Really enjoying the interviews on this channel. It’s a genius idea to make every guest answer the same set of controversial questions highly disputed in the Israeli society.
So what he's saying is that Hamas donned IOF uniforms before making video of themselves eating and playing silly games and looting the homes of "Israelis" that somehow looked more like impoverished Gaza homes than anything on a Kibbutz. Tank comander kills Israelis and then lies about it ua-cam.com/video/aBxDp15fOuE/v-deo.htmlsi=2jcUQygIJRR23r4A
If I'm for example a patrilineal Jew why can't I automatically convert after 6 years of living with the halahic Jews? According to Jewish history that was a standard procedure for a Ger Toshav? Also Zadukim (the opponents of the Pharisees) accepted patrilineal Jews as kosher so why is it not a thing anymore?
Patrilineal descent has no halachic status in determining Jewishness. You don't have the status of a Ger Toshav, that is something completely different - in today's day and age you can probably equate it to "Noahide." You can go through a conversion process whenever you'd like, though. Re: Tzedukim - their opinions are irrelevant, as their fundamental core structure is heretical.
@@yehudahecht1520 if one served in the army and is a citizen who abides by the Israeli law how is it not ger Toshav? And Tzedukim aren't irrelevant they've been dominating in Judaism and among the bnei Israel for the majority of the time before the Roman exile. And nowadays their tradition is kept going by the Karaim. Samaritans are also patrilineal and they practice second temple Judaism
@@abupinhus that's just your opinion. There's 30k Karaim in Israel only. Shemronim abide by the version of Judaism that's more ancient then the majority of religions in the world. Jews like to refer to Judaism as the original, base for other Abrahamic religion. Then second temple Judaism is logically a base for the modern Judaism. By your logic reformist Jews aren't Jewish either just heretics. I just would like Judaism to be more consistent and inclusive like the old school Judaism
@@nazarakopyantc514 Actually, as you said yourself, your opinion is just a wishfull thinking of rootless western woke person. It has no any connection with reality. You can dream and wish and express your feeling, just don't gaslight everyone else. My opinion, on other hand is supported by majority of traditional Jews, by people who know and understand jewish history. There are of course slight nuances, but more or less it reflects reality.
Israel's existence is on religion ,then how can you say it should not on religion which has got 3500yrs building their 1st church . It was destroyed again they build 2nd church agai destroyed by invaders. Now they are building their 3rd church in the same place.
@@alexfranklin1479 jews did not "built a church", they bult "temple". For jews church has very negative connotation. And meaning is also different, church is "kirka" - place of assemblage. We jews also have such places, they called "bet knesset" - house of assemblage in Hebrew, or synagogue in Greek. Temple, or in hebrew "bet mikdash" - is place deducated to God. So, we have plenty of "bet knesset", we do hope to get third "bet mikdash" soon.
Why Israel cannot be a religious state while all the 52 countries surrounding Israel is Muslim countries only . Then what prevent Israel to known as Jewish country
Disappointed. Claiming that all political leadership do not have empathy needs explanation or proof. Require poltitician to think long term and in societal goals above all is at best naive considereng the insentives. It hard to think long term when your job do not survive for more that one year.
There are a number of countries that are Christian by Constitution and greater numbers that are Muslim by constitution. Why is Israel the one that needs to change?
@@CarollemMen-cl8nzEngland, Norway, Greece, Malta, Serbia,Armenia, Costa Rica, Argentina, El Salvador, Samoa, Tonga, Iceland , Lichtenstein, Denmark, Hungary, Samoa and of course Vatican City. I think I’ve missed a few. And Israel, like all these countries but unlike a number of Muslims countries does not demand its citizens be Jewish. The Arab and Druze citizens of Israel are Muslim, and there are small members of other religions. Omg, how the Druze love being citizens of Israel. Bless them. The anti-semites, the self hating Jews, and the profoundly ignorant just won’t leave Israel alone. It’s sooo tiny. Leave them alone.
