जाति पर Isabel Wilkerson की किताब: दुनिया में चर्चा, India में चुप्पी
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 сер 2020
- #DilipMandalKiPathshala
यह किताब - Caste: The Origins of Our Discontent - इसाबेल विलकिरसन के अश्वेत होने के जीवन अनुभव से निकली है, जो उन्हें एक अलग विश्वदृष्टि देती है. इस अनुभव के आधार पर उन्होंने अमेरिका और नाजी जर्मनी के नस्लभेद को Indian caste system के साथ जोड़कर देखा है और यहां से उन्हें अमेरिकी नस्लभेद की समस्या को समझने की नई दृष्टि और भाषा मिली है.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
Only oppressed can feel oppression. Oppressors usually consider its not existence.
Kaise oppress kiya gya hai aapko aajtak? Please elaborate
It's in ur mind, if I see others without biased, then I will be treated well.
When law, constitution give I equality then y u r worry about others.
If some treated I had for 100 yrs, it does not mean that u will feel bad for next 100 yts.
@@ujarmritvaan3002 lmao proved his point
@@mjan1509 not 100 but atleast 1000 while you sell your countries to invaders.
All the caste must be same... We must unite, without discrimination
lol
CASTE is a biology -ecology -math competition -full of evolution and not with discrimination !!! lol
This journalist is good.like to here more from him...I am regular viewer of print ...promote him well shekar ji
Hi Abhishek. Do keep tuning in.
Dilip mondal jaise patrakar bahut jaruri hai ,Jo samaja ko ayena dikhate hai
jab caste certificate leke reservation lete ho tab aina dekhte ho ki nehi
hamara cut off open category jitna hi AATA lakin hai. To cast certificate ka Kya fayda .agar desh 52 %varg agar desh ke sansathao me 20 % se Kam bhagidari rakhata hai to kuch to galat hoga
@@helsreach001 hm....tumhara cutoof hamse lagbhag adha hota he...aur agar tumhe jati agar khatam karna he aur jati certificate nikalna he to kaise chalega
@@kp2294 thoda Google karlo pariksa ke sandharbh me
@@helsreach001 me jee ka baat kar raha tha...jab scholarship tumko mile humko nehi kyu
Muslim and Sikh have caste system too
I'm sikh i can confirm it .
Because South Asian religions and conversions also kept their vices. They didn't change their social nature by just conversion. That is a big misconception.
All Sikh Gurus belong to same Khatri caste and Gurudom was passed from father to son. Sikhism is an embodiment of caste not against caste. Now Sikhism is same as Jattism.
Muslims and Sikh have caste because converted casteist people continued that even after conversion into Sikh and Muslims basically both are founded on equality
@@bhinbhinkaka6514 you are totally wrong guru Granth Sahib includes ideology of Kabir tukaram ghasidas and ravidas etc saints all were believers of equality and rationality
@Andrew David because converted Thakur Bania Brahmin kept their identity intact even after conversion to Christianity and Islam
Guys , we can just be open to this debate on discrimination without spreading hatred .
I'm brahmin ,but I have no issues with that.
Mondal you have explained it very well.
That's what is necessary. The topic needs to be brought in public discourse.
Bro uska twitter check karo .. he spews hatred towards Brahmins all day .. standing up for Dalits does not justify humiliating other communities without knowing them personally .. he should condemn the crimes happening in society but he has no right to stereotype a community ..
@@nikitamishra3408 read manusmriti first
@@amarkhadse4718 Nothing can justify generalizing a 6.5 crore population ..Crimes and discrimination is a real thing . But is everyone (6.5 crore) a criminal ?
I get abused for my surname ? why ? what the hell have I done ? I don't discriminate people ..how is it fair to abuse me without knowing anything about me personally !?
@@nikitamishra3408 Unless you marry a dalit, they won't absolve you from casteism.
Our oppression is 3000 years old while they have faced it for 300 years. The level of pain in India is on another level. We sympathies with American blacks.
Break the shackles of caste system and the Hinduism. Majority people in developed countries are atheist and doing pretty good
@@schrodingerscat9426 before committing this ....
