American Lady Questions Muslim On Hadith Reliability! Muhammed Ali
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 бер 2023
- Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
/ themuslimlantern
cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
Follow me on Social Media:
/ chainless_slave
/ chainless_slave
/ themuslimlantern
Brothers and Sisters don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah!
Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY
www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern
cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
Of course brother
@@justintonu2104
Assalamu Alaikum
Try Insha'ALLAH to contact him on ig or twi. .tter or e m ail.
Why didn’t you tell her that all her sins were forgiven
You are a good defender of flawed interpretation brother. May Allah open your eyes. You saying Saheh Bukhari was compiled very close to the period of Prophet is not true, you should avoid doing that, there are a couple centuries in between. The issue we have with the Hadith today is created by the Umayad dynasty in their animosity with the Hashamids and they were involved in getting contaminating Hadith. In response to your hallucinated interpretation of the ayat in Surah Fatiha, "It is you we pray to and upon you we call for help". Why would Allah ask his Angels to prostate in front of Adam, as per your interoperation, Allah himself asked all the Angels to commit a sin & Azazeel seems to be in your league as he also said, what you always say..... Food for your thought. Try to find the one, who is always on the earth, to do what prophet did for his followers, "Bait-e-Rizwan". TC
in the 1st 4 gospels through Jesus's words you can't prove Jesus is God but a Muslim only. In fact Jon 17 :3 & 4 Jesus separates himself from God and says his work is done pre cruci-ficiton and after praying for the comfortoer who it the jon 1 :21 prophet after Musa in duet 18 :18, isaiah 42 prophet from mt selah Medina new covenent.... also there is duet 33 :2 Lord came with 10k at mt. paran or Mecca, matches Solomon 5 :10 - 16 describing Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him and using his name in hebrew.
---
All Prophets Taught Tawhid - Deut 4 :6, Mathew 12 :29.
Prophets said obey law - Duet 4 :2, Psalms 119, James 2 :17, Mathew 5 :17, Jon 14 :15
Prophets taught Allah forgives w/o sacrifice - Isiah 1 :18, Hosea 6 :6, Mathew 12 :7 & 9 :13!
Prophets taught no inherited sin - Deut 24 :16, Ezekiel 18 :20, Exo 23 :7.
Tawhid includes attributes such as God is not a Man like in numbers 23 :19 or Hosea 11 :9 or doesn't sleep like it says in the psalms. etc.
Bonus : Duet 12 : 31 - ... thing that the Lord hates they have done for their gods. They would even "toast" their sons and their daughters in the Nar to their gods.
Being a Muslim in the Southern US is an experience! When I became a Muslim in 2020, I had a lot of interesting experiences including my neighbors slamming on their brakes when they were driving because I wore a hijab outside for the first time 😅 Also, the world was deep in the Pandemic and going to a mosque was difficult. But Alhamdulillah you just keep praying and Allah swt shows you the way 😊😊😊
Jes zainab alhamdolillah subhanallah Allah hu akbar mashallah welcome to islam my dear sister🥰 may Allah SWT bless you your family🕋🇷🇺amin yarabbülalemin🕋🇷🇺 may Allah SWT guide all us as well🇺🇸🇨🇳 🇷🇺on the straight path🕋🇷🇺 amin yarabbülalemin🕋🇷🇺
May Allah make it easier for you.
this is wow
I understand Sister because I can relate. I'm originally from the Midwest, but I attended University in Texas where I took my Shahada. The South is known as the Bible Belt.
@jas .. Hadiths are false and will distort you from the real guidence and right path .. choose quran alone ...
Allah guides all those who seek the truth - Islam.
amen but the sign of qiyamah day
Well that’s very obvious never patronise someone uninterested or interested in Islam. Only Allah guides like you said. So don’t feel arrogant as a Muslim. The heart of the believer is between the two fingers of Allah.
@@Noneofyourbeeznis_ What are you even talking about?
