung and the other members being friendly?
do you notice it's a BROADCAST show. they can't show their true selfs in it -.-
Hwayoung even posted a statement saying how when the cameras are rolling we're suddenly really good friends, but when it's off i'm a complete outcast
don't trust a celebrities character but what you see in a show -.-
Is she still in the entertainment industry. Or she lives in ordinary life ryt now? (Hwayoung)
What song is this?
Day by bay
Looking at this, I
🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍
i think jiyeon and hwayoung close but because of her some unnies she someties bad to her
that statement was not from Hwayoung, plz say the truth plz =.= and do you know that all the things that people call "prove" were also cut from BROADCAST shows and fancams???? so can I call that the act too????
Hwayoung 🐍behind camera her very fib no manners with staff
zậy mà keenh14 vs ji tát hwa đúng là tin vịt
there are anything for bully here between them (Y)
Hwa young wrote that in the dorm they treat her like transparent and when the camera is on they put their hands around her and act like they are really good friends or rather best friend ._. Just saying . If I'm not wrong .
Mương 14))
sometimes jiyeon acts so sweet towards hwayoung. but sometimes she also treats her like a dirt
bleeee
*_dẹp mẹ đi :)))_*
(null)
Fake je