GTA 5 Roleplay - DOJ 341 - Lawyer Up (Civilian)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,7 тис.

  • @diddlydown1053
    @diddlydown1053 6 років тому +719

    They should really make a court house where stuff like this is sorted out. Now I would watch that

    • @rayraytendy
      @rayraytendy 4 роки тому +21

      So judge jutty

    • @ls43007
      @ls43007 4 роки тому +3

      The Book Of ƬЯXPXP no it’s clearly judge jutty

    • @omara2678
      @omara2678 4 роки тому +9

      MichaelDoesStuffVideos no it’s clearly Judge titty.

    • @maddawg0633
      @maddawg0633 4 роки тому +2

      *We* would

    • @Bruh-ov7iv
      @Bruh-ov7iv 4 роки тому +1

      What episode is the continuation

  • @sarcasticasshole4525
    @sarcasticasshole4525 6 років тому +219

    I just watched a 40 minute video of guys talking about traffic laws in a WHOLE Other country that I don’t live in. 10/10 would watch again

  • @CreedKade
    @CreedKade 7 років тому +158

    “Looken at 90 seconds in jail” 😂

    • @newportreds6710
      @newportreds6710 7 років тому +11

      In doj that's a lot. Obviously they can't do 20 years lol

  • @seductivequickie3955
    @seductivequickie3955 6 років тому +338

    2019 and we are still waiting on this court case

  • @willowens4822
    @willowens4822 7 років тому +169

    The only problem is the judge can't operate court papers in undeemed hours of the courthouse, therefore the paperwork for the license wouldn't go into actual effect until the opening of the courthouse the following day not at midnight because of court authorization. Which means it was an unlawful act by the police department and judge, laws don't change because the 2nd in Command is acquaintances with the judge... Also to be technical while the judge can suspend his license, the offender and the DMV has to be notorized fist, since the DMV is actually in control of what happens in license offences, so since it was at midnight the DMV was not notorized correctly of the incident!!

  • @strokin_6.7
    @strokin_6.7 7 років тому +73

    Can’t wait to see Andrew fight in court when you guys get the court system up and running. Good job to yourself, Jeff AND Andrew. I enjoyed this one

    • @uyhu24
      @uyhu24 6 років тому

      do you know which one is the court episode?

    • @teeivio173
      @teeivio173 5 років тому +1

      perseus Biggs never released it, nor did they did a part 2

  • @spencer7710
    @spencer7710 7 років тому +155

    But polecat was never told his license was suspended so how could he know he was driving on a suspended?

    • @ridiculousram249
      @ridiculousram249 7 років тому +1

      Spencer FFA exactly

    • @kylescott1382
      @kylescott1382 7 років тому +40

      Not only that Even if Andrew was to call the judge in the middle of the night the judge would most definitely not be able to suspend his license in that time. The judge would have to wait till morning to actually go to the courthouse and fill out the required paper work to suspend said license. It’s not possible for a judge alone to be able to suspend someone’s license let alone at his house in the middle of the night. Not only that but in DOJ I’m assuming that they don’t have anyone RPing as a judge so it starts to get very touchy in the matter that almost no judge would go out of there way to suspend a license in the middle of the night, especially with all the work that they do during the day.

    • @jayflicks2154
      @jayflicks2154 5 років тому +1

      ikr all they said is they were talking to the judge and trying to get it revoked

    • @meatballsupreme5586
      @meatballsupreme5586 5 років тому

      @@kylescott1382 he might have been the taget Else idt they would be able to do it

  • @BlaydeArmyGames
    @BlaydeArmyGames 6 років тому +26

    You guys should do more Lawyer-Esque episodes like this, I thoroughly enjoyed you and Jeff cross examining the evidence and even pulling cold hard facts directly from Andrew’s mouth. It’s such a shame he decided to combat this brilliant conversation filled with conclusive deductions with the classic “We’ll take it to court” statement.
    I sincerely hope you three revisit this with a type of Court script or as even part of your Civilian/Criminal episodes when you’re not participating as an officer of the law.

  • @ThirstyCartoon
    @ThirstyCartoon 6 років тому +29

    16:49 - they say the judge approved the order at 12:56
    23:37 - "this stop was initiated at roughly 12:50"
    case closed, it was approved after the stop started, making the impound illegal.

