The Mk I Martini-Henry and the Mk I Lee-Metford: Rate of Fire Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @MrAlex_Raven
    @MrAlex_Raven 5 років тому +427

    Ok Algorithm. You win this time.

    • @suckmysilencer747
      @suckmysilencer747 3 роки тому +7

      The Algorithm is back with a vengeance. It's taken me on a wild ride of 18th/19th century firearm demonstrations and I cannot stop watching.

    • @ScottKenny1978
      @ScottKenny1978 3 роки тому +3

      I see you are a person of culture, too, with that screen name.

    • @josephzayd9831
      @josephzayd9831 3 роки тому +1

      A trick : you can watch series on kaldrostream. I've been using it for watching a lot of movies lately.

    • @leroybeckett4313
      @leroybeckett4313 3 роки тому

      @Joseph Zayd Yup, been watching on KaldroStream for months myself =)

    • @NathanDudani
      @NathanDudani 3 роки тому

      @@suckmysilencer747 same

  • @NormanHarman
    @NormanHarman 7 років тому +342

    Maybe it’s just your backyard. But I really appreciate you filming out in the “environment” vs at a typical range. It adds to the the whole ambience that makes these videos so enjoyable above and beyond the history and shooting. And that fog shrouded mountainside is gorgeous.

  • @admiralpercy
    @admiralpercy 7 років тому +661

    0:38 Lol I've never heard the word "French" said with such disdain

    • @Matt_The_Hugenot
      @Matt_The_Hugenot 7 років тому +53

      Admiral Percy I thought he was quite restrained!

    • @CSSVirginia
      @CSSVirginia 7 років тому +2

      Admiral Percy I noticed that as well!

    • @outko24
      @outko24 7 років тому +18

      Well you obviously don't watch squires channel.....

    • @admiralpercy
      @admiralpercy 7 років тому +1

      out ko who be dat

    • @outko24
      @outko24 7 років тому +12

      Admiral Percy He's a British bloke who usually plays war games, and is known mainly for mocking the French. Its good stuff.

  • @lieutenantkettch
    @lieutenantkettch 4 роки тому +17

    That backdrop of the mountains draped in mist is magnificent. Canada has some gorgeous scenery.

  • @Alf763
    @Alf763 7 років тому +96

    your accent is so magnificently canadian it's the best part of this channel

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +42

      Accent? I don'thave an accent,..... YOU have the accent.... :-)

    • @johnconnor478
      @johnconnor478 7 років тому +2

      Where do you live in Ontario? I would love to do a video on you Im extremely Intersted in Anglo Saxon history

    • @BeukendaalMason
      @BeukendaalMason 5 років тому +4

      What are you talking aboot, eh?

    • @Comblockcapitalist
      @Comblockcapitalist 5 років тому +3

      You better say your soory bud.

    • @tameredanslederriere
      @tameredanslederriere 3 роки тому

      @@johnconnor478 by the scenery and the fact he mentioned Victoria he his probably from the island of victoria in british columbia!

  • @Hispanicpanick0
    @Hispanicpanick0 6 років тому +61

    Extremely high quality, felt like the golden age of the history channel!

  • @arthurdukeofwellington361
    @arthurdukeofwellington361 7 років тому +96

    Love your work as always. Did you realise you got a shout out by Ian from Forgotten Weapons and Bloke on the range? It's good to see you getting some well deserved mentions by some honourable sources!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +32

      Thank you!,.... yes, I had some pals let me know. Very appreciative, of course.

  • @Sedan57Chevy
    @Sedan57Chevy 7 років тому +72

    I love how all the UA-cam channels are starting to get together: really making this community that much stronger.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +19

      It is certainly a fun thing to do, collabs....

    • @BeingFireRetardant
      @BeingFireRetardant 2 роки тому +2

      @@britishmuzzleloaders
      Well, for what it's worth, I'm here because Othias said so. Turns out he was right, this is a great channel. Just subscribed. Excellent content.

  • @marknovak8255
    @marknovak8255 7 років тому +82

    Love the editing, which must take longer than the actual shooting. If, you don't count cleaning weapons, or BP brass washing, baking, tumbling, and reloading!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +28

      Editing definitely takes the lions share of time.... Labour of love, I suppose... :-) Thanks Mark!

