Schiit Audio co-founder Jason’s surprise reaction to Magnepans that have bass! (No, not the LRS+)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
- THE WOOFERS ARE PLAYING THE ENTIRE TIME IN THIS VIDEO. Jason from Schiit Audio listened to the new Magnepan Woofer prototype at the Texas Audio Roundup. This video captures his reactions.
I did allow sound to be captured here, although I do not believe it is a valid representation of what was heard, nor ever is in cases like this. However, in this case I do think it gives you as viewers a good depiction of what was going on in the room with these woofers particularly. Now I will say, when this was uploaded to UA-cam, it appears UA-cam did not pick up all the frequencies that this video was able to reproduce before having been uploaded.
Interview with Jason of Schiit Audio
• Interview - Texas Audi...
Interviews with Wendell of Magnepan, and more about the woofers being demonstrated:
• Interview - Texas Audi...
• Interview - Texas Audi...
Schiit Audio
www.schiit.com/
Magnepan
magnepan.com/
Shown in video:
Magnepan LRS+
Magnepan Ultra Wide Band Woofer Prototype
Any support helps!
A little from multiple people helps pay for improving video and audio equipment, video editing software, and my ability to attend audio events to cover the shows.
Patreon
/ theaudiobelle
Amazon Affiliate
amzn.to/3OAuoxa
Hey everyone, this is not a description video of what the Magnepan woofers are or do, or why we are demonstrating that it can play higher tones. This video is to show the reactions of another audiophile equipment manufacturer to the woofers, and his first time meeting Wendell of Magnepan. Further details on the woofers are mentioned in a separate video- ua-cam.com/video/4s9BqABrRv4/v-deo.html
This was great. So nice to see that spirit of mutual admiration between Jason and Wendell. Kudos to you for introducing them, Cynthia!
Wow, Jason's reaction says it all, the man can't believe what he's witnessing and he is pleased with it. I think I want this speaker system 🤣. Thank you very much TAB, how have I not found you for so long.
We need more young people in this hobby
Can’t wait the bass speaker, magnipans come out. Nice work Wendel
👋🏼Mrs Audio Belle,
😮!!! The audio was soooo impressive, I’m shocked too, can’t imagine how they sound in person 🙌🏼….
Thnx for sharing & I’ve really been enjoying your recent videos 🤙🏼
This presentation was awesome!! I actually attended the event and heard these with 3 others. All of us were looking at each other with that same look on our faces “no freaking way!” These subs were amazingly!!
Nice vid 👍.
Btw, the track with the drums is Hok-man Yim: Poem of Chinese Drum for anyone interested. Sounds really good as an audiophile test track.
I heard this on a pair of 1.7s powered by a Parasound A21+
I was shocked by the bass energy.
Not subwoofer level bass but for a non. Traditional speaker I was blown a way
Thank you so much.
Bravo Audio Belle! Those are some extraordinary transducers and that is a room full of good audio souls
Thank you so much Herb!!
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Great work Cynthia! Thank you for keeping us up to date on this important technology.
Holy Schiit, get this to the market already!
Always wanted a pair of LRS speakers, but I’m afraid my cats would enjoy them as well
I've heard that if you spray something with deer piss, cats will stay away.
Always been fascinated by flat panel speakers. Have quads myself
Thanks for sharing this. This feels like a very important development. Can’t wait to hear it firsthand!
I can't agree more, this feels like a new step forward has just been taken.
Wow, the first run of music ... or drums...was not nearly as effective as the second. The second was incredible! I do understand that the first had some odd high notes or "clicks" to show the speakers range, but WOW.... the second was huge even through my phone running through the car stereo! Wonderful symphony 🥰
Thank you for bringing together the masters of sound!
They should bring some master of acoustics too, that hotel room had a nasty echo
The algorithm has blessed me today.
The classical piece is Rimsky-Korsakov, Snegurochka (The Snow Maiden) - Dance of the Tumblers, from the cd "Exotic Dances From The Opera" with Eiji Oue, Minnesota Orchestra, 1996
I can only just imagine what those woofers and LRS can do if combined with an amp like the MC40x series from McIntosh (with autoformers) and a copy of the Reiner Respigi Pine and Fountains of Rome !!
🥰😁😇🤩
I used to be a real PS Audio head, now I'm a total Schiit head
Wow! Amazing range of tones for only a sub. Incredible.