  • @ttyylleerr1515
    @ttyylleerr1515 7 років тому +40

    This lawyer video was great cant wait for the court system.

  • @TheVilouboy
    @TheVilouboy 7 років тому +88

    PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO, PART TWO,

    • @TheSpanishGod
      @TheSpanishGod 7 років тому +1

      TheVilouboy PART TWO

    • @uyhu24
      @uyhu24 6 років тому +1

      do you know which one is the court episode?

    • @moosles1357
      @moosles1357 6 років тому +1

      I KNOW RIGHT!!!

  • @dopeymomasboy
    @dopeymomasboy 2 роки тому +49

    We need a "lawyer reacts" to this video lol

  • @Willams78
    @Willams78 Рік тому +8

    This was one of my favorite episodes. The back and forth on the laws kept me interested more than some criminal type behavior that they normally would do. Everybody in the whole episode knew the law up and down.

  • @jayjay77777
    @jayjay77777 3 роки тому +36

    Such an unsatisfying ending. Andrew knew he lost so he pulled the “we’ll take it to court” definitely should have blown up the car lol

    • @sportsgeeks9278
      @sportsgeeks9278 3 роки тому +1

      Right

    • @kingMT514
      @kingMT514 2 роки тому +4

      “But it’s not accurate role play” shit at that point fuck the role play

  • @teddybearmacky7975
    @teddybearmacky7975 6 років тому +14

    6:00 that red car performed the best drifting i have ever seen in GTA history

  • @robertpearson2793
    @robertpearson2793 7 років тому +37

    You, Jeff, and Polecat should do a video where one of you is a son, dad, and grandpa and you guys argue over everything.

  • @imtristanadams2630
    @imtristanadams2630 7 років тому +37

    If the court thing comes, YOU HAVE TO RECORD THE COURT TRIALS

    • @MAVORlC
      @MAVORlC 7 років тому

      Theres no court room interior so I'm not sure how'd it work

    • @DAVE11
      @DAVE11 7 років тому

      I hope to see this soon

  • @Feintgames
    @Feintgames 7 років тому +18

    That was pretty entertaining. Andrew really shows quality of character for not losing his shit.

  • @jessecraig1423
    @jessecraig1423 6 років тому +15

    Buggs an Jeff legitimately sound like lawyers. Lmao.

  • @southernpixel6856
    @southernpixel6856 4 роки тому +23

    This is as close as we will ever get to them roleplaying a court hearing

  • @nathan2758
    @nathan2758 7 років тому +21

    This is the first time I'm ever commenting on a UA-cam video, but I had to let you know how much I enjoyed this video Buggs! I watch your videos mostly for the dialogue between yourself, Polecat and Jeff, and especially with the police, and this video is pure psychological warfare haha! The level of intellectual ability you showed, as well as being able to think quickly on your feet and then articulate yourself directly and with authority is really impressive and I feel slightly bad for the other players that struggle to keep up. You guys remind me a lot of Rhett and Link, who also have a UA-cam channel and have a similar kind of wit. So keep up the great videos and as most people have mentioned, you would make a great lawyer and if I'm ever in need of one you're the first person I want!

  • @ryanrosen_
    @ryanrosen_ 7 років тому +14

    I'm actually really liking these civilian videos, keep it up man.

  • @censored.9903
    @censored.9903 4 роки тому +18

    this is probably the most underrated video buggs has uploaded

  • @peterisputnins3524
    @peterisputnins3524 7 років тому +12

    This was so fun to watch, despite the fact it was set mostly in just one place. Gta needs a court house, so you could attend there for the crimes that you make episodes before or the same episode and prove that you are innocent, that would be epic.

  • @davidmcmanus4751
    @davidmcmanus4751 5 років тому +29

    Those "politics" that he was referring to are the actual laws that he was sworn to enforce. This is the classic case of law enforcement not being able to distinguish between the terms "being the law" and being a "representative of the law". This "officer" has clearly proclaimed himself as "being the law", which portrays him as a person who is above the law, and therefore, not affected by the law, in essence, a domestic terrorist.

    • @neelsobhun2233
      @neelsobhun2233 4 роки тому +3

      David McManus you should become a lawyer 😂

  • @vanillishfilms3097
    @vanillishfilms3097 7 років тому +81

    a Rockstar Games advertisement in a Rockstar Games game.
    seems legit.