    • @jasonfishmd
      @jasonfishmd 3 роки тому

      Very well said!

    • @ScottKenny1978
      @ScottKenny1978 3 роки тому +2

      I'm sure that the reloading work barely makes a note compared to the editing. Most of the reloading time is spent watching the equipment run. Set it and forget it, really.

  • @chriskanemeier
    @chriskanemeier 5 років тому +46

    Well filmed, informative, to the point and good shooting. What's not to like?
    Cheers

  • @MadrasArsenal
    @MadrasArsenal 7 років тому +40

    As always Rob, top notch good sir.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +4

      Thanks Kurt!

    • @Mo-LoveInDaWorld
      @Mo-LoveInDaWorld 7 років тому +2

      britishmuzzleloaders do you ever worry that black powder will burn your astonishing mustache off (greetings from Ireland)

  • @RomeoWhiskey692
    @RomeoWhiskey692 5 років тому +2

    Excellent job gentleman ... top notch !
    Lloyd outdid himself .
    His narrative over the sound of the battle in the background brought to stark reality the scene , I could almost feel the rifle in my hands , and smell the smoke , hear the ululating cry of the enemy as they rushed the line .
    Steady on !
    Load and fire , load and fire .
    Incidentally , I took my first deer , at the age of eight , with a SMLE , .303 caliber .
    Excellent rifle .

  • @grozaAC
    @grozaAC 7 років тому +10

    This is the best channel on UA-cam.

  • @leoneljoannas
    @leoneljoannas 4 роки тому +2

    Sir, I discovered your channel today after watching "Zulu". I am not disappointed. Subscribed, from an Argie in exile! Godspeed!

  • @Matt_The_Hugenot
    @Matt_The_Hugenot 7 років тому +18

    Another excellent video. Interesting to note that even the Lee-Metford exceeds the German WWII estimate of what to expect when facing bolt action rifles.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +7

      Thanks!

    • @thitsugaya1224
      @thitsugaya1224 7 років тому +8

      Lee Enfield and Lee Medford rifles have just about the smoothest actions of any bolt action military rifles, I wouldn't feel uncomfortable taking them into a fight even now.

    • @colinkelly5420
      @colinkelly5420 5 років тому +1

      What were the German estimates?

    • @marcoalimandi6013
      @marcoalimandi6013 3 роки тому +2

      @@thitsugaya1224 they are a bit obsolete by nowadays tactics.
      Sad, to say the least.

  • @supremeghost7950
    @supremeghost7950 2 роки тому

    A man of culture.
    You are above dapper.
    Absolute perfection, how you handle these weapons.
    Just like watching melting butter flow I get the same feeling when i watch you handle these guns.

  • @scruffymchaggis8828
    @scruffymchaggis8828 7 років тому +13

    WOW really enjoyed this,like how you got the uniforms time period accurate.

  • @KMac329
    @KMac329 5 років тому +1

    One learns a great deal from watching these videos. Thank you, Britishmuzzleloaders!

  • @zaphodbeeblebrox9109
    @zaphodbeeblebrox9109 5 років тому +3

    Mate, i love your channels mix of irreverent humour and factual accuracy in a quasi-focumentary package. Top job marra.

  • @Cowth
    @Cowth Рік тому +1

    The martini is one of my favorite guns awesome video!

  • @TH3PLA1NP1L0T
    @TH3PLA1NP1L0T 5 років тому +4

    When the British tried to convert to magazine loading with Martini Henry
    Heath Robinson (not sure if I spelled that right) made one that was attached to the side of the Martini Henry
    When cocked down, the cartridge dropped into the barrel and you were able to cock it back.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  5 років тому +1

      An interesting but quite unsuitable gimmick, that was... very clever though!

  • @P61guy61
    @P61guy61 5 років тому

    A gem of UA-cam. Rain or shine your work is stellar. An honest and vivid reflection of history. Thank you for posting.

  • @osirisblue2087
    @osirisblue2087 4 роки тому +3

    After lots of searching finally found a video about the musket rifle used by British Indian army during the Afghanistan campaign. Thanks a lot for this detailed video Sir.

  • @535tony
    @535tony 5 років тому +1

    One of the best episodes yet.. Well done.

