Chief Seattle's Reply

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @ceezy9022
    @ceezy9022 7 років тому +44

    When a society cannot recognize wisdom such as this, that society is doomed.

    • @reforest4fertility
      @reforest4fertility 3 роки тому

      Then spread it like the wildfires engulfing US & Canada too. Make it rush into ears like the flood waters alternately plaguing the world. Deforestation is the cause. Clearcut logging must be stopped in Canada or there will be no fresh water, no fertile conditions to grow food, nothing to prevent carbon from acidifying the ocean. Of course, petroleum use must also end, as it is poisoning our bodies daily, even as i tap these plastic keys with my warm sweaty bare hands. Yeah, we must restore balance to Turtle Island

  • @GreenGlobalSolution5
    @GreenGlobalSolution5 8 років тому +41

    This soulful speech is even more relevant today than it was when it was delivered by Chief Seattle in 1852.
    Every time I truly listen to it I am moved to tears.
    If only everyone believed in Mother Earth as the Chief and I believe.
    Till the White Buffalo returns ................................................
    Tony Brophy
    Live in love.

    • @anon8287
      @anon8287 4 роки тому +1

      your autistic

  • @JoshuaSnyder48
    @JoshuaSnyder48 9 років тому +30

    This breaks my heart. I've grown up with and around Natives, and around/on reservations. I consider the native culture, at least by adoption, partly my own. On behalf of my ancestors, I am so, so sorry.

    • @voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885
      @voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 6 років тому

      Well at least the ponies were brought over by the Spanish, but otherwise yeah modern Western culture is messed up structurally. I don't idealize native cultures - the Aztecs ruined Mayan culture by bringing pederasty via the God Chin - but still nonwestern cultures were better overall.

    • @greenhearted8453
      @greenhearted8453 4 роки тому

      @@voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 I think you'll find it was a combination of other factors: deforestation, climate change, drought, overpopulation, overuse of the land, warfare.

    • @anon8287
      @anon8287 4 роки тому +1

      your autistic

  • @rocioaguilera7255
    @rocioaguilera7255 6 років тому +8

    It makes my eyes watery. It's so moving and wise. Yes, all creatures are our siblings. All is interconnected

  • @moqwah
    @moqwah 14 років тому +5

    thank you so much for this speech, it makes me think, we need more wise man like Chief Seatle

  • @Kirstine2510
    @Kirstine2510 13 років тому +1

    Lige så aktuel, måske mere nu, end da ordene blev udtalt første gang. Tydeligere for mig, hvor forudseende han var. Læste disse ord vel for over tyve år siden, og købte dem på skrift. Hvilken visdom i disse ord. Hvor er vores balance med naturen da kun løbet endnu mere af sporet siden da......... Love to the world

  • @RanjeevaSam
    @RanjeevaSam 14 років тому +2

    Thank you - thank you very very much. It has opened my eyes in many ways. Made me ashamed to benefit of western ideology. Thank you once again for posting - it's a very touching speech with a lot of wisdom.
    Ranjeeva

  • @downtourth
    @downtourth 8 років тому +9

    *_Could you imagine the deep heart felt pain being the most beautiful bravest loving trusting honest wise people this world has ever produced, caring for Mother Earth and realizing her wonder like no others.. then watch it stolen plundered trapped enslaved poisoned murdered Killed before them.. friends family wildlife.. their Children! Who could do that!? Why do we $till? \m/_*

    • @birdlynn417
      @birdlynn417 6 років тому +1

      I know it, how defeating the hope. Why the beautiful gets constantly destroyed again and again, and war still goes on. Stupid mankind. The brutal on top, and where is God's justice? To preserve the earth and what is good, why not more men joining in to protect the earth and the people for God's sake? Too sad.

    • @afelisafram2923
      @afelisafram2923 6 років тому +2

      How can I not feel and understand what Chief Seattle had in his mind when he wrote his letter. The concept of selling the earth does not exist in the native American tribes. We belong to earth, instead of selling, renting or destroy it, why not stop the nonsense, where ever we are, embrace what we have the air, the water, the soil, the natural resources and protect them like part of ourselves, is it hard to do it? I do not think so, Chief Seattle wrote that letter for the President at that time, but he wrote also to next generations after him and us today. Thank you you tube for sharing it with Facebook and Twitter and messenger groups.

  • @noahelge
    @noahelge 6 років тому +2

    "We are all one Tribe, the Human Tribe... "

  • @Mouryo
    @Mouryo 13 років тому +2

    This speech gives me goosebumps

  • @virginiaeasterling4347
    @virginiaeasterling4347 5 років тому +2

    I'm watching from My camper home in Clanton Alabama with my 2 dogs

  • @TheBestGoodbye
    @TheBestGoodbye Рік тому

    "Man did not weave the web of life, he is merely a strand in it. Whatever he does to the web, he does to himself. "
    I've studied western philosophy for a few years now and this is easily one of the most profound thoughts I've ever heard/read.

