nicolas L'Ecluse nope she wasn't even being left out. The situations where it looked like that were due to her own choices or just mere coincidence/teasing which happen to all the members
I know this is old but if you look at it deeper, the amount of good times Hwayoung and the other members spent with each other actually OUTWEIGHS the times where they had arguments. I mean come on, every group have arguments if not why are they humans? humans make mistakes guys. WAKE UP! these people just used some cut scenes to make it like as if T-ARA bullied Hwayoung. They just had arguments what is wrong with that? MBK ENT is also at fault, they suck at handling these kind of situations.
People, let's settle this down. Many say Hwayoung was bullied by T-ARA, but actually Hwayoung is not a victim. She acted up. She said she needed rest at the for her injury but then she went on a nail salon? The other members were working hard performing and to count Jiyeon's injuries, it was more and was worse than anything Hwayoung can experience. They got mad but they didn't bully Hwayoung, they only told her that what she did was so selfish and unprofessional. It was wrong that the members didn't say it calmly. But they have the right to get mad. In addition, before Hwayoung was in the airport, she was walking normally but when she was out at the airport, she had two men assisting her. Then she had a cast that she immediately threw away, just for the show and sympathy of the media and fans.
This is what happened: I only become a T-ara fan after the scandal and when other people and even my friends joined the hate wagon ....i decided that i would only make up my mind after i can see the whole picture not what antis want me to see. So in 2012 T-ara made their comeback with Day By Day they were at their height of the fame and were rivaling snsd and 2ne1. Hwayoung was injured a week after and performed on a chair performance once and then refused to perform on Music bank before 5 minutes of the show which lead the team to mess the dance and read from card boards (you can search for the live performance yourself). Still nothing happened after that because Hwayoung was expected to perform at their first ever big scale concert Budokan...but she actually refused to perform eventhough kks asked her to perform on a chair....The members were furious T-ara debuted as 6 members in 2009 and they worked heard since then. Hwayoung was added in 2010...but she seemed the least motivated (that's why she had the least fans). All the members had to perform even with injuries but why Hwayoung think she can not when even kks told her she can perform on a chair? A member absent meant a lot extra work re-forming the dances with a short time ....T-ara voiced their opinion on twitter and nobody expected them to be meant as bullying (because they weren't targeting anybody and were just talking about determination) until hwayoung replied implying she is a victim.
it breaks my heart when they hate t-ara. i have seen how hard they worked since their debut. especially eunjung. she could fall asleep anywhere because she was THAT exhausted. and i have seen eunjung and jiyeon perform with injuries.
Hello everyone, I am new to T-ARA and glad that i missed all the scandals. I do want to say that their songs are very catchy. I'm just glad and happy to find this talented group and now being part of my life. Now i can't stop searching for more of their videos to watch. T-ARA just gained a new fan. Fighting!!
This girls are bit harsh to each other. They tease each other, doing pranks but why you only see Hwayoung as a victim and hate T-ARA so much? 1. In dream girls- The girls pranked Hyomin and Eunjung by telling the two that they were going to be a diver. They laughed secretly when they fell on the pranks and plunged their faces on the basin with water. 2. Hello baby- Soyeon and Jiyeon put a lot of chili on Eunjung ramen because Eunjung is being harsh and keep saying that they lost the challenge. 3. Dream girls- they were acting (Jiyeon and Soyeon as mother and child/Hyomin and Eunjung as old couple) Jiyeon tapped Qri's shoulder really hard. BUT WHY in the evidences they only show Hwayoung being tapped by Jiyeon. It is very clear that the antis just used T-ARA's tweets to form a new story. Patch things, edits pictures and vids and made a new story to tear them apart. Sorry guys they are still alive and standing.
Haha. Hwayoung is bitter. Posting something again and many thinks its because of T-ara's successful comeback. The girls are still successful earning a lot of money and fame.
Iamqueen lea definitely! Hwayoung came to T-ARA as a nightmare and leave as their worst nightmare! So trashy! I hate myself for thinking bad things to hwayoung but I just cant help it, she ruin our girls image so I will ruin her also thats the game of kpop world. Tss bias must be on TOP no matter what!
Chelsea Ahito I used to like her before even she is not in T-ara anymore but posting that clove apple on her account is not a coincedence she really made it to seek for attention. She wants to grab attention using T-aras bad image due to the scandal
I feel sorry for Tara. And nowadays the new target is SNSD. This is the greatest rumor of all time in K-Pop. Jessica's personality doesn't match to be bullies. It would be more believable Jessica bully other member. Seriously, hater they don't care if it's true but only fact. Now haters are say Hayoung is really b**ch that is why tara bullies her.
This is what pisses me off. even people who believe the scandal was false still think Hwayoung was a victim/saint. she stayed quiet and gave vague statements for A LONG TIME so T-ara could get hated and she could ride the wave of sympathy and get more fame. she's evil. anyone who has done their research knows that.
lmao it's not hwayoung's fault if tara members were immature by posting those tweets. if hwayoung was a problem, then they should have fixed the problem privately. but no, they threw shade and shit happened. karma. even the members themselfs admitted that it was a mistake posting those tweets. the scandal was already too big, their ceo couldnt handle it well and told them to stay quiet. and that's that, you liking or not. i'm not saying hwayoung is innocent, but all of them did wrong lol
Amanda Mello Excuse me? Throwing shade at a lying parasite who does none of the work but gets paid none the less is a sin? What T-ara members had to go through was karma? You must be a lot like hwayoung yourself to feel that way. Best of luck with life
+Mish Mish the girls THEMSELVES admitted that what they did was wrong. they said in an interview that they shouldn't have made those tweets, they even reflected a lot about that. lmao if she was a lying parasite, if she was doing none of the work, then be mature, talk to the ceo and try to fix the problem. the scandal started because of those tweets. you liking or not ;)
This made me cry :( Even though I'm hating Hwayoung right now but I do miss the beatiful old days, when they didnt have to figure out with all those false scandal rumours. I'm so upset that Hwayoung is the trouble's start and she turned out to be an innocent girl, who was the patient of that bully shit. T-Ara brought her popularity and those unnies sent her love. But then she threw everything away with maybe just a little misunderstanding situation. Left without a word of explaining or whatever. She mad me!!! But I found out that I still look up for Hwayoung sometimes, to see if she really was bullied by T-Ara. And then I just feel sad about those lovely days from them. It's not T-Ara or even Hwayoung was the troublemaker, the bad had just come. Proud to know T-Ara is too strong to stand up against the hate!!!
I dont know why did it came out as bullying. People dont know anything. They just believe in directors cut videos so they think its bullying. They havent even watched the whole video. And one thing, if hwayoung was bullied then why didnt she speak about it?
Nobody can know their inside relationship between Jiyeon or T-ara and Hwayoung though. There are two statements spreading online. 1. T-ara bullied Hwayoung. 2. T-ara DIDN'T bully Hwayoung. But as I watch this video and such videos online and gather my own thoughts, I conclude T-ara DIDN'T bully Hwayoung because a simple one fact: you can see Hwayoung's parts are in many of the T-ara music videos. Second fact, the "bullying" case wasn't show up until they had a fight (I'm sure it must have been really a big fight, like someone cursed somebody's parents and family.) And I think, if Hwayoung had been being bullied by T-ara members since LONG TIME AGO, why T-ara's "bullying" news didn't come out to public? And Hwayoung was happy with t-ara members until the fight, right?