  • @rayfeltz8477
    @rayfeltz8477 7 років тому +17

    Finally a new video! In other thoughts, can we get this man a history channel series? Next after pawn stars, British arms with Lieutenant colonel Scotty Epicstache. I'd love it.

  • @zestamaster
    @zestamaster 6 років тому +1

    Just found your channel, the effort is palpable, and i love your presentation style

  • @jasonfishmd
    @jasonfishmd 3 роки тому +3

    Great stuff! You are an expert rifleman- the smoothness and precision of your weapon management is first class. Clear voice. And you make it very fun! Thanks!!!! JF

  • @FRANKTHRING1
    @FRANKTHRING1 3 роки тому

    Since I am working on a new account of the 1897-98 Pathan Rising I found this documentary most useful. Thank you for uploading !

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  3 роки тому

      Glad it was helpful! Cheers! A specific aspect or something along the lines of Mark Simner's book?

  • @611_hornet5
    @611_hornet5 7 років тому +113

    As Othais would say:
    "AH F*CK, THE FRENCH!"

  • @Theseus9-cl7ol
    @Theseus9-cl7ol 4 роки тому

    So cool, awesome real time backdrop with the smoke and mountain too.

  • @brianmoore1820
    @brianmoore1820 7 років тому +6

    Thank you. Always interesting and informative.

  • @davidtong2776
    @davidtong2776 4 роки тому

    No amount of talk equals a service like display.for getting the point across. Thanks again.

  • @gamesisfunny
    @gamesisfunny 7 років тому +86

    I also love watching lindybiege, you two are some of the few beacons of light on this site filled with mostly rubbish. Thanks for all the effort you put into these wonderfull videos.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +9

      You are most welcome. Thank you for your kind words!

    • @Skyfighter64
      @Skyfighter64 7 років тому +8

      Two other people to watch: "Forgotten Weapons" and "Bloke on the Range." Not exactly the same as this show, but very good presenters about the history and usage of Firearms.

    • @svenskafanan421
      @svenskafanan421 6 років тому

      The Captain god dag

    • @mikebazor4466
      @mikebazor4466 5 років тому +5

      Lindybiege is a disheveled man child with a dungeons and dragons mindset

    • @theortheo2401
      @theortheo2401 4 роки тому +1

      Lindybeige is the most biased individual out here. This gentleman right here is objective and factual.

  • @sidneydesousa1993
    @sidneydesousa1993 5 років тому +1

    oh boy your videos are so wonderful. don't know how to say how I like them. thank you so much

  • @Returnofthemick
    @Returnofthemick 7 років тому +3

    Well done Rob and Lloyd! :D

  • @dylandaley4003
    @dylandaley4003 3 роки тому

    Quality, watchable, well edited and produced. Well done

  • @MagicPortal
    @MagicPortal 7 років тому +8

    Excellent as always. And two youtube powers unite!

  • @Splodge542
    @Splodge542 5 років тому +1

    How did I miss this one? Superb.

  • @Procket12
    @Procket12 7 років тому +346

    Who's the heathen who down voted this video?

    • @JayRaxter
      @JayRaxter 7 років тому +30

      Anti-gun Bot voter....We just had the same discussion on Ian's (Forgotten Weapons) channel. He'll have 9 or 10 down votes within 5 minutes of publishing a video.

    • @kieranh2005
      @kieranh2005 7 років тому +5

      'Twas not I

    • @sugarnads
      @sugarnads 7 років тому +17

      Probably a damned frenchman, or praps a boer whos ancestors felt the lash that was the various Lee iterations...

    • @sugarnads
      @sugarnads 7 років тому +11

      End em rightly i say, unscrewing pommel byyyyy the numberrrrs......waaaait for ittttt....

    • @Procket12
      @Procket12 7 років тому +7

      Well the Boer's did get the last laugh seeing as The majority white South Africans are Afrikkaners. lol

  • @tw203809
    @tw203809 7 років тому

    Another home run. You have some of the best content on the web.

  • @leatherwood1370
    @leatherwood1370 7 років тому +6

    My first reenactment is in 6 days Oct 27-29 Battle of Leatherwood can't wait!!!