Production when, Wendell? 🙏 Need a pair sooo much, please & and thank u. Been waiting 15-20 years for production dipole subwoofers from Magnepan 😭
LOL -- they're in production engineering now.
Took me a while to realise these are LRS sized panels used as woofers (aren't they?) & rolled off at a high 10'Khz for awoofer, (it's almost full range for a man of my age) When the LRS came out, i heard 3 guys on a tube vid talk about it's sound & I wrote a comment to that Canadian hi-fi dealers tube vid as they they had interviewed Wendell. My comment asked them "why doesn't Magnepan make a same sized single pannel pair rolled off at circa' 300 or 350'Hz to stand next to the LRS's & add an extra 3'db in that range, the bass & richness zone' If I understood this vid correctly. Don't know why 1 guy said he 'thought it was the LRS playing' if he knew what was going on & I don't know why Wendel answered by leaning over & nodding towards the amps saying "no, you can see they're not turned on" ...because there was only 1 pair there, that still confuses me, because where were the LRS's if the only single pair I saw were the woofers, because Wendell could then have just said "The LRS"s aren't even here instead of pointing to the switched off LRS amp. Or maybe I got it all wrong & the woofers are invisible or behind that curtain
Other way around -- the LRS+'s aren't connected, you're listening to the new wideband dipole woofers -- you can see one to the right of the right hand LRS+, it's a small triangular tower.
Oh my! Cat’s outta the bag now. Those woofers really are amazing.
Good stuff, I want to see more of this.
This is iconic and outstanding 👍🏾🔥🔥😊
The paradox for Schiit is that those dipole woofers are driven by Class-D amps and a evidently need their input signal digitized if a DSP is involved. Where does that put Schiit's analog signal path in the end ? To drive the LRS I guess, but judging by the fact there were off during (at least the first part) of the demo, and no one had realized ; there's a... situation here.
Well, you'd hear the difference because the woofers "only" go to 10 kHz. So it will sound better with the LRS -- the point is that the woofers are so wideband you can almost use them full range!
at the end every signal is analog, speakers are analog
It would’ve been nice to see some pictures of the woofers. I have no idea what they look like. We only see the LRS plus
Homer,
You can see the woofers at the end of another video I did:
m.ua-cam.com/video/4s9BqABrRv4/v-deo.html
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Nice!
Thanks for this video. Brilliant idea
"Taiko" is the Japanese term you were going for. Koto is a stringed instrument.
I think they were saying the band was Kodo. They play taiko drums mostly
Having owned multiple Magnepan’s, and currently own two pairs… I have no idea what’s going on in this video. It’s confusing and I want to understand.
It's just a demo of the new wideband dipole woofers. The panels aren't playing at all.
Fantastic Tchaikowsky
So, the classic piece that starts at 8:40...was that WITH the LRS's added, or not? --Also, the camera person should have gone back there and showed a close-up view of the woofers.
LRS+'s off.
Cynthia, as you can tell from many of the comments, it is very important to tell listeners (viewers) what the system is doing. I suggest that next time you say, for example,
“We are listening to a cd of Kodo….(etc) through an Emotiva xxx preamp’s balanced outputs to Schiit Vidar amps run as monoblocks. Each drives a Magnepan dipole woofer in a tower array. The Vidars output 400 watts into 8 ohms in this way.”
I am still guessing at this point. I still don’t know which woofers we were listening to! The LRS has a woofer panel and a tweeter panel. Were there separate woofer enclosures along the wall? Were they run under their own power or by the Vidars? If the latter, why were the Vidars in the middle instead of by each speaker? Were the Vidars vertically biamped instead of run as balanced monoblocks? The answers actually matter a lot.
Still, the news is important, and thanks from lassoing Jason and putting him through testing hell, it’s fun to watch! 😃
He says quite clearly the LRS are switched off! Just separate dipole woofers along the wall...!
I've attended this demo in Toronto recently. Wendell played the subwoofers with a single stereo Vidar amp. He later played the LRS+ on its own, with the other single stereo Vidar amp. I can attest to how impressive the subwoofers are in person. Extremely tight, dynamic and loud with an iron grip. I'm not sure why he couldn't use a x-over so we could have heard the entire system together. But something tells me that the subwoofer won't be the same bargain that the LRS+ is.
Where are the subs? Built-in!!
Have to admit that was very good. It’s also nice to see Jason from That’s some good 💩 Audio 😂which I support. Have a Blessed Day.
So what exactly are we listening to?