@@Noneofyourbeeznis_ he sayin people find truth eho seek it not hypocrate and it is true be truth ful atleast to ur self.
@@Noneofyourbeeznis_not just believers 😅
Before I'm ex Muslim because lots of questions about Hadith, I'm listening you since 3 months, after listening you all my questions about Hadith is clear, now I'm a truly Muslim, mashallah ❤
Welcome back
Welcome back 🫂
I'm in tears after this shahada. From South Africa.
Where about in south africa
Allahu Akbar
Mash’Allah, Allahu Akbar. 🎉
Akhi, the way you broke it down explaining hadith was unrivalled! I’ve never heard it put that way, but I’m gonna take it and use it in my dawah, In’sha-Allah.
I’ve been watching your videos for a few weeks and I believe you have a gift in articulating to your specific audience.
There’s an old saying we Afro Americans (actually I’m also Aussie), say that deals with making things understandable: “Put the hay down where the goats can get to it.” Simply put - you have to deliver a palatable message directly to your intended audience.
May Allah azzawajal protect you always and elevate your rank, ameen. ❤
please learn the topic of "mustholah hadits". Will give you great detail of authentication of hadits.
امين يا الله🤲❤️
Assalamu alaykum akhi I’m Polynesians aussie too are you a revert as well?
Elhamdulillah
I can never get used to people say the shahada for the first time 💛 it always makes me so emotional 😩💛 الحمدلله على نعمة الاسلام
agree ...😥😥😥
100% agree
Me too ☺️
MashaAllah
Wallahi meeting a stranger and learning they are Muslim is the most incredible feeling, the immediate connection you feel to this is indescribable, like you have known them your whole life alhamdulillah
Muslims brotherhood is something else bro its beautiful
Fr❤
assalamualaikum to all muslim from malaysia 🇲🇾
Waalaikumussalam from Malaysia 😄🫶
Wa_alaykum_as-salam. from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Walaikum asalam muslim from Kashmir
وعليكم السلام من مصر
Indonesia
Much respect to sister Emma. She's asking the right questions! Allah hu Akbar! May Allah grant her a great life and happiness here and the hereafter. Ameen welcome to the family my sister
Amin yarabbülalemin🕋🇷🇺
Allahumma Ameen
امين يارب
امين يارب
Alhamdulillah As a revert I’m so proud of you may Allah bless you and keep you on the straight path
Ameen my brother in Islam. All love ❤️
best decision in life
Aameen
@@AmicableAgnostic I can answer this.... I simply looked at what Jesus told Moses in the Old Testament, to kill every living being except virgin girls, whom you can take as wives..... So if Jesus allowed this.... Then I didn't have issue converting to Islam.
Btw, I've noticed you copying and pasting the same questions on many videos and always targetting new converts.... I guess you only wants to share your doubts, right.... Nothing cynical there, Ahum, Ahum....
@@AmicableAgnosticcould you post the reference
Aslamalaikum to all Muslims from south Indian ex hindu.
Salam alaikum may Allah bless you
Are there more hindus accepting Islam?
May Allah bless you akhi
@@lanakay8329google it
Many accept Islam. But, they are not vocal in social media about it much.
Generally, Indians face societal pressure when they convert. May be that's the reason. People who have worked for us have accepted Islam alhamdulillah and they practice it very serious, Ma sha Allah. In fact, I really feel envious about the reverts and make me feel like I'm not good enough.
Alhamdulillah, I'm a born Muslim.😊
She sounded decent , nice and genuinely seeking the truth .. may Allah bless her and keep her on the right path
Ameen
امين يارب
I like this. Because the science of Hadith itself is something bible didn't have. In a straight forward manners the science of hadith itself would bulldoze Pauline Christianity.
Science of Hadith is based on hearsay. Allah authenticated the Qur'an but the ahadith came later on. Men created science of Hadith.