  • @brianwinters5434
    @brianwinters5434 5 років тому +1

    I have fired clean martini s and clean trapdoor about 8.to 9 out of the trapdoor and 10 out of the martini. This was with drawn brass cartridges with wrapped brass they often jammed but more so with the trapdoor thin ejector.

  • @calvinabbott6920
    @calvinabbott6920 5 років тому +67

    200 years later and we are in Afghanistan to protect the Royal Opium fields.

  • @medicineman360
    @medicineman360 6 років тому +2

    I love your videos. Very concise and thorough. Quite well-presented. Bravo!

  • @joshuathiel243
    @joshuathiel243 7 років тому +4

    Thanks for the awesome video!!!

  • @christophero55
    @christophero55 3 роки тому

    Great video and probably the third time I have watched it. I enjoy seeing these evolutionary comparison videos.

  • @arieheath7773
    @arieheath7773 7 років тому +32

    Never would have recognized Lloyds voice if you hadn't pointed it out.

  • @Marc-iw7mk
    @Marc-iw7mk 4 роки тому

    Fab episode, love the background history how the addition of a magazine changed future engagements. Look forward as a concurrent activity reading the books identified in the episode.

  • @Real_Claudy_Focan
    @Real_Claudy_Focan 7 років тому +12

    That's excellent grouping patterns for 100yds !
    This kind of video is kind of "historico-scientific" because it clearly show the powercreep of service weapons in the beginning of the XXth century !
    Now, imagine how "self-loading", semi-automatic rifles and even machine guns should have scared the troops on the field !
    We went from one shot a minute to one every ten seconds
    Then, nearly a shot every seconds
    To now, 800 shots a minute and even more !
    Now you can imagine the amount of firepower each soldier have in his hands !

  • @polymathart
    @polymathart 4 місяці тому

    2:12 Have you ever heard of the Norwegian Krag Petersen rifle? It’s a fascinating design: it uses a tilting breechblock like the Martini, the Peabody, the Lee Vertical 1875, and the Bavarian Werder rifle. What sets it apart is that it has a tubular magazine. One of the rarest rifles to ever see today, but an incredible idea.

  • @charlesjhemphilliii4792
    @charlesjhemphilliii4792 5 років тому +3

    Occasionally antique military imports has Lee metfords, for sale for 500 and 600 dollars.

  • @MrRedbeard762
    @MrRedbeard762 7 років тому +2

    A very well produced video, informative and fun. Thank you.

  • @Thorsaxe777
    @Thorsaxe777 7 років тому +4

    If I was a movie producer and needed an adviser/movie costume supervisor, you would be my pick, However, I couldn't offer you a cameo in the production, Maybe I could if you could accept that the movie has to stay on budget and authentic garments and equipment must be substituted. it doesn't matter if it was WW-2, the Great war or the conquest of India you would be a valuable asset to the filming of such productions.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +1

      Thank you! I think that might be an interesting project, should something like that ever come up.

  • @losonsrenoster
    @losonsrenoster 3 роки тому +1

    I own the only number 1 mark lll* Lee Metford in existence, anywhere on earth. I bought it in 2019 for the equivalent of USD170, it is a 1941 BSA Lee Enfield, but it is registered on the central firearms register as a Lee Metford. I did not take the trouble to change it, in SA it will probably take years. It shoots as well as any Lee Enfield though, I love it.

  • @kirinbob
    @kirinbob 5 років тому +4

    They should be compared in a 24 round pattern including 2 reloads of the magazine.

  • @JayRaxter
    @JayRaxter 7 років тому +1

    Man I must watch the same list. I love this channel, Lloyd's, and the Bloke on the range!

  • @Boomeus
    @Boomeus 7 років тому +4

    Excellent

  • @thetazman6
    @thetazman6 4 роки тому

    Love the channel, lots of hard work, research, humor and presentation skills. Exceptionally informative and educational, thanks

  • @grenmoyo3968
    @grenmoyo3968 7 років тому +33

    Magazine cutoff features.
    *GOD SAVE THE QUEEN INTENSIFIES!*

  • @mattarmstrong9205
    @mattarmstrong9205 7 років тому +1

    Great video Rob! Man I tell ya, every time I watch a new video of yours, I'm always pleasantly surprised by the progression of the editing and every increasing zeal. Keep it up! Top shelf stuff, museum class!

