Seachem Flourish review | Does Flourish work?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- Seachem Flourish is one of the most well known fertilizers on the market and I wanted to see what results I could get from it. This video will show you growth that I got with a month of use and I will give my opinion on the product.
#aquaapprentice
#FISHFAM
Intro Music:
/ rrpros1
INSTAGRAM @aqua_apprentice
You're not alone brother... I can't keep a java fern heathly to save my life lol... My Anubius look great though!!
thanks you know the saying, “misery loves company” lol
@@pleco101 agreed, I like crypts also, bulletproof.
Me too lol. The baby java ferns on the dead java fern grow better than I can ever get it to grow when i'm dedicated to it
its been a while bro! used seachem flourish in my planted tanks and so far i get good results :) great video
yea it's been a bit, had a lot to get done the past couple weeks. Yea I was actually happy with Flourish, did more than what I was expecting. Always good seeing you dbachelor.
@@AquaApprentice e
Glad your doing fine bro .It's always a pleasure to watch your videos good job.
Thanks Joe I really appreciate the kind words, it keeps me motivated.
Just put the java fern on to some drift wood and stock your tank a little bit more just don't touch your java fern after you glue it to the drift wood the leafs or parts that split off will grow by themselves around the tank some with massive java ferns just have them floating in the back and makes it look like a background plant
Idk if anyone can answer this but if I have a 10gal planted tank with activ flora for substrate and I used purified gallon bottled water for the tank. Will me using seachem flourish be adequate in adding the different minerals to the tank that are lost from using purified water when doing water changes?
Thanks for sharing.
My understanding is that Flourish only provides part of what plants need. In my 65 gallon, moderately stocked community tank, I supplement it with a normal dose of Easy-Green twice a week (since it doesn't list any significant micronutrients) and have seen pretty significant growth over the past two months I've been doing this. Prior to that most of my plants looked like your poor Java Fern. It was very depressing!
But I should also add that I also started CO2 injection via a CO2Art bazooka diffuser, so that complicates things. But I stand by my chemical hypothesis that Flourish and Easy-Green complement each other.
This makes sense to me. Your all in one is great but typically made for low tech so supplementing the two would give you the boost in macros that you need. Sounds like if you got Co2 you got a heavily planted tank and I have recently dipped my toe into Co2 and am loving the results.
Flourish mainly feed plants that absorb nutrients from the water column. Your crypts, which feed from the roots, will do better with a root tab pushed deep into the substrate next to each one. (I think yours are each a few inches apart. If they're really close, one tab for several will do.)
Anthony Ragan I actually have some DIY root tabs but I wanted to see the results without it first. My understanding is all plants benefit from water column ferts where not as many benefit from root tabs. That being said I agree with you that there are heavy root feeders out there, like crypts and swords that will do great with the tabs. Thanks for watching and for the advice.
Exactly, you are absolutely right.
Nice. I'd say it's a solid product. If you already have most of the nutrients big results won't really happen but if someone has not as many nutrients and add this stuff it'd have a big impact. Nice video and tank.
Completely agree Christian. It still definitely has its uses but there are are cheaper alternatives out there that I am dabbling with now.
@@AquaApprentice nice. Java fern grows great for me lol. Just don't plant it and it grows. Not sure what the problem is. Bad luck
I personally use macro and micro ferts from a small german brand and some diy CO2. Works well so far :)
I imagine are water is completely different but I am thinking I dont need macros in my water. That being said I could be completely incorrect and hopefully i find out after I try a few more things.
congrats on the sb win
Java fern doesnt like to be rooted into substrate. Attach it to wood or rock.
Yea I have done it in all these ways and it just doesn’t like me so I have stayed away for a bit but it may be time to try it again. Thanks for the tips though.
@@AquaApprentice did you cut the black string above the roots of the Java fern?
This stuff grows algae is my tanks quickly in small small doses!