Agree. Because the Bible way of compiling things are way too absurd if you analyze it using the hadith methodology of science. The narrator was unknown, the chain narrator was unknown, the biodata of narrator was of course unknown too. The reliability of the BIble is unreliable because you can't trace it objectively.
why use words like "Destroy"? No matter if it's wrong but why instigate someone to talk bad about Quran or Islam bro? We can do better.
@@abdul6423 Astaghfirullah thank you. I have change it, is it better or you have better word choice?
@@lovemamahouse Thank you for taking it in the right manner bro/sis, sure that's good or "dismantle" is also another word just FYI :)
Be safe!
May Allah reward you for the work you do. MashaAllah you have an excellent way of explaining things.
اخي ماهر السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
i didnt believe in the hadith that much but bro u explained it in a really beautiful way thank u so much , an7amdulilah ,and i am so happy for that lady insha allah god almighty guide oll of us ♥♥♥
Alhamdulillah. May ALLAH ﷻ guide you always and maintain you and all of us steadfast on the straight path.
@ahmad hanbal Nowhere did the brother/sister say that they denied the hadith due to their feelings. I personally was born and raised in a muslim family and I'm, alhamdulillah, a muslim, but I also had doubts about the eligibility of hadiths, because I never learned about the chain of narrations or how it worked, but alhamdulillah now I know.
@@AL-FATTAH_servant Insha allah ♥
@ahmad hanbal yes sir , actually to me it is not strange bc as we know there is shaitan , and he always trys to lead us astray ,wallahi everyday a lot of strange thoughts come to my head , sometimes I cant even study well , but we have Allah no doubt that he helps us ...love and respect ♥
@@nadar.9941
May ALLAH ﷻ maintain you and all of us steadfast on the straight path and increase us in knowledge and Iman.
We Muslims welcome any race the same way, black, brown white, purple , no favouritism based on colour!
SubhnAllāh.. multitudes of ppl coming to Islam is a sign/victory from Allāh سُبْحَٰنَهُۥ وَتَعَٰلَىٰ
Remember surah an Nasr
@@Noneofyourbeeznis_ 💯💯💯. So seek repentance guys inshaaAllah
Does it really matter? We are happy yet in the end according to your prophet it will be 73 sects and 72 go to hell. Good job guys - _-
You guys have already 8-10 sects!
subhaanAllahi wa bi-hamdih, astaghfirullah wa atoobu ilayh.
subhaanaka Rabbanaa wa bi-ham-dik , Allahumma-ghfirli
yeah it a bless but is scary at the same time that means ends of times are closer than we think ...my allah have mercy on us on the day of judgment
Wallah i cried for her.
Sister, you now have brothers in Palestine.
Wallah you have chosen the straight path and it's the best decision you've done in your life. This life is less than a blink of an eye in comparison with the hereafter.
Allah has chosen you to be a believer. He sees something good in you that even you might not know!
May Allah SWT keep you on this path and make you a steady pious righteous person.
❤❤❤❤❤
I like mohamed explanation so simple yet very effective, may Allah bless you, jazzakallahu brother.
الحمدلله
Alhumdulilah! May Allah give you the good of this life and the next sister Emma , Ameen.
I am an American sister that reverted 35 years ago , Alhumdulilah ❤
Alhumdulillah, May Allah continue to bless you and all of us.
Aameen
Maansha allaah
Clean soul looking for the truth…MashaAllah welcome to Islam…Allah o Akbar
إِذَا جَاءَ نَصْرُ اللَّهِ وَالْفَتْحُ وَرَأَيْتَ النَّاسَ يَدْخُلُونَ فِي دِينِ اللَّهِ أَفْوَاجًا فَسَبِّحْ بِحَمْدِ رَبِّكَ وَاسْتَغْفِرْهُ إِنَّهُ كَانَ تَوَّابًا
الحمدلله
Barakallahu Feek. Allaah guides those He Wills! How blessed this sister is! And there are millions of men women whose destiny will be otherwise. Dawah alone is the most warranted necessity for all of us, the children of Adam(A). May Allaah bless this #MuhammadAli!