  • @string-bag
    @string-bag 5 років тому +3

    It would be nice if the gunmaker Rossi would revive the Martini line of rifles.:)

  • @markc7551
    @markc7551 2 роки тому

    Here visiting at the recommendation of Forgotten Weapons. Great presentation. Looking forward to watching more of your videos. Subscribed.

  • @masaharumorimoto4761
    @masaharumorimoto4761 7 років тому +5

    Excellent!!!

  • @barrysmith5005
    @barrysmith5005 2 роки тому +1

    Your presentation and competence are to be commended thank you!

  • @judahwest1025
    @judahwest1025 5 років тому +3

    Standing in the rain, like an Imperial Soldier. I want to cry the Union Jack looking at this.

  • @johnfisk811
    @johnfisk811 7 років тому +1

    Lovely job Rob. Thank you. I suspect the easiest way they could have sped up the Martini ROF would have been a pouch that presented the rounds individually. I borrowed a 20 bore butt stock slip on set of cartridge loops for five rounds. Halved the time to load a fresh round and less awkward than the Enfield Martini trial metal magazine on the receiver. Ready use clips fixed to the stock were being offered for single shot military rifles like the Metcalfe Patent Cartridge Block.

  • @panthermartin7784
    @panthermartin7784 5 років тому +14

    Lol imagine hunting along n this chap hops out sporting his out fit n Martini

  • @es4152
    @es4152 2 роки тому

    Your mustache has won the internet. This is a great video.

  • @simplymadness8849
    @simplymadness8849 7 років тому +5

    Grade A content.

  • @kevinhendryx665
    @kevinhendryx665 2 роки тому

    Very helpful demonstration and examination! Useful research for a writing project involving these weapons.

  • @pericodelospalotes5738
    @pericodelospalotes5738 5 років тому +3

    I'm Spaniard and not an expert on English accents but judging buy the way you speak and that rear mountain you are in Canada, aren't you? Maybe in Scottland there are mountains but I understand you well so you must not be Scottish ;-)

    • @theotterguy
      @theotterguy 4 роки тому +1

      He is in British Columbia,Canada.

  • @europeanbourgeois8223
    @europeanbourgeois8223 7 років тому

    I adore our overseas supporters, you’re precious to this sceptred isle. Keep up the great work.

  • @jbearmcdougall1646
    @jbearmcdougall1646 5 років тому +3

    59 heathens who down thumbed the video.... Let's pray..

  • @markcartlidge231
    @markcartlidge231 4 роки тому

    F the algorithm.
    This chap is the best military historian I've seen.
    Bell dinged
    Addict in locked down 3.
    Kudos sir 👍.

  • @muwuny
    @muwuny 7 років тому +7

    Shame Lindybeige doesn't know what he's on about 90% of the time

    • @TchaikovskyFDR
      @TchaikovskyFDR 7 років тому +6

      I think he gives a quite broad range of information that other channels, like this, can go more in-depth upon. He's a terrific lad.

    • @muwuny
      @muwuny 7 років тому +3

      It would be fine if he just gave surface level information about a wide range of historical stuff, but the majority of the time he just gives out disinfo and repeats incorrect rumours and historical myths, especially involving modern history and firearms, just look at the absolute shitshow that his "bren vs spandau" video was. He should either get better knowledge of what he speaks about, or focus on what he knows already.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +8

      He did a great Churchill!

    • @muwuny
      @muwuny 7 років тому

      Yeah, I can give him that.

    • @wierdalien1
      @wierdalien1 7 років тому +6

      Bomber Harris the thing with that video is that if you actually listen to what he said, his use of language being fairly nuanced, he didnt actually say anything that was wrong or even controversial. All he really said was that because of the operational similarity he will call the MG-34/42 the spandau out of simplicity and british historicalness (cannot believe how much of shit storm that created, he explained his reasoning in the video, and honestly I just rolled with it because I knew what guns he was talking about etc etc.) that the Bren gets a hard rap because it isnt belt fed but it is execllent assault weapon but because of the lack of belt it can be a bit eh on the defence, whereas the MG34/42 is the best machince gun of the war in defence but a bit of pig in assault. He wrapped the video up by saying they are almost too different compare and honestly they were execllent guns.
      And queue two years of moaning.