What actually u have read about the religion....
U want to bycot it only because u don't know anything about it and let me tell u will an example...
Remember when u were kid and Don't want to study....
But now u know how Much it is important....
So like that u don't want to study that's why u want to boycott it.
Lol chattel slavery of America and caste system of India has no similarities.
@@schrodingerscat9426 USA is very religious and every discourse revolves around Bible. The athiest scandinavian countries u are taking about is sparsely populated. Population density is very low and lot of land is available. Their population size is comparable to our Cities or Municipalities.
@@adityavishwakarma958 I don't think I need religion to guide me to being a better person or whatever. I can be better person if I want to be with discipline and working on myself, improving myself everyday, I just need to think as a human
Shekhar Gupta, Dilip Mandal, can you please share transcript of this video?
Regards,
*भारत में जाती की व्याख्या- जो नहीं जाती, उसी को कहते हैं जाती 😪🤦♂️*
Interesting summary !
Thank you for such wonderful insights. It indeed is a topic which should be discussed more often especially in a country like India where it is still prevalent. Would get a copy of it in near future!
kitna discuss karoge be....jab 10 dalit party banakar bethe ho aur jati dekhkar vote de rahe ho
Hi Bikash. Thanks for tuning in.
सर क्या यह किताब हिंदी में मिल सकती है यदि हां तो कहां से और यदि नहीं तो कब तक इसका हिंदी अनुवाद मिल सकता है क्योंकि अंग्रेजी वर्जन पढ़ने में बहुत समय लग जाएगा।
Dilip Sir you already provided good summary . It's like I have read the book....🤗
Very good analysis.
a great book.....every indian must read if they want to make india developed and great country!!
She Is African American and writing on caste . Even you would have written something Indian should have been reading . Caste is having multiple prospects in india itself . People think of it in india in many frames . Better dont talk about europian ,American people's book or comment on caste .
@truth seeker you are fool and nobody can win over foolishness of a fool
Very good review sir
Superb Analysis Sir....
Good work by dilip sir.
Good. At least books are getting published outside India.
Please review more books like this🙏
Very nice aap ka विश्लेष bhaut accha hi
भारत हमारी स्वतंत्रता की पहचान है जबकि हिंदुस्तान गुलामी की । इसलिए भारतीय बने और भारतीय बनाएं ।
Sir Hindi me bhi available hai kya..?
That’s why we should mainly focus for SOCIAL JUSTICE
ooh....when dalit vote only for their party and tell others for social justice
tyrion lannister ohh really tell me which party- BJP😡😡😡 ridiculous.... BJP Morons are implementing CAA discriminating religious which is big thing and then how its possible that they will do social justice with Castiesm....
S k p yup that’s true BJP is doing at large scale only taking dalit votes by throwing jumlas like stand up India, making dalit President and saying not enter in mandir, providing prasad first to a dalit and not making any OBC and dalits trustee of Ram mandir nirman😡😡😡😡 bjp is hell regarding social justice
👍 Good work
I think before discussion people need to read this book and later provide there comments. If you had read this book and made this video I had valued for inputs more.
I completely agree with you.People are just basing their opinions on this short review.What people don't understand that this video is not a detailed analysis of the book merely a brief introduction so that people can know about it and curious people can acquire more knowledge.
sir ,India ke news channel meh ,cheetah vs lion dikha raha hai, yeh book uske saamne kya gul khilaygi
chutiyapa ka book chutiya logo ko pasand ayega
@@kp2294 oh PAID BJP boy Shut******
Ek shudra hone ke Nate Mai kah sakta ki cast system aaj bhi hai.
hm hoga bhi bhi kyu ki caste certificate to tum log nikalkar reservation lete ho to hoga hi
Mind Begs the Question:
Hitler - treated Jews 2nd Class,
British - treated Indians 2nd Class,
Unequal Rights based on Caste,Religion,
Gods System,or Evil System?
Mu slims treated non Mu slims as dhi mmis in Isl amic nations and demanded ja ziya tax to be paid for survival. Why so much hatred for ka firs??