  • @Eriyah
    @Eriyah 15 років тому +1

    sadly moving beyond words.

  • @sharongallant1011
    @sharongallant1011 2 роки тому +1

    Beautiful

  • @birdlynn417
    @birdlynn417 6 років тому

    My heart is so with this speech all the way. Thank you, Chief Seattle, you have passed on so much to all mankind. We love the earth just like you, and it pains me to see what is happening to her even in these later days. If feels as though God has forsaken her, and the evil man runs away with doing more harm than good. A very sad, but beautiful goodbye.

  • @denksehno
    @denksehno 9 років тому +10

    A history of a world and a people gone under the greed and blindness of white men. The american dream is the nightmare of mother earth and its loving children.

  • @pat153-ku1lu
    @pat153-ku1lu Рік тому

    I am so sorry to hear l hope one day you and your people get the land back

  • @claudialegarde856
    @claudialegarde856 3 роки тому +2

    Its not late to to protect Mother Earth.

  • @BlackAcidDevilSlays
    @BlackAcidDevilSlays 11 років тому +4

    The real State of the Union.

  • @wellido4134
    @wellido4134 3 роки тому +3

    ICSE Students where are you 😂❤️

  • @bradleysymons1
    @bradleysymons1 2 роки тому +1

    Visionary, predictions which are coming to pass with each passing day.

  • @DalilaCunha
    @DalilaCunha 11 років тому +1

    Awesome quotes!

  • @BIRDYBOOLA
    @BIRDYBOOLA 13 років тому

    It pains my heart to see that so many of you are closed books. Open up your hearts to these words of wisdom. Mutual respect for one another and this Earth that we were given to care for (not own) is what you need. You have not woven the web but are merely a strand in it. A strand connected to all other strands. I pray that you awaken one day to see the beauty and strength within each and every one of you. A small candle can penetrate the darkness. Let us be many candles and a great light.

  • @claudialegarde856
    @claudialegarde856 3 роки тому +1

    Now covid 19 for not listening to our great chiefs and their knowledge! The protectors of the land who followed their instructions from the creator.!

  • @sharongallant1011
    @sharongallant1011 2 роки тому

    Just like Jan Smuts the earth is precious

  • @TheDreamMechanic
    @TheDreamMechanic 13 років тому

    Truly great advice not heeded.

  • @PoetryETrain
    @PoetryETrain 12 років тому

    Thank you, this has been added to our playlists here and on facebook...

  • @stanhootzz1904
    @stanhootzz1904 6 років тому

    Thank u fer the share.

  • @shirandesilva68
    @shirandesilva68 9 років тому

    The original and and native people all said it around the world each native tribe believed in saving all the living matter of this earth we have continued to avoid and ignored their voices and gain so much of wealth through causing suffer and pain to all living matter.

  • @DalilaCunha
    @DalilaCunha 11 років тому +1

    well said !

  • @marakixano0maki
    @marakixano0maki 12 років тому +1

    Οι λεξεις και οι φρασεις του Σιατλ με συγκινουν ιδιαιτερα διοτι εχουν μια μικρη δοση αφηγηματικοτητας και το κανει σαν ενα δημιουργικο ποιημα!!!
    ΜΑΡΙΑ ΣΤΕΠΑΝΙΔΟΥ

  • @mikey41rules
    @mikey41rules 10 років тому +1

    Soundgarden - Into the Void.

  • @Kirstine2510
    @Kirstine2510 12 років тому

    Det er godt tyve år siden, at jeg første gang læste disse ord. Ti år siden, at jeg købte den lille bog, der findes på dansk med den lille bog m en dansk oversættelse.
    Da vi arbejde med denne tale i historieundervisningen som teenager, så virkede disse ord vel nørmest forældede, fra en svunden tid, men jo ældre jeg bliver, jo mere visdom synes derat være i disse ord.

  • @clalrinsangacsanga7856
    @clalrinsangacsanga7856 6 років тому +1

    Salute

  • @SanjakPitakrat
    @SanjakPitakrat 14 років тому

    Great video.

  • @sharongallant1011
    @sharongallant1011 2 роки тому

    It's nothing that one has done whatever has been done to the web dose to himself

  • @jsimo1431
    @jsimo1431 3 роки тому

    the one thing that always stuck with me was when a native chief said they could drink from any lake, river, or stream until the white man came. money is the root of all evil. it's behind all of it.

  • @jimbarios
    @jimbarios 14 років тому +1

    wat genre of music is dis?

  • @coltzin12
    @coltzin12 15 років тому

    Sometimes? I always.