I really don't know what to believe... but never the less thanks for making this! You are truly a dedicated fan and T-ARA is very lucky to have people like you still on their side. It's inspiring and I hope the people who judged without seeing everything will change their minds when they watch this video.
rumors are just rumors and haters gonna hate but past is past so please if they really bullied her (but i don't think so) they had a really good reason no one bully someone without a reason!
Looking at this after all these years, makes me show that idols are not always as they were, incredible to see comments from years ago agreeing with Hwayoung and blaming the members of that time of T-ara.
I agree with Chris Yau. I remember once Eunjung also mentioned that she wasn't very pleased about adding more members since some of them were quite lazy and arrogant while elder members were forced to work hard. I think that if they were bullying Hwa Young, she wouldn't be so silly to say that out. Those interested in bullying will always say good things about their victims in front of people to pretend they are good person. But Eunjung and other members are not like that.
T-ara doesn't deserve any hates. Why? because all of those bullshit rumors and scandals are NOT even true! They work their butt off so no, they don't deserve any of those bullshit hates. I'm not saying all people in Korea but also some other country too that also hates T-ara by believing those fucking bullshit rumors and scandals. People in Korea, need to stop hating them because they did nothing wrong. Queens are perfect and they have the best fan's service ever! I have been to T-ara concert before (once) and they all are SUPER nice to fans. They are not only acting nice but they are actually being nice to us fans! If you're the one that hates T-ara, please don't hate them because they did nothing wrong! They are NOT a bully! Please haters, stop all the bullshit hates!!!
PERFECT.... watching this made a tear slide down my cheek. How can the old fans watch this and not regret doing what they did?? turn their backs on our girls when they needed their fans the most. How many Fans know about the Petition to fight against those who want the dissolution of T-ara? i would post the link... but don't know if the person who did this would let me?
haters gonna hate.. without any proof they are just being nonsense and naive!! really dislike the antis.. i admit that T-ara being immature when that day they tweeted some "scolding" words on Hwayoung... but that's because antis dont understand how important the japan concert was to the girls.. they value that so much! im not saying Hwayoung being wrong not to perform... and yeah.. sometimes things/ argue should be solve among them... but they apologized for the childish tweets already!!! why cant haters understand the girls more... once a Queen's forever a Queen's love this video, and love my T-ara unnies... so proud of them!
Thanks for posting this. I haven't seen a lot of these pics. Now I am sure it was the 'company' that wanted Hwayoung out. Seemed like she got along with everyone of the girls. And like a family everyone has their disagreements. But I think all this has gotten blown up out of proportion. I love this video and still love all of T-ARA...including Hwayoung.....
please stop blaming t ara.. they did nothing to hwayoung.. hwayoung also admit it... it is common to prank each other if they are close.. i was a fan of t ara.. but i didnt hate them bcause of this stupid thing.. i just left because i want to be a fan of boy group.. my bias in t ara was hwayoung,, but i think positive of this case.. so, i didnt hate t ara and i still keep in touch with their show or comeback.. just please stop blaming them.. they also have emotion.. what if you are one of them,, and this happen when you did nothing and people keep talking shit to you.. what do you feel? think positive not negative..
@@coffeepinklove Oh. I'm sorry cus I reply to you after 5 years. Btw, that guy on your profile pic is so cute. Who is he? That guy looks like Woojin + Hyunjin. Lol.
If you never once prank your best friends/gangs,I pity you. I bet your childhood was extremely horrible. Jiyeon always shows her true self on-camera. She does what she want. She says what she want. Jiyeon is a cute spoilt brat that like to prank and hit others. So what? She is just being herself. Variety shows are made so that the fans can know how their idols are. She even hit Qri not just Hwayoung.
Hwa never said that she was being bullied......Have you searched this news seriously? She did not perform in Japan because she went to beauty salon. But she finally replied to her boss that she was sick. The adminstration of the company was angry about that so CCM fired Hwa. If Hwa really being bullied, she should say it out, but Hwa did not. T-ara are immature but it does not mean they are bad. They argue on Twitter doesn't mean they bully her, T-ara want Hwayoung to be more hard-working by the way in which they convince her on Twitter. Also, hwa's sister now is still a staff in CCM, if hwa was really being buillied, her sister would not stay in CCM.
you can tell they miss her , especially during the Day by Day performance without her, Soyeon sounded more sad, Areum looks like she was about to cry and Hyomin was mad during the Hwayoung rap
Despite everything, I miss them all together... I wish none of that would happen and T-ara ot8 would come back... but not everything we want is what we have😭😭😭
t-ara pls don't be deeply affected by the rumors continue to work hard and prepare some good performances and songs for us even though without hwayoung, u all should look ahead of the future and keep on moving even though hwayoung is no longer in the group but I guess she will support u all from the back. T-ara hwaiting 😉😃😘
I'm so happy to found out that they are people who are still supporting T-ARA, im not a Queen, but i like them, when all the news were around, i couldn't believe it, they are not like that. I hope everything is solved and T-ARA can be back on stage with all their members
If T-ARA is brave enough to apologized then why hwayoung didnt come out and apologize as well? If she was proof innocent enough, she must apologized from her eunnie's side also even tho "ego" pride will turn down. Have you guys thought about it?
I've never really took side to this affair but after watching this video, I think the possibility of bullying is small actually… Besides, I've never been a T-Ara fan really, even though I like their musics, so I don't know this group really well ^^ Anyway Fighting~
thx u for making this ^.^ I'm not a Queen. I just love Eunjung ~.~. I don't know much about the personalities of T ara and Hwayoung. I'm sure that netizen also not know. But why they said as they know them clearly... Poor Eunjung.... I know this scandal is the worst of the worst. But everything will be ok. Unnie, 5ting. Your true fans always stay by your side...
Rumors start from haters. People that believes the rumors are dumb. There, just a simple explanation how all this happened. Probably the person that spread this out wanted an interview because he/she wants to be famous.
It doesn't matter anyway, the past is the past. Both sides did wrong in some way, they could've settled it if they wanted, but they chose not to. So the outcome of their actions is the outcome they have to deal with.
Sally ToPics T-ara with their tweets.........and hwayoung dont want to perform.....and go to nail shop while other are working....so both are wrong........nah...its the past know..
@thumperpet86 SO? Are you the people who took camera in front of them? Videos can be edited easily using high-tech gadgets. There were also many videos which proven that those bullied videos were sevely edited. Also, no one created rumors about other groups, so that other groups' members are nice? T-ara and Hwa also have a lot of touching moments. If T-ara told to Hwa where considered as bullying, in my life, I have no friends till now. If T-ara reminded Hwa on Twitter where considered as bullied, in my ilfe, my parents always bullied me. "If she's being bullied.....if she is being bullied.." Because the fact is that she did not suffer bullying. If your idols have these rumors, I am sure you will not say this is bullying. Those evidence saying that T-ara are bullies which are not established and unilateral. If those evidence take to the court, I am sure they can't take any stance.
" i want to kinda believe hwayoungs story of being bullied because why would she lie about it?" She didn't lie, cuz she never say that she's being bullied.. It's netizen who suddenly came up with "evidences" and suddenly it seems like she's being bullied..
@donniejuanvaldez T-ara were mean to Hwa? WTF! What do you think who you are!? T-ara and Hwa also have a lot of touching moments. You are not the person along with them, why are you so sure? You only search the second-hand information at the internet!
