📺 It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit the world's best history documentary service with code 'WARSTORIES' for a huge discount! bit.ly/2MNt3cM
@@georgecoates2079 Until the Sherman was upgunned with the 76mm, it was no match versus Panther, Mark IV, Tiger I or II....even the Stug III....the Sherman had some good qualities, namely speed and umbers, but it also had a very high silhouette, which made it stand out even more.....I do not think I would want to be a Sherman Tanker in WW2....especially after viewing Fury as many times as I have
My great uncle was killed in action March 8 1945 . He was missing until March 25 when they found him buried by the Germans. He fought in operation blockbuster in the Hochwald and is now buried at the Groesbeek Canadian War cemetery. I wish I could find out exactly what happened to him. It’s incredible anyone got out of this battle. Canadians are incredible soldiers. I am so proud of my great uncle. 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
I am also extremely proud of ur great uncle. And I emphasise the word great. I am free to do as I choose in my life thanks to amazing ppl like ur uncle. So I say thank u Sir, I will never forget what u did for freedom.
Don't burden yourself trying to figure out what happened on the battlefield, its chaos , a hundred things could of gone wrong, keep his memory in your heart and mind that is what matters.
@@Hooibeest2D I watched a video on the liberation of the Netherlands. Who knew that Canada did so much.......? I also recently watched a film called "The Black Book" witch was terrific.
Thank you our northern brethren❤, for your sacrifices along side our own soldiers in the worst and most costly war in history. From a guy in a small city In New York(about an hour from the Canadian/U.S border.) May all the millions that lost their life in WW2 rest in peace.
Thank you my Dear southern brother! We will always fight together for freedom and we Canadians will always render our sacrifice to our American friends in need!🍁
Thank you to the Canadian soldiers who paid the ultimate price for freedom,my grandfather got hit by a sniper over in the Solomon's thankfully it just missed his heart, much respect from a brother in New Zealand..... RIP to ALL those who died for us all......
The British Centurion served in Canada until 1978 and light armor has always been a mix of American or Swiss designs license built in Canada. As far as choosing the Leopard goes, I imagine it was mainly due to cost and availability rather then being impressed. Indeed the Leopard 1's were awseome tanks in their day, and served countires without deep pockets well. The Leo 2A6M's used in Afghanistan were leased/purchased because they were surplus (a.k.a available immediately) and cheap. If DND could have run a proper competition and had time allowed odds are (according to various online sources...so take that with a grain of salt) the Challenger II would have toped their list.
Bringing these hugely important battles to view, you insure that the brave who fought here will not be forgotten. An example of young people not knowing much of these battles is as follows. Not long ago there was a lecturer doing a piece on WWII. A young teacher in the crowd asked, “when was world war eleven?” Keep doing this all important task. Thank you.
The said thing is that the youth of today don't know anything about the war. And they also don't care. For them the most important thing in their lives is thinking how to make a Tik-Tok video and get the most views. And that's no joke. They don't know anything about WW2.
Field Marshall Karl Gerd Von Lundstedt said that the three factors that caused the German defeat were ; 1. Germany had no oil. 2. American oil contribution amounted to SIX Billion barrels out of the SEVEN Billion barrels, consumed by the Allies. Most of the oil coming from Texas. 3. For D-Day a huge ‘Oil Pipeline’ between England and France was built under the Channel. 3. The ‘Allies’ overwhelming 'Airpower." 4. The Lend-Lease Act of the USA supplied the Soviet Union so they could fight the Germans with more than 400,000 jeeps and trucks, 14,000 aircraft, 8,000 tractors and 300,000 vehicles, and 13,000 battle tanks. Boots, clothing material, radios etc. Totalling $180 billion in today's currency.
even with CC you got to guess at some of the words because of"they sound the same so CC gives the wrong word many times. So for the people that are deaf what does music sound like when it is the droning of aircraft or guns going boom or machine gun fire. CC definitely could use some improvements. Yet I always have it on because just to get those words in matter.
I remember visiting Yper/ Belgium were the allied troops of mix Canadians, Aussies Gurkas etc died..there were fresh wreaths and as I tried to pray I felt enormous heavy sadness that I started to cry. My belgian husband asked me what happened but I cannot explain just that I felt too much sadness.
Mom is from New Brunswick - Dual Citizenship. Americans are only fed the Bulge and the Victories for American Troops. Least we never forget that America Invaded Canada during their first two wars - Revolution & 1812; both times the Canadians sent them back. Thank you - Good quick Story with decent footage & graphics. US Army - 1971 to 1973. Hopkinton, Mass, USA. God Bless.
@@peterson7082 Where were the "Canadian tanks" actually used in combat manufactured? Montreal Locomotive Works (MLW) was a Canadian railway locomotive manufacturer which existed under several names from 1883 to 1985. For a number of years it was a subsidiary of the American Locomotive Company. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Locomotive_Works
War of 1812 "Such exaggerations were key to the myth that it was Canada’s militia, not its expensive professional soldiers, who won the War of 1812. In reality, the militia were primarily assigned to transport and labour duties, although some served alongside British professional regulars and fencible regiments." www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/war-of-1812-editorial#:~:text=The%20War%20of%201812%20%28which%20lasted%20from%201812,and%20the%20Atlantic%2C%20and%20in%20the%20United%20States.
Wow-sorry to admit I have never even heard of this major battle. The before and after shots of the buildings was a great touch, but the Canadians are the superstars. They always seem to be forgotten-sad, SALUTE Canadians!