  • @marionerickson69
    @marionerickson69 10 років тому +2

    it is said that chief Seattle could not have known about the buffalo because the buffalo are too far east. Please google Chief Kwahs dagger and you will realize how first nations peoples used to share before contact. wheather he wrote this speech or not who cares you can't base the fact on that he didn't know about the buffalo because marriages were used in trade relationships. the carriers of the interior of bc knew of the coastal people and of the cree's across the rockies (there is a word for coastal people and cree people in carrier). So what I am saying is it is not safe to assume that chief seatle did not know of the buffalo especially at that time where in America a lot of native people where being displaced and moving further west. The only way you could prove that he didn't know of the buffalo is if perhaps there was no word for buffalo in coastal languages which is hard to prove because a lot of the coastal language was lost when natives where trading with white people (HBC) or sent to residential schools and forced speak English.

  • @twistedmr
    @twistedmr 14 років тому

    back at ya strokensword

  • @skycladdy
    @skycladdy 12 років тому

    @zzinglish53
    Third: If you want to know what ails the planet earth there is no way around studying economics (contemporary mainstream economics (especially Keynesians), Socialism (as in Das Kapital), and free market economics (especially “Austrian” Economics)). As starting point I’d recommend Carl Menger’s Principles of Economics, Henry Hazlitts Economics in one Lesson and Thomas Sowell’s Economic Facts and Fallacies;
    Think for yourself who is right, I think it’s largely the “Austrians”..

  • @skycladdy
    @skycladdy 12 років тому

    @zzinglish53
    Secondly: As nice as the speech is formulated it is full of romanticism, and gives the impression that Indians were super humans(especially because those words are ascribed to be said by them); As if they had no faults, lived in perfect harmony with every other creature on earth. For starters that also Indians are and were normal people with good and bad sides read this: Google for the Tom Woods article “were American Indians really environmentalists” and read the first link. ...

  • @AndreasHelberg
    @AndreasHelberg 12 років тому

    I am also thinking. On my channel "Steppenloewe1" (Lion of the step) I have posted some videos. The last is "footsteps/Fußstapfen" and is about a new way of thinking consistently. It greets Andreas.

  • @PoetryETrain
    @PoetryETrain 12 років тому

    @zzinglish53 Nice Write...

  • @PoetryETrain
    @PoetryETrain 12 років тому

    @zzinglish53 Nice write there....

  • @skycladdy
    @skycladdy 12 років тому

    Sorry for this bad wording and grammar. “As nice as the speech is formulated it is full of romanticism,..”
    Please read “As nicely as the speech is phrased it is full of romantic stereotypes,..”

  • @adamCarter20
    @adamCarter20 13 років тому +1

    Contaminate your bed and you will one night suffocate in your own waste

  • @huwzebediahthomas9193
    @huwzebediahthomas9193 2 роки тому

    ☯️

  • @drairlandadiazpino2791
    @drairlandadiazpino2791 12 років тому +1

    We know this american "courtesy" worldwide. That's why the whole world doesn't really like the United States. (And that's the truth)

  • @dudes110
    @dudes110 13 років тому

    This is not the original speech. This is the version that was written by Ted Perry for a film. Its nicely poetic but its not the original, To make a point The Salish did not hunt buffalo and the nearest Bison woukd have been a 1000 miles away for them to even have any knowlege of them. I think it is sad when we group people together that are really not the same. For example the Salish and the Lakota Sioux are both Native Americans but they are not the same people. They haven't same cultures.

  • @Glauberz1
    @Glauberz1 9 років тому

    Did he sold or not the land?

  • @beverly3397
    @beverly3397 2 роки тому

    Realize Native Americans still suffer and are taken advantage of

  • @hogo1
    @hogo1 13 років тому

    @supremecourtjester
    lol, what a joke, they new NOTHING about the theory of relativity.

  • @libbiewovsu
    @libbiewovsu 12 років тому

    click on 5:25 creeeepyyy....

  • @twistedmr
    @twistedmr 13 років тому

    @1977dwk I think we all know what i refer to..except yourself.

  • @supremecourtjester
    @supremecourtjester 13 років тому

    @hogo1 well as a matter of fact they did know about theory of relativity, they just didnt call it that. if you actually researched the wisdom instead of just being closed minded and cynical you will find that a lot of native american beliefs, over many tribes believe in a unified field which is a kin with the theory of relativity. their calendar is far more complex and accurate that our shitty gregorian calendar. i can keep going on if you like? just set your misery aside and learn something

  • @skycladdy
    @skycladdy 12 років тому

    @zzinglish53
    First: Isn’t it quite ironic to present “irrepressible” truth wrapped in a blatant lie, by putting those words a screen writer wrote a few decades ago into the mouth of native Indian who lived over a 150 years ago? So wouldn’t it be good if truth was really honored for what it is and the video author changed the title of the video or/and the description accordingly to e.g. “Screen writer Ted Perry’s speech, he wished was said by Chief Seattle”? Or is that too much Truth? ...

  • @dagwoodb
    @dagwoodb 13 років тому

    im norman /cherokee and english -normans were worse than anglo saxons maybe--indians never fought indians? ha such a joke-read history