الحمدلله
ماشاء الله
I have watched so many shahada this week , this one touched my heart , I am tearing of joy , may Allah protect us all , aameen
امين
Allah cleared my doubt and strengthened my belief of hadith through this man who answered and the woman who asked.
Welcome sister !
Thanks!
🎉
Can’t wait for todays stream!! ❤❤
same here
Same
saaaame
Where? I always miss these streams
@@Slimho me too :(
Allah Akbar. Welcome to Islam.
Thanks
I just came back from praying and I saw this ! Allahu Akbar , Ma'sha'Allah welcome to Islam sister . 🛐☪️
الحمدلله
Allahu akbar
الله اكبر
May Allah protect her and keep her on the right path, Allahuma Ameen.
امين يارب
Subhanallah
If you read this;
Say "SubhanAllah" 33x
Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x
Say "Allahu akbar" 34x
May Allah reward you.
Alhamdulillah Welcome to Islam sister
It was narrated from Jubair bin Nufair (RA) that a man asked Aishah (RA) about fasting and she said:
"The Messenger of Allah (SAW) used to fast all of Shaban, and he made sure to fast on Mondays and Thursdays."
(Sunan an-Nasa'i 2186, Book 22, Hadith 97)
Agreed this is the easy bit... The hard part is the Prophet was on defensive war with his sword at the same time to defend his religion. It's the easy parts we do
@@malhamaulkubra4437 What's your point? What's that got anything to do with fasting? And who said fasting is easy?
Follow Qur'an alone
@@aishaarshadalam3412 he means that the prophet SAW did both at the same time so fasting compared to that is easy. and actually fasting is easy .
@@Junior-yt6cx
The funny ''arabic expert'' again 🙄
إذهب أحسن لك يا جاهل اللغة العربية!!!
Welcome to Islam dear Emma, your shahada brought tears to my eyes.
May Allah Sobhano bless you and keep you steadfast InshaAllah.
امين يارب
MashaAllah! Alhumdulila! Her pronunciation in Arabic was great! May Allah swt grant her the best in this life and the afterlife! Ameen! And also May Allah swt bless brother Mohummad constantly for his great work! Ameen
Welcome my sister very happy to see you becoming muslim, i pray Allah makes it easy for you to understand and staying steadfast, Ameen and i hope you take things step by step without hurrying
الله يحفطك يا اخي محمد علي انت شخص لطيف وجيد و صابور ومقنع ولديك حكمة وعلم ومتواضع أسال الله عظيم ان يسترك و يبارك لك عملك وان اشهد أنك من مسلمين مؤمنين واحبك في الله يا أخي الكريم
Welcome to Islam from the Philippines, I already love you sister for the sake of Allah
Assalamualaikum my brothers and my sisters . I hope you are in good health ❤
Salaam & Love & Alhamdolillah From Bangladesh 😍😍😍
الحمدلله
Allahu Akbar.. All your past sins are forgiven sister after your Shahada and you are a clean slate like a new born baby. Allah choose people for the true religion who opened their heart to accept the truth.. Sister you should pray for all of us that may Allah bless us with guidance and protection. You are part of a very big Muslim family. I am from India and Allah will certainly connect you to the right people and make things easy for you. Just remain patient and steadfast upon the religion by trusting in Allah only. Everything eventually will fall in it's place for good. May Allah bless you and make you a light of guidance for your family, friends and community. Jazakallah Khair(May Allah reward you).
Brother Muhammad do make narrate ahadith in arabic. As muslims we find it very comforting the exact words of Prophet ﷺ words directly recited to us. It carries a lot of weight. Thank you for your effort. JazakAllahu khairan.
It's the Qur'an that you should concentrate on for the weight of words.
@@Junior-yt6cx وانجم اذا هوىٰ ما ضل صاحبكم وما غوىٰ وما هو إِلا وحي يوحىٰ(سورة نجم ٥٣: ٣ )
Quran (53: 1-3)
And brother what gives you an idea that I don’t concentrate on Quran?