इस किताब को हिन्दी मैं अनुवादित कराना चाहिए l
हर कोई English नहीं समज सकता लेकिन हिन्दी तो समझ ही सकता है l
Even when caste system is near it's end in the cities. I don't think it will be wiped out from rural areas anytime soon. Caste discrimination is very much prevalent in rural India
Caste is the foundation of society. It can only end when society cease to exist. We need to go back to hunter gathering time to end caste hierarchy.
@@bhinbhinkaka6514 but when reservation end because u want malai of reservation
@@kp2294 I dont get any kind of reservations.I am a Shudra and belong to General category
@@bhinbhinkaka6514you are not a shudra but your mentality is
Just leave the fake religion
Thank to you,sir
Human Hierarchy division was envisioned by Vedas, Plato, Confusious etc. Varna System, caste system are the product of this hierarchy which continues till today. It has redefined itself with time and geography. It was always been about control of resources and access. It has mechanism of supremacy and purity. In India base of caste is religion in America it is race, you can find castes in Africa, Japan etc. It is global issue. In Marxist terms one must think caste as a base along with class rather than superstructure.
Isabel is onto something here.
Bahut sundar sir... good explanation about book...
*Correction.
In 1822 British done a survey in india about the educational structure....
They found that everyone have right to study including dalits....
There might be a slight difference between the castes of teacher
Like somewhere only 7 percent teachers were bhramin and avg bhramin teacher in school was 40%.
Why we are divided....
Because we are reading history written by colonial powers.
We need caste system....
But not like it is present today,
It was not hereditary and was flexible.
That means bhramin (teachers) can become merchants (vaishya)
And those who are shudras were those who were caught in crime and was punished to serve .....
But as time changes...
It becomes rigid in nature.
Their is a psychological aspect of the caste system.
Comment down if u want to know.
Reservation will give opportunity not equality.
Diversity Training: WHY Indian upper caste do not get enraged for violence against dalits the way white people in west fight for rights of non whites.
Recently many people discussed this issue on social media ( you tube atleast some dalit media channels.)
There are many reasons.
Biggest one is theory of karma , which makes people believe dalits deserve the life they got due to past life karmas and any thing they get to mitigate their bad situation is non deserving and kind of favor to them. This is at subconscious level and people hardly recognize it. But let's keep that for other time as it by itself a very deep and broad topic.Another reason is white guilt against racism vs Caste pride in subcontinent. Let's keep that for some other time as well.
Coming to the issue:
BECAUSE most people don't see caste system as an Issue or atleast their issue. They don't see how caste system has harmed nation for miliniums and still doing it.
For educated upper caste: they see some intercaste marriage between upper castes and declare caste system non existent.
Most of them know Caste system through reservation system and start hating undeserving lower castes because they do not know and are not taught history of the land and why we came to this point. For them it's unjust ( technically they are right it's positive descrimination in favor of dalits) and need to go.
When upper caste say real issue is economic status and reservation should be on that basis they have middle class or poor in mind but they have no idea what actual poverty is in villages and condition of poorest which belong to dalit Community. They can't see that these dalits are not only kept poor but exploited and humiliated for generations and it's high time upper caste India realize how selfish they are being when they choose to ignore this fact. Conversely, you see in West presence of "White guilt" where white people are ready accept historic wrong doings and are ready to fight to amend it. That is due to education and diversity Training.
They are not taught how for thousands of years dalits were not allowed into temples, segregated from society and only after constitution they got basic human rights.
They don't realize how this issue threatens national security as well( naxalite movement).
They don't realize how caste system among upper caste also is detrimental to the unity of nation.
Is Caste based politics not hindrance and threat to unity of nation.
Stark inequality is a recognized threat to democracy and prosperity in any society. Don't we need to address that?
They are not taught in school why India remain segregated compared to societies around globe due to caste system. There are similar things like caste in other countries but nothing as vicious as Caste system.