Happy 4th Annivesarry T-Ara! I support T-Ara until the end. BTW, I had a feeling they did not bully Hwayoung as if they truly hated Hwayoung, would they show their hates to the camera for the people to know that they hate that person?? T-Ara Forever 3
Just an honest opinion ... I'm not a big fan of T-ara or any K-Pop culture per say?! Although, I happen to know and like some of the most popular K-Pop or Korean songs, i sang and moved with the beat... Anyways, I happen to came across the T-ara's while browsing UA-cam just few days ago. So, I was intrigued! I took time watching them and knowing them. Google them. Every video that appears in my UA-cam window, I watched. But, I was intrigued more with such unlikely comments... (probably not real fans?!). And so, I searched and try to know more of them until, I came across your, +QueensWorldwide 's account. Somehow, in my honest opinion, truly, your efforts have vindicated them, The T-ara's from such malicious intrigues that have escalated and have tarnished these young ladies' names. I felt sorry for them for what they have gone through. But, they move in this dog eat dog kind of world. No one is spared from intrigues. They have to be strong willed to be able to surpassed all of it. Accept that not everyone will appreciate them. Like what happened, some looked down on them, used them, mocked them. And I'm glad that somehow they manage to pull through! Showing they can be mature and wise with their actions. Having resilience in the face of adversity as they say. In such a short time, I can say that these are fine young ladies. They were young once, friendly, playful and yet misunderstood! Just felt sorry too for Hwayoung! They all suffered from the so called ... misconception and the devious media tactics of escalating rumors to make their advances. So sad that it had to happen! I hope they continue pursuing their dreams, wherever they are! More Power to T-ARA! God bless. " THE TONGUE HAS NO BONES, BUT IT IS STRONG ENOUGH TO BREAK A HEART. SO BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR WORDS. " :)
i also like tiara. i don't know whether the bullying is true or not (will keep a positive mind) but it is to be expected that she will become an outcast because she is a new member who joined after the other 6 had been together for so long, endured many hardships together, and became a success. you have to think about the other 6 also, (they may feel insulted that since another member is joining, what about their hard work, was it not enough). Also you have to be Korean to also understand their culture where they respect their elders even by 1 year older. and she joined in as one of the youngest and also she mentioned she was timid. I always and will always believe that the media/biased people will always blow things out of proportion. Not hating on any of the 7 people involved. but it would have been great to see what would have happened if the 8 member group had been formed
i dont think t-ara ever intentionally bullied hwayoung. but i think hwayoung did feel left out at times because the others have stronger personalities, particularly jiyeon.
I'm Vietnamese! I do not understand why people who used to be fans turned their backs on t-ara because a scandal was not true. It was unfair to the t-ara who had been ostracized for the past few years in the warmth. I ask the anti you do not do that anymore they have been shocked too big and can not stand it anymore !!
Eunjung said that they'd had arguments at times but that there was no bullying, and that they were surprised and sad to see Hwayoung get fired. She also said they were immature to scold her on twitter after the concert/beauty shop incident.
I'm happy for this video, you did a great job, i felt relief and this is my first, watched EunJung kiss HwaYoung...T-ARA..you're not alone...HwaYoung,you are not alone..stay strong and I pray for those haters, that they will love T-ARA after this. Haters, you're not gonna be happy for the rest of your life because you're haunted by guilt. If you wanna be happy, it's so easy , just say your sorry and let's be friend? ^_^
wahhhhh..thanks uploader! this made me cry! HOPE THAT THOSE ANTI's WILL OPEN THEIR EYES, AND SEE FOR THEMSELVES THE TRUTH! T-ARA FIGHTING!~ PROUD TO BE QUEEN~
After watch this, I believe that the scandal was made by the fucking antis. There is nothing wrong with them. It's normal if they are joking around because they are family! Poor Hwayoung. I wish I can back at that time so I could change MBK mind to not terminate Hwayoung's contract. but...sigh, it will never happen...and I wish Korean will realize and just move on same goes to other fans who are dissapointed with Hwayoung departure and stop being immature..if Korean still hate them dont worry China and Japan Queens are indeed loyal fans!! Proud Queen here!
poor hwayoung? she could have gone to the media and given one interview saying NO T-ARA DIDNT BULLY HER. but she didn't. she's to blame for T-ara's suffering too. T-ara was and will always be the original 6
I'm a Kamilia, and even I support ALL the members of T-ara. Why did one rumor of bullying suddenly discredit every single nice moment the T-ara members have with each other? All the videos of them being nice to each other become fake while all vids of them "ignoring" each other become heartless. Leave them alone already! T-ARA fighting! Hwayoung fighting! (True) Queens fighting!
I think the members may be a little annoyed that Hawyoung has joined a group already made and often feel that she doesn't work hard. They also seem to leave her out sometimes but I wouldn't go as far as to say it is bullying, just a little awkward and perhaps a bit harsh but they don't seem to have cruel intent towards her.
I really miss T-ara. I will support the girls forever. I didn't believe they bullied Hwayoung. I didn't believe the rumors. I believe T-ara, they can do it. They need to suffer because of the rumors and poor Qri or Ah Reum, the innocent ones. Why do antis have to do this. T-ARA HWAITING!
Just think about why did hwayoung wrote that? And why she said she was being bullied? If she wasn't bullied she wouldn't had left the group, right. Just the point of view of a normal person ( not a hater, not a fan).
Hey hey, Hwa Young did not wrote that, it was just a coincidence. Also, if she really was bullied, why didn't she speak out. No one can threat her anymore since she had already left and she had her fans. One more point, her sister stayed in CCM. If she knew that her sister Hwa Young was treated unfair like that, why would she stay? If you can answers those questions thoroughly, then I will agree with you. But if not, well, you are not very convincing.
How is that a coincidence...? There's obviously a reason why she wrote it and if not her members then who else? You act like it would be soo easy for her to speak out about the bullying but its not easy, especially if all members, most staff, and the company didn't even care about her.Do you think hwayoung would really let her sister quit the company over her? No of course not! Why let her sister's career end because hers was bad?? In reality you queens aren't very convincing because all you do is ask and never even give proof. So what? some fanmade video to support tara is your proof?
There are too much truths that we don't know. Truth about the CCM, Truth about T-ara and Hwayoung. Nobody will know the truth but themselves. The thing has passes by more than 1 year, they were all bullied by someone, some scandals. If people still support both T-ara and Hwayoung, all we can do is stop arguing, and stop hurting them with all those "truths" that has not proved. All we can do is blessing both of them having a bright future and when they meet again one day, they can smile to each others and say unnie, i miss u. Best wish for T-ara and Hwayoung
maybe they were really close like true blooded sisters. hmm... well, sisters fight too so why they can't. maybe the latter times when they were still together with hwayoung there must have been a misunderstanding and it showed in their actions and those actions started the rumors. It was solved but it's too late as the damage was huge. hmm... great work, you gave me some evidences that sometime in their lives they've become so close... so sad but if only they have been cautious enough of their actions this wont happen... well then, i think they have moved on... it's a good thing... (forgive my english)
Just because she was nice to them doesn't mean they were too her, I mean in most of the videos its hwayoung being nice to the other members...and what?she has to make a full statement to the public about the bullying so that people could believe her? You queens act like if she was bullied she should of said something, but in reality its harder than that, especially if all the members and some staff were against her.
but ya know in the videos t-ara were nice to hwayoung too n how do u kno that the staffs were against her? but ya i agree with u bout being scared to speak out but thats just call assuming things without knowing anything.. which is what every fan nd haters do,,and i think u r assuming from the so called "proofs" n the hateful things that the haters say bout them!!!
