Yeah lol, in New Mexico, we take pride in our flag. I have seen somewhere around ten videos and articles ranking flags, and New Mexico is always top five, normally number one. I believe it is the average best flag across all of the rankings I’ve seen, and I don’t think it’s particularly close. Thanks for agreeing lol, we don’t have too much to be proud of.
Aye man don't put yourselves down, y'all have...sand...really nice sand... But in all seriousness it is a very nice flag and it's usually top 5 or top 3 for good reason, simple yet very effective design
This list blows dude you just put half of the list in burn this flag just because it has words or a coat of arms rate it on design not just by what some stupid website said
I tried to focus on the flags as wholes and didn't really dive too deep into the state seals as the video wasn't geared towards that but I could do a video on state seal designs at some point because there are some wild things on some of these seals 😂
Correct, I just worded the Mississippi part weird, meant to just say it was Mississippi's newest flag, came out kind of like I meant it was the newest state flag in general, poor word choice
@@jabronjunklove760 so that definitely makes me look bad but I sincerely have no seen the video, I watch him fairly minimally, I can't even remember the last video of his I saw, I'm just somewhat familiar with his content style and opinions through more research during and after editing this video, which I applied during my newest video
This rules thing is crazy, you put so much flags in the bottom tier, without even looking at them individually. You aren’t grading the flags by their design. You are outsourcing your opinion to RECOMMENDATION( as stated in that very pamphlet) just to be uncontroversial. The ideal flag according to that book is a boring MS paint graphic design that ignores culture history and the people.
We all have our own opinions about design as good design is partially subjective. However, the reason I focus so hard on those recommended guidelines is because they're effective. Coat of Arms/State Seal flags don't have much design to judge. The biggest designed thing on them is the seal itself and I'm not doing a video on the design of the seals. Flags and seals should be distinct from each other while still communicating similar themes as they relate to the same state. The reality is that those flags are just lazy and AS A FLAG, they don't make for good design. As a seal, perhaps they do, that'd be a different video. You may not be a big fan of simpler flag designs and would prefer more detail and that's fine, that's where the subjective part of design comes in, but a large part of people like the simpler easier to understand approach, because they work better as flags. Design's effectiveness also comes down to its medium, if you have a 200 meter tall flagpole and a flag with a state seal at the top, I'd be willing to be more people wouldnt be able to tell which flag is up there, but go with a simpler design, like the flag of Chicago for example, and suddenly it becomes easier to discern.
@@acelm8437 haha I know it wasn't two weeks I was just poking fun at Texas. As for the ranking, despite it's popularity, I don't feel that Texas' flag is unique enough. It's a stars and stripes flag that's very nice to look at, but doesn't do anything different. The red, white, and blue represent typical traits that are used for flags, being purity, bravery, and loyalty. The lone star concept represents Texas' unity as a state but also their independent spirit, which is cool, but it isn't uniquely Texan, nor was it something created by Texas, in fact the lone star concept in North America was first seen in the short lived Republic of West Florida. Additionally, while the flag's have no relation nor connection to each other, I think of the flag of Chile, and how similar it is. The Chilean flag is so similar that it becomes apparent that the design doesn't stand out, and that other nations found themselves reaching near identical layouts. So I don't think it's a bad flag at all, I do like it, but given the nature of me ranking these by design, I don't think it's a unique enough flag to really sell it as a truly amazing flag. Of course, this is all personal opinion, and my criteria for an S tier flag isn't the same for other people, so take my opinion with a grain of salt
@@kitrod it's not the worst I will admit, if anything looking back I could've put it in "Needs Improvement" just for the fact it went with the tricolor over the plain background, but it does still feel very uninspired to me as it stands
“ fundamental rules”. No, they are guide lines, not rules. How are you even a designer if you think or believe they those are rules, they are only OK guidelines.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Seems I may have to do a video on just the state seal flags and see which ones come out on top there 🤔👀
As a former New Mexico resident I can confirm that the living conditions are much better if you hate snow. Or your used to it 😅
Tennessee is S tier, I'll die on that hill
@@eury-bosch for sure I could put it there too, looking back I feel I put it under where it should be
yessss (def not biased)
Thank you I live there
@Nightbot_notrealme too.
Yeah lol, in New Mexico, we take pride in our flag. I have seen somewhere around ten videos and articles ranking flags, and New Mexico is always top five, normally number one. I believe it is the average best flag across all of the rankings I’ve seen, and I don’t think it’s particularly close. Thanks for agreeing lol, we don’t have too much to be proud of.
Aye man don't put yourselves down, y'all have...sand...really nice sand...
But in all seriousness it is a very nice flag and it's usually top 5 or top 3 for good reason, simple yet very effective design
S Tier Flags:
Texas
California
Arizona
Tennessee
New Mexico
Colorado
Ohio
Alabama
A Tier
Alaska
Mississippi
Minnesota
Indiana
South Carolina
@@Roblox_mrtomas interesting 🤔
Thank you for liking South Carolina since I’m from there
This list blows dude you just put half of the list in burn this flag just because it has words or a coat of arms rate it on design not just by what some stupid website said
As a native Virginian, I'm sad you didn't discuss the nudity and violence that's on our state flag.
I tried to focus on the flags as wholes and didn't really dive too deep into the state seals as the video wasn't geared towards that but I could do a video on state seal designs at some point because there are some wild things on some of these seals 😂
Minnesota's New Flag is the newest
Correct, I just worded the Mississippi part weird, meant to just say it was Mississippi's newest flag, came out kind of like I meant it was the newest state flag in general, poor word choice
As an American i am mad at this tier list list its absolutely horrible
@@ArtistCarson as another American I'm curious as to what you would change? 🤔
@Senystyn a lot
A someone from Indiana I thought I'd be Arizona who would be dunking on us or Ohio not Illinois out of all states😂
I can't judge much being from Illinois but making fun of Indiana is fun 😂
@@Senystyn why do you hate indiana?