Example:
In my school ( one of the best in Gujarat at the time) mostly attended by upper caste ( jains, Patel, Bania, Brahmin) they would announce list of castes ( lower caste) and if you belong to any of them you go to office in the middle of lecture. Then they ask if your parents earn enough or you need to apply for certain assistance , if not you need to submit a letter in writing. Class used to burst into laughing when they announce these castes because most of the these caste names are used as curse words in Local language.
This is their experience with other lower caste. Teachers also used to laugh but missed opportunity to teach students that just how proudly they say their caste some are cursed to be in caste which is curse word for no fault of theirs ( karma theory comes in to play here) and that is wrong. No need to say No religious diversity as well.
********
Solution:
*********
What we can really use is diversity Training program like in US , starting from primary school to college and work place.
In this we can include all kinds of descrimination ( handicap, gender, race (north east people, ) , regional biases, sexual orientation and caste descrimination.
People should learn what kind of behavior is not appropriate, not legal, how to identify it, what are your legal rights, how can you help prevent it.
Media can help spread awareness too.
Remember : " Mile sur Mera tumhara" or " Chalo padhaye kuch Kar dikhaye".
School kids can have projects like making pen friends ( Facebook) from other religions, other caste, from different backgrounds.
Summer project can be to educate some one illiterate. You can be creative and sky is the limit.
Trips to local village where people still practicing these descrimination. This will create awareness and pressure to get rid of caste system based and other descrimination.
Dr Ambedkar said unless people share bread, birth, death , joy and sorrows together they will not feel cohesion in their hearts.
People need to know women ( Common women)did not have right to property and inheritance until constitution gave them that right. In absence of that knowledge they just hate Dr Ambedkar as someone who has imposed reservation for dalits and hate him along with dalits. In really Dr Ambedkar had to resign fighting for these rights for women ( Hindu code bill) and not a single leader of the time supported him and hindy leaders vehemently opposed it.( We were not that liberal as we are told, and we still aren't compared to West)
These things need to be discussed and debated. But how many social science students study such things?
In villages people still don't mingle in each others birth, death and marriage ceremony, seperate cemetery, seperate well. A lot need to be done.
This is a proven thing which has worked in US and West, can work in India as well.
Only change in attitude will bring equality.
We need to ask for this in every State and national level this should be implemented. There are other things that can be donebut that for other time.
Please start spreading word (email to people in power,in person what ever way) we have lost 73 years can't wait anymore.
But unfortunately, contrary to what is required, there is a big movement going on in which they deny there is or ever was Caste descrimination in India.
There is a big effort to blame whole thing on British ( Check Rajiv Malhotra, subramaniam swami etc on UA-cam).
If we don't accept problem how and when are we going to solve it.
Sir kaya bakwar kar rahay ho ?
Africa mai hai identity : Bantu vs non-Bantu races
Europe : Germanic vs Slave vs Celtic vs Eastern-European Caucasus vs Greek/Turkish.
Japan mai bhi cast system hai
india mai aadmi ko dhek kar cast nahi bata sakty hay
Buddy you missed out on the main point of the book!, it is not about the color of the skin, that is her whole argument.
The point she is saying is its more about creating a subservient identity, that could be based on religion, birth, race anything, it could be even on what month you were born in as long as there is a way to identify it.
@@vimalvaira
You can change your birth month by lying, change your theological nonsense. But you can't change your race because it's visible.
She said it's only visible in US and not in Europe or Africa. Which is wrong
@
Never talked about banning a book
Manish K S Again you are missing the point!
The point is black people are not looked down because they are black, they are looked down because of an identity! The same as the caste!
@@vimalvaira so who tell u to hold ur surname change it and give a surname of upper caste,but u dont want that because u want malai of reservation,so dont tell one side.if u feel discrimination then simply change ur surname to uppercaste surname,ok.
Brahminical forces should learn their lesson and behave. They may face severe backlash once Bahujans say enough is enough
जय भीम दिलीप मंडल साहब आपका टि्वटर अकाउंट और फेसबुक अस्थाई तौर पर पेज क्यों हटाया गया जानकारी बताने का कष्ट करेंगे
इस तरह के लोगो के चलते आज भी अमेरिका मे श्वेत बंदे इन कृत्रिम रूप से पीड़ित अश्वेत बंदो को समझ ही नही पाते ।
I think the fundamental question is about identity. Be it caste or religion. All religions/sects/castes have this notion that they are superior than other groups of similar nature. This is exemplified by notions like "this is the only true path" etc.