Tbh i think that EVERY idol group should be respected and do not deserve all this. No matter what they do, we have no rights to judge. I mean they ALL went through SO MUCH even before they debut
the other members of t-ara never bully t-ara hwayoung..if you watch this video you can see how sweet the other members in hwayoung unnie..but if you say that the other members just sweet to hwayoung unnie if the camera is rolling..do you have a proof?if the other t-ara members bully hwayoung unnie?non right?so don't judge.what if their is a reason why hwayoung unnie leave the group..T-ARA FIGHTING..T-ARA HWAYOUNG BACK TO T-ARA PLEASE..i cry when i watch this video gosh!
umm hell no. hwayoung made full use of the sympathy she got as a 'victim'...she's also responsible for T-ara's suffering. and T-ara was and always will be the original 6!
This video makes me smile,, cry,,, and feel very happy because i love them SO MUCH!!!!! JIYEON and other T-ARA!!!!! Stay strong!!! I'll keep fighting so thT i will meet you all!!!
DO I CARE with HATERS??? Nah….I JUST CARE with T-ARA. Closed-minded people will believed what they want to believed anyway. It's just a waste of time arguing to people who wouldn't listen and understand the real situation (why? Because they don't care) So I also DON'T CARE WITH HATERS. My love and support will forever with T-ARA!
Abing Abing What kind of opinion? If you are giving the benefit of the doubt for the 2 parties involve I respect everyone's opinion...but if you are insulting and comment non-sense without knowing what had happened then you are a closed minded.
I wonder. Do you know how Hwayoung feel if you in her position? or did you know Hwayoung was or wasnt bullied? Did you know their real life looks like? In my opinion maybe there is a bully Hwayoung nor Qri. Cause I used to be their fans and kinda disappointed on them. And from my point of view. Did T-ara help her while she was hurt? if they say birthday greeting to Hwayoung it could be fake too you know.. They are public figure and they might told by the manager to did that so the case shouldnt be spread. T-ara maybe fake too, Anyways the case already passed. and stop war thing and cursing. Its my opinion. *my english lacks a lot sorry for bad grammar*
Am I the only one who thinks "we can't know?..." I'm not part of the T-ARA fandom (that doesn't mean I hate them) but I think the people who believe or don't believe are being seriously rude... most comments written by people who support T-ARA sound like: "EFF haters they know nothing" and people who are hating on T-ARA sound like "EFF supporters they are blind"... I think the point of this video and many other videos regarding the bullying matter is to discuss and share information on the matter... if you guys are not caring bout other opinions and leaving rude comments to diss the other party then don't leave your comment at all.
Hwayoung said she was not bullied and supported T-ara, so why did you think she was bullied and don't you trust her? What did she say that was not true? The people I don't trust are KKS and some of the staff - their behaviour makes me suspicious and their stories don't fit with the evidence of the members, but Hwayoung, Areum and the original six all say virtually the same things. Hwayoung is not a snake and doesn't deserve the hate. Read my fair and truthful account of how the scandal developed. The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com
Although Snsd play pranks on each other sometimes, you can tell tell they just take it for fun, whereas in t ara u can feel that its on purpose and they are really laughing at hwayoung anyway its all over so dont bother
I sort of feel that way too, because of jessicas cold nature, ppl who are not close to her may not like her. But for snsd they ignore, you dont see them bullying. Taeyeon and jess had some conflict, you could see that tae disliked jess but she didnt bully, she ignored
Please stop judging and spreading rumors if you do not know what happened between them. All those proofs and videos were denied and HwaYoung did stated that she was not being bullied. If you chose to not believe in T-ara then just leave them alone, they don't deserve being treated this way when everything was explained yet people like you are still accusing them for things that they didn't do
![Last Day at Two Days and One Night [Two Days and One Night 4 Ep2345-1] | KBS WORLD TV 240728](/img/n.gif)
South Korea, such a technologically advanced country with medieval era minded citizens.
T-ara haven't bully Hwayoung,it's the true answer.
Agreed
hwayoung never said she was bullied
in my opinion she was just being left out by the others
nicolas L'Ecluse nope she wasn't even being left out. The situations where it looked like that were due to her own choices or just mere coincidence/teasing which happen to all the members
Agreed
@@nicolaslecluse5427 Qri even took a lot of selfies with her
I feel sorry for Eunjung, she deserves more success.
she is the true victim
if you don't love t ara,others people will love them
THIS IS WHY YOU DONT ADD NEW MEMBERS TO A GROUP! THEY CANT TAKE THE JOKES THAT THE OLD MEMBERS ARE USED TO>..
Yes
I know this is old but if you look at it deeper, the amount of good times Hwayoung and the other members spent with each other actually OUTWEIGHS the times where they had arguments. I mean come on, every group have arguments if not why are they humans? humans make mistakes guys. WAKE UP! these people just used some cut scenes to make it like as if T-ARA bullied Hwayoung. They just had arguments what is wrong with that? MBK ENT is also at fault, they suck at handling these kind of situations.
true
one of the t-ara members spoke out on the taxi show saying the reason she left t-ara was indeed because of bullying.
asn k Abusive? Bro go and read the real news.
asn k No seriously how is that abusive?
GIGAMANIAC Tan nope. hwayoung father control mbk at that times.. so no wonder
People, let's settle this down. Many say Hwayoung was bullied by T-ARA, but actually Hwayoung is not a victim. She acted up. She said she needed rest at the for her injury but then she went on a nail salon? The other members were working hard performing and to count Jiyeon's injuries, it was more and was worse than anything Hwayoung can experience. They got mad but they didn't bully Hwayoung, they only told her that what she did was so selfish and unprofessional. It was wrong that the members didn't say it calmly. But they have the right to get mad. In addition, before Hwayoung was in the airport, she was walking normally but when she was out at the airport, she had two men assisting her. Then she had a cast that she immediately threw away, just for the show and sympathy of the media and fans.
Agree with u.. so I don't like her. Feel happy that she is not in T-ARA now
Kyungsoo Do it's okay tho resting in a nail salon
Vanessa Alexis Ikr? Isn't that what you do when you rest or chill?
UssagieeTheUnicorn i also go to the bar, go to the cafe, etc. And what's the problem with that lol.
Vanessa Alexis Families sometimes quarel, just that
This is what happened:
I only become a T-ara fan after the scandal and when other people and even my friends joined the hate wagon ....i decided that i would only make up my mind after i can see the whole picture not what antis want me to see.
So in 2012 T-ara made their comeback with Day By Day they were at their height of the fame and were rivaling snsd and 2ne1. Hwayoung was injured a week after and performed on a chair performance once and then refused to perform on Music bank before 5 minutes of the show which lead the team to mess the dance and read from card boards (you can search for the live performance yourself).
Still nothing happened after that because Hwayoung was expected to perform at their first ever big scale concert Budokan...but she actually refused to perform eventhough kks asked her to perform on a chair....The members were furious T-ara debuted as 6 members in 2009 and they worked heard since then. Hwayoung was added in 2010...but she seemed the least motivated (that's why she had the least fans).
All the members had to perform even with injuries but why Hwayoung think she can not when even kks told her she can perform on a chair?