  • @TeeDeeTD
    @TeeDeeTD 11 місяців тому +17

    2024 and this is is still a top notch video… still waiting on the court case! 😂

  • @SoCalSaiMedia
    @SoCalSaiMedia 7 років тому +11

    The license plates were a nice touch on Buggs & Jeff's cars. OVRRULED & OBJECT lol

  • @brackendouglas3433
    @brackendouglas3433 6 років тому +19

    You lawyers missed it. Go back to 17:00 into the video and start listening. The officer admits that the revoke hit the system at 12:56pst and then towards the end of the video when you asked him to check the logs of when he started the traffic stop he says it was logged in at 12:50. So he wasn’t driving when suspension came through. Boom! Lawyered!

  • @callumotoole8485
    @callumotoole8485 2 роки тому +18

    let me just say, If this went to court, Buggs and Jeff would win by a landslide

  • @pglcraft4793
    @pglcraft4793 7 років тому +15

    The second he knew bugs and Jeff had polecat free to have his car he threatened to get them with obstruction, even though he was more than happy to argue with them about it for the 20 mins that spanned before that and give them the evidence they needed, which was around -10 seconds to have the restrictions come through. He essentially used his power, which is for the public, to get out of a hole he dug himself into and then filled with concrete.

    • @pglcraft4793
      @pglcraft4793 7 років тому +3

      But it was still good, I enjoyed it.

  • @Joedithas
    @Joedithas 6 років тому +29

    He said the license was suspended at 12:56!! Then backed it up `to 12:40!

    • @yaboi5139
      @yaboi5139 3 роки тому

      Yeah but we dont wanna worry about that

  • @MagicMaxiVII
    @MagicMaxiVII 7 років тому +39

    This is the issue with DOJ at the moment. There needs to be a court system. These cops feel like they can get away with anything because any wrong doing on their end will be handled in imaginary court. They dont have to answer for any of their illegal wrong doings at all. They do need to be held accountable. Also, that would make it so they have reasonable response times for things like drivers license suspentions and warrants, not this 10 minutes with 2 minutes of "talking" with the judge.

  • @YanitedBT
    @YanitedBT 6 років тому +12

    did anyone notice that soccer mom doing a crazy tokyo drift at 6:03 lmfaooo

  • @dddontae
    @dddontae 7 років тому +21

    Keep this going make it a series!!!!! Loved it!!

  • @SirPeasant
    @SirPeasant 7 років тому +34

    It would be great to have a court system

    • @arabianwarrior2367
      @arabianwarrior2367 7 років тому +1

      Grant Peevyhouse it will take a lot of time to process the court and a building they could use the IAA building

  • @jakenelson3943
    @jakenelson3943 3 роки тому +23

    It’s simple. Since the driver was not informed that his license was revoked till after the traffic stop they can not tow the vehicle.

  • @Drew.coggs_ig
    @Drew.coggs_ig 7 років тому +44

    I’m so ready for the court case

  • @nathannfford
    @nathannfford 7 років тому +25

    Make a part 2 where you are in court doing the lawsuit

  • @TheSethunfajakiu
    @TheSethunfajakiu 4 роки тому +15

    6:02 damn that suv is a good as driver

    • @Jake-kd6ej
      @Jake-kd6ej 4 роки тому +1

      you forgot an s ;) "ass"

  • @CadChamberlain
    @CadChamberlain 7 років тому +27

    Play as a drunk Santa chasing his reindeer

  • @Eric12886
    @Eric12886 6 років тому +23

    Anyone else bingewatch these

    • @Kiing_g
      @Kiing_g 6 років тому +2

      I feel I have almost watch all of them 💀

  • @eagles_nationfly_eagles_fl2093
    @eagles_nationfly_eagles_fl2093 5 років тому +11

    Some serious drift skills by the AI at 6:03

  • @skylersorenson1479
    @skylersorenson1479 6 років тому +10

    Please make a part two! Love watching all your videos and this is my favorite one I’ve watched so far!