  • @DumDumHistory
    @DumDumHistory 4 роки тому +1

    I've seen photographs of Home Guardsmen in the 1940s drilling with Lee-Metfords/Long Magazine Lee Enfields. Apparently the Young Soldiers Battalion guarding Churchill at Chartwell in 1942 were still carrying them.

  • @emilhajbert5326
    @emilhajbert5326 7 років тому +14

    Martini op plz nerf

    • @reginaldbeaulieu7856
      @reginaldbeaulieu7856 7 років тому

      Emil Hajbert lol I hate that on BF1

    • @Treblaine
      @Treblaine 7 років тому

      Emil Hajbert. "This 15% fire rate buff is totally OP, British Bias! And loot crates are filled with bushy moustaches and tea, it's nothing but a pay to win for whichever nation can pay for the largest navy!"

  • @keithwortelhock6078
    @keithwortelhock6078 3 роки тому +1

    The difference in felt recoil could easily be seen! Very informative video, as always. Thank you.

  • @peterzebot1795
    @peterzebot1795 7 років тому +3

    This is fake. They didn't use yellow sponge earplugs in 1883.
    REPLY

  • @alanmcconnaughey2698
    @alanmcconnaughey2698 7 років тому +1

    Thanks - I always look forward to your videos!

  • @mattbasque287
    @mattbasque287 3 роки тому

    Thanks for filming. Rain sucks with all the cleaning!

  • @survivalcomms
    @survivalcomms 7 років тому +2

    Another incredibly informative video. Thank you for sharing !

  • @user-cm8en8or1p
    @user-cm8en8or1p 6 років тому

    Love your channel my friend. Your videos are so detailed and informative.
    Respect from the UK 🇬🇧

  • @timdake
    @timdake 4 роки тому +1

    Wonderful video and demonstration. Worth watching twice. As for the range... I would not feel secure with the rock backstop. Sand and dirt are far less prone to ricochet.

  • @sanseijedi
    @sanseijedi 7 років тому

    Another enjoyable and informative video, professionally rendered; thanks! I'm impressed at your ability to narrate whilst with ear protection in place. When working in my shop wearing ear muffs, I find I have to flip one side off or I sound too strange to myself. Could just be me.

  • @bardofarmagh
    @bardofarmagh 2 роки тому

    Hah, you pulled that bolt faster than I've seen in any animation in that game I frequently play! Good stuff!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  2 роки тому

      Real life is not video games.... 😀

    • @bardofarmagh
      @bardofarmagh 2 роки тому

      @@britishmuzzleloaders yes, and I have often been fooled to believe that everything in video games is exaggerated (including the speed of operating a firearm) but it isn't the case this time! It's a lot faster with the real thing and I would say it looks quite satisfying to operate

  • @TheRandomPolishGuy
    @TheRandomPolishGuy 2 роки тому

    Arrived to your channel by 9-Hole reviews. Enjoying all of your content!

  • @mcintoshpc
    @mcintoshpc 2 роки тому +1

    That odd “thunk” sound that was coming from the metford is incredibly satisfying

  • @alexcrawford6162
    @alexcrawford6162 6 років тому

    Lindybeige and British Muzzleloaders in one video? This has turned into a very good day! And yes I’m late to the party, I was out of the country at the time haha.

  • @Bogie3855
    @Bogie3855 4 роки тому

    I have had a Martini of some form for the last 15yrs and find it to be my favorite action. Currently I have a Martini Cadet rebarrelled to 22lr. I have to say it is a delight to shoot and is the most accurate rifle I own with iron sights.

  • @sandmanhh67
    @sandmanhh67 7 років тому

    Thanks once again Rob. Fascinating vid - science and learning all in one.
    Mad coincidence - I started reading The Malakand Field Force a few weeks ago. Excellent book. I always thought Churchill would write pretty dry prose but its a great book full of stirring stuff, derring do, and fascinating facts all laced with military stats.
    Keep up the great work mate....you, Lindy, Bloke and Forgotten Weapons are my fave creators.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому +1

      Thank you very much. Have you read "The River War"?