They also call explosions and machine gun fire MUSIC instead of comic book style "BOOM" or "rat a tat a tat" or stampeding horses hoof noises is also "music"
inklingGirl67 Thank you so much, for instance - one of *Many -Others here - Oct. 1944 --Villers-Bocage/Normandy, ss-HauptsturmFührer Michael Wittmann (Ritterkreuz-Träger) w/his crew, Tiger-tank, destroyed 20-each-US-Armored-Vehicles(British-Canadian Crews) in = 21-Minutes......... - lost in Battle, one track, moved w/crew under fire, own German front-line, next morning maintained and repaired w/ new track and the tiger w/ Wittman and crew, (RIP) started in new next battle...... and and and, Now our Heroes are meanwhile in *Walhalla, side and side all *Camerades, also on side Camerades; of the other Feld-Post-Nummer..=. the former Enemies... . now on side too. Never we wont forget you... Thank's for attention,
The Brits called the Sherman "Ronsons" as they would light up with just one spark, the Germans called them "Tommy cookers" according to my grandfather who was in the 79th Armoured Div.
Are you familiar with the Eastern Front? This was NOT one of the most intense tank battles of WW2....not even close. The Soviets and Wehrmacht / SS Panzer Divisions engaged in this type of Tank Warfare on a Daily Basis.
I've got an original Canadian Army battle map of Xanten marked "secret". And a picture of my late dad with his Coy, in the main street about 50 yards from the old town gate, after the town was liberated.
Who was he with ? Btw, there's a documentary being made about this battle now by Real time History. Good to see these guys at War Stories generating interest !
@@hughbeastodonnell3733 He was the Anti-Tank Artillery Coy Captain in the South Saskatchewan Regt. He was originally commissioned during wartime in the Essex Scottish. He was a Sgt. in the local militia before the war. The 26th Field Battery, Royal Canadian Artillery.
@@cowgoesmoo3850 Another interesting part of the story... in that local militia unit was James "Jimmy Doohan" ... who after his own heroic WW2 service played "Scotty" in the original Star Trek. I was fortunate enough to meet him at our old high school's 75th Anniversary. He was a real gentleman.
@Damo Along ways off, but our countries paths crossed before, ... a war before. My late dads two uncles fell in WW1. James at Hill 60 Ypres, and Arthur at the north side of Moquet Farm on the Somme. Both places the Aussies who know their history, know well. Almost 2am here. ZZzz time. G'nite !
In the winter of 1945, the Sherman's were armed with 76 long barrels, and most tanks were tank destroyers 90mm M10s and Chaffee tank destroyers. The Sherman's was not the only tank. The air power and artillery
The Chaffee is a light tank, not a tank destroyer. And not all the Shermans had the 76. In fact, most of them were still using the 75, because the crews liked it better. The 75 was a much better gun for supporting infantry than the 76, which was really only good for tank on tank combat.
What is almost Unbelivable,its the fact that the German Hold on for so long with so few. They were fighting in the west,in the east and in italy,in a desproportion in man and material and nevertheless in some ocasions still be ablle to put the Allies in a total desarey and panic. Its a testament to the sheer power of their guns, their training an outstanding leadership and fighting Spirit.
Totally agree; and the current trend of using video game like graphics is hideous. It does nothing to bring realism, especially when you have animations of German and Allied tanks lined up firing at each other from 20 metres apart.
Well if you studied your history in the war it wasn't just Canadians yes of course Canadians but believe it or not the most valiant and courageous with the Russians how they came back after getting anilated and storm right into Germany and annihilated them yeah it was Russia that are the heroes the French to Canadians American all had a part in it the poles the checks Italy they change their mind after a while of course
Don't forget the Flying Tiger's without Those P.40 Tomahawk's the Chinese would be speaking Japanese. You would think they would remember the Atrocities of Nanking.
Nicknamed Ronson's, Zippo's, Rolling Coffin's. The M.4 Sherman powered by gasoline was a nightmare at the beginning of the War. Diesel isn't as explosive. The Panzer's and Tiger's up close had a light disadvantage. But over 500 yards, I wouldn't want to be in a Sherman. Knocking out the track's, or fusing the turrets with phosphorous round's was the only way of getting an edge. Up close the German's had to drop their .75 or .88 mm gun's almost to the ground, inside of 500 yd's.
@@frankatchison2519 thats why only the experienced tiger commanders got kills,they knew to never give up that advantage and stay far away in hiding and take them all out before they come close
@@YahooMurray ah yes god forbid we learn and see some history. Forgot history is racist and should be deleted from the records. We now pick and choose and edit what to learn. Tanks are mean machines.
Athe Germans couldn't replace the men & mat serial as fast as the Russians & the allies bc their factories were Being bombed night & day by the Brits&us
@@youraveragescotsman7119. You used the a keyword (until 1943) before then the Germans were obliterating the Soviets. Here’s an interesting fact, when the Germans started Operation Barbarossa (invasion of Soviet Union) Stalin sent his reserve armies to fight first, which is part of the reason why they sucked so bad at fighting. He wanted to weaken the Germans forces down before he sent his Front line troops in. (The reverse of what normal military doctrine is) Reserves are supposed to be the backup and last line of defense, like what the Germans used in the last days of the war in Berlin and other parts of Germany (they call it the Replacement Army). Anyway, so Stalin used his Reserves first, then in 1943 is when he called in his actual Army and other Frontline Forces. So there’s a little known fun fact.
Thank you for sharring what bravery by the Canadian tank crews , we thank you !😔. Looking back is easy to judge , the Sherman was not good tank without the longer barrel and sadly caught fire easily, weak armour.