Great To see!
Magnepans are Top 10
So, what _exactly_ is the product providing bass? It’d be helpful to provide that info, because from this,demo, I have virtually no clue.
I do not understand..
1. All agree to that LRS needs a subwoofer
2. The demo guy say the subwoofer goes to 10 000 Hz And it is no point to run them WITH the LRS because of that reason.
Then he tells that he needs to roll off the subwoofer lower to use it with the LRS..
So there was no point with this demonstration. When the point were to that the subwoofer helps the LRS to play full range. And that were not demonstrated.
So nobody knows how the subwoofers blend with LRS.
Why do this? If they set up the subwoofers and made a cross over where the LRS naturally roll off in the bass. Then it is just to play them all and engage and disengage the subwoofers..
That is the real test and how they're going to be used! The LRS do not need help to play frequencies up to 10 000 Hz.. just wasted time for all that is involved. And who is helped from him that he played the subwoofers and thought 2-3 times he were listening to the LRS.. ..waste of time if not they are trying to sell the subwoofer as product without any other drivers..
The real reason why that might not been done like it should been done as in the real world use case is that then the guy need to measure that room in the different listing positions with the positions the subwoofers has. Plus put in delays/alignment with the mains/LRS. And on top of that choose what crossover slopes, types and at what frequency..
And load all that into the DSP...
Had he time and knowledge to do that a proper demonstration.
Apperently not.
I know the stuff and what knowledge level is required. When I exactly use magnapans with two 18" open baffle hooked up to a DSP that are calibrated with delays, crossover for example.
I have a similar system, i.e. LRSs with two dipole 18" subs....I'm not sure what your criticism is. The point about playing to 10K is not do actually do that, but to make the point that the woofers are fast enough to merge well with the LRS+s. Given the location of the subs in the video, the crossover can't be higher than about 80hz, or there would be soundstage issues.
I think youre missing something here - These are not subwoofers per se but are Woofers. I believe the intent is not to add these to a full range speaker but to build future full range speakers around this woofer negating the need for a sub woofer.
@@5FWS5 Yes that should be awesome. To have a evolved magnapan.
@@peterdesmidt8742 the criticism is that it is a pointless demo when they do not crossover at ~80hz.
It is almost easier for then to put a super Tweeter (or something) to fill in the last octave.
Than sell 4 speakers that needs DSP adjustments, delays, crossover points and slopes. That kind of system will be >90% less attractive to a very narrow market segment..
(With saying that I use "two dipole 18" subs" were only to tell to those that know that a OB (dipole) is faster than a box generally are, that with over pressure and under pressure slow down the cone movement when it is in a box. But there is other drawbacks as less efficient, and benefits.)
Welcome to "Wendell World" lol.
Any idea as to IF or WHEN the Magnepan woofers would be available?
Frank,
No idea. Wendell said this is kind of like a concept car right now, that needs to get enough interest to continue the endeavor. I think he is still working on touring it around to get a fan base of the woofers. But that would be more of a question for Wendell and Magnepan. I think it’s still too early to consider being able to buy it any time soon, from what I found out later on.
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Thanks for getting back to me. From I am reading from owners of Magnepan there are lots of people interested but of course I am sure it all will revolve around how effectively the concept works and at what price point.
Thanks again.
Frank,
Of course! I hope we'll know more sooner than later, because I'd like to purchase a pair myself haha.
Have a wonderful rest of your Sunday!
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
That was awesome! Jason, is that why you guys don’t do speakers?
Yes, exciting new products. How about sending stock of EXISTING products to your "official" resellers in the UK? That would be great after 2 years.
The factory was six months behind thanks to high demand and labor shortages. They're caught up now so I imagine they'll be back in stock soon.
does the schiit have a project to make ... speakers, perhaps?
So will these be sold as a separate subwoofer or will this woofer be part of a new magnepan full range speaker?
Quite likely both.
cool channel so suscribed.
What amplifier was used?
May I suggest a low cut filter at 100hz to make the audio sound less muffled… maybe add some highs, mids…
@capwkidd,
Your suggestion is a good one. I recently found that the best option (at least for someone who likes deep bass, and an extra oompth in the midbass, is to use a crossover at 200hz to push 200+ to the panel Maggies. Then, 75 to 200 for the woofers. And, 75 and below to a conventional subwoofer. That is what I thought sounded the most full-bodied, at least.
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Amazing!
Great. What's the reference of this kodo record ?