@@AA-sb9ni my apologies on the insinuation. Are you stating those verses to mean three hadith is also wahi.
الله اكبر
الحمدلله
Masha Allah❣️ welcome to Islam sister
*SubhanAllah.. I didn't see that coming!*
May Allah keep guiding us and maintain us steadfast upon His Straight Path. Ameen
امين يارب
Mashalaah, I wish Emma knows how happy I am for her🎉🎉🎉. She's so brave and overcame her concerns. I know how difficult it is in American South - I will pray to Allah to make her journey as easy and enjoyable as possible! Welcome Emma!!
Her open-mindedness is so refreshing. May Allah bless and guide her and enter her to Paradise in the After-Life Insha-Allah.
Allahumma barik..been almost a year i hope sister emma is doing good and is in a good state of imaan. Hope she found a good community around her it made me a little sad that thats something shed worry about. Youll always have sisters in faith emma! If not a few steps away then definitely just a click away~🫂 May Allah bless you with good companions in this journey and remember that ultimately Allah is the wali(ally/protector) of the believers! May you always be under his protection and care🤍
الحمدلله
My cups of tea! Just watched one from brother Hamza! Now another one! My soul is so full today 😊😊. Wish tomorrow will be the same.
This video was really educational.
Welcome to the ummah sister.😇
Maasha Allah
Welcome to islam sister
Elhamdulillah
I did doubt hadiths but this vid has allowed me to accept it 100%
الحمد لله الذي هداها للإسلام
اللهم ثبتها وإيانا على الصراط المستقيم
جزاك الله خيرا أخ محمد علي
سبحان الله
Masha'Allah Tabarak'Allah brother Muhammed with such a beautiful and knowledgeable dawah that clears all doubts. You are the dawah role model. Jazzak Allahu Khair
الحمدلله
Subhanallah!
I Love this brother for only his logical explanation and the way he put the truth before nonbelievers. MashaAllah brother ❤
May Allah guide u and keep u on the right path and welcome to islam sister
امين يارب
gotta say i'm surprised for the shahada, literally made this video hundreds time better.. welcome to Islam, sister..
Alhamdullillah, always waiting for your video. May Allah give you best reward, Aminnn ...
Salam from Indonesia
Brother.. Please make a video on hadith. Even some muslims are doubting hadith..
The ahadith have no manuscripts.
Those Muslims need to research themselves. There is so much content online already.
If a video is needed, point them to "Farid Responds" channel
@@Junior-yt6cx This is an absolutely baseless claim. There are plenty manuscripts of Hadith.
Towards eternity made a video about hadiths.
Masha Allah. Mohamed Ali Is such a beautiful brother with a beautiful Akhlaq. May Allah swt accept what he is doing for islam. Ameen.
And may Allah swt bless the sister and make her path easy. Ameen.
Welcome Sister happy with you from part of the world call Thailand
SubhanAllsh sister! So happy for you!
الحمدلله
I noticed many Chrstans will ask for verification and authentication of Hadith (which is available),
but never have this critrea for their own Bble.
Which leads me to believe they just want a way to reject the truth.
When authentication is provided for Hadith, there will be a new excuse.
Most likely it is wiswas.
Bosnians, Albanians are "WYT" Muslims, and they are many more in Russia,Poland,etc.
And Chrstanity originates from Western Asia.
Chrstans in Bethlehem,Syria,Lebanon,Jordan,
and in Africa in Ethiopia,Eritrea have more in common culturally with Muslims than they do Americans!
May Allah have mercy and protect her from wiswas❤
May Allah protect you all and forgive us our sins and may Allah have mercy on our dead
Welcom sister.
Masya Allah..
Glad to know this..
😊🙏🏻🤲🏻🇮🇩
Sister welcome ❤️
Always say S.A.W.W with Prophet Muhammad(S.A.W.W)...
Welcome sister Emma to Islam.
This is the greatest decision of your life.
Keep making DUA (supplication) and prayers for a beautiful and successful journey of Guidance and ease in all your future endeavours. Ameen.