A member absent meant a lot extra work re-forming the dances with a short time ....T-ara voiced their opinion on twitter and nobody expected them to be meant as bullying (because they weren't targeting anybody and were just talking about determination) until hwayoung replied implying she is a victim.
heyy there im just really curious did your friends change their minds about hating t-ara or did they not ??
it breaks my heart when they hate t-ara. i have seen how hard they worked since their debut. especially eunjung. she could fall asleep anywhere because she was THAT exhausted. and i have seen eunjung and jiyeon perform with injuries.
I don't understand why they are so harsh towards them, but when others groups bicker each other members, the public love that. Why it is only T-ara?😢
Fuck Hwayoung,, i am also think if her not victim of bullying,, why not say anything to netizen. What so enjoy with their group break up ???
@@littlekyojin5450 Yeah so great and congrats to give up being human only to join the snake species
I never believed in this scandal. Always be a tara fan. Love their new song "Tiamo" Which is lovely.
Hello everyone, I am new to T-ARA and glad that i missed all the scandals. I do want to say that their songs are very catchy. I'm just glad and happy to find this talented group and now being part of my life. Now i can't stop searching for more of their videos to watch. T-ARA just gained a new fan. Fighting!!
Thanks for making the video, song and the message your videos transmits makes me feel touched :')
Let's support T-ara always!
Fighting!!
This girls are bit harsh to each other. They tease each other, doing pranks but why you only see Hwayoung as a victim and hate T-ARA so much?
1. In dream girls- The girls pranked Hyomin and Eunjung by telling the two that they were going to be a diver. They laughed secretly when they fell on the pranks and plunged their faces on the basin with water.
2. Hello baby- Soyeon and Jiyeon put a lot of chili on Eunjung ramen because Eunjung is being harsh and keep saying that they lost the challenge.
3. Dream girls- they were acting (Jiyeon and Soyeon as mother and child/Hyomin and Eunjung as old couple) Jiyeon tapped Qri's shoulder really hard. BUT WHY in the evidences they only show Hwayoung being tapped by Jiyeon.
It is very clear that the antis just used T-ARA's tweets to form a new story. Patch things, edits pictures and vids and made a new story to tear them apart. Sorry guys they are still alive and standing.
Fighting!!
They teased Hwayoung out of hatred
Haha. Hwayoung is bitter. Posting something again and many thinks its because of T-ara's successful comeback. The girls are still successful earning a lot of money and fame.
Iamqueen lea definitely! Hwayoung came to T-ARA as a nightmare and leave as their worst nightmare! So trashy! I hate myself for thinking bad things to hwayoung but I just cant help it, she ruin our girls image so I will ruin her also thats the game of kpop world. Tss bias must be on TOP no matter what!
Chelsea Ahito I used to like her before even she is not in T-ara anymore but posting that clove apple on her account is not a coincedence she really made it to seek for attention. She wants to grab attention using T-aras bad image due to the scandal
I just feel that the anti-t-ara fans and neitizens faked the scandal thing..
I feel sorry for Tara. And nowadays the new target is SNSD. This is the greatest rumor of all time in K-Pop. Jessica's personality doesn't match to be bullies. It would be more believable Jessica bully other member. Seriously, hater they don't care if it's true but only fact. Now haters are say Hayoung is really b**ch that is why tara bullies her.
This is what pisses me off. even people who believe the scandal was false still think Hwayoung was a victim/saint. she stayed quiet and gave vague statements for A LONG TIME so T-ara could get hated and she could ride the wave of sympathy and get more fame. she's evil. anyone who has done their research knows that.
of course she stayed quiet. her ceo told her to stay quiet. even tara members didnt say a word
Yeah the CEO told her to not tell people that she infact was NOT bullied? That's a very interesting theory.
lmao it's not hwayoung's fault if tara members were immature by posting those tweets. if hwayoung was a problem, then they should have fixed the problem privately. but no, they threw shade and shit happened. karma. even the members themselfs admitted that it was a mistake posting those tweets.
the scandal was already too big, their ceo couldnt handle it well and told them to stay quiet. and that's that, you liking or not. i'm not saying hwayoung is innocent, but all of them did wrong lol
Amanda Mello Excuse me? Throwing shade at a lying parasite who does none of the work but gets paid none the less is a sin? What T-ara members had to go through was karma? You must be a lot like hwayoung yourself to feel that way. Best of luck with life
+Mish Mish the girls THEMSELVES admitted that what they did was wrong. they said in an interview that they shouldn't have made those tweets, they even reflected a lot about that. lmao if she was a lying parasite, if she was doing none of the work, then be mature, talk to the ceo and try to fix the problem. the scandal started because of those tweets. you liking or not ;)
This made me cry :( Even though I'm hating Hwayoung right now but I do miss the beatiful old days, when they didnt have to figure out with all those false scandal rumours.
I'm so upset that Hwayoung is the trouble's start and she turned out to be an innocent girl, who was the patient of that bully shit. T-Ara brought her popularity and those unnies sent her love. But then she threw everything away with maybe just a little misunderstanding situation. Left without a word of explaining or whatever. She mad me!!!
But I found out that I still look up for Hwayoung sometimes, to see if she really was bullied by T-Ara. And then I just feel sad about those lovely days from them.
It's not T-Ara or even Hwayoung was the troublemaker, the bad had just come. Proud to know T-Ara is too strong to stand up against the hate!!!
They also pranked Jiyeon LMAO
I dont know why did it came out as bullying. People dont know anything. They just believe in directors cut videos so they think its bullying. They havent even watched the whole video. And one thing, if hwayoung was bullied then why didnt she speak about it?
Nobody can know their inside relationship between Jiyeon or T-ara and Hwayoung though.
There are two statements spreading online.
1. T-ara bullied Hwayoung.
2. T-ara DIDN'T bully Hwayoung.
But as I watch this video and such videos online and gather my own thoughts, I conclude T-ara DIDN'T bully Hwayoung because a simple one fact: you can see Hwayoung's parts are in many of the T-ara music videos.
Second fact, the "bullying" case wasn't show up until they had a fight (I'm sure it must have been really a big fight, like someone cursed somebody's parents and family.)
And I think, if Hwayoung had been being bullied by T-ara members since LONG TIME AGO, why T-ara's "bullying" news didn't come out to public? And Hwayoung was happy with t-ara members until the fight, right?
I really don't know what to believe... but never the less thanks for making this! You are truly a dedicated fan and T-ARA is very lucky to have people like you still on their side. It's inspiring and I hope the people who judged without seeing everything will change their minds when they watch this video.
rumors are just rumors and haters gonna hate
but past is past so please
if they really bullied her (but i don't think so) they had a really good reason
no one bully someone without a reason!
Looking at this after all these years, makes me show that idols are not always as they were, incredible to see comments from years ago agreeing with Hwayoung and blaming the members of that time of T-ara.
I'm a new fan and i don't care about the issue. I love them just the way they are. ♥
💝
You are welcomed with open hands
I agree with Chris Yau. I remember once Eunjung also mentioned that she wasn't very pleased about adding more members since some of them were quite lazy and arrogant while elder members were forced to work hard. I think that if they were bullying Hwa Young, she wouldn't be so silly to say that out. Those interested in bullying will always say good things about their victims in front of people to pretend they are good person. But Eunjung and other members are not like that.