I'm soo glad that print has covered this report. Sure racial discrimination is a big time issue worldwide..
jab 30 lake seat lete ho tab kharap nehi lagta...jati certificate nikalte tym kharap nehi lagta...sirf victim card khel
Manual sahab thoda padh lete to achcha rahta , kitni baatein galat bol di apne bina jane yaha apni baat saabit karne k liye
Kya galat bol diya? Jra detail mein likho
White Black conflict rooted in race but caste is not. And, two, intercaste marriages are validated in Hindu scriptures but black white inter marriages are not allowed at all in white black conflict.
I think that now time is coming when we had to make videos with English subtitles, as we will now communicate with our black scholar brothers, and discuss this problem.
Standing up for a particular community doesn't give right to humiliate others
If caste is comes from religion only then why Muslims, Even Old Baudhs are having this division. Its just a social issue . We have many so called low caste persons who became Maharashi . Balmiki , Ved Vyas , Durvasa are one of them . First Ramayana and Mahabharat are written by them . Caste is issue of Indian society mostly.
Sir ,, ess kitab ka marathi aur hindi me anuvad kijiye🙏
Another great example of orientalism as a western scholar seeing Easter society through Western lens.
Ambedkar in his article caste in india said that India is mix of races. So comparing race and caste is stupidity
There are two main castes: faithful and infidel.
Muh kholne ke liye pehle sareer mein reedh ki haddi ka bhi hona jaruri he aur humare yahan toh sab spineless hi hain..
You will find this review valid if you watched the (TheGreatCourses) course "America's long struggle against slavery".
दिलीप सर आप किन कठिन परिस्थितियों में बहुजन समाज के इन लोगों को जाग्रत करने का काम कर रहे हैं और यह है बहुजन समाज के सभी अगवा नेता बहुजन विचार को कोमा में जिंदा रखने की कोशिश कर रहे हैं सर इन सब को छोड़िए आप और आपके जैसे बहुजन समाज के व्यक्तियों को साथ लाकर एक बहुजन मूलनिवासी राष्ट्रीय पार्टी या सामाजिक संगठन की स्थापना की जाए क्योंकि अब आप देखिए आजादी के 70 साल होने पर भी बहुजन समाज मैं अपने वर्ग का इतिहास भारत का इतिहास भारत का राजनीतिक इतिहास पर एक राय नहीं है तो हम आगे कैसे बढ़ सकते हैं आप समझ सकते हैं गुमराह होना कितना आसान है पर आप बाबासाहेब के द्वारा बताए गए रास्ते पर साइंटिफिक और तथ्यात्मक तरीके से अपनी बात रखते हैं आपका धन्यवाद
Jai bhim jai bharat
Nice information
I believe lack of appreciation for this book is because of the very entrenched nature of caste system in india. There are sub castes within caste and the level complexity of this system is just very difficult for a simplistic understanding of a foreigner.
that has nothing to do with that book, people in India don't consider it a problem, though it has been the root of 99% problem in UP
@@vimalvaira thats why dalit vote only for dalit party
Caste discrimination is much like any other form of discrimination, but so ingrained in people's psyche, that it refuses to leave, because people refuse to let it go.
When some general category fellow is denied a job or promotion just because his forefathers discriminated he walks into the quagmire of caste . He starts hating the previledged & a reserve caste system starts. Caste system is here to stay forever.
Those dislike show how castiest people r around us
The problem is that you don't want to talk of solutions but raise the issue again and again just to become popular and sow seeds of discontent in society. Since thousands of years leaders from within Hindu community have fought against caste discrimination. You don't find that romantic now and therefore climb on the back of a foreign author who has zilch idea of Indian society.
हल यही है कि धर्म के नाम पर धंधा बंद करो। आरक्षण के खिलाफ आवाज उठाने से अच्छा है कि जाति को हटाने को आवाज उठाओ।
I'm really sorry for your uncle Vikas Dubey.