@@nickdanger3802 Our Sherman's were not as good as the Panzer V and VI.... probably equal to the Panzer III... but we simply had far more of them, we could replace tanks and crews and we had a far superior logistics chain. So, checkmate.
I've watched your videos for awhile and your construction of content and you voice is far superior to most of the other channels regardless of content, I enjoy watching your material and often share videos due to the accurate content, from a US Army 24 year long Vietnam Veteran I thank you.
6:10 *Balderdash* "...the allied soldiers had to fight every farm, every village, every forest...etc.": As was told to me by grandparents of German friends of mine (while stationed near Minden - Rinteln): Common practice, when the Amis came to a village, they would surround it, send in a messenger, inform Nazis, SS, etc. to surrender, lest the village/location be bombed to oblivion (with inhabitants). Unlike the Tommies/Limeys, the Amis had no need to fight house-to-house, tree-to-tree, etc... it was common for the Amis to leave behind 22 ft. tractor trailers, filled with grain, flour, bread, livestock, etc.... many of those trailers left behind were converted to farm shacks, chicken coops, etc. (in the Minden - Rinteln area, some were still in use, during the 70's)
@john Hopkins, Greetings from the Texas Hill Country. You provided good insights. My father, who would be 102 were he alive, was a decorated WW2 vet having fought in 6 campaigns with the American 3rd Army, 6th Armored Div.. in the ETO. Dad was 5’7” and fit nicely in to a Sherman tank. He recounted to me that early in 1945 after their breakout from the Ardennes Forest battle and in to Germany, that numerous small hamlets they encountered surrendered , but not all. All it took in certain instances was a small resistance for the town to be lit 🔥 up. The (misguided) Germans indeed believed they were fighting for the perpetuity of Germany itself. Ostensibly, most frontline allied soldiers wanted the war to end and to return home to resume some form of normalcy. Yet they likewise were savvy to the perils of guerrila warfare ambushes when rolling through the small German towns.
@ john hopkins There was a huge difference in what happened west of the Rhine when compared to actions that took place east of the Rhine. This documentary focuses on Germany's last concerted defence of the Fatherland west of the Rhine, where "every farm, every village, every forest...etc." would have been fought for. Once over the Rhine, Germany had little in the way of a cohesive defencive force, so capitulation and surrender of villages etc. to the Allies would have been more common as the Allies pushed east. Also, you must consider that 'hearts & minds' has always been a key military strategy of the British/Commonwealth forces, right up to this day.
Unbelievable how both sides could fight 😫 in insane weather! The German tanks were much better strength and range! Finally, the Canadians got a LONG barrel tanks for best range distance!
+@@frankatchison2519 I thought Estonia was lost fall 1944. Kurland, Latvia was still fighting after Berlin fell. Hungary, Silesia were bloody battle grounds. I am a big Eastern Front buff and military modeler. Western Front was peanuts compared to Eastern Front. From Jan-45 to May-45 some of the bloodiest fighting of WW-2 took place.
Hitler's bone headed Ardenne Offensive lost 500 badly needed tanks and killed scores of infantry solders on both sides. Hitler's bone headed idea shortened the War.
I'm no military expert but surely the main battle action carried out by the Canadian commander might have waited till the weather cleared and air attacks had softened up the German defences. Canadian tank force could have performed probing actions in the meantime and thus lessened their casualties.
Yeah I noticed six people with their thumbs down to me that's unethical and Men give their lives to save us from in a world that we couldn't have lived in and we still get people that don't appreciate that sacrifices they made for us may God be with them all and God help us all that ones that don't appreciate what they did for us
Steve Creighton I think your prejudice, is heartfelt but misplaced, the reason for the negative votes is unknown and could be for many different reasons. Many comments abhor the loud music drowning out the speech for example, or the bad production values, or the commentary or really anything that is presented, and not in any way critical of the men and the battle.
There seems something shocking that, so late in the war, that the Canadians, with so much mobility, seemed to have tried to bulldoze their way through - although the terrain was obviously a massive obstacle. Perhaps there were no other options.
Bit of an dork of an comander how can you send tanks through an gap with high ground and forest on each side occupied by well armed enemy positions . Anybody with a bit of military background can see that is suicide just by one glance at the map??????????
Your voice is still audible slightly behind the music. you still have room for increasing the volume of music so that we cant hear what people want to say.
People often say the Germans were wrong to build such powerful tanks because they were expensive and required a lot of resources to make, meaning there were very few of them compared to the vast numbers of inferior tanks fielded by the Allies. However the Germans could never hope to match Allied tank production, so it was perhaps the better option to build fewer but better tanks.
Wouldn't really call the Panther or Tiger "better" than the Sherman. Sherman was far more reliable compared to both and, with wet stowage, was the second most survivable tank of the war behind the Churchill MKVII. Sherman had a crew mortality rate of 0.78, meaning only 1 crew member was expected to die in the Tank, while the rest would escape easily due to spring-assisted hatches and a hatch for every crew member. The only advantage the German Tanks had was longer range and ambush positions.
@@youraveragescotsman7119 it might not be better in reliability,but if the tank is fit and well supplied,i would have chosen a tiger,pls this does not mean i side with nazis i also detest their practices
The Canadians gave so much towards final victory and in some ways haven't really had the recognition they deserved. Air support was obviously dependent on the weather which must have made the going really tough sometimes especially against less but superior German AFVs.
Interesting video but the sound effects are way too loud. It's what the people are telling that makes it interesting. If I want great sound effects I will watch a movie and not a documentary.