Hi, Somebody have used the LRS with a McIntosh Amplifier like mc2155?
isn' there too much echo in the room? how can you demonstrate speakers there?
@peterpixo,
Hotel rooms are often horrible for demonstrating audio equipment haha. Audio shows use hotel rooms at conferences to demonstrate equipment though. You kind of have to sift through the sound of the room to understand what the product sounds like. Oftentimes the mids will be over-accentuated. So a lot of the audio show comes down to "eye candy".
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
There's a KEF B139 hidden in there...😅🤪
Lovely
Great sounding and great selection on music too, do you know what is the name of the music played starting on minute 5:38 ?
@rokodrago,
Looks like it was "Journey" by He Xuntian.
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
@@TheAudioBelle Thank you Cynthia
I'm thoroughly confused: Are the two speakers in the room the LRS+ or are they the new woofer? Or are they both? Or are the LRS+ silent displays and the woofer is elsewhere in the room?
The two speakers are the LRS+. The woofer is the little triangular thing behind the whatever it is. The LRS+'s had their amp off -- this was just a demo of the woofers.
Great video. Too secretive. It seems these subwoofers offer double bass and midbass. They may not measure as well that way but appear to sound good. You can not tell if the LRS are on because the material are drums. The fact that so little information is given makes me think one could mimic this setup.
He says quite clearly the LRS are switched off and these woofers will go up to 10 kHz ! That's not mid bass..! 😖 So many of these comments are by people not paying attention to the video! 😣
I’m so confused, I need to know more?
What speakers are they?
Is it a new product
If I was running the Schiit company I would change the name to "Schijt" with the Dutch pronunciation sounding like "Shite".
I am slightly confused - these are subwoofers, and yet they are playing up to about 10kHz? How do they integrate with the main speakers if they play up that high? Or, is the DSP set up differently when they are used as subs, with the main speakers?
he mentioned using DSP to integrate it in the previous interview video
The crossover limits response. They won't be playing up to 10 kHz in a system. But to get "fast" bass, a woofer has to be matched precisely in amplitude and phase to the midrange above the crossover point until it's down 20 dB, and that means that extended woofer response is important, and that requires extended response -- though you don't need response to 10 kHz.
Girl, you are the bomb! 💥💫😆
Zero room treatment, sub optimal seating placement, early reflections with phase correlation issues and these folks want to talk critically about the 'sound' of these. They aren't hearing the speakers, they are hearing the room. Food for thought.
Well, more like a real world living room. But one of the things about dipoles is that they're less sensitive to room acoustics than conventional speakers. It's why dipole bass sounds better than point source bass -- smoother response in a real room. Anyway, it's a demo at a show, no way to make everything ideal!
I want one
To me the bass drum from the orchestra sounds blurred and ill defined compared to what i'm used to from my full range electrostatics playing a Telarc LP.
When will the LRS+ be out/released/available? Umm yeah I'm interested lol.
We are taking orders and almost ready for production
You got to understand it takes at least 10 years from conception to ready for sale. 🤣🤣🤣
@TheHeartofthecross,
The LRS+ is orderable. It’s the woofers that are still a concept right now.
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
It didn't sound good to me. I'm wondering if the microphone is a bit rubbish.
It is, and it's overloading. It's never going to sound good on UA-cam.
The room isn't optimal, is it?
@SPDATA1,
They hardly ever are at the events, being in hotel rooms. Exhibitors have to bring their own absorbers/diffusers to help with the sound. You also have to be choosy about the size of the hotel room you select, as a manufacturer. I’ve noticed with Magnepan and the LRS, they always select a small, more intimate room because that’s where that speaker sounds the best. The LRS+ in my larger living room didn’t quite fill the room like it needed to.
So the events are fun, you get to meet people and see different products in person. But the rooms may not all be optimal and sometimes due to that the sound of a system has to be taken with a grain of salt.
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Did he shared when he’ll be introducing them to the market and price point? Thanks
These are in production engineering now, hard to know when they'll be rolling off the assembly line. These are also the expensive woofers for higher end models -- there will be a range, but they're starting with the flagship.
I guess they will be available after I will be dead, so by now I' m enjoying my 3.7i with a Velodyne DD18
Demoed with a Schiit Freya S preamp, to the guy who designed it.
Is that dual Aegirs running in mono into the maggies?
P 194,
Nope, they were Vidars!