@@xenon6947 I am also sorry for your dad Burhan Wani
यह किताब हिंदी में है या नहीं यदि नहीं है तो , इसका हिन्दी मेंअनुवाद होना चाहिए।।
Bhai ye hamare samaj ki kadavi sachai hai , Bhale hi metro City me jati vavastha khatam hote AA rahi hai keuki vaha industrialization hai lakin hamare undeveloped area me hai .
Agar cast system nahi hota to Bharat kabhi gulam nahi hota ye khud sawarakar ne bhi Mana .
Bhramhanwad ne Bharat me Sara kabada KR Diya .
Khud shivaji Maharaj ko shudra kah KR unhe raja manane inkar Kiya tha .
I thought ,He was going to talk about new book " Delhi Riots 2020 "...Oh Well..
Caste system is not different than religions ,races or even nationality....We all have tribal mentality....There are over 500 different tribes in Africa..Most of them hate each others and live in different towns....
There are around 9 different ethnic groups in China....Hans only get married with Hans and same with Zhuang ,Hui or other ethnicities....
I think 90's generation doesnt have dicrimination problem....
Aap daily dikhao... India main charcha hoga... Don't worry
Bharat mein kyun charcha hogi.....african india k baare mein kya janti honi.......
With Kamala Harris, whose Mom comes from Indian brahmanical and is getting positioned as black, I am sure their will be more conversations amongst talking heads and hence their is some relevance to the topics touched in the book but really comparing US race issues with Indian caste system is apple and orange.
Sandeep Vaid maybe how they originated are different but their impact on society its pretty similar hence the theme of the book
👍
I would read Dr. Ambedkar's books instead.
India’s caste discrimination will not go away as long as we use our caste surnames. Resumes are screened just by looking at the surname. Votes are caste based on surname. Caste based surnames should be banned.
I can bet you are not Dalit and speaking from the same old SaVarna caste perspective ...In Tamil Nadu they abolished the caste surname and nothing happened....In fact removing surnames will lead to disorganization among Dalits and they will be oppressed on easily then .
Manuwadi media caste ke upar kabhi baat nahi karega
Jai Bhim
Why this mandal is on Print.. sorry print i am unsubscribing.
atmnirbhar bharat hai ab india
Caste system aur uski problem bhi ham videshio se sikhe ? Baksh do sir ,hum roj jhel rahe hai caste system ko but dharam ki burai nahi hai ye balki sawarn jatiyo ki hai!
You should have read the book first, before reviewing it.
What about Islamic and Christian castes? Or did she put only Hindus Caste
If everyone is converted from Hindu, whatever caste is there, it's the same thought process
Castism In India still exists u should know it ... don’t respond like high caste andh bhakt 😡😡😡😡😡
@@Rockstarzzz629 correct
Yes, in India even Christians, Muslims have castes which is not the case anywhere else
@@Rockstarzzz629 yes caste system exists and it is getting more and more complex. Now there is a phenomenon called secularization of caste. It means caste has left its original religious attachments and added new Secular elements
Classification and assortment are impossible.
Jay bheem Namo buddhay 🙏
She looks like Oprah
She is oprah winfrey
idhar sarkar ki treasury empty hai lekin pm cares fund bhara hua hai...aur ram mandir to ban hi gaya hai...modern vicharon se hume kya...hum to sarvashreshta hai...😁
Been wanting to read this book, good book review 👏🏻
Hi Yogitha. Do tell us what you think of the book.
Caste was never meant to be determined by birth but by talent and more importantly by seeking and learning.
Brahman means जिसने ब्रह्म को जाना or who has acquired the knowledge of Brahma. For that to happen you have to be a seeker and go deeper into spirituality through meditation. You have to get your Self-Realisation. You cannot be born as a brahmin just because of your family name. You have to become a brahmin by doing कड़ी तपस्या ।
Similarly you can't be born as a Kshatriya just because your father was one. You actually have to be a warrior and undergo proper training to become a Kshatriya.