The Narrator might find it easier to make himself heard if it wasn't necessary to shout over dubbed on explosions, an orchestra, and various electronic effects. Sadly, I had to give up.
It would have been far better for our guys if the planes that bombed Dresden in mid-February 1945 had instead been used to support Allied troops on the ground - both in the Hochwald area and in the whole Rhine-Ruhr campaign.
📺 It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit the world's best history documentary service with code 'WARSTORIES' for a huge discount! bit.ly/2MNt3cM
for witch reason you play that disturbing music?
Impossible to watch.
@@kostakisgeorgiou3637 0
Sherman’s sort of a poor tank compared to the German tanks. I wonder why they didn’t equip more of the with the British 17 pounder gun?
@@georgecoates2079 Until the Sherman was upgunned with the 76mm, it was no match versus Panther, Mark IV, Tiger I or II....even the Stug III....the Sherman had some good qualities, namely speed and umbers, but it also had a very high silhouette, which made it stand out even more.....I do not think I would want to be a Sherman Tanker in WW2....especially after viewing Fury as many times as I have
My great uncle was killed in action March 8 1945 . He was missing until March 25 when they found him buried by the Germans. He fought in operation blockbuster in the Hochwald and is now buried at the Groesbeek Canadian War cemetery. I wish I could find out exactly what happened to him. It’s incredible anyone got out of this battle. Canadians are incredible soldiers. I am so proud of my great uncle. 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
I am also extremely proud of ur great uncle. And I emphasise the word great. I am free to do as I choose in my life thanks to amazing ppl like ur uncle. So I say thank u Sir, I will never forget what u did for freedom.
We're proud of your uncle an all the others who took part too ......thank you to them all
Your southern brothers in the states are proud and grateful for men like your uncle too!🙏👊
Don't burden yourself trying to figure out what happened on the battlefield, its chaos , a hundred things could of gone wrong, keep his memory in your heart and mind that is what matters.
More than likely your great uncle died bravely....RIP to ALL those who died for freedom....
Respect to the Canadians who,s role in WW2 is vastly under rated.
If only they could see the state of things now lol
They were with us Brits from the very beginning.
Not for the Dutch! Canadians help out for free and freedom Americans for fee and controle
@@Hooibeest2D I watched a video on the liberation of the Netherlands. Who knew that Canada did so much.......? I also recently watched a film called "The Black Book" witch was terrific.
@@xanbex8324 most of the Nederlands was liberated by canadians and poles.
Black book is a good movie, based upon two stories if I'm not mistaken.
Thank you our northern brethren❤, for your sacrifices along side our own soldiers in the worst and most costly war in history. From a guy in a small city In New York(about an hour from the Canadian/U.S border.) May all the millions that lost their life in WW2 rest in peace.
Thank you my Dear southern brother! We will always fight together for freedom and we Canadians will always render our sacrifice to our American friends in need!🍁
Thank you to the Canadian soldiers who paid the ultimate price for freedom,my grandfather got hit by a sniper over in the Solomon's thankfully it just missed his heart, much respect from a brother in New Zealand..... RIP to ALL those who died for us all......
My great uncle was killed and never found because of the Canadian
@@romyhofer995 Excellent. Another murderous German got what he deserved.
The Canadian army was so impressed by the German armour that Canada has exclusively used German tanks since 1968
The British Centurion served in Canada until 1978 and light armor has always been a mix of American or Swiss designs license built in Canada. As far as choosing the Leopard goes, I imagine it was mainly due to cost and availability rather then being impressed. Indeed the Leopard 1's were awseome tanks in their day, and served countires without deep pockets well. The Leo 2A6M's used in Afghanistan were leased/purchased because they were surplus (a.k.a available immediately) and cheap. If DND could have run a proper competition and had time allowed odds are (according to various online sources...so take that with a grain of salt) the Challenger II would have toped their list.
Bloody well done, really appreciate the work that's gone into this series and the brave Canadians who never give up either!
Bringing these hugely important battles to view, you insure that the brave who fought here will not be forgotten. An example of young people not knowing much of these battles is as follows. Not long ago there was a lecturer doing a piece on WWII. A young teacher in the crowd asked, “when was world war eleven?” Keep doing this all important task. Thank you.
how addictive is this better than tv need some sleep but my brain needs more glad i am the boss
This man seriously needs sleep
Its better than “tv” because only 60 yr old boomers watch tv lol
It is tv...this is from a tv show.. Commercials getting as bad, way more intrusive
@@mandelorean6243 CT
Thank you Canadians, thank you allies for your bravery. The world will always remember you.
The said thing is that the youth of today don't know anything about the war.
And they also don't care.
For them the most important thing in their lives is thinking how to make a Tik-Tok video and get the most views.
And that's no joke.
They don't know anything about WW2.
I Love Canadians🇨🇦.. I had the pleasure of visiting Canada twice.. beautiful place ... It's a place I could see myself living.. 🇨🇦🙋🏽♀️
'Lots of tanks?
Canada's cool (no pun intended). All places are cool for one reason or another, that's why it is great to visit lots of places and peoples!
You are welcome to join us a be a Canadian as well! And you are always welcome to visit and stay a while to get to know us!!
to those brave canadians thank you for your actions
I wish they would make another season of this series... so well done.
Field Marshall Karl Gerd Von Lundstedt said that the three factors that caused the German defeat were ;
1. Germany had no oil.
2. American oil contribution amounted to SIX Billion barrels out of the SEVEN Billion barrels, consumed by the Allies. Most of the oil coming from Texas.