  • @chowskee
    @chowskee 5 років тому +13

    6:06 best drifting I’ve seen

  • @Oneyongwon
    @Oneyongwon 7 років тому +59

    Any body else see the AI suv drifting on the highway

    • @stepkickking9868
      @stepkickking9868 7 років тому +1

      Mikey W/D It was dsync, but it was pretty fucking sick 😂

    • @DAVE11
      @DAVE11 7 років тому

      Can someone text down how they ran out of time bc this video left off to fast

  • @Davi45452
    @Davi45452 5 років тому +17

    6:03 does nobody see that sweet Tokyo drift

  • @crazymexican2184
    @crazymexican2184 7 років тому +38

    Andrew gets visited by Agent 48 & Agent 49 ? Possibly future episode

  • @tyberzhan.3390
    @tyberzhan.3390 7 років тому +11

    Keep being lawyers i LOVE IT!

  • @michaelfaulkner4446
    @michaelfaulkner4446 6 років тому +12

    I know that this is a year old video. Lol. You guys should have mentioned more that they have to notify Polecat that indeed his Licence has been revoked before anything happens, then if he's caught driving again, that's when they have proper grounds for impound.

  • @itsthebrit4038
    @itsthebrit4038 6 років тому +10

    That was REALLY fucking thrilling for a law & politics episode holy shit good job

  • @rynea5686
    @rynea5686 7 років тому +16

    Can't wait for court system

  • @said4075
    @said4075 4 роки тому +17

    6:03 That SUV is a drift king

    • @danduerango7718
      @danduerango7718 4 роки тому +2

      Lmfaoo I just noticed that. This is why we need people like you in the world

    • @eeggg9953
      @eeggg9953 3 роки тому

      lmfaooo

  • @isiahsoto7791
    @isiahsoto7791 7 років тому +12

    OHHHH BOYYY , can’t wait for the court system to be taken place

  • @camhesse1
    @camhesse1 4 роки тому +10

    I love how he says "seems legit" so often lol. It is the one thing I know is said in I think every episode 😂😂😂😂

    • @Reborn_Yamato
      @Reborn_Yamato 4 роки тому +2

      That's it.

    • @Reborn_Yamato
      @Reborn_Yamato 4 роки тому +2

      And not on my screen.

    • @Reborn_Yamato
      @Reborn_Yamato 4 роки тому +3

      But not on my screen is used often but not as often as seems legit.

  • @mr.stealyogurl869
    @mr.stealyogurl869 6 років тому +13

    They were off by 5 seconds on the time line so if you do go to court you will win, and he even said at the end that he had no idea that the license had been suspended or not but was saying he had all the right to check but that still means that nobody on that scene had any idea that the license was suspended before they checked it and the time line being off just proves that his license was still valid when he was stopped meaning that his vehicle can’t be impounded and if he decided to go ahead and sue them, the odds of him winning are in his favour.

  • @mysticcaliber6782
    @mysticcaliber6782 Рік тому +12

    Buggs over here making Andrew nervous asf lol 😂

  • @OfficerBreadstik
    @OfficerBreadstik 7 років тому +9

    *buggs* " are you driving reckless "
    *polecat* " yes "
    *buggs* " ohh well your fucked we cant help "

  • @hypocritea4101
    @hypocritea4101 5 років тому +7

    This is one of the episodes that i definitely wish was continued. Even without a court system they could have just got into discord and argued it. It would've been really great to see.

  • @Daton.B
    @Daton.B 7 років тому +6

    Hands down one of the best videos on doj please make more of these!!!

  • @7520snag
    @7520snag Рік тому +10

    Gentlemen I’ve been a lawyer for 20 yrs and that was some very good litigation and in real they would not have grounds to impound your clients vehicle

  • @around403
    @around403 4 місяці тому +11

    2024 and still waiting on this court case

  • @masonHaINzZ1312
    @masonHaINzZ1312 5 років тому +24

    You forgot about the fact that your client wasn’t notified that his license was suspended. He also wasn’t driving on a suspended license. And in no way could a judge be making sound decisions at that time of night. How long did it take the judge to read the files and make a decision that would include more than 30 mins of paperwork and then send it back down the chain to actually enact the suspension.

    • @dallas4882
      @dallas4882 5 років тому

      That's exactly what they said

  • @noobninja8684
    @noobninja8684 4 роки тому +21

    Sad that it was never continued. Wish it was.