Ups... poor hwayoung
T-ara doesn't deserve any hates. Why? because all of those bullshit rumors and scandals are NOT even true! They work their butt off so no, they don't deserve any of those bullshit hates. I'm not saying all people in Korea but also some other country too that also hates T-ara by believing those fucking bullshit rumors and scandals. People in Korea, need to stop hating them because they did nothing wrong. Queens are perfect and they have the best fan's service ever! I have been to T-ara concert before (once) and they all are SUPER nice to fans. They are not only acting nice but they are actually being nice to us fans! If you're the one that hates T-ara, please don't hate them because they did nothing wrong! They are NOT a bully! Please haters, stop all the bullshit hates!!!
Try to compare the negative and positive. And see.. That was just haters. I will always be a king!
After 10 years and more. The truth has spoken up
I think person understand Hwayoung most is Hyomin ... that's one girl good and friendly..
Lam Min Ho Official All of them are good, tho. Hwayoung is like a bish because she made T-Ara career fall.
PERFECT.... watching this made a tear slide down my cheek. How can the old fans watch this and not regret doing what they did?? turn their backs on our girls when they needed their fans the most. How many Fans know about the Petition to fight against those who want the dissolution of T-ara? i would post the link... but don't know if the person who did this would let me?
haters gonna hate.. without any proof they are just being nonsense and naive!! really dislike the antis..
i admit that T-ara being immature when that day they tweeted some "scolding" words on Hwayoung... but that's because antis dont understand how important the japan concert was to the girls.. they value that so much! im not saying Hwayoung being wrong not to perform... and yeah.. sometimes things/ argue should be solve among them... but they apologized for the childish tweets already!!!
why cant haters understand the girls more...
once a Queen's forever a Queen's
love this video, and love my T-ara unnies... so proud of them!
i love t-ara and i will always them , i do not care about what other people saying , i hope someday they come back
Rational and true fans stayed loyal to T-ara because we knew the truth . Plus their music is freaking awesome !
Thanks for posting this. I haven't seen a lot of these pics. Now I am sure it was the 'company' that wanted Hwayoung out. Seemed like she got along with everyone of the girls. And like a family everyone has their disagreements. But I think all this has gotten blown up out of proportion. I love this video and still love all of T-ARA...including Hwayoung.....
please stop blaming t ara.. they did nothing to hwayoung.. hwayoung also admit it... it is common to prank each other if they are close.. i was a fan of t ara.. but i didnt hate them bcause of this stupid thing.. i just left because i want to be a fan of boy group.. my bias in t ara was hwayoung,, but i think positive of this case.. so, i didnt hate t ara and i still keep in touch with their show or comeback.. just please stop blaming them.. they also have emotion.. what if you are one of them,, and this happen when you did nothing and people keep talking shit to you.. what do you feel? think positive not negative..
You left only because of the boy group? Duh, I’m multistan. Why can’t you become one?
@@aisyariana4157 Sorry, this was like 5 years ago.. And I was not quite of a multistan back then. Because I just preferred to focus on one group.
@@coffeepinklove Oh. I'm sorry cus I reply to you after 5 years. Btw, that guy on your profile pic is so cute. Who is he? That guy looks like Woojin + Hyunjin. Lol.
@@aisyariana4157 it's ok. Yupp he's hyunjin 😉
If you never once prank your best friends/gangs,I pity you. I bet your childhood was extremely horrible. Jiyeon always shows her true self on-camera. She does what she want. She says what she want. Jiyeon is a cute spoilt brat that like to prank and hit others. So what? She is just being herself. Variety shows are made so that the fans can know how their idols are. She even hit Qri not just Hwayoung.
Hwa never said that she was being bullied......Have you searched this news seriously? She did not perform in Japan because she went to beauty salon. But she finally replied to her boss that she was sick. The adminstration of the company was angry about that so CCM fired Hwa. If Hwa really being bullied, she should say it out, but Hwa did not. T-ara are immature but it does not mean they are bad. They argue on Twitter doesn't mean they bully her, T-ara want Hwayoung to be more hard-working by the way in which they convince her on Twitter. Also, hwa's sister now is still a staff in CCM, if hwa was really being buillied, her sister would not stay in CCM.
Right!!
Hope everyone can know that how poor they are :(
you can tell they miss her , especially during the Day by Day performance without her, Soyeon sounded more sad, Areum looks like she was about to cry and Hyomin was mad during the Hwayoung rap
HWAYOUNG DID BUT KIM KWANGSOO TOLD HER TO KEEP HER MOUTH CLOSE!!!
-.- srsly
amy park Qri didn't bully her
Despite everything, I miss them all together... I wish none of that would happen and T-ara ot8 would come back... but not everything we want is what we have😭😭😭
a lot of T-ARA fans run away bcause of this fake scandal...!!
t-ara pls don't be deeply affected by the rumors continue to work hard and prepare some good performances and songs for us even though without hwayoung, u all should look ahead of the future and keep on moving even though hwayoung is no longer in the group but I guess she will support u all from the back. T-ara hwaiting 😉😃😘
now is the end hwayoung she bully t-ara is real...
I'm so happy to found out that they are people who are still supporting T-ARA, im not a Queen, but i like them, when all the news were around, i couldn't believe it, they are not like that. I hope everything is solved and T-ARA can be back on stage with all their members
If T-ARA is brave enough to apologized then why hwayoung didnt come out and apologize as well? If she was proof innocent enough, she must apologized from her eunnie's side also even tho "ego" pride will turn down. Have you guys thought about it?
People in Korea (Korean people) think it's true that t-area bullied her and international fans don't think so.
too bad they destroyed their own girl group and believed in more T-Ara haters (not all of them) :(
Those videos said that T-ara had bullied which are not convincing.
I've never really took side to this affair but after watching this video, I think the possibility of bullying is small actually… Besides, I've never been a T-Ara fan really, even though I like their musics, so I don't know this group really well ^^
Anyway Fighting~
Hey SONES! I love T-ara!
Dwin Suzy thanks so much !!
thx u for making this ^.^
I'm not a Queen. I just love Eunjung ~.~.
I don't know much about the personalities of T ara and Hwayoung. I'm sure that netizen also not know. But why they said as they know them clearly...
Poor Eunjung.... I know this scandal is the worst of the worst. But everything will be ok. Unnie, 5ting. Your true fans always stay by your side...
Rumors start from haters. People that believes the rumors are dumb.
There, just a simple explanation how all this happened. Probably the person that spread this out wanted an interview because he/she wants to be famous.
It doesn't matter anyway, the past is the past. Both sides did wrong in some way, they could've settled it if they wanted, but they chose not to. So the outcome of their actions is the outcome they have to deal with.
minta lavu im
MINTA LAGU IMLEK
how did both side did wrong that makes no sense to me
Sally ToPics T-ara with their tweets.........and hwayoung dont want to perform.....and go to nail shop while other are working....so both are wrong........nah...its the past know..
SNSD.are. Queens agree so much with you
@thumperpet86 SO? Are you the people who took camera in front of them? Videos can be edited easily using high-tech gadgets. There were also many videos which proven that those bullied videos were sevely edited. Also, no one created rumors about other groups, so that other groups' members are nice? T-ara and Hwa also have a lot of touching moments. If T-ara told to Hwa where considered as bullying, in my life, I have no friends till now. If T-ara reminded Hwa on Twitter where considered as bullied, in my ilfe, my parents always bullied me. "If she's being bullied.....if she is being bullied.." Because the fact is that she did not suffer bullying. If your idols have these rumors, I am sure you will not say this is bullying. Those evidence saying that T-ara are bullies which are not established and unilateral. If those evidence take to the court, I am sure they can't take any stance.
" i want to kinda believe hwayoungs story of being bullied because why would she lie about it?"
