I had a gf that loved this song, so I bought tickets to see STP on the Family Values tour in Dallas. They didn't play this song, so she broke up with me on the way home.
He's not posing. He just took over the role since well... Layne died. The rest of the band wants to keep making music. So they hired him to just.... well.... sing.
Just seen STP again the other day in NJ at the arts center. In all the years I've seen them I've never seen them on fire like they were the other night! Jeff is doing a fantastic job up there!
Odd I recall Jeff saying in an interview that he could never preform sour girl because of what the song meant to Scott....jeff's not a bad singer but I just don't feel comfortable listening to STP without Scott Weiland
Decent job by the singer but I wouldn't want to play these songs anymore if I was those guys. They got enough money already, just go home. Or do something totally new. Those are Scott's songs.
I love this song so much but jeff sounds mmm like a karaoke versión.. Sour girl has this pretty and lovely voice.. Chester do better work than jeff voice. Sounds like bon jovi...how I miss scott sing this pretty song
![Stone Temple Pilots - Sour Girl [Alive in the Windy City] HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CegYbIKlU0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
This guy kind of nails it. I have both “Stone Temple Pilots” eponymous CDs, and the vocals are indistinguishable
Great job Jeff. Thanks for keep the legacy, you're valuable too.
The found the right guy for sure. Still may all time faves 🤙🏽
Very respectable job by the new guy!
I had a gf that loved this song, so I bought tickets to see STP on the Family Values tour in Dallas. They didn't play this song, so she broke up with me on the way home.
If she broke up with you she was a sour girl.
Wow this is awesome ! Never heard Jeff do this song live yet ! Solid!
That a boy Jeff!! You did it justice! And the crowd there loved it too!
When all the comments are about Scott and Jeff and no one mentions THAT GUITAR SOLO!
Dean is awesome. The DeLeo brothers rock!
your average music listener unfortunately only pays attention to vocals - sad state of affairs in music appreciation in the USA
It’s so hard to fill shows of the beloved
But he’s doing a great job
Not the same but really nice work
Yep. I agree. Not the same. But a very good replacement!
You can pose but you will never bring the same energy as the creator.
He's not posing. He just took over the role since well... Layne died. The rest of the band wants to keep making music. So they hired him to just.... well.... sing.
Just seen STP again the other day in NJ at the arts center. In all the years I've seen them I've never seen them on fire like they were the other night! Jeff is doing a fantastic job up there!
Wow, Jeff nailed that one!
Hahaha are u kiddinme hahha sounds so karaoke... Like a bonjovi
What would you doo?????
They follow!!!!
Is what it is. Dig It
Or die. It's your decision???
Not bad vocals! Good job! Wow!
Not an easy go, Jeff. Good luck, though. I miss (irreplaceable) Scott...
It sounds great,But, It’s not Scott and I just can’t let go just yet..........
Me to scott sounds so good here..with emotion.. But jeff sounds like.. Give me my money and I sing like bon jovi hahaha like these
It's not the same, or as good without Scott! #RIPScott
Eric is so fucking good. I'm proud of you Jeff. Impossible shoes, but I love your work. You get it and are bringing what you have. Keep it up!
I hope they keep up the great work... too much talent to waste!
Too bad the sound is not more than a cell phone recording. It's hard to judge the singing from this.
Thought in one interview he said he wouldn't sing it.. because it was Scott's breakup story song...said it wouldn't be wright to sing it .
Odd I recall Jeff saying in an interview that he could never preform sour girl because of what the song meant to Scott....jeff's not a bad singer but I just don't feel comfortable listening to STP without Scott Weiland
I think that was Chester that said that but I could be wrong.
Or it was the other guys in the band.
Why jeff sounds like karaoke versión ?
Sorry...but Scott was and always be STP
Sorry...but Jeff is a VERY suitable replacement.
Decent job by the singer but I wouldn't want to play these songs anymore if I was those guys. They got enough money already, just go home. Or do something totally new. Those are Scott's songs.
He's not stealing them. Just trying to keep the music alive.
Those are OUR songs... we're all invested.
I love this song so much but jeff sounds mmm like a karaoke versión.. Sour girl has this pretty and lovely voice.. Chester do better work than jeff voice. Sounds like bon jovi...how I miss scott sing this pretty song
ua-cam.com/video/VCQUCFwsR5Q/v-deo.html prove yourself wrong, please...
Shut up.
Don't you get tired of saying the same thing in every comment? 🙄 Scott is dead get over it
@@lostz2754 They are two different songs as you compare sour girl with atlanta .. Sour girl has highs and softer than atlanta .. Bad comparison
@@SteveWright259 Same for you fucking fanatic
Sounds weak, not believable.