The biggest culprit is Manu. He made caste into a birthright to be passed on to the next generation which it was never meant to be. The book Manusmriti screwed up the entire concept for generations to come.
In today's time there are hardly any original brahmins left. Majority of all the sadhus and pandits are all पाखंडी ।
Just like members of a certain peaceful community are suffering because of following a particular book blindly. Similarly Indians have suffered a lot because of this book Manusmriti.
Caste superiority based on talent no lie is bigger than this
@@amarkhadse4718 you r lol it was based on talent
I said it about a previous video of this guy and I will say it again. This guy knows so little about literally everything and yet talks a lot about a bunch of stuff. It's a shame that Shekhar Gupta has to share platform with someone like him. Also not to forget, this guy is so biased, even Arnab will shy to stoop to such levels.
bhai bol de kitna arakshan chahiye or kab tak cahiye bs bold do...dimag mt khrab kro roz roz jatti k baatt kr k
Better to read annihilation of caste by br ambedkar and all other books written by him. The print is full of hatemongers and fascist.
Bakwaas!
bhai mere kya galat hai isme ?
ये जो बोलने वाला है यही गलत है
andha gulam shudra yadav.😆
@Nick Andex how many fake sc at act put by dalit ,simply tell u want reservation ka malai so u dont want to leave the caste victimhood,caste is just like a ident like hindu muslim jain sikh, nowdays there is no discrimination.if 5% there then action must ne taken.
and this author tell that dunia me bawal aur india me khamos....kya ho raha he dunia me aur india me to tum khud jherile jo reverse casteism kar rahe ho...aur konsa pahad tutgaya
@@kp2294 God copy pasting BJP same nonsense every where are you paid for it?
Muslims have caste tooo
I hope the NRI abroad will be ashamed enough to come to there senses
and privileged dalits also how they claimed after being privileged like handicap
www.nytimes.com/2020/07/14/opinion/caste-cisco-indian-americans-discrimination.html
जतिवाद बहुजनो की वजह से मजबूत है ,सवर्णों की वजह से नहीं
Sharam se duubmaro. Tum jaise logo ki wjah se desh piche jaa rhaa hai.
Mondal u check ur birth ..u lost it
Pandey.. What else expect from u...
His twitter account is suspended
@@nikitamishra3408 ua-cam.com/video/jYMOCh6aTJ4/v-deo.html
Hypocrisy ki sima hoti hai
If there’s one comment that proves how right Wilkinson is, this is it
@@amols8836 i don't care about kangana man .. but this dude spews hatred everyday on twitter even before the the kangana incident
Brahmno ki andhviswas ko dhajiya udane Wale book hi
Another foreigner trying to decode Indian society from planet apart.
We should stop thinking in this manner, that is why we know less of our reality than a lot of foreigners.
@@vimalvaira koi kuch nehi ....ye sirf chutiyapa karegi book me aur kuch nehi.....aur rahi jativaad ki to jab sab bolte he ki 85% ek ho kar vote karo to tab jativad nehi dikhta
S k p ur arrogance is beyond a reply! Its so true “khali bartan zada shoor”, without knowing whats in the book you have already given 2 cent opinion.
@@vimalvaira i dont want what is in the book ,i talk about the hypocrisy of so called dalit
University: Dilip Mandal ki Pathshala
Degree: M.B.B.S (Masters in Big Bull Sh*t)
why did you say that ?
@@vimalvaira jab sirf backchodi karega to yahi bolenge na
lol kuch bhi
Faltu ki pathsala h teri
Sahi kaha Tu faltu h
Chup karo
Tumhara gand kahe fat rha hai.....🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@PrinceYadav-lw7kb par tum to salo vaste certificate leke reservation lete ho tab kya hota he...tum jati dekhkar jab vote dete ho tab kya hota he...par hum kare to kharap
@@sandeepkumarpal2058 hamara kyu fatega...jinki jal raha he wo pathsala kholkar bakchodi kar raha he
Dilip mondal another bigot ...... like a jogendra mondal
His twitter account is suspended .. he spews hatred all day