She didn't lie, cuz she never say that she's being bullied.. It's netizen who suddenly came up with "evidences" and suddenly it seems like she's being bullied..
After all the answer is t ara doesnt bullied hwayoung. Hwayoung bullied t ara with her sister
now they are more mature..hopefully they get along more and forgive each other
Good luck for all of you
@donniejuanvaldez T-ara were mean to Hwa? WTF! What do you think who you are!? T-ara and Hwa also have a lot of touching moments. You are not the person along with them, why are you so sure? You only search the second-hand information at the internet!
If Hwayoung doesn’t wanna come back. I want Boram and Soyeon to come back!
QUEENS don't forget to support T-ara comeback!!!! 11 September 2014!!!!
If only T-ara dont have this kind of controversy they will be on the Top by now!!Hope to see them on stage again soon..Fighting!!
t ara never bully anyone....this rumor starts from haters.......PLEASE DONT BELIEVE SUCH THINGS!
Happy 4th Annivesarry T-Ara! I support T-Ara until the end. BTW, I had a feeling they did not bully Hwayoung as if they truly hated Hwayoung, would they show their hates to the camera for the people to know that they hate that person?? T-Ara Forever 3
Just an honest opinion ... I'm not a big fan of T-ara or any K-Pop culture per say?! Although, I happen to know and like some of the most popular K-Pop or Korean songs, i sang and moved with the beat... Anyways, I happen to came across the T-ara's while browsing UA-cam just few days ago. So, I was intrigued! I took time watching them and knowing them. Google them. Every video that appears in my UA-cam window, I watched. But, I was intrigued more with such unlikely comments... (probably not real fans?!). And so, I searched and try to know more of them until, I came across your, +QueensWorldwide 's account. Somehow, in my honest opinion, truly, your efforts have vindicated them, The T-ara's from such malicious intrigues that have escalated and have tarnished these young ladies' names. I felt sorry for them for what they have gone through. But, they move in this dog eat dog kind of world. No one is spared from intrigues. They have to be strong willed to be able to surpassed all of it. Accept that not everyone will appreciate them. Like what happened, some looked down on them, used them, mocked them.
And I'm glad that somehow they manage to pull through! Showing they can be mature and wise with their actions. Having resilience in the face of adversity as they say. In such a short time, I can say that these are fine young ladies. They were young once, friendly, playful and yet misunderstood! Just felt sorry too for Hwayoung! They all suffered from the so called ... misconception and the devious media tactics of escalating rumors to make their advances. So sad that it had to happen! I hope they continue pursuing their dreams, wherever they are! More Power to T-ARA! God bless.
" THE TONGUE HAS NO BONES, BUT IT IS STRONG ENOUGH TO BREAK A HEART. SO BE CAREFUL WITH YOUR WORDS. " :)
i also like tiara. i don't know whether the bullying is true or not (will keep a positive mind) but it is to be expected that she will become an outcast because she is a new member who joined after the other 6 had been together for so long, endured many hardships together, and became a success. you have to think about the other 6 also, (they may feel insulted that since another member is joining, what about their hard work, was it not enough). Also you have to be Korean to also understand their culture where they respect their elders even by 1 year older. and she joined in as one of the youngest and also she mentioned she was timid. I always and will always believe that the media/biased people will always blow things out of proportion. Not hating on any of the 7 people involved. but it would have been great to see what would have happened if the 8 member group had been formed
Agreed :)
i dont think t-ara ever intentionally bullied hwayoung. but i think hwayoung did feel left out at times because the others have stronger personalities, particularly jiyeon.
thank you for making and uploading this T~ara's compilation now my mind is clear...
I'm Vietnamese! I do not understand why people who used to be fans turned their backs on t-ara because a scandal was not true. It was unfair to the t-ara who had been ostracized for the past few years in the warmth. I ask the anti you do not do that anymore they have been shocked too big and can not stand it anymore !!
Eunjung said that they'd had arguments at times but that there was no bullying, and that they were surprised and sad to see Hwayoung get fired. She also said they were immature to scold her on twitter after the concert/beauty shop incident.
We believe in T-ara.. We love T-ara. 티아라의 음악을 들으며 삶의 기쁨과 활력을 얻습니다. ❤️❤️❤️
I'm happy for this video, you did a great job, i felt relief and this is my first, watched EunJung kiss HwaYoung...T-ARA..you're not alone...HwaYoung,you are not alone..stay strong and I pray for those haters, that they will love T-ARA after this.
Haters, you're not gonna be happy for the rest of your life because you're haunted by guilt. If you wanna be happy, it's so easy , just say your sorry and let's be friend? ^_^
Hi, I came from 2021😔
wahhhhh..thanks uploader! this made me cry! HOPE THAT THOSE ANTI's WILL OPEN THEIR EYES, AND SEE FOR THEMSELVES THE TRUTH!
T-ARA FIGHTING!~ PROUD TO BE QUEEN~
After watch this, I believe that the scandal was made by the fucking antis. There is nothing wrong with them. It's normal if they are joking around because they are family! Poor Hwayoung. I wish I can back at that time so I could change MBK mind to not terminate Hwayoung's contract. but...sigh, it will never happen...and I wish Korean will realize and just move on same goes to other fans who are dissapointed with Hwayoung departure and stop being immature..if Korean still hate them dont worry China and Japan Queens are indeed loyal fans!! Proud Queen here!
poor hwayoung? she could have gone to the media and given one interview saying NO T-ARA DIDNT BULLY HER. but she didn't. she's to blame for T-ara's suffering too. T-ara was and will always be the original 6
Mish mish why u always hating on her?
Mish mish report
lol dude you trolling me? hahaha
I'm a Kamilia, and even I support ALL the members of T-ara. Why did one rumor of bullying suddenly discredit every single nice moment the T-ara members have with each other? All the videos of them being nice to each other become fake while all vids of them "ignoring" each other become heartless. Leave them alone already! T-ARA fighting! Hwayoung fighting! (True) Queens fighting!
I think the members may be a little annoyed that Hawyoung has joined a group already made and often feel that she doesn't work hard. They also seem to leave her out sometimes but I wouldn't go as far as to say it is bullying, just a little awkward and perhaps a bit harsh but they don't seem to have cruel intent towards her.
I really miss T-ara. I will support the girls forever. I didn't believe they bullied Hwayoung. I didn't believe the rumors. I believe T-ara, they can do it. They need to suffer because of the rumors and poor Qri or Ah Reum, the innocent ones. Why do antis have to do this. T-ARA HWAITING!
I feel touched when I saw ur video. T-ara must sad too when Hwayoung leave them . Still support them. ♥
T-ara never bullied Hwayoung.
Just think about why did hwayoung wrote that? And why she said she was being bullied? If she wasn't bullied she wouldn't had left the group, right. Just the point of view of a normal person ( not a hater, not a fan).
I get what u mean but.... hwayoung didn't actually left the group... her contract was terminated!
Hey hey, Hwa Young did not wrote that, it was just a coincidence. Also, if she really was bullied, why didn't she speak out. No one can threat her anymore since she had already left and she had her fans. One more point, her sister stayed in CCM. If she knew that her sister Hwa Young was treated unfair like that, why would she stay? If you can answers those questions thoroughly, then I will agree with you. But if not, well, you are not very convincing.
Her sister is from a different group not from t ara DUH!