If thats the case you probably dont need it. I am guessing if it only started when you dose that you dont have enough plants or maybe just not fast growing plants and its leaving excess nutrients. I dont think fertilizing is necessary unless you start to see deficiencies in your plants. Good luck and I hope this helps
Dosing it every other day can cause a black beard algae bloom. This algae type will grow in aquariums where there is CO2 fluctuation. So, to avoid any BBA outbreak, I strongly recommend using Flourish Excel on daily basis
@@veronicagraham6799 how much daily ? I read half the dose every other day , I have fern problems also but my anubias are doing great so far I'm a beginner
@@TURKO2424 i’m a beginner too! so it really depends on what you have in your tank :) when i was doing it i used it every day with half doses and it ended up not doing well. depending on how many plants are in your tank, how big it is, and what you might have in it already the answer will change. If you can i’d find someone who’s experienced :)
This may sound dumb but does more fertilizer doses mean they’ll grow faster?
Not dumb at all. Yes a lot of species will definitely grow faster while others will be hard to tell if they are. The ultimate growth enhancer in a planted tank is CO2 if your looking for growth.
I have a 65 gallon tank
How much do I add flourish excel and Flourish ?
Thanks and best regards
Bob
Good video. I am using Floutish now in my tank, too. By the way, what's the soundtrack?
Sergio MG looks like he changed his name on SoundCloud so the original link in description does not work.
This is his Instagram
instagram.com/tito_beats?igshid=yygdduq50w0p
Hi, do you think fertilizer would help my outdoor plant bucket
Do we need to keep our filter off while dosing this ? & for how many hours ?
No you do not need to turn your filter of when you use fertilizer.
Not sure if anyone asked this yet. Do you use carbon in your filter, does the flourish work with activated carbon. Or do you have to remove it.
Remove it even when using water based fertilizers
I have a very similar landscape and I use flourish and root taps and my plants are massive thriving beautiful. Try rooftops they made all the difference in the world.
Carbon is the building block for all freshwater plants. Flourish provides this. There's a reason it's so popular. Not sure why but someone is spreading lies about it online.
why do you even need this stuff. I thought the fish fertilize the plants?? that's what Hydroponics is all about.
Well you don’t always need it. For example the plants I have are all low demand plants that will do fine with just the nutrients in the water and fish waste. The catch for mine was that as my plants grew and I got more there wasn’t enough for a large load of plants. So I started dosing and you could tell that the plants were healthier looking. Then you have other types of plants that have higher demand for other types of nutrients and that’s went fertilizing becomes critical. My suggestion is research the plants and buy what fits your needs. Other than that just give them a look from time to time to see if they aren’t thriving and then maybe give this fert or one of the all in one ferts a try.
Give your tank some excel "co2" . Make a video about it 😀
I could definitely do that. Do you think it should be in conjunction with Flourish or just on its own?
Aqua Apprentice both 😀
Awesome video!! Great tips!! Love the shirt!! New friend here!
NIce review...the first supplement review I've seen that covers weeks to actually show the "before & after" effect on the plants. No one can argue with color and growth.
Hello, I allow myself to contact you because I wanted to ask you a question. I always shake my bottle before applying Flourish fertilizers. Inside the bottle a reaction of this product which makes a lot of bubbles. does shaking the falcon before applying damage it? thanks in advance good day to you
Great video Aqua! Java Fern won't grow for me too! It's so annoying! Keep it up bro!
Thanks for the compliment. LOL good to see other people are having Java Fern issues. We will eventually get it figured out.
Jesus Christ... how am I gonna dose this in a 5 gallon tank?
I would use a pipette or a child medicine syringe or dosage cup. All those things have ml’s listed on it so you can do it more accurately. Since it took me so long to answer though you may already have your answer 😁
After watching the video, I must say Go Bucs!
Do not add it as soon as you do a water change, water conditioners remove most of the metals present in the nutrients so basically you are taking away the much needed iron
I don’t think it gets rid of iron but breaks up the chlorine bond. That being said I have never actually looked into this so I will do some research because if your right, I am wasting a lot of the fertilizer. Thanks for the comment.
@@AquaApprentice did you ever find out the answer ? I would like to know.
Anthony Lowney there is a lot of mixed opinions out there on this and I have no way of proving one or the other. I still add it after water changes, haven’t seen enough of an effect to stop
@@AquaApprentice Thanks for the quick reply.
It's good to practice this. To give time for the water conditioner to work first.. and to let a balance happen first.