Stay blessed.
MashaAllah, may Allah bless this sister and grant her closeness to Allah ameen ❤️
امين يارب
Takbeer
Allah hu akbar
Allahu Akbar
Allahuakbar.
Allahu Akbar
Sister Emma welcome to the biggest family in the world. Much love ❤from Germany 🇩🇪
الحمدلله
The American lady is a very discerning of logical reasonings by dae Muhammad Ali. May Allah give her hidayah. This video should have millions of views.
Mashallah
Al Hamdulillah…..guidance comes from Allah SWT. You are blessed in this world and hereafter….
Allahu Akbar... alhamdulillah...
الحمدلله
Welcome to Islam, sister. May Allah keep you steadfast in the Deen..
Yah Allah plz forgive all Ummah yah Allah
This is best answers I heard against hadith rejection
Masha ALLAH sister welcome from India
Brother Muhammed. May Allah bless you. I am always amazed by your manner of delivering the message. So simple and well structured and following such a logical sequence. I have one request. Please try to contact Brother Bobby from Bobby's perspective who is also very critical about the Ahadeeth.
YEAH I KNOW RIGHT? may Allah guide him, even though he talked about them with Uthman ibn Farooq
Q1: 1:40 How do you know Hadith accuracy?
2:21 1: Chain link to people we can trace back to knowing came from them. Lady admits we don’t know who bible came from.
3:58 2: All people in chain had to be known to be trustworthy or honest
4:28 3: Had to have good memory.Used to make tests based on memory. People had to rely on memory
6:57 Bible not divinely inspired:
due to changes that happened to it throughout history. Cannot know which part was from God. If human manipulates scripture and adds information, cannot say it’s from God.
There is no comparison between bible and Hadith, Quran is complete different level of authenticity.
9:25 Narrator of Hadith, very close for time of prophet two people before.
Q2: 10:16 How do you know Hadith is unchanged?
10:40 1: All narrations Bukari has found in other books
10:52 2: Consulted with community regarding agreement with Authenticity. Validated by human history.
13:03 3: Took it seriously. Can’t lie about prophet
Wow this is an excellent I was looking for an explanation for this for years but I’ve found it now. I am a born Muslim but still it is halal to question Alhamdulilah
Mashallah.. May Allah bless you for your hard work bro. Inshallah we all muslim need to same so that we can can own the Legacy of Prophet Mohammad S.A.W
Mohammed Ali, I learn something new from you every single time I hear you speak! Alhamd'Allah
I do have a request though, if you would speak slower please! I've noticed you do that when you get excited or when you start to laugh. Shukran brother.
One of the things I absolutely love, is that the title of the videos never give away that there is a shahadah coming!
MashAllah, it’s definitely a sign of sincerity from Br Muhammad that his work is not for clicks/likes. MashAllah
Beautiful video!
run the YT algorithm .... I m from Islamabad, Pakistan!
Iraq🇮🇶
Toronto
Earth
@@cutlet9227 Ahaa , are you guys from Earth 🌎 Muslim too like us on our planet ,if not you should become a Muslim Just like sister
Ameen
Congratulations Sister. I have been listening to this ,your conversation with Brother Mohammad Ali & your Subsequent Shahadah from Srinagar Kashmir!
Congratulations sister.
Assalamu alaikum brother Muhammad Ali. Since I almost daily watch your videos, I, rather easily, recognized your voice. Please keep me & my family in your duas as I was suffering from Brain tumor which I got operated upon in May 2023 but have been on Chemotherapy ever since upto first February, 2024.
Sister Emma Assalamualaikum congratulations, please pray for us because once you come to Islam your all past sins are forgiven
jazaka allah khayran
Brother in Islam I like your way to teach a people specially non Muslims, your reward in Jenna
alhamdulillah. may allah bless our muslim sister
MashaAllah MashaAllah MashaAllah…. Really amazed by the dawah of brother Mohammad Ali. May Allah bless him and the sister. Ameen