    • @sandmanhh67
      @sandmanhh67 7 років тому

      Not yet mate, but as Im mad keen on the Mahdi Wars Im looking forward to it. It sounds mad but Im saving it till I can get my hands on a first edition copy, as Ive found out that large sections of the original edition text were culled so as to remove all the bad stuff Churchill wrote about Kitchener under request from the publishers prior to WW1 starting as it was seen as "bad form" to criticise one of the blokes leading Blighty against the Fritz and then died in service. The version now in common circulation is the much abridged text.... a first edition set comes as two thick volumes packed with maps and diagrams.
      Its not cheap, but affordable if you keep an eye on auctions ;-)
      Im surprised at how readable Churchill is.....I honestly thought it would be very dry reading, but he has a wonderful way of putting the reader right in the firing line or location with his vivid descriptions, and is never slow to heap praise on men who deserved it. Makes me more interested in why he thought Kitchener was a poor leader in the Sudan campaign.
      I like collecting stuff that goes with my guns like original history books - picked up a first edition set of Napiers "The Peninsula War" recently for a bargain price, and a couple of other long out of print books on the Napoleonic War written by soldiers on their return. They make for fascinating reading as they contain a load of detail about mundane camp life and footsoldier level observations..... in a way doing what you do on your channel.....which is why Im a fan mate.
      There must be something antifreeze in your Canuck blood tho mate. Us normies would be wearing a greatcoat in that rain and wind.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому

      Best of luck finding it! Sounds like a worthwhile pursuit!

  • @benlaskowski357
    @benlaskowski357 4 роки тому

    A fantastically tight group with magazine fire! Well done!
    And special kudos for Lindybeige's Churchill impression. He's good! And Churchill himself is a remarkable orator and author.
    I say 'is': his works survive.

  • @bowmen08
    @bowmen08 7 років тому

    Ah, I see that you're not dead (metaphorically speaking, of course)! I must admit, I've yet to see another channel with such level of classiness and gloriousness. Keep up the good work, and all the best to you in life, sir!

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому

      Dead?.... Why-ever would you have assumed that? (even metaphorically).....Thanks for the kind words!

    • @bowmen08
      @bowmen08 7 років тому

      Oh, I think UA-cam did something stupid on its side, because for the love of me I could not see your new vids in my feed and was pretty sure you just suddenly stopped posting. I've rectified what caused that now.

  • @Procket12
    @Procket12 7 років тому +1

    I think I've got a pretty good idea for the timeline of development for the single shot rifles.
    The Synder is the first major cartridge conversion rifle with the lever having to be pulled to eject the spent cartridge and then the hammer having to be pulled all the way back to fire. Then the Springfield Trapdoor rifle functions similarly but has the round ejector unified with opening the breech block, but you still have to pull the hammer back all the way to fire. Same as the Remington Rolling Block. Then the Martini-Henry came along that combined ejecting the round with resetting the hammer.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders  7 років тому

      Something like that!

    • @EldarKinSlayer
      @EldarKinSlayer 7 років тому +1

      You totally missed the Sharps, Gallagher, Smith, Burnside, etc Civil War issued which all pre dated the Snider.

  • @bjornefellhanded9708
    @bjornefellhanded9708 5 років тому

    What an interesting video. We used to have a martini Henry before my parents idiotically handed it back in during the amnesty in the 90's (NSW Australia). Story goes it was recovered from between 2 walls during a demolition. Was slowly getting it back into functional condition. Never fired it though. All that said, please use a better backstop. Shooting at rock is insane. Even a negligible chance of ricochet is crazy.

  • @CircuitBurger
    @CircuitBurger 4 роки тому

    Absolutely bloody fantastic. History brought to life, and so well presented. Thanks again :)

  • @sureshasuresha7422
    @sureshasuresha7422 2 роки тому +1

    Beautiful sir

  • @pumpkinking5174
    @pumpkinking5174 3 роки тому

    As my late Grandfather would say, this is the cats whiskers.
    And as a proud Martini Henry owner, excellent presentation.

  • @samain11
    @samain11 4 роки тому

    I like these vids, accurate and enthusiastic. The Brits have had more effect on world history than anybody else, we should be understanding why and emulating it... not complaining.

  • @bernie2843
    @bernie2843 4 роки тому

    A day on the range is not complete unless it rains. That and range stew. Loved the video... Informative and a pantomime.