How is that a coincidence...? There's obviously a reason why she wrote it and if not her members then who else? You act like it would be soo easy for her to speak out about the bullying but its not easy, especially if all members, most staff, and the company didn't even care about her.Do you think hwayoung would really let her sister quit the company over her? No of course not! Why let her sister's career end because hers was bad?? In reality you queens aren't very convincing because all you do is ask and never even give proof. So what? some fanmade video to support tara is your proof?
Whatever , that topic is not even outstanding ...
After watch this video, i'm crying so harddd. This is the best friendship that i can't have😭😭😭😭
you guys just say and argue it logically. We never know the truth of somenone's heart
🤡🤡🤡🤡
Their companies should just tell the truth....whether the rumours are right or wrong, so that T-ara can move on with their life......Go T-ara!!
astar012 what do you think who you are? Are you a staff in CCM or an artist in Korea?
looking at the older comments from when the rumors started got me shook
There are too much truths that we don't know. Truth about the CCM, Truth about T-ara and Hwayoung. Nobody will know the truth but themselves. The thing has passes by more than 1 year, they were all bullied by someone, some scandals. If people still support both T-ara and Hwayoung, all we can do is stop arguing, and stop hurting them with all those "truths" that has not proved. All we can do is blessing both of them having a bright future and when they meet again one day, they can smile to each others and say unnie, i miss u. Best wish for T-ara and Hwayoung
maybe they were really close like true blooded sisters. hmm... well, sisters fight too so why they can't. maybe the latter times when they were still together with hwayoung there must have been a misunderstanding and it showed in their actions and those actions started the rumors. It was solved but it's too late as the damage was huge. hmm... great work, you gave me some evidences that sometime in their lives they've become so close... so sad but if only they have been cautious enough of their actions this wont happen... well then, i think they have moved on... it's a good thing... (forgive my english)
Just because she was nice to them doesn't mean they were too her, I mean in most of the videos its hwayoung being nice to the other members...and what?she has to make a full statement to the public about the bullying so that people could believe her? You queens act like if she was bullied she should of said something, but in reality its harder than that, especially if all the members and some staff were against her.
I think the staff no need to against her ...
but ya know in the videos t-ara were nice to hwayoung too n how do u kno that the staffs were against her? but ya i agree with u bout being scared to speak out but thats just call assuming things without knowing anything.. which is what every fan nd haters do,,and i think u r assuming from the so called "proofs" n the hateful things that the haters say bout them!!!
🤡🤡🤡hwayoung was the bully
Tbh i think that EVERY idol group should be respected and do not deserve all this. No matter what they do, we have no rights to judge. I mean they ALL went through SO MUCH even before they debut
the other members of t-ara never bully t-ara hwayoung..if you watch this video you can see how sweet the other members in hwayoung unnie..but if you say that the other members just sweet to hwayoung unnie if the camera is rolling..do you have a proof?if the other t-ara members bully hwayoung unnie?non right?so don't judge.what if their is a reason why hwayoung unnie leave the group..T-ARA FIGHTING..T-ARA HWAYOUNG BACK TO T-ARA PLEASE..i cry when i watch this video gosh!
YES MYUNGYEON!
umm hell no. hwayoung made full use of the sympathy she got as a 'victim'...she's also responsible for T-ara's suffering. and T-ara was and always will be the original 6!
Mish mish you again....keep hating on her bitch
This video makes me smile,, cry,,, and feel very happy because i love them SO MUCH!!!!! JIYEON and other T-ARA!!!!! Stay strong!!! I'll keep fighting so thT i will meet you all!!!
DO I CARE with HATERS??? Nah….I JUST CARE with T-ARA. Closed-minded people will believed what they want to believed anyway. It's just a waste of time arguing to people who wouldn't listen and understand the real situation (why? Because they don't care) So I also DON'T CARE WITH HATERS. My love and support will forever with T-ARA!
Abing Abing What kind of opinion? If you are giving the benefit of the doubt for the 2 parties involve I respect everyone's opinion...but if you are insulting and comment non-sense without knowing what had happened then you are a closed minded.
Abing Abing who's acting close minded and immature right now?
Sorry I didn't mean to hate t ara but if u guys include other girl group I just can't accepted it I'm sorry
X Lucifer Where did I include any other group with my comment? Did I mention any groups aside from T-ara?
well not u but others
If you live and work together, there will always be conflicts. Stay strong girls. You are beauitful
We love T-ARA 😍
That is truth.thank u for making this video.We will support,believe and love them 4ever
I wonder. Do you know how Hwayoung feel if you in her position? or did you know Hwayoung was or wasnt bullied? Did you know their real life looks like? In my opinion maybe there is a bully Hwayoung nor Qri. Cause I used to be their fans and kinda disappointed on them. And from my point of view. Did T-ara help her while she was hurt? if they say birthday greeting to Hwayoung it could be fake too you know.. They are public figure and they might told by the manager to did that so the case shouldnt be spread. T-ara maybe fake too, Anyways the case already passed. and stop war thing and cursing. Its my opinion. *my english lacks a lot sorry for bad grammar*
Love this video! Even I wasn't a Queen's in the past, now I am, but I miss Hwayoung
I really don't care about Hyawoung
I love T-ara
Am I the only one who thinks "we can't know?..." I'm not part of the T-ARA fandom (that doesn't mean I hate them) but I think the people who believe or don't believe are being seriously rude... most comments written by people who support T-ARA sound like: "EFF haters they know nothing" and people who are hating on T-ARA sound like "EFF supporters they are blind"... I think the point of this video and many other videos regarding the bullying matter is to discuss and share information on the matter... if you guys are not caring bout other opinions and leaving rude comments to diss the other party then don't leave your comment at all.
Corea quedó 🤡
i wanna ask part 1:57 are from what show? is it T-ARA Dot Com? if not can u tell me cause i watched it before but i forgot the show's name
T-ara bullies? I used to think so but nope not anymore, Hwayoung is a snake. I don't trust anything she says.
Hwayoung said she was not bullied and supported T-ara, so why did you think she was bullied and don't you trust her? What did she say that was not true? The people I don't trust are KKS and some of the staff - their behaviour makes me suspicious and their stories don't fit with the evidence of the members, but Hwayoung, Areum and the original six all say virtually the same things.
Hwayoung is not a snake and doesn't deserve the hate. Read my fair and truthful account of how the scandal developed.
The True Story of the T-ara Bullying Scandal t-ara-and-hwayoung.blogspot.com
Nightjar on the gate Hwayoung said that she is bully by T-ARA.
then like why did she drop out ...Tao was bullied in sm much but exo is now his family
Although Snsd play pranks on each other sometimes, you can tell tell they just take it for fun, whereas in t ara u can feel that its on purpose and they are really laughing at hwayoung anyway its all over so dont bother
in other words you are bias
you are sone so ofcource you will said snsd are the best and innocent while others groups are not
so jessica got bullied by the girls too? the soshibond must be fake too, then
I sort of feel that way too, because of jessicas cold nature, ppl who are not close to her may not like her. But for snsd they ignore, you dont see them bullying. Taeyeon and jess had some conflict, you could see that tae disliked jess but she didnt bully, she ignored
Please stop judging and spreading rumors if you do not know what happened between them. All those proofs and videos were denied and HwaYoung did stated that she was not being bullied. If you chose to not believe in T-ara then just leave them alone, they don't deserve being treated this way when everything was explained yet people like you are still accusing them for things that they didn't do
Almost shed my tears
:')
No matter what people said
I'm still love you T-ara
I hope You all can surpass this hardship