3. For D-Day a huge ‘Oil Pipeline’ between England and France was built under the Channel.
3. The ‘Allies’ overwhelming 'Airpower."
4. The Lend-Lease Act of the USA supplied the Soviet Union so they could fight the Germans with more than 400,000 jeeps and trucks, 14,000 aircraft, 8,000 tractors and 300,000 vehicles, and 13,000 battle tanks. Boots, clothing material, radios etc. Totalling $180 billion in today's currency.
Good thing we have closed caption. The background noise is so much louder than the people talking that it's impossible to know what they're saying!
Because this is a documentary TV series on History Channel.
even with CC you got to guess at some of the words because of"they sound the same so CC gives the wrong word many times. So for the people that are deaf what does music sound like when it is the droning of aircraft or guns going boom or machine gun fire. CC definitely could use some improvements. Yet I always have it on because just to get those words in matter.
I remember visiting Yper/ Belgium were the allied troops of mix Canadians, Aussies Gurkas etc died..there were fresh wreaths and as I tried to pray I felt enormous heavy sadness that I started to cry. My belgian husband asked me what happened but I cannot explain just that I felt too much sadness.
*Ypres WW1*
Great series! My Dad and his twin combat vets (USAAF B-25s & 82nd AB Pathfinders) lived the conflict. ALL of your programs are AWESOME!
Yeahhhhhh sure they did buddy.
Programmes*
Mom is from New Brunswick - Dual Citizenship. Americans are only fed the Bulge and the Victories for American Troops. Least we never forget that America Invaded Canada during their first two wars - Revolution & 1812; both times the Canadians sent them back. Thank you - Good quick Story with decent footage & graphics. US Army - 1971 to 1973. Hopkinton, Mass, USA. God Bless.
Where were the "Canadian tanks" manufactured?
@@nickdanger3802 Montreal Locomotive.
@@peterson7082 Where were the "Canadian tanks" actually used in combat manufactured? Montreal Locomotive Works (MLW) was a Canadian railway locomotive manufacturer which existed under several names from 1883 to 1985. For a number of years it was a subsidiary of the American Locomotive Company.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Locomotive_Works
War of 1812 "Such exaggerations were key to the myth that it was Canada’s militia, not its expensive professional soldiers, who won the War of 1812. In reality, the militia were primarily assigned to transport and labour duties, although some served alongside British professional regulars and fencible regiments."
www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/war-of-1812-editorial#:~:text=The%20War%20of%201812%20%28which%20lasted%20from%201812,and%20the%20Atlantic%2C%20and%20in%20the%20United%20States.
@@nickdanger3802 Oh the Canadian used tanks, my mistake. Well various, Fisher, Pullman, FMW, Chrysler, etc
I like Canadian war stories. This one's terrific!
Salute to the Germans in this Time the best Soldiers in the World!
Nearly 🇬🇧
Wow-sorry to admit I have never even heard of this major battle. The before and after shots of the buildings was a great touch, but the Canadians are the superstars. They always seem to be forgotten-sad, SALUTE Canadians!
We might make jokes about Canadians here in the states, but jokes aside we're proud and grateful to call you neighbor and ally!
Pity about the background music expectedly for people like me with hearing loss
They need to turn music up.....I can still hear talking.
It ain't you, it's a really bad mix:)
They also call explosions and machine gun fire MUSIC instead of comic book style "BOOM" or "rat a tat a tat" or stampeding horses hoof noises is also "music"
I use captions with no sound
This channel is more interesting than reading history books
(But still books is gold)
Wish I could hear what they're saying!
I love the German who says “the M4 Sherman you destroy a 100 of them, there are a 120 more”
inklingGirl67 Thank you so much, for instance - one of *Many -Others
here - Oct. 1944 --Villers-Bocage/Normandy, ss-HauptsturmFührer
Michael Wittmann (Ritterkreuz-Träger) w/his crew, Tiger-tank, destroyed 20-each-US-Armored-Vehicles(British-Canadian Crews) in = 21-Minutes.........
- lost in Battle, one track, moved w/crew under fire, own German front-line, next morning maintained and repaired w/ new track and the tiger
w/ Wittman and crew, (RIP)
started in new next battle...... and and and, Now our Heroes are meanwhile in *Walhalla, side and side all *Camerades, also on side
Camerades; of the other Feld-Post-Nummer..=. the former Enemies...
. now on side too.
Never we wont forget you... Thank's for attention,
@@AlexanderJScheuare you high
The Brits called the Sherman "Ronsons" as they would light up with just one spark, the Germans called them "Tommy cookers" according to my grandfather who was in the 79th Armoured Div.
@@simonbroberg969 that is true the Canadians nicknamed them bun-son burners and the Germans Tommy cookers
@@simonbroberg969
Yet there where so many of them that they won the war! Power in numbers.
Audio was better in ww2 than this channel. Spoils the viewing.
to think one of the most intense tank fights of WWII happened on small stretch of farmland
Are you familiar with the Eastern Front? This was NOT one of the most intense tank battles of WW2....not even close. The Soviets and Wehrmacht / SS Panzer Divisions engaged in this type of Tank Warfare on a Daily Basis.
@@tiocfaidharla7819 I’m well aware, hence why I said one of the
@@ambush_akula5261
"One of the?" Not even close.
@@jimjimsandburg2754 he's forgotten about Kursk.
@@tiocfaidharla7819 Do you need extra conscription for your eyes or something he said "One of the most"
I've got an original Canadian Army battle map of Xanten marked "secret". And a picture of my late dad with his Coy, in the main street about 50 yards from the old town gate, after the town was liberated.