@@LukeAPerson I don't I'm just projecting my Illinois hatred towards my neighbor
@@Senystyn true lol I hate Ohio and Michigan
just started watching and i hope you rate my flag the worst because it contains blood
@@dhitdaba which flag is this?????
@ look close to a blue flag (even though almost every state has a blue flag)
It's the Lucy Anna flag that has blood.
These results are almost the exact same as CGP Grey's video on the same subject.
@@jabronjunklove760 so that definitely makes me look bad but I sincerely have no seen the video, I watch him fairly minimally, I can't even remember the last video of his I saw, I'm just somewhat familiar with his content style and opinions through more research during and after editing this video, which I applied during my newest video
Bro just why I live in Louisiana and my most of my family live there
Why did you hate wisconsin >:( now you will never eat cheese ever again 😢
Wait no I can explain 😰
As a Wisconsinite, I can confirm that you should not eat cheese from our country again
AND AS A MICHIGANDER YOU WILL NEVER SEE A WOLF AGAIN D:
You You can't delete iowa Like that
Wow
I live in New Mexico and I like it a lot
This rules thing is crazy, you put so much flags in the bottom tier, without even looking at them individually. You aren’t grading the flags by their design. You are outsourcing your opinion to RECOMMENDATION( as stated in that very pamphlet) just to be uncontroversial. The ideal flag according to that book is a boring MS paint graphic design that ignores culture history and the people.
We all have our own opinions about design as good design is partially subjective. However, the reason I focus so hard on those recommended guidelines is because they're effective. Coat of Arms/State Seal flags don't have much design to judge. The biggest designed thing on them is the seal itself and I'm not doing a video on the design of the seals. Flags and seals should be distinct from each other while still communicating similar themes as they relate to the same state. The reality is that those flags are just lazy and AS A FLAG, they don't make for good design. As a seal, perhaps they do, that'd be a different video. You may not be a big fan of simpler flag designs and would prefer more detail and that's fine, that's where the subjective part of design comes in, but a large part of people like the simpler easier to understand approach, because they work better as flags. Design's effectiveness also comes down to its medium, if you have a 200 meter tall flagpole and a flag with a state seal at the top, I'd be willing to be more people wouldnt be able to tell which flag is up there, but go with a simpler design, like the flag of Chicago for example, and suddenly it becomes easier to discern.
@@Senystynperfect explanation
im the only one who loves my state flag pennsylvania
To each their own, enjoy what you enjoy 😌
@@Senystyn ok
2:39 I am offended
Texas was a country for 10 YEARS not 2 weeks, that was California
Also why was it not S tier? Just curious about what you thought could be improved
@@acelm8437 haha I know it wasn't two weeks I was just poking fun at Texas. As for the ranking, despite it's popularity, I don't feel that Texas' flag is unique enough. It's a stars and stripes flag that's very nice to look at, but doesn't do anything different. The red, white, and blue represent typical traits that are used for flags, being purity, bravery, and loyalty. The lone star concept represents Texas' unity as a state but also their independent spirit, which is cool, but it isn't uniquely Texan, nor was it something created by Texas, in fact the lone star concept in North America was first seen in the short lived Republic of West Florida. Additionally, while the flag's have no relation nor connection to each other, I think of the flag of Chile, and how similar it is. The Chilean flag is so similar that it becomes apparent that the design doesn't stand out, and that other nations found themselves reaching near identical layouts. So I don't think it's a bad flag at all, I do like it, but given the nature of me ranking these by design, I don't think it's a unique enough flag to really sell it as a truly amazing flag. Of course, this is all personal opinion, and my criteria for an S tier flag isn't the same for other people, so take my opinion with a grain of salt
Missouri's isn't that bad :(
@@kitrod it's not the worst I will admit, if anything looking back I could've put it in "Needs Improvement" just for the fact it went with the tricolor over the plain background, but it does still feel very uninspired to me as it stands
Honestly, I’m moving to Washington
Nice 👍🏻
@ I heard it’s pretty nice
You hurt my feelings I'm from Kansas
@@ZionWarrior13 I'm so sorry you're from Kansas that must be so hard 😭
STOP the blue back ground with a seal bias, they are good flags, and do their job well
@@Chance_Rice I am a professional hater unfortunately
Are they good flags though? They’re unoriginal, boring, and complicated
Minnesota is definitely s tier with Texas, California, Mississippi, Iowa, Idaho, Missouri, Alaska 1:22
Oooo interesting list 🤔
Where is Michigan
@@Nintendosgamer914 it's at 2:44
Oregon is s it made me sad when how you ranked it.😢
Us flags that should be rated on ZS to ZF scale
what did Indiana do to bro 😭
Maryland on top!!!!!!
I LIVE IN ILLINOIS TO YAY
@@txgplayer354 oh man I am so sorry
520th sub????🍞
Rhode island
Kanas tier.
Kanas.
ture
Utah is the best
You don’t like oranges because Florida not that good
How dare you disrespect Nebraska my cousin lives there 😡
my best friend lives there so I get a pass
“ fundamental rules”. No, they are guide lines, not rules. How are you even a designer if you think or believe they those are rules, they are only OK guidelines.
Cool
Here’s the thing almost everybody likes the Arizona flag, and I don’t really like it. I don’t want making sad But I don’t really like that flag
It is okay even though I was born in Arizona and still live there
I hate New York Flag
you and me both