  • @Nitro-Finn
    @Nitro-Finn 6 років тому +60

    This is weirdly so boring and highly entertaining at the same time..

  • @kvngmars7067
    @kvngmars7067 7 років тому +13

    Did anybody else see that red SUV Drifting On the highway😂😂😂

  • @OutlawSoul
    @OutlawSoul 4 роки тому +30

    andrew could be a legit cop.
    "what's felony speeding?"
    "it's double the speed limit."
    "show me the code."
    "It's a colloquial term we use. it has no code."
    aka. he made it up. well done andrew. this is how you 10/10 roleplay the bullshiter cop. TONY AWARD FOR YOU SIR.

    • @30hours51
      @30hours51 4 роки тому +1

      He explained it tho. He can use it as a term not the actual meaning

    • @OutlawSoul
      @OutlawSoul 4 роки тому +6

      @@30hours51 what? felony is a legal term dude. felony speeding doesn't exist in the statues. use it as a term without the meaning?
      he made it up to try to trump it up and intimidate the others. you can't explain something that has prior meaning which doesn't exist. like if you ask me what's going on, and I say I'm drying water.

    • @Pavonis-sh9bd
      @Pavonis-sh9bd 4 роки тому +1

      Felony speeding is charged with a fine exceeding $500, two to four points on your license and a minimum of one year in federal or state prison.

    • @aadvantagegold5220
      @aadvantagegold5220 4 роки тому +3

      @@Pavonis-sh9bd Not in the fictional state of San Andreas in this instance.

    • @Pavonis-sh9bd
      @Pavonis-sh9bd 4 роки тому +1

      @@aadvantagegold5220 ok, ok

  • @chrisgood1794
    @chrisgood1794 5 років тому +11

    I have been waiting on an outcome ever since this was released. We need the court episodes since their is always someone saying you will have your day in court!

  • @Iko1311
    @Iko1311 7 років тому +6

    Buggs you killed this, keep up the good work!!

  • @krrisss
    @krrisss 7 років тому +15

    I wish they really have a Court house would be a fun video.. Debating back and forth

  • @sguanti31
    @sguanti31 7 років тому +12

    Anyone else notice polecats wheel countiuously turning throughout the traffic stop?

  • @typomischief8101
    @typomischief8101 6 років тому +33

    8 months later... It was never continued

    • @bromotion2542
      @bromotion2542 6 років тому +7

      I was so excited to see the case being resolved in court

  • @frazure2857
    @frazure2857 4 роки тому +9

    6:03 that Greasley initiated tokyo drift mode 😂

  • @tylipscombe6340
    @tylipscombe6340 3 роки тому +22

    the maroon suv had some sick drifts 6:03

    • @Duckling131
      @Duckling131 3 роки тому +3

      I was looking for a comment on that 😂

    • @mergat2970
      @mergat2970 2 роки тому

      Arabic drift moment

    • @perfectcheese76
      @perfectcheese76 2 роки тому

      ​@@Duckling131 seriously 😂 I was like is nobody gonna acknowledge that suv jus powersliding for a good 30 feet or we jus gonna continue like nothin happened

  • @alexsexton4481
    @alexsexton4481 5 років тому +8

    The “OVRRULED” in the bottom left corner cracked me up for some reason

  • @ryanthomas5384
    @ryanthomas5384 5 років тому +18

    I come everyday and watch all the old videos everyday

  • @jordanwhite9319
    @jordanwhite9319 4 роки тому +33

    He's back!!! Where is lawyer up part 2?!?!?!

    • @Person-cc2ee
      @Person-cc2ee 4 роки тому +3

      Jordan White he hasn’t made a video like this for over a year

    • @Person-cc2ee
      @Person-cc2ee 4 роки тому +3

      This video is over 2 years old

    • @jordanwhite9319
      @jordanwhite9319 4 роки тому +5

      Then you might want to do some fact checks before you comment, because if you followed him like I do, you would know he uploaded a video last night and is going to start uploading content regularly again.

    • @parsec9446
      @parsec9446 4 роки тому +6

      Jordan White Damn, lawered up indeed

    • @future7040
      @future7040 4 роки тому +4

      Keigster Gaming just got Lawyered Up!