Who was he with ? Btw, there's a documentary being made about this battle now by Real time History. Good to see these guys at War Stories generating interest !
@@hughbeastodonnell3733 He was the Anti-Tank Artillery Coy Captain in the South Saskatchewan Regt. He was originally commissioned during wartime in the Essex Scottish. He was a Sgt. in the local militia before the war. The 26th Field Battery, Royal Canadian Artillery.
@@boxwoodgreen that's awesome, definitely a piece of cool history there.
@@cowgoesmoo3850 Another interesting part of the story... in that local militia unit was James "Jimmy Doohan" ... who after his own heroic WW2 service played "Scotty" in the original Star Trek. I was fortunate enough to meet him at our old high school's 75th Anniversary. He was a real gentleman.
@Damo Along ways off, but our countries paths crossed before, ... a war before. My late dads two uncles fell in WW1. James at Hill 60 Ypres, and Arthur at the north side of Moquet Farm on the Somme. Both places the Aussies who know their history, know well. Almost 2am here. ZZzz time. G'nite !
what a brave man the veteran is-awesome account and accuracy
What great men what great heros thank you all God bless you
Nice video, shame the music is that loud it nearly drowns out what people are saying
In the winter of 1945, the Sherman's were armed with 76 long barrels, and most tanks were tank destroyers 90mm M10s and Chaffee tank destroyers. The Sherman's was not the only tank. The air power and artillery
The Chaffee is a light tank, not a tank destroyer. And not all the Shermans had the 76. In fact, most of them were still using the 75, because the crews liked it better. The 75 was a much better gun for supporting infantry than the 76, which was really only good for tank on tank combat.
What is almost Unbelivable,its the fact that the German Hold on for so long with so few.
They were fighting in the west,in the east and in italy,in a desproportion in man and material and nevertheless in some ocasions still be ablle to put the Allies in a total desarey and panic.
Its a testament to the sheer power of their guns, their training an outstanding leadership and fighting Spirit.
Why put music louder than the voices ?, It drowns them out.
the 88mm is a awesome weapon for the germans
It's aint awesome when they would level the Barrel down & start using tht monster to fire at infantry.
One deadly gun for sure
@Hoa Tattis will check that aa gun
@Hoa Tattis nope the germans had the best gun of world war two
the volume of the music overwhelms the people talking.
annoyingly so
Totally agree; and the current trend of using video game like graphics is hideous. It does nothing to bring realism, especially when you have animations of German and Allied tanks lined up firing at each other from 20 metres apart.
Bloody annoying...
Canadians at their most valiant. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Well if you studied your history in the war it wasn't just Canadians yes of course Canadians but believe it or not the most valiant and courageous with the Russians how they came back after getting anilated and storm right into Germany and annihilated them yeah it was Russia that are the heroes the French to Canadians American all had a part in it the poles the checks Italy they change their mind after a while of course
Don't forget the Flying Tiger's without Those P.40 Tomahawk's the Chinese would be speaking Japanese. You would think they would remember the Atrocities of Nanking.
Nicknamed Ronson's, Zippo's, Rolling Coffin's. The M.4 Sherman powered by gasoline was a nightmare at the beginning of the War. Diesel isn't as explosive. The Panzer's and Tiger's up close had a light disadvantage. But over 500 yards, I wouldn't want to be in a Sherman. Knocking out the track's, or fusing the turrets with phosphorous round's was the only way of getting an edge. Up close the German's had to drop their .75 or .88 mm gun's almost to the ground, inside of 500 yd's.
@@frankatchison2519 thats why only the experienced tiger commanders got kills,they knew to never give up that advantage and stay far away in hiding and take them all out before they come close
Salute to the Canadian warrior
Love the Canadians
Good allies
The canadians played a massive part in the second world war and yet most people just gloss over
Because the Americans, British and the Soviets always brag about winning the WW II and made lots of movies out of it.
@@kevinlengkoan8534
yes, but if Canadians would make a movie about their activities in WWII, we would be happy to watch it.
I have met quite a number of Canadians and overall I find them pretty modest and not braggers . Solid folks!
@@jimjimsandburg2754 that's not entirely my point. It's all about Propaganda. And movies are a good Propaganda tools.
@@xanbex8324 Yeah, as a group we are pretty chill. We don't brag too much about Canada but we are very nasty in a fight.
Please turn up the music.., there was an anoying Sound of someone speaking underneath the music!!
really good war stories recommend subscribing to all 10/10
Jawohl *
Oddly this series was on Amazon Prime tv here in Canada only to discover it and 2 weeka ago and they took it off.
Probably triggered the little snowflakes up there - same problem in the USA plus China Joe
@@YahooMurray ah yes god forbid we learn and see some history. Forgot history is racist and should be deleted from the records. We now pick and choose and edit what to learn. Tanks are mean machines.
An apple fell and humans discovered gravity.Millions of life’s fell and they still haven’t discovered humanity
Because they make money from wars and downfall of humanity😞
it is unfortunately not an ideal world since humans and other creatures were created. We compete against and eat the others.
A booger from a giant nostril allows a preponderate of ancillary vocabulary without hindering the leveling of potato chips.
In the winter of 1945, the war had been over for months. Its the winter of 1944; the year is the point where the winter starts in.
Not always. The usage varies
thanks
Aside from the sound, this was one of the most salutary WW2 documentaries ever made.
Yes. Why the heck did they ever release it with such a flaw?