Maybe the most important progression in human political history was the founders of the United States Constitution declaring absolute separation of church and state. Why did they do that? Because the history of humanity is a history of one group of people believing and proclaiming that they have the inside line on God, they above all others have God's ear and thus they are all powerful and all righteous and always supposed to come out on top. Most organized religion is little more than a means by which one usually small group of people grasps and hold onto power over as many other people as they can. Democracy leaves it to each individual to decide for themselves the question of their relationship to God and the rules that people follow in a Democracy are rules that are meant, in theory, to provide the greatest good possible for the greatest number of people, human beings, not one group over another that is absolutely possible. Democracy is hard work. Democracy takes thought, knowledge, wisdom, and each person has to take responsibility for their part in it. Israel would stand a greater chance of being a strong nation if it severs government from religion. Ultimately the world will not be governed by religious zealots of any system of religious belief. That is where humanity is headed.
remember: 1st the land became holy, 2nd the people became a holy nation, and Hashem gave the land not to the galuth mode haredi/hasidim in funny Polish/Rus garments etc..
They indeed displayed a good share of irational stuff. But regarding the King institution that ruled Israel in the past, one must note that this instiution was created and given power by popluar demand rather then by devine decree. We can see this in the Book of Samuel.
@@reuvenpolonskiy2544 that is accurate but you must note that יהוה told Shmuel to anoint David and that the Torah prescribes a king and his qualifications.
@@eliyahukonn3245 This is true, there is such an understanding. But according to many others the Lord did not decree to put a King, but allowed it and defined the framework for its rule and chose the king.
@@eliyahukonn3245 This is certainly impossible. The idea is, that because the Lord knew a time would come where the people of Israel will demand a king and since he decided he will allow it, he adressed this beforhand by making the rules that define HOW to do it.
Really enjoying the interviews on this channel. It’s a genius idea to make every guest answer the same set of controversial questions highly disputed in the Israeli society.
This man should be chief Rabbi of Israel. He is right and courageous. Shoham is blessed to have such rav.
So what he's saying is that Hamas donned IOF uniforms before making video of themselves eating and playing silly games and looting the homes of "Israelis" that somehow looked more like impoverished Gaza homes than anything on a Kibbutz.
Tank comander kills Israelis and then lies about it
ua-cam.com/video/aBxDp15fOuE/v-deo.htmlsi=2jcUQygIJRR23r4A
Thank you. This was incredible. Kol hakavod. Am yisrael chai. Shana Tova
Wise man.
Thank you.
Hashem be with you. Wisdom is a gift from torah, torah come hashem
shalom shalom
Israel is Real
If I'm for example a patrilineal Jew why can't I automatically convert after 6 years of living with the halahic Jews? According to Jewish history that was a standard procedure for a Ger Toshav? Also Zadukim (the opponents of the Pharisees) accepted patrilineal Jews as kosher so why is it not a thing anymore?
Patrilineal descent has no halachic status in determining Jewishness. You don't have the status of a Ger Toshav, that is something completely different - in today's day and age you can probably equate it to "Noahide." You can go through a conversion process whenever you'd like, though.
Re: Tzedukim - their opinions are irrelevant, as their fundamental core structure is heretical.
@@yehudahecht1520 if one served in the army and is a citizen who abides by the Israeli law how is it not ger Toshav? And Tzedukim aren't irrelevant they've been dominating in Judaism and among the bnei Israel for the majority of the time before the Roman exile. And nowadays their tradition is kept going by the Karaim. Samaritans are also patrilineal and they practice second temple Judaism
@@nazarakopyantc514Anything of the jews kept in roman times, a and specialy what karaim and shomranim keep is completely irrelevant.
@@abupinhus that's just your opinion. There's 30k Karaim in Israel only. Shemronim abide by the version of Judaism that's more ancient then the majority of religions in the world. Jews like to refer to Judaism as the original, base for other Abrahamic religion. Then second temple Judaism is logically a base for the modern Judaism. By your logic reformist Jews aren't Jewish either just heretics. I just would like Judaism to be more consistent and inclusive like the old school Judaism
@@nazarakopyantc514 Actually, as you said yourself, your opinion is just a wishfull thinking of rootless western woke person. It has no any connection with reality. You can dream and wish and express your feeling, just don't gaslight everyone else. My opinion, on other hand is supported by majority of traditional Jews, by people who know and understand jewish history. There are of course slight nuances, but more or less it reflects reality.
Israel's existence is on religion ,then how can you say it should not on religion which has got 3500yrs building their 1st church . It was destroyed again they build 2nd church agai destroyed by invaders. Now they are building their 3rd church in the same place.