  • @HaggardGamer
    @HaggardGamer 7 років тому +12

    A Police Officer cannot request a license suspension. That would be up to the District Attorney's Office. Not only would a judge NEVER wake up to suspend a license, he would almost certainly make life hell for anybody that woke him up for a reckless driving charge.

  • @V1Transportation
    @V1Transportation 6 років тому +6

    The driver not having been notified would be my best guess at your only other option. good ep, hope there's more lawyer ones

  • @webstar90
    @webstar90 7 років тому +5

    Yes!! Stoked to hear the court system is coming!! You guys make for some awesome representation!

  • @aidennugget71
    @aidennugget71 7 років тому +8

    love how polecat says seems liget

  • @theitalianstallion5864
    @theitalianstallion5864 Рік тому +13

    its sad that that Benjamin vs San Andreas was never brought up again

  • @ammarnapata2193
    @ammarnapata2193 5 років тому +9

    This is one of their better episodes. I enjoyed this one

  • @DLionDK
    @DLionDK 7 років тому +5

    Damn Andrew was not getting happy. He did not like this.
    Edit: I freaking love this video! This is literally amazing! Please do another one.

  • @tonymarcum8165
    @tonymarcum8165 6 років тому +13

    Need part 2!!! Lawyer up!

  • @jonathanblankenship2095
    @jonathanblankenship2095 4 роки тому +13

    Red SUV: DEJA VU!!!

  • @cheekiewalrus5000
    @cheekiewalrus5000 6 років тому +13

    if you had argued that he wasn't given proper notification of the suspension y'all would've walked

  • @Austiekat01
    @Austiekat01 5 років тому +11

    5:59 did yall see that drifting suv goin down the highway😂😂

  • @jeremiahanderson7203
    @jeremiahanderson7203 6 років тому +14

    Next time say a ticket is not an admission of guilt, a person is innocent until they admit guilt, or found guilty in a court of law. A ticket is not enough to suspend a license until it goes to court!

  • @wolfofnyx
    @wolfofnyx 6 років тому +10

    I am anxiously waiting for Part II

  • @deanjohnston6974
    @deanjohnston6974 7 років тому +8

    We definitely need a court system lol and another lawyer episode

  • @danielgandarilla8024
    @danielgandarilla8024 3 роки тому +23

    I was really hoping there was a bomb in the car damn lol

    • @kaptainkmann7808
      @kaptainkmann7808 3 роки тому

      Then sue the city for unlawfully impounding and destroying your vehicle.

  • @ffspeople1
    @ffspeople1 6 років тому +12

    You forgot to mention the thing about not being able to impound a car without headlights.

  • @carrsonsiersma6920
    @carrsonsiersma6920 4 роки тому +7

    brooooo he needs to get back on the GTA videos. i miss these and i have watched like close to everyone of them.

  • @kristygremaud2256
    @kristygremaud2256 4 роки тому +18

    If you would of took that to court you probably would have won

  • @quenellwilliams8313
    @quenellwilliams8313 4 роки тому +13

    You guys need to do another on of these believe it or not this was really great

    • @tinanikkillz8570
      @tinanikkillz8570 4 роки тому +1

      There no longer doing these videos anymore they broke the crew up almost a year now

    • @MekhiTheOne
      @MekhiTheOne 4 роки тому

      @@tinanikkillz8570 nah they're still friends bugs just doesn't play GTA

    • @tinanikkillz8570
      @tinanikkillz8570 4 роки тому

      ahwoofe go to his community he explains that everyone left code zero so yes they broke off the group

    • @Fearstrikerr
      @Fearstrikerr 4 роки тому

      does anyone know if andrew p has a youtube or social media?

    • @Toxins4776
      @Toxins4776 4 роки тому

      Tinanik Killz they broke up the group but there still friends

  • @admercolindres4369
    @admercolindres4369 7 років тому +16

    Did anyone notice the SUV drift next to polecat

  • @jet7502
    @jet7502 4 роки тому +10

    6:02 that guy just started whippin it

  • @LighthouseCape
    @LighthouseCape 4 роки тому +7

    6:02
    Nobody:
    In my head:(eurobeat intensifies by seeing the red SUV)

  • @DEAD_ACCOUNT0000
    @DEAD_ACCOUNT0000 Рік тому +8

    6:02 why is nobody talking about that sick drift the red SUV on the right did?