You flourished but u didnt excel combine flourish and excel and u see some superb results. Excel is liquid carbon
Can tell me the name of the bigger plant in ur tank ?
ok! we are still missing you out here… Just checking in & was re-watching some of your old videos. Oh yes do not forget to make some thank you for closing my door during the hurricane cookies for your neighbor for Christmas! Merry 🎄 Christmas to you and your family. 🎁
Yea if not this Friday then next I will have a video out. Appreciate the encouragement it means a lot. Merry christmas to you and your family as well.
Aqua Apprentice I just found your Instagram so at least I know you’re still alive👌🏽
Your java fern may have died off if you butteries the risome (the part the roots come off from) because those plants aren’t supposed to have buried roots
Right. I attached to a rock just like I did with my anubias but no luck. I have stayed away from it for a bit but I think it’s time to try again. I will beat the Java Fern curse 😂
What’s that tune in the background?
Im kinda of on the same boat, as far as my java ferns dying of over time, mean while all my anubias of various different species seem to thrive relatively well.
Great info on the fertilizer. Looks like it really helped the plants. Happy your family did ok during the storm. ☺️
Thanks a lot. How did your family fare through it?
We did ok. Just without power for 4 days so it wasn't bad. Even family in Miami did ok as well ☺️
HopArt Studio that's awesome to hear. My family did ok in Miami as well. Crazy how unpredictable those hurricanes can be.
Is this good for turtles does it affect them?
Nice Video! Just subscribed, I have the same shirt, had her sign it when she lectured at the West Coast Goldfish Palooza in San Jose, CA, keep up the great work! :)
So glad to know you all through! Great video ☺
Thanks Rebecca, did your in-laws make it through ok as well? Also wanted to see if you got your sticker? Sent it out last week and thought I would check.
✌️✌️✌️ great video 👍👍👍👍👍
Why not have a root tab under the Fern then?
Hey, I have 2 betta fish and I would love to put a guppy in one of those is there any way I could get a guppy or two.
Let me first say I have no personal experience with bettas. The thing I hear most is every bettas temperament is different. I have seen some kept with a couple guppies in a 20 gallon but going any smaller can be risky. Overall I think most people will tell you not to keep them with anything else other than snails but if you decide to try I would just make sure you have a backup home for the guppies or the betta.
I am using this product for 4 months and didn't notice any differences and now my java fern started dying
Daniel sorry to hear that. I think it depends on how heavy you have planted and what types of plants. Some tap water has enough nutrients in it for a lot of things so this may not even be needed in your case. I don’t know why your java fern is dying but I would look for something else to be the cause. This just adds nutrients and nutrients wouldn’t kill anything but if anything maybe cause algae if there are excess nutrients.
I just had potassium, & Iron flourish oh and the flourish tabs I think those work real good I got what I need to set up the tub pond.Waiting for the fence to get fixed.Good vid.
I think potassium and Iron is definitely something that is lacking in our water naturally. Did the hurricane mess up your fence?
Do you have to also use root tabs
Justice For Maximilianmus root tabs aren’t necessary for every plant but is a good idea for any heavy root feeders like crypts and swords.
IMPORTANT QUESTION: Can I add Liquid Carbon and Pressurised CO2 in the same tank?
Yes you can. As liquid carbon is more of an anti algaecide.
Can this be used with an All In One Fertilizer?
Yes indeed.
Great info great video. Thanks for sharing your experiences..
Glad to see you back and safe..
Angelo thanks, I gotta try a few things out but maybe I can have some nice lush tanks like you in the future. Always good to see you
Aqua Apprentice wow thanks man your to kind.Want a little trick?
Cmon Angelo do I have to even answer that. Of course I want a trick 😁
Aqua Apprentice set your lights on a timer have it come on 8-12 off 12-4 on again 4-8 it helps the plants produce its own carbon naturally I do this to all my planted tanks. It works wonders my plants try it out if you'd like..😉I find my plants much healthier since I been doing this 😁👍👍
Came for the info stayed for the music 👌
My java moss some part is browning and also some red plant old leaves starts decaying with new leaves grow so do i need flourish potassium or iron?