@@alexfranklin1479 jews did not "built a church", they bult "temple". For jews church has very negative connotation. And meaning is also different, church is "kirka" - place of assemblage. We jews also have such places, they called "bet knesset" - house of assemblage in Hebrew, or synagogue in Greek. Temple, or in hebrew "bet mikdash" - is place deducated to God. So, we have plenty of "bet knesset", we do hope to get third "bet mikdash" soon.
12:00 how would you do that? you'll need someone to look after others to see if they keep shabbat, and that would be work wouldnt it?
Why Israel cannot be a religious state while all the 52 countries surrounding Israel is Muslim countries only . Then what prevent Israel to known as Jewish country
Because Jews are not like Muslims, in case you have not noticed.
halachah - we aren't supposed to have this until Moshiach comes
Disappointed. Claiming that all political leadership do not have empathy needs explanation or proof. Require poltitician to think long term and in societal goals above all is at best naive considereng the insentives. It hard to think long term when your job do not survive for more that one year.
🎉Se você fosse inteligente colocaria legendas em português
There are a number of countries that are Christian by Constitution and greater numbers that are Muslim by constitution. Why is Israel the one that needs to change?
What countries are Christian by Constitution?
@@CarollemMen-cl8nzEngland, Norway, Greece, Malta, Serbia,Armenia, Costa Rica, Argentina, El Salvador, Samoa, Tonga, Iceland , Lichtenstein, Denmark, Hungary, Samoa and of course Vatican City. I think I’ve missed a few.
And Israel, like all these countries but unlike a number of Muslims countries does not demand its citizens be Jewish. The Arab and Druze citizens of Israel are Muslim, and there are small members of other religions. Omg, how the Druze love being citizens of Israel. Bless them.
The anti-semites, the self hating Jews, and the profoundly ignorant just won’t leave Israel alone. It’s sooo tiny. Leave them alone.
Maybe the most important progression in human political history was the founders of the United States Constitution declaring absolute separation of church and state. Why did they do that? Because the history of humanity is a history of one group of people believing and proclaiming that they have the inside line on God, they above all others have God's ear and thus they are all powerful and all righteous and always supposed to come out on top. Most organized religion is little more than a means by which one usually small group of people grasps and hold onto power over as many other people as they can. Democracy leaves it to each individual to decide for themselves the question of their relationship to God and the rules that people follow in a Democracy are rules that are meant, in theory, to provide the greatest good possible for the greatest number of people, human beings, not one group over another that is absolutely possible. Democracy is hard work. Democracy takes thought, knowledge, wisdom, and each person has to take responsibility for their part in it. Israel would stand a greater chance of being a strong nation if it severs government from religion. Ultimately the world will not be governed by religious zealots of any system of religious belief. That is where humanity is headed.
remember: 1st the land became holy, 2nd the people became a holy nation, and Hashem gave the land not to the galuth mode haredi/hasidim in funny Polish/Rus garments etc..
😮done at 11 minutes
15:55 As soon as he quoted Rabbi Kook, I knew he wasn't credible. Rabbi Chaim Brisker and Rabbi Sonnenfeld would have been better.
I would be careful in who you disparage
@@joshmich873 Why?
Because no one gets to telk other people you're doing it wrong.
😮😮the rambam is dead!
😮not hashem but, יהוה
Only if you want to disregard the second דיברה, to not take Hashem's name in vain.
@@yehudahecht1520 only if you want to disregard common sense. You assume the worse. That reasoning is חילול יהוה.
@@infiniti28160 Elohim and there is no other, einstein.
😮two idols, sectarianism and democrazy. What was Israel when there was a king....a democrazy😅😅😅 don't think so.
They indeed displayed a good share of irational stuff. But regarding the King institution that ruled Israel in the past, one must note that this instiution was created and given power by popluar demand rather then by devine decree. We can see this in the Book of Samuel.
@@reuvenpolonskiy2544 that is accurate but you must note that יהוה told Shmuel to anoint David and that the Torah prescribes a king and his qualifications.
@@eliyahukonn3245 This is true, there is such an understanding.
But according to many others the Lord did not decree to put a King, but allowed it and defined the framework for its rule and chose the king.
@@reuvenpolonskiy2544 it's unlikely יהוה was taken by surprise.
@@eliyahukonn3245 This is certainly impossible. The idea is, that because the Lord knew a time would come where the people of Israel will demand a king and since he decided he will allow it, he adressed this beforhand by making the rules that define HOW to do it.