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Pay no attention to the black boxs behind the flowers / man
Nobody can just lusten. Everyone has to film everything. Even old ladies.
8 months later.
@gleamtarrest6310,
Uhhh…..yep.
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
How low do they go?
@davehardan8323,
Funny you ask that. I recently had the opportunity to EQ them with my MiniDSP. While doing so, I found out they only go down to about 75hz. That might not be bad for someone who likes extra oomph in the midbass. But if you like the deep bass of a conventional, monopole subwoofer....that's another story.
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
so where was the subwoofer?
To the right of the right hand LRS+, you can see it behind that whatever it is.
sounds exactly the same as the 35 year old speakers i got now. What are my chances of getting the guy in Toronto, that's had these in stock for years, to stop doubling the price every 18 months??
how can you say they sound the same as your speakers listening to a youtube video? Its impossible to tell unless you are there in person hearing them.
Sounds great with ear plugs 😂😂😂😂
Wooh-fur. Lol
Probably had a 10 giga watt amplifier
Man. But I would cringe if anyone zoomed in on my face and reactions with a camera,and then uploaded the video on to U tube. I would be demanding that it be removed from the net.
Now play a busy track on them. They can’t do that well.
soooooo that schiit can run Magnepans ??
Nope, 20.7s with Coda continuum no.8 v3 800w@4ohms
Why not try to make Magnapans specifacally for bass
They have planar woofers, the DWM, but they aren't as capable -- most of the area of a planar panel is devoted to bass. That's why they used dynamic drivers, which have a higher excursion.
@robertdavis9624,
Mostly, it has to do with the difference between monopole and dipole speakers. Monopole subwoofers can push an immense amount of pressure. Dipoles cannot, unless the engineer/designer were to make them to be quite large.
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
I love it when people who drink just do it with class to handle life's stupidity and can admit wow ..ok I didn't know every.....thing
Schiit Audio, really?
It'll take Wendell about 5 more years to get these out 🤣🤣🤣 and of course he will tell you nothing about the "technology" of it 🙄
Did you seriously just make a video about a product without ever showing it? 🤨
It's in there too the right of the right hand LRS+, the whole idea of this form factor is that it's easy to hide behind something in a living room.
1.7 still rull
No one seems impressed,come to my house if you want to be impressed
Magnepan and low end......nah....
They simply don’t have the excursion to produce the lowest octaves.
@revo1336,
Well....they still had to use cone drivers to accomplish it. The woofers go down to around 75hz. So if you want bass extension below that....well....you will still need a conventional subwoofer.
---Cynthia, The Audio Belle
Really, out of all the names in the English language you could not come up with a better name than schit ? What is wrong with people ? I am sure I will be running out and buying your product.
You gotta learn to say woofer right, its not wooo-fer.
Free Radical,
But it’s a wooooofer! 😂
--Cynthia, The Audio Belle
@@TheAudioBelle lol! just givin ya a hard time. Your doing good work!
With all due respect, these are NOT Magnepans with Bass, they are Magnepans with Subwoofers. Something us Maggie fans have been doing for 15 years. It's not "all new technology" lol as Wendell says. Well perhaps DSP is "all new" for Wendell.
FINALLY Magnepan has embraced the inevitable. The dynamic driver. We brought them there by flipping the users that heard our rigs with subs. I've been preaching for years Magnepan is a mid/high panel. Sure it will DO bass, but only in a non dynamic way. Shiit guy thinks it's impossible to integrate a dynamic driver with a dipole panel. Clearly he's never tried. I do it WITHOUT DSP even. And I teach how to do it as well. Magnepan is so stuck in its old ways it takes this long to add something as rudimentary as a dynamic driver to the mix. Something Martin Logan, Wisdom Audio, Apogee, Bob Carver, and others were combining in the 80s... I get the video is on reactions.. it's just kind of funny these are new reactions to old tech. I'm glad the "movers and shakers" of business are coming to functional audio realizations !! Kudos!! Thanks for your video !!
Those aren't Maggies at all, they're just playing the woofers. None of the speakers you mention equal the integration and quality of the new Maggie sub. They'd tried making hybrids over the years in the lab, but they didn't equal the quality of planar panels of similar extension. I had a small role in designing these and it wasn't easy to get dynamic woofers to sound as good as planar woofers of equal extension. These woofers are dipoles and they use multiple small drivers, because 10" and 12" drivers don't sound as good. It would not have been practical to make a dipole woofer before DSP because you need dipole equalization.