Kind of odd for java moss to brown as its a pretty low light plant. Do you dose excel or use any salt in your tanks? For your red plant your leaves are growing as others are dying off so it may just be converting from emersed grown to submerged. In most plant farms aquatic plants are grown emersed and therefore go through a transition period for a while once introduced to a tank. I would just keep an eye on things and if they get worst maybe a liquid fert like Flourish may help or you could also try an all-in-one like Easy green from aquarium co-op or Thrive from Niloc-G. good luck
I use Seachem Flourish used to use root zone that stuff suck tho great video man !
leaf zone not root
David's Fish Tanks never heard of leaf zone but thanks for the warning. Yea I think the flourish did a pretty good job but I am excited to try other types and see how they compare.
Will API leaf zone or other liquid fertilizer lower pH?
Most do not affect your PH levels. That being said I have no experience with leaf zone.
This will poison shrimp that is in the tank bc of cu content
nope
Not true. Minuscule amounts if dosed correctly.
tanks look good. Thanks for sharing. Glad all is well.
The tanks did improve a bit so I was pretty happy with it. Glad it went well too, was genuinely worried for quite a bit there.
Gr8 video ☺️👍
Thanks bud. Always appreciate the support you give.
What are the white growths on the orang fish (Molly?) @ 1:55???
Fotosynthesis858 it was a swordtail. Not sure what it was but the growths got even larger causing it to have trouble so I ended up putting it down.
Aqua Apprentice good call. It's always tough euthanizing a fish or any pet. I had to do that to a corydora cat that grew up misfigured from a fry. Great video. Keep up the good work. 👍🏾👍🏾
Aqua Apprentice BRO! I NEED YOUR HELP! I've been looking all over the web for the answer but keep getting conflicting answers. My question is about dosing with Flourish IRON. The chart I saw said to dose everyday except the 7th day. Do I do a water change at the end of the week then repeat the 6 day of dosing??? HELP! 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
Fotosynthesis858 can you tell me some info on what size tank you have, plant stock, and what else you are dosing? First thought with the amount of iron you are putting is a daily fert regiment at low doses but not sure without more info.
Look like someone WCW is Jenny haha
Justin Tinbui she is a very pretty girl but unfortunately for her I am married with 2 kids 😂. In all seriousness her channel helped me a lot in this hobby. Thanks for stopping by.
my crypts grow like 3-4 new leaves weekly
😮 wow that is definitely not typical. I think I get 1 leaf about every week and a half. You must be doing something right.
Irma was bad checking in from bradenton
Yea your right on the coast there so Im sure it affected you guys quite a bit. Used to visit Anna Maria over there pretty often.
I'm using flourish and flourish excel
dude check out my channel I gave u a shout out
Do you need this if using Amazonia soil ?
Filip laskovski When using soil you usually will get some leeching from the soil into the warmer column unless capped. What I would do is keep an eye on your plants and not add any liquid ferts until it looks like your plants need it. Reason being is that there may be excess nutrients in the water if you don’t wait and could be a big algae issue.
Aqua Apprentice awesome thanks for the advice bro
@@AquaApprentice hey i have really short green algae growing on my plants, what can i do?
Gansta Crips!
Lol they are getting there
are you running co2 in your tank? Thanks for the video.
No I don’t run CO2 in the tank. This is a low tech set up with all low demand plants. Your welcome for the vid 😁
Another great video! Glad to hear you didn't get the brunt of the hurricane. Good neighbors are worth more than gold. Since I relocated I have had the worst luck with java fern too. If you crack it let me know.
Yes I am lucky and surrounded by good neighbors but have had bad before and it is not fun. If I crack the Java fern problem I am letting everyone know of my great victory LOL
adding this Flourish to my two tanks resulting in my beautiful frogbits turning brown and dying and stinking up the tank. Be careful. Don't use this. I also added it to a used 10 gal tank that I decided to change substrate (to shrimp substrate) after I added Flourish - the cycling was stifled and again - plants started dying. Now the cycling has to continue longer. In short, I've had bad results.
Something else sounds off. I have continued to use this product and have had nothing but good results. I dont think your lying but this is really just providing nutrients that are already present in most water so it wouldn’t make sense for to do what you are saying. I would think if there was anything else that you have changed around the same time. It’s just odd and I hope you find your answer.