@@fergusmallon1337 That would remain a mystery!
My father was in the air force after ww2. He had much respect for the Canadian air force
All ur videos are next level wow
Done watching now waiting for Greatest Tank Battle - Battle For Germany cuz I like the battle between a Pershing and a Panther in Cologne, Germany.
WOW! WHAT BRAVE MEN ON BITH SIDES! AMAZING GREAT HISTORY LESSON!
Skill not quantity is what wins battles and wars.
This is something everyone needs to remember.
Explain then how Germany lost the Eastern Front when they had similar numbers to the Red Army until 1943?
Athe Germans couldn't replace the men & mat
serial as fast as the Russians & the allies bc their factories were
Being bombed night &
day by the Brits&us
@@youraveragescotsman7119. You used the a keyword (until 1943) before then the Germans were obliterating the Soviets.
Here’s an interesting fact, when the Germans started Operation Barbarossa (invasion of Soviet Union) Stalin sent his reserve armies to fight first, which is part of the reason why they sucked so bad at fighting.
He wanted to weaken the Germans forces down before he sent his Front line troops in. (The reverse of what normal military doctrine is)
Reserves are supposed to be the backup and last line of defense, like what the Germans used in the last days of the war in Berlin and other parts of Germany (they call it the Replacement Army).
Anyway, so Stalin used his Reserves first, then in 1943 is when he called in his actual Army and other Frontline Forces.
So there’s a little known fun fact.
The Germans were quite skilled during WW2. I wonder how that worked out for them in the long run...........
@@Americandragonrider333. wrong
If you have to steal historical documentaries from other sites, please could you ensure the audio works?
Thank you for sharring what bravery by the Canadian tank crews , we thank you !😔. Looking back is easy to judge , the Sherman was not good tank without the longer barrel and sadly caught fire easily, weak armour.
British and Canadian tanks were better???
@@nickdanger3802 Our Sherman's were not as good as the Panzer V and VI.... probably equal to the Panzer III... but we simply had far more of them, we could replace tanks and crews and we had a far superior logistics chain.
So, checkmate.
Stdu what bravery 1000cajadian tank vs 18 panzers
Thank - you .
The before and after pictures are haunting such as that brick tower.
I've watched your videos for awhile and your construction of content and you voice is far superior to most of the other channels regardless of content, I enjoy watching your material and often share videos due to the accurate content, from a US Army 24 year long Vietnam Veteran I thank you.
These aren't his videos.
Timeghost channel on youtube blows this away when it comes to information,
6:10 *Balderdash* "...the allied soldiers had to fight every farm, every village, every forest...etc.": As was told to me by grandparents of German friends of mine (while stationed near Minden - Rinteln): Common practice, when the Amis came to a village, they would surround it, send in a messenger, inform Nazis, SS, etc. to surrender, lest the village/location be bombed to oblivion (with inhabitants). Unlike the Tommies/Limeys, the Amis had no need to fight house-to-house, tree-to-tree, etc... it was common for the Amis to leave behind 22 ft. tractor trailers, filled with grain, flour, bread, livestock, etc.... many of those trailers left behind were converted to farm shacks, chicken coops, etc. (in the Minden - Rinteln area, some were still in use, during the 70's)
@john Hopkins, Greetings from the Texas Hill Country. You provided good insights. My father, who would be 102 were he alive, was a decorated WW2 vet having fought in 6 campaigns with the American 3rd Army, 6th Armored Div.. in the ETO. Dad was 5’7” and fit nicely in to a Sherman tank. He recounted to me that early in 1945 after their breakout from the Ardennes Forest battle and in to Germany, that numerous small hamlets they encountered surrendered , but not all. All it took in certain instances was a small resistance for the town to be lit 🔥 up. The (misguided) Germans indeed believed they were fighting for the perpetuity of Germany itself. Ostensibly, most frontline allied soldiers wanted the war to end and to return home to resume some form of normalcy. Yet they likewise were savvy to the perils of guerrila warfare ambushes when rolling through the small German towns.
@ john hopkins There was a huge difference in what happened west of the Rhine when compared to actions that took place east of the Rhine. This documentary focuses on Germany's last concerted defence of the Fatherland west of the Rhine, where "every farm, every village, every forest...etc." would have been fought for. Once over the Rhine, Germany had little in the way of a cohesive defencive force, so capitulation and surrender of villages etc. to the Allies would have been more common as the Allies pushed east. Also, you must consider that 'hearts & minds' has always been a key military strategy of the British/Commonwealth forces, right up to this day.
Canadians are so damn polite, it's surprising that they're also such ferocious and dogged fighters...
its not surprising to us...rudeness and belligerence is a sure sign of weakness!
Until we have a rifle or hockey stick in our hands, then watch out!
@@johnkidd1226 and a curling broom
@@donniedraftdodger7457 Tell that to the Chinese: To them rudeness and belligerence are signs of strength.
@@redfalcon8866 Only to themselves, a strong enemy is not intimidated.
Thanks
I like the Germans mentality: You have to take as many enemies with you to the grave as you can.
We always are the good guys and the invaders as the bad guys [in any country] so that mentality is the same with all soldiers. It has to be.
Well a pity any of them stayed alive.
@@patriciabrenner9216 Are you German?!
@@radomirratkovic4407 of course I am not German.
@@patriciabrenner9216 madame no offence but Brenner is a German surname😀
Unbelievable how both sides could fight 😫 in insane weather! The German tanks were much better strength and range! Finally, the Canadians got a LONG barrel tanks for best range distance!
background sounds are way too loud.
couldn't watch past the first minute or so.
The battle all negatives to the heroism of Canadian you only. Glorified the Germans.
😢🙏🙏🙏🙏 thank you all
Sorry! From Jan 45 to May 45 all of Germany,s last stands were in East, West Prussia. Kurland, Latvia, Silesia, Pomerania, Posen.
+@@frankatchison2519 I thought Estonia was lost fall 1944. Kurland, Latvia was still fighting after Berlin fell. Hungary, Silesia were bloody battle grounds. I am a big Eastern Front buff and military modeler. Western Front was peanuts compared to Eastern Front. From Jan-45 to May-45 some of the bloodiest fighting of WW-2 took place.
@@bloodyapril6392 🙄
Hitler's bone headed Ardenne Offensive lost 500 badly needed tanks and killed scores of infantry solders on both sides. Hitler's bone headed idea shortened the War.
Seriously. Turn down the volume on the background music. The narrator and interview subjects are much more important. Thank God for captioning.
Une fois de plus, les Canadiens remportent le prestige.
comme toujour
Best videos about ww2 hands down
I'm no military expert but surely the main battle action carried out by the Canadian commander might have waited till the weather cleared and air attacks had softened up the German defences. Canadian tank force could have performed probing actions in the meantime and thus lessened their casualties.
Absolutely
Gotta respect those old-timers, on BOTH sides! "Allied" doesn't automatically mean "good guy" and not ALL Germans were "evil Nazis"
every time i watch these documentaries, the soldiers all say "you shouldn't really do it, but this is what we did.."
Yeah I noticed six people with their thumbs down to me that's unethical and Men give their lives to save us from in a world that we couldn't have lived in and we still get people that don't appreciate that sacrifices they made for us may God be with them all and God help us all that ones that don't appreciate what they did for us
Steve Creighton
I think your prejudice, is heartfelt but misplaced, the reason for the negative votes is unknown and could be for many different reasons. Many comments abhor the loud music drowning out the speech for example, or the bad production values, or the commentary or really anything that is presented, and not in any way critical of the men and the battle.
those thumbs down are probably Nazis lovers
The Canadians fought some of the toughest battles
There seems something shocking that, so late in the war, that the Canadians, with so much mobility, seemed to have tried to bulldoze their way through - although the terrain was obviously a massive obstacle. Perhaps there were no other options.
Perhaps there were no other options.
Perhaps you are right.
The canadians suffered heavy lost in the first week of the operation...
Bit of an dork of an comander how can you send tanks through an gap with high ground and forest on each side occupied by well armed enemy positions . Anybody with a bit of military background can see that is suicide just by one glance at the map??????????
This was earlier in the birth of tanks. Tanks themselves were new. Not even 20years old. Not tactics or strategies.
Please beat your Audio Mixer Person until they change their ways. The verbiage is covered by music in large parts of the video.
Be Kind, Rewind!
I've watched 10 minutes and switched it off, the music is just ridiculous.
what about it ? i love the music
Too bad Canada did not have Infantry to protect the tanks like the Germans!
Turn down the dam music so we can hear this men actually speak Jesus christ
I like these guys.
War NEVER gains peace of the heart.
Your voice is still audible slightly behind the music. you still have room for increasing the volume of music so that we cant hear what people want to say.
People often say the Germans were wrong to build such powerful tanks because they were expensive and required a lot of resources to make, meaning there were very few of them compared to the vast numbers of inferior tanks fielded by the Allies. However the Germans could never hope to match Allied tank production, so it was perhaps the better option to build fewer but better tanks.
Wouldn't really call the Panther or Tiger "better" than the Sherman. Sherman was far more reliable compared to both and, with wet stowage, was the second most survivable tank of the war behind the Churchill MKVII. Sherman had a crew mortality rate of 0.78, meaning only 1 crew member was expected to die in the Tank, while the rest would escape easily due to spring-assisted hatches and a hatch for every crew member.
The only advantage the German Tanks had was longer range and ambush positions.
@@youraveragescotsman7119 it might not be better in reliability,but if the tank is fit and well supplied,i would have chosen a tiger,pls this does not mean i side with nazis i also detest their practices
If the damn thing didn’t break down.
@@youraveragescotsman7119 wrong. It's common knowledge the Panther is the best all around tank of the second world war
@@brennanleadbetter9708 they didn't. All that was worked out by 1943
Another video with needlessly loud music drowning out the dialog.
The Canadians gave so much towards final victory and in some ways haven't really had the recognition they deserved. Air support was obviously dependent on the weather which must have made the going really tough sometimes especially against less but superior German
AFVs.
Interesting video but the sound effects are way too loud. It's what the people are telling that makes it interesting. If I want great sound effects I will watch a movie and not a documentary.
One not always living a death handed them, is mostly running from their hearts heart. most
The Narrator might find it easier to make himself heard if it wasn't necessary to shout over dubbed on explosions, an orchestra, and various electronic effects. Sadly, I had to give up.
Yeah, this one was mixed horribly. Somebody messed up in production.
I love war history
Awesome. Thanks. 😊
Love these shows, but the background sound makes it almost impossible to hear the narrator or the other speakers.
It would have been far better for our guys if the planes that bombed Dresden in mid-February 1945 had instead been used to support Allied troops on the ground - both in the Hochwald area and in the whole Rhine-Ruhr campaign.
43:30, The allies did wreck 85% of Xanten with their medium and heavy bombers.
Brave men in Sherman tanks
88MM is the best with longer range.. and also best for close range
Very good, thanks.
Great to hear about it 👍